Indian & Eastern Newspaper Society v. CIT

119 ITR 996Supreme Court of India1979#441 most cited

What is Indian & Eastern Newspaper Society v. CIT authority for?

An assessment cannot be reopened under Section 147/148 based on a mere change of opinion by the Assessing Officer on material already considered during the original assessment, clarifying the scope of 'escaped assessment'.

205

judgments rely on this decision, according to BharatTax’s citation analysis of 384,072 Indian tax judgments — from 2008 to 2026.

Also referred to as

Indian & Eastern Newspaper Society v. CIT · 119 ITR 996 · Section 147 · Section 148 · reopening assessment · change of opinion · validity of reassessment · material already considered · Kalyanji Mavji clarification · quasi-judicial proceedings · opportunity of being heard · Section 147(b)

Also reported as

2 Taxmann 1972 Taxmann.com 197

Issues it is cited on

Judgments citing Indian & Eastern Newspaper Society v. CIT

Hsbc Asset Management (India) Private Limited, Mumbai vs. Income Tax Officer 1(1)(2), Mumbai

In the result, ground no.1 raised by assessee is allowed and assessment order framed found to be without jurisdiction

ITA 7292/MUM/2017[2008-09]Status: DisposedITAT Mumbai29 Apr 2022AY 2008-09

Bench: Shri Rahul Chaudhary & Shri Gagan Goyalhsbc Asset Management (India) Pvt. Ltd. 3Rd Floor, Mercantile Bank Chamber, 16 Veer Nariman, Mumbai-400001 Pan: Aabch0007N ...... Appellant Vs. Ito-1(1)(2) Mumbai. ..... Respondent Appellant By : Sh. Niraj Sheth, Ar Respondent By : Sh. Tejinder Pal Singh Anand, Sr. Dr Date Of Hearing : 28/02/2022 Date Of Pronouncement : 29/04/2022 Order Per Gagan Goyal, A.M: This Appeal By The Assessee Is Directed Against The Order Of Commissioner Of Income Tax (Appeals)-6, Mumbai [Hereinafter Referred To As ‘The Cit (A)’] Vide Order Dated 13.10.2017 For The Assessment Year (Ay) 2008-09. The Assessee Has Raised The Following Grounds Of Appeal: The Following Grounds Of Appeal Are Distinct & Separate & Without Prejudice To Each Other. 1. On The Facts & In Law, The Commissioner Of Income-Tax (Appeals) - 6, Mumbai [‘Cit(A)’] Erred In Upholding The Reassessment Proceedings Under Section 148 Of The Income-Tax Act, 1961 (‘The Act’) Initiated After Four Years From The End Of Relevant Assessment Year, Without Appreciating The Fact That Assessment Under Section 143(3) Was Made & The Appellant Had Disclosed Fully & Truly All Material Facts Necessary

For Appellant: Sh. Niraj Sheth, ARFor Respondent: Sh. Tejinder Pal Singh Anand, Sr. DR
Section 142(1)Section 143(2)Section 143(3)Section 148Section 37(1)Section 40A(9)

…y, our submissions and the reasons for reopening is similar. Thus, the re-opening is based on the Audit Objections, which as per the settled legal position, is illegal. Reliance is placed on following decisions: > Indian and Eastern Newspaper Society vs. CIT (119 ITR 996) (SC) wherein the Hon’ble Supreme Court has held that the opinion of the audit party on a point of law could not be regarded as “information” enabling the ITO to initiate reassessment proceedings under s. 147(b). The ITO had, when he made the original assessment, considered the provisions of ss. 9 and 10 pf the Indian I.T. Act, 1922. Any differen…

Dy CIT-CC-6(3), Mumbai vs. M/S. Marathon Nextgen Realty Ltd, Mumbai

ITA 798/MUM/2021[2011-12]Status: DisposedITAT Mumbai25 Mar 2022AY 2011-12

Bench: Vikas Awasthy & Shri Prashant Maharishiआअसं. 797/मुं/2021 ("न. व. 2012-13 ) आअसं. 798/मुं/2021 ("न. व. 2011-12 ) आअसं. 799/मुं/2021 ("न. व. 2010-11) Dy. Commissioner Of Income Tax, Central Circle – 6(3), Room No.1926, 19Th Floor, Air India Building, Nariman Point, Mumbai 400 021 ..... अपीलाथ" /Appellant बनाम Vs. M/S. Marathon Nextgen Realty Limited, Marathon Futurex Mafatlal Mill Compound, N.M.Joshi Marg, Lower Parel, Mumbai 400 013. Pan: Aaacp-8032-E ..... ""तवाद"/Respondent अपीलाथ" "वारा/ Appellant By : Shri J.P. Bairagra With Ms. Rupa Nanda ""तवाद" "वारा/Respondent By : Shri C.T. Mathews सुनवाई क" "त"थ/ Date Of Hearing : 23/02/2022 घोषणा क" "त"थ/ Date Of Pronouncement : 25/03/2022 आदेश/ Order Per Vikas Awasthy, Jm: These Three Appeals By The Revenue Are Directed Against The Orders Of Commissioner Of Income Tax(Appeals)-54, Mumbai [In Short ‘ The Cit(A)’], For The 2

For Appellant: Shri J.P. Bairagra with Ms. Rupa NandaFor Respondent: Shri C.T. Mathews
Section 147Section 148

…reopening of assessment on the basis of mere audit objections is unsustainable. In support of his contention the ld. Authorized Representative for the assessee placed reliance on the decision rendered in the case of Indian & Eastern Newspaper Society vs. CIT; 119 ITR 996 (SC). 5.2. The ld. Authorized Representative for the assessee further contended that in reply to the audit objections, the Assessing Officer furnished his detailed reply justifying the assessment order u/s. 143(3) of the Act and requested for dropping 4 ITA NO.798/MUM/2021 (A.Y.2011-12) audit objection. The ld. Authorized Representative for t…

Dy CIT, CC-6(3), Mumbai vs. M/S. Marathon Nextgen Realty Ltd, Mumbai

ITA 797/MUM/2021[2012-13]Status: DisposedITAT Mumbai25 Mar 2022AY 2012-13

Bench: Vikas Awasthy & Shri Prashant Maharishiआअसं. 797/मुं/2021 ("न. व. 2012-13 ) आअसं. 798/मुं/2021 ("न. व. 2011-12 ) आअसं. 799/मुं/2021 ("न. व. 2010-11) Dy. Commissioner Of Income Tax, Central Circle – 6(3), Room No.1926, 19Th Floor, Air India Building, Nariman Point, Mumbai 400 021 ..... अपीलाथ" /Appellant बनाम Vs. M/S. Marathon Nextgen Realty Limited, Marathon Futurex Mafatlal Mill Compound, N.M.Joshi Marg, Lower Parel, Mumbai 400 013. Pan: Aaacp-8032-E ..... ""तवाद"/Respondent अपीलाथ" "वारा/ Appellant By : Shri J.P. Bairagra With Ms. Rupa Nanda ""तवाद" "वारा/Respondent By : Shri C.T. Mathews सुनवाई क" "त"थ/ Date Of Hearing : 23/02/2022 घोषणा क" "त"थ/ Date Of Pronouncement : 25/03/2022 आदेश/ Order Per Vikas Awasthy, Jm: These Three Appeals By The Revenue Are Directed Against The Orders Of Commissioner Of Income Tax(Appeals)-54, Mumbai [In Short ‘ The Cit(A)’], For The 2

For Appellant: Shri J.P. Bairagra with Ms. Rupa NandaFor Respondent: Shri C.T. Mathews
Section 147Section 148

…reopening of assessment on the basis of mere audit objections is unsustainable. In support of his contention the ld. Authorized Representative for the assessee placed reliance on the decision rendered in the case of Indian & Eastern Newspaper Society vs. CIT; 119 ITR 996 (SC). 5.2. The ld. Authorized Representative for the assessee further contended that in reply to the audit objections, the Assessing Officer furnished his detailed reply justifying the assessment order u/s. 143(3) of the Act and requested for dropping 4 ITA NO.798/MUM/2021 (A.Y.2011-12) audit objection. The ld. Authorized Representative for t…

DCIT, Trichy vs. A.R.Akbar Sheriff, Ariyalur

In the result, the appeal filed by the assessee is dismissed as infructuous and the appeal filed by the Revenue is dismissed

ITA 1717/CHNY/2016[2010-11]Status: DisposedITAT Chennai24 Feb 2022AY 2010-11

Bench: Shri V. Durga Rao & Shri Manoj Kumar Aggarwalआयकर अपील सं./I.T.A. No.1644/Chny/2016 िनधा"रण वष"/Assessment Year: 2008-09 Shri A.R. Akbar Sheriff, Vs. The Deputy Commissioner Of 34, Trichy Main Road, Income Tax, Circle Iv, Ariyalur 621 305. Tiruchirappalli. [Pan:Addpa7056Q] (अपीलाथ"/Appellant) (""थ"/Respondent) आयकर अपील सं./I.T.A. No.1717/Chny/2016 िनधा"रण वष"/Assessment Year: 2008-09 The Assistant Commissioner Of Vs. Shri A.R. Akbar Sheriff, Income Tax, Circle I, 34, Trichy Main Road, Trichy. Ariyalur 621 305. (अपीलाथ"/Appellant) (""थ"/Respondent) अपीलाथ" की ओर से / Appellant By : Shri S. Sridhar, Advocate ""थ" की ओर से/Respondent By : Ms. R. Helan Ruby Jesintha, Addl. Jcit सुनवाई की तारीख/ Date Of Hearing : 17.02.2022 घोषणा की तारीख /Date Of Pronouncement : 24.02.2022 आदेश /O R D E R Per V. Durga Rao: Both The Cross Appeals Filed By The Assessee As Well As The Revenue Are Directed Against The Order Of The Ld. Commissioner Of Income Tax (Appeals) 1, Tiruchirappalli Dated 31.03.2016 Relevant To The Assessment Year 2008-09. The Assessee Has Challenged The Order

For Appellant: Shri S. Sridhar, AdvocateFor Respondent: Ms. R. Helan Ruby Jesintha, Addl. JCIT
Section 143(3)Section 147Section 148(2)

…3 I.T.A. Nos.1644 & 1717/Chny/16 the reopening has been solely made on the promptings of the of the R.A.P. on a question of law, which is not permissible, as held by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of Indian and Eastern Newspaper Society vs. CIT (1979) 119 ITR 996 (SC). We have gone through the decision of the Hon’ble Supreme Court, wherein, it has been held as under: “The opinion of an audit party on a point of law cannot be regarded as “information” within the meaning of section 147(b) of the I.T. Act, for the purpose of re-opening of assessment. But although an audit party does not possess the power to…

A.R.Akbar Shariff, Chennai vs. DCIT, Trichy

In the result, the appeal filed by the assessee is dismissed as infructuous and the appeal filed by the Revenue is dismissed

ITA 1644/CHNY/2016[2008-09]Status: DisposedITAT Chennai24 Feb 2022AY 2008-09

Bench: Shri V. Durga Rao & Shri Manoj Kumar Aggarwalआयकर अपील सं./I.T.A. No.1644/Chny/2016 िनधा"रण वष"/Assessment Year: 2008-09 Shri A.R. Akbar Sheriff, Vs. The Deputy Commissioner Of 34, Trichy Main Road, Income Tax, Circle Iv, Ariyalur 621 305. Tiruchirappalli. [Pan:Addpa7056Q] (अपीलाथ"/Appellant) (""थ"/Respondent) आयकर अपील सं./I.T.A. No.1717/Chny/2016 िनधा"रण वष"/Assessment Year: 2008-09 The Assistant Commissioner Of Vs. Shri A.R. Akbar Sheriff, Income Tax, Circle I, 34, Trichy Main Road, Trichy. Ariyalur 621 305. (अपीलाथ"/Appellant) (""थ"/Respondent) अपीलाथ" की ओर से / Appellant By : Shri S. Sridhar, Advocate ""थ" की ओर से/Respondent By : Ms. R. Helan Ruby Jesintha, Addl. Jcit सुनवाई की तारीख/ Date Of Hearing : 17.02.2022 घोषणा की तारीख /Date Of Pronouncement : 24.02.2022 आदेश /O R D E R Per V. Durga Rao: Both The Cross Appeals Filed By The Assessee As Well As The Revenue Are Directed Against The Order Of The Ld. Commissioner Of Income Tax (Appeals) 1, Tiruchirappalli Dated 31.03.2016 Relevant To The Assessment Year 2008-09. The Assessee Has Challenged The Order

For Appellant: Shri S. Sridhar, AdvocateFor Respondent: Ms. R. Helan Ruby Jesintha, Addl. JCIT
Section 143(3)Section 147Section 148(2)

…3 I.T.A. Nos.1644 & 1717/Chny/16 the reopening has been solely made on the promptings of the of the R.A.P. on a question of law, which is not permissible, as held by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of Indian and Eastern Newspaper Society vs. CIT (1979) 119 ITR 996 (SC). We have gone through the decision of the Hon’ble Supreme Court, wherein, it has been held as under: “The opinion of an audit party on a point of law cannot be regarded as “information” within the meaning of section 147(b) of the I.T. Act, for the purpose of re-opening of assessment. But although an audit party does not possess the power to…