CIT v. Vegetable Products Ltd.

88 ITR 192Supreme Court of India1973#5 most cited

What is CIT v. Vegetable Products Ltd. authority for?

When two equally plausible interpretations of a taxing provision are possible, or when conflicting views exist from non-jurisdictional High Courts, the interpretation that favors the assessee must be adopted.

2,664

judgments rely on this decision, according to BharatTax’s citation analysis of 385,718 Indian tax judgments — from 2005 to 2026.

Also referred to as

CIT v. Vegetable Products Ltd. · 88 ITR 192 · statutory interpretation · benefit of doubt assessee · two reasonable constructions · conflicting views · assessee favour · Section 143(3) · Section 153C · Section 153A · Section 144

Issues it is cited on

Judgments citing CIT v. Vegetable Products Ltd.

Bright Singh Chelladurai, Nagercoil vs. Income Tax Officer, Ward 1, Tirunelveli

In the result, appeal filed by the assessee is allowed

ITA 1428/CHNY/2023[2015-16]Status: DisposedITAT Chennai30 Apr 2024AY 2015-16

Bench: Shri Aby T. Varkey & Shri S.R.Raghunathaआयकर अपील सं./Ita No.1428/Chny/2023 िनधा"रण वष"/Assessment Year: 2015-16 V. Bright Singh Chelladurai, The Income Tax Officer, No.5, Nanthanial Street, Ward-1, Nagercoil, Tirunelveli. Kanyakumari-629 001. [Pan: Atvpb 0028 K] (अपीलाथ"/Appellant) (""यथ"/Respondent)

For Appellant: Shri Raghav Rajeev MenonFor Respondent: Shri D. Hema Bhupal, JCIT
Section 144Section 148Section 271ASection 271BSection 44A

…आयकर अपीलीय अिधकरण, ‘बी’ "यायपीठ, चे"ई। IN THE INCOME TAX APPELLATE TRIBUNAL ‘B’ BENCH: CHENNAI "ी एबी टी. वक", "ाियक सद" एवं एवं एवं एवं "ी एस. आर. रघुनाथा, लेखा सद" के सम" BEFORE SHRI ABY T. VARKEY, JUDICIAL MEMBER AND SHRI S.R.RAGHUNATHA, ACCOUNTANT MEMBER आयकर अपील सं./ITA No.1428/Chny/2023 िनधा"रण वष"/Assessment Year: 2015-16 v. Bright Singh Chelladurai, The Income Tax Officer, No.5, Nanthanial Street, Ward-1, Nagercoil, Tirunelveli. Kanyakumari-629 001. [PAN: ATVPB 0028 K] (अपीलाथ"/Appellant) (""यथ"/Respondent) अपीलाथ" क" ओर से/ Appellant by : Shri Raghav Rajeev Menon, Advocate ""यथ" क" ओर से /Respondent…

Vidya Sunil Mane, Kolhapur vs. Income Tax Officer TDS, Kolhapur

In the result, appeal of the assessee is Partly Allowed

ITA 131/PUN/2024[AY2014-2015 TDS Q4FY2013-2014]Status: DisposedITAT Pune26 Mar 2024

Bench: Shri S.S.Godara & Dr. Dipak P. Ripoteआयकर अपील सं. / Ita Nos.128, 129, 130 & 131/Pun/2024 िनधा"रणवष" / Assessment Years : 2013-14 & 2014-15 Vidya Sunil Mane, The Income Tax Officer, F1 Midc, Gokulshirgaon V Tds, Kolhapur. Kolhpur, Kolhapur – 416234. S Pan: Acbpm1640F Appellant/ Assessee Respondent /Revenue Assessee By Shri Mayuresh Doshi – Ar Revenue By Shri Sourabh Nayak – Addl.Cit(Dr) Date Of Hearing 19/03/2024 Date Of Pronouncement 26/03/2024 आदेश/ Order Per Dr. Dipak P. Ripote, Am: These Four Appeals Filed By The Assessee Are Against The Common Order Of Ld.Commissioner Of Income Tax(Appeals) [Nfac], Passed Under Section 250 Of The Income Tax Act, 1961 All Dated 21.11.2023. Since Issue Involved Is Same, All These Appeals Were Heard Together & Decided By This Consolidated Order. We Treat Appeal In Ita No.128/Pun/2024 For A.Y.2013-14, As A Lead Case. The Assessee For A.Y.2013-14 Has Raised The Following Grounds Of Appeal :

Section 200ASection 220(2)Section 234ESection 250

…Jurisdictional High Court, the decision which is favourable to the assessee needs to be followed; as observed by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of CIT Vs. Vegetable ITA Nos.128 to 131/PUN/2024 (04 Appeals) Vidya Sunil Mane [A] Products Limited [1973] 88 ITR 192 (SC). The decision of Hon’ble Karnataka High Court(supra) was followed by ITAT Pune Bench in the case of Medical Superintendent Rural Hospital, vs. DCIT, CPC(TDS) [2018] 100 taxmann.com 78. 2.5 In this case, Late Fee under section 234E has been levied for F.Y.2012-13. Admittedly,assessee had filed TDS Return on 24.09.2013 which is before 01.06.201…

Vidya Sunil Mane, Kolhapur vs. Income Tax Officer TDS, Kolhapur

In the result, appeal of the assessee is Partly Allowed

ITA 130/PUN/2024[AY2014-2015 TDS Q3FY2013-2014]Status: DisposedITAT Pune26 Mar 2024

Bench: Shri S.S.Godara & Dr. Dipak P. Ripoteआयकर अपील सं. / Ita Nos.128, 129, 130 & 131/Pun/2024 िनधा"रणवष" / Assessment Years : 2013-14 & 2014-15 Vidya Sunil Mane, The Income Tax Officer, F1 Midc, Gokulshirgaon V Tds, Kolhapur. Kolhpur, Kolhapur – 416234. S Pan: Acbpm1640F Appellant/ Assessee Respondent /Revenue Assessee By Shri Mayuresh Doshi – Ar Revenue By Shri Sourabh Nayak – Addl.Cit(Dr) Date Of Hearing 19/03/2024 Date Of Pronouncement 26/03/2024 आदेश/ Order Per Dr. Dipak P. Ripote, Am: These Four Appeals Filed By The Assessee Are Against The Common Order Of Ld.Commissioner Of Income Tax(Appeals) [Nfac], Passed Under Section 250 Of The Income Tax Act, 1961 All Dated 21.11.2023. Since Issue Involved Is Same, All These Appeals Were Heard Together & Decided By This Consolidated Order. We Treat Appeal In Ita No.128/Pun/2024 For A.Y.2013-14, As A Lead Case. The Assessee For A.Y.2013-14 Has Raised The Following Grounds Of Appeal :

Section 200ASection 220(2)Section 234ESection 250

…Jurisdictional High Court, the decision which is favourable to the assessee needs to be followed; as observed by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of CIT Vs. Vegetable ITA Nos.128 to 131/PUN/2024 (04 Appeals) Vidya Sunil Mane [A] Products Limited [1973] 88 ITR 192 (SC). The decision of Hon’ble Karnataka High Court(supra) was followed by ITAT Pune Bench in the case of Medical Superintendent Rural Hospital, vs. DCIT, CPC(TDS) [2018] 100 taxmann.com 78. 2.5 In this case, Late Fee under section 234E has been levied for F.Y.2012-13. Admittedly,assessee had filed TDS Return on 24.09.2013 which is before 01.06.201…

Vidya Sunil Mane, Kolhapur vs. Income Tax Officer TDS, Kolhapur

In the result, appeal of the assessee is Partly Allowed

ITA 129/PUN/2024[AY2014-2015 TDS Q2FY2013-2014]Status: DisposedITAT Pune26 Mar 2024

Bench: Shri S.S.Godara & Dr. Dipak P. Ripoteआयकर अपील सं. / Ita Nos.128, 129, 130 & 131/Pun/2024 िनधा"रणवष" / Assessment Years : 2013-14 & 2014-15 Vidya Sunil Mane, The Income Tax Officer, F1 Midc, Gokulshirgaon V Tds, Kolhapur. Kolhpur, Kolhapur – 416234. S Pan: Acbpm1640F Appellant/ Assessee Respondent /Revenue Assessee By Shri Mayuresh Doshi – Ar Revenue By Shri Sourabh Nayak – Addl.Cit(Dr) Date Of Hearing 19/03/2024 Date Of Pronouncement 26/03/2024 आदेश/ Order Per Dr. Dipak P. Ripote, Am: These Four Appeals Filed By The Assessee Are Against The Common Order Of Ld.Commissioner Of Income Tax(Appeals) [Nfac], Passed Under Section 250 Of The Income Tax Act, 1961 All Dated 21.11.2023. Since Issue Involved Is Same, All These Appeals Were Heard Together & Decided By This Consolidated Order. We Treat Appeal In Ita No.128/Pun/2024 For A.Y.2013-14, As A Lead Case. The Assessee For A.Y.2013-14 Has Raised The Following Grounds Of Appeal :

Section 200ASection 220(2)Section 234ESection 250

…Jurisdictional High Court, the decision which is favourable to the assessee needs to be followed; as observed by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of CIT Vs. Vegetable ITA Nos.128 to 131/PUN/2024 (04 Appeals) Vidya Sunil Mane [A] Products Limited [1973] 88 ITR 192 (SC). The decision of Hon’ble Karnataka High Court(supra) was followed by ITAT Pune Bench in the case of Medical Superintendent Rural Hospital, vs. DCIT, CPC(TDS) [2018] 100 taxmann.com 78. 2.5 In this case, Late Fee under section 234E has been levied for F.Y.2012-13. Admittedly,assessee had filed TDS Return on 24.09.2013 which is before 01.06.201…

Vidya Sunil Mane, Kolhapur vs. Income Tax Officer TDS Kolhapur, Kolhapur

In the result, appeal of the assessee is Partly Allowed

ITA 128/PUN/2024[2013-2014 TDS Q4 FY2012-2013]Status: DisposedITAT Pune26 Mar 2024

Bench: Shri S.S.Godara & Dr. Dipak P. Ripoteआयकर अपील सं. / Ita Nos.128, 129, 130 & 131/Pun/2024 िनधा"रणवष" / Assessment Years : 2013-14 & 2014-15 Vidya Sunil Mane, The Income Tax Officer, F1 Midc, Gokulshirgaon V Tds, Kolhapur. Kolhpur, Kolhapur – 416234. S Pan: Acbpm1640F Appellant/ Assessee Respondent /Revenue Assessee By Shri Mayuresh Doshi – Ar Revenue By Shri Sourabh Nayak – Addl.Cit(Dr) Date Of Hearing 19/03/2024 Date Of Pronouncement 26/03/2024 आदेश/ Order Per Dr. Dipak P. Ripote, Am: These Four Appeals Filed By The Assessee Are Against The Common Order Of Ld.Commissioner Of Income Tax(Appeals) [Nfac], Passed Under Section 250 Of The Income Tax Act, 1961 All Dated 21.11.2023. Since Issue Involved Is Same, All These Appeals Were Heard Together & Decided By This Consolidated Order. We Treat Appeal In Ita No.128/Pun/2024 For A.Y.2013-14, As A Lead Case. The Assessee For A.Y.2013-14 Has Raised The Following Grounds Of Appeal :

Section 200ASection 220(2)Section 234ESection 250

…Jurisdictional High Court, the decision which is favourable to the assessee needs to be followed; as observed by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of CIT Vs. Vegetable ITA Nos.128 to 131/PUN/2024 (04 Appeals) Vidya Sunil Mane [A] Products Limited [1973] 88 ITR 192 (SC). The decision of Hon’ble Karnataka High Court(supra) was followed by ITAT Pune Bench in the case of Medical Superintendent Rural Hospital, vs. DCIT, CPC(TDS) [2018] 100 taxmann.com 78. 2.5 In this case, Late Fee under section 234E has been levied for F.Y.2012-13. Admittedly,assessee had filed TDS Return on 24.09.2013 which is before 01.06.201…

Sri Prakash Bhajandas Talreja, Bengaluru vs. Deputy Commissioner of Income Tax, Central Circle-1(3), Bengaluru

In the result, ITA Nos.1061, 1062, 1063, 1065 & 1066/Bang/2023 are partly allowed and ITA No

ITA 1065/BANG/2023[2017-18]Status: DisposedITAT Bangalore22 Mar 2024AY 2017-18

Bench: Shri Chandra Poojari & Smt. Beena Pillaiita Nos.1061 To 1066/Bang/2023 Assessment Years: 2014-15, 2015-16, 2016-17, 2016-17, 2017-18 & 2018-19 Sri Prakash Bhajandas Talreja No.402, 4Th Floor, Embassy Centre No.11, Crescent Road Dcit Bengaluru 560 001 Vs. Central Circle-1(3) Karnataka Bengaluru Pan No : Abkpt1011B Assessee Respondent Assessee By : Shri V. Srinivasan, A.R. Respondent By : Shri G. Manoj Kumar, D.R. Date Of Hearing : 01.02.2024 Date Of Pronouncement : 22.03.2024 O R D E R Per Chandra Poojari: The Appeals In Ita Nos.1061, 1062, 1063, 1065 & 1066/Bang/2023 Are Emanated From The Common Order Of Cit(A) Central Circle, Bengaluru For The Assessment Years 2014-15 To 2018-19 Dated 16.11.2023. Ita No.1064/Bang/2023 Is Emanated From The Order Of Cit(A) Dated 11.8.2023 For The Assessment Year 2016-17 With Regard To Levy Of Penalty U/S 271Aab Of The Income Tax Act, 1961 (In Short “The Act”). Since The Issue In All These Appeals Is Common In Nature, These Are Clubbed Together, Heard Together & Disposed Of By This Common Order For The Sake Of Convenience. 2. First, We Will Take Up Ita Nos.1061, 1062, 1063, 1065 & 1066/Bang/2023 For Adjudication. The Common Ground In All These Appeals Except Change In Figures, Which Reads As Under:

For Appellant: Shri V. Srinivasan, A.RFor Respondent: Shri G. Manoj Kumar, D.R
Section 153CSection 271ASection 69

…sion are possible, that construction which Page 59 of 121 ITA Nos.1061 to 1066/Bang/2023 Sri Prakash Bhajandas Talreja, Bangalore favours the assessee must be adopted, which is in line with the Supreme Court judgment in the case of CIT v. Vegetable Products, 88 ITR 192 (SC). This is a well- accepted construction recognized by various courts. 9.94. Being so, he submitted that the seized material relied by the assessing officer for sustaining addition is not speaking one in itself and also not speaking in conjunction with some other evidence which the authorities found during the course of search or post search in…

Sri Prakash Bhajandas Talreja, Bengaluru vs. Deputy Commissioner of Income Tax, Central Circle-1(3), Bengaluru

In the result, ITA Nos.1061, 1062, 1063, 1065 & 1066/Bang/2023 are partly allowed and ITA No

ITA 1064/BANG/2023[2016-17]Status: HeardITAT Bangalore22 Mar 2024AY 2016-17

Bench: Shri Chandra Poojari & Smt. Beena Pillaiita Nos.1061 To 1066/Bang/2023 Assessment Years: 2014-15, 2015-16, 2016-17, 2016-17, 2017-18 & 2018-19 Sri Prakash Bhajandas Talreja No.402, 4Th Floor, Embassy Centre No.11, Crescent Road Dcit Bengaluru 560 001 Vs. Central Circle-1(3) Karnataka Bengaluru Pan No : Abkpt1011B Assessee Respondent Assessee By : Shri V. Srinivasan, A.R. Respondent By : Shri G. Manoj Kumar, D.R. Date Of Hearing : 01.02.2024 Date Of Pronouncement : 22.03.2024 O R D E R Per Chandra Poojari: The Appeals In Ita Nos.1061, 1062, 1063, 1065 & 1066/Bang/2023 Are Emanated From The Common Order Of Cit(A) Central Circle, Bengaluru For The Assessment Years 2014-15 To 2018-19 Dated 16.11.2023. Ita No.1064/Bang/2023 Is Emanated From The Order Of Cit(A) Dated 11.8.2023 For The Assessment Year 2016-17 With Regard To Levy Of Penalty U/S 271Aab Of The Income Tax Act, 1961 (In Short “The Act”). Since The Issue In All These Appeals Is Common In Nature, These Are Clubbed Together, Heard Together & Disposed Of By This Common Order For The Sake Of Convenience. 2. First, We Will Take Up Ita Nos.1061, 1062, 1063, 1065 & 1066/Bang/2023 For Adjudication. The Common Ground In All These Appeals Except Change In Figures, Which Reads As Under:

For Appellant: Shri V. Srinivasan, A.RFor Respondent: Shri G. Manoj Kumar, D.R
Section 153CSection 271ASection 69

…sion are possible, that construction which Page 59 of 121 ITA Nos.1061 to 1066/Bang/2023 Sri Prakash Bhajandas Talreja, Bangalore favours the assessee must be adopted, which is in line with the Supreme Court judgment in the case of CIT v. Vegetable Products, 88 ITR 192 (SC). This is a well- accepted construction recognized by various courts. 9.94. Being so, he submitted that the seized material relied by the assessing officer for sustaining addition is not speaking one in itself and also not speaking in conjunction with some other evidence which the authorities found during the course of search or post search in…

Sri Prakash Bhajandas Talreja, Bengaluru vs. Deputy Commissioner of Income-Tax, Central Circle-1(3), Bengaluru

In the result, ITA Nos.1061, 1062, 1063, 1065 & 1066/Bang/2023 are partly allowed and ITA No

ITA 1062/BANG/2023[2015-16]Status: DisposedITAT Bangalore22 Mar 2024AY 2015-16

Bench: Shri Chandra Poojari & Smt. Beena Pillaiita Nos.1061 To 1066/Bang/2023 Assessment Years: 2014-15, 2015-16, 2016-17, 2016-17, 2017-18 & 2018-19 Sri Prakash Bhajandas Talreja No.402, 4Th Floor, Embassy Centre No.11, Crescent Road Dcit Bengaluru 560 001 Vs. Central Circle-1(3) Karnataka Bengaluru Pan No : Abkpt1011B Assessee Respondent Assessee By : Shri V. Srinivasan, A.R. Respondent By : Shri G. Manoj Kumar, D.R. Date Of Hearing : 01.02.2024 Date Of Pronouncement : 22.03.2024 O R D E R Per Chandra Poojari: The Appeals In Ita Nos.1061, 1062, 1063, 1065 & 1066/Bang/2023 Are Emanated From The Common Order Of Cit(A) Central Circle, Bengaluru For The Assessment Years 2014-15 To 2018-19 Dated 16.11.2023. Ita No.1064/Bang/2023 Is Emanated From The Order Of Cit(A) Dated 11.8.2023 For The Assessment Year 2016-17 With Regard To Levy Of Penalty U/S 271Aab Of The Income Tax Act, 1961 (In Short “The Act”). Since The Issue In All These Appeals Is Common In Nature, These Are Clubbed Together, Heard Together & Disposed Of By This Common Order For The Sake Of Convenience. 2. First, We Will Take Up Ita Nos.1061, 1062, 1063, 1065 & 1066/Bang/2023 For Adjudication. The Common Ground In All These Appeals Except Change In Figures, Which Reads As Under:

For Appellant: Shri V. Srinivasan, A.RFor Respondent: Shri G. Manoj Kumar, D.R
Section 153CSection 271ASection 69

…sion are possible, that construction which Page 59 of 121 ITA Nos.1061 to 1066/Bang/2023 Sri Prakash Bhajandas Talreja, Bangalore favours the assessee must be adopted, which is in line with the Supreme Court judgment in the case of CIT v. Vegetable Products, 88 ITR 192 (SC). This is a well- accepted construction recognized by various courts. 9.94. Being so, he submitted that the seized material relied by the assessing officer for sustaining addition is not speaking one in itself and also not speaking in conjunction with some other evidence which the authorities found during the course of search or post search in…