CIT v. Pruthvi Brokers & Shareholders

349 ITR 336High Court2012#47 most cited

What is CIT v. Pruthvi Brokers & Shareholders authority for?

Appellate authorities can entertain fresh claims or revised computations of income made by an assessee, even if these were not submitted through a revised return of income.

956

judgments rely on this decision, according to BharatTax’s citation analysis of 384,082 Indian tax judgments — from 2014 to 2026.

Also referred to as

Pruthvi Brokers & Shareholders · 349 ITR 336 · Bombay High Court · appellate authority power · entertain fresh claim · additional ground of appeal · revised computation of income · absence of revised return · section 139 · Goetz India Ltd. · Tribunal power

Issues it is cited on

Judgments citing CIT v. Pruthvi Brokers & Shareholders

Anand Rathi Capital Advisors P.Ltd, Mumbai vs. DCIT Cen Cir 5(1), Mumbai

The appeal of the revenue is dismissed

ITA 7543/MUM/2016[2009-10]Status: DisposedITAT Mumbai03 Jan 2018AY 2009-10

Bench: Shri Rajendra, Am & Shri Ravish Sood, Jm Ita Nos. 7543, 7544, 7515 & 7546/Mum/2016 (निर्धारण वषा / Assessment Years:2009-10, 2011-12, 2013-14 & 2014-15) M/S Anand Rathi Capital Dcit, Central Circle-5(1) Advisors P. Ltd, 47A, 3Rd R. No. 1928, 19Th Floor, बिधम/ Floor, Plot No. 308 Air India Building, Vs. Hanuman Bldg, Perin Nariman Point, Nariman Street, Fort, Mumbai-400 021 Mumbai – 400 001. स्थामी रेखा सं./ जीआइआय सं./ Pan No. Aaacr2791N (अऩीराथी /Assessee) (प्रत्मथी / Revenue) :

For Appellant: Shri Anuj Kisnadwala, A.RFor Respondent: Shri Abhijit Patankar, D.R
Section 132(1)Section 143(3)Section 14ASection 153A

…o. 7546/Mum/2016 18 Anand Rathi Capital Advisors P. Ltd. vs. DCIT ITA Nos. 7472 -7474/Mum/2016 DCIT vs. Anand Rathi Capital Advisors P. Ltd judgment of the Hon’ble High Court of Bombay in the case of CIT Vs. Pruthvi Brokers and Shareholders Pvt. Ltd. (2012) 349 ITR 336 (Bom), wherein the Hon‟ble Court had observed that the assessee is entitled to raise not merely additional legal submissions before the appellate authorities, but is also entitled to raise additional claim before them, therefore, admit the aforesaid plea of the assessee which we find is based on the facts already available on record. The Hon‟ble…

Anand Rathi Global Finance Ltd, Mumbai vs. DCIT Cen Cir 5(1), Mumbai

The appeal of the revenue is dismissed

ITA 7527/MUM/2016[2012-13]Status: DisposedITAT Mumbai03 Jan 2018AY 2012-13

Bench: Shri Rajendra, Am & Shri Ravish Sood, Jm Ita Nos. 7527 & 7526/Mum/2016 (निर्धारण वषा / Assessment Years:2012-13 & 2014-15) M/S Anand Rathi Global Dcit, Central Circle-5(1) Finance Ltd., 4Th Floor, R. No. 1928, 19Th Floor, बिधम/ Silver Metropolis Bldg., Air India Building, Vs. Western Express Highway, Nariman Point, Goregaon (E), Mumbai-400 021 Mumbai-400 063 स्थायी लेखा सं./जीआइआर सं./ Pan No. Aabcr1136N (अऩीराथी /Assessee) (प्रत्मथी / Revenue) :

For Appellant: Shri Anuj Kisnadwala, A.RFor Respondent: Shri Abhijit Patankar, D.R
Section 132(1)Section 143(3)Section 14ASection 14A(1)Section 153A

…of the case though find that such a proposition was not advanced by the assessee before the lower authorities, but then, keeping in view the judgment of the Hon‟ble High Court of Bombay in the case of CIT Vs. Pruthvi Brokers and Shareholders Pvt. Ltd. (2012) 349 ITR 336 (Bom), wherein the Hon‟ble Court had observed that the assessee is entitled to raise not merely additional legal submissions before the appellate authorities, but is also entitled to raise additional claim before them. The Hon‟ble High Court further observed that the appellate authorities have jurisdiction to deal not merely with additional groun…

Siddhesh Capital Market Services P.Ltd, Mumbai vs. DCIT Cir 3(3), Mumbai

Appeal of the AO is dismissed

ITA 2517/MUM/2015[2010-11]Status: DisposedITAT Mumbai01 Jan 2018AY 2010-11

Bench: S/Shri Rajendra, A.M. & Amarjit Singh, J.M. आयकर अपील सुं./Ita No. 6532/Mum/2012,धनधावरण र्र्व /Assessment Year: 2009-10 M/S.Siddhesh Capital Market Services Dy. Commissioner Of Income Tax, P.Ltd,122, Maker Chamber Iii, Circle-3(3), Vs. Nariman Point, Mumbai – 400021 Mumbai. Pan: Aaccs4582N (अपीलाथी /Appellant) (प्रत्यथी / Respondent) आयकर अपील सुं./Ita No.2489/Mum/2015 धनधावरण र्र्व /Assessment Year: 2010-11 Dy. Commissioner Of Income Tax, M/S.Siddhesh Capital Market Services, Vs. Circle-3(3),Mumbai. Nariman Point, Mumbai – 400021 आयकर अपील सुं./Ita No.2517/Mum/2015 धनधावरण र्र्व /Assessment Year: 2010-11 M/S.Siddhesh Capital Market Services, Dy. Commissioner Of Income Tax, Vs. Nariman Point, Mumbai – 400021 Circle-3(3),Mumbai. Revenue By: Shri V. Justin-Dr Assessee By: Shri Vijay Mehta स नर्ाई की तारीख / Date Of Hearing: 03/10/2017 घोर्णा की तारीख / Date Of Pronouncement: 01/01/2018 आयकर अधधधनयम,1961 की धारा 254(1) के अन्द्तगवत आदेश Order U/S.254(1)Of The Income-Tax Act,1961(Act) लेखा सदस्य,राजेन्द्र के अन सार -Per Rajendra,Am: Challenging The Orders Dated 26.06.2012 & 12.01.2015 Of Cit(A)-7 & Cit-8,Respectively, The Assessee & The Assessing Officer(Ao)Have Filed Appeals For The Above-Mentioned Two Assessment Years.As The Issues Involved In Both The Appeals Are Common,So,We Are Adjudicat- Ing Them Together. Assessee-Company Is Engaged In The Business Of Finance,Trading, Investment & Derivative Transaction In Shares & Securities. The Details Of Filing Of Returns, Returned Incomes,Dates Of Assessments & Assessed Incomes Can Be Tabulated As Under: Ay. Roi Filed On Returned Income Asstt.Date Assessed Income 09-10 22.09.2009 (-) Rs.81,01,51,079/- 30.11.2011 (-) Rs.80,82,06,669/- 10-11 21.09.2010 Rs. 48,14,034/- 11.02.2013 Rs. 49,72,360/-

For Appellant: Shri Vijay MehtaFor Respondent: Shri V. Justin-DR
Section 10(34)Section 14ASection 254(1)Section 35Section 35D

…able u/s.35DD of the Act or not.We are of the opinion that the matter needs further verification.So,in the interest of justice we are restoring back the issue to the file of the FAA,who would decide the issue after considering the judgment of Pruthvi Brokers (349 ITR 336)of the Hon’ble Bombay High Court.Second ground of appeal is partly allowed. 4.Last ground of appeal is about valuation loss treated as speculation loss.It was brought to our notice that identical issue had arisen in the earlier year and that tribunal had decided the issue in favour of the assessee.We would like to reproduce the order of the Tribu…

DCIT Cir 3(3)(1), Mumbai vs. Siddhesh Capital Market Services P.Ltd, Mumbai

Appeal of the AO is dismissed

ITA 2489/MUM/2015[2010-11]Status: DisposedITAT Mumbai01 Jan 2018AY 2010-11

Bench: S/Shri Rajendra, A.M. & Amarjit Singh, J.M. आयकर अपील सुं./Ita No. 6532/Mum/2012,धनधावरण र्र्व /Assessment Year: 2009-10 M/S.Siddhesh Capital Market Services Dy. Commissioner Of Income Tax, P.Ltd,122, Maker Chamber Iii, Circle-3(3), Vs. Nariman Point, Mumbai – 400021 Mumbai. Pan: Aaccs4582N (अपीलाथी /Appellant) (प्रत्यथी / Respondent) आयकर अपील सुं./Ita No.2489/Mum/2015 धनधावरण र्र्व /Assessment Year: 2010-11 Dy. Commissioner Of Income Tax, M/S.Siddhesh Capital Market Services, Vs. Circle-3(3),Mumbai. Nariman Point, Mumbai – 400021 आयकर अपील सुं./Ita No.2517/Mum/2015 धनधावरण र्र्व /Assessment Year: 2010-11 M/S.Siddhesh Capital Market Services, Dy. Commissioner Of Income Tax, Vs. Nariman Point, Mumbai – 400021 Circle-3(3),Mumbai. Revenue By: Shri V. Justin-Dr Assessee By: Shri Vijay Mehta स नर्ाई की तारीख / Date Of Hearing: 03/10/2017 घोर्णा की तारीख / Date Of Pronouncement: 01/01/2018 आयकर अधधधनयम,1961 की धारा 254(1) के अन्द्तगवत आदेश Order U/S.254(1)Of The Income-Tax Act,1961(Act) लेखा सदस्य,राजेन्द्र के अन सार -Per Rajendra,Am: Challenging The Orders Dated 26.06.2012 & 12.01.2015 Of Cit(A)-7 & Cit-8,Respectively, The Assessee & The Assessing Officer(Ao)Have Filed Appeals For The Above-Mentioned Two Assessment Years.As The Issues Involved In Both The Appeals Are Common,So,We Are Adjudicat- Ing Them Together. Assessee-Company Is Engaged In The Business Of Finance,Trading, Investment & Derivative Transaction In Shares & Securities. The Details Of Filing Of Returns, Returned Incomes,Dates Of Assessments & Assessed Incomes Can Be Tabulated As Under: Ay. Roi Filed On Returned Income Asstt.Date Assessed Income 09-10 22.09.2009 (-) Rs.81,01,51,079/- 30.11.2011 (-) Rs.80,82,06,669/- 10-11 21.09.2010 Rs. 48,14,034/- 11.02.2013 Rs. 49,72,360/-

For Appellant: Shri Vijay MehtaFor Respondent: Shri V. Justin-DR
Section 10(34)Section 14ASection 254(1)Section 35Section 35D

…able u/s.35DD of the Act or not.We are of the opinion that the matter needs further verification.So,in the interest of justice we are restoring back the issue to the file of the FAA,who would decide the issue after considering the judgment of Pruthvi Brokers (349 ITR 336)of the Hon’ble Bombay High Court.Second ground of appeal is partly allowed. 4.Last ground of appeal is about valuation loss treated as speculation loss.It was brought to our notice that identical issue had arisen in the earlier year and that tribunal had decided the issue in favour of the assessee.We would like to reproduce the order of the Tribu…

Siddhesh Capital Market Services P.Ltd, Mumbai vs. DCIT Cir 3(3), Mumbai

Appeal of the AO is dismissed

ITA 6532/MUM/2012[2009-10]Status: DisposedITAT Mumbai01 Jan 2018AY 2009-10

Bench: S/Shri Rajendra, A.M. & Amarjit Singh, J.M. आयकर अपील सुं./Ita No. 6532/Mum/2012,धनधावरण र्र्व /Assessment Year: 2009-10 M/S.Siddhesh Capital Market Services Dy. Commissioner Of Income Tax, P.Ltd,122, Maker Chamber Iii, Circle-3(3), Vs. Nariman Point, Mumbai – 400021 Mumbai. Pan: Aaccs4582N (अपीलाथी /Appellant) (प्रत्यथी / Respondent) आयकर अपील सुं./Ita No.2489/Mum/2015 धनधावरण र्र्व /Assessment Year: 2010-11 Dy. Commissioner Of Income Tax, M/S.Siddhesh Capital Market Services, Vs. Circle-3(3),Mumbai. Nariman Point, Mumbai – 400021 आयकर अपील सुं./Ita No.2517/Mum/2015 धनधावरण र्र्व /Assessment Year: 2010-11 M/S.Siddhesh Capital Market Services, Dy. Commissioner Of Income Tax, Vs. Nariman Point, Mumbai – 400021 Circle-3(3),Mumbai. Revenue By: Shri V. Justin-Dr Assessee By: Shri Vijay Mehta स नर्ाई की तारीख / Date Of Hearing: 03/10/2017 घोर्णा की तारीख / Date Of Pronouncement: 01/01/2018 आयकर अधधधनयम,1961 की धारा 254(1) के अन्द्तगवत आदेश Order U/S.254(1)Of The Income-Tax Act,1961(Act) लेखा सदस्य,राजेन्द्र के अन सार -Per Rajendra,Am: Challenging The Orders Dated 26.06.2012 & 12.01.2015 Of Cit(A)-7 & Cit-8,Respectively, The Assessee & The Assessing Officer(Ao)Have Filed Appeals For The Above-Mentioned Two Assessment Years.As The Issues Involved In Both The Appeals Are Common,So,We Are Adjudicat- Ing Them Together. Assessee-Company Is Engaged In The Business Of Finance,Trading, Investment & Derivative Transaction In Shares & Securities. The Details Of Filing Of Returns, Returned Incomes,Dates Of Assessments & Assessed Incomes Can Be Tabulated As Under: Ay. Roi Filed On Returned Income Asstt.Date Assessed Income 09-10 22.09.2009 (-) Rs.81,01,51,079/- 30.11.2011 (-) Rs.80,82,06,669/- 10-11 21.09.2010 Rs. 48,14,034/- 11.02.2013 Rs. 49,72,360/-

For Appellant: Shri Vijay MehtaFor Respondent: Shri V. Justin-DR
Section 10(34)Section 14ASection 254(1)Section 35Section 35D

…able u/s.35DD of the Act or not.We are of the opinion that the matter needs further verification.So,in the interest of justice we are restoring back the issue to the file of the FAA,who would decide the issue after considering the judgment of Pruthvi Brokers (349 ITR 336)of the Hon’ble Bombay High Court.Second ground of appeal is partly allowed. 4.Last ground of appeal is about valuation loss treated as speculation loss.It was brought to our notice that identical issue had arisen in the earlier year and that tribunal had decided the issue in favour of the assessee.We would like to reproduce the order of the Tribu…

Sajjan India Ltd, Mumbai vs. Addl CIT RG 7(2), Mumbai

In the result the appeal of the assessee and revenue for AY 2011-12

ITA 5550/MUM/2015[2011-12]Status: DisposedITAT Mumbai28 Nov 2017AY 2011-12

Bench: Shri C.N.Prasad & Shri Ramit Kocharआयकर अपीऱ सं./I.T.A. No.5550/Mum/2015 (नििाारण वर्ा / Assessment Year: 2011-12) बिाम/ Sajjan India Limited Addl. Cit, Range 7(2) C/O Shankarlal Jain & Aayakar Bhawan Associates , 12, Engineer M K Road V. Building, 265, Princess Queens Road Street, Mumbai-400020 Mumbai-400020 स्थायी ऱेखा सं./ Pan : Aaacs6498M (अपीऱाथी /Appellant) (प्रत्यथी / Respondent) ..

For Appellant: Shri. Shankarlal JainFor Respondent: Shri. V. Jenardhanan, DR
Section 115JSection 143(3)Section 14A

…आयकर अपीऱीय अधिकरण “K” न्यायपीठ म ुंबई में। IN THE INCOME TAX APPELLATE TRIBUNAL “K” BENCH, MUMBAI BEFORE SHRI C.N.PRASAD, JUDICIAL MEMBER AND SHRI RAMIT KOCHAR, ACCOUNTANT MEMBER आयकर अपीऱ सं./I.T.A. No.5550/Mum/2015 (नििाारण वर्ा / Assessment Year: 2011-12) बिाम/ Sajjan India Limited Addl. CIT, Range 7(2) C/o Shankarlal Jain & Aayakar Bhawan Associates , 12, Engineer M K Road v. Building, 265, Princess Queens Road Street, Mumbai-400020 Mumbai-400020 स्थायी ऱेखा सं./ PAN : AAACS6498M (अपीऱाथी /Appellant) (प्रत्यथी / Respondent) .. आयकर अपीऱ सं./I.T.A. No. 5751/Mum/2015 (नििाारण वर्ा / Assessment Year: 2011-12)…

Bhavesh P. Gandhi, Mumbai vs. ACIT Cen Cir 38, Mumbai

In the result, this appeal filed by the assessee stands allowed

ITA 6580/MUM/2016[2007-08]Status: DisposedITAT Mumbai11 Oct 2017AY 2007-08

Bench: Shri Shamim Yahya, Am & Shri Pawan Singh, Jm आयकर अपील सं./I.T.A. No.6580/Mum/2016 ("नधा"रण वष" / Assessment Year: 2007-08) Mr. Bhavesh P. Gandhi Acit, Central Circle – 38, Now Dcit-Cc-6(3), 19Th Floor, C/O. Skil House, 209, Bank Street बनाम/ Cross Lane, Fort, Mumbai-400 023 Air India Building, Nariman Point, Vs. Mumbai-400 021 "थायी लेखा सं./जीआइआर सं./Pan/Gir No. Aabpg 9515 D (अपीलाथ" /Appellant) (""यथ" / Respondent) : अपीलाथ" क" ओर से / Appellant By : Shri S. K. Mutsaddi ""यथ" क" ओर से/Respondent By : Shri B. Pruseth

For Appellant: Shri S. K. MutsaddiFor Respondent: Shri B. Pruseth
Section 143(3)Section 153A

…to the root of the appeal and it is humbly prayed that by following the decisions in Jute Corporation of India v. CIT – 187 ITR 688 (Supreme Court), Ahmedabad Electricity Co. Ltd. v. CIT – 199 ITR 351 (Bom.) & CIT v. Prithvi Brokers & Shareholders Pvt. Ltd. – 349 ITR 336 (Bom.), the same be admitted. 4. At the outset it is noted that there is a delay of nine days in filing the appeal. The reasonable cause for the delay has been attributed to the illness of the ld. Counsel. 5. Upon hearing both the counsels and perusing the records, we condone the delay. 6. At the outset we deal with the additional ground. This…