5 orders · Page 1 of 1
The Patna High Court held that the assessment order passed on the surrendered PAN (Annexure-P/1) is untenable and set it aside. The Court reasoned that the petitioner's earlier PAN was surrendered and a new one was issued with a changed status. Even if some transactions were noticed in the earlier PAN, it was within the competence of the Jurisdictional Assessing Officer to proceed with reassessment under the new PAN, treating undisclosed transactions from the earlier PAN as escaped assessment. The Court noted that the cited decisions from the Bombay and Calcutta High Courts had identical facts where assessments on surrendered PANs were set aside. However, the Court clarified that the Department is not prohibited from carrying out fresh proceedings. It observed that a reassessment could be initiated under Section 148 of the Act after issuing a notice under Section 148A, and the assessment could be completed through the faceless assessment procedure in the new PAN, treating transactions from the earlier PAN as escaped assessment if not disclosed. The Court also noted that any future proceedings would be relatable to the date of the notice issued under Section 148A against the old PAN, and the assessee would not be entitled to raise the question of limitation.
The High Court held that a change in the address recorded in the PAN card does not automatically result in a change of the Jurisdictional Assessing Officer (JAO). The Court noted that while the petitioner claims to have changed his PAN address in 2017 and sought a JAO transfer, there is no clear evidence of follow-up or formal approval under Section 127 of the Income Tax Act, 1961. The Court observed that the petitioner had not objected to the jurisdiction of the Muzaffarpur JAO and that returns filed after 2017 still indicated the Muzaffarpur JAO. The change of address in the PAN database primarily facilitates the service of notices. The Court also referred to the Department's FAQ, which outlines a procedure for migrating PAN to a new AO, requiring written applications and approvals. Given that the petitioner has not followed this procedure and is now facing a Section 148 notice which will be handled under the Faceless Assessment Scheme, no prejudice is caused. Therefore, the Court found no reason to interfere with the notice issued under Section 148.
The High Court held that recovery of the demand should await the disposal of the appeal before the National Faceless Appeal Centre, given that the demand is based on an assessment order passed prior to the Tribunal's order. The court noted that 20% of the demand had already been recovered. The court clarified that if the assessment is set aside, the assessee would be entitled to a refund along with interest, whichever is higher between statutory interest and the interest paid by the assessee on the cash credit account. If the assessment is not set aside, the assessee would be saved from interest on the amount recovered in the intervening period. No further recovery would be made based on the impugned assessment order until the appeal is disposed of. The writ petition was disposed of with these observations, without commenting on the merits of the assessment.
The High Court held that the assessment order clearly recorded satisfaction for initiating penalty proceedings under Section 271(1)(c) for furnishing inaccurate particulars and concealment of income. The Tribunal's finding to the contrary was considered erroneous. The Court noted that the issue of whether satisfaction was recorded was not raised in previous proceedings, including the High Court challenge to the Section 263 order, and demonstrably, satisfaction was recorded. The Court found no reason to sustain the Tribunal's order and answered the question of law in favor of the revenue. However, since the First Appellate Authority had interfered with the penalty order on quantum, the High Court remanded the matter back to the Tribunal for a factual adjudication on the legality of the penalty imposed and modified by the First Appellate Authority. The Tribunal was directed to consider the matter expeditiously, within six months.
The High Court held that the CIT's order under Section 263 was justified. The Court agreed with the principle that once books are rejected and net profit is estimated, further additions based on those books are generally not permissible. However, in this case, the substantial amount of unexplained sundry creditors (Rs. 1,51,86,178) was not accounted for by the AO. The Court reasoned that if these sundry credits are not explained, they would either need to be added to the contract receipts before estimating net profit or treated as income from other sources, leading to higher tax liability. The CIT also correctly noted the non-verification of TDS. Therefore, the assessment order was indeed erroneous and prejudicial to the revenue. The High Court found no reason to interfere with the CIT's order and annulled the Tribunal's order, directing the AO to complete the assessment. The questions of law were answered against the assessee and in favour of the Revenue.