2 orders · Page 1 of 1
The High Court held that while the CIT's reference to the refusal of Section 80G exemption and the show cause notice for Section 12AA cancellation could be seen as an attempt to overreach a stay order, it did not invalidate the remaining part of the Section 263 order. The Court disagreed with the petitioner's submission that mere grant of Section 12AA exemption obviates the need for assessment proceedings. The CIT's reasoning for setting aside the assessment order, based on the AO's failure to examine the genuineness of expenses, their application towards trust objects, and the specifics of trading and income/expenditure accounts for hospital units, was found to be valid. The Court warned the CIT against overreaching court orders but upheld the Section 263 order. The AO was directed to keep in mind that the impugned order dated 28.09.2010 and the show cause notice dated 13.03.2010 were quashed by the Court, and to decide the matter in accordance with law, allowing the petitioner to take pleas regarding sale of medicines, commissions, Naivedyam, and Prasad as per legal principles.
The High Court held that while the CIT's reference to the refusal of Section 80G exemption and the show-cause notice for Section 12AA cancellation, despite a stay order, could be seen as an attempt to overreach the court's orders, it did not invalidate the remaining part of the Section 263 order. The court disagreed with the petitioner's submission that Section 12AA registration absolved the Assessing Officer of the need for proper assessment proceedings. The CIT correctly identified lacunae in the assessment process, including the failure to verify the genuineness of expenses, their application towards the trust's objects, and the details of trading accounts for hospital units. The CIT's order setting aside the assessment order and directing a de novo assessment was upheld. However, the CIT was cautioned against overreaching court orders in the future. The Assessing Officer was directed to consider that the impugned order dated 28.09.2010 and the show cause notice dated 13.03.2010 were quashed by the High Court, and to allow the petitioner to take pleas regarding sales of medicines, commissions, Naivedyam, and Prasad as per legal principles.