6 orders · Page 1 of 1
The Court held that the Public Interest Litigation (PIL) had become infructuous. The learned Advocate General for the State of Arunachal Pradesh submitted that all the Hydro-Power Projects have been abandoned and the process for cancellation of contracts is being undertaken. He assured that any future projects would be initiated strictly in accordance with law, with necessary clearances from statutory authorities and adequate safeguards for the indigenous people, referencing provisions of the Right to Fair Compensation and Transparency in Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Resettlement Act, 2013. Considering these submissions, the Court found no reason to keep the PIL pending. The PIL was accordingly closed, with a directive that any future dam construction must strictly adhere to the law and consider the safety, security, and all other aspects of the affected people. The petitioners or any affected persons were granted liberty to approach the Court again in case of any violation.
The High Court addressed the substantial questions of law raised by the parties. Regarding the exclusion of comparables with abnormal profits or losses, the Court held that companies earning abnormal profits or incurring abnormal losses cannot be regarded as reliable comparables for benchmarking ALP. The Tribunal's reasoning for exclusion was found to be in conformity with the Act and Rules, and no substantial question of law arose as it was a finding of fact. Similarly, concerning the exclusion of comparables with profit margins below 6%, the Court found no infirmity in the Tribunal's approach, especially given the assessee's cost-plus 6% contractual basis. The Court held that no substantial question of law arose. On the acceptance of Satyam Computers Limited as a comparable, the Court found no reason to exclude it based on the assessee's contention of unreliability due to alleged falsification, as no prima facie material was placed on record. The Court noted that Satyam Computers' profit margin was within the range of other comparables and that other comparables with high profit margins were not questioned. Thus, no substantial question of law arose. The issue regarding the treatment of donations and income-tax refunds was not adjudicated as it did not fall within the scope of the remand order from the Supreme Court. The appeals were disposed of in view of these observations.
The Tribunal held that the Defendant's occupation was purely permissive, based on an oral license granted out of natural love and affection, with no consideration. This license was validly revoked by the Plaintiff. The Defendant's plea of adverse possession was rejected as there was no evidence of hostile possession brought to the Plaintiff's knowledge, and the suit for possession was filed within the limitation period after revocation. The Tribunal found that a licensee cannot set up title in themselves during or after the license. The Defendant's reliance on the joint bank account was insufficient to prove joint funds were used for the property's purchase or construction. The auction terms and relinquishment deed further negated the Defendant's claim of a pre-existing family settlement. The Tribunal found the Defendant's defense to be based on conjecture and unsubstantiated allegations, while the Plaintiff established his case through title documents and evidence. The award of mesne profits was deemed a necessary consequence of unauthorized occupation post-revocation, and the LSJ's discretion in quantifying it was upheld. The Tribunal found no illegality or perversity in the LSJ's judgment, which was based on proper appreciation of evidence and correct application of law. The appeals were dismissed.
The High Court dismissed the criminal revision. The Court noted that the complainant (P.W.-4) stated that the petitioner filed a return for AY 2003-04 claiming a refund of Rs. 35,875/- based on a TDS Certificate from Eastern Coalfield Ltd. and an account with the Bank of India. Enquiries revealed the document was forged, and the Bank of India confirmed no housing loan existed in the petitioner's name. P.W.-6, the Branch Manager of Bank of India, deposed that housing loan account number 1230 did not exist at his branch and proved the letter confirming this (Exhibit-7). The Court found that the petitioner claimed a refund of Rs. 35,875/- based on a forged document without providing any valid explanation. The Court referred to Section 277 and Section 278E of the Income Tax Act, noting that the trial court passed a reasoned order, which was upheld by the appellate court. Consequently, the Court found no valid reasons to interfere with the impugned judgment and no legal substance in the petitioner's arguments.
The High Court allowed the application for withdrawal of the appeal. Consequently, the appeal was dismissed as withdrawn. The court granted the liberty sought by the Revenue to file an application for revival of the appeal. It was clarified that the withdrawal would not be considered an affirmation of the ITAT's order on merits, and the legal issue claimed by the Revenue was left open for adjudication in an appropriate case. The specific findings or reasoning of the ITAT on the merits of the case were not discussed or decided by the High Court.