COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX vs. RAMAN GANDOTRA

PDF · subscribers
ITA/10/2014HC J&KJKHC02009835201427 December 2018Bench: HON'BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE,HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE TASHI RABSTAN8 pages
AI SummaryClosed

What did the High Court hold?

The Court held that the Public Interest Litigation (PIL) had become infructuous. The learned Advocate General for the State of Arunachal Pradesh submitted that all the Hydro-Power Projects have been abandoned and the process for cancellation of contracts is being undertaken. He assured that any future projects would be initiated strictly in accordance with law, with necessary clearances from statutory authorities and adequate safeguards for the indigenous people, referencing provisions of the Right to Fair Compensation and Transparency in Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Resettlement Act, 2013. Considering these submissions, the Court found no reason to keep the PIL pending. The PIL was accordingly closed, with a directive that any future dam construction must strictly adhere to the law and consider the safety, security, and all other aspects of the affected people. The petitioners or any affected persons were granted liberty to approach the Court again in case of any violation.

What were the facts?

This Public Interest Litigation (PIL) was filed in 2014 by indigenous people of the Adi tribe in Arunachal Pradesh, represented by Mr. Karunath Pazing and others. They raised concerns regarding the State Government's initiative to build numerous Hydro-Power Projects in the Siang valley, alleging that 233 MoAs/MoUs were executed, with 50 on the Siang River and its tributaries. The petitioners contended that these projects were initiated recklessly, without scientific research or regard for consequences. Pleadings were exchanged, and an additional affidavit was filed on July 26, 2022. The Court had previously directed the petitioners to suggest pre-condition measures for safety and security.

What were the issues?

1. Whether the Hydro-Power Projects initiated by the Government of Arunachal Pradesh in the Siang valley were undertaken with due regard to scientific research, environmental impact, and the safety and security of the indigenous population, particularly concerning the execution of 233 MoAs/MoUs, 50 of which were on the Siang River and its tributaries. Assessee's Contention (Petitioners): The projects were initiated recklessly without scientific research or consideration of consequences, posing risks to the affected indigenous people. Revenue's Contention (State of Arunachal Pradesh): All projects have been abandoned, and cancellation processes are underway. Any future projects will strictly follow established legal procedures, including clearances from statutory authorities and adequate safeguards for indigenous people, referencing the Right to Fair Compensation and Transparency in Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Resettlement Act, 2013, specifically Sections 4 and 7.

Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?

Section 4,Section 7

AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below

Page No.# 1/8 GAHC040005892014

THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT (HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH) (ITANAGAR BENCH) Case No. : PIL 10/2014 1:MR. KARUNATH PAZING AND 7 ORS. S/O MR. TAKANG PAZING, R/O RASING VILLAGE, PO/PS BOLENG, DIST. EAST SIANG, AP 2: MR. TAGORI MIZE S/.O MR. TOMER MIZE R/O RIGA UGENG VILLAGE P.O. RIGA P.S. BOLENG EAST SIANG DIST. AP 3: MR. TONGIN NOPI S/O MR. OIN NOPI R/O SIMOANG VILLAGE PO/PS YINGKIONG UPPER SIANG DIST. AP 4: MR. TEN TEKSENG S/O MR. ONOK TEKSENG R/O SIMONG VILLAGE PO/PS YINGKIONG DIST. UPPER SIANG A P 5: MR. YASUNG NITIK S/O MR. YOMBO NITIK R/O RASING TUTING VILLAGE PO/PS TUTING UPPER SIANG DIST. AP

Page No.# 2/8 6: MR. GAMMUT NIJO S/O MR. AMBO NIJO R/O TUTING TOWN PO/PS TUTING UPPER SIANG DIST. AP 7: MR. DUNGGO LIBANG S/O MR. ANUP LIBANG R/O SIMONG VILLAGE PO/PS YINGKIONG DIST. UPPER SIANG A P 8: MR. ONI PANYANG S/O MR. OKEK PANYANG R/O PANGGING VILLAGE PO/PS GEKU UPPER SIANG DIST. A VERSUS 1:THE STATE OF A.P. AND 25 ORS. REPRESENTED BY THE CHIEF SECRETARY, GOVT. OF AP, ITANAGAR 2:THE SECRETARY POWER GOVT. OF AP ITANAGAR 3:THE CHAIRMAN ARUNACHAL PRADESH STATE POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD ITANAGAR 4:THE UNION OF INDIA REPRESENTED BY THE SECRETARY MINISTRY OF POWER SHRAM SHAKTI BHAWAN RAFI MARG NEW DELHI 5:THE CHAIRMAN and MANAGING DIRECTOR NEEPCO LTD. BROOKLAND COMPOUND LOWER NEW COLONY SHILLONG-793003 MEGHALAYA

Page No.# 3/8 6:THE CHAIRMAN and MANAGING DIRECTOR NHPC SECTOR-33 FARIDABAD-121003 HARYANA 7:THE CHAIRMAN and MANAGING DIRECTOR M/S JAIPRAKASH ASSOCIATES LTD. JA HOUSE 63 BASANT LOK VASANT VIHAR NEW DELHI-110057 8:THE CHAIRMAN and MANAGING DIRECTOR M/S RELIANCE POWER LTD H BLOCK 1ST FLOOR DHIRUBHAI AMBANI KNOWLEDGE CITY NAVI MUMBAI-400710 9:THE CHAIRMAN and MANAGING DIRECTOR M/S DS CONSTRUCTION POWER LTD. A-97/98 LAJPAT NAGAR PART-1 NEW DELHI-110024 10:THE CHAIRMAN and MANAGING DIRECTOR M/S VELCAN ENERGY HOLDINGS LTD G-77 SUJAN SINGH PARK NEW DELH-110033 11:THE CHAIRMAN and MANAGING DIRECTOR M/S RAAJRATNA ENERGY HOLDINGS PVT LTD. 8-2-293/A/A/2 and 1 PLOT 227 ROAD NO. 22 BANJARA HILLS HYDERABAD-34 12:THE CHAIRMAN and MANAGING DIRECTOR M/S RAAJRATNA METAL INDUSTRIES LTD 909 SAKAR-III NEAR INCOME TAX AHMEDABAD-380014 GUJRAT 13:THE CHAIRMAN and MANAGING DIRECTOR M/S ADISHANKAR POWER PVT. LTD. C-79 SOUTH EXTENSION PART-II NEW DELHI-110049 14:THE CHAIRMAN and MANAGING DIRECTOR M/S ABIR CONSTRUCTION PVT. LTD C-BLOCK GROUND FLOOR

Page No.# 4/8 PLOT NO. 14 FACTORY ROAD ADJOINING SAFDARJUNG HOSPITAL NEW DELHI-110029 15:THE CHAIRMAN and MANAGING DIRECTOR M/S SATYAM NORTH EAST HYDRO POWER LTD N-S-52 BANDERDEVA-791123 ARUNACHAL PRADESH 16:THE CHAIRMAN and MANAGING DIRECTOR M/S YAMNE POWER PVT. LTD 6-3-1090 TRS TOWER RAJBHAWAN ROAD SOMAJIGUDA HYDERABAD-500082 ANDHRA PRADESH 17:THE CHAIRMAN and MANAGING DIRECTOR M/S L and T POWER DEVELOPMENT LTD L and T HOUSE NM MARG BALLARD ESTATE PO BOK-278 MUMBAR-400001 18:THE CHAIRMAN and MANAGING DIRECTOR M/S CHADALAVADA CONSTRUCTION PVT. LTD 3-988/19 SBH COLONY SRINAGAR COLONY POST HYDERABAD-500074 19:THE CHAIRMAN and MANAGING DIRECTOR M/S NANO EXCEL POWER CORPORATION LTD. 5-35-103 I.E. PRASHANTI NAGAR KUKATPALLY HYDERABAD-500072 ANDHRA PRADESH 20:THE CHAIRMAN and MANAGING DIRECTOR M/S SUPERECO INDIA PVT LTD. 81/1334 VASANT KUNJ NEW DELHI-110070 21:THE CHAIRMAN and MANAGING DIRECTOR

Page No.# 5/8 M/S SARDA ECO POWER LTD 5-35-103 PLACEBO COMPLEX PRASHANT NAGAR I.E. KUKATPALLY HYDERABAD-509072 22:THE CHAIRMAN and MANAGING DIRECTOR M/S MEENAKSHI INFRASTRUCTURES PVT. LTD. MEENAKSHI HOUSE 8-2-418 ROAD NO. 7 BANJARA HILLS HYDERABAD-500034 23:THE CHAIRMAN and MANAGING DIRECTOR M/S ASANA POWER PROJECTS FLAT NO. 502 8-3-945 SRINILAYA ESTATE AMEERPET HYDERABAD-500073 ANDHRA PRADESH 24:THE CHAIRMAN and MANAGING DIRECTOR M/S ABHYUDAYA POWER P LTD. 3/1 OUDON STREET KOLKOTA-700017 25:THE CHAIRMAN and MANAGING DIRECTOR M/S SAISUDHIR ENERGY LTD. 401 G.P. ELITE 8-2-283/4 RAOD NO. 14 BANJDARA HILLS HYDERABAD-500034 ANDHRA PRADESH 26:THE CHAIRMAN and MANAGING DIRECTOR M/S BSS ARUNACHAL ANERGY DEVELOPMENT PVT. LTD. C/O NABUM TUKI HOUSE POLO COLONY NAHARLAGUN ARUNACHAL PRADESH-79111 Advocate for the Petitioner : MrT Tabing Advocate for the Respondent : CGC

Page No.# 6/8 BEFORE HONBLE MR. JUSTICE S.K.MEDHI HONBLE MRS. JUSTICE MALASRI NANDI ORDER Date : 06.09.2022 (Sanjay Kumar Medhi, J)

Heard Mr. N. Pada, learned counsel for the petitioners and also heard Mr. K. Ete, learned Advocate General for the State of Arunachal Pradesh assisted by Mr. S. Tapin, learned senior Government Advocate. By means of this PIL, the petitioners, who are indigenous people belonging to Adi tribe are raising serious issues with regard to the initiative of the Government to build Hydro-Power Projects in the Siang valley over the River Siang and its tributaries. 2. It is specifically alleged that as many as 233 Nos. of MoAs/MoUs have been executed and out of those, 50 Nos. were over Siang River and its tributaries. It has been alleged that the projects have been initiated in a reckless manner without having any regard to the consequences of the same and without following any scientific research. 3. The PIL which is instituted in the year 2014 is pending and in the meantime, pleadings have been exchanged including an additional affidavit filed recently on 26.07.2022. 4. This Court on the last occasion on being appraised that most of the projects are not functional had directed the learned counsel for the petitioners to suggest some measures as pre-conditions to ensure the safety and security of the people who could be affected by such projects. 5. This Court had also requested the assistance of the learned Advocate

Page No.# 7/8 General, who is present in the hearing today. 6. Mr. Ete, learned Advocate General, however, by drawing the attention of this Court to the additional affidavit dated 26.07.2022 has submitted that all the projects have been abandoned and the process for cancellation of the contracts, if any, are also be taken up. He otherwise submits that in case of any such projects being taken up, the same can be done only by following the procedure established in law including clearance from statutory authorities in which the adequate safeguard and safety of the indigenous people would be taken care of. 7. By referring to Right to Fair Compensation and Transparency in Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Resettlement Act, 2013, the learned Advocate General submits that under the said Act there are adequate provisions including Sections 4 and 7 to look after the situations of this nature which has been contemplated by the petitioners. He accordingly, submits that in the event any such move is taken in the future, all necessary precautions would be taken. 8. After hearing both the parties and taking into consideration the submissions made on behalf of the State by the learned Advocate General, this Court is of the opinion that there is no reason to keep this PIL pending as the same has become infructous. 9. The PIL is accordingly, closed. However, it is stated that in the event the State of Arunachal Pradesh takes a decision to go ahead with construction of dams, those are required to be done strictly with accordance with law and take into consideration the safety, security and all other aspects of the affected people. 10. It is further, observed that in case of any such violation, the petitioners or

Page No.# 8/8 any other affected persons will be in liberty to approach this Court. 11. In terms of above, the PIL stands disposed of.

JUDGE JUDGE

Comparing Assistant

More judgments on Section 4

All 2,665 judgments and leading authorities on Section 4 →

Recent GST High Court judgments

Search GST case law →