SHIVHARE ASSOCIATES ,JINSI NALA vs. ASSISSTANT COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX , GWALIOR

PDF · subscribers
ITA 259/AGR/2026Status: DisposedITAT Agra18 November 2026AY 2013-1430 pages
AI SummaryPartly Allowed

What did the Tribunal hold?

The Tribunal noted that for AY 2015-16, the assessee failed to produce necessary documents to substantiate its claim of genuine loans from Smt. Mohini Gupta and Shri Radhey Shyam Rathore before the AO, CIT(A), and even before the Tribunal. While the assessee provided some details in a submission, these were not supported by documentary evidence. In the interest of justice, the Tribunal set aside the CIT(A)'s order concerning the addition of Rs. 1,20,94,794/- (unexplained cash credit) and restored the matter to the CIT(A)'s file for fresh adjudication, granting the assessee one more opportunity to submit supporting documents. This ground was allowed for statistical purposes. For AYs 2012-13 and 2013-14, which involved similar issues of rejection of books of account and estimation of profit, the Tribunal directed the AO to apply a Net Profit (NP) rate of 2.7% on estimated sales before deducting interest and salary to partners, subject to the minimum returned income. This decision was based on the principle that the NP rate on suppressed/undisclosed sales should be brought to tax. Therefore, the appeals were partly allowed.

What were the facts?

The assessee, Shivhare Associates, a partnership firm engaged in the retail business of liquor and beer, filed its return for AY 2015-16. The Assessing Officer (AO) selected the case for manual scrutiny and issued notices. The assessee failed to comply with several notices and produce books of account, purchase bills, sale bills, expense vouchers, and inventory. The AO rejected the assessee's trading results, noting that all payments for purchases appeared to be made in cash, contravening Section 40A(3), and that TCS collected on purchases was significantly lower than shown purchases. The AO also noted that the assessee sold goods below the Minimum Selling Price (MSP) fixed by the Madhya Pradesh Government. Consequently, the AO added Rs. 1,23,49,627/- as suppressed profit. The assessee's appeal to the CIT(A) was dismissed. Similar issues arose for AYs 2012-13 and 2013-14.

What were the issues?

1. Whether the AO erred in rejecting the assessee's books of account and trading results for AY 2015-16, and consequently adding Rs. 1,23,49,627/- on account of suppressed profit, turning on Section 144 and principles of commercial accounting. - Assessee's contention: The AO wrongly rejected the books without specific proof of illegality or suppression. The books were audited without adverse remarks and should not have been rejected without defects being identified. - Revenue's contention: The assessee failed to produce books of account and other necessary documents, leaving the AO with no option but to determine profits on commercial principles and based on the government's pricing policy. 2. Whether the CIT(A) erred in confirming the AO's addition of Rs. 1,20,94,794/- (comprising Rs. 10,00,000/- from Smt. Mohini Gupta and Rs. 1,10,94,794/- from Shri Radhey Shyam Rathore) on account of unexplained cash credits for AY 2015-16, turning on Section 68. - Assessee's contention: The loans were taken through account payee cheques, and the AO/CIT(A) added the amounts without verifying genuineness and creditworthiness. The assessee sought an opportunity to produce documents. - Revenue's contention: The assessee failed to provide evidence regarding the identity, creditworthiness, and genuineness of the transactions. Mere provision of PAN and bank details is insufficient to discharge the onus under Section 68.

Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?

Section 144,Section 40A(3),Section 68,Section 250,Section 271(1)(c)

AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below

Income Tax Appellate Tribunal, AGRA (DB

Before: SHRI SUNIL KUMAR SINGH & SHRI BRAJESH KUMAR SINGH

For Appellant: Shri Mahendra Agarwal, Advocate
For Respondent: Shri Anil Kumar, Sr. DR and Ms
Hearing: 03.09.2026Pronounced: 18.11.2026

IN THE INCOME TAX APPELLATE TRIBUNAL, AGRA (DB) BENCH, AGRA BEFORE: SHRI SUNIL KUMAR SINGH, JUDICIAL MEMBER AND SHRI BRAJESH KUMAR SINGH, ACCOUNTANT MEMBER

ITA No. 246, 258 & 259/Agr/2026 Assessment Years: 2015-16, 2012-13 & 2013-14 Shivhare Associates, Vs. ACIT, Circle 1(1), Chhaparwala Pull, , Jinsi Nala City Centre, Gwalior-474002 No. 1, Gwalior (MP)-474009 PAN : ABBFS6377G (Appellant) (Respondent) Assessee by Shri Mahendra Agarwal, Advocate Department by Shri Anil Kumar, Sr. DR and Ms. Sangeeta Yadav Date of hearing 03.09.2026 Date of pronouncement 18.11.2026 ORDER PER:BENCH These three appeals are directed against the separate impugned orders dated 30.01.2026, 17.02.2026 and 17.02.2026 passed in appeal Nos. CIT(A), Gwalior/10380/2017-18, CIT(A), Gwalior/10047/2015-16 and CIT(A), Gwalior/10491/2015-16 by the ld. Commissioner of Income Tax(Appeals), National Faceless Appeal Centre (NFAC), Delhi [hereinafter referred to as the “CIT(A)] u/s. 250 of the Income Tax Act, 1961 (hereinafter referred to as the “Act”) for the A.Yrs. 2015-16, 2012-

ITA No.246, 258 & 259/Agr/2026

13 and 2013-14 respectively, wherein ld. CIT(A) has dismissed assessee’s appeals.All these appeals have similar issues.Therefore, they were heard together and is being disposed by this common order for the sake of convenience and brevity. The ITA no. 246/Agr/2026 for A.Y. 2015-16 is taken as the lead case. ITA No. 246.Agr/2026 (A.Y. 2015-16): 2. Brief facts of the case: The assessee is a partnership firm and during the year was carrying on the retail business of country and foreign liquor and beer under the contract obtained from Madhya Pradesh Government. The AO noted that the assessee filed its return of income on 28.09.2015declaring total income of Rs.38,29,260/-. The case was selected under manual scrutiny and accordingly, notice u/s. 143(2) dated 21.09.2016 was issued and duly served upon the assessee. The AO issued various notices to the assessee as noted in para-1 of the assessment order, but according to the AO, the assessee failed to make compliance to the said notices. The AO in order to complete the assessment proceedings, issued show cause notice dated 16.10.2017 asking the assessee to explain as to why the assessment should not be completed u/s. 144 of the Act. In compliance to this notice, Shri Praveen Shivhare, partner of the firm and Shri M.K. Agarwalthe AR of the assessee, attended. The AO noted that the assessee filed written replies 2 | P a g e

ITA No.246, 258 & 259/Agr/2026

but the assessee failed to produce the books of account in spite of specifically asked vide order sheet entry dated 29.11.2017. Accordingly, the AO passed the assessment order on merits in view of the reply filed by the assessee.

Addition on account of trading results – Rs.1,23,49,627/-: 3. The AO noted that in order to examine the trading results shown in respect of the liquor business asked the assessee vide order sheet entry dated 24.11.2017 to produce cash book, ledger, purchase bills, sale bills, bills/vouchers of expenses. The AO noted that the assessee failed to produce the same for verification. The AO further noted that on 29.11.2017, the partner of the firm and AR of the assessee firm attended and stated that no sale bills have been maintained/issued. The AO noted that the assessee was again vide order sheet entry dated 29.11.2017 given an opportunity to produce the above documents, but the assessee failed to produce the same for verification. The AO noted in absence of books of account, purchase bills, sale bills, bills/vouchers of expenses, inventory of opening and closing stock trading result shown by the assessee cannot be accepted. The AO also noted some other defects and rejected the trading results declared by the assessee. The relevant discussion in para 4.2 of assessment order is reproduced as under: 3 | P a g e

ITA No.246, 258 & 259/Agr/2026

“4.2 In absence of books of account, purchase bills, sale bills, bills/vouchers of expenses, inventory of opening and closing stock trading result shown by the assessee cannot be accepted. On going through ITS details, it has been found that TCS has been collected on purchases of Rs. 10,95,27,219/- whereas assessee has shown purchases of Rs.34,87,36,408/-. On going through copy of account of purchase filed, it has been found that all the payments have been made in cash in contravention to section 40A(3) of the I.T. Act. In view of the above discrepancies trading result shown by the assessee in profit and loss account filed cannot be accepted and the same is hereby rejected.”

3.1 The AO further noted that on going through the profit & loss account, it was found that the assessee had sold goods on less than minimum selling price (MSP). The AO noted that w.e.f. 01.04.2013, the State Government had applied Commercial Tax (Sales Tax) on sale of liquor, which is collected by the District Excise Department on behalf of the Commercial Tax Department. The AO also noted that as per the State Policy, the minimum selling price and maximum retail selling price was fixed by the State Government. The AO further noted that the minimum selling price was fixed by adding 10% of the ex-godown purchase cost and the maximum retail price (MRP) was fixed by adding 30% on the purchase cost. The AO also noted that a vendor could not sell the wine/beer below the MSP and above the MRP, which are also mentioned on the liquor containers. Thereafter, the AO worked out the suppressed profit by adding 10% of purchase cost as per the profit & loss account as the total sale value on MSP and after reducing the sales as 4 | P a g e

ITA No.246, 258 & 259/Agr/2026

shown in profit & loss account, added Rs.1,23,49,627/- to the total income of the assessee. In this regard, the relevant discussion and the computation of Rs.1,23,49,627/- as calculated by the AO in para nos. 4.6 to 4.8 of the assessment order are reproduced as under:

“4.6 The assessee has shown purchases at Rs.34,87,36,408/-. The minimum selling price and maximum retail price is being worked out as under:- MSP (348736408+10% of 348736408) = Rs.38,35,10,049/- MRP(348736408+30% of 348736408) = Rs.45,33,57,330/- 4.7 Considering the entirety of the case extra profit is being worked out on the basis of MSP and this extra profit will cover all the discrepancies mentioned above. Purchase cost as per profit and loss account Rs.34,87,36,408/- Add:10% of purchase cost Rs.3,48,73,641/-

Total sale on MSP Rs.38,36,10,049/- Less: sales as shown in P&L account Rs.37,12,60,422/- Extra profit Rs.1,23,49,627/- 4.8 Thus, extra profit is being worked out at Rs.1,23,49,627/- and the same is being added to the total income of the assessee. Issue penalty notice u 271(1)(c) of the I.T. Act. (Addition: Rs.1,23,49,627/-)”

3.2 Aggrieved with the said order, the assessee filed an appeal before the learned CIT(A).Before the learned CIT(A), it was submitted that the AO wrongly rejected the books of account without giving any specific instance or specific illegality without any proof. It was further submitted that there was no positive proof of suppression of sales and since there 5 | P a g e

ITA No.246, 258 & 259/Agr/2026

was no defect in the assessee’s books of account and the accounts were audited and without any adverse remark by the AO, the same could not have been rejected. However, the learned CIT(A) did not agree with the same and noted that the books of account and other documents were not produced and the AO was left with no option but to determine the profits on commercial principles. The ld. CIT(A) also noted that the stand of the assessee that he maintains the books of account and the AO could not find any error in the books is contradictory and observed that when the books were not produced, then how an error could be determined. The ld. CIT(A) also taking note of the policy of the Government, wherein the minimum selling price and maximum retail price was fixed observed that same was not followed by the assessee. The Ld. CIT(A) also did not accept the plea of the assessee that the assessee was forced to sell the liquor at the lesser rate as it was contrary to public policy and was not supported by providing necessary documentary evidences. Accordingly, the ld. CIT(A) upheld the order of the AO rejecting books of account and enhancing the trading profit by Rs.1,23,49,627/-. In this regard, the relevant extract of the order of the Ld. CIT(A) is reproduced as under:

“6. Decision Grounds No. 1 to 4:

6 | P a g e

ITA No.246, 258 & 259/Agr/2026

6.1 Vide these grounds the appellant assessee agitates about addition of Rs. 1,23,49,627 on account of increase due to redetermination of the trading profit. During the assessment proceedings the appellant assessee (an excise contractor firm) was required by the AO to produce its cash book, ledger, purchase bills, sales bills, vouchers of expenses on various dates namely 24.11.2017 and 29.11.2017. However, the appellant assessee did not comply with the requisition of the details. The appellant assessee was unable to submit its inventory of opening & closing stock even though Shri Mahendra Kumar Agarwal, advocate, AR for the appellant appeared during the assessment proceedings. In absence of books of accounts, purchase bills, sales bills, vouchers of expenses & inventory details, the AO rejected the books and determined the profits based on the total purchases details as reported by the appellant assessee, thereby making an addition in the net profit of Rs. 1,23,49,627. In contrast, in the appellate proceedings the appellant assessee submits that the books have been wrongly rejected without giving any instance orspecific illegality or without any report. It is further submitted that there was no positive proof of suppression of sales. Since, there is no defect in the appellant assessee's books of accounts and the accounts are audited without any adverse remark by the AO, the same could not have been rejected. 6.2 The contention of the appellant assessee and the contents of the assessment orders were carefully gene through. What is material is that the AO wanted to examine the details of inventory, various vouchers for expenses, books which was not produced before the AO. In the absence of books before the AO for examination, the AO was left with no option but to determine the profits on commercial principles. The appellant assessee's submissions that he maintains the books regularly and the AO could not find any error in the books is contradictory and preposterous as when the books are not produced, how an error could be determined? In the absence ofstock and inventory details, higher fora has already decided that books can be rejected. In the eminent judgment of Kachwala Gems Vs. Jt. CIT 288 ITR 10 (SC) it has been held that book rejection is justifiable in the absence of maintenance of stock or inventory records for incompleteness. Further, in the assessment order the AO mentions that the West Bengal government has already decided the Minimum Selling Price (MSP) and the Maximum Retail Price (MRP) which the appellant assesse has not followed. As per state excise policy, the MSP was 10% of the ex-godown purchase cost. Public policy demands that the MSP could not have been breached by the appellant assessee. Thus in the absence of books, since, the trading results could not have been properly determined, the AO undertook the exercise of rejecting the books and determined the selling price based on MSP on the basis of the purchases as shown by the 7 | P a g e

ITA No.246, 258 & 259/Agr/2026

appellant assessee. In such circumstances, he proceeded to add the differential between the determined sales figure & the actual figure quoted by the appellant assessee. The contention that the appellant assessee was forced to sell at a lesser rate is contrary to public policy and has not been supported by providing necessary documentary evidences. Thus the book rejections based on non- availability of stock details & sales details besides any other parts of the contended accounts which are maintained by the assesse, is confirmed and the addition made based on the excise department's MSP (Minimum Selling Price) figures are confirmed. The total increase in profit of Rs 1,23,49,627 is confirmed in full. Grounds fail.”

4.

Aggrieved with the said order, the assessee is in appeal before us on the following grounds:

“2. That the Ld. Assessing Officer erred in adding Rs. 12349627/- on account of extra profit by adding 10% of purchase cost without any basis and on assumption and presumption and Ld. Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals) NFAC, Delhi also erred in confirmed the same. Hence the addition of Rs. 12349627/- may kindly be deleted. 3. That the Ld. Assessing Officer and Ld. Commissioner of Income Tax ( Appeals) NFAC, Delhi erred in not accepting the books of accounts on the basis of non production of books of accounts and bills and vouchers of purchases and expenses whereas the assessee maintained regular books of accounts and get audited every year and no any defect is pointed out by the Ld. Assessing Officer during the course of assessment proceedings. Hence not accepting the books of account is unjustified and against the law. 4. That the Ld. Assessing Officer erred in adding the entire amount of difference of sales calculated by adding 10% of purchase cost in the total income of the assessee whereas it is settled law that the entire amount of the sales cannot be added in the total income of the assessee. The net profit rate has to be adopted and once it is adopted the same can be treated as the income of the assessee and Ld. Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals ) NFAC Delhi also erred in confirmed the same, Hence

8 | P a g e

ITA No.246, 258 & 259/Agr/2026

the addition of Rs. 12349627/- may kindly be deleted and the net profit rate may kindly be applied. 5. That the Ld. Commissioner of Income Tax Appeals NAFC, Delhi erred in not considering the decision of Hon’ble ITAT Agra Bench, Agra in the case of assessee firm it self in the assessment year 2010-11. Same may be considered.”

5.

At the time of hearing, the learned AR filed a written submission and stated that on similar facts, in the case of the assessee for A.Y. 2010-11 and 2011-12, this Bench of the Tribunal by a common order dated 16.05.2018 and a corrigendum order dated 23.05.2018 in ITA nos. 47 and 48/Agr/2015 and ITA nos. 71 and 72/Agr/2015 for A.Y. 2010-11 and 2011-12, directed the AO to apply net profit rate of 2.7% of the estimated sales before deducting interest and salary to partners subject to the minimum returned income. It was submitted that the learned CIT(A) did not consider the above order of the Tribunal on the same facts and submitted that the order of the learned CIT(A) may be reversed and modified accordingly in terms of the above order of the Tribunal. To justify the above estimation, the Ld. AR also filed a comparative chart of gross profit and net profit on trading results for A.Y. 2008-09 to A.Y. 2015-16 which is reproduced as under:

9 | P a g e

ITA No.246, 258 & 259/Agr/2026

“M/s Shivhare Associates, Jinsi Marg No. 1, Gwalior Comparative chart of Gross Profit and Net Profit on Trading results Assessment Sales Rs. Gross Profit Net Profit Net Profit Remarks Year Before Rs. % After % deducting % deducting Interest and Interest and Salary Salary 2008-09 103159162 7420887 7.19 2002427 1.94 2938972 2.9 Adhoc addition of Rs. 576552/-after appeal effect 2009-10 100095112 8486895 8.48 1090815 1.09 2103614 2.1 Adhoc addition of Rs. 501430/-no appeal done 2010-11 154743908 12633589 8.16 1441940 0.93 2938461 1.9 ITAT HELD 2.7% Before Interest and Salary to partners 2011-12 246560430 18018328 7.31 2341328 0.95 3534883 1.43 ITAT HELD 2.7% Before Interest and Salary to partners 2012-13 297123563 0 0 3465819 1.16 4912740 1.65 Under appeal before ITAT 2013-14 410019033 0 0 5866361 1.43 9875014 2.41 Under appeal before ITAT 2014-15 276131640 0 0 2849603 1.03 6299012 2.28 Under appeal before CIT (Appeal) NFAC 2015-16 371260422 0 0 3829255 1.03 6941927 1.87 Under appeal before ITAT

6.

On the other hand, the learned Sr. DR supported the orders of the

authorities below and submittedthat the estimation of profit by and

considering the suppressed/ undisclosed sales amounting to Rs.

1,23,49,627/- by the AO was justified and the same should be confirmed.

In this regard, the Sr Dr. stated that in the case of the assessee,the ld.

CIT(A) distinguished the facts for not accepting the plea of the assessee

for adopting net profit @ 2.7% in the appellate order for AY 2012-13 and

2013-14 and relied upon the same to support the order of the AO/Ld. 10 | P a g e

ITA No.246, 258 & 259/Agr/2026

CIT(A) for this year also. The said observations of the Ld. CIT(A) for A.Y. 2012-13 relied upon and the Sr. DR are reproduced as under: “6.3 The appellant assessee's further submission that in the AY 2011- 12 the Hon'ble ITAT Bench, Agra determined the book profit at 2.7% of net profit before deducting interest & salary to partners is replicable and to be applied in this year was considered; however, on perusal of the Hon'ble Tribunal's order in the case of Shri Laxmi Narayan Shivhare vs. JCIT and ACIT vs. Shri Laxmi Narayan Shivharefor AY 2009-10, it is observed from para 20.4 that the Hon'ble ITAT mentions that the AO & CIT(A) in that year estimated business profit based on their own assumption & presumption. Estimation of profit was made by estimating first purchases then applying certain percentage of G.P. and then finally converting purchases into salesand then estimating profits by thereafter applying certain percentageof G.P. Further, purchase comparison reveals that as per the appellant, the purchase was Rs. 30.29 crores while as per the AO, the purchase was Rs. 39.79 crores. Similarly, for AY 2010-11 and 2011-12 in appellant's case, the Hon'ble ITAT in para 12 has mentioned that no specific deficiency in the purchase invoices was pointed out by the Ld. CIT(A) and hence in all the years including AY 2009-10, 2.7% of net profit before interest & salary was found appropriate. 6.4 In contrast, in the instant appeal the AO has adopted the purchases as shown by the appellant assessee and the sales figure has been adopted based on the minimum selling price (MSP) fixed by the State Government. Based on the difference between the actual sale figures & the MSP the NP is determined. Thus, the AO neither assumed or presumed anything nor he applied any GP rate, nor he estimated any purchase. Purchases were accepted as submitted by the appellant assessee. The only reason for the books rejection was that appellant assessee did not produce any books of account, vouchers, invoices etc. Hence, the AO adopted the MSP based on the purchase figures as submitted by the appellant assessee. Thus, the decision of the Ld. Tribunal for AY 2009-10 till 2011-12 adopting the Net Profit rate @ 2.7% cannot be applied ipso facto on the facts & circumstance of the impugned AY 2012-13. The total increase in profit of Rs. 1,50,34,147, therefore, is confirmed in full. All the grounds fail.” (emphasis supplied by us)

11 | P a g e

ITA No.246, 258 & 259/Agr/2026

6.1 The ld. DR further submitted that in the event the above plea of the department is not accepted, then the net profit @ 2.7% as determined by the Tribunal in assessee’s own case was not justified. In this regard, the Ld. DR by placing reliance upon the orders of Hon’ble M.P. High Court in the case of Badri Prasad Bhagwandas & Co. vs. CIT, (1995) 82 Taxman 109 (MP) dated 11.10.1994 and of the Co-ordinate Bench of Hyderabad Tribunal in ITO, Suryapet vs. Sri Beeravelli Venkat Reddy & Others (ITA Nos. 148 to 177/Hyd/2012 dated 07.05.2012), submitted that the net profit @ 5% of the total estimated saleswas justified and not 2.7% as determined by the Tribunal in assessee’s own casebeforededucting interest and salary to partners subject to the minimum returned income.

7.

We have heard both the parties and perused the material on record.As noted above, during the year also, the assessee has been carrying on retail business of country and Indian made foreign liquor (IMFL) and sales of beer under the contract obtained on the excise department of Madhya Pradesh Government. As per the records available before us, the assessee is in this business at least from A.Y. 2008-09 and it appears that from A.Y. 2008-09 to A.Y. 2015-16, every year, the case of the assessee has been picked up for scrutiny and regular assessments have been made. As per the chart submitted by the 12 | P a g e

ITA No.246, 258 & 259/Agr/2026

assessee (which is reproduced earlier in this order), it is stated that for A.Y. 2008-09, there was an ad-hoc addition of Rs.5,76,552/- after appeal effect whereas for A.Y. 2009-10, there was an ad-hoc addition of Rs.5,01,430/-, for which no appeal was filed by the assessee. The appeals for A.Y. 2012-13, 2013-14 and 2015-16 are before us for adjudication whereas the appeal for A.Y. 2014-15 is pending for adjudication before the learned CIT(A). For A.Y. 2010-11, the AO after rejecting the books of accounts of the assessee u/s 145 (3) of the Act had computed the suppressed sales by taking the average of minimum selling price and maximum retail price which came to Rs. 18,46,03,933/-. The AO thereafter noted that the disclosed sales by the assessee was Rs. 15,47,43,908/- and added the difference of Rs. 2,98,60,025/- (Rs. 18,46,03,933 – Rs. 15,47,43,908) to the total income of the assessee. On appeal, the learned CIT(A) agreed with the findings of the AO that the rejection of books of account was justified, but referred to of the decision of the jurisdictional Hon’ble Madhya Pradesh High Court in the case of CIT vs Balchand Ajit Kumar 263 ITR 610 and Manmohan Sadani vs. CIT 304 ITR 52, which held that total sales cannot be regarded for as the profit of the assessee and on the contrary it is the net profit which was to adopted in such cases. In view of the above decisions, the Ld. CIT (A) held that the entire suppressed/undisclosed sales cannot be taxed and 13 | P a g e

ITA No.246, 258 & 259/Agr/2026

only the net profit can be taxed.Accordingly, the Ld. CIT(A) held that it would be fair and reasonable to estimate the net profit of the assessee @ 3% of the total purchases cost debited by the assessee. On further appeal, this Bench of the Tribunal by a common order dated 16.05.2018 and corrigendum order dated 23.05.20218 in ITA nos. 47 and 48/Agr/2015 and ITA nos. 71 and 72/Agr/2015 for A.Y. 2010-11 and 2011-12, directed the AO to apply net profit rate of 2.7% of the estimated sales before deducting interest and salary to partners subject to the minimum returned income. In this regard, the relevant extract of the order of this Bench of the Tribunal is reproduced as under: “These Cross appeals are directed against the order of Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals), Gwalior in respect of assessment year 2010-11 and 2011-12. 2. At the outset, Ld. Counsel for the assessee submitted that there is a common question of law and facts on the issue of estimate against estimation of income in these cross appeals, therefore, they were being heard together and are being disposed of by this consolidated order. 3. The facts and circumstances of this case are in pari materia to the facts and circumstance of the cases of Laxmi Narain Shivhare and others in ITA No. 233/Agr/2014 and ITA No. 285/Agr/2014 where the assessees were a liquor contractor dealing in country liquor, Indian made foreign liquor (IMFL) and Beer. The AO observed that “in view of the glaring defects of the sales, totallyunsupported by any day today shop wise register of stock and sales, the true profits cannot be deducted from the books of account maintained by the assessee and accordingly books of accounts are rejected under section 145(3) of the Act.” Thereafter, he has collected information from the excise department and estimated the sales turnover on the basis of the information so collected and estimated the sales turnover as against the sales declared by the assessee and added the amount of the difference between the total sales turnover estimated by the AO and the sales turnover declared by the assessee on account of suppressed sales of Rs. 2,98,60,025/- and Rs.1,88,17,217/- in respect of assessment years 2010-11 and 2011-12 respectively, as income of the 14 | P a g e

ITA No.246, 258 & 259/Agr/2026

assessee. The ld. CIT(A) has confirmed the action of the AO as regards to estimating the turnover on the basis of information received from the excise department, however, he has rejected the AO’s view of assessing the suppressed sales as taxable income of the assessee by holding that the entire suppressed sale cannot be taxed as ‘income’ and only the net profit part can be taxed as income. The ld CIT(A) has reproduced the reply of the assessee at pages 2 to 9 of the impugned order. 4. While rejecting the finding of the AO in respect of computation of suppressed sales as income of the assessee, the ld. CIT(A) has adopted N.P. rate at 3% on the sales turnover estimated by AO, inter alia observing as under: “3.3 I have gone through the assessment order, written submissions, case laws relied upon by the appellant and argument put forth during the course of appellate proceedings carefully. It is seen that the appellant, inspite of having been granted more than sufficient opportunities failed to produce sales bills/vouchers before the A.O for verification. In view of the facts discussed by the A.O in the assessment order, I am of the considered view that the action of the A.O rejecting the book results u/s 145(3) and estimating the income is in accordance with the provisions of law. Hence the action of the A.O estimating the income is held to be justified. However, in view of the following facts and decisions of jurisdictional High Court and various benches of ITAT, the estimation of income made by A.O appears to be on higher side. 3.4 The appellant is a liquor contractor and bound to pay the prescribed fee (Duty & basic excise duty) to the Govt, to take the delivery of the material which has to be sold before the end of license period. I find force in the argument of the appellant that if the appellant does not sell the material as per the market trend then by the end of the license period he may be in possession of unsold stock and face huge losses. As the appellant does not have any right to get back the prescribed fee paid to the Govt, in respect of the unsold stock, therefore, he has to sell the goods even at discounted rates. 3.5 The Hon’ble M.P. High Court (jurisdictional High Court) in the case of CIT Vs Balchand Ajit Kumar 263 ITR 610 M.P has held that the total sales cannot be regarded as the profit of the assessee. In the case of Manmohan Sadani Vs CIT 304 ITR 52 M.P the Hon’ble jurisdictional High Court has held that total sales cannot be regarded as profit of the assessee, on the contrary it is a net profit rate which has to be adopted in such cases. In view of the findings of the Hon’ble M.P High Court(jurisdictional High Court) in the above cited two cases I am of the considered opinion that the entire suppressed/undisclosed sale estimated by A.O 15 | P a g e

ITA No.246, 258 & 259/Agr/2026

cannot be taxed as ‘Income’ of the appellant. Only the net profit part can be taxed. 3.6 On the facts similar to the facts of the appellant, the ITAT, Coordinate Bench of Hyderabad, ITAT (ITA No.391/Hyd/2009) in the case of Manjeet Singh Bagga Vs. ITO has held that estimation of profit@3% of the purchases made by the appellant(Liquor Contractor) would meet end of justice. In the case of Kanak Durga Wines Hyderabad Vs ITO Hyderabad bench-B of the ITAT (ITA No.591/Hyd./2011) has estimated the net profit of the assessee(Liquor Contractor) @3% of the purchases or stock put for sale during the year under consideration. In the case of G.Sudarshan Hyderabad Vs ITO (ITA No.l26/Hyd./2012) Hyderabad bench-A of the ITAT directed the Assessing Officer to estimate the net profit of the assessee at 3% of the purchases or stock put for sale during the year, subject to the condition that the income shall not go below the returned income. 3.7 After going through the various decisions of jurisdictional High Court and ITAT discussed above, I am of the considered opinion that the entire suppressed/undisclosed sale of the appellant cannot be taxed as income. Only the net profit part can be taxed as ‘income . After taking into account, the argument put forth by the appellant in the written submissions and decisions relied upon by the appellant. 1 am of the considered view that it would be fair and reasonable to estimate the net profit of the appellant @3% of the total purchases cost debited by the assessee. It is seen from the assessment order that the total purchases cost debited by the appellant is Rs.14,83,37,420/-. The amount of net profit on this purchase cost @3% would be Rs.44,51,623/-. The appellant has declared total income of Rs.14,41,940/- from liquor business. Hence the addition of Rs.30,09,683/-(44,5I,623-14,41,940) is confirmed and balance addition of Rs.2,68,50,342/- is hereby deleted. …………………… 6. The ld. counsel has submitted a comparative chart on trading result showing the sales turnover, GP and NP etc. declared by the assessees, as extracted hereunder: - .

16 | P a g e

ITA No.246, 258 & 259/Agr/2026

Comparative Chart of Gross and Net Profit on Trading results Assessm Sales (Rs.) Gross profit Net Profit Remarks entYear Rs. Rs. % after % without deducting deducting interest interest and salary and salary 2006-07 2464568 904581 37.16 35798 1.47 - Accepted 2007-08 Nil Nil Nil - Nil - - 2008-09 103159162 7420887 7.19 2002427 1.94 2.9 576000 2009-10 100095112 8486895 8.48 1090815 1.09 2.1 501000 *2010-11 154743908 12633589 8.16 1441940 0.93 1.9 Under *2011-12 246560430 18018328 7.31 2341328 0.95 1.43 appeal

……………………… 10. We observed that the finding of the ld. CIT(A) are concurring with the observation of the AO, regarding rejection of books of account u/s 145(3), on the basis of glaring mistake pointed out and thereby, estimation of the turnover on the basis of information received from the excise department as correct and justified, and is in conformity with law. 11. That the ld. CIT(A) has rightly followed the decisions of the Hon’ble Jurisdictional Madhya Pradesh High Court given in the cases of ‘Commissioner of Income Tax vs. Balchand Ajit Kumar’, 263 ITR 610 and ‘Manmohan Sadani vs. Commissioner of Income Tax’, 304 ITR 52 while holding that where the books of account are being rejected, the entire sales cannot be charged to tax as income, only the profit rate is to be applied. As such, the finding of CIT(A) on the issue of applying net profit rate on the sales is in conformity with the law. Therefore, the departments ground of appeal that the difference in sales, as estimated by the AO as suppressed sales, be treated as income of the assessee, is hereby rejected. 12. From the above, it is amply clear that the ld. CIT(A) hasn’t pointed out any specific deficiency in the purchase invoices or the expense invoices, nor discussed any comparable case on identical facts, to form the basis for application of a particular net profit rate on gross total receipts, in the case of the assessee. On perusal of the comparative ‘Net Profit Chart’ of the assesses’s past history on profit rate, as above, it is evident that the Net Profit Rate is reasonably declared at 0.95 and 0.93 in respect of assessment year 2010-11 and 2011-12 respectively as against 1.94% and 1.09% of the previous years after deducting interest and salary to partners. After considering the decisions cited and the history of the case, it is factually clear that the profit rate applied by the Ld. CIT(A) at 3 % is on the higher side and is unreasonable.

17 | P a g e

ITA No.246, 258 & 259/Agr/2026

13.

Following the Hon’ble Jurisdictional MP High Court and considering our observation in the case of ‘Shri Laxmi Narain Shivhare’, (Supra) of ITAT, Agra Bench, on parity of facts, in case of retail trade of liquor, as such, we hold that it would be just fair and reasonable to apply a net profit rate of 2.7% on the sales price as estimated by the AO. Accordingly, the AO is directed to apply 2.7% NP rate on the estimated sales after deducting interest and salary to partners as per law, subject to the minimum returned income.” (emphasis supplied by us)

7.1 In this background, the ld. AR submits that the facts being similar in the present year also, as the assessee was carrying out the same business under the same circumstances, and therefore, the net profit @ 2.7%of the estimated sales before deducting interest and salary to partners subject to the minimum returned income as adopted by the Tribunal should have been accepted by the learned CIT(A). The said plea was taken by the assessee in its submissions filed before the Ld. CIT(A) which is reproduced as para 14 on page no. 10 of the order of the Ld. CIT(A). However, on the perusal of the findings of the Ld. CIT(A) where he confirmed the action of the AO, we notice that the Ld. CIT(A) did not consider the plea of the assessee for relying upon the order of this Tribunal as referred above i.e. to adopt the net profit @ 2.7%of the estimated sales before deducting interest and salary to partners subject to the minimum returned income. In this regard, the relevant findingsof the Ld. CIT(A) arealready reproduced earlier in this order.

18 | P a g e

ITA No.246, 258 & 259/Agr/2026

7.2 On the other hand, the Sr Dr. stated that the ld. CIT(A) distinguished the facts for not accepting the plea of the assessee for adopting net profit @ 2.7% in the appellate order for AY 2012-13 and 2013-14 and relied upon the same to support the order of the AO/Ld. CIT(A) for this year also.

7.3 On perusal of the assessment order for A.Y. 2010-11, it is noticed that the AO on page no. 2 of the assessment order noted that the assessee had produced the books of account. Further, the AO noted that the direct purchases cost was well documented as the payments in the shape of excise duty, basic license fees, transportations fees, ex godown purchase cost of IMFL/beer ware verifiable but the corresponding side of the P&L account being sale of liquor was totally unverifiable. The AO noted that this gives the assessee tremendous scope of suppressing its sale and consequently corresponding income liable to be taxed. For mainly these reasons, the books of account were rejected by the AO for A.Y. 2010-11. For A.Y. 2011-12, the order of the AO is silent with respect to the production of books of account by the assessee. However, again, the AO noted that the assessee neither furnished complete details of sales nor produced any sale bills/vouchers for the same and therefore, the sales shown by the assessee were not verifiable and accordingly 19 | P a g e

ITA No.246, 258 & 259/Agr/2026

rejected the books of account. In the appeal before us, i.e., A.Y. 2015-16, the AO has categorically noted that the assessee did not produce the books of account despite two opportunities given to the assessee by the AO. We may note here that in the other two appeals for A.Y. 2012-13 and 2013-14, the order of the AO is silent with respect to the production of books of account before the AO. Also, in these two years, the AO again records that the assessee was asked to furnish the complete details of sales of country liquor, IMFL and beer, but the assessee neither furnished complete details of sales nor produced the sale bills/vouchers for the same and therefore, the sales shown by the assessee was not verifiable. Accordingly, the AO rejected the books of account for A.Y. 2012-13 and 2013-14. For A.Y. 2015-16, the AO rejected the trading business shown by the assessee for the reasons given in para no. 4.2 of the assessment order,which included the non- production of the books of account before the AO during the assessment proceedings. The said para no. 4.2 of the assessment order has been reproduced by us earlier in this order(para no. 3 page no. 4).The learned CIT(A) did not agree with the submissions of the assessee that the assessee was forced to sell at a lesser rate to the minimum selling price, as it was contrary to the public policy and was not supported by providing necessary documentary evidence. Accordingly, the Ld. CIT(A) confirmed 20 | P a g e

ITA No.246, 258 & 259/Agr/2026

the order of the AO in treating the entire estimated suppressed/undisclosed sales of Rs. 1,23,49,627/-as the enhanced income of the assessee. In this regard, the findings of the Ld. CIT(A) for confirming the addition of Rs. 1,23,49,627/- as discussed in para no. 6.1 to 6.3 of his order is already reproduced earlier in this order (para no. 3.2 page nos. 6-8).

7.4 On the basis of the above facts and assessment history of the assessee firm from A.Y. 2008-09 to 2015-16, it is noted that for A.Y. 2010-11, the books of accounts were rejected by the AO andthe entire suppressed/ undisclosed sales was considered as the profit of the assessee and added to the total income. The rejection of books of account was affirmed by the ld. CIT(A) for A.Y. 2010-11, but the learned CIT(A) relying upon the decision of the jurisdictional Hon’ble Madhya Pradesh High Court in the case of CIT vs Balchand Ajit Kumar (supra) and Manmohan Sadani vs. CIT (supra)held that entire suppressed income cannot be taxed and only the net profit was to adopted in such cases as profits. The ld. CIT(A) reduced the same to 3% of the total sales, which, as discussed above, was reduced to 2.7% by the Tribunal. There are no distinguishing facts brought by the ld. CIT(A) or by the ld. CIT/DR to the finding of this Bench of the Tribunal in the case of the 21 | P a g e

ITA No.246, 258 & 259/Agr/2026

assessee for A.Y. 2010-11 and 2011-12 that entire suppressed/ undisclosed sales cannot be taxed as profit and only the net profit can be taxed. As discussed above, the assessee is doing the same business over the years and the books of account are being rejected since A.Y. 2010-11 and net profit being estimated.For this year also,we agree with the reasons given by the AO for the rejection of the books of accounts of the assessee.We are also conscious of the fact that there is a different reason for the rejection of books of accounts for A.Y. 2015-16, but ultimately, the issue is regarding as to whether the entire suppressed/undisclosed sales are to be taxed or an estimated net profit on suchsuppressed/undisclosed sales is to be taxed. This issue is squarely covered by the order of this Bench of the Tribunal in the case of the assessee for A.Y. 2010-11 and 2011-12 wherein, it directed the AO to apply net profit rate of 2.7% of the estimated sales before deducting interest and salary to partners subject to the minimum returned income. In this regard, we are also supported by the chart submitted by the assessee wherein the net profit has been declared by the assessee @ 1.65%, 2.41% and 1.87% before deducting interest and salary for A.Y. 2012-13, 2013-14 and 2015-16 wherein similar net profit @ 1.94% and 1.09%was consideredby this Bench of the Tribunal to be reasonably declared by the assessee for A.Y. 2010-11 and 2011-12 in para no. 12 of 22 | P a g e

ITA No.246, 258 & 259/Agr/2026

its order dated 16.05.2018.Therefore, we do not agree with the Ld. CIT(A) in upholding the order of the AO to tax the entire suppressed/undisclosed sales of Rs. 1,23,49,627/- as the income of the assessee.

7.5 In this regard, the submission of the ld. DR and the case laws relied upon by him for considering that the net profit @ 5% of the sales has been carefully considered by us but are not found to be acceptable. In the decision of Hon’ble Madhya Pradesh High Court in Badri Prasad Bhagwandas & Co. v. CIT (supra) relied upon by the Sr. DR, we notice that in the said case, the total sales were estimated by considering the sales of the assessee at 2.5 times of the license fees whereas in the present case, the sales have not been estimated in the said manner. Therefore, the facts are distinguishable in the case of the assessee. Similarly, in the case of ITO, Suryapet v. Sri Beeravelli Venkat Reddy (supra)relied upon by the Sr. DR, we notice that the Tribunal noted that it is well settled law that the best guide for estimation of income after rejecting the books of account is either the past history of the assessee or any other comparable case. Further, in the said case, the ld. DR had filed a written submission wherein it was referred that it was found in the latest ACB Investigation in the liquor trade that the sales were made 23 | P a g e

ITA No.246, 258 & 259/Agr/2026

much above MRP by forming cartels of the liquor traders, whereas no such finding is there on record in the case of the present assessee or with respect to the liquor trade carried out in the State of Madhya Pradesh. Therefore, again, the facts are distinguishable in the present case.

7.6 Therefore, in view of the above facts and following the order of this Bench in the case of the assessee for A.Y. 2010-11 and 2011-12 as referred above, we direct the AO to apply net profit rate of 2.7% of the estimated sales before deducting interest and salary to partners subject to the minimum returned income. Ground nos. 2 to 5 of the appeal is partly allowed.

8.

Addition of Rs. 1,10,94,794/- u/s 68 of the Act on account of unsecured loan: 8.1 During the course of assessment proceedings, on perusal of the tax audit report, the AO noted that during the year, the assessee had taken new loan of Rs.10,00,000/- from Smt. Mohini Gupta and further an unsecured loan of Rs.1,10,94,794/- from Shri Radhey Shyam Rathore. The AO asked the assessee to file the following details in order to examine the above loan transactions: 24 | P a g e

ITA No.246, 258 & 259/Agr/2026

“(a) To file confirmation from depositors alongwith copy of their PAN. (b) To file copy of account of depositors alongwith complete postal address. (c) To file computation of income, copy of acknowledgment of return, tax audit report, profit and loss account and balance sheet for A.Y.2013-14, 2014-15 and 2015-16. (d) To file copy of bank statement of depositors and explain source of deposit before giving loan to the assessee.”

8.2 The assessee filed reply on 29.11.2017. On perusal of the reply, the AO noted that the assessee failed to file the confirmation from Smt. Mohini Gupta and Shri Radhey Shyam Rathore apart from other details required as stated above. Accordingly, the AO did not accept the said loans as genuine and added the same u/s. 68 of the Act. In this regard, the relevant discussion in para nos. 3.1 and 3.2 of the assessment order are reproduced as under: “3.1 On the issue of unsecured loan in reply filed on 29.11.2017 the assessee stated as under:- "That the unsecured loans of Smt. Kamla Devi Shivhare Rs.3539080/-, Smt. Bhoari Bai Rs.358548/-, Shri Hari Om Jha Rs.424810/-, Shri Harish Shivhare Rs.393254/-, Shri Naveen Shivhare Rs.629212/- are old and carrying on earlier years. It is further submitted that the loan of Rs.1000000/- has been received from Smt. Mohini Gupta w/o Shri Agyat Gupta R/o Basant Bihar, Gwalior on 10.02.2015 vide cheque no.664671 of ICICI bank, copy of confirmation and other details for genuineness and creditworthiness of loan will be submitted on next date of hearing. The loan of Rs.1crore has been received from Shri Radhey Shyam Rathore c/o Sagita Hotel, A.B. Road, Guna (M.P.) said amount received through RTGS on 08.05.2014, the name of the Shri Rathore also mentioned in the bank statement of the assessee firm of bank account

25 | P a g e

ITA No.246, 258 & 259/Agr/2026

no.30040078341 of State Bank of India his PAN is ABQPR2295H. He assessed in Circle-3, Gwalior.” 3.2 The reply of the assessee has been examined and it has been found that on the next date of hearing on 01.12.2017 the assessee failed to file confirmation from Smt. Mohini Gupta and from Shri Radhey Shyam Rathore apart from other details required as discussed above. Thus, it is clear that the assessee has failed to prove the identity of depositor, creditworthiness of depositor and genuineness of transaction in case of depositor Smt. Mohini Gupta and Shri Radhey Shyam Rathore in terms of provision of section 68 of the I.T. Act. Accordingly, unsecured loan taken from Smt. Mohini Gupta at Rs.10,00,000/- and unsecured loan taken from Shri Radhey Shyam Rathore at Rs.1,00,00,000/-, total credit Rs.1,10,94,794/- in the name of Radhey Shyam Rathore remained unexplained and the same is being added to the total income u/s 68 of the l.T. Act. The assessee has credited to the account of Shri Radhey Shyam Rathore by Rs.10,94,794/ on account of interest. Since, unsecured loan remained unexplained as such interest at Rs.10,94,794/- also remained unexplained. Issue penalty notice u/s 271(1)(c) of the I.T. Act. (Addition: Rs. 10,00,000/-+ Rs.1,10,94,794/-)”

8.3 Aggrieved with the said order, the assessee filed an appeal before the learned CIT(A). The ld. CIT(A) dismissed the appeal of the assessee, wherein, the ld. CIT(A) observed that even during the appellate stage, the assessee could not explain the same. The ld. CIT(A) observed that during the appellate proceedings also, the assessee merely submitted the names of the parties and contended that since the amounts were received through bank account and PAN of the parties were provided, the addition was unwarranted. The ld. CIT(A) noted that on careful consideration of the matter, it was observed that the assessee failed to provide evidence regarding the identity, creditworthiness of the creditors 26 | P a g e

ITA No.246, 258 & 259/Agr/2026

and the genuineness of the transactions. The ld. CIT(A), relying upon plethora of case laws, as discussed in the appellate order, held that merely a PAN and a bank routing have been held as not satisfactory discharge of onus required under explanation to be made u/s. 68 of the Act. The learned CIT(A) held that since the assessee had failed both during the assessment and appellate proceedings to explain the source of the money, the identity & capacity of the parties and the genuineness of the transactions, the addition made by the AO was justified and accordingly, the same was confirmed.

9.

Aggrieved with the said order, the assessee is in appeal before us on the following ground of appeal: “6. That the Ld. Assessing Officer erred in adding Rs. 12094794/- on account of unexplained cash credit whereas both the unsecured loans were taken through account payee cheques and Ld. Assessing Officer without verifying their genuineness and creditworthiness added in the total income of the assessee and Ld. Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals) NFAC, Delhi also erred in confirmed the same. Hence the addition of Rs. 12094794/- may kindly be deleted.” 10. During the course of hearing, the learned AR submitted that due to certain disputes, the details as required by the AO could not be produced before the AO/CIT(A). The ld. AR submitted that the matter may be set aside to the file of the AO to give one more opportunity to the assessee to produce necessary documents to substantiate its claim that the loan of 27 | P a g e

ITA No.246, 258 & 259/Agr/2026

Rs.10,00,000/- from Smt. Mohini Gupta and of Rs.1,10,94,794/- from Shri Radhey Shyam Rathore are genuine loans. 11. On the other hand, the Ld. AR supported the findings of the lower authorities and opposed the plea of the assessee to give one more opportunity to the assessee to produce necessary documents to substantiate its claim that the loan of Rs.10,00,000/- from Smt. Mohini Gupta and of Rs.1,10,94,794/- from Shri Radhey Shyam Rathore are genuine loans. 12. We have heard both the parties and perused the material on record. We notice that the assessee did not produce the necessary documents to substantiate its claim that the loan of Rs.10,00,000/- from Smt. Mohini Gupta and of Rs.1,10,94,794/- from Shri Radhey Shyam Rathore are genuine loans both before the AO as well as the Ld. CIT(A). Further, we also notice that the supporting documents have also not been file before us. However, the assessee has filed the following submission before us which is reproduced as under: “In this regard it is submitted that the loan of Rs.1000000/- has been received from Smt. Mohini Gupta W/o Shri Agyat Gupta R/o Basant Bihar, Gwalior on 10.02.2015 vide cheque No.664671 of ICICI Bank and the loan of Rs.1 crorehas been received from Shri Radhey Shyam Rathore, C/o Sangita Hotel, A B Road, Guna (M.P.). Said amount received through RTGS on 08.05.2014, the name of the Shri Rathore also mentioned in the bank statement of the assessee firm of Bank account No.30040078341 of State Bank of India. His PAN is ABQPR2295H. He assessed in Circle-3, Gwalior. Hence both the loans are of well known persons and genuine 28 | P a g e

ITA No.246, 258 & 259/Agr/2026

Therefore, it is requested that kindly consider the above said facts and circumstances of the case and addition Rs. 12349627/- on account of extra profit in the business and Rs. 1000000/- & Rs. 11094794/- on account of unexplained cash credit made made by the Ld. Assessing Officer may kindly be deleted.”

12.1 Therefore, in the interest of justice and to give one more opportunity to the assessee to submit the necessary documents in support of its claim that the aforesaid loans are genuine loans, we set aside the order of the Ld. CIT(A) and restore the matter to his file for fresh adjudication after affording reasonable opportunity for being heard and accordance with law. Ground no. 6 of the appeal is allowed for statistical purposes. 13. In the result, the appeal of the assessee is partly allowed (ground no 6 allowed for statistical purposes)

14.

ITA NO. 258 and 259/Agr/2026 (A.Y. 2012-13 and 2013-14) 14.1 The facts of the appeal in ITA No. 246/Agr/2026relating to ground nos. 2 to 5 of the said appeal and ITA No. 258 and 259/Agr/2026are similar inasmuch as it relates to the dispute arising out of the rejection of the books of accounts by the AO and estimation of profit aswhether the entire suppressed/undisclosed sales is to be brought to taxed or the net profit on such suppressed/undisclosed sales is to be brought to taxed. The assessee has filed identical grounds of appeal being ground nos. 2 29 | P a g e

ITA No.246, 258 & 259/Agr/2026

to 5 for A.Y. 2012-13 and 2013-14 to the ground nos. 2 to 5 of the appeal for A.Y. 2015-16 except for the variation in the amount of addition made by the AO. This issue has already been decided by us in ITA no. 246/Agr/2026 for A.Y. 2015-16.Therefore, our observations in ITA No. 246/Agr/2026will be squarely applicable in ITA No. 258 and 259/Agr/2026 and we accordingly directthe AO to apply N.P. rate of 2.7% on the estimated sales before deducting interest and salary to partners subject to the minimum returned income. Ground nos. 2 to 5 of both the appeals are partly allowed.

15.

To sum up, the appeal of the assessee in ITA No. 246/Agr/2026 is partly allowed (ground no 6 allowed for statistical purposes) and the appeals in ITA Nos. 258& 259/Agr/2026 are partly allowed. Order pronounced in the open court on 18/11/2026.

Sd/- Sd/- (SUNIL KUMAR SINGH) (BRAJESH KUMAR SINGH) JUDICIAL MEMBER ACCOUNTANT MEMBER Dated: 18/11/2026 *aks/- Copy forwarded to: Aamir 1. Appellant Digitally signed 2. Respondent by Aamir Siddiqui 3. CIT Siddiqui Date: 2026.11.18 4. CIT(A) 12:44:07 +05'30' 5. DR Asst. Registrar, ITAT, Agra

30 | P a g e

More judgments on Section 40A(3)

All 3,452 judgments and leading authorities on Section 40A(3) →

Recent GST High Court judgments

Search GST case law →