THE COMMISSIONER, COMMERCIAL TAX U.P. vs. S/S GAYATRI PROJECT LTD.
What did the High Court hold?
The Tribunal held that the revision lacked merit and was accordingly dismissed. The questions of law were answered in favour of the assessee and against the revenue. The Court relied on its earlier decision in Comfort Systems Vs Commissioner, Commercial Tax, U.P., Lucknow (supra), which addressed similar arguments regarding the applicability of Sections 3, 4, and 5 of the Central Sales Tax Act, 1956, in the context of Rule 9(1)(e) of the UP VAT Rules, 2008. The Court reiterated that the phrase 'as a result of sale in the course of inter-state trade or commerce' in Rule 9(1)(e) must be read to include all transactions covered under Section 3 of the Central Sales Tax Act, 1956, in light of the Supreme Court's decision in Gannon Dunkerley-II. The Court found that the appellate authorities had concurrently held that the goods imported by the assessee were used for the execution of the civil works contract, and no material was brought forth to doubt these findings. Therefore, the revenue's contention that the goods were not applied to the contract was not accepted. The Court also clarified that the concept of subsequent sale was not relevant as the assessee's case clearly fell under Rule 9(1)(b) of the UP VAT Rules, 2008, based on the import of goods for execution of the works contract.
What were the facts?
The Revenue, Commissioner, Commercial Tax U.P., filed a revision against the order of the Commercial Tax Tribunal dated January 23, 2019. The Tribunal had upheld the order of the First Appellate Authority, which had allowed the assessee, S/S Gayatri Project Ltd., a civil work contractor, the benefit of Section 3F(2)(b) of the U.P. Trade Tax Act and Sections 3, 4, and 5 of the Central Sales Tax Act, 1956. The assessee had opted for a composition scheme for civil contractors. The Assessing Officer disallowed the compounded rate on imported goods exceeding 5% of the contract value, treating them as subject to normal assessment. The dispute arose over whether these imported goods, used for the civil works contract, were taxable under the normal assessment or covered by the composition scheme and Central Sales Tax provisions.
What were the issues?
1. Whether, on the facts and circumstances, the Commercial Tax Tribunal and the First Appellate Authority were justified in allowing the benefit of Section 3F(2)(b) of the U.P. Trade Tax Act to the dealer when it had opted for a composition scheme and agreed to pay tax accordingly? 2. Whether, on the facts and circumstances, the Commercial Tax Tribunal and the First Appellate Authority were justified in granting the benefit of Sections 3, 4, and 5 of the Central Sales Tax Act, 1956, when the dealer had opted for a composition of money in lieu of tax under Section 7(D)? 3. Whether, on the facts and circumstances, the Commercial Tax Tribunal and the First Appellate Authority were justified in deleting the tax assessed by the assessing authority in view of the composition scheme and Section 7D, which states 'notwithstanding anything contained in this act, but subject to the direction of the State Government'? Revenue's Contentions: The Revenue argued that there was no exclusionary clause in Section 6 of the U.P. VAT Act, 2008, read with Rule 9 of the Value Added Tax Rules, 2008, to exclude goods/transactions covered under Sections 3, 4, and 5 of the Central Sales Tax Act, 1956. Therefore, the assessee was liable to full tax on those goods. The Revenue also contended that it was not examined whether the imported goods were actually applied to the civil works contract for which the assessee was admitted to the compounding benefit. Assessee's Contentions: The assessee contended that the entire value of imported goods was used for executing the civil works contract and that the State authorities could not tax such goods by virtue of Sections 3, 4, and 5 of the Central Sales Tax Act, 1956, as explained in Gannon Dunkerley & Co. & Others Vs State of Rajasthan & Others (1993) 1 SCC 364. The assessee further relied on this Court's decision in Comfort Systems Vs Commissioner, Commercial Tax, U.P., Lucknow (2019) 39 VLJ 176, for the first submission of the revenue. Regarding the second submission, the assessee pointed to concurrent findings of fact by the appellate authorities that the imported goods were applied towards the execution of the civil works contract.
Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?
Section 3F(2)(b),Section 3,Section 4,Section 5,Section 7(D),Section 6,Section 3-F(2)(i)
AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below
Court No. - 1 Case :- SALES/TRADE TAX REVISION No. - 118 of 2019 Applicant :- The Commissioner, Commercial Tax U.P. Opposite Party :- S/S Gayatri Project Ltd. Counsel for Applicant :- Bipin Kumar Pandey Counsel for Opposite Party :- Rahul Agarwal Hon'ble Saumitra Dayal Singh,J. 1. Heard Sri Bipin Kumar Pandey, learned Standing Counsel and Sri Rahul Agarwal, learned counsel for the assessee. 2. The present revision has been admitted on the following questions of law:- "I. Whether on the facts and circumstances of the case the Commercial Tax Tribunal as well as the Ist Appellate Authority were legally justified in allowing the benefit of section 3F(2) (b) of the U.P. Trade Tax Act specifically when the dealer has opted the composition of scheme and has agreed to pay the tax in accordance with the composition of scheme dated 11.2.05? II. Whether on the facts and circumstances of the case the Commercial Tax Tribunal as well as Ist Appellate Authority were legally justified in granting the benefit of Section 3,4 and 5 of the Central Sales Tax Act especially when the dealer has opted for composition of money in lieu of tax under section 7(D)? III. Whether on the facts and circumstances of the case the Commercial Tax Tribunal as well as Ist Appellate Authority were legally justified in deleting the amount of tax assessed by the assessing authority in view of the composition of scheme dated 11.2.05 and section 7D specifically prescribed that 'notwithstanding anything contained in this act, but subject to the direction of the State Government..............?" 3. The present revision has been filed by the revenue against the judgment and order of the Commercial Tax Tribunal, Bench 3 Kanpur (Jhansi) dated 23.01.2019 by which the said Tribunal has rejected the second appeal filed by the revenue against the order of the First Appellate Authority in Appeal No.403 of 2017 for Assessment Year 2008-09. Thus, the Tribunal has affirmed the order passed by the First Appellate Authority. 4. In short, the assessee is a civil work contractor. During the assessment year in question, it had executed certain
civil works contract and had offered itself to taxation under the UP VAT Act, 2008 (hereinafter referred to as the 'Act') under the compounding scheme for civil contractors as had been introduced by a circular dated 10.08.2000. 5. There is no dispute to the eligibility of the assessee to the compounding scheme. However, according to the Assessing Officer, the assessee had imported goods (that were applied to the contract) in excess of 5% of the value of the contract. Thus, cement, iron and steel, lime and other unclassified goods of value of Rs.20,61,45,265/- had been imported by the assessee in excess of 5% value of the contract. Invoking Clause 3 of the scheme of compounding noted above, the Assessing Officer excluded the said value of goods from the assessment made on compounded basis and subjected the same to tax under the normal mode of assessment. It is here that the dispute arose giving rise to the present revision. According to the revenue, since there is no exclusionary clause under Section 6 of the Act read with Rule 9 of the Value Added Tax Rules, 2008 (hereinafter referred to as the 'Rules'), to exclude from the scope of assessment goods/transactions that may be covered under Sections 3, 4 and 5 of the Central Sales Tax Act, 1956 (hereinafter referred to as the 'Central Act'), the assessee was liable to suffer a full rate of tax on those goods. Accordingly, assuming profit of 20% derived by the assessee on the aforesaid value of goods, the Assessing Officer subjected to assessee to tax on a deemed sale of Rs.24,73,74,318/-. 6. The assessee on its part contended that there being no dispute that it had imported the entire value of goods only for the purposes of execution of individual civil contract and that it had actually applied those goods for execution of that contract, by virtue of law contained in Sections 3, 4 and 5 of the Central Act as has been explained in the case of Gannon Dunkerley & Co. & Others Vs State of Rajasthan & Others (1993) 1 SCC 364 (hereinafter referred to as the 'Gannon Dunkerley'). The State authorities could never subject such goods to tax. 7. The aforesaid issue was decided against the assessee by the Assessing Authority. Upon first appeal filed by the assessee, the First Appellate Authority upon consideration of entire material placed before him reached a conclusion that there was no dispute to the fact that the assessee had imported the goods (including the disputed goods) against express or implied contracts only for execution of
the civil works contract awarded to it. Thus, according to the First Appellate Authority, there was no dispute that the entire quantity of goods had been moved from outside the State to inside the State only for the purpose of execution of pre-existing civil works contract. Thereafter, the First Appellate Authority has reasoned that in such facts the subsequent sale affected by the assessee in favour of the contractee would remain excluded by virtue of Section 3 of the Central Act. The aforesaid findings recorded by the First Appellate Authority both as to fact as also on the inference of law drawn by it have been affirmed by the Tribunal. 8. Sri Bipin Kumar Pandey, learned Standing Counsel, would contend that in absence of any provision similar to that contained in Section 3-F(2)(b)(i) of the UP Trade Tax Act, 1948 in the UP VAT Act or the Rules, there can be no exclusion from assessment of transaction that may otherwise fall within the description of Sections 3, 4 and 5 of the Central Act. Even otherwise, he would submit that in the present case, it has not been examined by the authorities with reference to the contract whether the goods that were imported had actually being applied by the assessee to the civil works contract executed by it for which it had been admitted to the benefits of compound. 9. Sri Rahul Agarwal, learned counsel for the assessee, on the other hand would submit, that the first submission advanced by learned counsel for the revenue, has been decided in favour of the assessee by this Court in Comfort Systems Vs Commissioner, Commercial Tax, U.P., Lucknow (2019) 39 VLJ 176. Insofar as the second submission is concerned, he would submit that the concurrent findings had been recorded by the appellate authorities that there is no dispute on fact that the goods imported by the assessee had been applied towards execution of the civil works contract. Therefore, it does not lie with the revenue to raise such an issue in the present proceeding which have to be confined to the question of law. 10. In fact, no question of law may ever arise on that issue in view of the concurrent finding of fact recorded by both appellate authorities which was neither shown to be perverse or otherwise grossly erroneous. 11. However, he would submit that, even if the reasoning given by the First Appellate Authority considering the sale to be a subsequent sale, is found to be erroneous, it may
not lead to any different conclusion in view of the decision of this Court in the case of Comfort Systems Vs Commissioner, Commercial Tax, U.P., Lucknow (supra) and a clear categorical finding of fact recorded by both the appellate authorities, that the entire quantity of goods had been imported in pursuance of the works contract awarded to the assessee and those goods had been applied for execution of that contract. 12. Having heard learned counsel for the parties, in the first place, the issue raised by learned Standing Counsel on Sections 3, 4 and 5 of the Central Act being not applicable in view of the different language of Rule 9 of the UP VAT Rules, had been considered and decided against the revenue in the case of Comfort Systems Vs Commissioner, Commercial Tax, U.P., Lucknow (supra). The same argument had been advanced in that case. However, relying in view of the decision of the Supreme Court in Gannon Dunkerley (supra), the same was repelled and it was held as below: "19. That being the governing principle, the language of Rule 9(1)(e) of the Rules relied upon by the learned Standing Counsel has to be examined in that light. In absence of any legislative competence on part of the State legislature to impose tax on deemed sale in the course of inter-state trade, the phrase "as a result of sale in the course of inter-state trade or commerce" appearing in Rule 9(1)(e) of the Rules cannot be restricted or confined to inter-state sale but as referring to transaction of "a sale or purchase of goods" falling under section 3 of the Central Sales Tax Act, 1956. 20. If that Rule were to be read to allow for deductions on deemed inter-state sales alone, it may render the Rule largely redundant, inasmuch as a transaction of inter-state sale made inside the state of U.P. would never be referable to any works contract being executed inside the state of U.P. A works contract being executed outside the state of U.P. may never qualify for assessment inside the state of U.P. in the context of Rule 9(1)(e) of the Rules. The only other situation where the Rule may remain functional may be of sale in transit in pursuance of a works contract being executed inside the State of U.P. However, there does not appear any reason or circumstance to limit the applicability of the Rule to that species of inter-state sale transactions alone. 21. Therefore, merely because there was no privity of contract between the contractee and the actual seller of the goods (from whom the assessee made the purchases), and though such seller was not known/specified at the time of the execution of the works contract document, it would make no difference to the eligibilty to deduction claimed by the assessee under Rule 9(1)(e) of the Rules, on deemed inter- state sale arising upon transfer of property in goods involved in the execution of the works contract. On the findings recorded by the Tribunal, the goods in question had been moved from outside the State solely by reason of the pre-existing works contract and those goods had been
applied only solely the execution of that works contract. Therefore, the deemed sale of goods arose, only by way of inter-state sale as the movement of goods was occasioned by the prior contract of sale, namely the works contract. 22. Rule 9(1)(e), though worded differently from section 3- F(2)(i) of U.P.Trade Tax Act, 1948, it does not and it cannot be permitted to convey a different meaning, in view of the binding principle laid down by the Supreme Court in the case of Gannon Dunkerley-II. Also, in absence of legislative intent to exclude the applicability of that Rule to some cases of inter-state sale (such as the present case), would be to allow such interpretation of the law to arise in conflict with the law laid down in Gannon Dunkerley-II. Therefore, the phrase - "as a result of sale in the course of inter-state trade or commerce" appearing in Rule 9(1)(e) of the Rules has to be read to include in its cover all transactions covered under section 3 of the Central Sales Tax Act, 1956." 13. Insofar as the second submission advanced by learned Standing Counsel is concerned, clearly both appellate authorities have considered the material that was brought before them, and have thereafter concluded that there is no dispute to the fact that the assessee imported the goods against express and implied contracts and applied the same to the works contract pursuant to which it had made the import of goods. No material has been brought before this Court to doubt the correctness of that finding. Therefore, that submission advanced by learned Standing Counsel also cannot be accepted. 14. As to the last submission advanced by learned counsel for the assessee, it is true that the concept of subsequent sale was not relevant in the present case inasmuch as it was the assessee's clear and consistent case before the authorities that it had imported the disputed goods for execution of the civil works contract and as such assessee's case clearly fell under Rule 9(1) (b) of the UP VAT Rules. 15. By way of conclusion, it is observed that in the facts of the present case the earlier decision of this Court in the case of Comfort Systems Vs Commissioner, Commercial Tax, U.P., Lucknow (supra) is squarely applicable. 16. The revision lacks merit and, is accordingly, dismissed. The questions of law as noted above are answered accordingly i.e. in favour of the assessee and against the revenue. Order Date :- 1.7.2019 S.Chaurasia
More judgments on Section 3
- Mr. K.Mohanlal vs The Deputy Commissioner of Income TaxWP/25987/20255 Nov 2026
- St. Josephs High School, Kandivali West… vs CIT(Exemption), Mumbai, CumballaITA 5715/MUM/2026[2026-27]Status: Disposed29 Oct 2026AY 2026-27
- The Assessing Officer, Textiles Committee vs M/S. Premium Suiting Pvt. LtdC.A. No.-000785-000785 - 201626 Oct 2026
- Bhagyalaxmi Kitchenware LLP, Vasai Road East vs Income Tax Officer Ward 4(1), ThaneITA 1593/MUM/2026[2022-23]Status: Disposed16 Oct 2026AY 2022-23
- Sandeep Rao Madhavaram Sivaiahgari… vs ACIT., Central Circle-3(3), HyderabadITA 101/HYD/2025[2020-2021]Status: Disposed13 Oct 2026AY 2020-2021
Recent GST High Court judgments
Search GST case law →- M/S.Ritika Ispat PVT. LTD.,Balanda, Sundergarh vs. The Commissioner Of Commercial Taxes And Goods And Services Tax, Odisha, CuttackOrissa · 4 Nov 2026
- M/S Shree Sai Jagannath, Rourkela, Sundargarh vs. Chief Commissioner, CGST, Central Excise And Customs, BhubaneswarOrissa · 4 Nov 2026
- M/S.Shree Construction, Khordha vs. The Principal Commissioner, CGST And Central Excise, BhubaneswarOrissa · 4 Nov 2026
- Pramod Kumar Behera vs. Union Of INDIAOrissa · 4 Nov 2026
- Santosh Kumar Pradhan (Late Biswabhar Pradhan) vs. The Chief Commissioner, CGST And Central Excise And Customs, BhubaneswarOrissa · 4 Nov 2026