ST. JOSEPHS HIGH SCHOOL,KANDIVALI WEST, MUMBAI vs. CIT(EXEMPTION), MUMBAI, CUMBALLA, MUMBAI

PDF · subscribers
ITA 5715/MUM/2026Status: DisposedITAT Mumbai29 October 2026AY 2026-2713 pages
AI SummaryRemanded

What did the Tribunal hold?

The Tribunal held that the absence of a separate trust deed or Memorandum of Association, or a scheme, is not by itself fatal to the renewal of registration. Section 12AB(1)(b) and Rule 17A(2) do not prescribe a written trust deed as the only permissible means of establishing the applicant's constitution. Rule 17A(2)(b) specifically applies to institutions established otherwise than under an instrument and requires a self-certified copy of the document evidencing creation or establishment. The Tribunal found that the CIT(E) erred in treating the application to the Charity Commissioner and the registration certificate as merely evidence of registration and not as evidence of creation or establishment. The Tribunal noted that the assessee's case is that it has been registered as a public charitable trust since 1969, and these documents, along with others, should be considered as evidence of creation. The Tribunal decided that the matter should be remanded to the CIT(E) for a fresh consideration of the application and the evidence furnished by the assessee, including the documents evidencing its establishment and charitable activities, without being prejudiced by the erroneous premise that a trust deed is mandatory. The Tribunal did not decide on the genuineness of activities or compliance with other laws.

What were the facts?

The assessee, St. Josephs High School, filed an application for renewal of registration under Section 12AB of the Income-tax Act, 1961, in Form No. 10AB on 26.09.2025. The Commissioner of Income-tax (Exemptions), Mumbai (CIT(E)), rejected the application, deeming it incomplete. The CIT(E) required the assessee to furnish the instrument of trust or Memorandum of Association as per Rule 17A(2) of the Income-tax Rules, 1962. The assessee responded that it was established under Canon Law and not a separate written instrument, providing its registration certificate from the Charity Commissioner under the Maharashtra Public Trusts Act, 1950, and other supporting documents. The CIT(E) found these documents insufficient to evidence the creation of the trust and rejected the application.

What were the issues?

1. Whether the learned CIT(E) erred in rejecting the application for registration under Section 12AB solely on the ground that the Appellant failed to furnish the instrument of Trust/MOA, which amounts to non-compliance with Section 12AB(1)(b) read with Rule 17A(2)? 2. Whether the learned CIT(E) erred in observing that the application to the Charity Commissioner and the subsequent registration certificate do not constitute documents evidencing the creation of the trust under Rule 17A(2)(b), overlooking the trust's registration since 1969? Assessee's Contentions: The assessee argued that Rule 17A(2)(b) contemplates institutions established otherwise than under an instrument. Its registration as a public charitable trust since 1969, along with the application to the Charity Commissioner, registration certificate, earlier income-tax registrations, and records of charitable functioning, constitute relevant evidence. Insisting on a deed that never existed is contrary to the Rule and the principle of consistency. Reliance was placed on previous ITAT decisions in St. Joseph’s High School v. CIT(E) and St. John the Evangelist Church v. CIT(E). The assessee also contended that the Indian Trusts Act, 1882, is not applicable to public charitable trusts and that a scheme is not invariably necessary. Revenue's Contentions: The Departmental Representative supported the need for statutory inquiry, stating that while a formal deed may not exist, adequate alternative evidence of establishment, objects, governing authority, and genuine activities must be produced. The registration certificate, though relevant, does not necessarily establish all conditions under Section 12AB. Earlier registration and long existence do not preclude examination of the present application. The relied-upon school decision was distinguished as having a wider documentary record. In the alternative, restoration to the CIT(E) for verification was sought.

Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?

Section 12AB,Section 12AB(1)(b),Section 12A(1)(ac)(ii),Section 12A,Section 12AA,Section 3,Section 5

AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below

Income Tax Appellate Tribunal, MUMBAI BENCHES, MUMBAI

Before: SHRI SAKTIJIT DEY & SHRI MAKARAND VASANT MAHADEOKAR

PER MAKARAND VASANT MAHADEOKAR, ACCOUNTANT MEMBER: This appeal by the assessee is directed against the order dated 30.03.2026 passed by the Commissioner of Income-tax (Exemptions), Mumbai [“CIT(E)”], rejecting its application in Form No.10AB seeking renewal of regular registration under section 12AB of the Income-tax Act, 1961 [“the Act”]. The controversy concerns the evidence required under Rule 17A(2) of the Income-tax Rules, 1962 where an institution states that it was established otherwise than under a separate written instrument.

ITA No. 5715/MUM/2026 ST. JOSEPHS HIGH SCHOOL 2. The assessee has raised the following grounds, which are reproduced as filed: On the facts and circumstances of the case and in law, 1.] The learned CIT(E) erred in rejecting the Application for Registration under Section 12AB of the Act solely on the ground that the Appellant failed to furnish the instrument of Trust /MOA as it amounts to non-compliance and non-fulfillment of mandatory requirements prescribed under Section 12AB (1)(b) of the Act read with Rule 17A(2) of the Income Tax Rules, 1962. 2.] The learned CIT(E) erred in observing that the application in Schedule II and subsequent registration Certificate issued by the Charity Commissioner do not constitute documents "evidencing the creation of the trust" as prescribed under Rule 17A(2)(b) of Income tax Rules, 1962 by completely overlooking the fact that the appellant is a charitable trust duly registered with the Charity Commissioner under the Maharashtra Public Trusts Act, 1950 based on valid declaration of trust since the year 1969 and exists as a public charitable trust. 3.] The learned CIT(E) failed to consider and appreciate the Certificate of Registration granted by the Charity Commissioner under the Maharashtra Public Trusts Act, 1950 which is a valid document that establishes the existence of the Appellant Trust and is covered by the provisions of Rule 17(A)(2)(b) - any document evidencing the creation or establishment of the trust. 4.] The learned CIT(E) erred in observing that the Canon Law does not have any direct application for management and administrations of charitable trusts. 5.] The learned CIT(E) erred in relying upon the provisions of the Indian Trusts Act, 1882 as the same are clearly not applicable in the case of the Appellant Trust – as it is undisputedly a public charitable trust. 6.] The learned CIT(E) erred in summarily rejecting the renewal application without considering the historical context and past records and evidence like audit reports and Return of Income filed over the past several decades that confirm the trust's long-standing charitable existence. 7.] The CIT (E) failed to appreciate that there has been no change in the objects of the School, the nature of its activities, or the applicable law, the learned CIT(E) is bound by the "Rule of Consistency" as established by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Radhasoami Satsang vs. CIT. The CIT (E) cannot arbitrarily change its stand to deny a status it has historically recognized and accepted. 8.] The learned CIT(E) failed to appreciate that the Department has granted/renewed registration under Section 12A/12AA/12AB of the Act for several decades in the past based on the same set of documents furnished on earlier occasions. 9.] The learned CIT(E) failed to appreciate that his power under section 12AB of the Act is limited to verifying the genuineness of the activities of the charitable nature of object which in the case of the Appellant has not been doubted and 2

ITA No. 5715/MUM/2026 ST. JOSEPHS HIGH SCHOOL therefore the order passed by the CIT (E) on the alleged ground based on format of the document, rather than the nature of the activities is contrary to the provisions of the Act. 10.] The learned CIT(E) failed to appreciate that the rejection Order passed by him certainly affects the day-to-day management and functioning of the Appellant Trust though he may not have intended so. 3. The grounds arise from a common grievance and are, therefore, considered together. The assessee seeks setting aside of the rejection and a direction to grant registration under section 12AB.

4.

The relevant facts, as recorded in the impugned order, are that the assessee filed its application in Form No.10AB on 26.09.2025 under section 12A(1)(ac)(ii). On preliminary verification, the CIT(E) considered the application incomplete and issued notice dated 14.11.2025 requiring the documents prescribed under Rule 17A(2). The assessee responded by letter dated 04.12.2025 and furnished certain details and supporting documents. A further notice dated 15.03.2026 specifically called for a self-certified copy of the instrument of trust or Memorandum of Association.

5.

In response, the assessee explained that it had not been constituted under a separate written trust deed or Memorandum of Association and referred to administration under Canon Law. It furnished a copy of the application for registration as a public trust. Paragraph 3.1 of the impugned order records this explanation, but treats that application as evidence of registration alone and not as evidence of creation or establishment. The CIT(E) also noted that no scheme settled by the Charity Commissioner or a competent Court had been furnished.

6.

After reproducing section 12AB(1)(b) and clauses (a), (b) and (c) of Rule 17A(2), the CIT(E), in paragraphs 4.3 and 4.4, regarded the instrument of trust as mandatory and as the sole source of the trust’s legal existence. According to him, the objects, beneficiaries, trust property, authority of the trustees and manner of administration could not be ascertained without that 3

ITA No. 5715/MUM/2026 ST. JOSEPHS HIGH SCHOOL instrument. In paragraphs 4.5 and 4.6, he referred to sections 3 and 5 of the Indian Trusts Act, 1882, while acknowledging that the enactment applies to private trusts. He considered that the relevant concepts could nevertheless be adopted in examining a public trust.

7.

The CIT(E) further held that the reference to Canon Law did not dispense with compliance with the Income-tax Act and the Maharashtra Public Trusts Act, 1950. In paragraphs 4.7 to 6, he concluded that, in the absence of the instrument or satisfactory evidence of creation, the requisite satisfaction about the objects, genuineness of activities and compliance with other material laws could not be reached. The application was accordingly rejected. The concluding portion states that the existing regular registration would remain valid till assessment year 2026-27 and advises the assessee to formulate an instrument or obtain a scheme. These observations form part of the reasoning under challenge.

8.

During the course of hearing before us, the learned Authorized Representative (AR) submitted that Rule 17A(2)(b) expressly contemplates institutions established otherwise than under an instrument. The assessee’s case is that it has been registered as a public charitable trust under the Maharashtra Public Trusts Act since 1969 and that the Schedule II application, the registration certificate, earlier income-tax registrations and records of its continued charitable functioning constitute relevant evidence. It was contended that there had been no change in the objects or activities and that the same documentary foundation had been accepted on earlier occasions. Insistence on producing a deed which never existed was, according to the learned AR, contrary to the Rule and the principle of consistency. The reference to Canon Law was explained as describing the historical manner of administration, without claiming exemption from the applicable secular legislation.

ITA No. 5715/MUM/2026 ST. JOSEPHS HIGH SCHOOL 9. Reliance was placed on the order in St. Joseph’s High School v. CIT(E), ITA Nos.5646 and 5849/Mum/2026, dated 05.08.2026, and on St. John the Evangelist Church v. CIT(E), ITA No.5828/Mum/2026, dated 08.09.2026. The assessee sought renewal on the strength of the former decision. The submissions also questioned the reliance on the Indian Trusts Act and the suggestion that a scheme was invariably necessary.

10.

The learned Departmental Representative (DR) supported the need for an effective statutory inquiry. His submission was that a formal deed need not exist in every case, but the applicant must produce adequate alternative evidence of its establishment, objects, governing authority and genuine activities. He distinguished the application submitted to the Charity Commissioner from the findings and register entries resulting from the statutory inquiry, and contended that a registration certificate, though relevant, did not necessarily establish every condition under section 12AB. Earlier registration and long existence, according to him, did not exclude examination of the present application.

11.

The learned DR further submitted that the school decision relied upon proceeded on a wider documentary record, including earlier tax registrations, educational recognition, NGO Darpan registration and evidence of continued educational activities. He urged that the sufficiency of that institution’s evidence could not be presumed in this appeal. In the alternative, restoration to the CIT(E) for the necessary verification was sought.

12.

We have considered the rival submissions, the impugned order and the decisions relied upon. Two questions arise. The first is whether absence of a separate trust deed or Memorandum of Association, or of a scheme, is by itself fatal to renewal. The second is whether, on removing that erroneous premise, renewal must necessarily be directed without any further examination of the statutory conditions. The two questions require distinct consideration. 5

ITA No. 5715/MUM/2026 ST. JOSEPHS HIGH SCHOOL 13. Section 12AB(1)(b) permits the Commissioner to call for documents and make inquiries concerning genuine activities and compliance with other laws material to achieving the institution’s objects. His decision must also rest on satisfaction concerning those objects. The inquiry is substantive, and the assessee must furnish evidence sufficient for that purpose. The provision does not, however, prescribe a written trust deed as the only permissible means of establishing the applicant’s constitution.

14.

Rule 17A(2) differentiates between an applicant constituted under an instrument and one constituted otherwise. Clause (a) requires the constitutive instrument in the former situation. Clause (b) applies in the latter and requires a self-certified copy of the document evidencing creation or establishment. Clause (c) separately requires evidence of registration with the relevant Registrar. The distinction between an instrument which creates an institution and a document which evidences its establishment must be maintained. Requiring a constitutive instrument even in the latter situation would deprive clause (b) of its operation.

15.

The conclusion in paragraphs 4.3, 4.4 and 4.7 of the impugned order does not give effect to that distinction. The CIT(E) quoted clause (b), but proceeded on the basis that the absence of an instrument necessarily prevented all further inquiry. That is an error of law. The assessee’s inability to produce a document which, according to its explanation, never existed cannot, without examination of the alternative evidence, be equated with failure to comply with a universal statutory requirement to furnish a deed.

16.

There is, nevertheless, a legitimate distinction between dispensing with a formal deed and dispensing with proof. Clause (b) preserves the requirement of evidence. The CIT(E) may examine whether the documents relate to this assessee, what they establish about its origin and objects, and whether the activities are genuine. If a particular relevant matter remains unclear, he may require clarification or supporting records. Such a 6

ITA No. 5715/MUM/2026 ST. JOSEPHS HIGH SCHOOL requisition must identify the matter requiring verification; it cannot merely repeat a demand for the unavailable deed.

17.

The Schedule II application and the statutory registration records must be considered in their proper setting. Under sections 19 to 21 of the Maharashtra Public Trusts Act, the inquiry, findings and consequential register entries concern, inter alia, the existence and public character of the trust, its origin and objects, trustees and mode of succession. An application states the particulars asserted by the applicant; the findings and entries record the outcome of the statutory process. These documents do not have identical evidentiary weight. They are, however, capable of being considered together as evidence of establishment.

18.

The CIT(E)’s categorical exclusion of the public-trust application from consideration under clause (b) is, therefore, unsustainable. The separate requirement in clause (c) does not prohibit a statutory registration document from also having evidentiary value for clause (b). Equally, registration under the State enactment does not automatically conclude every inquiry under section 12AB. The correct approach is to assess the contents and cumulative probative value of the documents, rather than accept or reject them merely by their description.

19.

The decision relied upon in St. Joseph’s High School, ITA Nos.5646 and 5849/Mum/2026, concerns the institution at Vikhroli. The present appeal concerns the institution at Kandivali. The similarity of names does not make them the same assessee. The dates of establishment and registration, educational recognition and other documents discussed in that decision must, therefore, remain confined to its own record.

20.

In paragraphs 19 to 23 of that decision, the coordinate Bench explained the distinction between the two modes of establishment

ITA No. 5715/MUM/2026 ST. JOSEPHS HIGH SCHOOL recognized by Rule 17A and the evidentiary relevance of public-trust records. Paragraph 20 states: “The emphasis, therefore, shifts from the constitutive instrument itself to the evidentiary material demonstrating the existence and establishment of the institution.” At the same time, paragraph 23 preserves the statutory inquiry in the 21. following terms: “The question is whether the material produced is sufficient to enable the Commissioner to arrive at the satisfaction contemplated by section 12AB.” 22. We respectfully follow that interpretation. The direction to grant renewal in paragraph 33 of the school decision was made on the documentary record and findings in that case. Paragraphs 21, 28 and 31 refer to the earlier registrations, educational recognition and continued activities whose correctness had not been doubted. The decision does not prescribe each document mentioned there as a mandatory checklist for other applicants. It also does not hold that the failure of one reason for rejection necessarily establishes all remaining statutory conditions in every appeal.

23.

The later decision in St. John the Evangelist Church (supra), cited in the submissions, accepted the same legal principle. In paragraphs 15 and 16, however, the Bench restored the application for the limited examination of the other statutory parameters because those matters had not been examined by the CIT(E). It prohibited renewed rejection merely for want of a deed, Memorandum of Association or scheme. The difference in relief reflects the state of the factual examination; it does not disclose a difference in the interpretation of Rule 17A. We follow that distinction in determining the appropriate relief here.

24.

The reference to the Indian Trusts Act does not sustain the impugned conclusion. Section 1 excludes its application to public or private religious or charitable endowments. The CIT(E) himself acknowledges the limited

ITA No. 5715/MUM/2026 ST. JOSEPHS HIGH SCHOOL field of that enactment. General principles concerning fiduciary obligations may assist in understanding a trust, and definitions may be adopted where the applicable enactment so provides. That does not justify importing section 5 as an overriding requirement that every public charitable institution must have a registered written deed. Such an approach would be incompatible with the alternative expressly recognized in Rule 17A(2)(b).

25.

As regards Canon Law, the application for income-tax registration must satisfy the applicable statutory provisions. Reference to ecclesiastical administration does not, by itself, establish compliance with those provisions. Conversely, it supplies no basis for presuming non-compliance. What requires examination is the assessee’s own constitution and supporting records. The impugned order’s general discussion of church administration, although the applicant is a school, does not identify a particular breach by this assessee. It cannot substitute for consideration of the material furnished.

26.

Nor has any provision been identified which requires every such institution to obtain a scheme settled by the Charity Commissioner or a Court as a precondition to registration under section 12AB. If an existing scheme governs the assessee, it is relevant evidence. Its absence cannot be converted into an independent statutory disqualification without identifying an applicable legal requirement. The advice to create a fresh instrument or procure a scheme cannot cure the error in refusing to examine the alternative evidence contemplated by the Rule.

27.

Earlier registration is also material. The impugned order itself recognizes an existing regular registration valid till assessment year 2026- 27. In Radhasoami Satsang v. CIT, (1992) 193 ITR 321 (SC), the Hon’ble Supreme Court recognized the relevance of consistency where a fundamental aspect accepted in earlier years remains unchanged, while explaining that strict res judicata does not govern income-tax proceedings. The assessee’s plea that the same documents had previously been accepted must receive 9

ITA No. 5715/MUM/2026 ST. JOSEPHS HIGH SCHOOL reasoned consideration. Prior registration does not dispense with the present statutory inquiry, but it cannot be ignored while evaluating the claimed continuity of the institution’s constitution and activities.

28.

The jurisdictional decision in The Chamber of Tax Consultants v. CIT(E), Writ Petition (L) No.7587 of 2026, dated 09.03.2026, reported at (2026) 184 taxmann.com 374 (Bom.), referred to in the school decision, concerns rejection for want of express irrevocability or dissolution clauses and the related declaration in Form No.10AB. It reinforces the prohibition against introducing a condition unsupported by the statute. Its operative directions should not, however, be read as granting automatic renewal to every institution whose eligibility on the other statutory parameters remains unexamined.

29.

We now turn to the relief. Paragraph 5 of the impugned order expressly states that the CIT(E) could not reach satisfaction on the statutory parameters because of the documentary premise adopted by him. His order contains no substantive evaluation of the assessee’s objects or actual activities on the alternative evidentiary basis. The absence of an independent adverse finding is relevant in setting aside the rejection, but it cannot in these circumstances be treated as an affirmative finding that every condition stands fulfilled. A direction for unconditional renewal would require that further factual conclusion.

30.

We accordingly accept the assessee’s challenge to the legal basis of rejection, but consider a confined restoration necessary for completion of the inquiry which that error prevented. This course neither treats the absence of a deed as a defect requiring rectification nor requires the assessee to reproduce the documentary collection of the Vikhroli school. It requires a decision on this assessee’s records and on the conditions which section 12AB actually prescribes.

ITA No. 5715/MUM/2026 ST. JOSEPHS HIGH SCHOOL 31. The impugned order dated 30.03.2026 is set aside and the application filed on 26.09.2025 is restored to the file of the CIT(E). He shall evaluate the Schedule II application, the public-trust registration certificate, the earlier income-tax registrations and the other supporting material furnished by the assessee on their substantive evidentiary worth. Where a matter concerning origin, objects or governance requires clarification, he may call for the relevant findings or register entries from the public-trust proceedings or other available corroborative records, specifying the matter sought to be verified. He shall not insist upon creation of a fresh deed or procurement of a new scheme as a condition for considering renewal.

32.

The remaining inquiry shall be confined to the objects, genuineness of activities and compliance with the requirements of other laws material to achieving those objects, within section 12AB. Any proposed adverse inference must be put to the assessee with reference to the particular material or deficiency relied upon. The existing registration and the contention that there has been no change in objects or activities shall receive express consideration. The application shall not again be rejected merely because no separate trust deed, Memorandum of Association or scheme exists, or because the evidence of establishment also forms part of the statutory registration proceedings.

33.

After affording a reasonable opportunity of being heard, the CIT(E) shall pass a speaking order in accordance with these findings and grant renewal if the statutory conditions are satisfied. The effective period and duration shall be determined under the law applicable to the application, including the proviso inserted in section 12AB(1) by the Finance Act, 2025 where its conditions are fulfilled. Since the matter concerns renewal of an existing registration, it shall be disposed of expeditiously. These directions do not authorize an inquiry into unrelated matters beyond the statutory scope of registration.

ITA No. 5715/MUM/2026 ST. JOSEPHS HIGH SCHOOL 34. Registration does not, by itself, determine the availability or computation of exemption in a particular assessment year. Such questions shall be considered in the appropriate proceedings in accordance with law. No appeal concerning section 80G is before us and no direction under that provision is called for.

35.

Grounds Nos.1 to 3 and 5 are allowed to the extent of the legal conclusions recorded above and the consequential restoration. Ground No.4 is disposed of in terms of paragraph 25. Grounds Nos.6 to 8 are restored for consideration of the relevant evidence and the plea of consistency in accordance with our directions. Ground No.9 succeeds against rejection merely for want of a formal instrument; its wider contention restricting the inquiry to genuineness alone is not accepted. Ground No.10 requires no separate relief in view of the setting aside of the impugned order.

36.

In the result, the appeal filed by the assessee is allowed for statistical purposes.

Order pronounced in the open court on 29-10-2026.

Sd/- Sd/- SAKTIJIT DEY MAKARAND VASANT MAHADEOKAR VICE PRESIDENT ACCOUNTANT MEMBER Mumbai Dated: 29-10-2026 Tarun Kushwaha Sr. P.S.

ITA No. 5715/MUM/2026 ST. JOSEPHS HIGH SCHOOL

Copy to: ST. JOSEPHS HIGH SCHOOL, ST. JOSEPHS HIGH SCHOOL, M.G. ROAD, KANDIVALI-WEST, MUMBAI- 1 400 067, MUMBAI-400067, MAHARASHTRA CIT(EXEMPTION), MUMBAI, 601,6TH FLOOR, CUMBALLA HILL, 2 MTNL BUILDING, PEDDAR ROAD, CUMBALLA, MUMBAI-400026, MUMBAI-400026, MAHARASHTRA 3 THE PCIT / CIT, 4 THE D.R., ITAT, MUMBAI BENCH 5 GUARD FILE

More judgments on Section 12AB

All 6,249 judgments and leading authorities on Section 12AB →

Recent GST High Court judgments

Search GST case law →