ANUPINDER SINGH vs. COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX AND ANR.

PDF · subscribers
CWP/14724/1993HC Punjab & HaryanaPHHC01009323199319 July 2012Author: MR. JUSTICE AJAY KUMAR MITTAL,MR. JUSTICE GURMEET SINGH SANDHAWALIA6 pages
AI SummaryPartly Allowed

What did the High Court hold?

The High Court held that the writ petitions deserved to succeed. It observed that the petitioner received the enhanced compensation and interest between July and November 1989. In such circumstances, rejecting the petition on the ground that the assessee had the High Court's order by November 4, 1988, and thus interest could only be waived up to November 30, 1988, was incorrect. The Court reasoned that it was not disputed that the enhanced compensation and interest were received between July and November 1989, and the assessee did not know the exact amount to be declared in the income tax return prior to this receipt. Therefore, the assessee was entitled to a waiver of interest until the date of receipt of the enhanced compensation. The Commissioner's order was set aside to the extent that it did not grant a complete waiver of interest. The matter was remanded to the Commissioner for passing a fresh order in accordance with the observations made, holding that the Commissioner was not right in holding that there was no proper justification for delay after November 30, 1988.

What were the facts?

The petitioner, Anupinder Singh, was a co-owner of agricultural land acquired by the State Government on October 12, 1979. Initially determined compensation was enhanced by the District Judge and subsequently by the High Court to ₹2,42,000/- per acre by a judgment dated October 7, 1988. The State's appeal was dismissed on March 8, 1989. The petitioner received the enhanced compensation and interest in two installments between July and November 1989. Income tax returns for assessment years 1982-83 to 1988-89 were filed voluntarily. The Assessing Officer completed assessments and charged interest under Sections 139(8) and 217 of the Income Tax Act, 1961, and initiated penalty proceedings, which were later withdrawn. The Deputy Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals) deleted interest for assessment years 1982-83 to 1984-85. The petitioner sought waiver of interest and penalty under Section 273A for assessment years 1983-84 to 1988-89. The Commissioner waived interest only up to November 30, 1988, citing that the assessee knew the tax liability from the High Court judgment dated October 7, 1988, received on November 4, 1988, but filed returns on May 18, 1990.

What were the issues?

1. Whether the Commissioner erred in partly allowing the petition under Section 273A of the Income Tax Act, 1961, by waiving interest only up to November 30, 1988, and not in toto, considering the enhanced compensation and interest were received between July and November 1989? Assessee's Contention: The petitioner argued that since the exact amount of enhanced compensation and interest was not known in the earlier years when the returns were due, the entire interest charged under Sections 139(8) and 217 of the Act should have been waived. Reliance was placed on Shanti Sarup Sharma v. Commissioner of Income Tax, Apex Finance and Leasing Limited v. Commissioner of Income Tax, Smt. Parkash Devi v. Commissioner of Wealth Tax, and Ganesh Trading Co. v. Commissioner of Income Tax. The petitioner contended that once the conditions under Section 273A were fulfilled, the interest ought to have been waived completely. Revenue's Contention: The judgment does not explicitly record the revenue's arguments. However, the Commissioner's order, which was under challenge, indicated that the assessee had knowledge of the tax liability from the High Court judgment dated October 7, 1988, received on November 4, 1988, and therefore, interest was justifiable for the period after November 30, 1988.

Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?

Section 139(2),Section 148,Section 139(8),Section 217,Section 271(1)(a),Section 273(b),Section 273A

AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below

IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA AT CHANDIGARH Date of decision: 19.07.2012 Anupinder Singh -----Petitioner Vs. Commissioner of Income Tax, Patiala and another ----Respondents CORAM:- HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE AJAY KUMAR MITTAL HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE GURMEET SINGH SANDHAWALIA Present:- Mr. Rajesh Garg, Advocate for the petitioner. Ms. Urvashi Dhugga, Advocate for the respondents. Ajay Kumar Mittal,J. 1. This order shall dispose of Civil Writ Petition Nos. 14724 to 14727 of 1993 as learned counsel for the parties are agreed that the facts and the issue involved are identical in all the petitions. However, the facts are being taken from CWP No.14724 of 1993 which may be briefly noticed. 2. In CWP No.14724 of 1993, the petitioner was co-owner of agricultural land measuring 9 bighas 14 biswas situated in the revenue estate of Village Barewal, District Patiala. The said land was acquired by the State Government on 12.10.1979 and the compensation was determined by the Land Acquisition Collector.

The petitioner challenged the award before the District Judge, Patiala. Compensation was enhanced to ` 96,800/- per acre. On further appeal, the amount of compensation was enhanced to ` 2,42,000/- per acre by this Court vide judgment dated 7.10.1988. Aggrieved by the judgment, the State of Punjab filed LPA No.248 of 1989 in this Court which was dismissed on March 8, 1989. The petitioner received compensation from July to November 1989 in two installments. The petitioner filed income tax returns for the assessment years 1982-83 to 1988-89 prior to the issuance of notices either under section 139(2) or under section 148 of the Income Tax Act, 1961 (in short, “the Act”). The assessment was completed on the basis of income declared by the Assessing Officer on 30.4.1991. However, the Assessing Officer charged interest under sections 139(8) and 217 of the Act and also ordered to initiate penalty proceedings under section 271(1) (a) and 273(b) of the Act. The penalty proceedings ordered to be initiated were later on withdrawn. On appeal, the Deputy Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals) Chandigarh Range Chandigarh deleted the interest charged under sections 139(8) and 217 of the Act in respect of assessment years 1982-83 to 1984-85. The department went in appeal against the said order before the Tribunal. The petitioner moved a petition under section 273A for waiver of interest and penalty imposable/imposed for the assessment years 1983-84 to 1988- 89 on 9.1.1991. According to the petitioner, the returns for the relevant assessment years had been filed voluntarily and in good faith which were accepted by the Assessing Officer. The Commissioner of

Income Tax vide order dated 9.2.1993, Annexure P.2 held that the liability to pay tax was known to the assessee on 7.10.1988 and at best he should have filed the returns by 30.11.1988 when he had received the judgment of the High Court on 4.11.1988 but the same were filed on 18.5.1990, thus, there was reasonable cause for delay for the period upto 30.11.1988 and for the remaining period, there was no proper justification for delay in filing the returns. The Commissioner, thus, waived interest under Sections 139(8) and 217 of the Act upto 30.11.1988 only. Hence these petitions. 3. Learned counsel for the petitioners submitted that the enhanced compensation and interest thereon was received and it was on that basis that the returns were filed for the earlier years and since the assessees had not known the exact amount of enhanced compensation and the interest in those years, charging of interest under Sections 139(8) and 217 of the Act in toto should have been waived. He placed reliance upon a Division Bench judgment of this Court in Shanti Sarup Sharma v. Commissioner of Income Tax and another, (1999) 237 ITR 376 to submit that the compensation and interest received from the Government on a subsequent date which was not ascertained at the time of due date for filing of the return for a particular assessment year, the interest under sections 139(8) and 217 of the Act was liable to be waived. Learned counsel further submitted that the Commissioner had erred in partly allowing the petition filed under section 273A of the Act. Once the conditions as enumerated in Section 273A of the Act were fulfilled by the

assessee,interest under sections 139(8)/217 of the Act ought to have been waived completely. Reliance was also placed on judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Apex Finance and Leasing Limited v. Commissioner of Income Tax and others, (1994) 207 ITR 781, Division Bench judgment of this Court in Smt.Parkash Devi v. Commissioner of Wealth Tax, Jullundur, (1983) 141 ITR 122, and Single Bench judgment of this Court in Ganesh Trading Co. v. Commissioner of Income Tax and another, (2004) 265 ITR 495 in support of the contentions. 4. After hearing learned counsel for the parties and perusing the record, we find that the writ petitions deserve to succeed. 5. A Division Bench of this Court while considering the provisions relating to Section 18B of the Wealth Tax Act, 1957 which are pari materia to those in Section 273A of the Act, in Parkash Devi (Smt.) v. CWT (1983) 141 ITR 122, held that the following five conditions are required to be fulfilled:- “1) that the returns were filed by the petitioner prior to the issuance of a notice to her under sub-section (2) of section 14 of the Act; 2) that these were filed voluntarily and in good faith; 3) that the petitioner had made full and true disclosure of her net wealth; 4) that she had cooperated in the inquiry relating to the assessment of her net wealth; and 5) that she had paid or made satisfactory arrangements for the payment of the tax or interest payable in consequence of an order passed under the Act in respect of the relevant assessment years.”

6.

Further, this Court while delving into the scope of Section 273A of the Act in Shanti Sarup Sharma's case (supra) held as under:- “Section 273A of the Income Tax Act, 1961, empowers the Commissioner to reduce or waive interest and penalty. The power under Section 273A is discretionary. The Commissioner is given the discretion, when the requisite conditions envisaged by that section are satisfied, that he may waive or reduce the penalty or the interest imposable under the Act. However, the exercise of discretion cannot be either arbitrary or capricious and has to be judicious and objective. Section 273A does not confer absolute discretion upon the Commissioner to pass any order which he pleases to make. He is required to consider the application on the merits.” 7. Adjudicating the issue in favour of the petitioner, the Division Bench of this Court observed that the petitioner therein had received compensation in February 1991 and, therefore, there was no justification in charging interest for the earlier period. 8. Adverting to the factual matrix in the present case, the petitioner received the enhanced compensation during the period from July to November 1989 in two installments relating to assessment years 1982-83 to 1988-89. In such a situation, the rejection of the petition on the ground that the assessee had the order of the High Court available with him on 4.11.1988 and so the interest could be waived upto 30.11.1988, would not be correct. It was not disputed that the enhanced compensation and the interest was received between July to November 1989 and the assessee did not

know before that the amount which was to be depicted in the income tax return for purposes of tax. The assessee was, thus, entitled for waiver of interest till the date of receipt of enhanced compensation. 9. In view of the above, all the four petitions are partly allowed and it is held that the Commissioner was not right in holding that there was no proper justification for delay after 30.11.1988 in filing return for the assessment years in question. The order Annexure P.2 in all the petitions is set aside to that extent. The matter is remanded to respondent No.1 for passing fresh order in accordance with law keeping in view the observations made hereinabove.

(Ajay Kumar Mittal)

Judge July 19, 2012 (Gurmeet Singh Sandhawalia) 'gs' Judge

More judgments on Section 139(2)

All 31 judgments and leading authorities on Section 139(2) →

Recent GST High Court judgments

Search GST case law →