THE COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX TDS KANPUR and ANOTHER vs. SPICE MOBILITY LTD. NOIDA

PDF · subscribers
IAPL/295/2016HC AllahabadUPHC01177027201631 July 20187 pages
AI SummaryDismissed

What did the High Court hold?

The Tribunal was justified in setting aside the order passed by the CIT(Appeals) upholding the AO's order under Section 201(1)/201(1A). The Court reasoned that the Department had taken inconsistent stands. In the assessment proceedings under Section 143(3), the default for non-deduction of TDS on payments to regional distributors was treated as falling under Section 194-C, and this assessment order had attained finality, having been upheld by the Tribunal and this Court. However, in the subsequent proceedings under Section 201(1)/201(1A), the Department sought to treat the same non-deduction as a default under Section 194-H. The Court held that Section 201(1)/201(1A) does not authorize the Department to treat the same default under two different provisions. Pursuing the default under Section 194-H in Section 201 proceedings amounted to an impermissible review of the assessment order that had already become final. Therefore, the inconsistent stand of the Department was deemed erroneous and bad in law. The questions of law were answered against the Revenue and in favour of the assessee. The appeals were dismissed.

What were the facts?

The Revenue (Commissioner of Income Tax (TDS)) appealed against the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal's (Tribunal) order concerning assessment years 2009-10 and 2010-11. The respondent-assessee, Spice Mobility Ltd., made payments to regional distributors for advertisement and sales promotion. The Assessing Officer (AO) initially treated the non-deduction of TDS on these payments as a default under Section 194-C of the Income Tax Act, 1961, and this was upheld by the Tribunal and this Court. Subsequently, in proceedings under Section 201(1)/201(1A) of the Act, the Revenue treated the same non-deduction as a default under Section 194-H. The CIT(Appeals) upheld the AO's order treating the assessee as being in default under Section 194-H. The Tribunal, however, set aside the CIT(Appeals) order, finding it inconsistent with the earlier finalized assessment under Section 194-C.

What were the issues?

1. Whether the Tribunal was justified in ignoring that it had previously upheld the disallowance under Section 40(a)(ia) in the assessment order (Section 143(3)) while quashing the order under Section 201/201(1A) which treated the default under Section 194-H instead of Section 194-C? (Question of law) 2. Whether the Tribunal was justified in holding to the contrary when it is not disputed that the assessee had not deducted TDS as evident from its reply and the order under Section 201(1)/201(1A)? (Question of law) 3. Whether, on the facts and circumstances, the Tribunal was justified in law in holding that unless the assessee is treated as being in default for the specific amount of tax not deducted in the correct section (194-C instead of 194-H), the order under Section 201(1)/201(1A) cannot be sustained and therefore quashed? (Question of law) 4. Whether the finding in the assessment order under Section 143(3) can be a ground for deciding the fate of the order under Section 201(1)/201(1A) even when the default for non-deduction of TDS on certain payments has been decided in favour of the Department by the Tribunal? (Question of law) Assessee's Contention: The Tribunal correctly set aside the order under Section 201(1)/201(1A) because the Revenue was taking inconsistent stands by treating the same non-deduction of TDS under Section 194-C in assessment proceedings (which attained finality) and under Section 194-H in proceedings under Section 201. This amounted to reviewing a finalized assessment order. Revenue's Contention: The Tribunal was not justified in quashing the order under Section 201/201(1A) because the default under Section 194-H was a separate issue, and the assessee had indeed failed to deduct TDS. They relied on the fact that the assessee had not deducted TDS as evident from its reply and the order under Section 201(1)/201(1A).

Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?

Section 260-A,Section 40(a)(ia),Section 194-H,Section 194-C,Section 201,Section 201(1),Section 201(1A),Section 143(3)

AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below

Court No. - 35 1. Case :- INCOME TAX APPEAL No. - 295 of 2016 Appellant :- The Commissioner Of Income Tax (Tds) Kanpur & Another Respondent :- Spice Mobility Ltd., Noida Counsel for Appellant :- Gaurav Mahajan Counsel for Respondent :- R.S. Agarwal, Praveen Kumar Mishra Case :- INCOME TAX APPEAL No. - 19 of 2017 Appellant :- The Commissioner Of Income Tax(Tds),Kanpur And Another Respondent :- Spice Mobility Ltd. Counsel for Appellant :- Gaurav Mahajan Counsel for Respondent :- R.S. Agarwal,Praveen Kumar Mishra Hon'ble Bharati Sapru,J. Hon'ble Dinesh Kumar Singh,J. 1. The Revenue has preferred these appeals under Section 260-A of the Income Tax Act, 1961 (hereinafter referred to as “the Act”) against the common order dated 28th January, 2016 passed by the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal, Delhi Bench “B”, New Delhi (hereinafter referred to as 'Tribunal') in ITA No. 5074 and 5075/Del/2014 respectively. The Assessment Years are 2009-10 and 2010-11. 3. In the appeals, the following common questions of law have been formulated by the appellant- Revenue.

“1. Whether the Tribunal is justified in ignoring the fact that the Hon'ble Tribunal had itself upheld the disallowance u/s 40a(ia) in assessment order 143(3) on expenses incurred by the deductor– assessee while quashing the order u/s 201/201(1A) which was passed treating the default u/s 194-H instead of Section 194-C of the Act? Whether the Tribunal is justified in holding to the contrary when it is not in dispute that while making payments the assessee has not deducted TDS as is evident from the reply of the assessee and the discussion in the order u/s 201(1)/201 (1A) of the Act itself. 3. Whether on the facts and in the circumstances of the case the Tribunal is justified in law in holding that unless the assessee is treated as assessee in default in respect of specific amount of tax not deducted in the correct Section (194-C in this case) instead of u/s 194-H of the Act therefore the order u/s 201(1)/201(1A) of the Act can not be sustained and therefore quashed? 4. Whether the finding recorded in the assessment order passed u/s 143(3) of the Act can be taken as a ground for deciding the fate of the order passed u/s 201(1)/201(1A) of the Act even when substantively the default of the assessee for non deduction of TDS on certain payments has been decided in favour of the Department by the Tribunal itself?

4.

The respondent-assessee is a public limited company engaged in the business of trading of mobile phones, handset, manufacturing trading, servicing, and maintenance of computer hardware etc. 5. The Assessing Officer (hereinafter referred to as “A.O.”) conducted a spot enquiry on 23rd March, 2012 and during the course of verification proceedings he found that during the Financial Years 2008-09 and 2009-10 (Assessment Years 2009-10 and 2010-11) the respondent-assessee had made payments to its regional distributors towards advertisement and sales promotion of its products sold by them, but did not deduct TDS as per provisions of Section 194-H of the Act. 6. In view of the above, the A.O. treated the respondent as assessee in default for non-deduction of tax at source and calculated the consequent short deductions and interest as per Section 201(1) read with Section 201(1A) of the Act. The A.O. passed a composite order for the Assessment Year (hereinafter referred to “A.Y.”). 2009-10 and 2010-11 on 23rd March, 2013, thereby raised demand of Rs.91,41,176.00 and 64,97,046.00 respectively for the two A.Ys.

7.

Against the aforesaid order passed by the A.O., respondent-assessee preferred an appeal before the Commissioner of Income Tax, Income Tax Office, Ayakar Bhawan, A-2D, Sector-24, Noida (hereinafter referred to as “C.I.T. (Appeals)”). The C.I.T. (Appeals), after examining agreement between respondent- assessee and its regional distributors, held that the relationship between the respondent-assessee and its regional distributors was one of principle- agent and, therefore, the payment made to the regional distributors by the respondent-assessee for marketing, advertising and brand promotion attracted the provisions of Section 194-H of the Act and the respondent-assessee was required to deduct tax at source against the payment made to the regional distributors towards advertisement and sales promotion related services. The C.I.T. (Appeals) upheld the order passed by the A.O. treating the respondent-assessee as assessee in default and passing the order under Section 201(1)/201(1A) of the Act. 8. Aggrieved by the aforesaid order passed by the C.I.T. (Appeals) the respondent-assessee filed

an appeal before the Tribunal. The Tribunal had held that the assessment proceedings were completed considering the default of TDS qua Section 194-C of the Act, but in proceedings under Section 201 of the Act, default for the same payment, had been considered under Section 194- H. The respondent-assessee had already challenged the assessment proceedings in respect of default of TDS qua Section 194-C of the Act and he lost upto Tribunal and the Tribunal vide order dated 29th December, 2014 had upheld the order passed by the A.O. treating the default under Section 194-C of the Act. The Tribunal, therefore, set-aside the order passed by the C.I.T. (Appeals) upholding the order of A.O. u/s 201/201(1A) of the Act. 9. Against the said order dated 29th December, 2014, the respondent-assessee had filed appeal before this Court being Income Tax Appeal No.99 of 2015. This Court vide order dated 13th May, 2015 had dismissed the appeal of the respondent-assessee. The learned counsel for the respondent-assessee during the course of hearing of these appeals has informed the Court that the respondent-assessee had preferred SLP before the

Supreme Court against the order dated 13th May, 2015 passed by this Court in Income Tax Appeal No. 99 of 2015 and the same is pending consideration before the Supreme Court. 10. We have heard Mr. Gaurav Mahajan, learned counsel appearing for the appellant-department, and Mr. Praveen Kumar Mishra, learned counsel appearing for the respondent-assessee. 11. It is clear that during the assessment proceedings the Department had treated the default of the respondent-assessee in not deducting the tax at source on the payment made to its regional distributors for advertisement and brand promotion etc. as default under Section 194-C of the Act and the assessment proceedings were finalized. The assessment order has been upheld by this Court. Now in the proceedings under Section 201 of the Act, the Department is treating the same as default under Section 194-H of the Act. Provisions of section 201(1)/201(1A) do not authorize the Department to treat the same default under two provisions. The proceedings under Section 201(1)/201(1A) of the Act for treating the default of the respondent-assessee under Section 194-H amounts to reviewing the assessment order which had attained

finality. The inconsistent stand of the Department in assessment proceedings and the proceedings under Section 201 of the Act is wholly erroneous and bad in law. We, therefore, uphold the impugned order passed by the Tribunal and dismiss both the appeals. 12. The questions of law are answered against the Revenue and in favour of the respondent-assessee. Order Date :- 1.8.2018 MVS Chauhan/-

Recent GST High Court judgments

Search GST case law →