ASHUTOSH KHARE vs. CENTRAL BOARD OF DIRECT TAXES AND ANOTHER

PDF · subscribers
WTAX/308/2021HC AllahabadUPHC01064691202114 July 20212 pages
AI SummaryDismissed

What did the High Court hold?

The Tribunal noted the revenue's submission, based on instructions and the CBDT Circular No. 04 of 2021, that the department would cancel the settlement certificate dated January 30, 2021, and issue a fresh one. This fresh certificate would treat the petitioner's case as an assessment case, not a 'search case', and reflect a revised computation of the settlement amount. The circular clarified that a 'search case' pertains to assessments or reassessments made under specific sections (143(3)/144/147/153A/153C/158BC) on the basis of a search under Section 132 or requisition under Section 132A. The Tribunal found that in view of the revenue's fair statement and proposed action, no cause of action survived at that juncture. The writ petition was accordingly dismissed, with liberty to the petitioner to pursue afresh if a cause of action still existed.

What were the facts?

The petitioner, Ashutosh Khare (HUF), is aggrieved by a certificate of settlement issued by revenue authorities under the Vivad se Vishwas scheme. The revenue had classified the petitioner's case as a 'search case' for determining the settlement amount, which the petitioner contended was incorrect as it was a reassessment case. The petitioner challenged the certificate on this ground. The revenue, after reviewing its position and in light of a new CBDT Circular No. 04 of 2021 dated March 23, 2021, agreed to cancel the existing certificate and issue a fresh one.

What were the issues?

1. Whether a reassessment case can be treated as a 'search case' for the purposes of determining the settlement amount under the Vivad se Vishwas scheme, and if so, under which provisions of the Income-tax Act, 1961? The assessee argued that a reassessment case should not be classified as a 'search case' under the Vivad se Vishwas scheme, as this classification incorrectly led to a higher settlement amount. The assessee relied on the distinction between reassessment and search cases. The revenue, initially classifying the case as a 'search case', later revised its position. It relied on CBDT Circular No. 04 of 2021, dated March 23, 2021, which clarified the definition of a 'search case' for the Vivad se Vishwas scheme. The revenue stated that based on this circular, the petitioner's case would be treated as an assessment case.

Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?

Section 132,Section 132A,Section 143(3),Section 144,Section 147,Section 153A,Section 153C,Section 158BC

AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below

Court No. - 3 Case :- WRIT TAX No. - 308 of 2021 Petitioner :- Ashutosh Khare Respondent :- Central Board Of Direct Taxes And Another Counsel for Petitioner :- Ashish Bansal,Shalini Goel Counsel for Respondent :- Bharat Ji Agrawal (Sr. Advocate),Gaurav Mahajan Hon'ble Naheed Ara Moonis,J. Hon'ble Saumitra Dayal Singh,J. 1. Heard Ms. Shalini Goel, learned counsel for the petitioner and Sri Gaurav Mahanjan, learned appearing for the respondents. 2. On oral prayer made by the learned counsel for the petitioner and in the light of the statement of the learned counsel for the revenue, Ms. Shalini Goel is permitted to correct cause title of the case to disclose the correct name of the petitioner as Ashutosh Khare (HUF). 3. Office to correct the record accordingly. 4. The petitioner is aggrieved by the fact that while issuing certificate of settlement reached between the parties, the revenue authorities have treated the petitioner's case as a 'search case' and determined the settlement amount accordingly. According to the petitioner, a reassessment case could not have been treated as a 'search case', therefore, the certificate issued has been challenged, on that ground. 6. Upon instructions received and placed on record by Mr. Mahajan, it has been informed that the revenue has revisited its position and the CBDT has issued a Circular No.04 of 2021, dated 23.03.2021. By that Circular, it has been provided in para 4 as below:- "Several representations have been received seeking further clarity with regard to the classification of a case as a 'search case' for the

purposes of Vivad se Vishwas. The matter has been examined. In order to remove any uncertainty in this regard, and in exercise of powers under Section 10 and 11 of Vivad se Vishwas, it is hereby clarified that a 'search case' means an assessment or reassessment

made

under

sections 143(3)/144/147/153A/153C/158BC of the Income-tax Act in the case of a person referred to in section 153A or section 153C or section 158BC or section 158BD of the Income-tax Act on the basis of search initiated under Section 132, or requisition made under section 132A of the Income-tax Act. The FAQ No.70 of circular 21/2020 stands modified to this extent." 7. He further states, in light of the binding Circulation issued by the CBDT, the department will now cancel the certificate of settlement dated 30.01.2021 and issue a fresh certificate of settlement reached disclosing the revised computation of the settlement amount, treating the petitioner's case as an assessment case only. 8. In view of such fair statement made by Mr. Mahajan, no cause of action survives at present. Accordingly, the writ petition is dismissed, leaving it open to the petitioner to pursue afresh, if cause survives. Order Date :- 15.7.2021 Abhilash

More judgments on Section 132

All 16,113 judgments and leading authorities on Section 132 →

Recent GST High Court judgments

Search GST case law →