MOHD. ARSHAD KHAN vs. UNION OF INDIA AND ANOTHER

PDF · subscribers
WTAX/982/2022HC AllahabadUPHC01121235202231 July 20222 pages
AI SummaryRemanded

What did the High Court hold?

The High Court observed that the respondents' approach in dealing with the petitioner's matter appeared arbitrary and whimsical, causing him to run from pillar to post for a refund of Rs. 38,543/- for Assessment Year 2016-17. The court noted that instead of disposing of his application for treating the return as valid, the respondents were keeping the matter pending. The court expressed hope and trust that the Principal Commissioner of Income Tax, Gorakhpur, would look into the matter and ensure the petitioner's grievance is redressed by passing an appropriate order in accordance with the law within two weeks from the date of the order. The writ petition was disposed of with these directions.

What were the facts?

The petitioner, Mohd. Arshad Khan, filed his income tax return for Assessment Year 2016-17 claiming a refund of Rs. 38,543/-. His return was marked as defective, and he learned of this much later. He applied for his return to be treated as valid. The Income Tax Department informed him that his return was invalid and advised him to move an application under Section 139(9) of the Income Tax Act, 1961. Instead, he filed a writ petition before the High Court. The High Court, on July 25, 2022, granted the respondent a week to obtain instructions on the appropriate authority and provision for the petitioner to approach for redressal. On August 1, 2022, the respondent produced written instructions indicating the application for condonation of delay was governed by Section 119/119(2)(b) of the IT Act, 1961, and CBDT Circular No. 09/2015. The petitioner's application for condonation of delay was filed on April 25, 2022, and forwarded to the Joint Commissioner of Income Tax, Range-1, Gorakhpur, for a report. The circular suggests disposal within six months from the end of the month the application is received.

What were the issues?

1. Whether the approach of the respondents in dealing with the petitioner's grievance regarding his defective income tax return and refund claim for Assessment Year 2016-17 has been arbitrary and whimsical, leading to undue delay in redressal? Assessee's Contention: The petitioner argued that his return was marked defective, and he came to know of it late. He sought to have his return treated as valid to claim his refund. He approached the High Court as he was being directed to move applications under Section 139(9) after a significant delay. Revenue's Contention: The respondent department, through written instructions, indicated that the process for condonation of delay in filing the income tax return and refund claim is governed by Section 119/119(2)(b) of the Income Tax Act, 1961, and CBDT Circular No. 09/2015. The petitioner's application for condonation of delay was filed on April 25, 2022, and was being processed, with a recommendation for disposal within six months from receipt.

Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?

Section 139(9),Section 119,Section 119(2)(b)

AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below

Court No. - 3 Case :- WRIT TAX No. - 982 of 2022 Petitioner :- Mohd. Arshad Khan Respondent :- Union Of India And Another Counsel for Petitioner :- Firdos Ahmad,Mahesh Kumar Counsel for Respondent :- A.S.G.I. Hon'ble Surya Prakash Kesarwani,J. Hon'ble Jayant Banerji,J. Heard Sri Firdos Ahmad, learned counsel for the petitioner and Sri Garurav Mahajan, learned Senior Standing Counsel for respondent - Income Tax Department. On 25.07.2022, this court passed the following order: "Heard learned counsel for the petitioner and Sri Gaurav Mahajan, learned counsel for the respondent No.2. Grievance of the petitioner is that he filed his return of income for the Assessment Year 2016-17 claiming refund of Rs.38,543/- but his return was marked as defective about which he came to know much later. Therefore, he submitted an application for treating his return as a valid return. Learned counsel for the petitioner submits that on the complaint made on Grievance Cell it was intimated that his return was invalid. Therefore, he may move an application under Section 139(9) of the Income Tax Act, 1961 before the jurisdictional authority. However, the petitioner has filed the present writ petition. Sri Gaurav Mahajan, learned counsel for the Income Tax Department prays or and is granted a week's time to obtain instructions as to which authority and under which provision, the petitioner may approach for redressal of his grievance, i.e. for for validating his income tax return for the Assessment Year, 2016-17 and to get the refund. Put up as a fresh case before the appropriate bench on 01.08.2022." Today, Sri Mahajan, learned Senior Standing Counsel has produced before us a copy of the written instruction dated 30.07.2022 given by the Office of Principal Commissioner of Income Tax, Gorakhpur through the Income Tax Officer (Hq/Admn.), which is kept on record. The aforesaid instruction reads as under: "Kind reference is invited to your letter dated 28.07.2022 on the subject cited above. 2. In the context of information desired by the Hon'ble High Court vide its Order dated 25.07.2022 in the case of above mentioned assessee, it is being submitted that condonation of delay in filing the Income Tax Return is being governed under section 119/119 2(b) of the I.T. Act 1961 (copy enclosed). Subsequently, the CBDT vide its Circular No. 09/2015 circulated vide its office letter F.No. 312/22/2015-OT dated 09.06.2015 has also prescribed competent authority in terms of monitory limit as well as necessary instruction to subordinate authorities while considering the application of condonation of delay in filing refund claim and claim of carry forward losses under section 119 (2)(b) (copy enclosed). 3. In this regard, it is being also intimated that the assessee named Mohd. Arshad Khan has filed his application for condonation of delay on dated 25.04.2022 and as per point no.5 of the Circular No.09/2015, his application has been forwarded to the Joint Commissioner of Income Tax, Range- 1, Gorakhpur to submit the requisite report i.e. income loss declared and or refund claimed is correct and genuine and also that the case is of genuine hardship on merits. Further, the assessee has filed his application for condonation of delay on dated 25.04.2022 & as per point no. 3 of the above mentioned circular, his application may be disposed of within the period upto October 2022 (as far as possible, within the period of six month from the end of the month in which application is received by competent authority ). 4. Therefore, keeping in view the facts mentioned supra, I have hen directed to request you to kindly take necessary action in order to furnish the information desired by the Hon'ble High Court Allahabad. Further, I have also been directed enclose herewith all the relevant documents as stated above in respect of the said case for your kind perusal and further necessary action."

Prima facie, the approach of the respondents even in dealing with petty matters like the present one, appears to be totally arbitrary and whimsical. The petitioner is running from pillar to post to get a refund of Rs.38,543/- relating to Assessment Year 2016-17 and instead of disposing of his application for treating the return as valid, the respondents are keeping the matter pending. We hope and trust that the respondent No.2/ The Principal Commissioner of Income Tax Gorakhpur shall look into the matter and shall ensure that grievance of the petitioner is redressed by passing an appropriate order in accordance with law within two weeks from today. With the aforesaid directions, the writ petition is disposed of. Order Date :- 1.8.2022 NLY Digitally signed by NAND LAL YADAV Date: 2022.08.02 10:20:38 IST Reason: Location: High Court of Judicature at Allahabad

More judgments on Section 139(9)

All 275 judgments and leading authorities on Section 139(9) →

Recent GST High Court judgments

Search GST case law →