RAJEEV KUMAR AGARWAL vs. UNION OF INDIA AND ANOTHER

PDF · subscribers
WTAX/737/2022HC AllahabadUPHC01077800202223 May 20224 pages
AI SummaryPartly Allowed

What did the High Court hold?

The Tribunal held that the impugned order dated 30.11.2021, rejecting the petitioner's immunity application under Section 270AA, was unsustainable. The Tribunal found that the AO issued notice on 29.11.2021, requiring a reply by 30.11.2021, and on the very next day, passed the order rejecting the application. The petitioner had specifically requested an opportunity for further substantiation and a personal hearing in his reply dated 30.11.2021. The AO's order merely stated that the reply was 'not found satisfactory' without providing any specific reasons. This action was found to be in gross violation of the principles of natural justice and the statutory mandate of the proviso to Section 270AA(4), which requires an opportunity of being heard before rejecting an application. Consequently, the penalty order dated 18.03.2022, passed subsequent to the rejection of the immunity application, was also quashed. The AO was directed to pass a fresh order on the immunity application within one month, affording a reasonable opportunity of hearing. If the immunity application is allowed, the appeal filed by the petitioner under Section 246A will stand withdrawn. If rejected, the AO can pass a penalty order after providing a reasonable opportunity of hearing.

What were the facts?

The petitioner, Rajeev Kumar Agarwal, filed a writ petition challenging an order dated 30.11.2021 rejecting his application for immunity under Section 270AA of the Income Tax Act, 1961, and a subsequent penalty order dated 18.03.2022 under Section 270A. The petitioner had deposited the entire tax and penalty within one month of the demand notice and applied for immunity on 09.10.2021. A notice on this application was issued on 29.11.2021, requiring a reply by 30.11.2021. The petitioner submitted a reply on 30.11.2021, requesting further substantiation and a personal hearing. Despite this, the Assessing Officer (AO) rejected the immunity application on 30.11.2021. Subsequently, the petitioner filed an appeal under Section 246A against the assessment order for AY 2019-20, and a penalty was imposed. The petitioner stated he was unaware that the immunity order could be challenged in the High Court and undertook to withdraw his appeal if the writ petition succeeded.

What were the issues?

1. Whether the order dated 30.11.2021 rejecting the petitioner's immunity application under Section 270AA of the Income Tax Act, 1961, is liable to be quashed for violating the principles of natural justice and the statutory mandate of Section 270AA(4). Assessee's Contention: The assessee argued that the order rejecting the immunity application was passed in violation of the proviso to Section 270AA(4), which mandates an opportunity of being heard before rejection. The assessee contended that despite requesting a personal hearing, the AO passed an unreasoned order merely stating the reply was unsatisfactory, thereby breaching the principles of natural justice and the statutory requirement for reasons. Revenue's Contention: The judgment does not record any specific arguments made by the revenue in response to the assessee's contentions regarding the rejection of the immunity application. However, the AO's order itself stated that the assessee's reply was considered but not found satisfactory.

Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?

Section 270AA,Section 270A,Section 246A

AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below

Court No. - 3 Case :- WRIT TAX No. - 737 of 2022 Petitioner :- Rajeev Kumar Agarwal Respondent :- Union Of India And Another Counsel for Petitioner :- Abhinav Mehrotra,Satya Vrata Mehrotra Counsel for Respondent :- A.S.G.I.,Gaurav Mahajan,Gopal Verma Hon'ble Surya Prakash Kesarwani,J. Hon'ble Jayant Banerji,J. 1. Heard Sri Abhinav Mehrotra, learned counsel for the petitioner, Shri Gopal Verma, learned Central Government Standing Counsel for the respondent no. 1 and Sri Krishna Agarwal, learned counsel for the rest of the respondents/Income Tax Department. 2. An amendment application dated 24.05.2022 has been filed today. With the consent of the learned counsel for the parties, Amendment Application is allowed. 3. Necessary amendment be carried out during the course of the day. 4. This writ petition has been filed praying to quash the order dated 30.11.2021, rejecting the immunity application of the petitioner submitted under Section 270 AA and also to quash the penalty order dated 18.03.2022, under Section 270 A of the Income Tax Act, 1961. 5. Undisputedly, the petitioner deposited the entire tax and penalty within one month from the date of demand notice. He submitted an application for immunity from penalty under Section 270AA of the Act, 1961 on 09.10.2021. The notice on the aforesaid application was issued by the respondent no.2 on 29.11.2021, observing as under :- “You are also informed that if no reply is received in this office on or before fixed date i.e. 30.11.2021 (04:00PM), penalty order will be

passed without any further correspondence on the basis of material available on record.” 6. The petitioner hurriedly submitted the reply to the aforesaid notice dated 29.11.2021. In paragraph 4.3 of his reply the petitioner specifically requested as under :- “Your honour is requested to allow opportunity to substantiate further and assessee also requests that thereafter a personal hearing be also fixed.” 7. Despite the aforesaid request of the petitioner and also despite the fact that notice was given on 29.11.2021, the respondent no.2 passed the order on 30.11.2021 rejecting the immunity application of the petitioner. Since the immunity application of the petitioner was rejected, therefore, subsequently on 01.03.2022, the petitioner filed an appeal under Section 246A of the Act, 1961 against the A.O. for the A.Y. 2019-20. Subsequently, the penalty under Section 270A of the Act 1961 has been imposed by the impugned order dated 18.03.2022. 8. In paragraph Nos. 2 and 3 of the affidavit accompanying the writ petition, the petitioner has stated as under : “2. That, the petitioner has filed an Income Tax Appeal before the Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals) assailing the Order of Assessment Dt. 25.09.2021. This was filed under the advice of our Chartered Accountant to save limitation and the Petitioner was not aware that the Order Dt.30.11.2021 can be challenged before the Hon’ble High Court under Article 226 of the Constitution of India. This position of law transpired to Petitioner upon legal advice subsequently received. 3. That, the Deponent further unconditionally undertakes that in the case Writ Petition filed by the Petitioner succeeds,he shall NOT prosecute the appeal filed by him challenging the Order of Assessment Dt. 25.09.2021 and shall unconditionally WITHDRAW the appeal with due intimation to this Hon’ble Court.” 9. Sub-section (4) of Section 270 AA of the Income Tax Act, 1961 reads as under : “(4) The Assessing Officer shall, within a period of one month from the end of the month in which the application under sub-section (1) is received, pass an order accepting or rejecting such application: 2

Provided that no order rejecting the application shall be passed unless the assessee has been given an opportunity of being heard.” 10. From perusal of the facts as noted above, it is evident that notice on the immunity application of the petitioner was issued by the respondent no.2 only on 29.11.2021 and on the very next day the impugned order rejecting the immunity application was passed with the following observations : “In this regard, reply dated 30.11.2021 was received. The reply of the assessee is considered, however, it is not found satisfactory. All the contentions put forward by the assessee are rejected assessment order is passed following the principles of natural justice and after duly considering the facts of the case.” 11. It is further relevant to mention that the petitioner specifically requested in his reply/letter dated 30.11.2021 that an opportunity of hearing be afforded. However, the respondent no.2 arbitrarily passed the impugned order recording the reasons only in one line that the reply is not found satisfactory. Thus, the impugned order dated 30.11.2021 is not only in breach of the proviso to Sub Section (4) of Section 270 AA but it is also unreasoned inasmuch as it merely records that “the reply is not found satisfactory”. Therefore, the impugned order cannot be said to be an order containing reasons. Not only the principles of natural justice but also the statutory mandate of proviso to sub-section (4) of Section 270 AA have been grossly violated by the respondent no.2. Such an act of the respondent no.2 is deprecated. 12. For the reasons aforestated, the impugned order dated 30.11.2021 passed by the respondent no.2 under Section 270 AA of the Act, 1961 can not be sustained and is hereby quashed. Consequently, the penalty order dated 18.03.2022, under Section 270 A of the Act, 1961, passed by the respondent no.2 can also not be sustained and is quashed. The respondent no.2 is directed to pass an order afresh on the immunity application of the petitioner, in accordance with law, within one month from today, after affording reasonable opportunity of hearing to the petitioner. In the event 3

the respondent no.2 finds that immunity application is liable to be allowed, in terms of the aforequoted affidavit of the petitioner, the appeal filed by the petitioner before the appellate authority under Section 246A of the Act, 1961 against the Assessment Order shall automatically stand withdrawn. In the event the respondent no.2 rejects the immunity application of the petitioner then the respondent no.2 shall have liberty to pass penalty order under Section 270 A of the Act, 1961, in accordance with law, after affording reasonable opportunity of hearing to the petitioner. 13. Writ petition is allowed to the extent indicated above. Order Date :- 24.5.2022/vkg 4 Digitally signed by VINOD KUMAR GOSWAMI Date: 2022.05.27 11:01:36 IST Reason: Location: High Court of Judicature at Allahabad

More judgments on Section 270AA

All 187 judgments and leading authorities on Section 270AA →

Recent GST High Court judgments

Search GST case law →