COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX GHAZIABAD vs. M/S PROGRESSIVE TOOLS AND COMPONENTS PVT. LTD.

PDF · subscribers
IAPL/30/2010HC AllahabadUPHC01195051201008 January 20184 pages
AI SummaryDismissed

What did the High Court hold?

The Tribunal held that HSCI cannot be given a different treatment regarding its status as a company in which the public is substantially interested, simply because its shares are held to the extent of 99.99% by Honda Japan. The Tribunal reasoned that Honda Japan, being listed on the stock exchange, would be considered a company in which the public is substantially interested. Consequently, its Indian subsidiary, HSCI, should also be treated as a company in which the public has substantial interest. Therefore, the provisions of Section 2(22)(e) of the Act were not attracted, and the loan given by HSCI to the assessee could not be treated as a deemed dividend. The Tribunal further emphasized the principle of judicial discipline, citing the Supreme Court decision in Sundarjas Kanyalal Bhatija Vs. Collector, Thane, Maharashtra, AIR 1990 SC 261, stating that coordinate benches of the Tribunal should refrain from passing contrary orders in similar matters and should follow the view of previous benches. The Tribunal found the view taken by its coordinate benches to be justified. The question of law was answered in favour of the assessee and against the department. The appeal was dismissed.

What were the facts?

The assessee, M/s Progressive Tools And Components Pvt. Ltd., received a loan of Rs. 3,00,00,000/- from Honda Siel Cars India Ltd. (HSCI) during the assessment year 2003-04. The interest on this loan was Rs. 6,83,768/-. The entire amount was repaid within the same financial year. HSCI is a subsidiary of Honda Japan (HJ), with HJ holding 99.90% of its shares. HSCI is considered a closely held company. The Assessing Officer (AO) treated this loan as a deemed dividend under Section 2(22)(e) of the Income Tax Act, 1961, making an addition of Rs. 3,06,83,768/-. The Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals) confirmed this addition. The Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT) deleted this addition. The Revenue (Commissioner of Income Tax, Ghaziabad) has appealed this ITAT order dated 8.5.2009.

What were the issues?

1. Whether, on the facts and circumstances of the case, the ITAT was legally justified in deleting the addition of Rs. 3,06,83,768/- made by the AO on account of deemed dividend under Section 2(22)(e) of the Income Tax Act, 1961, considering that Honda Siel Cars India Ltd. (HSCI) is a subsidiary of Honda Japan (HJ) holding 99.90% shares, and the loan given by HSCI to the assessee was a deemed dividend, as confirmed by the CIT(A). Assessee's Contention: The ITAT held that HSCI, being a subsidiary of a listed company (Honda Japan) and thus a company in which the public is substantially interested, does not attract the provisions of Section 2(22)(e). The Tribunal relied on decisions of coordinate benches and the Apex Court regarding judicial discipline, stating that a coordinate bench should follow the view of a previous bench in similar matters. Revenue's Contention: The Revenue argued that HSCI is a closely held company and the loan given to the assessee, where the beneficial owner of the assessee company (Honda Japan) held more than 10% voting power in HSCI and was substantially interested in the assessee company through intermediary concerns holding 50% of its share capital, should be treated as a deemed dividend under Section 2(22)(e). The Revenue contended that the CIT(A) had correctly confirmed the addition.

Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?

Section 2(22)(e),Section 2(17)

AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below

Court No. - 35 Case :- INCOME TAX APPEAL No. - 30 of 2010 Appellant :- Commissioner Of Income Tax, Ghaziabad Respondent :- M/S Progressive Tools And Components Pvt. Ltd. Counsel for Appellant :- S.S.C. I.T.,Piyush Agrawal Counsel for Respondent :- R.R. Kapoor Hon'ble Bharati Sapru,J. Hon'ble Neeraj Tiwari,J. Heard Sri Dhananjay Awasthi, learned counsel for the appellant and Sri R.R. Kapoor, learned counsel for the department. This appeal has been filed by the department against an order of Tribunal dated 8.5.2009 for the assessment year 2003-04. The question of law referred to is as under. “Whether on the facts and the circumstances of the case, as per the law the Hon'ble ITAT was legally justified in deleting the addition made by the AO of Rs. 3,06,83,768/- on account of deemed dividend as per provisions of Section 22/(22)) of the IT Act because the Honda Siel Cars Ltd. (India) is subsidiary company of Honda Japan having shares holdings of 99.90% and the loan given by said company HSCI is a deemed dividend which was correctly confirmed CIT (A), Ghaziabad.” The facts of the case are that the assessee company received loan of Rs. 3,00,00,000/- from Honda Siel Cars India Ltd (hereinafter termed as HSCI) during the relevant period under consideration. The interest element amounted to Rs. 6,83,768/- and the entire amount of debt along with interest was repaid during the same financial year only. The lender, i.e. HSCI is practically a wholly owned subsidiary of Honda Japan (hereinafter termed as HJ), wherein the equity to the extent of 99.90% of the total paid up share capital of the HSCI is held by HJ. At the first instance, the lender, i.e. HSCI is a closely held company in which public is not substantially interested. Thus, the HSCI is covered within the ambit of Section 2 (17) of the Income Tax Act, 1961 wherein the "company" means any Indian company and thus duly fulfills the first

criteria of lender being a "company" the payment of which may attract the provisions of section 2(22)(e) of the Act. The HJ is a registered company as well as beneficial share holder of HSCI in India. Further, the HJ along with its associate/group/subsidiary concerns is holding more than 20% of the share capital of another foreign company i.e. F-Tech Inc (herein after referred to as FTI). The foreign company i.e. F-Tech Inc. has yet another wholly owned subsidiary in Japan which is Fukuda Engineering Company Ltd. (FECL) Yet another associate/group concern of the same group is Nichimen Inc (NI) located in Japan. All the above stated three Japanese companies are inextricably linked and part and parcel of the Japanese Conglomerate HONDA JAPAN (HJ). The three Japanese companies as mentioned above (F- Tech Inc, Fukuda Engg. and Nichimen Inc.) together held 50% of the share capital of the assessee company during the relevant period under consideration. These shares of the assessee company have been moving from the Indian promoters to the Japanese associates in the recent years. The shareholding pattern has rapidly changed especially in the year under consideration as well as the immediately preceding year as the holding of the Associated companies of Honda Japan have acquired almost 50% equity in the Assessee company. Thus from the above share holding pattern as well as information available on record, it can be logically concluded that the beneficial ownership of shares of the assessee company vested with HJ i.e. Honda Japan. The HJ held more than 10% of the voting powers in HSCI and in turn was substantially interested in the assessee company through its intermediary concerns, which held 50% of the total paid up share capital of the assessee

company. The money which flowed from HSCI to the assessee company was for the ultimate benefit of HJ only. With the back ground of the above said undisputed facts, the next step is to ascertain the requisite conditions before which a payment by a company to its beneficial (and not only registered) shareholder/s can be regarded as dividend within the meaning of sub-clause (e) of section 2(22). The question, therefore, was whether the assessee could avail the benefits of the provisions of Section 2 (22) (e) of the Act. The Tribunal while considering the matter held that it was of the view that HSCI cannot be given a different treatment in regard to its status of company being a company in which public is substantially interested just because its shares are held to the extent of 99.99% by Honda Japan. Obviously, Honda Japan is a company which is listed in the Stock Exchange and is a company which would have to be held as a company in which the public is substantially interested in view of its listing of stock exchange, and the Indian subsidiary of Honda Japan being HSCI was also liable to be held to be a company in which public has substantial interest and in view of this also the provisions of Section 2 (22) (e) of the Act are not attracted and consequently even on this ground the loan given by HSCI to the assessee company cannot be treated as deemed dividend. In similar circumstances, the coordinate bench of the Tribunal has given relief to another assessee with regard to the benefits available under Section 22/(22) of the IT Act. The Tribunal has set aside the findings of the A.O. as well as the CIT(Appeals) and has remanded the matter back for reconsideration.

It is well settled that while resolving a dispute, if one bench of the tribunal takes a certain view, then another coordinate bench of the Tribunal should refrain from passing contrary order in the similar matter and if it disagrees with the view of the previous bench, the later should refer to larger bench for proper adjudication, in order to maintain judicial discipline. Reliance may be placed on a decision of Hon'ble Apex Court in the case of Sundarjas Kanyalal Bhatija Vs. Collector, Thane, Maharashtra, AIR 1990 SC 261. Having heard learned Counsel for the parties and having perused the material on record as well as the impugned order of the Tribunal, we are of the view that the view taken by the Tribunal is completely justified especially in view of many decisions of the coordinate benches of the Tribunal as well as the decisions upto the Apex Court wherein it has been held that the decisions taken by the coordinate benches have to be followed by the Tribunal while adjudicating similar set of cases. In view of above, the question of law is answered in favour of the assessee and against the department. There is no merit in this appeal. It is accordingly dismissed. Order Date :- 9.1.2018 Arvind

More judgments on Section 2(22)(e)

All 1,908 judgments and leading authorities on Section 2(22)(e) →

Recent GST High Court judgments

Search GST case law →