COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX -II vs. M/S MUSTANG LEATHER PVT. LTD.

PDF · subscribers
IAPL/752/2012HC AllahabadUPHC01174651201218 February 20182 pages
AI SummaryDismissed

What did the High Court hold?

The Tribunal held that a deemed dividend under Section 2(22)(e) of the Income Tax Act, 1961, could only be assessed in the hands of a person who is a shareholder of the lender company, not in the hands of a borrowing concern in which such shareholder is a member or partner having substantial interest. The Tribunal noted that the assessee-company was admittedly not a shareholder of the lender company. Therefore, the addition made on account of deemed dividend was deleted. The Tribunal relied on the Delhi High Court's decision in CIT v. Ankitech (P) Ltd. & Ors., which held that the legal fiction created by Section 2(22)(e) enlarges the definition of dividend but does not extend to broadening the concept of shareholders. The circular relied upon by the Revenue was also held to be not binding. The question of law was answered against the revenue and in favour of the assessee. The appeal was dismissed.

What were the facts?

The appeals were filed by the Commissioner of Income Tax-II (Revenue) against an order of the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT) dated May 24, 2012, for the assessment year 2007-08. The ITAT had deleted an addition made by the Revenue on account of deemed dividend under Section 2(22)(e) of the Income Tax Act, 1961. The transaction in question was between the assessee company, M/s Mustang Leather Pvt. Ltd., and M/s Treadstone Ltd. The Revenue treated this transaction as a loan and advance, thereby attracting the provisions of deemed dividend. The assessee company was not a shareholder of the lender company, but both companies had common shareholders. The appeals were heard together as the controversy was identical.

What were the issues?

1. Whether the ITAT was correct in law in deleting the addition made on account of deemed dividend under Section 2(22)(e) of the Income Tax Act, 1961, by treating the transaction between the assessee company and M/s Treadstone Ltd as a commercial/trade transaction and not a loan and advance, particularly when such a transaction is defined as deemed dividend under Section 2(22)(e)? Assessee's Contention: The ITAT rightly held that a deemed dividend under Section 2(22)(e) can only be assessed in the hands of a shareholder of the lender company, not in the hands of a borrowing concern in which such shareholder has a substantial interest. The assessee company was not a shareholder of the lender company. Revenue's Contention: The transaction, despite being between two companies with common shareholders and the assessee not being a shareholder of the lender, should be treated as a deemed dividend under Section 2(22)(e). The Revenue likely relied on the deeming fiction of the section to extend its application beyond direct shareholders.

Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?

Section 2(22)(e),Section 260-A

AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below

Court No. - 35 Case :- INCOME TAX APPEAL No. - 752 of 2012 Appellant :- Commissioner Of Income Tax -Ii Respondent :- M/S Mustang Leather Pvt. Ltd. Counsel for Appellant :- Subham Agarwal,S.S.C. I.T. With Case :- INCOME TAX APPEAL No. - 304 of 2015 Appellant :- Commissioner Of Income Tax -Ii Respondent :- M/S Mustang Leather Pvt. Ltd. Counsel for Appellant :- Shambhu Chopra Hon'ble Bharati Sapru,J. Hon'ble Neeraj Tiwari,J. Heard Sri Shubham Agrawal, learned Counsel for the appellant. As the controversy involved in both these appeals is identical, therefore, both the appeals are being heard and decided by a common judgement and order treating this appeal as a leading case. This is an appeal filed by the revenue under Section 260-A of the Income Tax Act, 1961 against an order of the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal dated 24.05.2012 for the assessment year 2007-08. The question of law sought to be answered are hereunder:- "1. Whether the ITAT was correct in law in deleting the addition made on account of deemed dividend u/s 2 (22) (e) of I.T. Act, 1961 by treating the transaction between the assessee company and M/s Treadstone Ltd as Commercial/Trade transaction and not loan and advances, particularly when such a transaction is defined as deemed dividend u/s 2(22) (e)." The Tribunal has taken a view rightly that a deemed dividend could only have been assessed in the hands of a person who is shareholder of the lender company and not in the hands of the borrowing concern in which such shareholder is a member or partner having substantial interest. Admittedly, in the present case the assessee-company was not a shareholder of the lender company. But, in this case both the lender and the borrower have common shareholders.

This view has recently been taken by Delhi High Court in the case of CIT v. Ankitech (P) Ltd. & Ors reported in (2011) 242 CTR. For ready reference we quote paragraph nos. 25 and 28 of the said judgement :- "25. Further, it is an admitted case that under normal circumstances, such a loan or advance given to the shareholders or to a concern, would not qualify as dividend. It has been made so by legal fiction created under Section 2 (22) (e) of the Act. We have to keep in mind that this legal provision relates to ―dividend‖. Thus, by a deeming provision, it is the definition of dividend which is enlarged. Legal fiction does not extend to ―shareholder‖. When we keep in mind this aspect, the conclusion would be obvious, viz., loan or advance given under the conditions specified under Section 2(22) (e) of the Act would also be treated as dividend. The fiction has to stop here and is not to be extended further for broadening the concept of shareholders by way of legal fiction. It is a common case that any company is supposed to distribute the profits in the form of dividend to its shareholders/members and such dividend cannot be given to non-members. The second category specified under Section 2(22) (e) of the Act, viz., a concern (like the assessee herein), which is given the loan or advance is admittedly not a shareholder/member of the payer company. Therefore, under no circumstance, it could be treated as shareholder/member receiving dividend. If the intention of the Legislature was to tax such loan or advance as deemed dividend at the hands of ―deeming shareholder‖, then the Legislature would have inserted deeming provision in respect of shareholder as well, that has not happened. Most of the arguments of the learned counsels for the Revenue would stand answered, once we look into the matter from this perspective. .............. 28. Insofar as reliance upon Circular No. 495 dated 22.09.1997 issued by Central Board of Direct Taxes is concerned, we are inclined to agree with the observations of the Mumbai Bench decision in Bhaumik Colour (P) Ltd. (supra) that such observations are not binding on the Courts. Once it is found that such loan or advance cannot be treated as deemed dividend at the hands of such a concern which is not a shareholder, and that according to us is the correct legal position, such a circular would be of no avail." The question of law is, therefore, answered against the revenue and infavour of the assessee. The appeal is dismissed as above. No costs. Order Date :- 19.2.2018 S.P.

More judgments on Section 2(22)(e)

All 1,908 judgments and leading authorities on Section 2(22)(e) →

Recent GST High Court judgments

Search GST case law →