COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX CEN vs. SHRI JAI KUMAR JAIN

PDF · subscribers
ITA/139/2008HC RajasthanRJHC02039745200823 May 20176 pages
AI SummaryDismissed

What did the High Court hold?

The High Court agreed with the ITAT's view. It held that all questions raised in the appeal were questions of fact, which had been decided by the ITAT, the final fact-finding authority, against the Department. Therefore, no interference was required. The ITAT's reasoning, as quoted, indicated that additions were deleted because they were based on papers not found from the assessee, not confronted to the assessee during search, or lacked corroborative evidence. Specifically, for unrecorded sales and transactions with Shri Atul Jain, the ITAT found that additions were made based on documents found from third parties without proper confrontation or corroboration, citing the principle that mere entries in loose sheets or documents found from third parties, without supporting evidence, lack evidentiary value. The ITAT also deleted the addition for investment in unrecorded sales and transactions with Shri Atul Jain on similar grounds. The interest under Section 158BFA(1) was deleted by the ITAT, and the High Court found no reason to interfere. The High Court concluded that all issues were answered in favour of the assessee and against the Department.

What were the facts?

This appeal by the Commissioner of Income Tax (Central) challenges a judgment of the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT) which dismissed the Department's appeal and allowed the assessee's appeal. The ITAT had significantly reduced the total income assessed by the Assessing Officer (AO) and confirmed by the Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals) [CIT(A)]. The original assessment involved substantial additions to the assessee's income, including unexplained cash, jewellery, sale of loose diamonds, unrecorded sales, investments in unrecorded sales, and unrecorded transactions with Shri Atul Jain. The ITAT also deleted interest charged under Section 158BFA(1) of the Income Tax Act, 1961.

What were the issues?

The High Court framed ten substantial questions of law. These include: 1. Whether the ITAT was justified in reducing the total income from Rs. 1,34,65,680/- to Rs. 5,03,199/-, despite the assessee admitting or failing to explain most additions? (Section 132(4A)) 2. Whether the ITAT was justified in not confirming the addition of Rs. 3,18,370/- on account of unexplained cash found during search, based on the son's statement and lack of book entries? (Section 132(4A)) 3. Whether the ITAT was justified in not confirming the addition of Rs. 4,43,693/- for unexplained jewellery, given the assessee's failure to explain and change of stand? (Section 132(4A)) 4. Whether the ITAT was justified in not confirming the addition of Rs. 86,46,406/- for unexplained sale of loose diamonds, when the purchaser denied transactions and family members were unaware? (Section 132(4A)) 5. Whether the ITAT was justified in not confirming the addition of Rs. 86,46,406/- for unexplained sale of loose diamonds, when it was a colourable device to invest unaccounted money? (Section 132(4A)) 6. Whether the ITAT was right in not confirming additions of Rs. 2,39,876/- and Rs. 95,705/- for profit on unrecorded sales, as they were not reflected in books and unexplained? (Section 132(4A)) 7. Whether the ITAT was justified in deleting the addition of Rs. 9,43,300/- for investment in unrecorded sales, despite the assessee admitting them as unrecorded? (Section 132(4A)) 8. Whether the ITAT was right in not confirming additions of Rs. 5,55,810/- and Rs. 3,00,000/- for unrecorded transactions with Shri Atul Jain, who admitted them? (Section 132(4A)) 9. Whether the ITAT was justified in deleting interest of Rs. 20,99,285/- under Section 158BFA(1), given the late filing of the block period return and mandatory nature of the provision? (Section 158BFA(1)) 10. Whether the ITAT was justified in allowing telescoping without establishing the nexus between income earned and investment/expenditure? (Section 132(4A)) The appellant (Revenue) argued that the ITAT was not justified in deleting additions made by the AO and confirmed by the CIT(A), highlighting the assessee's failure to explain transactions and the basis of the AO's findings. The respondent (Assessee) did not have its arguments recorded in detail in the provided text, but the ITAT's reasoning, as quoted, suggests the assessee's arguments likely focused on the lack of proper evidence and confrontation of documents. The ITAT relied on the case of JCR Bhandari vs. ACIT.

Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?

Section 132(4A),Section 158BFA(1)

AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below

HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE FOR RAJASTHAN BENCH AT JAIPUR D.B. Income Tax Appeal No. 139 / 2008 Commissioner Of Income Tax Central ----Appellant Versus Shri Jai Kumar Jain through LRs

----Respondent _____________________________________________________ For Appellant(s) : Mr. Anuroop Singhi with Mr. N.S. Bhati For Respondent(s) : Mr. Ananat Kasliwal _____________________________________________________ HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE K.S. JHAVERI HON'BLE DR. JUSTICE VIRENDRA KUMAR MATHUR Judgment 23/05/2017 1. By way of this appeal, the appellant has challenged the judgment of the Tribunal whereby the Tribunal has dismissed the appeal of the Department and allowed the appeal filed by the assessee. 2. While admitting the appeal, this Court framed the following substantial question of law: “(i) Whether the ITAT was justified in reducing the total income of the assessee from Rs. 1,34,65,680/- to merely Rs. 5,03,199/-, inspite of the fact that majority of the additions were admitted or not explained by the assessee? (ii) Whether the ITAT was justified in not confirming the addition of Rs. 3,18,370/- made on account of unexplained cash found during search, when the addition was made on the basis of statement of son of the assessee and the fact that it was nor recorded in the books of accounts? (iii) Whether the ITAT was justified in not confirming the addition of Rs. 4,43,693/- made on account of unexplained jewellery found during the search, when the assessee itself during the assessment has failed to explain the same and changed his own stand? (iv) Whether the ITAT was justified in not confirming the addition of Rs. 86,46,406/- made on account of

(2 of 6) [ITA-139/2008] unexplained sale of loose diamonds, when the purchaser itself has denied the transactions and the family members, who have sold the diamond were also not aware of the said transaction? (v) Whether the ITAT was justified in not confirming the addition of Rs. 86,46,406/- made on account of unexplained sale of loose diamonds, when it was prove that the said transaction was nothing but a colourable device to invest the unaccounted money of the assessee in the business? (vi) Whether the ITAT was right & justified in not confirming the addition of Rs. 2,39,876/- and Rs. 95,705/- made on account of profit on unrecorded sales, when the said transactions was not reflected in the books of accounts and the assessee itself failed to provide any explanation to the same? (vii) Whether the ITAT was justified in deleting the entire addition of Rs. 9,43,300/-, made on account of investment in unrecorded sales, inspite of the fact that the assessee in his own statements have admitted these as unrecorded. (viii) Whether the ITAT was right & justified in not confirming the addition of Rs. 5,55,810/- and Rs. 3,00,000/- made on account of unrecorded transactions found with Shri Atul Jain, who himself has admitted the said transactions with the assessee? (ix) Whether the ITAT was right and justified in deleting the interest of Rs. 20,99,285/- charged u/s 158BFA(1) ignoring the fact that admittedly the return for the block period was filed late by the assessee as specified in the notice u/s158BC and also considering the fact that the provisions of Section 158BFA(1) are mandatory in natur? (x) Whether the ITAT was justified in Assessing Officer to provide the benefit of telecoping to the assessee without considering the fact that the nexus between income earned and investment/expenditure made is required to be established?” 3. Heard learned counsel for the parties. 3.1 Counsel for the appellant has taken us to the order of AO as well as CIT (A) and thereafter to the order of the Tribunal. He referred to the following findings of the authorities on different substantial questions which can be summarized by the following table:

(3 of 6) [ITA-139/2008] SQOL NO. A.O. CIT(A) ITAT 1. ITAT was justified in reducing income 1,34,65,680 to merely 5,03,199 (Page No. 180) 2. CASH Addition of Rs.3,18,370 unexplained cash (page no. 39) CASH Relief of Rs.291460 and 26910 addition sustained (Page no. 189, para 7) CASH Deleted the addition (page no. 229, para 6) 3. Jewellery Addition made 4,43,693 (page 44 to 52) Jewellery Deleted Rs.3,13,301 of jewellery and deleted Rs.1,30,092 of silver (page no. 191 para no. 12,13) Jewellery Deleted the addition (page no 150, para 44) 4. Loss of diamond Addition of Rs.86,46,406/- (page no. 137) Deleted page no.201(para 22) Deleted Page no.258 (Para 49) 5. Do Do Do 6. Unrecorded Sale Addition-2,39,876 (Page No. 141 point 5) Addition -95,705/- (Page no.150) Unrecorded Sale Deleted-1,19,938 out of 2,39,876(page no.208, Para 35) Deleted-95,705/- (Page no.210, Para 38) Unrecorded Sale Deleted-2,39,876 (page no. 234 to 236, Para 18,19,20) Deleted -95,705/- (page no.239, Para28,29,30) 7. Investment made on account unrecorded sale Addition of Rs.9,43,300 (Page no. 154) Investment made on account unrecorded sale Addition by AO:- Rs.9,43,300 CIT confirmed the Addition:-8,67,836 Relief granted:- 75,464 page 212 para 44 Investment made on account unrecorded sale Deleted (page no. 237 to 238, para no.25 amd 26) 8. Unrecorded transaction found Deleted:-5,55,810 (page no. 216, para Page no 243 point 36

(4 of 6) [ITA-139/2008] with Shri Atul Jain Addition:-5,55,810 (Page no. 172) Addition:-3.00,000 (Page no. 177) 54) Deleted:- 3,00,000 (Page no. 218, para 58) 9. Section 158BFA(1) interest of Rs.20,99,285 Deleted Deleted 3.2 However, in view of the observations made by the Tribunal which reads as under: “18. The brief facts of these ground are that the AO held that above loose paper shows transaction of sales of Rs. 23,98,760/-. Since assessee has not replied on this paper, he applied rate of 10% to make addition of Rs. 2,39,876/-. the ld. CIT (A) held that the said transaction relate to purchase of goods in name of Valia Steel Industries. He assumed that profit arising out of this deal must have been shared by both the parties and therefore addition of Rs. 1,19,938/- was confirmed and balance deleted. 28. The brief facts of this ground are that the AO observed that page 53 of annexure A-24 shows weight of 95,705 Kg. Which is unrecorded sales. He took its sale value at Rs. 9,57,050/- and applying profit rate of 10% made addition of Rs. 95,705/-. 36. We have considered the rival submission and perused the material on record. We find that addition is made on the basis of the papers found from Shri Atul Jain. In search these papers were not confronted to the assessee. From the assessment order it is borne out whether Atul Jain stated these papers as pertaining to the assessee. No presumption can be drawn against the assessee u/s 132 (4A) of the Income Tax Act 1961 in respect of a paper not from him. No addition can be made on the basis of documents found from the third party and in the absence of corroborative evidence as held in case of JCR Bhandari vs. ACIT 79 TTJ 1 (Jd) where it was held as under: “In our considered opinion, it may hardly be denied that the India Evidence Act or for that matter the Statutory provisions of the Indian Evidence Act may not be applicable strictly to the proceedings under the I.T. Act but the basic/broad principle of the law or

(5 of 6) [ITA-139/2008] evidence do apply to the said proceedings, it is settled position of law that the slips or loose sheets do not fall within the purview of ‘book’. An entry in a bookof accounts, maintained in the regular course of busies, is relevant to be considered in respect of the transactions reflected thereby, no doubt, but is not conclusively decisive thereof or of the matter contained therein or liability reflected thereby, and much less so an entry in a loose sheet. It is only some other evidence whether in the form of statement of the author of the entry or the statement of some other person connected with the transactions contained in the entry, or in the some other form, supportive of the entry, ehich lends weight/credence to the entry in the book, depending upon the trustworthiness of the said deponent or reliability of the said entry assumes the nature of reliable evidence on the basis of which some addition can be made/sustained. An entry in a loose sheet is of a still feeble nature, and an entry in a loose sheet found in the possession of another/third person is much more so. As such a mere entry is a loose sheet, by itself, without sworn statement of the learned persons, supportive of the entry, hardly has any evidentiary value, worth the name. The legal position being as emerging above, we are of the considered opinion that no liability can be fastened nor can an addition be made on the basis of a mere entry in a loose sheet without there being some further trustworthy/reliable corroborative evidence lending credence to such an entry”. 4. We are in complete agreement with the view taken by the Tribunal. All questions raised in this appeal are questions of fact and the same are decided by the final fact finding authority against the Department in which no interference is required. 3.3 The issues are answered in favour of assessee and against the Department. 4. The appeal stands dismissed. (VIRENDRA KUMAR MATHUR),J. (K.S. JHAVERI),J.

(6 of 6) [ITA-139/2008] /bm gandhi 179

More judgments on Section 132(4A)

All 641 judgments and leading authorities on Section 132(4A) →

Recent GST High Court judgments

Search GST case law →