RAM KANWAR vs. COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX GURGAON HARYANA

PDF · subscribers
ITA/81/2015HC Punjab & HaryanaPHHC01110184201509 July 20153 pages
AI SummaryPartly Allowed

What did the High Court hold?

Regarding issue (i), the High Court held that the question of service of notice under Section 143(2) was a pure question of fact and not a question of law. The Court noted that the assessee had not disputed the service of the notice in previous appeals before the CIT (Appeals) and even before the Tribunal, where it was sought to be raised for the first time in 2009. The original and fresh assessment orders, as well as the CIT (Appeals) orders, mentioned the service of the notice. Therefore, the Tribunal was justified in declining to raise this ground. The appeal on this issue was dismissed. Regarding issue (ii), the Court noted that the assessee had filed a rectification application before the Tribunal which was pending. The assessee was granted liberty to file a fresh appeal against the impugned order of the Tribunal and the order on the rectification application if desired. Thus, this issue was not decided on merits by the High Court. Regarding issue (iii), the Court held that this was also not a question of law. The assessee claimed a deduction of Rs. 19,83,350/- for commission and expenditure related to property sale brokering. The Tribunal, observing a lack of complete details, allowed a deduction of Rs. 10 lacs liberally, acknowledging that some expenditure would have been incurred. The Court found no perversity or irrationality in the Tribunal's order. The appeal on this issue was dismissed.

What were the facts?

This appeal by the assessee, Ram Kanwar, is against an order of the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (Tribunal) dated August 8, 2014, which upheld the assessment in part. The matter pertains to the block period from April 1, 1987, to February 18, 1997. The assessee sought to raise three substantial questions of law before the High Court. The first question concerned the issuance and service of a mandatory notice under Section 143(2). The second question related to the chargeability of exempt income to the share of a coparcener in the context of bank deposits arising from the sale of ancestral HUF property. The third question pertained to the allowance of expenses relatable to income charged under Section 5 read with Sections 29, 57, and 158BC of the Act.

What were the issues?

The Tribunal had to decide three questions: 1. Whether the additional ground of appeal regarding the issuance and service of a mandatory notice under Section 143(2) was sustainable and validly declined to be raised for the first instance before the Tribunal, in pursuance to ACIT & another V Hotel Blue (2010) 3 SCC 259? 2. Whether the 'chargeability of exempt income' to the share of a coparcener, falling in bank deposits (Rs. 50 lacs) from the sale of ancestral HUF property and admitted by the AO, is required to be considered while determining undisclosed income under Section 158B(b) of the Act? 3. Whether, while arriving at the chargeable income under Section 5 read with Sections 29, 57, and 158BC of the Act, there is a requirement under the 'authority of law' for granting the allowance for the deduction of expenses relatable to the 'income charged'? Assessee's contentions: For issue (i), the assessee contended that the notice under Section 143(2) was not served and sought to raise this as an additional ground before the Tribunal, relying on ACIT & another V Hotel Blue. For issue (ii), the assessee argued that exempt income should be considered when determining undisclosed income. For issue (iii), the assessee argued for the allowance of expenses relatable to the income charged. Revenue's contentions: No specific contentions for the revenue were recorded for issues (i) and (iii). For issue (ii), the judgment notes that a rectification application by the assessee before the Tribunal was pending.

Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?

Section 143(2),Section 158B(b),Section 5,Section 29,Section 57,Section 158BC

AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below

IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA AT CHANDIGARH

ITA-81-2015 (O&M) Date of decision:- 09.07.2015

Ram Kanwar ...Appellant Versus

Commissioner of Income Tax, Gurgaon. ...Respondent

CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE S.J. VAZIFDAR, ACTING CHIEF JUSTICE

HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE G.S. SANDHAWALIA

Present: Mr. S.K. Yadav, Advocate,

for Mr. Sachin Bhardwaj, Advocate,

for the appellant. * * * * S.J. VAZIFDAR, A.C.J. (ORAL)

This is an appeal against the order of the Tribunal dated 08.08.2014 upholding the assessment in part.

The matter pertains to the block period 01.04.1987 to 18.02.1997. 2. The appellant/assessee contends that the following three issues raise substantial questions of law:- “(i) Whether under the facts & circumstances of the case, additional ground of appeal qua the issuance & service of mandatory notice u/s 143(2) is sustainable and (or) validly declined to be raised for the first instance before the Tribunal in pursuance to ACIT & another V Hotel Blue (2010) 3 SCC 259?

(ii) Whether the ‘chargeability of exempt income’ to the share of coparcener as falling in pursuance bank deposits (Rs. 50 lacs) qua the sale of ancestral HUF property & admitted by AO is required to be considered while determining undisclosed income u/s 158B(b) of the Act?

(iii) Whether under the facts & circumstances of the case, while arriving at the chargeable income u/s 5 read with Sections 29, 57, 158 BC of the Act, there is a requirement under the ‘authority of law’ for granting the allowance for the deducting of expenses relatable to the ‘income charged’?”

AMODH SHARMA 2015.07.10 15:55 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this document chandigarh

ITA-81-2015 (O&M) 2ٰ Re: Question (i) 4. The first question sought to be raised is purely one of fact. The appellant contended that the notice under Section 143(2) of the Income Tax Act, 1961 (in short the Act) had not been served upon him. However, as rightly noted by the Tribunal, the original assessment order mentions the service of the notice under Section 143(2) of the Act. It is important to note that the assessee filed an appeal before the CIT (Appeals), but did not dispute the service of the notice under Section 143(2) of the Act upon him. It is even more important to note that the CIT (Appeals) set aside the assessment order and directed the Assessing Officer to pass a fresh order. Even at that stage, the assessee did not raise any grievance about not having been served with the notice. Furthermore, the fresh assessment order also mentions the service of the notice under Section 143(2) of the Act upon the assessee. The assessee filed an appeal against this order before the CIT (Appeals), but even at that stage did not dispute the service of the notice under Section 143(2) of the Act. Even in the appeal before the Tribunal, this grievance was not raised. Instead, it was sought to be raised for the first time only in the year 2009 by way of an additional ground. In these circumstances, it would have been surprising if the Tribunal had accepted the contention of the assessee that he had not been served with the notice. 5. In these circumstances, it is only a pure question of fact and raises no question of law. Re: Question (ii) 6. The assessee has filed a rectification application before the Tribunal which is pending.

The appellant will be at liberty to file a fresh appeal against the impugned order of the Tribunal and the order on the application that may be passed, if he so desires. AMODH SHARMA 2015.07.10 15:55 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this document chandigarh

ITA-81-2015 (O&M) 3ٰ Re: Question (iii) 6. Question (iii) also does not raise a question of law. The assessee claimed a deduction of ` 19,83,350/- on account of commission and expenditure incurred by him while brokering/arranging transactions regarding the sale of various properties. The Tribunal observed that the assessee had not maintained complete details of the expenditure incurred in this respect. The Tribunal has in fact taken a liberal view and allowed a deduction of ` 10 lacs while observing that the assessee would have incurred some expenditure towards brokerage, commission, conveyance, documentation etc. There is nothing perverse or irrational in the order of the Tribunal in this regard. 7. The appeal in respect of questions (i) and (iii) is, therefore, dismissed. The appellant, however, is at liberty to file a fresh appeal against the order that may be passed by the Tribunal upon the rectification application.

(S.J. VAZIFDAR) ACTING CHIEF JUSTICE

(G.S. SANDHAWALIA)

JUDGE 09.07.2015 Amodh AMODH SHARMA 2015.07.10 15:55 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this document chandigarh

Recent GST High Court judgments

Search GST case law →