SURJEET JAISWAL HUF vs. ASSISTANT COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX, CIRCLE 34(1), DELHI & ANR.

PDF · subscribers
W.P.(C)/4458/2022HC DelhiDLHC01313398202216 March 2022Author: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE MANMOHAN,HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE DINESH KUMAR SHARMA16 pages
AI SummaryAllowed

What did the High Court hold?

The Delhi High Court held that the reassessment notices issued under Section 148 of the Income Tax Act, 1961, post-March 31, 2021, without following the procedure prescribed in the substituted Sections 147 to 151 (effective from April 1, 2021) were invalid. The Court found that the Explanations A(a)(ii)/A(b) to the Notifications dated March 31, 2021, and April 27, 2021, were ultra vires the Taxation and Other Laws (Relaxation of Certain Provisions) Act, 2020, and therefore, bad in law and void. The Court reasoned that the Finance Act, 2021, introduced a new procedure for reassessment, and the executive could not use administrative powers to undermine parliamentary supremacy or frustrate the operation of these substituted provisions. The Court explicitly disagreed with the views of the Chhattisgarh High Court in Palak Khatuja and agreed with the Allahabad and Rajasthan High Courts in Ashok Kumar Agarwal and Bpip Infra Private Limited, respectively. The Court concluded that the substitution made by the Finance Act, 2021, was applicable, as the new Act manifested an intention to destroy the old procedure. Consequently, the impugned reassessment notices were quashed, and the writ petitions were allowed. The Revenue was granted liberty to take further steps if permitted by law.

What were the facts?

The petitioners, various entities including Macquarie Aerospace Finance Limited, HKAC Leasing IGO No 7 Limited, and others, filed writ petitions before the Delhi High Court. The common issue in these petitions pertained to reassessment notices issued under Section 148 of the Income Tax Act, 1961. The notices were issued post-March 31, 2021, without adhering to the procedure stipulated in the substituted Sections 147 to 151 of the Income Tax Act, 1961, which became effective from April 1, 2021. The Revenue contended that certain Explanations in Notifications issued on March 31, 2021, and April 27, 2021, allowed for the continuation of the old procedure. The assessment years are not explicitly stated for all petitioners but the dispute centers on notices issued after the procedural changes.

What were the issues?

1. Whether reassessment notices issued under Section 148 of the Income Tax Act, 1961, post-March 31, 2021, are valid if they do not comply with the procedure prescribed in the substituted Sections 147 to 151 of the Act, effective from April 1, 2021? (Question of law turning on Sections 147-151 of the Income Tax Act, 1961 and Section 3(1) of the Taxation and Other Laws (Relaxation of Certain Provisions) Act, 2020). Assessee's Contention: The petitioners argued that since the impugned notices were issued after March 31, 2021, they must comply with the newly substituted Sections 147 to 151. They relied on the judgment in Mon Mohan Kohli vs. Assistant Commissioner of Income Tax & Anr. to support their claim that the Explanations in the Notifications were ultra vires. Revenue's Contention: The Revenue contended that the Explanations in the Notifications dated March 31, 2021, and April 27, 2021, saved the notices issued under the old procedure. They argued that Section 6 of the General Clauses Act saved notices issued under Section 148 post-March 31, 2021, and that the substitution made by the Finance Act, 2021, was not applicable to past Assessment Years. They also argued that the Covid-19 pandemic justified the continued operation of the old provisions.

Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?

Section 147,Section 148,Section 151,Section 3(1)

AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below

Heard together (2 matters)

W.P.(C) 4389/2022
W.P.(C) 4390/2022

Read from the judgment's own cause title. This page is filed under one of them.

$~23-26, 29, 31, 36-46, 48, 50, 51, 53, 54, 56, 58-65, 68-73 * IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI

4389/2022 APPL.13081/2022,

APPL.13082/2022

MACQUARIE AEROSPACE FINANCE 5092 LIMITED

(FORMERLY KNOWN AS AWAS 5092 IRELAND LIMITED)

ASSISTANT COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX CIRCLE 2 (2)

(1) INTERNATIONAL TAXATION & ORS.

4390/2022 APPL.13083/2022,

APPL.13084/2022

MACQUARIE AEROSPACE FINANCE 5090 LIMITED

(FORMERLY KNOWN AS AWAS IRELAND LEASING SEVEN

LIMITED)

ASSISTANT COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX CIRCLE 2

(2)(1) (INTERNATIONAL TAXATION), NEW DELHI AND ORS.

4391/2022 APPL.13085/2022,

APPL.13086/2022

HKAC LEASING IGO NO 7 LIMITED

4392/2022 APPL.13087/2022,

APPL.13088/2022

MACQUARIE AEROSPACE FINANCE 5027 LIMITED

FORMERLY KNOWN AS AWAS IRELAND LEASING SIX

LIMITED

ASSISTANT COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX CIRCLE 2 2 1

INTERNATIONAL TAXATION & ORS.

W.P.(C) 4395/2022 & CM APPL.13094/2022, CM APPL.13095/2022

NARESH RAWAT (HUF)

INCOME TAX OFFICER, WARD 36(1) DELHI & ANR.

W.P.(C) 4398/2022 & CM APPL.13111/2022, CM APPL.13112/2022

AVA MERCHANDISING SOLUTIONS PRIVATE LIMITED

Mr. Rishabh Jain, Advocate.

DY. COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX, CIRCLE -1(1) NEW

DELHI

W.P.(C) 4409/2022 & CM APPL.13144/2022, CM APPL.13145/2022

ORIX AVIATION SYSTEMS LIMITED

W.P.(C) 4412/2022 & CM APPL.13159/2022, CM APPL.13160/2022

HKAC LEASING (IGO NO. 9) LIMITED

4421/2022 APPL.13225/2022,

APPL.13226/2022, CM APPL.13227/2022

INDIA FINSEC LIMITED

Mr. Siddharth Ranka with Mr. Mishal

Johari and Mr. Mani Bhadra Jain,

INCOME TAX OFFICER WARD 10-1 & ANR. ..... Respondents

W.P.(C) 4426/2022 & CM APPL.13240/2022, CM APPL.13241/2022

EMESS REALCON PRIVATE LIMITED

ACIT, CIRCLE 7(1), DELHI AND ANR.

W.P.(C) 4427/2022 & CM APPL.13242/2022, CM APPL.13243/2022

MAYANK GOEL

INCOME TAX OFFICER, WARD 58(1) DELHI AND ANR.

W.P.(C) 4428/2022 & CM APPL.13244/2022, CM APPL.13245/2022

MANJU SOMANI

ITO, WARD 70(1), DELHI & ANR.

Mr. Sunil Kumar Agarwal, Advocate

W.P.(C) 4429/2022 & CM APPL.13246/2022, CM APPL.13247/2022

TUSHAR RAWAT

Mr. Sarthak Jain with Mr. Vishal

Malik and Mr. Linoy Varghese,

ASSISTANT COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX, CIRCLE 22(2)

DELHI & ANR.

Mr. Sunil Kumar Agarwal, Advocate.

W.P.(C) 4430/2022 & CM APPL.13246/2022, CM APPL.13247/2022

VEER HANUMAN BUILDPRO PRIVATE LIMITED ..... Petitioner

Mr. Siddharth Ranka with Mr. Mishal

Johari and Mr. Mani Bhadra Jain,

INCOME-TAX OFFICER, WARD 26(1), DELHI & ANR.

Mr. Puneet Rai, Sr. Standing Counsel

with Mr. Karan Pandey, Advocate.

W.P.(C) 4431/2022 & CM APPL.13251/2022, CM APPL.13252/2022

KULDIP SINGH GULATI

Mr. Neeraj Yadav, Advocate.

DEPUTY COMMISSIONER INCOME TAX & ANR. ...Respondents

Mr. Sunil Agarwal, Sr. Standing

Counsel with Mr. Tushar Gupta,

Mr. Samarth Chaudhari, Advocates.

W.P.(C) 4432/2022 & CM APPL.13253/2022

M AND ME SYSTEMS PVT LTD

DCIT CIRCLE 16 (1), DELHI

Mr. Abhishek Maratha, Advocate.

W.P.(C) 4434/2022 & CM APPL.13258/2022, CM APPL.13259/2022

HKAC LEASING (IGO NO. 8) LIMITED

DEPUTY COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX, CIRCLE 2 (1)(1),

(INTL.TAX. ), NEW DELHI AND ORS.

W.P.(C) 4437/2022 & CM APPL.13263/2022, CM APPL.13264/2022

MAHESH KUMAR VERMA

Mr. Neeraj Yadav, Advocate.

DEPUTY COMMISSIONER INCOME TAX & ANR.

W.P.(C) 4439/2022 & CM APPL.13266/2022, CM APPL.13267/2022

ISH REALTORS PRIVATE LIMITED

Mr. Gaurav Jain with Ms. Akshita

Goyal and Mr. Shubham Gupta,

INCOME TAX OFFICER, WARD 12(1), DELHI ..... Respondent

W.P.(C) 4441/2022 & CM APPL.13269/2022, CM APPL.13270/2022

HARISH BANSAL

UNION OF INDIA & ORS.

Mr. Manish Kumar, Advocate for

UOI.

W.P.(C) 4443/2022 & CM APPL.13273/2022

IPHITO REAL ESTATE PRIVATE LIMITED

OFFICE OF THE ASSISTANT COMMISSIONER OF INCOME

TAX & ANR.

W.P.(C) 4444/2022 & CM APPL.13274/2022, CM APPL.13275/2022

RAKESH RAWAT

INCOME TAX OFFICER, WARD 21(1) DELHI & ANR.

Mr. Puneet Rai, Sr. Standing Counsel

with Mr. Karan Pandey, Advocate.

W.P.(C) 4446/2022 & CM APPL.13278/2022, CM APPL.13279/2022

TUSHAR RAWAT HUF

INCOME TAX OFFICER, WARD 36(1) DELHI & ANR.

W.P.(C) 4448/2022, CM APPL. 13282/2022

PANKAJ ARORA

Mr. Mani Bhadra, Advocate.

ASSISTANT COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX CIRCLE 49(1) & ANR.

W.P.(C) 4449/2022, CM APPL. 13283/2022

NARESH KUMAR GUPTA

Mr. Mani Bhadra, Advocate.

ASSISTANT COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX CIRCLE 34(5) & ANR.

W.P.(C) 4451/2022, CM APPL. 13286-87/2022

KANWALJEET KAUR

Mr. Saurabh D. Karan Singh,

ASSISTANT COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX CIRCLE (34) 1 DELHI

W.P.(C) 4452/2022, CM APPL. 13289/2022, CM APPL. 13288/2022

HARCHARAN SINGH

Mr. Saurabh D. Karan Singh,

INCOME TAX OFFICER WARD (35) 1, DELHI ..... Respondent

W.P.(C) 4455/2022, CM APPL. 13293/2022, CM APPL. 13294/2022

KARAN SINGH

DCIT, CIRCLE 13(1), DELHI & ANR.

W.P.(C) 4456/2022

M/S A.P. GOYAL CHARITABLE TRUST ..... Petitioner

Mr. Bhuwan Raj with Mr. Raghunath

Pathak, Mr. Abhinav Verma and

Ms. Manju Savita, Advocates.

INCOME TAX OFFICER

W.P.(C) 4457/2022, CM APPL. 13295/2022, CM APPL. 13294/2022

KULDEEP BISHNOI

ASSISTANT COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX, CENTRAL CIRCLE-32 DELHI AND ANR.

Mr. Abhishek Maratha, Sr. Standing

Counsel.

W.P.(C) 4458/2022, CM APPL. 13297/2022, CM APPL. 13298/2022

SURJEET JAISWAL HUF

Mr. Amol Sinha with Mr. Ashvini

Kumar, Advocates.

ASSISTANT COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX, CIRCLE 34(1), DELHI & ANR.

W.P.(C) 4461/2022, CM APPL. 13302/2022, CM APPL. 13303/2022

A V BOBBINS PVT LTD

Mr. Ravi Pratap with Mr. Shyam

Sundar, Advocates.

ASSISTANT COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX, CIRCLE - 1(1) NEW DELHI AND ANR.

W.P.(C) 4462/2022, CM APPL. 13304/2022, CM APPL. 13305/2022

MAYANK GOEL

INCOME TAX OFFICER, WARD 58-1 & ANR. ..... Respondents

W.P.(C) 4463/2022, CM APPL. 13306/2022, CM APPL. 13307/2022

VRINDA GOLD JEWELLERY HOUSE PRIVATE LIMITED

Mr. Gaurav Jain with Ms. Akshita

Goyal and Mr. Shubham Gupta,

ASSISTANT COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX CIRCLE 25(1) DELHI AND ANR

Mr. Ruchir Bhatia, Advocate.

W.P.(C) 4464/2022, CM APPL. 13308/2022, CM APPL. 13309/2022

M/S. UNIPATCH RUBBER LTD

Mr. S. Krishnan with Mr. K.

Sampath, Advocates.

ASSISTANT COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX & ORS.

Mr. Sunil Agarwal, Sr. Standing

Counsel with Mr. Tushar Gupta,

Mr. Samarth Chaudhari, Advocates.

W.P.(C) 4465/2022

ANUPAMA HARIBANSH CHOUDHARY

Mr. Rishi Jaiswal with Ms. Prachi

Rai, Advocates.

INCOME TAX OFFICER, WARD 30(5) DELHI ..... Respondent

W.P.(C) 4490/2022, CM APPL. 13375/2022, 13376/2022 HKAC LEASING 6860 IREALAND LIMITED

Mr. Ruchir Bhatia, Advocate.

CORAM:

HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE MANMOHAN

HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE DINESH KUMAR SHARMA

16.03.2022 O R D E R

1.

Learned counsel for the parties admit that as the impugned notices in the present matters have been issued post 31st March, 2021 without following the procedure prescribed in the substituted Sections 147 to 151 w.e.f. 01st April, 2021, the present matters are covered by the judgment dated 15th 2. The conclusion reached by this Court in Mon Mohan Kohli (supra) is reproduced hereinbelow:- December, 2021 passed by this Court in the case of Mon Mohan Kohli vs. Assistant Commissioner of Income Tax & Anr., W.P.(C) No.6176/2021. “CONCLUSION 97. This Court is of the view that as the Legislature has introduced the new provisions, Sections 147 to 151 of the Income Tax Act, 1961 by way of the Finance Act, 2021 with effect from 1st April, 2021 and as the said Section 147 is not even mentioned in the impugned Explanations, the reassessment notices relating to any Assessment Year issued under Section 148 after 31st 98. It is clarified that the power of reassessment that existed prior to 31 March, 2021 had to comply with the substituted Sections. st March, 2021 continued to exist till the extended period i.e. till 30th June, 2021; however, the Finance Act, 2021 has merely changed the procedure to be followed prior to issuance of notice with effect from 1st 99. This Court is of the opinion that Section 3(1) of Relaxation Act empowers the Government/Executive to extend only the time limits and it does not delegate the power to legislate on provisions to be followed for initiation of reassessment proceedings. In fact, the Relaxation Act does not April, 2021.

give power to Government to extend the erstwhile Sections 147 to 151 beyond 31st March, 2021 and/or defer the operation of substituted provisions enacted by the Finance Act, 2021. Consequently, the impugned Explanations in the Notifications dated 31st March, 2021 and 27th 100. The submission of the Revenue that Section 6 of the General Clauses Act saves notices issued under Section 148 post 31 April, 2021 are not conditional legislation and are beyond the power delegated to the Government as well as ultra vires the parent statute i.e. the Relaxation Act. Accordingly, this Court is respectfully not in agreement with the view of the Chhattisgarh High Court in Palak Khatuja (supra), but with the views of the Allahabad High Court and Rajasthan High Court in Ashok Kumar Agarwal (supra) and Bpip Infra Private Limited (supra) respectively. 101. The argument of the respondents that the substitution made by the Finance Act, 2021 is not applicable to past Assessment Years, as it is substantial in nature is contradicted by Respondents’ own Circular 549 of 1989 and its own submission that from 1 March, 2021 is untenable in law, as in the present case, the repeal is followed by a fresh legislation on the same subject and the new Act manifests an intention to destroy the old procedure. Consequently, if the Legislature has permitted reassessment to be made in a particular manner, it can only be in this manner, or not at all. 102. Revenue cannot rely on Covid-19 for contending that the new provisions Sections 147 to 151 of the Income Tax Act, 1961 should not operate during the period 1 July, 2021, the substitution made by the Finance Act, 2021 will be applicable. st April, 2021 to 30th 103. Consequently, this Court is of the view that the Executive/Respondents/Revenue cannot use the administrative power to issue Notifications under Section 3(1) of the June, 2021 as Parliament was fully aware of Covid-19 Pandemic when it passed the Finance Act, 2021. Also, the arguments of the respondents qua non-obstante clause in Section 3(1) of the Relaxation Act, ‘legal fiction’ and ‘stop the clock provision’ are contrary to facts and untenable in law.

Relaxation Act, 2020 to undermine the expression of Parliamentary supremacy in the form of an Act of Parliament, namely, the Finance Act, 2021. This Court is also of the opinion that the Executive/Respondents/Revenue cannot frustrate the purpose of substituted statutory provisions, like Sections 147 to 151 of Income Tax Act, 1961 in the present instance, by emptying it of content or impeding or postponing their effectual operation.”

3.

Keeping in view the aforesaid, Explanations A(a)(ii)/A(b) to the Notifications dated 31st March, 2021 and 27th 4. Consequently, the impugned reassessment notices issued under Section 148 of the Income Tax Act, 1961 are quashed and the present writ petitions are allowed. If the law permits the respondents/revenue to take further steps in the matter, they shall be at liberty to do so. Needless to state that if and when such steps are taken and if the petitioners have a grievance, they shall be at liberty to take their remedies in accordance with law. April, 2021 are declared to be ultra vires the Relaxation Act, 2020 and are therefore bad in law and null and void.

MANMOHAN, J

DINESH KUMAR SHARMA, J MARCH 16, 2022

More judgments on Section 147

All 57,238 judgments and leading authorities on Section 147 →

Recent GST High Court judgments

Search GST case law →