COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX CENTRAL GURGAON vs. RAJESH POPLI

PDF · subscribers
ITA/96/2015HC Punjab & HaryanaPHHC01110200201511 February 20165 pages
AI SummaryAllowed

What did the High Court hold?

The High Court held that the criminal complaint and the subsequent conviction could not sustain because the assessment order, which was the very foundation of the prosecution, had been set aside by a Division Bench of the High Court. The Court noted that the Division Bench's order dated 27.02.2020 had set aside the assessment order and remanded the matter for fresh assessment. Consequently, any prosecution based on that assessment order was deemed unsustainable. The High Court concluded that for want of a valid assessment order, the complaint itself was not maintainable. Therefore, the revision petitions were allowed, the impugned judgments of conviction and orders of sentence passed by the trial court and affirmed by the appellate court were set aside, and the petitioners were acquitted of the charges framed against them. The principle established is that a criminal prosecution under the Income Tax Act, predicated on a specific assessment order, becomes invalid if that assessment order is subsequently quashed or set aside.

What were the facts?

The petitioners, Vijay Kumar and Kalyan Singh, along with their firm M/s Kalyan Rice & General Mills, Kartarpur, and another partner Varinder Kumar, were convicted by the Judicial Magistrate First Class, Jalandhar, for offences under Sections 276(c), 277, and 278(B) of the Income Tax Act, 1961. The conviction stemmed from a complaint filed by the Income Tax Officer alleging tax evasion for the assessment year 1981-82, based on discrepancies in the Income Tax Return. The trial court awarded sentences of six months rigorous imprisonment and a fine of Rs. 500/- to each convict, to run concurrently. Appeals filed by the petitioners before the Additional Sessions Judge were dismissed by a common judgment dated 14.08.2004. These revision petitions were filed challenging the concurrent judgments of conviction and sentence.

What were the issues?

1. Whether the criminal complaint and subsequent conviction are maintainable when the assessment order, which formed the foundation of the prosecution, has been set aside by a higher court? (Question of law) Assessee's Contention: The learned counsel for the petitioners argued that the assessment order dated 08.01.1988 was the very foundation of the complaint. Subsequently, by an order dated 27.02.2020, a Division Bench of the High Court set aside this assessment order and directed a fresh assessment. Therefore, with the foundation of the prosecution demolished, the complaint is not maintainable, and the impugned judgments deserve to be set aside. Revenue's Contention: The learned counsel for the respondent No.2/Department did not dispute the fact that the assessment order, on the basis of which the complaint was filed, had been set aside by the Division Bench of the High Court.

Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?

Section 276(c),Section 277,Section 278(B)

AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below

IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB & HARYANA AT CHANDIGARH

CRR-1654-2004 (O&M) Date of decision : 22.09.2026

Vijay Kumar & Anr. ..... Petitioners VERSUS State of Punjab & Ors.

..... Respondents 107-II

CRR-1708-2004 (O&M)

Kalyan Singh ..... Petitioner VERSUS State of Punjab & Anr.

..... Respondents

CORAM: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SURYA PARTAP SINGH

Present : Mr. Shantanu Bansal, Advocate for Mr. Yugank Goyal, Advocate for the petitioners.

Ms. Gagandeep Kaur, DAG Punjab.

Mr. Vidul Kapoor, Advocate for the respondent No.2.

* SURYA PARTAP SINGH, J.

These are two revision petitions. Both the petitions have been filed against the judgment dated 14.08.2004, passed in two criminal appeals, by the Court of learned Additional Sessions Judge, hereinafter being referred to as ‘Appellate Court’. The abovesaid appeals were filed by the present

petitioners, against their conviction for the commission of offence punishable under Sections 276(c) read with Section 278(b) of Income Tax Act. 2.

In nut-shell, the facts emerging from record are that the Income Tax Officer had filed a complaint against ‘M/s Kalyan Rice & General Mills, Kartarpur’ and its partners, namely ‘Vijay Kumar’ (the petitioner No.1 in CRR-1654-2004), ‘Kalyan Singh’ (the petitioner in CRR-1708- 2004) and ‘Varinder Kumar’, alleging the commission of offence by them under Sections 276-C and 277 of Income Tax Act, 1961. 3.

Once the complaint was filed, a trial was conducted by the Court of learned Judicial Magistrate First Class Jalandhar, hereinafter being referred to as ‘trial Court’ only. The learned trial Court, by virtue of judgment dated 21.02.1995, held the petitioners and their above-named co- accused guilty for the commission of offence punishable under Sections 276(c), 277 read with Section 278(B) of Income Tax Act. In view of abovementioned judgment of conviction, passed by the learned trial Court, following sentences were awarded to the petitioners:-

Convicts Offence under Section

Sentence

Vijay Kumar 277 read with Section 278(B) of Income Tax Act

Kalyan Singh 276(C) read with Section 278-B of Income Tax Act

277 read with Section 278(b)

All the sentences were ordered to be run concurrently. 4.

Aggrieved of the abovementioned judgment of conviction and order of sentence, the petitioners had filed two separate appeals, i.e. one by ‘Kalyan Singh’ and another by ‘Vijay Kumar’ and the firm. However, the abovementioned appeals, which were disposed of by a common judgment, did not find favour of the learned Appellate Court, and thus, by virtue of judgment dated 14.08.2004, both the appeals were dismissed. 5.

Feeling dissatisfied with the abovementioned judgments, passed by the learned trial Court, vis-à-vis the learned Appellate Court, the present revision petitions have been preferred. 6.

In nut-shell, the facts emerging from record are that the abovementioned complaint was filed against the petitioners by alleging that in the Income Tax Return for the year 1981-82 certain discrepancies, with regard to evasion of tax, were detected. It was the claim of the respondents/complainant that the abovementioned entries, in the Income Tax Return, were with the intention to evade payment of income tax and cause revenue loss to the State Exchequer. Thus, the complaint. 7.

Today, the learned counsel for the petitioners has contended that the very foundation of the complaint in question was the assessment order dated 08.01.1988. According to learned counsel for the petitioners, by virtue of order dated 27.02.2020, in ITA No.26 of 2001, the Division Bench of this Court set aside the abovementioned assessment order and a direction has been issued for fresh assessment.

As per learned counsel for the petitioners, in view of the fact that the very foundation of the prosecution stands demolished, the complaint is not maintainable and therefore, the impugned judgment of conviction and order of sentence, passed by the learned trial Court, vis-à-vis the judgment, passed by the learned Appellate Court in appeal, deserve to be set aside. 9.

The learned counsel for the respondent No.2/Department has not disputed this fact that the assessment order, on the basis of which the complaint in question was filed, has been set aside by the Division Bench of this Court. 10.

The record has been perused carefully. 11.

The order dated 27.02.2020, passed by the Division Bench of this Court, reads as under:- “This appeal has been filed against the order of the revenue making substantial addition on the basis of stock variation. The primary grouse of the appellant was that at the relevant period it had obtained the contract for milling rice. For some period it did not have an electric connection and it had got that some paddy milled from its sister concern and that explained the stock variation. The authorities below having not accepted this explanation, the present appeal has been filed. Before us it is not disputed that the sister concern had also reflected this transaction and that was ultimately accepted by the revenue. In these circumstances, both the learned counsel have agreed that it would be appropriate if the matter is decided afresh in

view of the changed circumstances i.e. plea of the sister concerned having been accepted. Impugned order is set aside and the matter is remanded back. Since the main case has been decided, the pending civil miscellaneous application, if any, also stands disposed of.” 12.

The abovementioned order makes it apparent that the assessment order, on the basis of which complaint has been filed, stands set aside and therefore, in my opinion, any prosecution based on the abovementioned assessment cannot sustain. 13.

In view of abovementioned developments, it is hereby observed that for want of assessment order, the complaint itself is not maintainable. Hence, by accepting the present revisions, the impugned judgment of conviction and order of sentence, passed by the learned trial Court, vis-à-vis the judgment, passed by the learned Appellate Court in appeal, are hereby set aside. The petitioners are acquitted of the charges framed against them. 14.

Accordingly, the present petitions stand allowed in the aforesaid terms. 15.

Pending miscellaneous application(s), if any, stand(s) disposed of. 16.

A photocopy of this order be placed on the file of connected case.

(SURYA PARTAP SINGH)

JUDGE

22.09.2026 Gaurav Thakur

Whether speaking / reasoned

Yes/No

Whether Reportable

Yes/No

Latest GST High Court judgments

Search GST case law →