C I T JAIPUR II JAIPUR vs. SMT PUSHPA KALRA

PDF · subscribers
ITA/161/2012HC RajasthanRJHC02017619201211 September 20176 pages
AI SummaryDismissed

What did the High Court hold?

The Tribunal held that Section 50C is not applicable where the property was sold through an unregistered sale agreement. The AO was not justified in referring the matter to the DVO. Even if the Stamp Duty Authority assessed a value for stamp duty purposes, the assessee's right is protected by Section 50C(2), allowing the assessee to challenge the valuation. The Tribunal noted that a DVO report obtained in the purchaser's case valued the property at Rs. 32,01,100, and the addition made in the purchaser's hands based on a higher valuation was deleted by the CIT(A). Therefore, the addition made in the assessee's hands was not justified. The Tribunal answered both substantial questions of law in favour of the assessee. The appeal was dismissed.

What were the facts?

The assessee, Smt. Pushpa Kalra, sold a piece of land via an unregistered sale agreement dated September 6, 2002, for Rs. 18,00,000. The sale deed was registered on May 6, 2007, with the Sub-Registrar, Jaipur, valuing the property at Rs. 2,58,44,260. The Assessing Officer (AO) reopened the case under Section 147 and, applying Section 50C, determined the long-term capital gain at Rs. 2,40,39,372, adding it to the assessee's total income. The CIT(A) confirmed the AO's order. The assessee argued that Section 50C was not applicable as the agreement was unregistered, and the valuation by the Sub-Registrar was arbitrary and later than the agreement date. The assessee also pointed to a DVO valuation of Rs. 32,01,100 in the purchaser's case, which was deleted by the CIT(A). The appeal is against the ITAT's order allowing the assessee's appeal.

What were the issues?

1. Whether, in the facts and circumstances, the ITAT was justified in law in holding that Section 50C is not applicable to a property transferred by an unregistered agreement, even if registered later, and valuation was made? 2. Whether, in the facts and circumstances, the ITAT was justified in law in holding that the assessee's right is protected by Section 50C(2), allowing challenge to valuation, when the assessee did not challenge the valuation and Section 50C(2)(b) is applicable, precluding reference to DVO? Assessee's contentions: Section 50C is not applicable to unregistered agreements. The valuation by the stamp valuation authority was as of the registration date, not the agreement date. The DLC rate was significantly lower. The valuation by the Stamp Valuation Authority exceeded the fair market value, necessitating a reference to the DVO under Section 50C(2). A DVO report in the purchaser's case valued the property at Rs. 32,01,100, and this addition was deleted by the CIT(A). The assessee relied on Mooli Rami Reddy Vs. I.T.O. and Navneet Kumar Thakkar. Revenue's contentions: The ITAT erred in holding Section 50C inapplicable. The assessee did not challenge the valuation before the AO, thus Section 50C(2)(b) applies, and no reference to DVO could be made. The assessee did not challenge the valuation.

Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?

Section 50C,Section 147,Section 143(3),Section 50C(2),Section 50C(2)(b),Section 2(47)

AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below

HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE FOR RAJASTHAN BENCH AT JAIPUR D.B. Income Tax Appeal No. 161 / 2012 COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX, JAIPUR-II ,JAIPUR ----Appellant Versus SMT PUSHPA KALRA, E-29, LAJPAT MARG, C-SCHEME, JAIPUR ----Respondent _____________________________________________________ For Appellant(s) : Mr. K.D. Mathur for Mr. R.B. Mathur For Respondent(s) : Mr. Gunjan Pathak with Mr. Aditya Bohra _____________________________________________________ HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE K.S. JHAVERI HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE INDERJEET SINGH Order 11/09/2017

1.

By way of this appeal, the appellant has assailed the judgment and order of the Tribunal whereby the Tribunal has allowed the appeal of the assessee reversing the view taken by the CIT(A). 2. This Court while admitting the matter framed the following substantial questions of law:- “i) Whether in the facts and circumstances of the case, the ITAT was justified in law in holding that provisions of Section 50C are not applicable in this case the property was transferred by unregistered agreement without appreciating that the agreement was registered later on and valuation was made? ii) Whether in the facts and circumstances of the case, the ITAT was justified of the case, the ITAT was justified in law in holding that the right of the assessee is protected by the

(2 of 6) [ITA-161/2012] provisions of Section 50C(2) whereby assessee can challenge valuation without appreciating that in this case, valuation has to be challenged by the assessee and Section 50C(2)(b) is applicable so no reference to DVO could be made. Further the assessee did not challenge the valuation.?” 3. The facts of the case are that the assessee sold a piece of land to Ms. Hardevi vide unregistered sale agreement dated 06.09.2002. The sale consideration of this property was shown at Rs. 18,00,000/- in the return of income. Later on the purchaser got sale deed register in her favour from assessee on 06.05.2007 in pursuance to said agreement and the Sub-Registrar, Jaipur valued the property at Rs. 2,58,44,260/-. thus, there was difference of Rs. 2,40,44,260/-. On the basis of this information Assessing Officer reopened the case u/s 148 of the Act and made assessment u/s 143(3)/147. the assessee did not object that the value adopted or assesseed exceeds the fair market value of the property as on the date of transfer. The assessee has not even submitted whether the valuation was disputed in appeal or revision or reference before any authority or court. Hence, the AO applied provisions of Section 50C and adopted the final value taken by the Sub-Registrar of Rs.2,58,44,260/- as sale consideration value and after allowing index cost of acquisition and exemption u/s 54EC for investment in REC bonds, worked out long term capital gain of Rs. 2,40,39,372/- and added the same in her total income. 4. The AO after considering the evidence on record has assessed income on the basis of MOU and considered income for the relevant year 2003-04. Even CIT(A) has confirmed the same,

(3 of 6) [ITA-161/2012] the Tribunal while considering the same has observed as under:- “Regarding calculating capital gain of Rs. 2,40,39,372/- on transfer of said plot of land without considering the provisions of Section 50C(2), the following submissions have been made by ld. A/R:-. “It is evident from facts stated above that value assessed by stamp valuation authority is as on date of execution and registration of sale deed. In law the ld. A. O. could accept the declared consideration r adobt the value assessed by stamp valuation authority (assessable w.e.f. transactions effected from 1.09.09) as on date of transaction giving rise to capital gains if later is more. Thus for the purpose of application of Section 50C the rates prevailing as on the date agreement are to be adopted that too if it was so assessed by stamp valuation authority (assessable w.e.f. 1-10-09 and not the rates prevailing on the date of registration of sale deed of property. This legal view is supported from the judgment in case of Mooli Rami Reddy Vs. I.T.O. WD-1(2) Vishakhapatnam 2011-TIOL- 135 ITAT-VIZAG (P.B Page 25-29) The ld. CIT(A) has wrongly brushed aside the above referred judgment holding that facts of the case were different. It is submitted that in the case of question of law was decided and facts were only referred. The judgment is not on the facts of the case but is an interpretation of law. The judgment is clearly applicable in the case of assessee also. The impugned plot of land measuring to 1400 Sq. Yds (1170.55 Sq.mt) was situated in Prithvi Raj nagar (entire are is Land being agricultural and under Court orders land held as acquired by State Govt.) which is not regularlized and carved out of such acquired agricultural land and thus not even a residential plot of land for which notified DLC rate as on date of transfer was Rs. 1300/- per Sq.mt. (P.B Page 7-11) and thus by no stretch of imagination it can be valued at Rs. 2,58,44,260/- except in an grossly arbitrary manner. The purchaser is contesting the demand of stamp duty raised by such gross arbitrary manner and Hon’ble Supreme Court has granted a blanket stay of said arbitrary demand (P.B.Page 46). that the alleged value if adopted or assessed at all by Stamp Valuation Authority then it exceeds the fair market value of the property as on date of transfer and, therefore, it was the

(4 of 6) [ITA-161/2012] requirement of law u/s 50C(2) that the ld. A. O. should have referred the matter to valuation officer. The valuation of property was referred by A.O. in case of purchaser and the assessee also made reference of that A. O. in course of assessment proceedings which was ignored by ld. A. O. the ld. A. O. is thus wrong and has erred in law in brushing aside valuation report made by Valuation officer (I.T. Dept) of he said same property in case of purchaser even though it have the same effect as that having been prepared u/s 50C(2) and so the said report was binding on A. O. The D. V. O. valued the property at 32,01,100/- and in appeal the ld. CIT(A) accepted the declared value of Rs. 18,00,000/-- (P.B. Page 30-36) The ld. CIT(A) held that assessee did not raised objection before ld. A. O. so as to invoke section 50C(2) by him and refer the case to valuation officer for valuation of property. It is submitted that assessee raised objection as is evident from assessment order but as there was already a valuation report of Valuation Officer (IT Dept.) of the said property it referred to the same as well as filed copy of appeal order of CIT(A) in case of purchaser. The ld. A. O. should have considered the same as he is not expected to take advantage of technical mistake of an ignorant lady assessee moreso when relevant material is made available to him. The ld. CIT(A) also held that A.O. is not bound to accept valuation adopted by the VO in other cases. In this connection it is submitted that valuation is always of property and it is not relevant in whose name it is done. Event he reference to Valuation officer (IT Dept.) is made u/s 50C(2) in case of assessee is made even the same valuation is bound to come from valuation officer as in law the valuation is of same property for same date which cannot change. Thus order of CIT(A) is not correct in law. The ld. CIT(A) also discussed in detail the provisions of stamp law etc. but the same are not relevant due to wide definition of transfer u/s 2(47) specially clause (v) of said section and further that the ld. AO assessed capital gain in A.Y. 2003-04 on the basis of agreement to sale dated 06.09.02 and ld. CIT(A) also confirmed the same in appeal order. The husband of assessee Shri Madhav Kalra has also sold that adjacent plot NO. A-6 (front portion plot A-6 and back portion was plot No.

(5 of 6) [ITA-161/2012] A-7) for Rs. 22,00,000/- on same date i.e. 06.09.02 by agreement to sale and registration of sale deed of it was also done on same date i.e. 16.05.07. The same Inspector valued the property arbitrarily in same way determining value of Rs. 2,59,33,450/-. The A.O. similarly initiated reassessment proceedings for A.Y. 2003-04 in this case but after considering the legal position as stated above dropped the proceedings initiated u/s 148. In view of this it is submitted that in law two assessee cannot be treated differently in assessment on exactly the same facts.” 5. We have heard counsel for both the sides. 6. Taking into consideration, the Tribunal has come to the right conclusion regarding encashment by 6th April, 2003. 7. In that view of the matter, the income can be considered for A.Y 2004-05 not for 2003-04 and it has not committed any error in observing as under:- “13.2. For the sake of further clarification, we noticed that in case of purchaser of the property in question, the matter was referred by the AO to the DVO who has valued this property at Rs. 32,01,100/- and in accordance with the DVO’s report the AO took value of this property at Rs. 32,01,100. the assessee filed appeal before ld. CIT(A) who deleted the addition made by AO by holding that there was no material before the AO that purchaser has paid any payment over and above the consideration shown in sale agreement. Copy of the order of ld. CIT(A) in case of purchaser i.e. Smt. Hardevi Asnani is placed in the paper book at pages 30 to 36. For this reason also no addition can be made in the hands of assessee as the departmental valuer has valued the property at Rs. 32 lakhs or odd which has already been deleted by ld. CIT(A) in the case of purchaser. This appeal was also brought to the notice of ld. CIT(A). However, he has not taken into consideration.” 8. The Tribunal while considering the matter has given finding which reads as under:-

(6 of 6) [ITA-161/2012] “14.2. The cases on which reliance has been placed by ld. A/R i.e. in case of Navneet Kumar Thakkar and in case of Mooli Ram Reddy are squarely applicable on the facts of the case. In this case, as discussed above, have clearly held that where the property was sold through unregistered sale agreement, provisions of section 50C are not applicable and, therefore, AO was not justified in referring the matter to the DVO. Even and otherwise, if the Stamp Duty Authority has assessed some value for the purpose of stamp duty, the right of the assessee is protected by provisions of section 50C(2) whereby assessee can challenge the valuation adopted by the AO in view of provisions of section 50C. In support of this contention the assessee has filed a report of DVO obtained in case of purchaser who has valued the property at Rs. 32,01,100/- and impugned addition was made in the hands of purchaser by the AO and the same has been deleted by ld. CIT(A). Therefore, for this reason also it can be said that addition made by AO which confirmed by ld. CIT(A) was not justified.” 9. Taking into consideration, both the issues are answered in favour of the assessee against the department. 10. The appeal stands dismissed. (INDERJEET SINGH),J. (K.S. JHAVERI),J. A.Sharma/51

More judgments on Section 50C

All 3,326 judgments and leading authorities on Section 50C →

Recent GST High Court judgments

Search GST case law →