RAJESH SHANTILAL PATEL,SURAT vs. ITO, WARD 1(2)(6), SURAT

PDF · subscribers
ITA 1138/SRT/2025Status: DisposedITAT Surat04 November 2026AY 2018-1910 pages
AI SummaryRemanded

What did the Tribunal hold?

The Tribunal considered the rival submissions and the material on record. The core issue was whether the assessee was entitled to use the stamp duty value as on the date of the Agreement dated 14.07.2008, invoking the provisos to section 56(2)(x)(b). The AO had denied this benefit, stating that the agreement did not cover Block No. 25 and that the consideration for it was paid after the agreement date. However, the assessee's AR presented evidence from the agreement and bank records showing that Block No. 25 was included and a part of the consideration was paid via banking channel before the agreement date. These factual aspects, crucial for the provisos' applicability, were not adequately examined by the AO. Regarding the revenue's contention that the agreement was unregistered, the Tribunal held that registration of the agreement is not necessary in the context of the provisos to section 56(2)(x)(b) or section 50C, citing judicial decisions. Consequently, the Tribunal restored the issue to the file of the AO for a fresh examination of the assessee's claim, considering the observations made and the available material, and to recompute the addition, if any, in accordance with law, after affording adequate opportunity to the assessee. The appeal was allowed for statistical purposes.

What were the facts?

The assessee, Rajesh Shantilal Patel, filed an appeal before the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT), Surat Bench, against the order of the Commissioner of Income-Tax (Appeals)-NFAC, Delhi. The assessment year in question is 2018-19. The assessment order was passed by the National e-Assessment Centre, Delhi, under section 143(3) read with section 144B of the Income-tax Act, 1961. The Assessing Officer (AO) made an addition of Rs. 1,68,11,517/- under the head 'Income from Other Sources' by invoking section 56(2)(x)(b) of the Act. This addition was made on the grounds that the assessee purchased three properties for a consideration lesser than the stamp duty valuation. The assessee's appeal before the CIT(A) was unsuccessful, leading to the present appeal before the ITAT.

What were the issues?

1. Whether the learned CIT(A) erred in upholding the addition of Rs. 1,68,11,517/- under section 56(2)(x)(b) of the Income-tax Act, 1961, on account of alleged deemed income from other sources, thereby rendering the assessment order without jurisdiction, perverse, illegal, invalid, arbitrary, bad in law, and void ab initio? 2. Whether the learned CIT(A) erred in upholding the assessment order without granting a sufficient and meaningful opportunity to the assessee to comply with the Show Cause Notice (SCN) issued at the fag end of the time-barring period, thus violating the principles of natural justice and rendering the assessment order without jurisdiction, bad in law, void ab initio, illegal, and unjustified? Assessee's Contentions: - The assessee argued that the lands were purchased through an Agreement dated 14.07.2008, with registered sale deeds executed in AY 2018-19 due to conversion process. A part of the consideration was paid through banking channels on 04.06.2008, before the agreement date. Therefore, the assessee is entitled to the benefit of the 1st and 2nd provisos to section 56(2)(x)(b), allowing the use of stamp duty value as on the agreement date. The AO incorrectly denied this benefit based on factually incorrect premises regarding the inclusion of Block No. 25 and the payment date for its consideration. Revenue's Contentions: - The Revenue, through the learned DR, reiterated the AO's observations. It was further argued that the Agreement dated 14.07.2008 is an unregistered document, and as per the decision in CIT v. Balbir Singh Maini, an unregistered agreement lacks legal existence for the assessee's contentions. Therefore, the benefit of the provisos cannot be granted. Alternatively, the Revenue suggested remanding the matter to the AO for proper verification.

Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?

Section 56(2)(x)(b),Section 143(3),Section 144B,Section 50C

AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below

Income Tax Appellate Tribunal, SURAT BENCH, SURAT

Before: MS. SUCHITRA KAMBLE & SHRI B.M. BIYANI

For Appellant: Shri Akshay M. Modi, CA
For Respondent: Shri Ashish Kumar, Sr. DR
Hearing: 31.08.2026Pronounced: 04.11.2026

आदेश / O R D E R Per B.M. Biyani, A.M.: Feeling aggrieved by the order of first appeal dated 25.08.2025 passed by learned Commissioner of Income-Tax (Appeals)-NFAC, Delhi [“Ld. CIT(A)”], which in turn arises out of the assessment-order dated 22.04.2021 passed by learned National e-Assessment Centre, Delhi [“Ld. AO”] u/s 143(3) r.w.s. 144B of Income-tax Act, 1961 [“the Act”] for Assessment-Year [“AY”] 2018- 19, the assessee has filed this appeal.

Page 1 of 10

2. The background facts leading to present appeal are such that the assessee-individual filed his return of income of AY 2018-19 declaring a total income of Rs. 19,30,282/-. The case of assessee was selected for scrutiny assessment and the Ld. AO issued notices u/s 143(2)/142(1) which the assessee complied with. During proceedings, the Ld. AO observed that the assessee had purchased three properties by paying consideration lesser than the valuations made by stamps authority. The Ld. AO has given relevant details i.e. the description of properties, stamps valuation, consideration paid, difference, etc. on Page No. 5 of assessment-order. The lands purchased by assessee are described as (i) Block No. 25, (ii) Block No. 21-B-2, and (iii) Block No. 21-B-2 Paiki. Accordingly, the Ld. AO has computed the lesser consideration paid by assessee at Rs. 1,68,11,517/-. Accordingly, the Ld. AO invoked section 56(2)(x)(b) and made addition under the head “Income from Other sources”. Aggrieved, the assesse carried matter in first-appeal before Ld. CIT(A) but did not get success. Now, the assessee has come before us by way of next appeal.

3.

The grounds raised by assessee are as under:

“1. On the facts and in the circumstances of the case as well in law, the learned CIT (Appeals), NFAC, New Delhi has erred in upholding order of the learned Addl./Joint/Deputy/Asstt.Commissioner/ Income Tax Officer of Income Tax, National e- Assessment Centre, Delhi (for the sake of brevity "The AO") passed u/s 143(3) r.w.s. 144B of the Act invoking the provisions of Section 56(2)(x)(b) of the Act for making addition on account of the alleged deemed income from other sources to the extent of Rs. 1,68,11,517/- being without jurisdiction, perverse, illegal, invalid, arbitrary, bad in law, void ab initio, is liable to be quashed or annulled in toto. 2. On the facts and in the circumstances of the case as well in law, CIT(A) erred in upholding the order u/s 143(3) r.w.s. 144B of the Act, without granting sufficient and meaningful opportunity to make compliance to the SCN dtd. 16-04-2021 issued at the fag end of the time barring period and hence, the whole assessment proceedings being carried out in pure violation of principles of natural justice, is without jurisdiction, bad in

Page 2 of 10

law, void ab initio, illegal, unjustified and hence, the assessment order is liable to be struck down. 3. On the facts and in the circumstances of the case as well in law, both the lower authorities have erred in not properly appreciating the entire correspondences made in the course of assessment/appeal proceedings, already been supplied with the appeal memo forming part of the statement of facts including cogent explanations and submissions made in writing by the appellant on various dates along with the various enclosures attached with the said submission and hence, not justified. 4. Your appellant further reserves his rights to add, alter, amend or modify any of the aforesaid grounds before or at the time of hearing of an appeal.”

4.

We have heard the learned Representatives of both sides and carefully consider the documents held in case file including the orders of lower- authorities.

5.

Ld. AR for assessee submitted that the assessee purchased impugned lands through an Agreement dated 14.07.2008 but, however, the registered sale-deeds were executed during the previous year 2017-18 relevant to AY 2018-19 under consideration due to pendency of conversion process. Further, the assessee paid part of the consideration through banking channel on 04.06.2008 before entering into Agreement dated 14.07.2008. Therefore, the assessee was entitled to the benefit of 1st & 2nd proviso to section 56(2)(x)(b) which prescribe thus:

“Provided that where the date of the agreement fixing the amount of consideration for the transfer of immovable property and the date of registration are not the same, the stamp duty value on the date of agreement may be taken for the purposes of this sub-section.

Provided further that the provisions of the first proviso shall apply only in a case where the amount of consideration referred to therein, or a part thereof, has been paid by way of an account payee cheque or an account payee bank draft or by use of electronic clearing system through a bank account or through such other electronic mode as may be prescribed, on or before the date of agreement for transfer of such immovable property:”

6.

However, the Ld. AO has not given benefit of the aforesaid 1st & 2nd Proviso to assessee. Ld. AR drew us to Paras 10 & 11 of assessment-order, where the Ld. AO has assigned reasons for not giving such benefit. Precisely, these reasons are:

(i) The Agreement dated 14/7/2008 furnished by assessee relates only to lands at Block No.21, B-2 and B-2 Paiki. It does not relate to the land at Block No. B-25.

(ii) The purchase consideration of Rs.45,58,950/- paid for the B.No.25, has been paid on 05/01/2017 which is after the date of the above agreement i.e. 14/7/2008.

7.

However, Ld. AR contended, the reasons assigned by Ld. AO are factually not correct. To demonstrate as to how, the Ld. AR invited our attention to following pages of the Agreement dated 14.07.2008:

8. By referring to above pages, Ld. AR narrated as under:

(i) That in the details of payment, it is clearly mentioned that the assessee made payment of Rs. 3,50,000/- on 04.06.2008 through Cheque No. 210788 drawn on The Surat Peoples Co-operative Bank Ltd. Copy of assesse’s bank pass-book is also filed wherein the debit entry of Rs. 3,50,000/- on 04.06.2008 is reflected. Thus, the assessee has made part payment through banking channel before entering into agreement dated 14.07.2008 and condition of 2nd Proviso is satisfied.

(ii) That in the “details of land”, in Point No. 1, Block 21 is mentioned which covers the Property described as “Block No. 21-B-2” and “Block No. 21-B-2 Paiki”. Therafter, in Point No. 2, “Block No. 25” is mentioned.

9.

Accordingly, Ld. AR submitted that the Ld. AO denied the benefit of the aforesaid provisos on incorrect factual premises. He therefore requested that the claim of the assessee be considered in the light of the Agreement and the supporting bank records and suitable relief be granted.

10.

Per contra, Ld. DR for revenue reiterated the observations made by the Ld. AO in the assessment-order, as discussed hereinabove. He further submitted that the Agreement dated 14.07.2008 relied upon by the assessee is an unregistered document and, in view of the landmark decision of Hon’ble Supreme Court in CIT v. Balbir Singh Maini, an unregistered agreement does not have legal existence for the purposes contended by the

Page 7 of 10

assessee. Accordingly, he submitted that the benefit of the provisos to section 56(2)(x)(b) cannot be granted to the assessee. Alternatively, Ld. DR submitted that, if the Bench considers it appropriate, the matter may be restored to the file of Ld. AO for proper verification and adjudication in accordance with law.

11.

We have considered the rival submissions and perused the orders of lower authorities as well as the material available on record. The short issue requiring our consideration is whether, on the facts of the present case, the assessee is entitled to take the stamp duty value as on the date of Agreement dated 14.07.2008 by invoking the first and second provisos to section 56(2)(x)(b) of the Act. The said provisos, inter alia, contemplate a case where the date of the agreement fixing the amount of consideration and the date of registration are different and provide for adoption of the stamp duty value as on the date of such agreement, subject to the prescribed condition regarding payment of the consideration or part thereof through the specified banking/electronic modes on or before the date of agreement.

12.

In present case, the Ld. AO has denied the benefit primarily on the footing that the Agreement dated 14.07.2008 did not cover Block No. 25 and that the consideration relating thereto was paid on 05.01.2017. However, before us, the Ld. AR has specifically contended, with reference to the Agreement, that Block No. 25 is also included in the details of land forming part of the Agreement and that an amount of Rs. 3,50,000/- was paid through banking channel on 04.06.2008, i.e. prior to the date of the

Page 8 of 10

Agreement. The assessee has also relied upon the corresponding entry in the bank pass-book. These factual aspects, which go to the very applicability of the aforesaid provisos, have not been examined by the Ld. AO in the manner now placed before us.

13.

As regards the objection of Ld. DR regarding the Agreement being unregistered, we find that as per judicial decisions of appellate forums, the registration of agreement is not necessary in the context of Provisos to section 56(2)(x)(b) or section 50C. Hence, the contention raised by Ld. DR is rejected.

14.

Accordingly, we restore the issue to the file of Ld. AO with a direction to examine the claim of the assessee afresh, in the light of the observations made hereinabove and after considering the material available on record, and thereafter recompute the addition, if any, in accordance with law. Needless to say, adequate opportunity of being heard shall be afforded to the assessee. Ordered accordingly.

15.

Resultantly, this appeal is allowed for statistical purposes.

Order pronounced in open court on 04/11/2026

Sd/- Sd/- (SUCHITRA KAMBLE) (B.M. BIYANI) JUDICIAL MEMBER ACCOUNTANT MEMBER Surat

Page 9 of 10

दिन ांक /Dated : 04/11/2026 Kishore/Sr. PS Copies to: (1) The appellant (2) The respondent (3) CIT (4) CIT(A) (5) Departmental Representative (6) Guard File By order HEMA KISHORE Digitally signed by HEMA KISHORE JAKKA JAKKA Date: 2026.11.04 19:59:21 +05'30' UE COPYAssistant Registrar/Sr.PS Income Tax Appellate Tribunal Surat Bench, Surat

Page 10 of 10

More judgments on Section 56(2)(x)(b)

All 70 judgments and leading authorities on Section 56(2)(x)(b) →

Recent GST High Court judgments

Search GST case law →