THE COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX vs. M/S BLUE LINES

PDF · subscribers
ITA/763/2008HC KarnatakaKAHC01036363200802 August 2014Bench: B.MANOHAR,N.KUMAR16 pages
AI SummaryRemanded

What did the High Court hold?

The High Court held that the Tribunal's finding in ITA Nos. 760, 762-765/2008, that the Revenue was not justified in drawing a presumption under Section 132(4)(A) because the seized materials did not reflect the assessee's name and cheques were stale, blank, or in third-party names, could not be faulted. Consequently, the Court did not delve into the legal issue regarding the scope of presumption under Section 147 read with Section 143(3). For ITA Nos. 761, 766, 769/2008, the Court found that the Tribunal had not properly appreciated the assessee's case regarding the Rs. 2,05,00,000 claim, granting relief based on a statement of affairs not presented as a defence. The matter was remanded for fresh consideration. Similarly, regarding the Rs. 33,05,000 claim (money lending cheques) and the Rs. 20,03,680 cash found, the Tribunal had failed to appreciate the material, hear arguments, or record findings, despite the First Appellate Authority's decisions. These aspects were also remanded for fresh consideration. The claim of Rs. 11,39,000 in ITA No. 764/2008 was also noted as not having a finding from the Tribunal, despite relief granted by the First Appellate Authority, and was included in the remand. The operative direction was to set aside the impugned ITAT order and remand the matters to the Tribunal for fresh consideration.

What were the facts?

These appeals by the Revenue (Commissioner of Income-Tax and Assistant Commissioner of Income-Tax) challenge orders of the Income-Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT) for assessment years 1998-1999 to 2003-2004 and 1999-2000. The assessee is M/s. Blue Lines, Prop: Sri.Balakrishna Setty K.S. (HUF). In some appeals (ITA Nos. 760, 762-765/2008), the Revenue disputes the ITAT's finding that it was not justified in drawing a presumption under Section 132(4)(A) of the Income-Tax Act, 1961, as the assessee's name was not reflected in seized materials. In other appeals (ITA Nos. 761, 766, 769/2008), the dispute involves claims of undisclosed income (Rs. 2,05,00,000), unaccounted money lending cheques (Rs. 33,05,000), and cash found during search (Rs. 20,03,680). The High Court is considering these appeals filed under Section 260-A of the Income-Tax Act, 1961.

What were the issues?

1. Whether, in the facts of the case, the Revenue was justified in drawing a presumption under Section 132(4)(A) of the Income-Tax Act, 1961, when the assessee's name was not reflected in any of the seized materials, and the seized cheques were stale, blank, or in the name of third parties? (Question of law and fact, concerning Section 132(4)(A)). 2. Whether the Tribunal properly appreciated the assessee's case regarding a claim of Rs. 2,05,00,000 (undisclosed income) and erred in granting relief based on a statement of affairs filed on 31.03.1999, which was not presented as a defence before lower authorities? (Question of law and fact). 3. Whether the Tribunal erred in not properly appreciating the material on record and hearing arguments concerning a claim of Rs. 33,05,000 representing unaccounted money lending cheques, after the First Appellate Authority had set aside the Assessing Officer's finding on this issue? (Question of law and fact). 4. Whether the Tribunal erred in not recording any finding on the claim regarding cash found during the search (Rs. 20,03,680), despite the First Appellate Authority affirming the finding, and in allowing the appeal without assigning reasons for this aspect? (Question of law and fact). 5. Whether the Tribunal erred in not recording any finding on a claim for Rs. 11,39,000 stated to be unaccounted on the basis of a cheque found, despite the First Appellate Authority granting relief to the assessee? (Question of law and fact). Assessee's contentions: Not explicitly recorded for all issues. However, the assessee's arguments likely revolved around the lack of direct evidence linking the seized materials to them, the validity of the statement of affairs, and explanations for the money lending cheques and cash. The assessee relied on the orders of the First Appellate Authority and the Tribunal. Revenue's contentions: The Revenue argued for the validity of presumptions under Section 132(4)(A) and challenged the Tribunal's findings on the quantum of income and additions, seeking to uphold the Assessing Officer's orders.

Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?

Section 132(4)(A),Section 147,Section 143(3),Section 260-A

AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below

Cited by 12 judgments on BharatTax

See all citing judgments →

Counted from the text of the judgments hosted here. Most recent first.

1 IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BANGALORE

DATED THIS THE 02ND DAY OF AUGUST, 2014

PRESENT:

THE HON'BLE Mr.JUSTICE N.KUMAR

AND

THE HON'BLE Mr.JUSTICE B.MANOHAR

ITA No.760/2008 c/w ITA No.761/2008, ITA No.762/2008, ITA No.763/2008, ITA No.764/2008, ITA No.765/2008, ITA No.766/2008, ITA No.769/2008

In ITA No.760/2008

BETWEEN:

1.

The Commissioner of Income-Tax,

Central Circle, C.R.Building,

Queens Road, Bangalore.

2.

The Assistant Commissioner of Income-Tax,

Central Circle – 1(2), C.R.Building,

Queens Road, Bangalore.

…Appellants

(By Sri.K.V.Aravind, Adv.)

2 AND:

M/s.Blue Lines, Prop : Sri.Balakrishna Setty K.S. (HUF), No.106, 1st Floor, Money Chambers, #6, K.H.Road, Bangalore – 560 027.

...Respondent

(By Sri.S.Sarangan, Sr.Counsel for Sri.P.Dinesh, Adv.)

ITA No.760/2008 is filed under Section 260-A of Income- Tax Act, 1961 arising out of order dated 07.03.2008 passed in ITA No.1249/BNG/2007, for the Assessment Year 1998-1999, praying that this Court may be pleased to formulate the substantial questions of law stated therein and allow the appeal and set aside the order passed by the ITAT, Bangalore in ITA No. 1249/BNG/2007 dated 07.03.2008 confirming the order of the Appellate Commissioner and confirm the order passed by the Assistant Commissioner of Income Tax, Central Circle – 1(2), Bangalore. * * * *

In ITA No.761/2008

BETWEEN:

1.

The Commissioner of Income-Tax,

Central Circle, C.R.Building,

Queens Road, Bangalore.

2.

The Assistant Commissioner of Income-Tax,

Central Circle – 1(2),

3 C.R.Building,

Queens Road, Bangalore.

…Appellants

(By Sri.K.V.Aravind, Adv.)

AND:

M/s.Blue Lines, Prop : Sri.Balakrishna Setty K.S. (HUF), No.106, 1st Floor, Money Chambers, #6, K.H.Road, Bangalore – 560 027.

...Respondent

(By Sri.S.Sarangan, Sr.Counsel for Sri.P.Dinesh, Adv.)

ITA No.761/2008 is filed under Section 260-A of Income- Tax Act, 1961 arising out of order dated 07.03.2008 passed in ITA No.1250/BNG/2007, for the Assessment Year 1999-2000, praying that this Court may be pleased to formulate the substantial questions of law stated therein and allow the appeal and set aside the order passed by the ITAT, Bangalore in ITA No. 1250/BNG/2007 dated 07.03.2008 confirming the order of the Appellate Commissioner and confirm the order passed by the Assistant Commissioner of Income Tax, Central Circle – 1(2), Bangalore.

* * * *

4 In ITA No.762/2008

BETWEEN:

1.

The Commissioner of Income-Tax,

Central Circle, C.R.Building,

Queens Road, Bangalore.

2.

The Assistant Commissioner of Income-Tax,

Central Circle – 1(2), C.R.Building,

Queens Road, Bangalore.

…Appellants

(By Sri.K.V.Aravind, Adv.)

AND:

M/s.Blue Lines, Prop : Sri.Balakrishna Setty K.S. (HUF), No.106, 1st Floor, Money Chambers, #6, K.H.Road, Bangalore – 560 027.

...Respondent

(By Sri.S.Sarangan, Sr.Counsel for Sri.P.Dinesh, Adv.)

ITA No.762/2008 is filed under Section 260-A of Income- Tax Act, 1961 arising out of order dated 07.03.2008 passed in ITA No.1251/BNG/2007, for the Assessment Year 2000-2001, praying that this Court may be pleased to formulate the substantial questions of law stated therein and allow the appeal and set aside the order passed by the ITAT, Bangalore in ITA No. 1251/BNG/2007 dated 07.03.2008 confirming the order of the

5 Appellate Commissioner and confirm the order passed by the Assistant Commissioner of Income Tax, Central Circle – 1(2), Bangalore. * * * *

In ITA No.763/2008

BETWEEN:

1.

The Commissioner of Income-Tax,

Central Circle, C.R.Building,

Queens Road, Bangalore.

2.

The Assistant Commissioner of Income-Tax,

Central Circle – 1(2), C.R.Building,

Queens Road, Bangalore.

…Appellants

(By Sri.K.V.Aravind, Adv.)

AND:

M/s.Blue Lines, Prop : Sri.Balakrishna Setty K.S. (HUF), No.106, 1st Floor, Money Chambers, #6, K.H.Road, Bangalore – 560 027.

...Respondent

(By Sri.S.Sarangan, Sr.Counsel for Sri.P.Dinesh, Adv.)

ITA No.763/2008 is filed under Section 260-A of Income- Tax Act, 1961 arising out of order dated 07.03.2008 passed in

6 ITA No.1252/BNG/2007, for the Assessment Year 2001-2002, praying that this Court may be pleased to formulate the substantial questions of law stated therein and allow the appeal and set aside the order passed by the ITAT, Bangalore in ITA No. 1252/BNG/2007 dated 07.03.2008 confirming the order of the Appellate Commissioner and confirm the order passed by the Assistant Commissioner of Income Tax, Central Circle – 1(2), Bangalore. * * * * In ITA No.764/2008

BETWEEN:

1.

The Commissioner of Income-Tax,

Central Circle, C.R.Building,

Queens Road, Bangalore.

2.

The Assistant Commissioner of Income-Tax,

Central Circle – 1(2), C.R.Building,

Queens Road, Bangalore.

…Appellants

(By Sri.K.V.Aravind, Adv.)

AND:

M/s.Blue Lines, Prop : Sri.Balakrishna Setty K.S. (HUF), No.106, 1st Floor, Money Chambers, #6, K.H.Road, Bangalore – 560 027.

...Respondent

(By Sri.S.Sarangan, Sr.Counsel for Sri.P.Dinesh, Adv.)

7 ITA No.764/2008 is filed under Section 260-A of Income- Tax Act, 1961 arising out of order dated 07.03.2008 passed in ITA No.1253/BNG/2007, for the Assessment Year 2002-2003, praying that this Court may be pleased to formulate the substantial questions of law stated therein and allow the appeal and set aside the order passed by the ITAT, Bangalore in ITA No. 1253/BNG/2007 dated 07.03.2008 confirming the order of the Appellate Commissioner and confirm the order passed by the Assistant Commissioner of Income Tax, Central Circle – 1(2), Bangalore. * * * *

In ITA No.765/2008

BETWEEN:

1.

The Commissioner of Income-Tax,

Central Circle, C.R.Building,

Queens Road, Bangalore.

2.

The Assistant Commissioner of Income-Tax,

Central Circle – 1(2), C.R.Building, Queens Road, Bangalore.

…Appellants

(By Sri.K.V.Aravind, Adv.)

8 AND:

M/s.Blue Lines, Prop : Sri.Balakrishna Setty K.S. (HUF), No.106, 1st Floor, Money Chambers, #6, K.H.Road, Bangalore – 560 027.

...Respondent

(By Sri.S.Sarangan, Sr.Counsel for Sri.P.Dinesh, Adv.)

ITA No.765/2008 is filed under Section 260-A of Income- Tax Act, 1961 arising out of order dated 07.03.2008 passed in ITA No.1254/BNG/2007, for the Assessment Year 2003-2004, praying that this Court may be pleased to formulate the substantial questions of law stated therein and allow the appeal and set aside the order passed by the ITAT, Bangalore in ITA No. 1254/BNG/2007 dated 07.03.2008 confirming the order of the Appellate Commissioner and confirm the order passed by the Assistant Commissioner of Income Tax, Central Circle – 1(2), Bangalore. * * * *

In ITA No.766/2008

BETWEEN:

1.

The Commissioner of Income-Tax,

Central Circle, C.R.Building,

Queens Road, Bangalore.

9 2. The Assistant Commissioner of Income-Tax,

Central Circle – 1(2), C.R.Building,

Queens Road, Bangalore.

…Appellants

(By Sri.K.V.Aravind, Adv.)

AND:

M/s.Blue Lines, Prop : Sri.Balakrishna Setty K.S. (HUF), No.106, 1st Floor, Money Chambers, #6, K.H.Road, Bangalore – 560 027.

...Respondent

(By Sri.S.Sarangan, Sr.Counsel for Sri.P.Dinesh, Adv.)

ITA No.766/2008 is filed under Section 260-A of Income- Tax Act, 1961 arising out of order dated 07.03.2008 passed in ITA No.1272/Bang/2007, for the Assessment Year 1999-2000, praying that this Court may be pleased to formulate the substantial questions of law stated therein and allow the appeal and set aside the order passed by the ITAT, Bangalore in ITA No. 1272/Bang/2007 dated 07.03.2008 confirming the order of the Appellate Commissioner and confirm the order passed by the Assistant Commissioner of Income Tax, Central Circle – 1(2), Bangalore. * * * *

In ITA No.769/2008

BETWEEN:

1.

The Commissioner of Income-Tax,

Central Circle, C.R.Building,

Queens Road, Bangalore.

2.

The Assistant Commissioner of Income-Tax,

Central Circle – 1(2), C.R.Building,

Queens Road, Bangalore.

…Appellants

(By Sri.K.V.Aravind, Adv.)

AND:

M/s.Blue Lines, Prop : Sri.Balakrishna Setty K.S. (HUF), No.106, 1st Floor, Money Chambers, #6, K.H.Road, Bangalore – 560 027.

...Respondent

(By Sri.S.Sarangan, Sr.Counsel for Sri.P.Dinesh, Adv.)

ITA No.769/2008 is filed under Section 260-A of Income- Tax Act, 1961 arising out of order dated 07.03.2008 passed in ITA No.1273/BNG/2007, for the Assessment Year 1998-1999, praying that this Court may be pleased to formulate the substantial questions of law stated therein and allow the appeal and set aside the order passed by the ITAT, Bangalore in ITA No.

11 1273/BNG/2007 dated 07.03.2008 confirming the order of the Appellate Commissioner and confirm the order passed by the Assistant Commissioner of Income Tax, Central Circle – 1(2), Bangalore.

These Appeals coming on for Hearing, this day, N.KUMAR, J., delivered the following:

J U D G M E N T

All these appeals are preferred by the Revenue. They are taken up together for consideration as a common question of law is involved in all these appeals and the assessee is the same.

2.

In so far as ITA No.760/2008, 762/2008, 763/2008, 764/2008, 765/2008 are concerned, the Revenue is in appeal, challenging the observation made by the Tribunal that in the facts of this case, the Revenue was not justified in drawing the presumption under Section 132(4)(A) on the ground the assessee name was not reflected in any of the seized materials. However, they are not disputing the quantum of tax

12 determined by the Authorities. As a consequence thereof, only if the presumption is held in favour of the Department, they would be entitled

to the consequential claim regarding interest. The reason given by the Tribunal is, though there was a seizure and there were materials seized in the search, the said materials did not reflect the name of the assessee. Most of the cheques were stale and some other cheques were blank and some other cheques were in the name of the third parties.

3.

In the facts of these cases, we are of the view that the finding recorded by the Tribunal on this aspect cannot be found fault with and therefore, we are not going into the legal issue regarding the scope of presumption, which arrises under Section 147 read with Section 143(3) and infact in other three appeals also, similar finding was recorded by the Tribunal.

13 4. In so far as ITA No.761/2008, ITA No.766/2008 and ITA No.769/2008 are concerned, the claim was three-fold. First claim is of Rs.2,05,00,000/- undisclosed income. The recipient of the income during the course of the search of the premises admitted the receipt of the said payment. The second claim pertains to an amount of Rs.33,05,000/- additions made by the Assessing Authority representing the unaccounted money lending cheques. The third claim was regarding cash found during the time of search was Rs.20,03,680/-.

5.

In so far as claim for Rs.2,05,00,000/- is concerned, the Tribunal has not properly appreciated the case of the assessee and taking into consideration, a sum of Rs.79,55,280/- reflected in the statement of affairs filed on 31.03.1999 has granted the relief. The said statement was not put forth as a defence before the Assessing Authority or before the First Appellate Authority though an assessment order disclosing the

14 said amount was placed before both the Authorities. Under these circumstances, it is not possible to affirm the said finding recorded by the Tribunal. The Tribunal shall re-hear the matter, take note of the materials on record and decide the said question afresh.

6.

In so far as the claim for Rs.33,05,000/- representing unaccounted money lending cheques are concerned, the First Appellate Authority has set aside the said finding by giving cogent reasons. That was challenged by the Revenue before the Tribunal. Though the Tribunal has set out in detail the facts regarding the said claim and the contention of the assessee explaining the same, it has not appreciated the material on record, heard the arguments and recorded the finding one way or the other. Therefore, when the Tribunal holds appeal is allowed, if that claim is also set aside without assigning any reasons, it

15 cannot be sustained. Therefore, the said claim also requires to be considered by the Tribunal afresh.

7.

In so far as the cash found at the time of search, Rs.20,03,680/-, the third claim is concerned, the First Appellate Authority has affirmed the finding recorded by the Tribunal. The assessee was in appeal. The Tribunal has not recorded any finding on this aspect of the matter. Again, in the operative portion of the order, states that the appeal is allowed, it cannot be construed as setting aside the order of the Appellate Authority as no reasons are given. Therefore, that aspect also requires to be considered by the Tribunal afresh.

8.

In ITA No.764/2008, a claim for Rs.11,39,000/- was stated to be unaccounted on the basis of the cheque found but the Tribunal has not recorded any finding on that aspect though the First

16 Appellate Authority has granted the relief to the assesee. Hence, we pass the following order:

i) ITA No.760/2008, ITA No.762/2008, ITA No.763/2008, ITA No.765/2005 are dismissed. ii) ITA No.761/2008, ITA No.764/2008, ITA No.766/2008, ITA No.769/2008 are allowed. iii) The impugned order passed by the Tribunal is set aside. The matter is remanded back to the Tribunal for fresh consideration in the light of the observations made in this order.

Ordered accordingly.

Sd/-

JUDGE

Sd/- dh*

JUDGE

More judgments on Section 147

All 57,238 judgments and leading authorities on Section 147 →

Latest GST High Court judgments

Search GST case law →