THE COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX - INTERNATIONAL TAXATION -2 vs. MENTOR GRAPHICS IRELAND LTD.

PDF · subscribers
ITA/611/2019HC DelhiDLHC01028636201919 May 20222 pages
AI SummaryDismissed

What did the High Court hold?

The Delhi High Court held that the questions of law raised in the appeal were conclusively decided in favour of the respondent-assessee by the Supreme Court in the case of Engineering Analysis Centre of Excellence Private Limited vs. Commissioner of Income Tax and Anr., (2021) SCCOnLine SC 159. The Court noted that judicial discipline mandates that a High Court is bound to follow the judgment of the Apex Court until it is set aside. The mere filing of a review application by the Revenue against the Supreme Court's order was not a ground for the High Court to deviate from following the binding precedent. Therefore, as the issues of law had been conclusively decided by the Supreme Court in favour of the assessee, no substantial question of law arose for consideration in the present appeal. Consequently, the appeal was dismissed. No specific finding was given by the High Court on the merits of the ITAT's order, as it relied entirely on the Supreme Court's decision.

What were the facts?

The Revenue, represented by the Commissioner of Income Tax - International Taxation -2, filed an appeal under Section 260A of the Income Tax Act, 1961, against the order dated 26th November, 2018, passed by the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT), Delhi Bench ‘E’. The appeal pertains to Assessment Year 2013-14. The dispute involves the deletion of an addition of Rs. 15,40,57,603/- by the ITAT. The core of the dispute is whether the consideration received by the assessee, Mentor Graphics Ireland Ltd., on granting a license for software use constituted royalty under the Income Tax Act and the India-Ireland Double Taxation Avoidance Agreement (DTAA). The Revenue sought to challenge the ITAT's findings on this matter.

What were the issues?

The Tribunal had to decide the following questions of law: 1. Whether on the facts and in the circumstances of the case and in law, the ITAT was justified in deleting the addition of Rs. 15,40,57,603/- by holding that consideration of Rs. 14,50,57,603/- received by the Assessee on grant of licence for use of software was not Royalty within the meaning of Article 12 of Indo-Ireland DTAA? 2. Whether on the facts and in the circumstances of the case and in law, the ITAT was justified in holding that consideration of Rs. 15,40,57,603/- received by the Assessee on grant of licence for use of software was not Royalty within the meaning of section 9(1)(vi) of the Income Tax Act, 1961? The Revenue contended that the ITAT erred in deleting the addition. The Assessee's contentions are not explicitly recorded in the provided judgment. However, the Revenue's counsel fairly stated that the questions of law are covered by the Supreme Court's decision in Engineering Analysis Centre of Excellence Private Limited vs. Commissioner of Income Tax and Anr., (2021) SCCOnLine SC 159, and that the appeal was filed to keep the matter alive while a review petition was pending before the Supreme Court.

Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?

Section 260A,Section 9(1)(vi)

AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below

$~22 * IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI + ITA 611/2019 THE COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX - INTERNATIONAL TAXATION -2 ..... Appellant Through: Mr.Ruchir Bhatia, standing counsel with Ms.Mansie Jain, Advocate. versus MENTOR GRAPHICS IRELAND LTD. ..... Respondent Through: Mr.Mayank Nagi, Advocate. CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE MANMOHAN HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE MANMEET PRITAM SINGH ARORA O R D E R % 19.05.2022 Present appeal has been filed under Section 260A of the Income Tax Act, 1961 (hereinafter referred to as ‘Act’) for the Assessment Year 2013-14 challenging the judgment and order dated 26th November, 2018 passed by the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal, Delhi Bench ‘E’, New Delhi. The questions of law sought to be agitated by the appellant-Revenue in the present appeal are reproduced hereinbelow:- “A. Whether on the facts and in the circumstances of the case and in law, the ITAT was justified in deleting the addition of Rs.15,40,57,603/- by holding that consideration of Rs.14,50,57,603/- received by the Assessee on grant of licence for use of software was not Royalty within the meaning of Article 12 of Indo- Ireland DTAA? B. Whether on the facts and in the circumstances of the case and in law, the ITAT was justified in holding that consideration of Rs.15,40,57,603/- received by the Assessee on grant of licence for use of software was not Royalty within the meaning of section 9(1)(vi) of the Income Tax Act, 1961?” This is a digitally signed order. The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above. The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 15/06/2026 at 01:29:29

Learned counsel for the appellant fairly states that the aforesaid questions of law are covered by the decision dated 2nd March, 2021 passed by the Supreme Court in Engineering Analysis Centre of Excellence Private Limited vs. Commissioner of Income Tax and Anr., (2021) SCCOnLine SC 159. He, however, states that the Revenue has preferred a review petition against the said order. He states that the present appeal has been filed to keep the matter alive. Judicial discipline mandates that the High Court is bound to follow the judgment and order of the Apex Court till it is set aside. The mere fact that the appellant-Revenue has filed a review application will not be a ground for the High Court to not follow the binding judgment of the Apex Court. Consequently, as the issues of law raised in the present appeal have been conclusively decided in favour of the respondent-assessee by the Supreme Court, no substantial question of law arises for consideration in the present appeal. Accordingly, the same is dismissed. MANMOHAN, J MANMEET PRITAM SINGH ARORA, J MAY 19, 2022/KA This is a digitally signed order. The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above. The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 15/06/2026 at 01:29:29

More judgments on Section 9(1)(vi)

All 1,849 judgments and leading authorities on Section 9(1)(vi) →

Recent GST High Court judgments

Search GST case law →