COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX (TDS)-2 vs. M/S SHREE VARDHMAN DEVELOPERS PVT. LTD.
What did the High Court hold?
The High Court allowed the appeals, setting aside the order of the Tribunal. The Court held that the applicability of Section 194-C of the Income Tax Act, 1961, to payments of External Development Charges (EDC) was to be decided in light of the Court's earlier judgment in Puri Constructions Pvt. Ltd. vs. Additional Commissioner of Income Tax & Ors. The Court found itself unable to sustain the view taken by the Tribunal insofar as it ran contrary to the principles enunciated in Puri Construction. The questions framed were answered in favour of the appellants (Revenue). The operative direction was to set aside the impugned order of the Tribunal to the extent it was contrary to the principles in Puri Construction. The Court noted that an appeal was pending before the Supreme Court against the Puri Constructions judgment but no interim orders were in operation.
What were the facts?
The Commissioner of Income Tax (TDS)-2 (the Revenue) filed two appeals before the Delhi High Court against an order of the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT). The ITAT had deleted the applicability of Tax Deduction at Source (TDS) on External Development Charges (EDC) and interest paid on EDC to Haryana Urban Development Authority/Director of Town & Country Planning (HUDA/DTCP). The respondent is M/s Shree Vardhman Developers Pvt. Ltd. The appeals were admitted and proceeded to be heard on merits, with the High Court noting the pendency of a Special Leave Petition before the Supreme Court against a relevant prior judgment, but without any interim orders being in operation.
What were the issues?
1. Whether the Ld. ITAT and Ld. CIT(A) erred in deleting the applicability of provisions of Tax Deduction at Source (TDS) on External Development Charges (EDC) and Interest paid on EDC to HUDA/DTCP? (Question of law) 2. Whether the decision of Ld. ITAT and Ld. CIT(A) are liable to be set aside in view of the judgment dated 13.02.2024 of this Hon'ble Court in Puri Constructions Pvt. Ltd. vs. ACIT? Assessee's Contentions: The judgment does not record specific contentions made by the assessee (M/s Shree Vardhman Developers Pvt. Ltd.) in these appeals. However, the ITAT and CIT(A) had deleted the applicability of TDS on EDC and interest thereon. Revenue's Contentions: The Revenue contended that TDS provisions were applicable to payments of EDC and interest thereon to HUDA/DTCP. The Revenue relied on the judgment of the High Court in Puri Constructions Pvt. Ltd. vs. ACIT.
Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?
Section 194-C,Section 190,Section 195,Section 196,Section 201,Section 271-C
AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below
ITA 309/2024 & ITA 312/2024 Page 1 of 6
$~18 & 19 * IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI + ITA 309/2024
COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX (TDS)-2.....Appellant
Through: Mr. Vipul Agrawal, SSC along with Mr. Gibran Naushad and Ms. Sakashi Shairwal, JSCs.
versus
M/S SHREE VARDHMAN DEVELOPERS PVT. LTD. .....Respondent Through: Mr. Rajat Juneja, Mr. Anmol Kumar, Advs. 19 + ITA 312/2024
COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX (TDS)-2.....Appellant
Through: Mr. Vipul Agrawal, SSC along with Mr. Gibran Naushad and Ms. Sakashi Shairwal, JSCs.
versus
M/S SHREE VARDHMAN DEVELOPERS PVT. LTD. .....Respondent Through: Mr. Rajat Juneja, Mr. Anmol Kumar, Advs.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE YASHWANT VARMA
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE RAVINDER DUDEJA
O R D E R %
11.09.2024 1. These two appeals have been preferred and have posited the following common questions of law for our consideration: “A. Whether the Ld. ITAT and Ld. CIT(A) erred in deleting the applicability of provisions of Tax Deduction at Source (TDS) on External Development Charges (EDC) and Interest paid on EDC to Haryana Urban Development Authority/Director of Town & Country Planning (HUDA/DTCP)? This is a digitally signed order. The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above. The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 03/07/2025 at 00:35:04
ITA 309/2024 & ITA 312/2024 Page 2 of 6
B. Whether the decision of Ld. ITAT and Ld. CIT(A) are liable to set aside in view of the judgment dated 13.02.2024 of this Hon'ble Court in Puri Constructions Pvt. Ltd. vs. ACIT (2024) 462 ITR 326?” 2. Having heard learned counsels for parties and on going through the order passed by the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal1 dated 21 December 2023, we find that the challenge which stands raised would warrant acceptance bearing in mind the decision rendered by the Court in Puri Constructions Pvt. Ltd. vs. Additional Commissioner of Income Tax & Ors.2 We consequently admit these appeals formally and proceed to examine the issue on merits. 3. In Puri Constructions while dealing with the aspect of the applicability of Chapter XVII-B on the payment of External Development Charges3, we had held as follows: - “48. As was clarified by us in the prefatory parts of this judgment, we propose to decide and rule upon the applicability of Section 194-C of the Act principally and leave it open for the writ petitioners as well as the respondents to proceed further in respect of notices that may have been issued referable to Sections 201 and 271-C of the Act in accordance with the present judgment. We shall also while examining the challenge which stands raised deal with an additional ground which has been urged in some of the writ petitions and which had questioned the validity of the show-cause notices not even referring to the appropriate provision comprised in Chapter 17-B which was sought to be invoked and thus asserting that those notices are liable to be quashed on the ground of lacking in material particulars and being wholly vague. 49. The principal question which stands raised would have to be answered on an understanding of the scope the scope and ambit of Section 194-C. We at the outset note that the aforesaid provision places an obligation on any person responsible for paying a sum to any resident for carrying out any work pursuant to a contract between the resident and a specified person, to deduct tax at source at the time of crediting such sum to the account of the resident or at
1 Tribunal 2 2024 SCC OnLine Del 939 3 EDC This is a digitally signed order. The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above. The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 03/07/2025 at 00:35:04
ITA 309/2024 & ITA 312/2024 Page 3 of 6
the time of payment. The resident, who is envisaged to have a contract with a specified person, is referred to in that provision as the “contractor”. The liability to deduct tax, on an ex facie reading of Section 194-C, stands attracted at the time of payment of any sum or the credit thereof to the account of the contractor. The existence of a contract which is spoken of in Section 194-C is between the contractor and a specified person. The provision thus does not construct a contractual relationship between the person responsible for paying the sum and deducting tax with the contractor as a precondition. This is clearly not a prerequisite for Section 194-C being attracted. For the purposes of Section 194-C, all that is required is a payment being effected to a contractor who has a contractual relationship with a specified person. xxxx
xxxx
xxxx 63. In our considered opinion the fact that EDC is determined, computed or is recoverable by the DTCP is wholly inconsequential since Section 194-C is solely concerned with a payment being made to a contractor who has an arrangement with a specified person. Merely because an exercise of quantification is undertaken by the specified person, the same would have no bearing on the applicability of Section 194-C. We would thus be of the opinion that the moment the petitioners effected a payment in favour of HSVP in connection with the external development work which was to be executed by it pursuant to the arrangement that existed between the said entity and the State Government, the provisions of Section 194-C stood attracted. 64. It is also pertinent to note that Chapter 17-B, and more particularly Section 190 thereof, commences with a non obstante clause and thus places a responsibility upon a person effecting a payment which is taxable under the provisions of the Act to deduct and collect tax at source in accordance with the provisions placed in that chapter. The aforesaid provisions except in certain contingencies and in respect of certain category of payments, does not confer any discretion in a person effecting payment to consider whether tax is liable to be deducted and collected at source. It is only in certain contingencies, such as those which are spoken of in Section 195, that the statute enables the person responsible for effecting a payment to consider whether the amount sought to be paid would be income chargeable under the Act. This is evident from Section 195 which is extracted hereunder: xxxx
xxxx
xxxx 72. Ultimately, the question which warrants consideration is whether EDC was a payment to the State. This must necessarily be answered in the negative bearing in mind the undisputed fact that This is a digitally signed order. The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above. The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 03/07/2025 at 00:35:04
ITA 309/2024 & ITA 312/2024 Page 4 of 6
the income was placed in the hands and at the disposal of HSVP. We note that undisputedly at least till 31-3-2017 all EDC payments even as per the DTCP were being made out in favour of HSVP. It is only thereafter that EDC was deposited with the DTCP. This too leads us to the irresistible conclusion that the payments made to HSVP would not fall within Section 196. 73. We also bear in mind the unambiguous legislative command of Section 194-C which places the payer under the unshrinkable obligation of deducting tax from all payments being made to a contractor. We have already noticed in the preceding parts of this decision that Section 194-C of the Act vests no discretion in the payer to examine or contemplate chargeability of that payment to tax. We, in this connection, note the following pertinent observations as rendered by the Supreme Court in Associated Cement Co. Ltd. v. CIT: xxxx
xxxx
xxxx 74. In light of the foregoing discussion and for reasons set out hereinabove, we find ourselves unable to concur with the view taken by the Tribunal in Santur Infrastructure (P) Ltd. case, Satya Developers (P) Ltd. case, Perfect Constech (P) Ltd. case and Spaze Tower (P) Ltd. case. Those decisions have proceeded on the basis of a contractual obligation between the petitioner and HSVP being a prerequisite. They have additionally based their decision on the fact that HSVP was undertaking external development work on the directives of the DTCP. These, for reasons recorded hereinabove, were factors wholly irrelevant for the purposes of considering the applicability of Section 194-C. 75. That only leaves to consider some of the supplemental questions which were raised and which included the show-cause notices not specifically adverting to the specific provision contained in Chapter 17-B and in terms of which the petitioners were held liable to deduct tax. We, in this regard, also bear in consideration the two earlier rounds of litigation when in the first instance the respondents had sought to hold the petitioners liable to deduct tax under Section 194 in BPTP Ltd. case and subsequently under Section 194-I as is evident from the judgment in DLF Homes Panchkula (PJ Ltd. case. 76. We are of the firm opinion that in matters pertaining to taxation we would not readily import the principle of a power otherwise inhering being sufficient for the purposes of examining the validity of a show-cause notice. Chapter 17-B embodies Sections 192 to 206-AB and refers to various contingencies and situations where a payer is bound in law to deduct tax. The respondents were thus clearly obliged to indicate with sufficient clarity the specific This is a digitally signed order. The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above. The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 03/07/2025 at 00:35:04
ITA 309/2024 & ITA 312/2024 Page 5 of 6
statutory provision contained in Chapter 17-B and which according to them placed an obligation on the petitioners to deduct tax. This aspect of criticality could not have been left to supposition or for the writ petitioners grappling to understand and discern an obligation to deduct tax flowing from any one of the more than the fifty sections comprised in Chapter 17-B. A show-cause notice fundamentally must apprise the noticee of the case that it is called upon to answer, the context in which an explanation is sought and the charge that it has to answer. The notice thus cannot leave the assessee grappling with or trying to discern the provision which it is supposed to have infringed. In the absence of requisite particulars, the show-cause notice would be liable to be quashed on the ground of being wholly vague. As far back as in State of Orissa v. Binapani Deiss, the Supreme Court had pertinently observed: xxxx
xxxx
xxxx 81. The principle of a power otherwise inhering or existing and not being impacted by the mere mention of a wrong provision is one which we apply to ratify, save and uphold a decision which is otherwise found to be valid and sustainable. We would be wary of either readily or unhesitatingly adopting or invoking that precept at the stage of a show-cause notice especially where the noticee is left to fathom which of the more than fifty variable obligations it is alleged to have violated. 82. However, while this may have conceivably been a valid ground to interdict some of the impugned show-cause notices, we find no justification to invoke our prerogative writ powers on this score since the petitioners have, in the course of these proceedings, been afforded more than an ample and adequate opportunity to establish why Section 194-C would not be attracted and have been heard at great length on the questions which were raised. The applicability of Section 194-C also appears to have been expressly raised in the counter-affidavits which were filed and thus placing the petitioners on adequate notice. In any case and in view of the above, we are of the firm opinion that the principles of prejudice would not stand attracted. It would thus be inappropriate at this late stage of the day to interfere with the show-cause notices on this ground.” 4. We take note of the fact that an appeal is stated to have been taken against the decision in Puri Constructions before the Supreme Court in M/s Natureville Promoters Private Limited v. Union of India & Ors.4. We are however not apprised of any interim order(s)
4 SLP(C) No. 11448/2024 This is a digitally signed order. The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above. The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 03/07/2025 at 00:35:04
ITA 309/2024 & ITA 312/2024 Page 6 of 6
that may operate. 5. Accordingly, and for reasons aforenoted, we find ourselves unable to sustain the view taken by the Tribunal and insofar as it runs contrary to the principles enunciated in Puri Construction. The questions as framed are thus answered in favour of the appellants. The impugned order of the Tribunal to the aforesaid extent shall stand set aside.
YASHWANT VARMA, J.
RAVINDER DUDEJA, J. SEPTEMBER 11, 2024/neha This is a digitally signed order. The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above. The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 03/07/2025 at 00:35:04
More judgments on Section 194-C
- Dinakar Jayaraman, Chennai vs DCIT, Ncc-8(1), ChennaiITA 1065/CHNY/2026[2016-17]Status: Disposed29 Jun 2026AY 2016-17
- Commissioner of Income Tax (TDS)-1, Delhi vs Liberty Retail Revolutions LtdITA/170/202522 May 2025
- Commissioner of Income Tax (TDS)-1, Delhi vs Liberty Retail Revolutions LtdITA - 170 / 202522 May 2025
- M/S. Chandan Trans-Cons Pvt. Ltd, Rourkela vs DCIT, Rourkela Circle, RourkelaITA 15/CTK/2024[2009-10]Status: Heard9 Jul 2024AY 2009-10
- M/S. Chandan Trans-Cons Pvt. Ltd, Rourkela vs DCIT, Rourkela Circle, RourkelaITA 14/CTK/2024[2008-09]Status: Heard9 Jul 2024AY 2008-09
Recent GST High Court judgments
Search GST case law →- Kbb Nuts PVT. Limited vs. Mr. Suresh Chand & Ors.Delhi · 3 Nov 2026
- Amritsar Haveli Cuisines Private Limited & Anr. vs. Amarbir Singh & Ors.Delhi · 3 Nov 2026
- Abd Maestro Private Limited vs. Great Galleon Ventures LTDDelhi · 3 Nov 2026
- Jangeer Singh Trading As Jangeer Singh Kabulshah Agriculture Works vs. Yogesh Jangid Trading As Jangid Agro Engineering & Anr.Delhi · 3 Nov 2026
- Rabindranath Behera vs. The Chief Commissioner, CT And GST, OdishaOrissa · 3 Nov 2026