PR. COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX -7 vs. SHRI SANJAY CHANDRA

PDF · subscribers
ITA/249/2024HC DelhiDLHC01056642202201 May 2024Bench: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE PURUSHAINDRA KUMAR KAURAV,HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE YASHWANT VARMA4 pages
AI SummaryDismissed

What did the High Court hold?

The High Court found no merit in the appeal. It noted that the ITAT had correctly concluded that the issue of valuation, if applicable, had to follow the procedure prescribed by Section 56(2)(vii)(c) of the Act read with Rule 11UA of the Income Tax Rules, 1962. The ITAT had also found that the market value of the shares was negative and far below the value paid by the assessee. The High Court observed that these findings by the ITAT were neither questioned before it nor asserted to be perverse or contrary to the record. Consequently, the High Court dismissed the appeal. No issue was expressly left undecided.

What were the facts?

The Principal Commissioner of Income Tax (PCIT) appealed an order of the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT) dated November 8, 2019. The ITAT had deleted additions of Rs. 646,80,72,998/- made under Section 56(2)(vii)(c) of the Income Tax Act. The Assessing Officer (AO) based the addition on the fair market value of shares, specifically a transaction value of Rs. 179.73 per share with Telenor. The ITAT found that the shares purchased by the assessee of Simpson Unitech Wireless Pvt. Ltd. and Acorus Unitech Wireless Pvt. Ltd. from Unitech Holdings Pvt. Ltd. at Rs. 10/- were below book and fair market value due to significant losses, resulting in a negative value. The ITAT confirmed the findings of the Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals) and dismissed the revenue's appeal.

What were the issues?

1. Whether the ITAT erred in deleting additions of Rs. 646,80,72,998/- under Section 56(2)(vii)(c) of the Income Tax Act, which pertains to taxing the difference between the fair market value and consideration for certain property received by an assessee. 2. Whether the ITAT erred in deleting the addition without a speaking order, failing to decide the actual grounds of appeal raised by the department. 3. Whether the ITAT erred in deleting the addition made under Section 56(2)(vii)(c)(ii) as the difference between the fair market value (FMV) of shares of AUWPL & SUWPL and the acquisition price, without appreciating that the basis for FMV was a concrete price of Rs. 179.73 per share paid by Telenor, and that Section 56(2)(vii)(c)(ii) does not require actual receipt of money/income for taxing the difference. 4. Whether the ITAT erred in not appreciating that the FMV of shares of AUWPL & SUWPL should be calculated considering the intrinsic value of the underlying asset (shares of Unitech Wireless Companies) rather than the face value, and that the premium of Rs. 169.73 per share was a concrete figure. 5. Whether the ITAT erred in not applying landmark judgments of the Supreme Court in Sumati Dayal vs CIT and CIT vs Durga Prasad More regarding appreciation of explanations based on human probabilities, and McDowell and Company Limited regarding colorable devices in tax planning. Assessee's Contentions: The ITAT found that the shares had a negative value due to losses, and the AO's basis for valuation (Telenor's transaction) was incorrect. The ITAT held that valuation should follow Section 56(2)(vii)(c) and Rule 11UA, and the market value was negative. The High Court noted that these findings were not questioned or asserted as perverse. Revenue's Contentions: The PCIT argued that the ITAT erred in deleting the additions, that the ITAT's order was not speaking, and that the FMV calculation was flawed, ignoring the concrete price paid by Telenor and the intrinsic value of the underlying assets. The PCIT also argued that the ITAT failed to apply relevant Supreme Court judgments.

Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?

Section 56(2)(vii)(c)

AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below

$~191 * IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI + ITA 249/2024

PR. COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX -7 ..... Appellant

Through: Mr.Puneet Rai, Sr.SC with

Mr.Ashivini Kumar and

Mr.Rishabh Nangia, Advs.

versus

SHRI SANJAY CHANDRA

..... Respondent

Through: None.

CORAM:

HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE YASHWANT VARMA

HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE PURUSHAINDRA KUMAR

KAURAV

O R D E R %

01.05.2024

CM APPL. 25301/2024 (Exemption) 1. Allowed, subject to all just exceptions. 2. Application is disposed of. CM APPL. 25302/2024 (Delay in re-filling) 1. This is an application filed by the appellant seeking condonation of 625 days' delay in re-filing the present appeal. 2. For the reasons stated in the application, the delay of 625 days in re-filing the appeal is condoned. 3. Application is disposed of. ITA 249/2024 4. The Principal Commissioner of Income Tax [“PCIT”] impugns the order of the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal [“ITAT”] dated 08 November 2019 and has proposed the following questions of law for our consideration:-

“A. Whether on the facts and circumstances of the case and in This is a digitally signed order. The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above. The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 08/05/2024 at 12:41:45

law the Hon’ble ITAT has erred in law in deleting the additions of Rs. 646,80,72,998/- u/s 56(2)(vii)(c) of the act which provides that when an assessee or HUF receive in any previous year from any person or persons on or after 01.10.2009, any moveable property for a consideration which is less than the aggregate fair market value of the property by an amount exceeding fifty thousand rupees, the aggregate fair market value of such property as exceeds such consideration shall be chargeable to income tax under the head “Income from Other Sources”. B. Whether on the facts and circumstances of the case and in law the Hon’ble ITAT has erred in deleting the addition of Rs. 646,80,72,998/- without making a speaking order since actual ground of appeal raised by the department in its appeal has not been decided by the Hon’ble ITAT. C. Whether on the facts and circumstances of the case and in law the Hon’ble ITAT has erred in deleting the addition of Rs. 646,80,72,998/- made u/s 56(2)(Vii)(c)(ii), being the difference between F.M.V of the shares of AUWPL & SUWPL and the price shown for the acquisition of these shares by assessee without appreciating that the basis for valuing the said FMV was a real & concrete price of Rs. 179,73 per share of Unitech Wireless Companies paid by Telenor which was the underlying asset held by AUWPL & SUWPL and the Hon’ble ITAT also failed to appreciate that Section 56(2)(vii)(c)(ii) does not envisage actual receipt of money/income for taxing the difference between price paid & its FMV.” D. Whether, on the facts and circumstances of the case and in law the Hon’ble ITAT has erred innot appreciating that FMV of the shares of the said 2 affiliate companies viz AUWPL, & SUWPL have to be calculated by considering the correct intrinsic value of the main under lying asset of these companies which is the shares of Unitech Wireless Companies shown as Investment in its Balance Sheet whereas the assessee while computing the FMV of the said share of the 2 affiliate companies have adopted the face value of the shares in Unitech Wireless Companies held by the said affiliate companies and have ignored the premium portion of Rs. 169.73, whereas in the instant case, the premium of Rs. 169.73 per share in respect of shares of 8 Unitech Wireless Companies is not an imaginary figure, instead it is a concrete & real figure which is arrived atafter negation between Unitech Ltd, 8 Unitech Wireless Companies and Telenor Communications As, Norway.” E. Whether, on the facts and circumstances of the case and in law while deciding this appeal the Hon’ble ITAT has erred in not applying the Landmark judgements of Hon Apex This is a digitally signed order. The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above. The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 08/05/2024 at 12:41:45

Court in Sumati Dayal vs CIT 214 ITR 801 and CIT vs Durga Prasad More 82 ITR 540 wherein it washeld that any explanation submitted in income tax proceedings has to beAppreciated in the light of human probabilities than on mechanical aspects and the landmark decision of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of McDowell and Company Limited, 154 ITR 148 wherein it has beenheld that tax planning may be legitimate provided it is within theframework of the law and any colourable devices cannot be part of tax planning and it is wrong to encourage or entertain the belief that it ishonourable to avoid the payment of tax by dubious methods.”

5.

We note that the following significant findings have come to be returned by the ITAT in the order impugned before us:

"5. After hearing both the parties and on perusal of the impugned order, we find that it is an undisputed fact that the shares purchased by the assessee of Simpson Unitech Wireless Pvt. Ltd. and Acorus Unitech Wireless Pvt. Ltd. from Unitech Holdings Pvt. Ltd. at Rs.10/- was not only below the book value but also below the fair market value, because these companies were having negative value due to huge losses made in the earlier years. The Assessing Officer had tried to make the addition solely on the ground that premium of Rs. 179.73 per share in respect of eight Unitech Wireless Company paid by the Telenor Company is the basis to value the shares. Such a reasoning, first of all could not be upheld because the valuation if at all of the share has to be done either in terms of Rule 11UA or in terms of Section 56(2)(vii)(c) which provides that it has to be as per the market value and the market value of the share has been found to be negative and far below the value of the shares paid by the assessee. Ld. CIT DR also could not rebut the factual finding arrived by the Ld. CIT (A) which is based on material on record. Thus, we do not find any infirmity in the findings of the Ld. CIT (A), and therefore, the same is confirmed. Consequently, the appeal filed by the Revenue is dismissed."

6.

The ITAT has taken into consideration what appears to be the undisputed position of the Assessing Officer ["AO"] having essentially been guided by the transactional value of INR 179.73/- per share which constituted the substratum of a contract with Telenor. 7. It has thus and in our considered opinion correctly come to This is a digitally signed order. The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above. The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 08/05/2024 at 12:41:45

conclude that the issue of valuation, if liable to be undertaken, had to follow the route as prescribed by Section 56(2)(vii)(c) of the Act read along with Rule 11UA of the Income Tax Rules, 1962. 8. It was additionally found that the market value of the shares was in in any case found to be negative and far below the value which was paid by the respondent-assessee. 9. The aforesaid findings are neither questioned before us and nor are they asserted to be perverse or contrary to the record. 10. In view of the aforesaid, we find no merit in the instant appeal.It shall consequently stand dismissed.

YASHWANT VARMA, J.

PURUSHAINDRA KUMAR KAURAV, J. MAY 01, 2024/MJ

This is a digitally signed order. The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above. The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 08/05/2024 at 12:41:45

More judgments on Section 56(2)(vii)(c)

All 57 judgments and leading authorities on Section 56(2)(vii)(c) →

Recent GST High Court judgments

Search GST case law →