The Commisioner of Income-tax vs. M/s. Hyderabad Industries Ltd.,
What did the High Court hold?
The Tribunal was correct in its findings. Regarding the first issue, the Tribunal held that the Assessing Officer's action of disallowing the bonus claim under Section 43B was outside the purview of Section 143(1)(a). The Tribunal reasoned that while rectification under Section 154 is permissible for intimations under Section 143(1)(a), a debatable issue requiring such rectification militates against a simple Section 143(1)(a) intimation. The proper course would have been to issue a notice under Section 143(2). Furthermore, the Tribunal found that the bonus payment, though made after March 31st, was made before the due date for filing the return, satisfying the proviso to Section 43B. The Assessing Officer cannot question the propriety of the bonus quantum if it was factually paid. Regarding the second issue, the Revenue conceded that it was covered by the judgment in Commissioner of Income Tax v. Lakshmi Machine Works, against the Revenue. Therefore, the Tribunal's order was upheld.
What were the facts?
The Revenue appealed against the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal's order concerning the assessment year 1995-96 for M/s. Hyderabad Industries Ltd. The assessee had claimed a deduction of Rs. 2,42,83,798/- as bonus paid to employees. The initial return was accepted under Section 143(1)(a). Subsequently, the Assessing Officer initiated rectification proceedings under Section 154, noting that the provision for bonus in the books was Rs. 1,26,95,168/-, and the remaining amount was paid after March 31st of the concerned year. The assessee contended that the higher bonus payment was due to a Government ordinance and an agreement with workers, and the amount was paid before the return filing due date. The Assessing Officer disallowed the differential amount under Section 43B. The CIT(A) dismissed the assessee's appeal, but the Tribunal allowed it.
What were the issues?
1. Whether the Tribunal was correct in holding that the disallowance of the claim of bonus amounting to Rs.1,14,00,983/- made under Section 43B of the Income Tax Act was outside the purview of Section 143(1)(a) of the Income Tax Act, 1961? 2. Whether the Tribunal was correct in holding that excise duty did not form part of the total turnover for the purpose of computing the deduction under Section 80HHC of the Income Tax Act? Assessee's contentions: - The difference between the provision and actual payment of bonus is not relevant. - The quantum of bonus paid is dependent on several factors and the Assessing Officer cannot question its propriety. - If bonus is paid before the last date for filing returns, Section 43B would cover such payments. - The Tribunal correctly interpreted Section 43B. Revenue's contentions: - The Tribunal's view on the justification for taking recourse to Section 154 and the purport of Section 143(1)(a) is unsustainable. - The interpretation of Section 154 by the Tribunal is too narrow, and it applies to intimations under Section 143(1)(a) as well. - Since the differential amount was paid after March 31st, it could not be brought under the purview of Section 43B.
Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?
Section 143(1)(a),Section 154,Section 43B,Section 143(2),Section 80HHC
AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below
* HON’BLE SRI JUSTICE L. NARASIMHA REDDY
+ I.T.T.A No. 141 OF 2004
% Dated 17-12-2014
The Commissioner of Income Tax, Hyderabad - I
…Appellant
VERSUS
$ M/s. Hyderabad Industries Ltd., Hyderabad …..Respondent
! Counsel for the Appellant: Smt. Kiranmayee for Sri J.V. Prasad
^Counsel for the Respondent: Sri Ch. Pushyam Kiran
<GIST:
>HEAD NOTE:
? Cases referred 1. 290 ITR 667
HON’BLE SRI JUSTICE L. NARASIMHA REDDY
I.T.T.A No.141 OF 2004
17-12-2014
BETWEEN
The Commissioner of Income Tax, Hyderabad - I …Appellant
And
M/s. Hyderabad Industries Ltd., Hyderabad …..Respondent
HON’BLE SRI JUSTICE L. NARASIMHA REDDY
I.T.T.A No. 141 OF 2004
JUDGMENT: (per the Hon'ble Sri Justice L. Narasimha Reddy)
The Revenue filed this appeal by raising the following questions: “1. Whether on the facts and in the circumstances of the case, the Tribunal was correct in law in holding that the disallowance of the claim of bonus amounting to Rs.1,14,00,983/- made under sec.43B of the Income Tax Act was outside the purview of sec. 143(1)(a) of the Income Tax Act, 1961?
Whether on the facts and in the circumstances of the case, the Tribunal was correct in law in holding that excise duty did not form part of the total turn over for the purpose of computing the deduction under sec.80HHC of the Income Tax Act?”
The respondent is an industry and is an assessee under the Income Tax Act, 1961 (for short, ‘the Act’). In the return filed by it for the assessment year 1995-96, it claimed inter alia deduction of a sum of Rs.2,42,83,798/- as bonus paid to the employees. The return was accepted through intimation under Section 143(1)(a) of the Act by the assessing officer. However at a later stage, he initiated steps under
Section 154 of the Act for rectification. The reason furnished by him was that in the books of account for the concerned year, provision was made only for a sum of Rs.1,26,95,168/- for bonus, whereas almost double the amount was paid. It was also observed that the remaining amount was paid after the 31st March of the concerned year and at the most, it could have been reflected in the subsequent year. The respondent took the plea that though provision was made only for a limited amount, a higher amount of bonus had to be paid on account of the ordinance issued by the Government and that the amount was paid before the filing of return for the concerned year.
Not satisfied with the explanation offered by the respondent, the assessing officer passed an order excluding the differential amount from the purview of Section 43B of the Act. Aggrieved by that, the respondent filed an appeal before the Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals-IV), Hyderabad. The appeal was dismissed. Thereafter, it filed ITA No. 452/Hyd/1998 before the Hyderabad Bench ‘B’ of the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (for short, ‘the Tribunal’). The appeal was allowed through a common order dated 29-11-2002 passed in a bunch of eight appeals. Hence, this appeal
Smt. Kiranmayee, learned counsel representing Sri J.V.Prasad, learned Standing Counsel for the appellant, submits that the view taken by the Tribunal, be it as regards justification on the part of the assessing officer in taking recourse to Section 154 of the Act or the purport of Section 143 (1) (a) of the Act cannot be sustained in law. She contends that the interpretation placed by the Tribunal on Section 154 of the Act in this behalf is too narrow and for invoking that provision, it does not make any difference whether the subject matter is an order passed under Section 143(3) or intimation under Section 143(1)(a). She further contends that once the differential amount was admittedly paid subsequent to 31st March of the concerned year, there was no way that it could have been brought under the purview of Section 43B of the Act.
Sri Ch. Pushyam Kiran, learned counsel for the respondent, on the other hand, submits that the difference between the provision made for payment of bonus and the actual payment is not of much relevance under the Act. He contends that the quantum of bonus paid by an industry would depend upon several factors and at any rate, an authority under the Act cannot pronounce upon the propriety or otherwise as to the quantum of percentage of bonus. He further submits that once the payment was made before the last date for filing of returns of a particular assessment year, Section 43B of the Act would cover such payments and the Tribunal has taken the correct view of the matter. Being an industry covered by the provisions of the Payment of Bonus Act, the respondent is under obligation to pay bonus year after year. As is fairly well known, the percentage of bonus to be paid in a particular year would depend upon several factors. The Act itself stipulates the minimum bonus as 8.33% of the basic pay of an employee. In a given case for a given year, the appropriate Government may issue notification stipulating any other figure as minimum bonus or there may exist agreements between the factory and the workers. In the instant case, both the factors existed. On the one hand, the Government issued ordinance stipulating the percentage of bonus and on the other hand, there existed an agreement between the management and the workers.
It is no doubt true that the respondent made provision for Rs.1,26,95,168/- in its books of account towards bonus. That figure hardly has any sanctity or authenticity. It appears that the figure was mentioned, taking into account the liability that was incurred under that head for the previous year. Even where the appropriate Government does not issue any ordinance or notification or in the absence of any agreement, an industry has its own discretion to pay the bonus of its choice, subject to statutory requirements. It is no facet of the power of the assessing officer to tell upon the justification or otherwise as to the percentage of bonus paid by an assessee. The only thing he can verify is as to whether bonus has been paid as a matter of fact. If it is paid, deduction has to be permitted under Section 43B of the Act and otherwise not. It is not even the case of the appellant that the amount of Rs.2,42,83,798/- was not paid as bonus for that year.
Another facet of this very aspect is whether an intimation given under Section 143 (1) (a) of the Act could have been the subject matter of exercise under Section 154 of the Act. The facility of rectification of any mistake is created under Section 154 of the Act. A perusal of the same discloses that what can be rectified is an order passed under the provisions of the Act or even an intimation under sub-section (1) of Section 143 of the Act. Though it cannot be said that the assessing officer committed any mistake in taking recourse to Section 154 of the Act vis-à-vis an intimation under Section 143 (1) (a) of the Act, a semblance of contradiction is manifest. If there exists any debatable issue warranting exercise under Section 154 of the Act, that very ground militates against the steps under Section 143 (1) (a) simplicitor. The proper recourse would have been to issue notice under Section 143(2) of the Act, to give an opportunity to the assessee and then pass an order. This however is purely academic in the instant case.
The next question is about the applicability or otherwise of Section 43B of the Act to the facts of the case. Payment of bonus, no doubt, was made after 31st March of the concerned year. However, it was before the due date for submission of returns. The proviso to Section 43B of the Act is to the effect that the amount must be actually paid by the assessee “on or before due date applicable in his case for furnishing the return of income”. Admittedly, the payment was made before the due date for filing of the return.
The discussion undertaken above is referable to question No.1. So far as question No.2 is concerned, in all fairness, learned counsel for the appellant stated that the question is covered by the judgment in Commissioner of Income Tax v. Lakshmi Machine Works, against the Revenue.
Viewed from any angle, we do not find any basis to interfere with the order passed by the Tribunal. The appeal is accordingly dismissed. There shall be no order as to costs.
___________________________ L. NARASIMHA REDDY, J
____________________________ CHALLA KODANDA RAM, J 17-12-2014 ks Note: LR Copy to be marked. B/O ks
More judgments on Section 154
- Sanjeev Kumar, Uttar Pradesh vs Ward 3 (2)(4) Muzaffarnagar, Aayakar…ITA 6556/DEL/2026[2021-22]Status: Disposed18 Nov 2026AY 2021-22
- Sanjeev Kumar, Uttar Pradesh vs Ward 3 (2)(4) Muzaffarnagar, Aayakar…ITA 6555/DEL/2026[2020-21]Status: Disposed18 Nov 2026AY 2020-21
- Lowes India Private Limited, Bangalore vs Deputy Commissioner of Income Tax, Circle…ITA 1245/BANG/2026[2022-23]Status: Disposed16 Nov 2026AY 2022-23
- Dyneshwar Nagrao Nimbulkar Through Legal… vs ITO Ward 4(4), NagpurITA 817/NAG/2026[2011-2012]Status: Disposed16 Nov 2026AY 2011-2012
- Dyneshwar Nagrao Nimbulkar Through Legal… vs ITO Ward 4(4), NagpurITA 816/NAG/2026[2011-2012]Status: Disposed16 Nov 2026AY 2011-2012
Recent GST High Court judgments
Search GST case law →- Tvl. Devaerakkam Mercy Mary vs. The Assistant Commissioner (St)Madras · 4 Nov 2026
- Procter And Gamble Health LTD vs. Union Of INDIATelangana · 4 Nov 2026
- M/S Ritika Ispat PVT. Limited, Balanda, Sundargarh vs. The Commissioner Of Commercial Taxes And Goods And Services Tax, Odisha, CuttackOrissa · 4 Nov 2026
- M/S.Ritika Ispat PVT. LTD.,Balanda, Sundergarh vs. The Commissioner Of Commercial Taxes And Goods And Services Tax, Odisha, CuttackOrissa · 4 Nov 2026
- Biswanath Pradhan vs. The Principal Commnr., CGST And Central Excise, BhubaneswarOrissa · 4 Nov 2026