MENZIES AVIATION BOBBA(BANGALORE) PRIVATE LIMITED,BENGALURU vs. INCOME TAX DEPARTMENT, THE ASSISTANT COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX - CIRCLE 4(1)(1), BENGALURU

PDF · subscribers
ITA 665/BANG/2025Status: DisposedITAT Bangalore29 October 202610 pages
AI SummaryPartly Allowed

What did the Tribunal hold?

The Tribunal held that the final assessment order, though dated 30.09.2024, was communicated to the assessee on 09.01.2025. Following the decisions of the Hon'ble Kerala High Court in Govt. Wood Works v. State of Kerala and the Hon'ble Jurisdictional High Court in M/s Maharaja Shopping Complex vs. DCIT, the Tribunal considered the order to be passed only on 09.01.2025. This date was beyond the limitation period provided in section 144C(13) of the Act, which mandates the AO to pass the final assessment order within one month of receiving DRP directions. Consequently, the impugned final assessment order was held to be bad in law and quashed. Grounds No. 2 & 3 raised by the assessee were allowed. As relief was granted on this issue, other grounds were rendered academic and dismissed as infructuous.

What were the facts?

The assessee, Menzies Aviation Bobba(Bangalore) Private Limited, filed an appeal against the final assessment order dated 30.09.2024, passed under section 143(3) r.w.s. 144C(13) of the Income Tax Act, 1961, for AY 2021-22. This order was passed pursuant to directions from the Dispute Resolution Panel (DRP). The assessee contended that the final assessment order was barred by limitation as it was communicated on 09.01.2025, not on the date mentioned in the order (30.09.2024). The assessee argued that the order was uploaded on the ITBA portal and intimated to the assessee and AO on 09.01.2025, making it effectively passed on that date. The revenue did not file any reply or documentation to rebut this contention.

What were the issues?

1. Whether the final assessment order dated 30.09.2024, passed under section 143(3) read with section 144C(13) of the Act, is barred by limitation under section 153 of the Act, as it was communicated on 09.01.2025 instead of 30.09.2024, violating section 282 read with Rule 127 of the Act. Assessee's Contention: The final assessment order is barred by limitation as it was effectively passed on 09.01.2025, the date of its communication, not the date mentioned in the order. Reliance was placed on the principle that an order is passed when it is pronounced, published, or the affected party has the means of knowing it, citing Kerala High Court in Govt. Wood Works v. State of Kerala and Karnataka High Court in M/s Maharaja Shopping Complex vs. DCIT. Revenue's Contention: No specific argument recorded in the judgment. The revenue did not place on record any reply or documentation to rebut the assessee's claim regarding the date of passing the order.

Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?

Section 143(3),Section 144C(13),Section 153,Section 282,Section 234A,Section 234B,Section 234C,Section 270A

AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below

Income Tax Appellate Tribunal, BANGALORE BENCHES, BANGALORE

Before: SHRI BALAKRISHNAN S & SHRI SANDEEP SINGH KARHAIL

आयकर अपीलीय अधिकरण, बेंगलुरू पीठें, बेंगलुरू INCOME TAX APPELLATE TRIBUNAL, BANGALORE BENCHES, BANGALORE BENCH: C BEFORE SHRI BALAKRISHNAN S, ACCOUNTANT MEMBER AND SHRI SANDEEP SINGH KARHAIL, JUDICIAL MEMBER IT(TP)A 665/BANG/2025 (निर्धारण वर्ा/Assessment Year: AY 2021-22) MENZIES AVIATION INCOME TAX DEPARTMENT, BOBBA(BANGALORE) PRIVATE THE ASSISTANT LIMITED COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX - CIRCLE 4(1)(1) NO.2, 2ND FLOOR, MOTI CHAMBERS,4TH A MAIN ROAD, ROOM NO. 230, 2ND FLOOR, Vs. EMINENT POWER SYSTEMS, BMTC DEPOT BUILDING,80 HEBBAL, BENGALURU-560024, FEET ROAD, KORAMANGALA, KARNATAKA BENGALURU-560095, KARNATAKA अपीलधर्थी Appellant प्रत्यर्थी Respondent

Permanent Account Number of Assessee: AAECM6862D

अपीलधर्थी द्वारा/Appellant represented by: Sri. Sumeet Khurana, CA प्रत्यर्थी द्वारा/Respondent represented by: Ms. Pavuna Sundari, CIT on behalf of CIT DR सुनवाई की तारीख / Date of conclusion of hearing: 18-Aug-2026 घोषणा की तारीख / Date of pronouncement: 29-Oct-2026 आदेश / ORDER PER SANDEEP SINGH KARHAIL, JUDICIAL MEMBER: The assessee has filed the present appeal against the impugned final assessment order dated 30.09.2024, passed under section 143(3) r.w.s. 144C(13) of the Income Tax Act, 1961 (“the Act”), pursuant to the directions dated 27.08.2024 issued by the leanred Dispute Resolution Panel – 2, Bengaluru (“learned DRP”), for the assessment year 2021-22.

2.

In this appeal, the assessee has raised the following grounds: - General Ground: 1. On the facts and circumstances of the case and in law, the final assessment order passed by the Learned Assessing Officer (Ld. AO), pursuant to the directions of the Hon'ble Dispute Resolution Panel-2. Bangalore (Panel), and the order of the Ld. Deputy Commissioner of Income-tax, Transfer Pricing-Circle (2)(1) (1), Bangalore (Ld. TPO') to the extent prejudicial to the Appellant, is bad in law and facts and liable to be quashed. Legal Grounds: Final Assessment Order barred by limitation under section 153 of the Income-tax Act, 1961 ('the Act) as it was not served as per section 282 of the Act 2. On the facts and circumstances of the case and in law, the final assessment order dated 30 September 2024, passed under section 143(3) read with section 144C(13) of the Income-tax Act, 1961 (the Act') is barred by limitation as per section 153 of the Act, as the same was communicated on 09 January 2025 instead of 30 September 2024 violating section 282 read with Rule 127 of the Act. While doing so, the Ld. AD erred in: a) generating the impugned order manually whereas the draft assessment order was system generated. which proves that ITBA portal was functioning properly for the Appellant (b) issuing final assessment order quoting Document Identification Number manually on the body of said order dated 09 January 2025 in contravention to the Circular No. 19 of 2019 by the CBDT and thus rendering such an order to be invalid and never to have been issued as per para 4 to the said Circular. 3. On the facts and circumstances of the case and in law, the final assessment order itself is invalid, the consequential demand notice dated 30 September 2024 (received on 09 January 2025) and the penalty notice issued under section 270A on 09 January 2025 are unsustainable in law and must be quashed. Final Assessment order is time barred under section 153(1) as the reference to TPO was made after the time limit 4. On the facts and in the circumstances of the case and in law, the Learned AO erred in making the reference after time limit provided in section 153(1) of the Act making the assessment time barred.

Assessment proceedings are without jurisdiction

5.

On the facts and in the circumstances of the case and in law, the initiation of assessment proceeding and the draft order passed dated November 28, 2023, having been issued and passed by National Faceless Assessment Centre ('NFAC') respectively are without jurisdiction as the case was transferred to Jurisdictional Assessing Officer on February 15, 2022. Grounds relating to Transfer Pricing (‘TP’) Payment of Technical Services

6.

On the facts and in the circumstances of the case and in law, the Hon'ble DRP erred in upholding the action of Ld. AO/Ld. TPO in making an adjustment of INR 7,80.00,000 towards payment of technical service. 7. On the facts and in the circumstances of the case and in law, the Ld. AO/Hon'ble DRP/Ld. TPO erred in arbitrarily determining the arm's length price of payment of technical service paid to the Associate Enterprise (AEs) as INR NIL. While doing so, the Ld. AO/Hon'ble DRP/Ld. TPO grossly erred in: 7.1. discarding the Appellant's aggregate approach that applied the Transactional Net Margin Method ('TNMM’) method in its TP Study and selecting the Comparable Uncontrolled Price (CUP) method instead, and in relying on a hypothetical CUP as per Rule 10AB of the Rules, on the basis that no third party would pay for such services. 7.2. observing that the margins Le., 29.43% are not commensurate with payment of these services by ignoring that the comparable margins range from 1.21% to 1.88%. 7.3. observing that the basic evidence to support the claim of costs incurred at the AE's end are not available without appreciating that those documents does not belong to the Appellant and the Appellant has no right to ask for same. 7.4. incorrectly observing that the service fee is higher than last year whereas the service fee is same as last year i.e., INR 7,80,00,000 7.5 observing that the TPO is required to investigate whether the cost allocated as per determined keys is reasonable/legitimate cost by disregarding the terms of agreement which provide for a lump sum fee of INR 7,80,00,000 7.6. transgressing the powers provided under section 92CA of the Act by arbitrarily adjudicating on the justification for the expenses incurred for the business rather than whether the value of the international transactions was in accordance with the arm's length principle. 7.7. making contradictory observations that the Appellant did not demonstrate whether the services are actually rendered while the Hon'ble DRP has acknowledged that based on evidence submitted the services are in the nature of management control and general information sharing, thereby, reaching an incorrect conclusion. 7.8. Concluding that the Appellant did not show tangible and direct benefit commensurate to the payment made the services received from the AE 7.9. concluding that the Appellant is required to furnish documentary evidence which can prove the payment had been made actually, Grounds relating to corporate tax ('CT') Genuineness of expenses 8. On the facts and in the circumstances of the case and in law, the Learned AO/Hon'ble DRP erred in disallowing the payment made to Aviation Ground Supp of INR 20,83,333 on which TDS of 78,125 by observing that the Appellant had failed to furnish the details of nature of payment, TDS deducted, however the same was furnished by the Appellant vide submission dated 01 August 2024 filed before the Learned AD and Hon'ble DRP. Addition on account of undisclosed sales 9. On the facts and in the circumstances of the case and in law, the Learned AO/Hon'ble DRP has erred in making an addition of INR 29,09,662 being 4% of the difference of INR 7,27,41,555 between the sales reported in GSTR-3 and income tax return and while doing so, grossly erred in disregarding the reconciliation submitted by the Appellant. Deduction under section 80G 10. On the facts and in the circumstances of the case and in law, the Learned AO had failed to follow the directions of Hon'ble DRP violating the provisions of section 144C(13) of the Act, wherein the Hon'ble DRP had observed that the payment of INR 4,00,000 made to Indian Institute of Science is eligible for deduction under section 80G(2)(a)(iiif) of the Act and had directed to allow the total deduction under section 80G of INR 47,14,000 Non-adjustment on account of ICDS 11. On the facts and in the circumstances of the case and in law, the Learned AO had failed to follow the directions of Hon'ble DRP violating the provisions of section 144C(13) of the Act, wherein the Hon'ble DRP had observed that the already disallowed INR 51332517 and disallowance by Learned AO will result in double disallowance, thereby directed the Learned AO to delete the disallowance. Levy of interest under section 234A, 2348 and 234C of the Act 12. On the facts and in the circumstances of the case and in law, the Learned AO has erred in levying interest under section 234A, 2348 and 234C of the Act.

Initiation of penalty proceedings under section 270A of the Act 13. On the facts and in the circumstances of the case and in law, the Learned AO has erred in initiating penalty proceedings under section 270A of the Act. 3. Ground No. 1 is general in nature. Therefore, the same needs no separate adjudication.

4.

In Grounds No. 2 & 3, raised in the present appeal, the assessee has challenged the validity of the final assessment order on the basis that the same was passed beyond the limitation period prescribed under section 144C(13) of the Act.

5.

During the hearing, the learned Authorised Representative (“learned AR”) submitted that the learned DRP issued directions under section 144C(5) of the Act on 27.08.2024 and these directions were sent to the assessee as well as the Assessing Officer (“AO”) vide e-mail dated 27.08.2024. The learned AR submitted that accordingly, the AO ought to have passed the order on or before 30.09.2024, i.e. within one month from the end of the month in which such direction was received. The learned AR submitted that in the present case, only on 09.01.2025 the final assessment order dated 30.09.2024 was uploaded on ITBA Portal. It was submitted that prior to the said date no order was available on the ITBA Portal and in this regard the learned AR placed on record the screenshot of the ITBA Portal as on 09.12.2024. The learned AR further submitted that even the letter intimating the Document Identification Number (“DIN”) of the assessment order is dated 09.01.2025. The learned AR further submitted that the penalty notice under section 274 r.w.s. 270A of the Act was also issued on 09.01.2025. In order to further substantiate its claim that the impugned final assessment order was not issued within the time prescribed under section 144C(13) of the Act, the learned AR submitted that the DIN series for services generated in October 2024 commenced with Numeric sequence “10698…” whereas the DIN for the impugned final assessment order begins with “10720…”.

In this regard, on a sample basis the learned AR placed on record the redacted copy of assessment order dated 28.10.2024 in case of some other assessee. Thus, the learned AR submitted that since DIN is allotted in a chronological and sequential manner, a DIN bearing the higher running number cannot validly pertain to a date in September 2024 if lower number DIN were issued only subsequently in October 2024. Accordingly, the learned AR submitted that the impugned final assessment order, though dated 30.09.2024 was only passed on 09.01.2025, i.e. that date on which the said order was uploaded on ITBA Portal, and therefore, was not passed within the time prescribed under section 144C(13) of the Act.

6.

Before proceeding further, it is relevant to note the provisions of section 144C(13) of the Act, and the same reads as follows: - (13) Upon receipt of the directions issued under sub-section (5), the Assessing Officer shall, in conformity with the directions, complete, notwithstanding anything to the contrary contained in section 153 or section 153B, the assessment without providing any further opportunity of being heard to the assessee, within one month from the end of the month in which such direction is received.” 7. Thus, from the plain reading of the provisions of section 144C(13) of the Act, it is evident that upon receipt of the directions issued by the learned DRP under section 144C(5) of the Act, the AO is required to complete the assessment in conformity with the directions within one month from the end of the month in which such directions are received. From the perusal of the record, it is evident that in the present case, the learned DRP issued directions under section 144C(5) of the Act on 27.08.2024. We find that vide e-mail dated 27.08.2024 sent at 5:57PM, the said directions were communicated to the assessee. From the copy of the said e-mail, forming part of the paper book Volume – II at Page No. 575, we find that the directions were also communicated vide the same e-mail to the AO, as the e-mail address of the AO, i.e. bangalore.dcit4.1.1@incometax.gov.in, is also mentioned in the said e-mail. Thus, it is evident that both the assessee as well as the AO received the directions issued by the learned DRP on 27.08.2024.

Therefore, in terms of the provisions of section 144C(13) of the Act, the AO was required to pass the final assessment order on or before 30.09.2024, i.e. within one month from the end of the month in which the learned DRP’s direction was received. As per the assessee, the final assessment order was only received on 09.01.2025 when the same was uploaded on the ITBA Portal. From the perusal of the screenshot of the ITBA Portal as on 09.12.2024, we find that the status of assessment is mentioned as “OPEN” for the assessment year 2021-22. Further, we find that the DIN of the final assessment order was intimated to the assessee vide letter dated 09.01.2025. Copy of the said intimation letter forms part of the separate compilation filed by the learned AR at Page No. 28. It is pertinent to note that although the CBDT, vide Instructions No. 1 of 2018 dated 12.02.2018, mandated that all departmental orders/communication/notices being issued to the assessee be digitally signed by the AO. However, in the present case, the impugned final assessment order is manually signed.

8.

During the hearing, the learned Departmental Representative (“learned DR”) sought one week’s time to file the written submissions in response to various contentions raised by the assessee. However, till the passing of this order, the Revenue has not placed on record any reply/written submission rebutting the contentions of the learned AR, nor has it placed on record any document to support that the final assessment order was, in fact, passed on 30.09.2024.

9.

Therefore, having considered the submissions and perusal of the documents placed on record, we find merits in the contentions of the learned AR that in the present case the final assessment order was passed on 09.01.2025, i.e. the date on which the same was uploaded on the ITBA Portal and intimated to the assessee and the AO. In this regard, gainful reference can also be made to the following observations of the Hon’ble Kerala High Court in the case of Govt. Wood Works v. State of Kerala, reported in [1988] STC Vol. 69 Pg. 62. In this case, the Hon'ble Kerala High Court in para 14 observed as follows: -

“14. The order of any authority cannot be said to be passed unless it is in some way pronounced or published or the party affected has the means of knowing it. It is not enough if the order is made, signed, and kept in the file, because such order may be liable to change at the hands of the authority who may modify it or even destroy it, before it is made known, based on subsequent information, thinking or change of opinion. To make the order complete and effective, it should be issued, so as to be beyond the control of the authority concerned, for any possible change or modification therein. This should be done within the prescribed period, though the actual service of the order may be beyond that period. This aspect of the matter had not come up for consideration in the cases of Viswanaihan Chettiar [1954] 25 ITR 79 (Mad.) and Laxmidas & Co. [1969] 72 ITR 88 (Bom) where the only question dealt with was whether service of the order after the prescribed period rendered it invalid. Unless, therefore, the order of the Deputy Commissioner in this case had been so issued from his office within the period prescribed, it has to be held that the proceedings are barred by limitation. This question has not been considered by the Tribunal. The Tribunal, which passed the order, apparently did not have the benefit of the decision in Malayil Mills case (T. R. C. Nos. 15 and 16 of 1981 decided on 7th June, 1982-Kerala High Court) which, so far as we could see, remains, unreported. The matter has therefore to go back to the Tribunal for an examination of the records to ascertain whether the order of the Deputy Commissioner had been issued from his office within the period of four years prescribed in Section 35(2) of the Act. The Tribunal will adjudicate the matter in the light of the observations contained herein and in the judgment in the case of Malayil Mills (T.R.C. Nos. 15 and 16 of 1981 decided on 7th June, 1982 - Kerala High Court) extracted earlier.”

10.

The Hon’ble Jurisdictional High Court in M/s Maharaja Shopping Complex vs. DCIT, in ITA No. 832 of 2008, vide order dated 14.10.2014, following the aforementioned decision of the Hon’ble Kerala High Court in Govt. Wood Works (supra) observed as follows: - “Learned counsel for the revenue is unable to point out from the records whether the assessment order was dispatched from the office before 31.03.2006. Therefore, it is clear when the same was received by the assessee on 18.04.2006, it might have been dispatched few days prior to that and subsequent to 31.03.2006. In that view of the matter, the law laid down as aforesaid squarely applies to the facts of this case and therefore, any just conclusion that could be reached is that the order passed is barred by law of limitation. In that view of the matter, the additional substantial question of law framed today is answered in favour of the assessee and against the revenue. Accordingly, the appeal is allowed. The impugned orders are set-aside.” 11. We find that the Hon’ble Jurisdictional High Court in Himalaya Drug Company vs. DCIT, reported in (2025) 176 taxmann.com 55 (Karnataka), held

that the timelines under section 144C(13) of the Act are mandatory and the AO must pass the final assessment order within one month of receiving the DRP directions, with no scope for extensions or discretion.

12.

Since, in the present case, the final assessment order, even though dated 30.09.2024, has been communicated to the assessee on 09.01.2025, following the decisions of the Hon’ble Kerala High Court and Hon’ble Jurisdictional High Court cited supra, we are of the considered view that the final assessment order can be treated to have passed only on 09.01.2025, and thus, is beyond the limitation period as provided in section 144C(13) of the Act. Accordingly, the impugned final assessment order is bad in law and is quashed. As a result, Grounds No. 2 & 3, raised in assessee’s appeal, are allowed.

13.

Since the relief has been granted to the assessee on this short issue, the other grounds raised in the present appeal are rendered academic and therefore are dismissed as infructuous.

14.

In the result, the appeal by the assessee is partly allowed. Order pronounced in the open court on 29-Oct-2026.

Sd/- Sd/- (BALAKRISHNAN S) (SANDEEP SINGH KARHAIL) ACCOUNTANT MEMBER JUDICIAL MEMBER

Bangalore, Dated, the 29-Oct-2026 *VM* Copy to:

MENZIES AVIATION BOBBA(BANGALORE) PRIVATE LIMITED, NO.2, 2ND FLOOR, MOTI CHAMBERS,4TH 1 A MAIN ROAD, EMINENT POWER SYSTEMS, HEBBAL, BENGALURU-560024, KARNATAKA INCOME TAX DEPARTMENT, THE ASSISTANT COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX - CIRCLE 4(1)(1), 2 ROOM NO. 230, 2ND FLOOR, BMTC DEPOT BUILDING,80 FEET ROAD, KORAMANGALA, BENGALURU-560095, KARNATAKA 3 THE PCIT / CIT, 4 THE D.R., ITAT, BANGALORE BENCH 5 GUARD FILE

BY ORDER P G RAJANI Digitally signed by P G RAJANI Date: 2026.11.10 15:33:59 +05'30' ASSISTANT REGISTRAR I.T.A.T., BANGALORE

More judgments on Section 144C(13)

All 3,530 judgments and leading authorities on Section 144C(13) →

Latest GST High Court judgments

Search GST case law →