ASSISTANT COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX, BANGALORE vs. NVIDIA GRAPHICS PRIVATE LIMITED, BANGALORE

PDF · subscribers
ITA 1298/BANG/2025Status: DisposedITAT Bangalore29 October 2026AY 2014-157 pages
AI SummaryDismissed

What did the Tribunal hold?

The Tribunal held that the CIT(A) did not err in excluding and including comparables by relying on earlier decisions of the Tribunal for the same assessment year. The Tribunal respectfully followed the decision of the Jurisdictional High Court in SAP Labs India Pvt Ltd. vs. The Income Tax Officer, which held that there is no prohibition in following a Tribunal's decision for the same assessment year or preceding years, provided the relevant facts and circumstances remain identical. If the functional analysis and other relevant factors continue to be the same, and the issue has already been adjudicated, the Tribunal can follow its earlier decision instead of undertaking a repetitive exercise. The Revenue's grounds of appeal were dismissed. The appeal of the Revenue was dismissed.

What were the facts?

The Revenue has appealed the order of the CIT(A) for Assessment Year 2014-15. The assessee, Nvidia Graphics Private Limited, a subsidiary of NVIDIA Graphics Holding Company, Mauritius, provides software development (SWD) and marketing support services (MSS) to its Associated Enterprises. The Assessing Officer (AO) made reference to the Transfer Pricing Officer (TPO) for determining the Arm's Length Price (ALP). The TPO made an upward adjustment of INR 73,31,91,911/-. The AO passed the final assessment order incorporating these adjustments. The assessee appealed to the CIT(A), who partly allowed the appeal. The Revenue is aggrieved by the CIT(A)'s order deleting the entire adjustment of INR 73,31,91,911/-.

What were the issues?

1. Whether the CIT(A) erred in excluding Larsen & Toubro Infotech Private Limited, Persistent Systems Limited, Infosys Limited, Thirdware Solutions Limited, and Cigniti Technologies Limited from the comparables for software development services, without independent factual analysis, by relying on previous ITAT decisions. 2. Whether the CIT(A) erred in including Akshay Software Technologies Ltd. and Maveric Systems Ltd. as comparables for software development services, without independent analysis, solely relying on earlier ITAT decisions. 3. Whether the CIT(A) erred in excluding I Media Corp Ltd., Killick Agencies and marketing Ltd., and IRunway India Pvt. Ltd. from the comparables for marketing and support services, without independent FAR analysis, by merely relying on previous decisions. 4. Whether the CIT(A) erred in including India Tourism Development Corporation Ltd. as a comparable for marketing and support services, without independent evaluation, solely based on ITAT precedents. 5. Whether the CIT(A) failed to provide cogent and reasoned justification for the inclusion and exclusion of comparables, rendering the order arbitrary. Assessee's Contention: The assessee relied on the order of the CIT(A). Revenue's Contention: The CIT(A) erroneously relied on earlier tribunal decisions without undertaking any FAR analysis and prayed for the AO's order to be upheld.

Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?

Section 92CA,Section 143(3),Section 144C,Section 147,Section 92C

AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below

Income Tax Appellate Tribunal, BANGALORE BENCHES, BANGALORE

Before: SHRI BALAKRISHNAN S & SHRI KESHAV DUBEY

Pronounced: 29.10.2026

PER SHRI BALAKRISHNAN S, ACCOUNTANT MEMBER:

This appeal filed by the Revenue against the order of Commissioner of Income Tax, Appeal, Bengaluru- 12 [(CIT (A)] vide order dt 21.03.2025, arising out of the order passed under section 143(3) r.w.s. 144C of the Income Tax Act, 1961 (for short ‘Act’) for the Assessment Year 2014-15, dated 23.02.2018.

2.

Brief facts are that the assessee company is a wholly owned subsidiary of NVIDIA Graphics Holding Company, Mauritius and is engaged in the business of providing software development services (SWD) and marketing support services to its Associated Enterprise (AE), NVIDIA International and NVIDIA Singapore Pte Ltd respectively. The assessee filed its Return of Income for the AY 2014- 15 on 14.11.2014, declaring a total income of INR 913,483,890/- under the normal provisions of the Act.

The case was selected for scrutiny and notices u/s 143(2) dt: 29/08/2015 and notice u/s 142(1) dated 08/09/2017 were issued. The Authorised Representatives (Ld AR) of the assessee company appeared on various dates and furnished relevant details, particulars and clarifications as called for by Learned Assessing Officer (Ld AO).

3.

The learned AO made a reference to the TPO under section 92CA of the Act vide latter dt 01.10.2016 for computation of Arm’s Length Price (ALP) in relation to the international transactions

ITA No.1298/Bang/2025 Nvidia Graphics Private Limited, Bengaluru Page 3 of 7 reported by the assessee in Form 3CEB, with prior approval of the Pr. CIT Bangalore-5. The learned TPO, rejected the transfer Pricing document furnished by the assessee. The TPO based on the independent search process conducted proceeded to determine the ALP. The TPO concurred with the TNM method applied by the assessee as MAM. The TPO passed an order under section 92CA(3) of the Act on 30.10.2017 by making upward adjustment of Rs.68,87,84,459/- in SWD segment and Rs.4,44,07,452/- in the MSS segment, aggregating to an upward adjustment of Rs.73,31,91,911/-. Thereafter Ld AO passed the draft assessment order on 18.12.2017. The assessee submitted that it would not file objections before the Dispute Resolution Panel. Therefore the Ld AO issued the final assessment order under section 143(3) r.w.s 144 C of the Act dt 23rd February 2018 where in the same adjustments as in the draft assessment order were incorporated. Aggrieved by the final assessment order the assessee filed an appeal before the CIT(A) on 22nd March 2018.

The Ld AO parallely initiated proceedings under section 147 of the Act and passed the reassessment order assessing the total income Rs.1,68,21,557,803/-. Aggrieved by the reassessment order the assessee preferred an appeal before the CIT(A). The Ld CIT(A) partly allowed the appeal. Aggrieved by the order of CIT(A) the assessee preferred an appeal before the Tribunal concluded that the re assessment proceedings are void abinitio by order dated 23rd October 2024.

With respect to regular assessment proceedings the Ld CIT(A) passed an order on 21st March 2025. The Ld TPO issued an OGE pursuant to

ITA No.1298/Bang/2025 Nvidia Graphics Private Limited, Bengaluru Page 4 of 7 order of the Ld CIT(A) on 17th April 2025 by deleting the entire adjustment of Rs.73,31,91,911/-.

4.

On being aggrieved by the Order of the Ld CIT(A), Revenue is in appeal by raising following grounds. 1. Whether the ld. CIT(A) has erred in law and on facts in excluding the following comparables from the software development services segment – Larsen & Toubro Infotech Private Limited, Persistent Systems Limited, Infosys Limited, Thirdware Solutions Limited and Cigniti Technologies Limited without undertaking an independent factual comparability analysis as mandated under Rule 10B(2) of the Income Tax Rules, 1962 r.w.s. 92C of the Income Tax Act, 1961, and by merely relying on previous decisions of the Hon’ble ITAT? 2. Whether the ld. CIT(A) has erred in law and on facts in including Akshay Software Technologies Ltd and Maveric Systems Ltd. in the list of comparables for software development services without conducting an independent analysis under Rule 10B(2) of the Income Tax Rules, 1962 r.w.s. 92C of the Income Tax Act, 1961, solely relying upon earlier ITAT decisions without demonstrating their factual applicability to the assessee’s case? 3. Whether the ld. CIT(A) has erred in law and on facts in excluding I Media Corp Ltd., Killick Agencies and marketing Ltd. and IRunway India Pvt. Ltd. from the list of comparables for marketing and support services without conducting an independent FAR analysis under rule 10B(2) of the Income Tax Rules, 1962 and by merely placing reliance on previous without examining their relevance in the context of the present case? 4. Whether the ld. CIT(A) has erred in including India Tourism Development Corporation Ltd. as a comparable for marketing and support services without undertaking an independent evaluation under Rule 10B(2) of the Income Tax Rules, 1962 r.w.s. 92C of the Act, solely based on reliance on ITAT precedents? 5. Whether the ld. CIT(A) has failed to provide cogent and reasoned justification for the inclusion and exclusion of the above mentioned comparables, thereby rendering the order arbitrary, non-speaking, legally unsustainable?

4.1 The core issue emanating from the above grounds is with respect to inclusion and exclusion of certain comparables by the Ld CIT(A) by relying on the earlier decisions of the tribunal.

ITA No.1298/Bang/2025 Nvidia Graphics Private Limited, Bengaluru Page 5 of 7

5.

The Ld DR submitted that the Ld CIT(A) erroneously relied on the earlier decisions of the tribunal without undertaking any FAR analysis. She therefore prayed that the order of Ld AO be upheld.

6.

The Ld AR relied on the orders of Ld CIT(A). 7. We have heard the rival contentions and perused the material available on record. The Ld CIT(A) solely relying on various decisions of the Tribunal for the same AY, allowed the appeal of the assessee. The solitary grievance of the Revenue is that the Ld CIT(A) without conducting an independent analysis with respect to the inclusions and exclusion of comparables as prescribed under Rule 10B(2) of the Income Tax Rules 1962, simply relied on earlier decisions of the Tribunal. Recently the Honorable High Court of Karnataka in the case SAP labs India Pvt Ltd. Vs The Income Tax Officer in ITA No 10/2011, held in Para 19 as follows:

IX. Correctness of Tribunal following earlier decisions: 19. One of the principal grievances raised by the Revenue is that the Tribunal has excluded or included comparables by placing reliance on its decisions rendered in other cases, including cases relating to the same assessee. It is contended that once the Tribunal interferes with the findings of the TPO regarding the inclusion or exclusion of comparables, it is required to undertake an independent exercise in accordance with Section 92C of the Act and Rule 10B of the Rules. 19.1 The said contention cannot be accepted. Once the Tribunal, in the case of any taxpayer, records findings regarding the functions performed, assets employed, or risks assumed and, on that basis, finds justification to include or exclude a comparable, there can be no prohibition in following such decision where it relates to the same assessment year or to the preceding years, as permissible under Rule 10B, provided the relevant facts and circumstances remain identical. If the functional analysis and other relevant factors continue to be the

ITA No.1298/Bang/2025 Nvidia Graphics Private Limited, Bengaluru Page 6 of 7 same, and the issue has already been adjudicated by the Tribunal, no fault can be found with the Tribunal following its earlier decision instead of undertaking a repetitive exercise. Merely because the Tribunal has relied upon its earlier decision, it cannot be said that its findings are not in conformity with Section 92C of the Act and Rule 10B of the Rules. 19.2 However, it is always open to the Revenue or the assessee to demonstrate that the inclusion or exclusion of a particular comparable in the earlier decision was incorrect or that the facts of the present case are distinguishable so as to warrant a different conclusion. 7.1 In the instant case the Ld CIT(A) has followed the decisions of Tribunal for the same assessment year while concluding on the inclusions and exclusions of the comparables. We find that the Ld CIT(A) while relying on the various decisions of Tribunal of different assessee has deleted the upward adjustment made by the TPO. Respectfully following the decision of the Jurisdictional High Court in the case of SAP labs India Pvt Ltd. (supra) we do not find any infirmity in the order of the Ld CIT(A) and therefore no interference is required in the order of Ld CIT(A). Accordingly the grounds raised by the Revenue are dismissed.

8.

In the result the appeal of the Revenue is dismissed.

Pronounced in the open court on the date mentioned on the caption page.

Order pronounced in the open court on 29 Oct, 2026

Sd/- Sd/- (Keshav Dubey) (Balakrishnan S.) Judicial Member Accountant Member

Bangalore,

ITA No.1298/Bang/2025 Nvidia Graphics Private Limited, Bengaluru Page 7 of 7 Dated 29 Oct, 2026. VG/SPS Copy to: 1. The Applicant 2. The Respondent 3. The CIT 4. The DR, ITAT, Bangalore. 5 Guard file By order P G Digitally signed by P G RAJANI RAJANI Date: 2026.11.10 16:40:43 +05'30' Asst. Registrar, ITAT, Bangalore.

More judgments on Section 92CA

All 4,123 judgments and leading authorities on Section 92CA →

Recent GST High Court judgments

Search GST case law →