DCIT, CIRCLE-8(1), HYDERABAD vs. UNITED ONLINE SOFTWARE DEVELOPMENT (INDIA) PRIVATE LIMITED, HYDERABAD

PDF · subscribers
ITA 2024/HYD/2025Status: DisposedITAT Hyderabad13 November 2026AY 2008-0928 pages

In favour of the assessee: the Revenue's appeal was dismissed. From the AI summary of this appeal.

AI SummaryDismissed

What did the Tribunal hold?

The Tribunal held that the Assessing Officer (AO) was indeed required to issue a fresh Draft Assessment Order under section 144C of the Income-tax Act, 1961, before passing the consequential assessment order dated 03.08.2020. The Tribunal relied on the judgment of the Hon'ble Delhi High Court in the case of JCB India Ltd. (supra), which was followed by the CIT(A). The Tribunal found that the failure to issue a draft assessment order under section 144C(1) is an incurable defect, leading to the invalidation of the final assessment order. The Revenue's argument that the subsequent order was merely consequential and did not require a fresh draft order was rejected. The Tribunal emphasized that the requirement of section 144C provides substantive rights to the assessee to object to proposed variations before the Dispute Resolution Panel (DRP), and this opportunity cannot be taken away by treating it as purely procedural. The Tribunal noted that the AO's order dated 03.08.2020 was passed without adhering to this mandatory procedure, vitiating the assessment. Consequently, the appeal filed by the Revenue was dismissed.

What were the facts?

The Revenue appealed the CIT(A)'s order for AY 2008-2009, which quashed the Assessing Officer's (AO) assessment order dated 03.08.2020. The assessee, a software development company, had its international transactions referred to the TPO, who proposed an adjustment. A draft assessment order was issued on 15.12.2011, and the assessee filed objections before the DRP. The AO passed a final assessment order on 12.10.2012. The ITAT granted partial relief and remanded two comparables for reconsideration. Following the ITAT's order, the TPO passed a consequential order on 28.03.2017, and the AO issued the impugned order on 03.08.2020. The assessee contended that this order was invalid as no fresh draft assessment order was issued under Section 144C.

What were the issues?

1. Whether the Assessing Officer was required to issue a fresh Draft Assessment Order under section 144C of the Income-tax Act, 1961 before passing the consequential assessment order dated 03.08.2020, given that a valid Draft Assessment Order was already issued on 15.12.2011 and the subsequent order was consequential to ITAT directions. - Revenue's contention: A fresh draft order is not required as the order dated 03.08.2020 was merely consequential to ITAT directions and TPO's recomputation, not a fresh adjudication. The assessee had already exercised its right to file objections to the original draft order. - Assessee's contention (as understood from the CIT(A)'s decision and the Revenue's grounds): The AO failed to follow the procedure prescribed under section 144C by not issuing a fresh draft assessment order, rendering the consequential order invalid. 2. Whether the provisions of section 144C are attracted again when giving effect to an appellate order. - Revenue's contention: Section 144C is not triggered again after ITAT's remand as the consequential order is a mechanical implementation and does not involve fresh adjudication. The TPO merely recomputed ALP pursuant to ITAT's directions, not a fresh order under section 92CA(3). - Assessee's contention: The AO was required to issue a fresh draft order as per section 144C.

Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?

Section 144C,Section 92CA,Section 254,Section 10A,Section 153C,Section 153

AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below

Income Tax Appellate Tribunal, HYDERABAD

Before: SHRI VIJAY PAL RAO & SHRI MANJUNATHA G.

For Respondent: CA Ravi Bharadawaj
Pronounced: 13.11.2026

PER VIJAY PAL RAO, VICE PRESIDENT:

This appeal by the Revenue is directed against the Order dated 17.09.2025 of the learned CIT(A)-10, Hyderabad for the assessment year 2008-2009.

2.

The Revenue has raised the following grounds of appeal:

1.

“That the Ld. CIT(A) has erred in law and on facts in holding that the Assessing Officer was required to issue a fresh Draft Assessment Order under section 144C of the Income-tax Act, 1961 before passing the consequential assessment order dated 03.08.2020.The Ld. CIT(A) failed to appreciate that a valid Draft Assessment Order had already been issued on 15.12.2011, and the subsequent order dated 03.08.2020 was merely a consequential order passed to give effect to the binding directions of the Hon'ble ITAT and the recomputation made by the TPO pursuant to such directions.

2.

The Ld. CIT(A) erred in law and on facts in holding that the provisions of section 144C are attracted once again while giving effect to an appellate order. The Id. CIT(A) failed to appreciate that a consequential order passed pursuant to the directions of the Hon'ble ITAT is merely a mechanical implementation and does not involve fresh adjudication requiring another draft assessment order.

3.

The Ld. CIT(A) misinterpreted the statutory scheme of sections 92CA, 144C and 254 by incorrectly concluding that the AO was required to provide another opportunity of hearing before passing the consequential order. The Ld. CIT(A) failed to appreciate that once the Hon'ble ITAT issued binding directions for re-computation of ALP and the TPO recomputed the ALP accordingly, the AO had no discretion but to implement the same.

4.

The Ld. CIT(A) erred in concluding that a fresh draft order was required because of a "new" TPO order. The Ld. CIT(A) failed to appreciate that the TPO had not passed a fresh order under section 92CA(3); he merely recomputed the ALP pursuant to the ITAT's explicit directions, which does not trigger the procedure under section 144C afresh.

5.

The Ld. CIT(A) failed to appreciate that the assessee had already exercised its right to file objections before the Hon'ble DRP against the original Draft Assessment Order dated 15.12.2011, and the matter had reached finality except to the extent remanded by the Hon'ble ITAT. Consequently, section 144C is not triggered again after the ITAT's remand.

6.

The Ld. CIT(A) erred in relying on judicial precedents that are distinguishable on facts and law, as the cited cases pertain to situations of fresh Transfer Pricing orders or fresh variations, whereas the present case involves only a consequential order implementing appellate directions without any new variation. The Ld. CIT(A) failed to consider relevant and binding precedents governing the nature of consequential orders and non-applicability of the draft order procedure.

7.

The Ld. CIT(A) has erred in relying on the decision in Zuari Cement Ltd. vs. ACIT, which is factually and legally distinguishable from the present case. The decision in Zuari Cement pertained to a situation where no draft assessment order was issued at the original stage, thereby depriving the assessee of its statutory remedy before the DRP. In the present case, however, a valid draft assessment order was issued on 15.12.2011, the assessee filed objections, and the DRP issued its directions. The subsequent order dated 03.08.2020 is merely a consequential order giving effect to the binding directions of the Hon'ble ITAT without any fresh variation. Therefore, the ratio of Zuari Cement is not applicable and has been erroneously invoked by the Ld. CIT(A).

8.

The Ld. CIT(A) has further erred in relying on the judgment of the Hon'ble Telangana High Court in ITA No.971/Hyd/2017 dated 20.06.2018, which is distinguishable on facts. In that case, the assessment was vitiated due to failure to issue a draft assessment order at the original stage in violation of section 144C. In the present case, the original draft order dated 15.12.2011 was duly issued and the assessee's objections were adjudicated by the DRP. The order dated 03.08.2020 merely gives effect to the ITAT's directions and does not constitute a fresh assessment. Accordingly, the reliance placed on this judgment is misplaced and the said decision has no application to the present factual situation.

9.

The Ld. CIT(A) has also erred in relying on the decision of the Pune Bench of the Tribunal in Soktas India Pvt. Ltd. vs. ACIT, which is wholly distinguishable. In that case, after remand, the TPO had passed a fresh order leading to a fresh variation, thereby necessitating issuance of a fresh draft assessment order. In the present case, the TPO did not pass any fresh order, he only recomputed the ALP as specifically directed by the Hon'ble ITAT. The Assessing Officer's order dated 03.08.2020 was purely consequential in nature and did not involve any new issue or variation requiring initiation of section 144C proceedings afresh. Hence, the reliance on Soktas India Pvt. Ltd. is misplaced and the Ld. CIT(A) has erred in applying it to the present case.

10.

The Ld. CIT(A) erred in observing that non-issuance of a fresh draft order caused prejudice to the assessee. The Ld. CIT(A) failed to note that the assessee was already fully heard by the DRP as well as the ITAT, and the consequential order merely reflected the relief granted by the ITAT and recomputed by the TPO.

11.

The Ld. CIT(A) erred in setting aside the valid consequential order dated 03.08.2020 even though the AO strictly complied

with the binding directions of the Hon'ble ITAT and the TPO's re-computation, and no statutory non-compliance was involved.

12.

The order of the Ld. CIT(A) is erroneous, contrary to the facts on record and inconsistent with the scheme of the Income Tax Act, 1961 relating to Transfer Pricing assessments, DRP mechanism, and appellate effect.”

3.

The assessee is a 100% export-oriented unit and filed its return of income for the year under consideration on 25.09.2008 admitting total income of Rs.1,70,443/- after claiming deduction u/sec.10A of the Income Tax Act [in short "the Act"], 1961 on account of export of software development services. Since there were international transactions entered into by the assessee therefore, the matter was referred to the Transfer Pricing Officer [in short “TPO”] for determination of Arm’s Length Price [in short “ALP”] of the international transactions. The TPO passed order u/sec.92CA(3) of the Act on 24.10.2010 proposing an upward adjustment of Rs.3,55,03,343/-. Thereafter, Draft Assessment Order was passed by the Assessing Officer u/sec.144C(1) of the Act on 15.12.2011 and against which the assessee filed its

objections before the Disputes Resolution Panel [in short “DRP”] and in pursuance to the directions of the DRP the Assessing Officer passed Final Assessment Order dated 12.10.2012. The assessee challenged the Final Assessment Order before the Tribunal and the Tribunal vide Order dated 22.04.2016 granted part relief to the assessee by excluding some of the comparables selected by the TPO and also remanded two of the comparables viz., (i) Bodhtree Consulting Ltd. (Seg.) and (ii) LGS Global Ltd. for reconsideration as comparable for determination of ALP. In pursuance to the Order of the Tribunal, the TPO has passed consequential order dated 28.03.2017 and thereafter, the Assessing Officer passed the impugned order on 03.08.2020.

4.

The assessee challenged the order of the Assessing Officer before the learned CIT(A) and contended that the impugned order passed by the Assessing Officer is invalid as Assessing Officer has not followed the procedure prescribed u/sec.144C of the Act as no Draft Assessment Order was passed by the Assessing Officer. The learned CIT(A) has quashed the assessment order passed by the Assessing

Officer by holding the same as invalid for want of Draft Assessment Order. Aggrieved by the impugned order of the learned CIT(A), the Revenue has filed the present appeal.

5.

The learned CIT-DR has submitted that the Tribunal has issued certain directions while passing the order dated 22.04.2016 and therefore, the Assessing Officer/TPO was only to give effect to the directions of the Tribunal and consequently, the order passed by the TPO and Assessing Officer are only the giving effect orders to the directions of the Tribunal and therefore, no Draft Assessment Order was required to be framed/issued by the Assessing Officer when the orders were passed only to give effect to the directions of the Tribunal. It is not a case of fresh adjudication of the issue and therefore, the Draft Assessment Order was not required. The learned DR has further submitted that the directions issued by the Tribunal were binding for re-computation of the ALP and consequently, the TPO recomputed the ALP which was incorporated by the Assessing Officer while passing the impugned order. The learned CIT(A) has erred in relying on the decision of Hon’ble

Andhra Pradesh High Court in the case of Zuari Cement Ltd. vs. ACIT WP (C) No.5557/2012 dated 21.02.2013 which is factually and legally distinguishable as in the said case the original assessment order was passed without draft assessment and therefore, the same was quashed by the Hon’ble High Court as not passed in accordance with the provisions of sec.144C of the Act whereas the in the present case the order passed by the Assessing Officer is merely a consequential order giving effect to the directions of the Tribunal without any fresh variation. Therefore, the ratio laid down in the case of Zuari Cement Ltd. vs. ACIT (supra) is not applicable in the case in hand. The learned DR has further submitted that the learned CIT(A) has also relied upon the decision of ITAT, Hyderabad Bench in the case of DCIT vs. Srini Pharmaceuticals Pvt. Ltd., dated 20.06.2018 in ITA.No.971/Hyd./2017 wherein the Tribunal has relied upon the Judgment of Honb’le Delhi High Court in the case of JCB India Ltd., vs. DCIT [2017] 398 ITR 189 (Del.) which is also not applicable in the facts of the present case as the Hon’ble Delhi High Court has considered the issue

arising from the fresh adjudication of the issue by the Assessing Officer/TPO and assessee was permitted to file fresh TP study and fresh comparable for the purpose of determination of ALP. Thus, the learned DR has submitted that in the case in hand there was no order of the Tribunal for fresh adjudication of the issue or the matter, but it was only specific directions given to the Assessing Officer/TPO while passing the consequential orders. The learned DR has then relied upon the Judgment of Hon’ble Karnataka High Court in the case of Wipro Ltd., vs. JCIT [2021] 438 ITR 581 and submitted that the Hon’ble High Court has held that where orders to be given effect are to be made by following principle already laid down by the higher forum, it would not be a case of fresh assessment and it would simply means that the order of higher forum are to be applied and followed by the Assessing Officer. The learned DR has thus submitted that in the case of the assessee the orders passed by the TPO and Assessing Officer are only in the nature of giving effect to the directions/order of this Tribunal and therefore, no Draft Assessment Order was required to be issued before passing

the consequential order by the Assessing Officer. Thus, the learned DR has submitted that the impugned order of the learned CIT(A) may be set aside, and order of the Assessing Officer be restored.

6.

On the other hand, the learned Counsel for the Assessee has submitted that once the matter was remanded to the Assessing Officer and in consequence the Assessing Officer has referred the same to the TPO for determination of ALP then, after receiving the order of the TPO the Assessing Officer is bound to pass Draft Assessment Order as per sec.144C(1) of the Act. The failure to pass the Draft Assessment Order vitiates the order passed by the Assessing Officer as invalid not in accordance with the provisions of sec.144C of the Act. He has supported the impugned order of the learned CIT(A).

7.

We have considered the rival submissions as well as relevant material on record. In the first round of appeal filed by the assessee against the Final Assessment Order, the Tribunal vide Order dated 22.04.2016 has issued the

directions in respect of two comparables viz., (i) Bodhtree Consulting Ltd. (Seg.) and (ii) LGS Global Ltd. in Para nos.6 to 6.5 and 8 to 8.2 respectively as under:

“6. Bodhtree Consulting Ltd. (Seq.)

6.1. The Id. AR objecting to the said company as comparable, relied upon the decision of the ITAT, Hyderabad in assessee's own case for AY 2005-06 wherein the Bench held as follows:

"20. The Learned AR submitted that since the aforesaid company fails the RPT filter it cannot be treated as a comparable. The learned DR supported the order of the TPO.

21.

We have considered the submissions of the parties and perused the materials on record. The ground on which the learned AR seeks for exclusion of the aforesaid company is, its related party transaction as a percentage to the total revenue is 34.68% which is more than the accept/reject matrix of more than 25% fixed by the TPO. It is to be noted that in final filters adopted by the TPO in para 9.7 of his order he himself has excluded companies having RPT of more than 25%. therefore, direct the Assessing Officer/TPO to examine this aspect and exclude it from the list of comparables if the assessee's contention is found to be correct.

6.2. The Id. AR also relied upon the following cases:

1.

ITAT Delhi in case of Cash Edge India Pvt. Ltd. in ITA No. 5848/D/2012 for AY 2008-09

6.3. It is to be noted that in the case of 3DPLM Software Solutions Ltd, (TS-359-ITAT-2013(Bang)-TP) AY 2008-09, the coordinate bench has taken this company as comparable.

6.4. Ld. AR submitted that this company is engaged in providing open and end to end web solutions, software consultancy, design and development of software and also submitted that this is into business of software products. For that he submitted snap shot of companies profile from the net in page 561 of the paper book, which states as "we also provide product engineering and enterprise services to Fortune 500 firms and SMES". Also "As a partner of industry leading technology providers, Bodhtree delivers best-in-class solutions that are tailored to meet the needs of global SME's and fortune listed organizations". Ld AR also submitted a letter from Chartered Accountats, M/s Gokhale & Co., which is addressed to ACIT (TP), Hyderabad (Refer pages 563 & 564 of the paper book). M/s Gokhale & Co., submits details about the Bodhtree e paper solutions.

6.5. After analyzing the above submissions, we are of the view that the submissions on profile of the company, it is mentioned as "we also provide product engineering and enterprise services to fortune 500 firms. This also will be categorized as software services and cannot be categorized as software product. The auditor of this company submitted the letter before TPO, which was part of assessment proceedings. These submissions are made by Id. AR as additional evidence and we direct AO/TPO to analyse this comparable with the submissions of the assessee after giving them an opportunity of being heard. In case, this comparable is found to be into software products, it may be eliminated from the list of comparables.”

“8. LGS Global Ltd.

8.1. Objecting to the said company as comparable, Id. AR submitted that this company is offering services in consultancy services, BPO, testing services and application maintenance outsourcing. Further, this company has capital work-in-progress towards capitalized software and product development cost. In principle, software products cannot be considered as comparables for software services company. The Id. AR relied upon the decision of the ITAT Delhi Bench in case of Cash Edge India Pvt. Ltd. (supra) wherein the bench held as follows:

15.

As regards the argument of Ld. A.R. regarding exclusion of LGS Global Ltd., Avani Cincon, Kals Information Systems and Bothtree Consultants, we are of the opinion that the company having similar functions can only be compared with the assessee and as per various decisions of the Tribunal as relied upon by the Ld. A.R., these companies were into development of the product also in addition to the business of providing services.

16.

Ld. D.R. had argued that the TPO had taken segmental figures only to make the comparison. Therefore, we hold that this issue can be examined by the Assessing Officer afresh to ascertain as to whether segmental data relating to the provision of services were

used or consolidated results were used for making comparison.

17.

As regards the last argument of the Ld. A.R. regarding inclusion of finance and bank charges in operating expenses while computing the margin and comparables, we are in agreement with the argument of the Ld. A.R. that finance and bank charges form part of operating expenses and need to be included while calculating margin of comparables.

18.

Therefore, in view of the facts and circumstances of the present case and in view of the discussions made above and in view of various judicial pronouncements, we direct the Assessing Officer to re- adjudicate the issue of arms length pricing and determine the same by excluding the comparables having turnover of more than Rs.200 crores. The Assessing Officer will also take into account the bank and finance charges as part of operating expenses of com parables for arriving at the margin. Similarly, Assessing Officer will only take segmental results relating to services only for comparing the companies Ws. Kals Information Systems, Avani Cincon, LGS GLobal Ltd. and Bodhtree Consulting Systems as the consolidated results of these companies cannot be compared with the assessee, as assessee is admittedly into service providing activities. It is further directed that if segmental results of the above companies relating to similar services as being provided by assessee are not available, then these companies will have to be

excluded as comparables as held in various judicial pronouncements relied upon by Ld. A.R.

8.2. In view of the above and also Id. AR submitted that the revenue in FY 2007-08 is three times higher than the revenue of FY 2006-07. We direct the AO to apply the turnover filter and exclude the companies whose turnover are more than 200 crores. Since, we do not have segmental report, we direct AO to determine the service and product details from this company and if in case it is found that it is into product, this company will have to be excluded from the list of comparables.”

8.

Thus, the Tribunal while considering the comparability of the company Bodhtree Consulting Ltd. (Seg.) it was noted that the profile of the said company shows various products and services were provided by the said company to the Fortune 500 Firms therefore, the said record was considered by the Tribunal as additional evidence and Assessing Officer/TPO was directed to analyze this comparable with the submissions of the assessee after giving an appropriate opportunity of being heard. Therefore, it is clear from the order of the Tribunal that the matter relating to the issue of comparability of Bodhtree Consulting Ltd. (Seg.) was remanded to the Assessing Officer/TPO for the analysis of the relevant facts and evidence filed by the

assessee and thereafter decide the same by considering the submissions of the assessee as well as an opportunity of being heard given to the assessee. The only guideline given by the Tribunal is that, in case the said company is found to be in software product it may be excluded from the list of comparables. Therefore, the Tribunal has not given any finding regarding the comparability of the said company Bodhtree Consulting Ltd. (Seg.) but the TPO/Assessing Officer was to take a decision on the said matter.

9.

As regards the matter regarding functional comparability of LGS Global Ltd., the Tribunal has directed the Assessing Officer to apply the turnover filter and exclude the company whose turnovers are more than Rs.200 crores. Therefore, in directions relating to LGS Global Ltd., the Tribunal has not remanded the matter for fresh decision to be taken by the Assessing Officer/TPO but only to do the clerical work of applying the turnover filter and excluding the company if the turnover is more than Rs.200 crore. Thus, in the order of the Tribunal this was not at all remanded to the Assessing Officer/TPO for their decision/adjudication.

However, in pursuance to the directions of the Tribunal, the TPO has passed the Order dated 28.03.2017 in Para nos.5.1, 5.2, 6 and 7 as under:

“5.1. But verification of information obtained by the Department u/s.133(6) of the Act during TP proceedings revealed that both these companies are into software development. The extract of reply submitted by M/s. Bodhtree Consulting u/s.133(6) of the Act, to the Department is as under:

xxxxx xxxxx xxxxx

xxxxx xxxxx xxxxx

xxxxx xxxxx xxxxx

5.2. As regards M/s. LGS global Ltd., even the information furnished by the said company to the Department as per the provisions of Sec. 133(6) of the Act points to the fact that the said company is Software Development Service provider. The extract of reply submitted by the said company u/s.133(6) of the Act, to the Department is as under.

xxxxx xxxxx xxxxx

xxxxx xxxxx xxxxx

6.

Further, it has been observed from the TP study report submitted by the Taxpayer that M/s. Lanco Global Systems Ltd., (Now M/s. LGS Global Systems Ltd.,) was taken as comparable by the Taxpayer itself. The observation made by the Taxpayer in its TP study report is reproduced as under.

"Lanco Global Systems Ltd:

Lanco Global Systems Limited is primarily engaged in providing software development services. niche strengths in verticals like finance and logistics and in The company is developing technology like web.

For the period ended March 31, 2007 and March 31 2006, 100 percent each of the operating revenues wre derived from software services (exports).

7.

Keeping the above discusion in view, both the companies M/s. Bodhtree Consulting Ltd. (Seg) and M/s.LGS Global are retained as comparables.”

10.

Thus, it is clear that so far as the comparability of Bodhtree Consulting Ltd. (Seg.) the TPO has verified the record, and information as obtained u/sec.133(6) of the Act and then given a finding. As regards Lanco Global Systems Limited [Now M/s. LGS Global Systems Ltd.,] the TPO has not followed the directions of the Tribunal whereby it was directed to apply the turnover filter and exclude the company if the turnover is more than Rs.200 crore. But the TPO has retained the said company as comparable while passing the consequential order without following the directions of the Tribunal. Therefore, the TPO has given its decision in respect

of both these comparable companies remanded by the Tribunal and hence the procedure provided u/sec.144C is required to be followed while passing the order by the Assessing Officer after receiving the order of the TPO. The Hon’ble Delhi High Court in the case of JCB India Ltd., vs. DCIT (supra) has specifically observed in Para no.17 as under:

“17. The Court is unable to agree with the submissions made on behalf of the Revenue by Mr. Jain. Section 144C (1) of the Act is unambiguous. It requires the AO to pass a draft assessment order after receipt of the report from the TPO. There is nothing in the wording of Section 144C (1) which would indicate that this requirement of passing a draft assessment order does not arise where the exercise had been undertaken by the TPO on remand to it, of the said issue, by the ITAT.”

11.

Thus, the Hon’ble High Court has held that sec.144C(1) requires the Assessing Officer to pass Draft Assessment Order after receipt of the order/report from the TPO. It was further observed that there is nothing in the language of sec.144(1) which would indicate that this requirement of passing Draft Assessment Order does not arise where the exercise has been undertaken by the TPO on remand to it of the said issue by the ITAT. The Hon’ble High Court has then held in Para nos.19 to 25 as under:

“19. As already noted, the final assessment order of the AO stood vitiated not on account of mere irregularity but since it was an incurable illegality. Section 292B of the Act would not protect such an order. This has been explained by this Court in its decision dated 17th July 2015 passed in ITA No. 275/2015 (Pr. Commissioner of Income Tax, Delhi-2, New Delhi v. Citi Financial Consumer Finance India Pvt. Ltd.) where it was held:

"Section 292B of the Act cannot be read to confer jurisdiction on the AO where none exists. The said Section only protects return of income, assessment, notice, summons or other proceedings from any mistake in such return of income, assessment notices, summons or other proceedings, provided the same are in substance and in effect in conformity with the intent of purposes of the Act."

20.

The Court further observed that Section 292B of the Act cannot save an order not passed in accordance with the provisions of the Act. As the Court explained, "the issue involved is not about a mistake in the said order but the power of the AO to pass the order."

21.

In almost identical facts, in Turner International (supra), this Court held in favour of the Assessee on the ground that it was mandatory for the AO to have passed a draft assessment order under Section 144C of the Act prior to issuing

the final assessment order. The following passages from said decision are relevant for the present purposes:

"11. The question whether the final assessment order stands vitiated for failure to adhere to the mandatory requirements of first passing draft assessment order in terms of Section 144C(1) of the Act is no longer res intregra. There is a long series of decisions to which reference would be made presently.

12.

In Zuari Cement Ltd. v. ACIT (decision dated 21st February, 2013 in WP(C) No.5557/2012), the Division Bench (DB) of the Andhra Pradesh High Court categorically held that the failure to pass a draft assessment order under Section 144C (1) of the Act would result in rendering the final assessment order "without jurisdiction, null and void and unenforceable."

In that case, the consequent demand notice was also set aside. The decision of the Andhra Pradesh High Court was affirmed by the Supreme Court by the dismissal of the Revenue's SLP (C) [CC No. 16694/2013] on 27th September, 2013.

13.

In Vijay Television (P) Ltd. v. Dispute Resolution Panel [2014] 369 ITR 113 (Mad.), a similar question arose. There, the Revenue sought to rectify a mistake by issuing a corrigendum after the final assessment order was passed. Consequently, not only the final assessment order but also the corrigendum issued thereafter was challenged. Following the decision of the Andhra Pradesh High Court in Zuari Cement Ltd. v. ACIT (supra) and a

number of other decisions, the Madras High Court in Vijay Television (P) Ltd. v. Dispute Resolution Panel (supra) quashed the final order of the AO and the demand notice. Interestingly, even as regards the corrigendum issued, the Madras High Court held that it was beyond the time permissible for issuance of such corrigendum and, therefore, it could not be sustained in law.

14.

Recently, this Court in ESPN Star Sports Mauritius S.N.C. ET Compagnie v. Union of India [2016] 388 ITR 383 (Del.), following the decision of the Andhra Pradesh High Court in Zuari Cement Ltd. v. ACIT (supra), the Madras High Court in Vijay Television (P) Ltd. v. Dispute Resolution Panel, Chennai (supra) as well as the Bombay High Court in International Air Transport Association v. DCIT (2016) 290 CTR (Bom) 46, came to the same conclusion."

22.

In the decision of the Gujarat High Court in C-Sam (India) (supra), the Court negated the plea that non-compliance with the terms of Section 144C of the Act is merely an 'irregularity'. The Gujarat High Court held that it was of 'great importance and mandatory'. The following passages of the said decision of Gujarat High Court are relevant for the present purposes:

"6. These statutory provisions make it abundantly clear that the procedure laid down under Section 144C of the Act is of great importance and is mandatory. Before the Assessing Officer can make variations in the returned income of an eligible assessee, as noted, sub-section (1) of Section 144C lays down the procedure to be followed

notwithstanding anything to the contrary contained in the Act. This non-obstante clause thus gives an overriding effect to the procedure 'notwithstanding anything to the contrary contained in the Act'. Sub-section (5) of Section 144C empowers the DRP to issue directions to the Assessing Officer to enable him to complete the assessment. Sub-section (10) of Section 144C makes, such directions binding on the Assessing Officer. As per Sub-Section 144C, the Assessing Officer is required to pass the order of assessment in terms of such directions without any further hearing being granted to the assessee.

7.

The procedure laid down under Section 144C of the Act is thus of great importance. When an Assessing Officer proposes to make variations to the returned income declared by an eligible assesses he has to first pass a draft order, provide a copy thereof to the assessee and only thereupon the assessee could exercise his valuable right to raise objections before the DRP on any of the proposed variations. In addition to giving such opportunity to an assessee, decision of the DRP is made binding on the Assessing Officer. It is therefore not possible to uphold the Revenue's contention that such requirement is merely a procedural. The requirement is mandatory and gives substantive rights to the assessee to object to any additions before they are made and such objections have to be considered not by the Assessing Officer but by the DRP. Interestingly, once the DRP gives directions under sub-section (5) of Section 144C, the

Assessing Officer is expected to pass the order of assessment in terms of such directions without giving any further hearing to the assessee. Thus, at the level of the Assessing Officer, the directions of the DRP under sub- section (5) of Section 144C would bind even the assessee. He may of course challenge the order of the Assessing Officer before the Tribunal and take up all contentions. Nevertheless at the stage of assessment, he has no remedy against the directions issued by the DRP under sub-section (5). All these provisions amply demonstrate that the legislature desired to give an important opportunity to an assessee who is likely to be subjected to upward revision of income on the basis of, transfer pricing mechanism. Such opportunity cannot be taken away by treating it as purely procedural in nature."

23.

In the present case, just as in Turner International (supra), it is submitted that, at the most, failure to pass a draft assessment order under Section 144C of the Act is a curable defect and that the Court should now delegate the parties to a stage as it was when the TPO issued a fresh order after the remand by the ITAT.

24.

This very argument of the Revenue has been negated by the Court in Turner International (supra) where it was observed in paras 15 and 16 as under:

"15. Mr. Dileep Shivpuri, learned counsel for the Revenue sought to contend that the failure to adhere to the mandatory requirement of issuing a draft assessment order under Section 144C (1) of the Act would, at best,

be a curable defect. According to him the matter must be restored to the AO to pass a draft assessment order and for the Petitioner, thereafter, to pursue the matter before the DRP.

16.

The Court is unable to accept the above submission. The legal position as explained in the above decisions in unambiguous. The failure by the AO to adhere to the mandatory requirement of Section 144C (1) of the Act and first pass a draft assessment order would result in invalidation of the final assessment order and the consequent demand notices and penalty proceedings."

25.

For all of the aforementioned reasons, the Court finds no difficulty in holding that the impugned final assessment orders dated 30th March 2016 passed by the AO for AYs 2006-07, 2007- 08 and 2008 -09 are without jurisdiction on account of the failure, by the AO, to first pass a draft assessment order and thereafter, subject to the objections filed before the DRP and the orders of the DRP, to pass the final assessment order. The Court also sets aside the orders of the TPO dated 30th March 2016 issued pursuant to the remand by the ITAT.”

12.

Thus, a final order stands vitiated due to an incurable illegality in the order being passed without passing the Draft Assessment Order. We further note that the learned CIT(A) has passed the impugned order by following various

decisions including the Judgment of Hon’ble Delhi High Courtin the case of JCB India Ltd., (supra).

13.

As regards the decision of Hon’ble Karnataka High Court in the case of Wipro Ltd., vs. JCIT (supra) relied upon by the learned DR the issue before the Hon’ble High Court was regarding the limitation u/sec.153C(2) and 153(3) for passing the order in pursuance to the directions of the Tribunal. The Hon’ble High Court has specifically observed that the Assessing Officer was required to give effect to the Order of the Tribunal wherein the principles already laid down and therefore, it was considered as not a case of fresh adjudication or re-assessment but it is simply an order passed by applying the order of the Tribunal. Hence, the said Judgment of the Hon’ble High Court in our considered view will not help the case of the Revenue. Apart from the decision of Hon’ble Karnataka High Court the Revenue has not brought any contrary decision to the Judgment of Hon’ble Delhi High Court in the case of JCB India Ltd., (supra). Accordingly, in the facts and circumstances of the case as discussed above and following the Judgment of Hon’ble Delhi

High Court in the case of JCB India Ltd., (supra), we do not find any error or illegality in the impugned order of the learned CIT(A) quashing the order passed by the Assessing Officer without passing the Draft Assessment Order.

14.

In the result, appeal of the Revenue is dismissed.

Order pronounced in the open court on 13.11.2026.

Sd/- Sd/- MANJUNATHA G VIJAY PAL RAO ACCOUNTANT MEMBER VICE PRESIDENT Hyderabad, Dated 13th day of November, 2026 VBP Copy to: DCIT, CIRCLE-8(1), ROOM NO. 914, 9TH FLOOR, SIGNATURE TOWERS, OPP- BOTANICAL GARDEN, 1 KONDAPUR, KOTHAGUDA, HYDERABAD-500084, TELANGANA UNITED ONLINE SOFTWARE DEVELOPMENT (INDIA) PRIVATE LIMITED, 6-3-1099/1100, 1ST FLOOR AND 6TH 2 FLOORS, BABUKHANS MILLENNIUM CENTRE, SOMAJIGUDA S.O KHAIRATABAD, HYDERABAD. PIN - 500082, TELANGANA 3 THE COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX (IT & TP), HYDERABAD. 4 THE D.R., ITAT, HYDERABAD A-BENCH, HYDERABAD. 5 GUARD FILE TRUE COPY

ASSISTANT REGISTRAR / I.T.A.T., HYDERABAD GEETHA Digitally signed by GEETHA VISHWANATHAN DN: C=IN, O=INCOME TAX APPELLATE TRIBUNAL HYDERABAD, 2.5.4.20=fff52f4bdbd8c1faf4d9bc1b8157b0d648ac4049d668b28b2ca12ec8baf5aa71, OU=INCOME TAX APPELLATE TRIBUNAL,CID - 7079141, 2.5.4.17=500080, S=Telangana, VISHWANATHAN SerialNumber=78b106a34018ddebb6525c6db66e1f41656628afdc4474204cd60eeba1d782ed, CN=GEETHA VISHWANATHAN Date: 2026.11.17 13:06:42 +05'30' 28

More judgments on Section 144C

All 3,960 judgments and leading authorities on Section 144C →

Recent GST High Court judgments

Search GST case law →