T. RATHIESH vs. COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX-I VIZAG
What did the High Court hold?
The Tribunal held that an assessee can adopt both cash and mercantile systems for different components of income. However, the assessee cannot "blow hot and cold at one and the same time." If the assessee intends to treat the amount deducted as TDS as a component of tax paid, the corresponding interest income must form part of the returns and assessment. Conversely, if the assessee intends to pay tax on interest as and when received, the TDS amount can be treated as outstanding income until actual receipt. The Tribunal found that Section 198 of the Act is attracted. When TDS becomes incapable of adjustment towards tax payable, it acquires the character of income. Therefore, the TDS amount, in this case, deserves to be treated as income for the concerned assessment year, as the assessee did not receive the interest. The attempt to treat the TDS amount as tax paid on income not offered for taxation was not permitted. The appeals are partly allowed, holding that the assessee cannot claim credit for TDS as tax paid, and it shall be treated as an item of income.
What were the facts?
The assessee, Sri Y. Rathiesh, was the Managing Director of M/s. A.P. Tanneries Limited (1st company) and advanced loans to it and M/s. Associated Tanners (2nd company). The 2nd company paid interest regularly, and the assessee adopted the mercantile system for this income, paying tax. For the 1st company, which showed accumulated interest in its books but did not make actual payment, the assessee adopted the cash system. The 1st company deducted tax at source (TDS) on the interest payable and issued certificates. The assessee did not offer the interest income from the 1st company for taxation under the cash system but sought to utilize the TDS certificates. The Assessing Officer, Commissioner, and Tribunal disagreed, holding that the assessee could not claim the benefit of TDS without offering the corresponding interest income. The appeals are filed under Section 260A of the Income Tax Act, 1961, against the Tribunal's order dated 09-11-2001.
What were the issues?
1. Whether the assessee can adopt a hybrid accounting system, partly cash and partly mercantile, for different components of income within the same return, and if so, whether the authorities erred in applying mercantile system principles to the entire return. 2. Whether the assessee is entitled to claim the benefit of Tax Deducted at Source (TDS) on interest income from the 1st company, even when the interest itself was not offered for taxation under the cash system due to non-receipt. Assessee's contentions: It is permissible for an assessee to adopt partly the cash system and partly the mercantile system. Even while holding this as permissible, the authorities applied the principles of the mercantile system for the entire returns. The assessee ought not to have been levied tax on interest when the 1st company did not pay it. Once TDS was deducted, the assessee was entitled to claim the benefit thereof. Revenue's contentions: Though a dual method is permissible, the assessee cannot claim the benefit of TDS in its entirety while refusing to pay tax on the corresponding interest. The assessee acquired a right to receive interest once it was shown in the company's books, which is sufficient to levy tax, especially when the assessee is taking full advantage of the TDS amount.
Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?
AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below
* HON’BLE SRI JUSTICE L. NARASIMHA REDDY
+ I.T.T.A Nos. 52 AND 54 OF 2002
% Dated 06-08-2014
Sri Y. Rathiesh …Appellant
VERSUS
$ The Commissioner of Income Tax – I, Visakhapatnam …..Respondent
…RESPONDENT
! Counsel for the Appellant: Smt. K. Neeraja
^Counsel for the Respondent: Sri S.R. Ashok, Senior Counsel
<GIST:
>HEAD NOTE:
? Cases referred
HON’BLE SRI JUSTICE L. NARASIMHA REDDY
I.T.T.A Nos. 52 AND 54 OF 2002
06-08-2014
BETWEEN
Sri Y. Rathiesh …Appellant
And
The Commissioner of Income Tax – I, Visakhapatnam …..Respondent
HON’BLE SRI JUSTICE L. NARASIMHA REDDY
I.T.T.A Nos. 52 AND 54 OF 2002
COMMON JUDGMENT: (per the Hon'ble Sri Justice L. Narasimha Reddy)
These two appeals filed under Section 260A of the Income Tax Act, 1961 (for short ‘the Act’) arise out of common order dated 09-11-2001 passed by the Visakhapatnam Bench of the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (for short ‘the Tribunal’) in I.T.A No. 2254
and 2257 of 1996 and batch. The assessee is the appellant.
The appellant was functioning as a Managing Director of M/s. A.P. Tanneries Limited (for short, ‘the 1st company’). He gave loan of certain amounts to the said company as well as to another company by name M/s. Associated Tanners (for short, ‘the 2nd company’). The latter was paying interest on the amount advanced by him regularly, whereas the former was just showing the accumulated interest, in its account books without making actual payment. It was also his case that even while showing the interest payable to him in the account books, the 1st company deducted tax at source (TDS) on the amount of interest payable and issued certificates, in relation thereto. In the returns filed by him, the appellant was adopting a hybrid procedure. While in respect of his transaction with the 1st company, he adopted cash system, as regards the transaction with the 2nd company, he adopted the mercantile system. The result was that he did not pay the tax on the interest payable to him by the 1st company, even while he enjoyed the entire benefit of TDS made in that behalf. There is no dispute about the interest paid by the 2nd company, since the appellant has shown the same as income and paid tax thereon.
The assessing officer took objection to this and passed an order of assessment treating the interest payable by the 1st company on transfer basis, as income and levied tax. The same result ensued for various financial years. Aggrieved by that, the
appellant filed appeals before the Commissioner of Income Tax, Visakhapatnam. The appeals were dismissed. Thereupon, the appellant filed further appeals before the Tribunal. Through order dated 09-11-2001, the Tribunal dismissed the appeals.
Learned counsel for the appellant submits that it is open for an assessee to adopt partly the cash system and partly, the mercantile system and even while holding the same as permissible, the authorities under the Act have adopted the principles underlying the mercantile system for the entire returns. It is pleaded that when the 1st company did not pay the interest at all, the appellant ought not to have been levied tax on such amount. She has also urged that once TDS is deducted even while withholding the payment of the corresponding amount, the appellant was entitled to claim the benefit thereof.
Sri S.R. Ashok, learned Senior Counsel for the Income Tax Department submits that though it is permissible for an assessee to adopt dual method for the same returns, the appellant cannot claim the benefit of TDS in its entirety and at the same time, refuse to pay tax on the corresponding interest. Learned Senior Counsel submits that the appellant acquired a right to receive interest from the 1st company once it was shown in the account books of that organization; and that is sufficient to levy tax upon the appellant, particularly when he is taking full advantage of the amount recovered as TDS.
The assessee has option to file returns by adopting the cash
system or mercantile system. In a given case, he can adopt both the systems for different components in one and the same returns. The broad distinction between these two systems is well known. Under the cash system, the assessee would be under an obligation to pay tax only on such of the amount which has been actually received by him. In contrast, under the mercantile system, mere entitlement to receive would bring about the obligation to pay tax. The assessees choose one of them or both of them for different parts, after taking note of the advantages and disadvantages in adopting these methods.
We are concerned with the income of the appellant in the form of interest, on the loans which he has advanced to the two companies referred to above. As a matter of fact, he is the Managing Director of the 1st company. His case is that the 2nd company was paying interest regularly and in relation to the transaction of that company, he adopted mercantile system. There is no dispute about payment of tax on that. For the transaction with the 1st company, he has chosen to adopt the cash system. He stated that though the amount payable to him as interest was being shown in the account books of the company, the actual payment of the amount was not done. Another contention was that even while not paying the amount, TDS was affected.
By adopting the cash system for this component of his returns, the appellant did not pay any tax on the interest payable to him by the 1st company, on the ground that the amount has not
been paid at all. If that were to have been all, there would not have been any controversy. The reason is that under the cash system, the liability to pay tax arises only when the concerned amount is received as income. The 1st company made TDS in respect of the amount payable to the appellant as interest and issued certificate. The appellant wanted to use the certificate in its entirety. In other words, the amount reflected in the TDS certificate was being shown as tax already paid. This would have devastating effect. The amount covered by the certificate would take care of the interest payable on other income of the appellant. For example, if the amount reflected in TDS constitutes tax payable on a sum of Rs.1,00,000/-, that would have taken care of the income of the appellant to the extent of Rs.1,00,000/- from other sources, though the interest as regards which the TDS was affected, was not reflected in the returns at all. All the authorities under the Act i.e., the assessing officer, the Commissioner and the Tribunal did not approve the method adopted by the appellant.
The appellant cannot be permitted to blow hot and cold at one and the same time. If no TDS was affected and interest was not paid, he would not have been under an obligation to show the amount of interest in his returns, much less to pay tax thereon. However, once TDS is affected, he cannot be permitted to use the certificate to cover other amounts even while refusing to show the amount of interest in his returns. The steps taken by the authorities in this behalf cannot be treated as applying the parameters for mercantile system to a component of the returns filed under the cash system. The effect of the order passed by the
assessing officer as upheld by the Commissioner and the Tribunal is only that the appellant must desist from having the best of both the systems and discarding the one, which is disadvantageous to him. Once he intends to treat the amount deducted as TDS as a component of tax paid, the corresponding to the TDS must form part of the returns and assessment. On the other hand, if he intends to pay the tax on the interest as and when he receives it, the amount covered by the TDS certificate can be treated as just income outstanding, till the actual date of receipt.
In the facts of the present case, Section 198 gets attracted. Whenever an amount deducted as tax at source becomes incapable of being adjusted or counted towards tax payable, it acquires the character of income. In such an event, it partakes the character of any other income and is liable to be dealt with accordingly, in the order of assessment. Since the appellant has adopted the cash system and he did not receive the interest regarding which the TDS was affected, the TDS amount deserves to be treated as income. However, the attempt made by him to treat that amount as tax for the corresponding amount, cannot be permitted.
For the foregoing reasons, we partly allow the appeals holding that the appellant cannot be permitted to give credit to the amount representing TDS as tax and on the other hand, it shall be treated as an item of income for the concerned assessment year.
The miscellaneous petitions filed in these appeals shall also
stand disposed of. There shall be no order as to costs.
___________________________ L. NARASIMHA REDDY, J
____________________________ CHALLA KODANDA RAM, J 06-08-2014 ks Note: LR copy to be marked. B/O ks
More judgments on Section 198
- Hanoze Harish Thakkar, Mumbai vs Income Tax Officer Ward 19(1)(5), MumbaiITA 9314/MUM/2025[2014-15]Status: Disposed25 Sept 2026AY 2014-15
- Netscout Systems Industrial Private… vs DCIT- Circle 1(3)(1), MumbaiITA 3582/MUM/2026[2016-17]Status: Disposed8 Sept 2026AY 2016-17
- Anita Grover, Delhi vs Income Tax Officer, DelhiITA 4305/DEL/2026[2019-20]Status: Disposed31 Aug 2026AY 2019-20
- Knight Frank Property Services Private… vs Dy. Commissioner of Income Tax, Circle…ITA 1247/MUM/2026[2018-19]Status: Disposed8 Jul 2026AY 2018-19
- JCIT(OSD)(E) Circle-1 Ahmedabad, Ahmedabad vs Gujarat Maritime Board, GandhinagarITA 212/AHD/2023[2019-20]Status: Disposed13 May 2026AY 2019-20
Recent GST High Court judgments
Search GST case law →- Subrat Kumar Samal vs. The Commissioner, CGST, Cx And Customs, BhubaneswarOrissa · 3 Nov 2026
- Laxmipriya Biswal vs. Assistant Commissioner Of State Tax,BhubaneswarOrissa · 3 Nov 2026
- M/S Shree Jagannath Engineering,Angul vs. Assistant Commissioner, Angul Division ,AngulOrissa · 3 Nov 2026
- M/S. Archana Agro, Nayagarh vs. The Chief Commissioner Of Commercial Taxes And Goods And Services Tax, CuttackOrissa · 3 Nov 2026
- M/S.Shree Jagannath Associates, Angul vs. The Chief Commissioner Of Commercial Taxes And Goods And Services Tax, CuttackOrissa · 3 Nov 2026