Shakti LPG Ltd. vs. Income Tax Officer

PDF · subscribers
ITTA/215/2003HC TelanganaHBHC01017474200317 September 2014Author: CHALLA KODANDA RAM,L.NARASIMHA REDDY6 pages
AI SummaryDismissed

What did the High Court hold?

The Tribunal held that the appellant failed to demonstrate that the recipient of the payment qualified under Section 195(1) of the Act, nor did it establish that the amount paid was not taxable. The Tribunal noted that the payment was made in the context of installing sophisticated machinery. It observed that if the contract had distinct components of machinery sale and installation with specified consideration, the appellant should have disclosed this in its returns. Since this was not done and the plea was not taken in its correct perspective in the Section 201 proceedings, the Tribunal found it difficult to accept the contention of severability of the two components. Consequently, the Tribunal concluded that the recipient did not qualify under Section 195(1), the amount was taxable, and the appellant was obligated to deduct tax at source. Therefore, the proceedings under Section 201 were justified. While acknowledging the Supreme Court's ruling in GE India Technology Centre's case regarding the permissibility of verifying taxability in Section 201 proceedings, the Tribunal desisted from detailed discussion as the facts did not permit. The appeal was dismissed, but the appellant was protected from steps under Section 221 of the Act.

What were the facts?

The appellant, Shakti LPG Ltd., involved in filling LPG, entered into a contract with M/s. Imodco Inc, USA, for acquiring and installing machinery in 1994-95, paying US $1,00,000/-. The appellant did not deduct tax at source, contending the payment was for goods and not taxable. Proceedings under Section 201 of the Income Tax Act, 1961, were initiated, treating the appellant as an assessee in default. The Assessing Officer demanded the tax and interest, amounting to Rs. 86,735/-. The Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals) dismissed the appellant's appeal, as did the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT) through its order dated 30-08-2002. The appellant filed a further appeal to the High Court under Section 260A.

What were the issues?

1. Whether the appellant was under an obligation to deduct tax at source under Section 195 of the Income Tax Act, 1961, on the payment of US $1,00,000/- to M/s. Imodco Inc, USA, for the acquisition and installation of machinery. Assessee's contentions: The appellant argued that Section 195, not Section 201, was attracted. They contended that the amount was not chargeable to tax under the Act, either due to the nature of the recipient or the transaction. They further argued that the contract was composite, comprising sale of goods and installation, and only the installation portion might be taxable. Reliance was placed on the Supreme Court judgment in GE India Technology Centre P Ltd. v. CIT. Revenue's contentions: The respondent argued that the appellant was obligated to deduct tax at source under Section 195 and its failure led to proceedings under Section 201. They asserted that the taxability of the amount was beyond doubt, making Section 201 the appropriate provision. The revenue also contended that the appellant had not previously raised the plea of a composite contract with separate components.

Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?

Section 260A,Section 201,Section 195,Section 91(2)(b),Section 221

AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below

HON’BLE SRI JUSTICE L. NARASIMHA REDDY AND HON’BLE SRI JUSTICE CHALLA KODANDA RAM

I.T.T.A No. 215 OF 2003

17-09-2014

BETWEEN

Shakti LPG Ltd., Hyderabad …Appellant

And

Income Tax Officer, Ward-8, (TDS), Hyderabad …..Respondent

HON’BLE SRI JUSTICE L. NARASIMHA REDDY AND HON’BLE SRI JUSTICE CHALLA KODANDA RAM

I.T.T.A No. 215 OF 2003

JUDGMENT: (per the Hon'ble Sri Justice L. Narasimha Reddy)

The unsuccessful appellant in ITA No.301/Hyd/1996 before the Hyderabad Bench ‘A’ of the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (for short, ‘the Tribunal’) filed this appeal under Section 260A of the Income Tax Act, 1961 (for short, ‘the Act’) feeling aggrieved by the order dated 30-08-2002.

The facts, in brief, are that the appellant is an assessee and is involved in the activity of filling the liquefied petroleum gas. As a part of its activity, it is said to have entered into a contract with

M/s. Imodco Inc, a firm from USA to acquire some machinery and installation thereof in the premises of the factory/plant in the year 1994-95. A sum of US $ 1,00,000/- was paid as consideration. However, no deduction at source, towards tax was made. Therefore, proceedings under Section 201 of the Act were initiated and a notice was issued treating the appellant as ‘assessee in default’. The reply submitted by the appellant was that the amount was paid to a non-resident and the contract was mostly for supply of goods on purchase and on that account, there was no occasion to effect deduction of tax at source. That plea was not accepted by the assessing officer and an order was passed requiring the appellant to pay not only the tax which was supposed to be deducted, but also interest thereon, being Rs.86,735/-. Feeling aggrieved by that, the appellant filed an appeal before the Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals). That was dismissed on 14-11-1995. Thereupon, it approached the Tribunal with a further appeal. The Tribunal rejected the appeal through order dated 30-08-2002.

Sri Y. Ratnakar, learned counsel for the appellant submits that the provision that gets attracted to the facts of this case is Section 195 and not Section 201 of the Act. He submits that even under Section 195, the occasion to effect deduction of tax would arise if only the amount was chargeable to tax under the provisions of the Act and in the instant case, whether one goes by the nature of person who received the amount or the nature of transaction, the amount was not chargeable. He further submits

that even otherwise, the contract was composite in nature comprising of the sale of goods by the recipient of the amount and the contract of installation and at the best, it can be the second portion of it, that can be brought under the purview of Section 195 read with Section 91 (2) (b) of the Act. He placed reliance upon the judgment of the Supreme Court in GE India Technology Centr e P Ltd., v. CIT[1].

Sri S.R. Ashok, learned Senior Counsel for the respondent, on the other hand, submits that the appellant was under an obligation to effect the deduction of tax at source and to remit the same to the department, when it paid the amount of US $ 1,00,000/- to the U.S firm and its failure, naturally resulted in initiation of proceedings under Section 201 of the Act. He contends that there is absolutely no doubt whatever, as to the taxability of the amount paid by the appellant and in that view of the matter, Section 201 is the appropriate provision. Learned Senior Counsel further submits that the appellant never came forward with a plea that the contract comprised of two parts and it cannot be permitted to canvass that contention at this stage, for the first time.

The deduction of tax at source, is one of the important features of the Act. In a way, it obviates the necessity for the department to track the amount paid by an assessee to another, and then to levy tax on the recipient. What started as a matter of convenience has assumed the character of legal obligation on the part of the person who pays the amount. The failure to deduct tax

at source which was otherwise to be done, invites several consequences, including levy of interest under Section 201 of the Act. Such assessee is liable to be treated as the one, in default, under Section 221 of the Act.

Section 195 of the Act deals with a set of circumstances, pertaining to deduction of tax at source where, not only the person who receives the amount, but also the nature of the amount that is paid become relevant. In other words, the verification can be person specific and/or the amount specific. If the person who receives the amount happens to be non-resident, subject to certain qualifications, the individual who pays the amount stands relieved from the obligation to effect deduction of the tax on the amount so paid. Similarly, if the amount paid is not taxable under the Act, the obligation ceases. Section 195 reads:

“Other sums. 1 9 5 (1): Any person responsible for paying to a non-resident, not being a company, or to a foreign company, any interest [(not being interest referred to in section 194LB or section 194LC)] [or section 194LD] or any other sum chargeable under the provisions of this Act (not being income chargeable under the head “Salaries”) shall, at the time of credit of such income to the account of the payee or at the time of payment thereof in cash or by the issue of a cheque or draft or by any other mode, whichever is earlier, deduct income-tax thereon at the rates in force…… (remaining part of the section is omitted as not relevant for this case).”

In the instant case, the appellant is not able to demonstrate that the person or agency whom it paid the amount is the one that

is described in the first part of sub-section (1) of Section 195 of the Act and thereby it is not under obligation to pay tax at all. Secondly, the appellant was not able to establish that the amount paid by it is not taxable. It is not in dispute that it was paid in the context of the installation of a machinery of sophisticated technology.

In case, the contract has separate components of sale of machinery on the one hand and the installation of machinery on the other hand and the consideration for both of them was specified, the appellant could have certainly mentioned the same in his returns, in which case it was possible for the assessing authority to address the issue even from the point of view of Sections 195 and 201 of the Act. That not having been done and the plea not having been taken in its correct perspective in the proceedings initiated under Section 201, it is difficult to accept the contention as to the severality of the two components referred to above. The inescapable conclusion is that, (a) the recipient of the amount did not qualify under Section 195(1), (b) the amount paid by the appellant was taxable and (c) the appellant was under obligation to effect deduction of tax at source.

Since that was not done, no exception can be taken to the proceedings under Section 201 of the Act.

Though it is urged on behalf of the Revenue that in the proceedings under Section 201 of the Act, any verification as to

the taxability or otherwise of the income or the components thereof is impermissible and though the learned counsel for the appellant has placed reliance upon the judgment of the Supreme Court in GE India Technology Centre’s case (1 supra), which in a way held that such an exercise is permissible, we desist from dealing with the same in detail since the facts of the present case do not permit of it.

We, therefore, dismiss the appeal. However, since there was an arguable point at every stage on account of there being a possibility to take different views on the same set of facts, we direct that the appellant shall not be exposed to steps under Section 221 of the Act and other relevant provisions.

There shall be no order as to costs.

___________________________ L. NARASIMHA REDDY, J

____________________________ CHALLA KODANDA RAM, J 17-09-2014 ks Note: LR copy to be marked. B/O ks [1] 327 ITR 456

More judgments on Section 201

All 1,755 judgments and leading authorities on Section 201 →

Recent GST High Court judgments

Search GST case law →