The Commissioner of Incoem tax vs. M/s. Andhra Conductors (P) Ltd.,

PDF · subscribers
ITTA/35/2004HC TelanganaHBHC01049834200426 November 2014Author: CHALLA KODANDA RAM,L.NARASIMHA REDDY7 pages
AI SummaryDismissed

What did the High Court hold?

The Tribunal held that the Assessing Officer erred in invoking Section 43B of the Income Tax Act. Section 43B disallows deductions for certain sums unless actually paid. However, the occasion to invoke this section arises only if a deduction is claimed and not proven to be paid. In this case, the assessee had not claimed any deduction for the sales tax amount. The Tribunal agreed with the Commissioner's observation that the assessee had not made any claim for deduction towards sales tax. The Tribunal further clarified that while any amount received by an assessee is to be added to income, mere recognition of a liability to pay sales tax does not lead to the inference that the amount has been received. The Supreme Court's decision in Chowringhee Sales Bureau P. Ltd. was distinguished because it involved a specific finding that the assessee had received the sales tax amount. Since no such finding was recorded by the Assessing Officer in the present case, there was no basis to add the amount to the assessee's income. The appeal filed by the revenue was dismissed.

What were the facts?

The revenue is appealing an order of the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (Visakhapatnam Bench) and the Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals) for the assessment year 1990-91. The assessee, a manufacturer of electrical cables, had Rs. 14,92,647/- shown as sales tax liability in its books. The Assessing Officer added this amount to the assessee's income, disallowing it under Section 43B of the Income Tax Act. The Commissioner (Appeals) allowed the assessee's appeal, and the Tribunal dismissed the revenue's appeal. The revenue contends that recognizing the sales tax liability implies receipt of the amount, which should be treated as a trade receipt, deductible only upon actual remittance. The assessee argues that there's no proof of receiving this amount and that the Assessing Officer did not ascertain the facts.

What were the issues?

1. Whether, as a question of law, the Tribunal erred in upholding the Commissioner's order which allowed the assessee's appeal, thereby not treating the amount of Rs. 14,92,647/- as a trade receipt, despite the assessee recognizing it as a liability under the A.P. General Sales Tax Act? Assessee's contentions: The assessee argued that there was no evidence on record to show that it had received the amount representing sales tax from any purchaser. It further contended that the Assessing Officer did not conduct any inquiry or ascertain the relevant facts. The assessee relied on the findings of the Commissioner and the Tribunal, stating that the Supreme Court's decision in Chowringhee Sales Bureau P. Ltd. v. Commissioner of Income-Tax, West Bengal, was distinguishable as it involved a finding of fact that the assessee had received the sales tax amount. Revenue's contentions: The revenue argued that once the assessee recognized the liability to pay sales tax, it should be inferred that the amount was received. The revenue contended that this amount should be added as a trade or business receipt, and a deduction would only be permissible upon proof of remittance to the State Exchequer. The revenue relied on the Supreme Court judgment in Chowringhee Sales Bureau P. Ltd. v. Commissioner of Income-Tax, West Bengal.

Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?

Section 43B,Section 260A,Section 139,Section 28,Section 36

AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below

THE HON’BLE SRI JUSTICE L.NARASIMHA REDDY

AND

THE HON’BLE SRI JUSTICE CHALLA KODANDA RAM

I.T.T.A.No.35 of 2004

JUDGMENT: (Per the Hon’ble Sri Justice L.Narasimha Reddy)

Not satisfied with the order, dated 25.08.1995, passed by the Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals) and the one, dated 02.07.2002, passed by the Visakhapatnam Bench of the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (for short ‘the Tribunal’), in I.T.A.No.1712/Hyd/95, the revenue filed this appeal. The dispute is referable to the assessment year 1990-91.

The respondent is a manufacturer of Electrical cables. As part of its activity, it manufactures cables of different categories and sells them to the persons, or agencies, who place the order upon it. The sales tax payable on the sale of the product is a component of sale consideration. In its books of account, it maintained a separate account as regards the sales tax liability. On the one hand, it was entering the amount of sales tax, as and when received, as part of consideration and, on the other hand, was making entries as regards sales tax, as and when it is remitted to the State Exchequer.

In the books of account referable to assessment year 1990- 91, the amount due towards sales tax was shown as Rs.14,92,647/-. Returns were submitted under the Income Tax Act (for short ‘the Act’). The Assessing Officer passed an order, dated 25.02.1993, discussing various claims made by the respondent. At the end of the order, he added a sum of Rs.14,92,647/- to income, by observing that the said amount is disallowed under Section 43B of the Act.

Feeling aggrieved by that, the respondent filed an appeal before the Commissioner. The appeal was allowed on 25.08.1995. Challenging the said order, the revenue filed I.T.A.No.1712 of 1995 before the Tribunal and the appeal was dismissed.

Sri J.V.Prasad, learned counsel for the appellant, submits that once the respondent has recognized the liability to pay sales tax, it is to be inferred that the amount has already been received by them, and the deduction thereof, would arise, if only the amount has been remitted. According to the learned counsel, the amount received towards sales tax, deserves to be added as trade or business receipt, and only when it is proved that the amount is paid to the State Exchequer that the corresponding deduction can be made. Learned counsel further submits that the view taken by the Commissioner and the Tribunal cannot be sustained in law. He placed reliance upon a judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Chowringhee Sales Bureau P. Ltd. v. Commissioner of Income- Tax, West Bengal[1].

Sri Vedula Srinivas, learned counsel for the respondent, on the other hand, submits that though his client recognized the liability to pay sales tax to the extent of Rs.14,92,647/-, there is nothing on record to show that he received that amount from any purchaser. He contends that the Assessing Officer did not undertake any discussion whatever, much less did he ascertain the relevant facts from the respondent. Learned counsel submits that the Commissioner as well as the Tribunal have taken the relevant facts into account, and applied the correct principles of law. He contends that the judgment of the Supreme Court in Chowringhee Sales Bureau P. Ltd.’s case (supra) does not apply to the facts of the present case, since a finding of fact was recorded therein to the effect that the assessee did receive the amount representing sales

tax, but did not remit the same to the State Exchequer.

Though it is not the practice to read the order of assessment in detail, in an appeal filed under Section 260A of the Act, we have gone through the order of assessment and those passed by the Commissioner and the Tribunal, in detail in view of the peculiar facts of the case. The Assessing Officer has undertaken extensive discussion, with reference to each and every claim made by the respondent, and passed orders, incorporating his conclusions. However, in the context of the amount payable towards A.P. General Sales Tax Act, no discussion whatever was undertaken and the only portion of the order referable to that aspect reads: “(8) Disallowance u/s.43B: (i) APGST Balance as on 31.03.1990 Rs.18,81,394 Less: Opening balance Rs. 3,88,747 ___________ Rs.14,92,647

(ii) APGST price variation account balance as on 31.03.1990 Rs.35,377 Less: Opening balance Rs.24,297 __________ Rs. 11,080”

Since reference was made to Section 43B of the Act, it becomes necessary to have a glance of it:

“43B. Certain deductions to be only on actual payment- Notwithstanding anything contained in any other provision of this Act, a deduction otherwise allowable under this Act in respect of – (a) any sum payable by the assessee by way of tax, duty, cess, or fee, by whatever name called, under any law for the time being in force, or (b) any sum payable by the assessee as an employer by way of contribution to any

provident fund or superannuation fund or gratuity fund or any other fund for the welfare of employees, or (c) any sum referred to in clause (ii) of sub- section (1) of section 36, or (d) any sum payable by the assessee as interest on any loan or borrowing from any public financial institution or a State Financial Corporation or a State Industrial Investment Corporation, in accordance with the terms and conditions of the agreement governing such loan or borrowing; or (e) any sum payable by the assessee as interest on any loan or advances from a scheduled bank in accordance with the terms and conditions of the agreement governing such loan or advances, or (f) any sum payable by the assessee as an employer in lieu of any leave at the credit of his employee; shall be allowed irrespective of the previous year in which the liability to pay such sum was incurred by the assessee according to the method of accounting regularly employed by him only in computing the income referred to in section 28 of that previous year in which such sum is actually paid by him: provided that nothing contained in this section shall apply in relation to any sum which is actually paid by the assessee on or before the due date applicable in his case for furnishing the return of income under sub-section (1) of section 139 in respect of the previous year in which the liability to pay such sum was incurred as aforesaid and the evidence of such payment is furnished by the assessee along with such return.”

Though Section 43 of the Act, occurs in the Chapter pertaining to deductions, it is, indeed, an exception to deductions. The Section prohibits the deduction of any amount representing the sales tax, unless it is proved to have been paid. This is, in a way, deviation from the normal practice, where deductions are allowed even if the mere provision is made and not the actual payment. The occasion for invoking Section 43 of the Act, would have arisen, if only the

respondent made a claim of deduction of Rs.14,92,647/- towards sales tax and no proof of payment thereof has been placed before the Assessing Officer. When no deduction whatever was claimed, there was no necessity or occasion to invoke Section 43B of the Act.

Any amount, which is received by an assessee, is to be added to income, though the source or the category of the income may differ and the legal consequences may also be different. In case the respondent has received any amount towards sales tax, it deserves to be treated as trade or business receipt, and the same is liable to tax. If the amount so received is remitted to the State Exchequer, deduction can certainly be claimed under the relevant provisions of the Act.

There may be cases where sales of a fairly high magnitude have taken place, but the seller, who happens to be an assessee, is yet to receive the entire sale consideration or the component of sales tax. In such a case, the sale, takes place, with the movement or supply of the goods. Correspondingly, the liability to pay sales tax must be recognised. The actual payment of sales tax, may not take place, on the same day, on which the sale has taken place. Once the sale has taken place, the liability to pay sales tax arises. However, the trader has the facility to pay the sales tax, even at a later point of time. Some times there may be dispute as to the quantum of sales tax and interpretations, may vary. As and when the amount even including the component of sales tax is received, the remittance can be made by the trader. However, mere recognition of the liability to pay sales tax does not lead to an inference, much less a conclusion, that the amount is already in the hands of the trader. In case the Assessing Officer has the proof with him, that the amount representing the sales tax has been received by the trader, he can certainly add that income as the one, by trading it as ‘trade or

business receipt’. It is only on proof of payment of the amount so received to the concerned department, that he can claim deductions.

I n Chowringhee Sales Bureau P. Ltd.’s case (supra), the Hon’ble Supreme Court was dealing with a case where the assessee did receive the amount representing sales tax, but he did not remit to the State exchequer by claiming that there is a dispute as to the very liability to pay it. Taking that into account, the Hon’ble Supreme Court held as under:

“It is apparent from the order of the Appellate Assistant Commissioner and has not been disputed before us in the present case that in the cash memos issued by the appellant to the purchasers in the auction sale, it was the appellant who was shown as the seller. The amount realized by the appellant from the purchasers included sales tax. The appellant, however, did not pay the amount of sales tax to the actual owner of the goods auctioned because the statutory liability for the payment of that sales tax was that of the appellant. The appellant company did not also deposit the amount realized by it as sales tax in the State exchequer because it took the position that the statutory provision creating that liability upon it was not valid. As the amount of sales tax was received by the appellant in its character as an auctioneer, the amount, in our view, should be held to form part of its trading or business receipt. The appellant would, of course, be entitled to claim deduction of the amount as and when it pays it to the State Government.”

What made difference in that case was that the finding as to receipt of payment of the amount representing sales tax. Such a finding is not at all feasible in the instant case. Unless the Assessing Officer recorded a finding to the effect that the respondent has received the amount shown as the sales tax, there was no basis for him to add it to the income of the respondent. The Commissioner made a specific observation to the effect that the respondent did not make any claim of deduction of any amount towards sales tax.

There was no occasion for dealing with that at all. We are in agreement with the findings recorded by the Commissioner and the Tribunal. The appeal is accordingly dismissed. There shall be no order as to costs. The miscellaneous petitions filed in this appeal shall also stand disposed of. ____________________ L.NARASIMHA REDDY, J.

_____________________ CHALLA KODANDA RAM, J. Date:26.11.2014 GJ

[1] 1973 ITR 542

More judgments on Section 43B

All 7,457 judgments and leading authorities on Section 43B →

Recent GST High Court judgments

Search GST case law →