RAKESH PRAKASH,PATNA vs. DC/AC CIRCLE-4, PATNA, PATNA

PDF · subscribers
ITA 485/PAT/2025Status: DisposedITAT Patna12 November 2026AY 2021-20227 pages
AI SummaryAllowed

What did the Tribunal hold?

The Tribunal held that the issue concerning the disallowance of employee contributions to PF and ESIC for delayed deposit is debatable, especially in light of the pending consideration before the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of Woodland (Aero Club) Pvt. Ltd. v. ACIT and the fact that the Supreme Court had admitted an SLP to review the decision in Checkmate Services Private Limited. The Tribunal noted that a debatable issue cannot form the basis for an adjustment made in an intimation issued under Section 143(1) of the Act by the CPC. Therefore, the intimation issued under Section 143(1) was quashed. However, liberty was granted to the Revenue to initiate proceedings within the purview of the Income Tax Act in accordance with law. The appeals of the assessee were allowed for both assessment years.

What were the facts?

The assessee, Rakesh Prakash, filed appeals against the orders of the CIT(A) for Assessment Years 2020-21 and 2021-22. For AY 2020-21, the CPC disallowed employee contributions to PF and ESIC of Rs. 44,17,481/- under Section 36(1)(va) for non-deposit by the statutory due date. For AY 2021-22, a similar disallowance of Rs. 16,38,351/- was made. The assessee's applications under Section 154 were unsuccessful. The CIT(A) confirmed the disallowances, relying on the Supreme Court's decision in Checkmate Services Private Limited vs. CIT. The assessee argued that the deposits were made within the due date for filing the return under Section 139(1) and that the issue was debatable, citing COVID-related extensions and an SLP filed for review of the Checkmate Services decision.

What were the issues?

1. Whether the disallowance of employee contributions to PF and ESIC made under Section 143(1) of the Income Tax Act, 1961, is sustainable when the issue is considered debatable and pending before the Supreme Court. Assessee's Contentions: - The employee contributions were deposited within the due date for filing the return under Section 139(1) of the Act. - The Hon'ble Supreme Court's directions regarding extension of limitation periods during the Covid pandemic should be considered. - An SLP has been admitted by the Hon'ble Supreme Court to review the decision in Checkmate Services Private Limited. - The issue is debatable, and therefore, disallowance under Section 143(1) is not permissible. Reliance was placed on the decision of the Co-ordinate Bench in Atibari Tea Company Limited vs. DCIT. Revenue's Contentions: - The issue is settled by the decision of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Checkmate Services Private Limited (supra). - The order of the Ld. CIT(A) should be upheld.

Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?

Section 36(1)(va),Section 143(1),Section 139(1),Section 43B,Section 2(24)(x)

AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below

Income Tax Appellate Tribunal, PATNA ‘DB’ BENCH

Before: SHRI PRADIP KUMAR CHOUBEY & SHRI GOPALAN GURUSAMY

For Appellant: Shri Miraj D Shah, AR
For Respondent: Shri Ravi Kant Chowdhary, Sr. DR
Hearing: 12.10.2026Pronounced: 12.11.2026

IN THE INCOME TAX APPELLATE TRIBUNAL PATNA ‘DB’ BENCH (VIRTUAL HEARING AT KOLKATA) BEFORE SHRI PRADIP KUMAR CHOUBEY, JUDICIAL MEMBER AND SHRI GOPALAN GURUSAMY, ACCOUNTANT MEMBER ITA Nos.484 & 485/PAT/2025 Assessment Years: 2020-21 & 2021-22 Rakesh Prakash Vs. DC/AC Circle-4, Patna 81, 1st Floor, Commercial Building near Children Park, Sri Krishna Puri, Patna, Bihar-800001 [PAN: AKCPP8293J] APPELLANT RESPONDENT Appellant by : Shri Miraj D Shah, AR Respondent by : Shri Ravi Kant Chowdhary, Sr. DR Date of hearing : 12.10.2026 Date of Pronouncement : 12.11.2026 O R D E R PER GOPALAN GURUSAMY, ACCOUNTANT MEMBER: The captioned Appeals are filed by the Assessee against the order of the Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals)-Gurugram [‘Ld. CIT(A)’ for short) dated 14.08.2025 & 13.08.2025 passed u/s 250 of the Income Tax Act, 1961 (“the Act”, for short) for the Assessment Year 2020-21 & 2021-22 (Appeal Nos. NFAC/2019-20/10296534 & NFAC/2020-21/10296535 respectively.

2.

Brief facts of the case are for the assessment year 2020-21, the Assessee has filed return of income declaring a total income of Rs.47,10,399/-. While processing the return u/s 143(1) of the Act, the

ITA No.484 & 485/PAT/2025 Rakesh Prakash; A.Y: 2020-21 & 2021-22 CPC, Bengaluru disallowed the Employee Contribution to PF of Rs.41,47,698/- and Employee Contribution to ESIC of Rs.2,69,483/-, aggregating to RS.44,17,481/- u/s 36(1)(va) of the Act as the Employees Contribution were not deposited within the due date prescribed in the respective Acts. Similarly, for the Assessment year 2021-22, an amount of Rs.16,38,351/- was disallowed on account of delay in the Employees Contribution to PF and ESIC. The Assessee challenged the same by filing application u/s 154 of the Act before the Authorities in which it could not succeed. Subsequently, Appeal was filed before the Ld. CIT(A) who has confirmed the adjustments u/s 143(1) of the Act by relying on the decision of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Checkmate Services Private Limited vs. CIT [2022] 143 taxmann.com 178 (SC) dated 12.10.2022.

3.

The Ld. AR represented that, though there was a delay in the deposit of the amount into the funds, the same was deposited within the due date for filing the return u/s 139(1) of the Act, and hence, the same should be allowed. The Ld. AR also relied on the order of the Hon’ble Supreme Court for the extension of the limitation period during the Covid condition and argued that the period available to deposit the amount would get extended in view of the said directions of the Hon’ble Supreme Court. It was also argued that the Hon’ble Supreme Court admitted an SLP to review the decision rendered in the Page | 2

ITA No.484 & 485/PAT/2025 Rakesh Prakash; A.Y: 2020-21 & 2021-22 case of Checkmate Services Private Limited (supra). It was submitted that, as the amounts had already been paid within the due date for filing the return u/s 139(1) of the Act, and in any case the delay was only marginal, and in view of the conflicting judicial decisions, the Assessee requested that the impugned disallowance may be deleted. The Ld. AR also relied on the decision of the Co-ordinate Bench of Kolkata in the case of Atibari Tea Company Limited vs. DCIT, Circle- 1(1), Jalpaiguri in ITA No.3164/KOL/2025 dated 13.07.2026.

4.

On the other hand, the Ld. DR contended that the issue was settled in view of the decision of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Checkmate Services Private Limited (supra) and pleaded for upholding the order of the Ld. CIT(A).

5.

We have considered the rival submissions. We note that the Co-ordinate Bench at Kolkata in the case of Atibari Tea Company Limited vs. DCIT, Circle-1(1), Jalpaiguri in ITA No.3164/KOL/2025, order dated 13.07.2026 dealt with similar issue which are as under:-

“3.1. The entire decision of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Woodland (Aero Club) Pvt. Ltd. v. ACIT referred to supra reads as follows: “1. The High Court recorded the following findings as regards as the issue in question. i. Employer's contributions under Section 36(1)(iv) and employees’ contributions covered under Section 36(1)(va) read with Section

ITA No.484 & 485/PAT/2025 Rakesh Prakash; A.Y: 2020-21 & 2021-22 2(24)(x) are fundamentally different in nature and must be treated separately. ii. Employees' contribution deducted from their salaries Reason: are deemed to be income under Section 2(24)(x) and are held in trust by the employer. The employers can claim deduction only if they deposit these amounts on or before the statutory due date under Section 36(1)(va). iii. The non-obstante clause in Section 43B cannot be applied to employees' contributions governed by Section 36(1)(va). iv. Alom Extrusions (supra) has been distinguished as the same has not considered Sections 2(24)(x) and 36(1)(va). v. Explanation 5 to Section 43B was not considered at all while arriving at the decision that employees' contribution must be deposited on or before the due dates under relevant statutes.” 2. As per Section 2(24)(x), any amount recovered by the employer from the employees towards their contribution to any provident or superannuation fund or any other fund set up under the provisions of the ESI Act, 1948 or any other fund for the welfare of the employees is income. 3. Section 36(1)(va) of the Act says that any sum so received by the assessee - employer from his employees to which provisions of Section 2(24)(x) applies, the assessee - employer shall be entitled to deduction while computing income under Section 28, if such sum is credited by the assessee - employer to the employees account before the due date. 4. The Explanation to Section 36(1) (va) says that the 'due date' means the date by which the assessee -cemployer is required to credit the employees contribution in the relevant fund under any Act, Rule, Order or Notification issued thereunder. 5. There are two School of thoughts as regards the interpretation of the words “due date”. 6. A combined reading of the Section 2(24)(x) and that Section 36(1) (va) of the Act, prima facie is indicative that any sum received by the assessee - employer from any of his employees as contribution towards PF & ESI is the income of the assessee under Section 2(24)(x) and it continues to be so, unless it is credited by the assessee - employer to the employee's account in the relevant fund on or before the due date specified under the relevant PF, ESI Act.

ITA No.484 & 485/PAT/2025 Rakesh Prakash; A.Y: 2020-21 & 2021-22 7. The employee's contribution towards PF, ESI received by the assessee - employer is his income under Section 2(24)(x) and if he wants to have it deducted from his income under Section 36(1)(va), he must credit the same to the employee's account in the relevant fund on or before the due date specified under the relevant PF,ESI Act. 8. The aforesaid view is supported by the following judgments of the High Courts:- (i) Unifac Management Services (India) (P.) Ltd. v. Dy. CIT [2018] 100 taxmann.com244 [2019] 260 Taxman 60/[2018] 409 ITR 225 (Mad.), (ii) CIT v. Gujarat State Road Transport Corpn. [2014]41 taxmann.com 100/366 ITR 170/223 Taxman 398 (Guj.), (iii) CIT v. Merchem Ltd. [2015] 61 taxmann.com 119/235 Taxman 291/378 ITR 443 (Ker.), (iv) B.S. Patel v. Dy. CIT [2010] 326 ITR 457/[2008] 171 Taxman 304 (MP) and (v) Popular Vehicles & Services Pvt Ltd v. CIT [2018] 96 taxmann.com 13/257 Taxman 120/406 ITR (Ker). 9. The other view is that there is no difference between employees and employer contribution to PF, ESI and both would be guided by the provisions of Section 43B of the Act so as to allow deduction in the hands of the assessee - employer if the contributions are deposited on or before the due date of filling of return under Section 139(1) of the Income Tax Act, 1961. 10. The aforesaid view is supported by the following Judgments:- (i) CIT v. Aimil Ltd. [2010] 188 Taxman 265/321 ITR 508 (Delhi HC), (ii) Pr. CIT v. Plamman HR (P) Ltd. (IT Appeal No. 170 of 2018, dated 12.02.2018 (Delhi HC). (iii) CIT v. Nipso Ployfabriks Ltd. [2013] 350 ITR 327/213 Taxman 376/30 taxmann.com90 (HP). (iv) Sagun Foundry (P.) Ltd. v. CIT [2017] 78 taxmann.com 47 (All). (v) CIT v. Udaipur Dugdh Utpadak Sahakari Sangh Ltd. [2014] 366 ITR 163/[2013] 217 Taxman 64 (Mag.)/35 taxmann.com 616 (Raj.). (vi) CIT v. Sabari Enterprises [2008] 298 ITR 141 (Kar). (vii) CIT v. Hemla Embroidery Mills (P.) Ltd. [2014] 366 ITR 167/[2013] 217 Taxman 207/37 taxmann.com 160 (Punj. & Har.). (viii) CIT v. Ghatge Patil Transports Ltd. [2014] 368

ITA No.484 & 485/PAT/2025 Rakesh Prakash; A.Y: 2020-21 & 2021-22 ITR 749/[2015] 53 taxmann.com 141/228 Taxman 340. (ix) Bihar State Warehousing Corpn. Ltd. v. CIT [2016] 368 ITR 410 (Patna). (x) CIT v. Vijay Shree Ltd. [2014] 43 taxmann.com 396/224 Taxman. 12 (Cal.) (Mag.) (xi) CIT v. Industrial Security & Intelligence India Pvt. Ltd. [Tax Case (Appeal) Nos.585 and 586 of 2015 & M.P.No.1 of 2015, dated 24-7-2015. (xii) Gauhati High Court in the case of CIT v. George Williamson (Assam) Ltd. [2006] 284 ITR 619 (Gauhati). (xiii) CIT v. Kichha Sugar Ltd. [2013] 356 ITR 351/216 Taxman 90/35 taxmann.com 54 (Uttarakhand). (xiv) Pr. CIT v. Plamman HR (P) Ltd, [IT Appeal No. 599 of 2017, dated 11.09.2017]. 11. In view of the conflicting opinion, as referred to above, we would like to look into this issue. 12. Issue notice, returnable in four weeks. 13. Dasti, in addition, is permitted” 3.2 It was further submitted that the issue is now pending before the Hon’ble Supreme Court vide SLP dated 27.01.2026. It was the submission that the issue is a debatable issue and the disallowance is not permissible in an intimation issued u/s 143(1) of the Act. It was prayed that the intimation issued u/s 143(1) may be cancelled. 4. In reply, the ld. Sr. DR vehemently supported the orders of the CPC and JCIT(A). 5. We have considered the rival submissions. A perusal of the facts in the present case clearly shows that the issue in the decision of Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Checkmate Services (P) Ltd. vs. CIT is now under fresh consideration before Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Woodland (Aero Club) Pvt. Ltd. v. ACIT referred to supra and the Hon’ble Supreme Court has also considered various decisions. Admittedly the issue is a debatable issue in the present scenario. This being so, as a debatable issue is not permissible in an adjustment made in an intimation issued u/s 143(1) by the CPC. The CPC has taken the issue of PF & ESI contribution in respect of employees, the intimation issued u/s 143(1) dated 02.06.2025 stands quashed as the issue being debatable. Liberty is however granted to the revenue to initiate proceedings within the purview of the Income Tax Act in accordance with law. 6. In the result, the appeal of the assessee stands allowed.”

ITA No.484 & 485/PAT/2025 Rakesh Prakash; A.Y: 2020-21 & 2021-22 6. Respectfully following the above decision, we hold that as the issue is debatable, the impugned intimation u/s 143(1) of the Act would not survive. However, liberty is granted to the Revenue to initiate proceedings within the purview of the Act in accordance with law.

7.

In the result, Appeal of the Assessee stands allowed for both years.

Order pronounced on 12.11.2026. Sd/- Sd/- (PRADIP KUMAR CHOUBEY) (GOPALAN GURUSAMY) JUDICIAL MEMBER ACCOUNTANT MEMBER Dated: 12.11.2026 Deepak Prakash, PS Sangeeta Digitally signed by Sangeeta Sinha //TRUE COPY// Sinha Date: 2026.11.12 16:48:11 +05'30'

More judgments on Section 36(1)(va)

All 6,223 judgments and leading authorities on Section 36(1)(va) →

Recent GST High Court judgments

Search GST case law →