OM ENTERPRISES vs. COMMISSIONER OF INCOME-TAX

PDF · subscribers
T.A./71/2008HC JharkhandJHHC01011712200816 August 2012Author: HON'BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE(MR JUSTICE PRAKASH TATIA),HON'BLE MRS. JUSTICE JAYA ROY6 pages
AI SummaryAllowed

What did the High Court hold?

The High Court held that the doctrine of merger cannot be applied when an appeal is dismissed on the ground of limitation, as such dismissal does not decide the appeal on merits. Therefore, the order of the lower authority remains effective. Regarding the second issue, the Court referred to Section 184(7) of the Income Tax Act, 1961, which states that once registration is granted, it is valid for subsequent assessment years unless there is a change in the firm's constitution or failure to furnish a declaration in Form No. 12 within the allowed time. Since the AO granted registration for AY 1987-88 and there was no subsequent disqualification for AY 1988-89, the firm is deemed to be registered for AY 1987-88 and all subsequent years. Consequently, the appeal was allowed, and the appellant-firm is to be treated as registered from AY 1987-88 and for AY 1988-89.

What were the facts?

The assessee, Om Enterprises, is appealing against an order concerning assessment year 1988-89. The firm was registered from assessment year 1984-85. Due to reconstitution in financial year 1986-87 (AY 1987-88), it applied for re-registration. The Assessing Officer (AO) refused, and the CIT(A) dismissed the appeal. The ITAT remanded the matter for AY 1987-88. The firm was subsequently assessed as unregistered for AY 1988-89. The assessee did not appeal the AY 1988-89 assessment order before the CIT(A) due to a delay of 1253 days, leading to dismissal on grounds of limitation. Applications under Sections 154, 185A, and 251 were rejected. The AO granted registration for AY 1987-88 on 26.02.1996. The assessee sought rectification of the AY 1988-89 assessment order, arguing that registration for AY 1987-88 implied continuous registration.

What were the issues?

1. Whether the doctrine of merger applies in the facts and circumstances of the case, particularly in view of the fact that the status as of “Registered Firm” was denied to the appellant for the previous year, followed in the current assessment year, but allowed in the previous assessment year after remand. (Question of law) 2. Whether in the facts and circumstances of the case, the status as of “Registered Firm” as being allowed for the preceding assessment year and for subsequent years, the same has to be allowed for the year under appeal (Assessment year 1988-89). (Question of mixed law and fact) Assessee's Contentions: - The appeal before the CIT(A) for AY 1988-89 was dismissed on limitation, not on merits, thus the doctrine of merger does not apply. The order of the lower authority (AO) should be considered effective. - Registration granted for AY 1987-88 should be considered valid for AY 1988-89 and subsequent years as per Section 184(7) of the Income Tax Act, 1961, as there was no change in constitution or failure to furnish Form No. 12. Revenue's Contentions: - The judgment does not record specific contentions for the revenue on these issues.

Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?

Section 184(7),Section 154,Section 185A,Section 251

AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JHARKHAND AT RANCHI Om Enterprises .... .... ....       Appellant

­Versus­ 1. The Commissioner of Income Tax, Dhanbad 2. The Income Tax Officer, Dhanbad ....  Respondents

CORAM : HON'BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE HON'BLE MRS. JUSTICE JAYA ROY

For the Appellant : M/s B. Boddar, Sr. Advocate Mahendra Choudhary, Anil Choudhary, Darshan Poddar,  Piyush Poddar, Amrita Sinha, Advocates For the Respondent : M/s Deepak Roshan, Amit Kumar, Rupa Kumari, Advocates

Reportable Dated 16

th   August, 2012

Heard learned counsel for the parties. In this tax appeal, the following substantial question of law is involved: (i) Whether the doctrine of Merger applies in the facts and circumstances of the case, particularly in view of the fact that the status as of “Registered Firm” was  denied  to  the  appellant  for  the  previous  year, followed in the current assessment year, but allowed in the previous assessment year after remand. (ii) Whether in the facts and circumstances of the case,   the   status   as   of   “Registered   Firm”   as   being allowed   for   the   preceding   assessment   year   and   for

subsequent years, the same have to be allowed for the year under appeal (Assessment year 1988­89). The   facts   which   are   in   dispute   are   that   the appellant's firm was registered firm from the assessment year 1984­85.   However,   due   to  reconstitution   of   the   firm   during financial   year   1986­87   corresponding   to   assessment   year 1987­88 the appellant applied for re­registration of the firm by submitting Form No. 11­A under the Income Tax Act, 1961. The A.O. refused the registration of the firm and against that order, the   assessee   preferred   appeal   before   the   C.I.T.   (A),   who dismissed the appeal so far the registration part is concerned. On further appeal, the I.T.A.T. vide order dated 04.08.1995, remanded the matter for registration to A.O. for the assessment year 1987­88. Therefore, the petitioner's firm stand registered from  and   for   the   assessment   year   1987­88   and   has   been assessed as such. During this period, the appellant­petitioner was   already   assessed   for   the   subsequent   assessment   year 1988­89 treating the petitioner's firm to be a not registered firm. The petitioner since pursuing its appeal before the I.T.A.T. as well as after remand, before the A.O. for getting registration of the firm from the year 1987­88, therefore did not choose to prefer appeal against the assessment order for the year 1988­89, and   after   dismissal   of   his   appeal   before   the   C.I.T.   (A)   (for assessment year 1988­89). It would be worthwhile to mention here   that   the   C.I.T.   (A)   dismissed   appeal   of   the   appellant­

assessee for the assessment year 1988­89, on the ground of delay holding it to be barred by time as the appeal was preferred by the assessee after delay of 1253 days. Therefore, the C.I.T. (A) did not decide the appeal on merits. However, petitioner submitted an application under Sections 154,185A and Section 251   of   the   Income   Tax   Act,   1961,   which   stand   rejected throughout up to tribunal. The petitioner since got the order of registration of his firm vide order dated 26.02.1996 pertaining to year 1987­88 as was passed by the A.O. after remand by the I.T.A.T. for the purpose of registration of the firm, therefore, the petitioner's contention before the A.O. was that since as registration has already been ordered for the year 1987­88, therefore, as from that year, the appellant's firm's registration continues from the year 1987­88, till its constitution is changed. Therefore, since the fact of non­registration of the firm became non­existent with effect from the date submitting the  Form  11­A of the Income Tax Act, 1961 for assessment year 1987­88, the order passed by the Assessing Officer for the assessment year 1988­89 should have been rectified. The A.O. refused to rectify, the C.I.T. (A) and tribunal also dismissed the appeals. Therefore, this appeal has been preferred by the assessee. It   appears   from   the   order   passed   by   the   lower authority that there were two issues involved:

First, whether in a case where the impugned order before the appellate authority was dismissed on the ground of being barred by time whether the order of original authority is stand merged in the order passed by the appellate authority and second, what is the effect of the order of the registration of the firm   on   application   submitted   for   previous   year   and   that registration   was   granted   subsequent   to   the   assessment   of   a subsequent year? So far as the first question is concerned, the theory of merger cannot be applied in a case where the appeal itself was not competent. The appeal become competent only when it is within the limitation and before that as per the settled law, the appellate authority has no jurisdiction to examine the merits of the appeal so as to judge the legality and validity of the impugned order under the appeal. Therefore, the principle of merger   cannot   apply   when   the   appeal   is   dismissed   on   the ground of bar of limitation. Therefore, the order can be treated to be passed by the lower authority whose order was challenged under   the   appeal.   In   this   case,   the   appellant's   appeal   was dismissed on the ground of bar of limitation, and therefore, that was not a decision on merit. Consequentially, the effective order was passed by the lower authority. The registration of certificate since was applied prior to the assessment year relevant i.e. the assessment year 1988­89 and it was assessed according to the fact  that the firm was not

registered   for   the   assessment   year   1988­89.   However,   this assessment order was sought to be rectified by moving proper application by the appellant­assessee on the ground that the application for registration of the firm has been allowed for the assessment year 1987­88. As per Section 184(7) of the Income Tax Act, 1961, once the registration is granted, it is a valid registration for subsequent assessment year subject to condition enumerated under Section 184(7) of the Income Tax Act, 1961 wherein it has been provided that under certain circumstances that registration will come to an end for the reasons namely­that there is change in the constitution or share of the partners and the   firm   has   not   furnished,   within   time   allowed   in   such extended   time,   a   declaration   to   the   effect   in   Form   No.   12. Therefore, once the registration certificate has been granted and it has not been subsequently effected by subsequent event or by default   committed   by   the   firm,   then   it   continues   for   all subsequent years. Therefore, the firm shall be deemed to be registered for and from the assessment year 1987­88 and for all subsequent   years   and   it   is   not   a   case   of   the   Revenue   that subsequently   for   the   assessment   year   1988­89,   the   assessee incurred   any   disqualification   so   as   to   render   it   as   an unregistered firm. Therefore,   it   is   held   that   in   the   facts   and circumstances   of   the   case,   the   principle   of   merger   of   lower authority's   order   in   appellate   authority's   order   cannot   be

applied. It is also held that the appellant­firm is  required to be treated to be registered from the assessment year 1987­88 and also for the assessment year 1989­90 and appeal is allowed. (Prakash Tatia, C. J.)

(Jaya Roy , J.) SI/Anit

More judgments on Section 154

All 9,427 judgments and leading authorities on Section 154 →

Recent GST High Court judgments

Search GST case law →