COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX DHANBAD vs. Dhanbad Central Cooperative Bank Ltd Hirapur

PDF · subscribers
T.A./20/2012HC JharkhandJHHC01022836201215 April 2013Author: HON'BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE(MR JUSTICE PRAKASH TATIA),HON'BLE MRS. JUSTICE JAYA ROY3 pages
AI SummaryDismissed

What did the High Court hold?

The Tribunal held that the assessee's method of accounting, which was in accordance with RBI guidelines and Instruction No. 9949 of the Reserve Bank of India, was acceptable. The Tribunal noted that Section 45(ii) of the RBI Act contains a non-obstante clause, giving it precedence over other laws. Following the Delhi High Court's decision in CIT vs. Vasisth Chay Vyapar Ltd. & Ors., the Tribunal found that the issue was covered and the addition made by the AO was deleted. Regarding the embezzlement loss, the Tribunal relied on a CBDT Circular and judgments from the Gujarat High Court (Dinesh Mills Ltd. vs. CIT) and Allahabad High Court (Harijan Evam Nirbal Varg Avas vs. CIT) to hold that such losses should be treated as accidental business losses and allowed as deductions in the year they are discovered. The High Court found no illegality in the Tribunal's order and no question of law involved in the appeal.

What were the facts?

The Assessing Officer (AO) added Rs. 2,59,02,596 to the total income of the assessee, The Dhanbad Central Co-operative Bank Ltd., for the assessment year under appeal. The AO disallowed a provision for bad and doubtful debts, stating that Section 145 of the Income Tax Act, 1961, mandates a single accounting system (cash or mercantile) and does not permit mixed realization of income and expenses. The CIT(A) and ITAT, however, found that the assessee's accounts were maintained as per RBI guidelines, specifically Section 45(ii) of the RBI Act, which has an overriding effect. They relied on the Delhi High Court's decision in CIT vs. Vasisth Chay Vyapar Ltd. & Ors. The ITAT also allowed a loss due to embezzlement, treating it as an accidental business loss deductible in the year of discovery, citing CBDT Circular and Gujarat and Allahabad High Court judgments.

What were the issues?

1. Whether the assessee's method of accounting, which involved a provision for bad and doubtful debts, was permissible under Section 145 of the Income Tax Act, 1961, especially when maintained as per RBI guidelines. Assessee's contention: The assessee argued that its accounts were maintained in accordance with RBI guidelines, and Section 45(ii) of the RBI Act, with its non-obstante clause, overrides other laws. They relied on the Delhi High Court's decision in CIT vs. Vasisth Chay Vyapar Ltd. & Ors. Revenue's contention: The revenue, through the AO, contended that Section 145 restricts the accounting method to either cash or mercantile, disallowing a mixed approach, and thus the provision for bad and doubtful debts was not allowable. 2. Whether a loss due to embezzlement by an employee should be treated as a deductible business loss in the year of discovery. Assessee's contention: The assessee relied on a CBDT Circular stating that losses due to employee embezzlement should be treated as accidental business losses deductible in the year of discovery. They also cited judgments from the Gujarat High Court in Dinesh Mills Ltd. vs. CIT and the Allahabad High Court in Harijan Evam Nirbal Varg Avas vs. CIT. Revenue's contention: Not recorded in the judgment.

Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?

Section 145,Section 36(i),Section 45(ii)

AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JHARKHAND AT RANCHI Tax Appeal No. 20 of 2012 The Commissioner of Income Tax, Dhanbad Appellant

Versus The Dhanbad Central Co­operative Bank Ltd. ....    Respondent

CORAM : HON'BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE   HON'BLE MRS. JUSTICE JAYA ROY

For the Appellant : Mr. Deepak Roshan, Advocate Ms. Rupa Kumari, Advocate For the Respondent : Mr. Krishna Murari, Advocate

Order No.07        Dated, 15

th   April, 2013

Heard learned counsel for the parties. 2. The   Assessing   officer   vide   assessment   order   dated 21.12.2009 held that, Section 145 of the Income Tax Act provides that   either   cash   or   mercantile   system   of   accounting   has   to   be followed and therefore, there is no scope of realising income in cash and expenses in mercantile system. The Assessing officer then held that,   since   provisions   are   not   allowable   and   the   assessee   has claimed separately by a provision for bad and doubtful debts as per Section   36(i)   of   the   Income   Tax   Act,   1961   an   amount   of Rs.2,59,02,596/­ is added to the total income of the assessee.

3.

However, the C.I.T. (A) as well as the I.T.A.T. observed that the accounts is maintained as per the guidelines issued by the R.B.I.  and Section 45(ii) of the R.B.I. Act starts with non obstante clause which overrides other laws. The C.I.T. (A) as well as the Tribunal followed the decision of Delhi High Court in case of C.I.T. Vs. Vasisth Chay Vyapar Ltd. & Ors. 330 ITR 440 (Del.) (2011) and held that the issue is covered by the decision of Delhi High Court. Learned counsel for the appellant could not distinguish the ratio of the decision of Delhi High Court. 4. In   view   of   the   said   decision,   the   C.I.T.(A)   and   the I.T.A.T. accepted the method of accounting of the assessee and which   was   in   accordance   with   the   Instruction   No.9949   of   the Reserve Bank of India and therefore, addition was deleted. 5. In view of the above reasons, we are of the considered opinion that on this point, no question of law is involved. 6. The   another   issue   raised   is   arising   out   of   the   some embezzlement by which the assessee suffered some loss for which an F.I.R. was also lodged and the investigation was also done by the bank officers. The I.T.A.T. relied upon the C.B.D.T. Circular which provides that loss due to embezzlement by an employee, the same should be treated as accidental to the business and this loss should be allowed as deduction for the year in which it is discovered. The I.T.A.T. after relying upon the judgment of the Gujrat High Court delivered in the case of  Dinesh Mills Ltd. Vs. C.I.T. reported in

(2002) 254  ITR  673 (Guj.)  and judgement  of  Allahabad  High

Court delivered in the case of Harijan Evam Nirbal Varg Avas Vs C.I.T. reported in (1998) 229 ITR 776 (All.) observed that the loss on account of theft be treated as business loss. 7. We do not find any illegality in the order passed by the Tribunal and no question of law is involved in this appeal. 8. Hence, this appeal is dismissed. (Prakash Tatia, C. J.)

(Jaya Roy , J.) SI/Anit

More judgments on Section 145

All 1,768 judgments and leading authorities on Section 145 →

Recent GST High Court judgments

Search GST case law →