COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX vs. C.C.L.

PDF · subscribers
T.A./13/2001HC JharkhandJHHC01013214200112 October 2012Bench: HON'BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE(MR JUSTICE PRAKASH TATIA),HON'BLE MRS. JUSTICE JAYA ROY3 pages
AI SummaryDismissed

What did the High Court hold?

The Court noted that questions 1, 2, and 4 had already been answered by this Court in a previous Tax Appeal (No. 14 of 1999(R)) between the same parties, vide order dated 13th June, 2012. Therefore, the Court did not need to provide separate answers for these questions and decided the appeal accordingly. Regarding question 3, concerning the provision for wages, the Court noted the ITAT's finding that the assessee had claimed this expenditure in the books for assessment year 1989-90 and not for assessment year 1990-91. The ITAT held that the assessee was unjustified in claiming it in assessment year 1990-91 and that the expenditure should be taken into account for Section 115J computation, allowing the assessee's appeal on this ground. However, the revenue's counsel could not demonstrate any variation in tax effect arising from this decision. Consequently, the Court deemed it unnecessary to answer question 3 and dismissed the appeal as it did not affect the revenue.

What were the facts?

The appeal concerns the Commissioner of Income Tax, Ranchi (appellant/revenue) against Central Coal Fields Ltd. (respondent/assessee) for the assessment years 1989-90 and 1990-91. The High Court of Jharkhand at Ranchi is hearing the appeal against an order passed by the ITAT, Patna Bench. The appeal raises four questions of law. Questions 1, 2, and 4 pertain to guest house expenditure and depreciation on sold/surveyed assets for assessment year 1990-91. Question 3 relates to the set-off of provision for wages for assessment year 1989-90 against income for assessment year 1990-91 for the purpose of Section 115J. The parties agreed that questions 1, 2, and 4 were decided by this Court in a previous appeal between the same parties.

What were the issues?

The Tribunal had to decide four questions of law: 1. Whether, on the facts and in the circumstances, the Tribunal was justified in law in treating part of guest house expenditure as revenue expenditure under Section 37(4) for assessment year 1990-91. 2. Whether, on the facts and in the circumstances, the Tribunal was justified in giving relief of Rs. 16,15,298/- to the assessee in respect of guest house expenses for assessment year 1990-91. 3. Whether, on the facts and in the circumstances, the Tribunal was justified in holding that provision for wages of Rs. 48,19,00,000/- should be set off against the income for assessment year 1989-90 for computation of taxable income for assessment year 1990-91 for the purpose of Section 115J. 4. Whether, on the facts and in the circumstances, the Tribunal was justified in allowing relief to the assessee on depreciation on sold/surveyed assets for assessment year 1990-91 amounting to Rs. 39,42,000/- in light of Sections 43(6) and 50. Assessee's contentions: Not recorded. Revenue's contentions: Not recorded, except that the revenue's counsel could not satisfy the court regarding any variation in tax effect due to the ITAT's decision on question 3.

Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?

Section 37(4),Section 115J,Section 43(6),Section 50

AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below

- 1 - IN THE HIGH COURT OF JHARKHAND AT RANCHI T.A. No. 13 of 2001

Commissioner of Income Tax, Ranchi ... ... Appellant Versus Central Coal Fields Ltd. ... ... Respondent ----- CORAM: HON'BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE HON'BLE MRS. JUSTICE JAYA ROY ------ For the Appellant : Mr. Deepak Roshan, Advocate Miss Rupa Kumari, Advocate For the Respondent : Mr. B. Poddar, Sr. Advocate M/s. Mahendra Kr. Choudhary, Piyush Poddar, Miss Darshana Poddar, & Amrita Sinha, Advocates ------ Dated 12th October, 2012 Heard learned counsel for the parties. 2. Four questions have been raised by the appellant/revenue in this Tax Appeal No. 13 of 2001 which are as follows :- (1)“Whether on the facts and in the circumstances of the case, the Tribunal was justified in law in treating part of guest house expenditure as revenue expenditure under Section 37(4) of the Income Tax Act, 1961 for the assessment year 1990-91?” (2)“Whether on the facts and in the circumstances of the case, the Tribunal was justified in giving relief of Rs. 16,15,298/- to the assessee in respect of claim of guest house expenses for the assessment year 1990-91?”

- 2 - (3)“Whether on the facts and in the circumstances of the case, the Tribunal was justified to hold that provision for wages of Rs. 48,19,00,000/- should be set off against the income for assessment year 1989-90 for computation of taxable income for the assessment year 1990-91 for the purpose of section 115 J of the Income Tax Act?” (4)“Whether on the facts and in the circumstances of the case, the Tribunal was justified in allowing relief to the assessee on the issue of allowing depreciation on sale off assets/surveyed off assets for the assessment year 1990-91 Rs. 39,42,000/- in the light of the provisions of section 43(6) and section 50 of the Income Tax Act?” 3. Learned counsel for both the parties submitted that question Nos. 1, 2 and 4 have already been answered by this Court in Tax Appeal No. 14 of 1999(R) (Commissioner of Income Tax Vs. M/s. Central Coalfields Limited) vide order dated 13th June, 2012 which was the matter between the parties. 4. In view of the above reasons, we need not to give answer to the question Nos. 1, 2 and 4 and the appeal is decided accordingly in the light of decision given in Tax Appeal No. 14 of 1999(R) dated 13th June, 2012. 5. The question No. 3 is with respect to the provision for wages and its set off against the income for the assessment

- 3 - year 1989-90. Admittedly, as per the order passed by the I.T.A.T., Patna Bench, Patna, which is the impugned order, in para 4 it has been mentioned that so far as wage liability disallowance issue is concerned, the assessee had claimed this expenditure in their books of accounts of assessment year 1989-90 and consequently they had not claimed it in their books of account of assessment year 1990-91. The Tribunal held that the assessee was unjustified in claiming the same in the assessment year 1990-91. The Tribunal further held that this expenditure has got to be taken into account in the computation of taxable income for the purpose of Section 115 J and on this ground the assessee's appeal was allowed. 6. Learned counsel for the revenue could not satisfy that because of this decision of I.T.A.T. there will be any variation in the tax effect. Therefore, there is no need to answer this question and the appeal is liable to be dismissed because it is not affecting the revenue in any manner. Hence, the appeal is dismissed. (Prakash Tatia, C.J.)

(Jaya Roy, J.) Birendra/

Recent GST High Court judgments

Search GST case law →