COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX vs. PRADEEP IRON INDUTRIES PLTD

PDF · subscribers
T.A./10/2003HC JharkhandJHHC01011276200319 September 2012Bench: HON'BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE(MR JUSTICE PRAKASH TATIA),HON'BLE MRS. JUSTICE JAYA ROY4 pages
AI SummaryDismissed

What did the High Court hold?

The High Court held that the ITAT was justified in holding that the notice under Section 147 of the Act was issued beyond the provisions of law. The Court found force in the assessee's submission that the case was squarely covered by the Patna High Court's judgment in Hemraj Munshi Ram Vs. Union of India and Ors. In that case, the issuance of notice under Section 148 was found to be without reason and basis because the relevant material was already seized and in the possession of the revenue, and there was no failure by the assessee to disclose material facts. The Court observed that the facts in the present appeals were identical. The Court also noted that the Revenue's argument that the AO had jurisdiction to issue notice under Section 148 to comply with appellate directions was self-contradictory. If there was no bar of limitation after a remand order, then there was no necessity to opt for the mode of issuing notice under Sections 148 and 147. The Court concluded that no question of law was involved and the ITAT had not committed any error. Consequently, the appeals were dismissed.

What were the facts?

The appeals by the Commissioner of Income Tax, Jamshedpur (Revenue) challenge the order of the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT) for Assessment Years 1979-80 to 1982-83. The ITAT had cancelled the reassessment orders passed by the Assessing Officer (AO) under Sections 143(3)/147/251 of the Income Tax Act, 1961, holding that the issuance of notice under Section 148 was beyond the provisions of the Act. The proceedings stemmed from a search and seizure operation on December 4, 1981. The CIT(A) had set aside the initial assessment order on March 18, 1988, restoring the matter to the AO for fresh assessment with directions. The limitation for fresh assessment expired on March 31, 1990. The AO issued a notice under Section 148 on March 9, 1990, and the reassessment order was passed on December 3, 1991. The ITAT's order dated May 15, 1993, is under challenge.

What were the issues?

The substantial question of law framed for decision is: Whether the ITAT was justified in cancelling the order passed by the Assessing Officer under Sections 143(3)/147/251 of the Income Tax Act, 1961, for the Assessment Years 1979-80 to 1982-83 by holding that the issuance of notice under Section 148 was beyond the provisions of the Act? The Revenue contended that the AO had jurisdiction to issue notice under Section 148 of the Act for making assessment or reassessment to give effect to the appellate authority's directions, citing Section 150(1) read with Section 153(2) of the Act, and that the period of limitation prescribed for making assessment under the Act could not apply in such cases. The Revenue argued that the AO issued the notice under Section 148 to get an extension of the period of limitation for assessment, which was permissible to comply with the appellate order. The Respondent (assessee) argued that the issuance of notice under Section 148 was without reason and basis, as the relevant material was already seized and in the possession of the revenue, and there was no failure on the part of the assessee to disclose material facts. They relied on the Patna High Court judgment in Hemraj Munshi Ram Vs. Union of India and Ors.

Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?

Section 143(3),Section 147,Section 148,Section 251,Section 150(1),Section 153(2)

AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below

1 IN THE HIGH COURT OF JHARKHAND AT RANCHI T.A. No. 31 of 2002 with T.A. No. 10 of 2003 with T.A. No. 11 of 2003 Commissioner of Income Tax, Jamshedpur ... ... Appellant (in all appeals)

Vrs. Pradeep Iron Industries (P) Ltd., Kolkata ...... Respondent (in all appeals)

------ CORAM: HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE HON’BLE MRS. JUSTICE JAYA ROY ------ For the Appellant: Mr. Deepak Roshan, Sr. S.C.(Rev.) Ms. Rupa Kumari, Adv. Mr. Amit Kumar, Adv. For the Respondent: Mr. B. Poddar, Sr. Adv. Mr. M.K. Choudhary, Adv. Mr. Piyush Poddar,Adv. Ms. Darshana Poddar, Adv. Ms. Amrita Sinha, Adv. ------ Dated 19

th September 2012.

Heard learned counsel for the parties. 2. The following substantial question of law has been framed in these appeals: “Whether the I.T.A.T. Is justified on the facts and in circumstances of the case in cancelling the order passed by the Assessing Officer U/s 143(3)/147/251 of the I.T. Act, 61 for the Assessment Years 1979-80 to 1982-83 by holding that issuance of notice U/s 148 was beyond the provisions of the Act ?” 3. In these three appeals, though the assessment years are different but the question is the same and these are being decided by a common order. 4. Raising the same issue, another Tax Appeal No. 08 of 2003 against the same respondent has been preferred by the revenue, which was dismissed vide order dated 3.04.2006 on the ground of its being barred by time.

2 5. The relevant dates as mentioned in the order passed by the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal, Patna Bench, Patna, Circuit Bench at Ranchi in its impugned order dated 27.05.2002 are as under: (I) Date of Search

04.12.81 (ii) Date of order of the CIT(A) (Shri B.C. Mohanty setting aside the restoring the matter to the file of A.O. to be done afresh with certain direction 18.3.88 (iii) Date of service of the order dated 18.3.88 on I.T. Deptt. 22.3.88 (iv) Limitation of fresh assessment expired on 31.3.90 (v) Date of notice u/s 148 9.3.1990 (vi) Letter for filing of return u/s 148 3.12.1991 (vii) Date of reassessment order u/s 143(3)/ 147/251 30.3.92 (viii) Date of order of ITAT(Departmental Appeal against CIT(A) order dated 18.3.88 15.02.93 6. From the above dates, it is clear that during the course of search and seizure operation, certain incriminating materials were found, on the basis of which assessment proceedings were concluded by passing an assessment order and the assessment order was set aside by the CIT(A) vide order dated 18.3.1988. Therefore, the proceeding of assessment stands reopened and this assessment could have been made up to 31.3.1990. Admittedly, no assessment was made till 31.3.1990. However, it appears from the facts of the case that to get extension of the period of limitation for assessment, the A.O. issued notice under Section 148 of the Income Tax Act, 1961, on 09.3.1990, about 22 days before the expiry of the period of limitation for assessment. On the basis of the above notice dated 09.3.1990, under Section 148 of the Income Tax Act, 1961, reassessment order was made under Section 147 read with Sections 143(3)/147/251 of the Act of 1961 on 03.12.1991. Learned counsel for the appellant submitted that in view of sub-section 1 of Section 150 read with Section 153(2), the period of limitation prescribed for making assessment in the Act of 1961, cannot have application in the cases where the A.O. proceeded to comply with the direction contained in the appellate order and, therefore, the

3 A.O. had jurisdiction to issue notice under Section 148 of the Act for the purpose of making any assessment or reassessment or recomputation to give effect to any finding or direction contained in the order passed by the appellate authority. However, the argument is self contradictory. If there was no bar of limitation in making the assessment after remand order, then what was necessity for opting for the mode by issuing notice under Sections 148 and 147 ?. Admittedly, in consequence of search and seizure operation, the assessment was completed by making the assessment orders on 30.11.1978, 30.11.1979, 30.11.1980 and 30.11.1981 in all these four matters (including the cases of Tax Appeal No. 08 of 2003 which has been dismissed vide order dated 03.04.2006). Therefore, the matters which were pending before the A.O. before making the assessment orders and against the above assessment orders, the appeals were preferred and assessment orders were set aside by CIT(A) vide order dated 15.3.1988 and matters were remanded to the A.O. These proceedings could have been completed by or before 31.3.1990. The A.O. had two years time with it. The relevant materials were already lying with the officers as they were seized during the course of the search and seizure. The A.O. could have completed the assessment but it appears that in the present cases, a pretext has been taken by the A.O. and thereafter, only for the extension of period of limitation, the A.O. issued notice under Section 148 of the Act of 1961. Such intention is apparent from the facts mentioned in the order passed by the Tribunal as well as the stand taken by the Revenue. The other argument that, after remand order, if A.O. proceeds for assessment and there was no limitation, then there was no necessity of taking help of Section 148 and Section 147 of the Act of 1961. 7. Otherwise also, there is a force in the submission of the learned senior counsel for the respondent, Mr. Poddar, that these cases are squarely covered by the judgment of Patna High Court delivered in the case of Hemraj Munshi Ram Vs. Union of India and Ors. reported in (2000) 245 ITR 155 wherein issuance of notice under Section 148 itself is found to be without any

4 reason and basis as the relevant material was already seized and were in possession of the revenue itself and in that fact circumstances, particulars furnished could be generally verifiable by the revenue and there was no reason to hold that assessee had failed to disclose fully and truly material facts to the A.O. In these cases also, the facts are identical to that of the case of Hemraj Munshi Ram(supra). Therefore, in fact, in these appeals, no question of law involves and the Tribunal has not committed any error in holding that notice under Section 147 of the Act of 1961 was given beyond the provision of law. These appeals are, therefore, dismissed. (Prakash Tatia,C.J.) (Jaya Roy, J.) Sudhir

More judgments on Section 147

All 57,238 judgments and leading authorities on Section 147 →

Latest GST High Court judgments

Search GST case law →