THE COMMISSIONER OF INCOME-TAX vs. M/S IBM INDIA PVT LTD

PDF · subscribers
ITA/210/2014HC KarnatakaKAHC01021662201429 October 2026Author: CHIEF JUSTICE,K.S. HEMALEKHA7 pages
AI SummaryDismissed

What did the High Court hold?

The High Court noted that Question 1 was covered against the Revenue by a previous decision of the same court in CIT vs. IBM Global Services India Pvt. Ltd. Similarly, Question 7 was covered against the Revenue by Supreme Court and High Court decisions concerning revenue expenditure. Regarding the remaining questions (2-6), the court observed that Question 2 concerning Avani Cincom Technologies, KALS Information Systems Ltd, and Celesial Biolabs Ltd, and Questions 3 & 4 concerning Infosys Technologies, WIPRO Limited, and Tata Elxsi Limited, were covered in favour of the Assessee by the court's decision in CIT vs. Logica Private Ltd. Question 5 was considered a general question already covered by the specific company exclusions. For Question 6, concerning Birla Technologies, the Revenue argued it failed RPT filters. However, the Tribunal had excluded it because its exports were less than 25%. The Tribunal found this reason erroneous, as Birla Technologies' entire income from software services and license fees was derived from exports. The High Court held that the finding on whether Birla Technologies' export income exceeded 25% was a question of fact, and since there was no challenge that this finding was perverse, no substantial question of law arose. Consequently, the High Court held that no substantial questions of law arose for consideration and dismissed the appeal.

What were the facts?

The Commissioner of Income-Tax (LTU), Bangalore, and the Joint Commissioner of Income-Tax (LTU), Bangalore (collectively referred to as the Revenue), filed an appeal under Section 260A of the Income Tax Act, 1961, against an order dated December 20, 2013, passed by the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT) in IT(TP)A No. 1543/Bang/2012. The appeal pertains to Assessment Year 2008-09 and challenges the ITAT's decision to set aside certain disallowances made by the assessing officer and the transfer pricing officer (TPO). The dispute involves the determination of Arm's Length Price (ALP) for international transactions and claims for deductions under Sections 10A and 10AA of the Act. The High Court had previously admitted the appeal for consideration of substantial questions of law.

What were the issues?

The High Court was to decide the following substantial questions of law: 1. Whether the Tribunal erred in setting aside the disallowance under Sections 10A & 10AA when the assessee did not maintain separate books of accounts or primary documents for individual units, leading to apportionment of expenses based on unverifiable allocation ratios. 2. Whether the Tribunal correctly held that Avani Cincom Technologies, KALS Information Systems Ltd, and Celesial Biolabs Ltd could not be considered comparables, despite satisfying the TPO's qualitative and quantitative filters. 3. Whether the Tribunal was correct in directing the exclusion of Infosys Technologies and Wipro Ltd (IT segment) by considering brand value as a vital factor, without appreciating that brand is not a variable in data mining profit margins of comparables. 4. Whether the Tribunal correctly held Tata Elxsi Ltd as functionally different and excluded it, despite it satisfying the TPO's filters, especially when segmental results were used. 5. Whether the Tribunal erred in rejecting six comparables included by the TPO, without appreciating that comparable selection depends on assessee-specific FAR analysis and the TPO's specific facts. 6. Whether the Tribunal was correct in holding Birla Technologies as a comparable, despite it failing the Related Party Transaction (RPT) filters. 7. Whether the Tribunal was correct in allowing the entrance fee for corporate club membership as revenue expenditure. Assessee's contentions (implied from the questions and the court's discussion): The assessee likely argued that the disallowances were incorrect, that the comparables chosen by the TPO were appropriate or that the Tribunal's exclusions/inclusions were justified. For Question 1, the assessee likely argued that sufficient documentation was maintained or that the allocation was reasonable. For Questions 2-5, the assessee likely supported the Tribunal's view on the functional dissimilarity or the impact of brand value. For Question 6, the assessee likely supported the Tribunal's inclusion of Birla Technologies. For Question 7, the assessee likely argued for the deductibility of the entrance fee. Revenue's contentions (implied from the questions): The Revenue argued that the disallowance under Sections 10A & 10AA was justified due to lack of separate books and unverifiable allocation (Question 1). The Revenue contended that the comparables identified by the TPO met the filters and should have been included (Questions 2, 4, 5). The Revenue argued that brand value should not lead to exclusion of Infosys and Wipro (Question 3). The Revenue argued that Birla Technologies failed RPT filters and should not be a comparable (Question 6). The Revenue argued that the corporate club membership fee was capital expenditure (Question 7).

Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?

Section 10A,Section 10AA,Section 260A

AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below

IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU

DATED THIS THE 29TH DAY OF OCTOBER, 2026

PRESENT

THE HON'BLE MR. VIBHU BAKHRU, CHIEF JUSTICE

AND

THE HON'BLE MRS. JUSTICE K.S. HEMALEKHA

INCOME TAX APPEAL NO.210 OF 2014

BETWEEN:

THE COMMISSIONER OF INCOME-TAX,

LTU,

JSS TOWERS, BSK III STAGE,

BANGALORE.

THE JOINT COMMISSIONER OF INCOME-TAX,

LTU,

JSS TOWERS, BSK III STAGE,

BANGALORE-560085. …APPELLANTS

(BY SRI. E.I. SANMATHI, ADVOCATE A/W MR. NIRMAL MATHEW, ADVOCATE)

AND:

M/S. IBM INDIA PVT. LTD., NO.12, SUBRAMANYA ARCADE, BANNERGHATTA MAIN ROAD, BANGALORE-560029. …RESPONDENT

(BY SRI. PERCY PARDIWALA, SENIOR ADVOCATE A/W SMT. TANMAYEE RAJKUMAR, ADVOCATE; MS. MAYURI K.V., ADVOCATE)

Digitally signed by MAHALAKSHMI B M Location: High Court of Karnataka

THIS ITA IS FILED UNDER SECTION 260A OF INCOME TAX ACT, 1961 AGGRIEVED BY THE ORDER DATED 20.12.2013 PASSED IN IT (TP)A NO.1543/BANG/2012, FOR THE ASSESSMENT YEAR 2008-09 PRAYING TO FORMULATE THE SUBSTANTIAL QUESTIONS OF LAW STATED ABOVE; ALLOW THE APPEAL AND SET ASIDE THE ORDERS PASSED BY THE INCOME-TAX APPELLATE TRIBUNAL, BANGALORE IN IT(TP)A NO.1543/BANG/2012 DATED 20.12.2013 AND CONFIRM THE ORDER OF THE APPELLATE COMMISSIONER CONFIRMING THE ORDER PASSED BY THE JOINT COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX, LTU, BANGALORE.

THIS APPEAL, COMING ON FOR FINAL HEARING, THIS DAY, JUDGMENT WAS DELIVERED THEREIN AS UNDER:

CORAM: HON'BLE MR. VIBHU BAKHRU, CHIEF JUSTICE and HON'BLE MRS. JUSTICE K.S. HEMALEKHA

ORAL JUDGMENT

(PER: HON'BLE MR. VIBHU BAKHRU, CHIEF JUSTICE)

The present appeal was taken up for consideration on 10.09.2026, and this Court passed the following order: "1. The revenue has filed the present appeal under Section 260A of the Income Tax Act, 1961 impugning an order dated 20.12.2023 passed by the learned Income Tax Appellate Tribunal in IT(TP)A 1543/Bang/2012 in respect of assessment year 2008-2009. The revenue has projected the following questions for consideration before this court which were accepted by an order dated 13.07.2015 :

"1. Whether the Tribunal was correct in setting aside the disallowance made by the assessing officer of the claim u/s.10A & 10AA of the Act, when the assessee has not maintained separate books of accounts, not maintained primary documents which are necessary to determine the income of individual

units and in the absence of the details, the expenses have been apportioned on the basis of an allocation ratio which is unverifiable?

2.

Whether the Tribunal was correct in holding that Avani Cincom Technologies, KALS Information Systems Ltd and Celesial Biolabs Ltd cannot be considered as comparables being functionally different without appreciating that the comparables satisfy all the qualitative and quantitative filers applied by the TPO?

3.

Whether the Tribunal was correct in directing the exclusion of Infosys technologies and Wipro Ltd-IT segment by holding that the brand value of the company is a vital factor in deciding the profit margin of the company without appreciating that the brand is not a variable in data mining profit margin of a comparable?

4.

Whether the Tribunal was correct in holding that Tata Elxsi Ltd cannot be included in the final list of comparables as it was functionally different without appreciating that it satisfied all the qualitative and quantitative filers applied by the TPO especially when the segmental results have been used?

5.

Whether the Tribunal was correct in rejecting the six comparables included by the TPO in the final list without appreciating that the selection of comparables in a case depends upon assesses specific FAR analysis and without appreciating the specific facts brought on record by the TPO?

6.

Whether the Tribunal was correct in holding that Birla Technologies should be taken as a comparables as there was no other basis for rejecting it as a comparable without appreciating that the company failed the obvious RPT filters?

7.

Whether the Tribunal was right in holding that the entrance fee for acquiring corporate club

membership incurred by the assessee had to be allowed as revenue expenditure?

The learned counsel for the revenue fairly states that question No.1 as projected is covered against the revenue by the decision of this court in The Commissioner of Income Tax and Another vs M/s IBM Global Services India Pvt. Ltd.1 He also fairly states that question No.7 is also covered against the revenue by the decision of the Supreme Court in Commissioner of Income Tax vs United Glass Mfg. Co. Ltd.2 and the decisions of this court in The Commissioner of Income Tax, Hubli vs The Sandur Manganese and Iron Ores Limited, Yeshwanthpur, Bellary District3 and Commissioner of Income-tax, Central Circle vs Infosys Technologies Limited4.

3.

List for further proceedings on the remaining questions of law on 15.09.2026."

Thus, this Court is required to consider the remaining five questions of law. 3. Question No.2 relates to the exclusion of the following companies as comparables: a. Avani Cincom Technologies; b. KALS Information Systems Limited; and c. Celesial Biolabs Limited.

1 ITA No.286/2010, DD 3.11.2020 2 [2012] 28 taxmann.com 429 (SC) 3 Income Tax Referred Case Nos.13 to 24/2002, DD 21.03.2005 4 [2012] 18 taxmann.com 169 (Karnataka)

4.

Question Nos.3 and 4 relate to exclusion of Infosys Technologies, WIPRO Limited and Tata Elxsi Limited. Concededly, the exclusion of the aforesaid companies is covered in favour of the Assessee and against the Revenue by the recent decision of this Court in The Commissioner of Income-Tax and another Vs. M/s. Logica Private Ltd.5. 5. Question No.5 is a general question which covers the specific companies that have been mentioned in the other questions. Thus, it does not require to be considered separately. 6. Question No.6, as projected, relates to the inclusion of Birla Technologies as a comparable. According to the Revenue, the Tribunal erred in including the said company as a comparable for the purpose of determining the Arm's Length Price [ALP] of international transactions, on the ground that the company had failed the Related Party Transaction [RPT] filters. 7. However, we note that M/s. Birla Technologies had been excluded not for the reason that it had failed the RPT filters, but on the ground that its exports were less than 25%.

5 Income Tax Appeal No.338/2013 D.D. 28.10.2026

8.

The Tribunal found that excluding the said company on the aforesaid ground was factually erroneous, as the said company's income from software services and license fees was entirely derived from exports. The relevant extract of the impugned order is set out below: "9.25 The learned counsel for the assessee also submitted that two comparables excluded by the TPO should be included as comparable.

M/s Birla Technologies: The reason assigned by the TPO for excluding this company as comparable was that the exports sales were less than 25%. In this regard, the learned counsel for the assessee drew our attention to pages-689 to 698 and page 317 of T.P. Paper book, which is a compilation of the annual reports of various companies filed by the assessee. Perusal of page-698 shows that total income from software services/licence fee of assessee was Rs.24,12,30,696/-. It is also clear from the Director's report that the entire income were derived from exports. It thus, appears that the reason assigned by the TPO for rejecting this company as comparable which was for the reasons that the company has export sales of less than 25% of the total sales is on an erroneous basis. We therefore, hold that this company should be taken as a comparable as there is no other basis for rejecting this company as comparable assigned by the TPO."

9.

The question as to whether the income derived by Birla Technologies from exports is more than 25% is a question of fact. There is no challenge that the said finding is perverse; therefore, no substantial question of law in this regard falls for consideration of this Court.

10.

In view of the above, no substantial questions of law arise for consideration of this Court. The appeal is accordingly dismissed.

Sd/- (VIBHU BAKHRU) CHIEF JUSTICE

Sd/- (K.S. HEMALEKHA) JUDGE

MBM List No.: 1 Sl No.: 23

Recent GST High Court judgments

Search GST case law →