DIRECTOR OF INCOME TAX and ANOTHER vs. M/S ONGC

PDF · subscribers
ITA/35/2009HC UttarakhandUKHC01000469200920 November 2018Bench: HON'BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE,HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ALOK SINGH3 pages
AI SummaryDismissed

What did the High Court hold?

The High Court held that the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal's order dated November 7, 2008, was merely an order giving effect to the decision of the Uttarakhand High Court dated November 16, 2006. The Tribunal was legally obligated to implement the High Court's opinion. The Court found that any grievance the Revenue had against the High Court's order should have been raised before the Supreme Court under Section 261 of the Income Tax Act. Since the Revenue did not avail this remedy and the High Court's order had attained finality, the consequential order of the ITAT giving effect to it could not be questioned again through an appeal under Section 260A. The Court noted that the contention regarding the benefit of Section 14 of the Limitation Act was relevant only if the Revenue preferred an appeal to the Supreme Court, which was not the case before the present Court. Therefore, the appeal was dismissed.

What were the facts?

This appeal by the Revenue is against an order of the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT) dated November 7, 2008, for Assessment Year 1983-84. The assessee, M/s ONGC, had appealed an assessment order to the Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals), who allowed the appeal. The Revenue then appealed to the ITAT. The ITAT, by order dated November 24, 1992, made a reference to the Allahabad High Court. Following the formation of Uttarakhand in 2000, the reference was transferred to the Uttarakhand High Court. The High Court, on November 16, 2006, decided the question of law in favor of the assessee. The ITAT's order of November 7, 2008, merely gave effect to the High Court's decision as per Section 260 of the Income Tax Act. The Revenue is now appealing the ITAT's order giving effect to the High Court's decision.

What were the issues?

1. Whether the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal's order dated November 7, 2008, giving effect to the Uttarakhand High Court's decision of November 16, 2006, is appealable under Section 260A of the Income Tax Act, when the High Court's decision has attained finality. The Revenue argued that the ITAT's order, though consequential, could be challenged. The Revenue also contended that they might have the benefit of Section 14 of the Limitation Act if they were to prefer an appeal to the Supreme Court against the Uttarakhand High Court's order. The assessee did not record any specific arguments in the judgment.

Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?

Section 260A,Section 256,Section 260,Section 261,Section 14

AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below

IN THE HIGH COURT OF UTTARAKHAND AT NAINITAL

Income Tax Appeal No. 35 of 2009

Director of Income Tax and another

...Appellants

Vs.

M/s ONGC

...Respondent

Mr. Hari Mohan Bhatia, learned Senior Standing Counsel for the appellants- Income Tax. Mr. (Dr.) Udyog Shukla, learned counsel for the respondent.

Dated: 20th November, 2018

Coram: Hon’ble Ramesh Ranganathan, C.J. Hon’ble Alok Singh, J.

Ramesh Ranganathan, C.J. (Oral)

This appeal, under Section 260A of the Income Tax Act, is preferred by the Revenue against the order of the Delhi Bench of the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal in ITA No. 1756/DEL/89 dated 07.11.2008 for the assessment year 1983-84.

2.

Against the assessment order passed by the assessing authority on 31.01.1985, the assessee carried the matter in appeal to the Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals) who, vide order dated 04.01.1989, allowed the appeal. Against the order of the Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals), the Revenue carried the matter in Appeal to the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal. The Delhi Bench of the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal, by its order under Section 256 of the Income Tax Act dated 24.11.1992, made a reference to the Allahabad High Court. When the reference was pending consideration of the Allahabad High Court, the State of Uttarakhand came into being in the year 2000, and consequently the reference application was transferred from the Allahabad High Court to the Uttarakhand High Court which, by its order dated 16.11.2006, decided the question of law referred for its opinion against the Revenue and in favour of the assessee. The Income Tax Appellate Tribunal, by its order dated 07.11.2008, gave effect to the

2 order of the Uttarakhand High Court dated 16.11.2006 in terms of Section 260 of the Income Tax Act. Aggrieved by the said order of the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal dated 07.11.2008, the Revenue is now in appeal before this Court.

3.

From the facts noted hereinabove, it is evident that the order impugned in this appeal is the order of the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal dated 07.11.2008, which is only an order giving effect to the order passed by the Uttarakhand High Court, in the reference application, on 16.11.2006. The Income Tax Appellate Tribunal was obligated in law to give effect to the opinion of the Uttarakhand High Court in its order dated 16.11.2006. Any grievance, which the Revenue may have against the order of the Uttarakhand High Court dated 16.11.2006, could only have been agitated before the Supreme Court under Section 261 of the Income Tax Act. No such remedy was availed by the Revenue and the reference order dated 16.11.2006 has attained finality. The consequential order of the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal dated 07.11.2008 cannot be questioned again by way of an appeal under Section 260A of the Income Tax Act since the Tribunal has only given effect to the reference order passed by the Uttarakhand High Court on 16.11.2006.

4.

While Sri Hari Mohan Bhatia, learned Senior Standing Counsel, would submit that the Revenue would have the benefit of Section 14 of the Limitation Act while preferring an appeal to the Supreme Court against the order passed by the Uttarakhand High Court on 16.11.2006, at least for the period from the date on which the present appeal was filed in the year 2009 till date, we see no reason to examine this contention in the present appeal since it is only if and when the Revenue prefers an appeal to the Supreme Court against the order of the Uttarakhand High Court dated 16.11.2006, would this question necessitate examination, not by us, but by the Supreme Court.

3 5. The appeal fails and is accordingly dismissed.

(Alok Singh, J.)

(Ramesh Ranganathan, C.J.) 20.11.2018

20.11.2018 Rahul

Recent GST High Court judgments

Search GST case law →