COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX, vs. SMTI. MAYA RANI DEY,
What did the High Court hold?
The High Court found itself in respectful agreement with the ITAT's finding that the assessment order was barred by time. The court noted that the search was conducted on 08.12.1999, based on a warrant issued in the name of Partha Sarathi Dey, who was deceased on 18.08.1999. Despite this, notices were issued to the legal representatives. The court observed that the assessment order dated 31.12.2003 did not clearly state that the initial proceedings were dropped. The respondent's assertion that the last of the notices (dated 07.06.2000, 17.11.2000, and 07.12.2000) was received on 28.12.2000 was accepted. Consequently, in terms of section 158BE(2), the assessment should have been completed by 31.12.2002. The court also considered the cited decisions, finding them distinguishable. The appeal was dismissed. The issue of the proceedings being void ab initio was implicitly upheld by agreeing with the ITAT's finding on the time-bar.
What were the facts?
This case involves an appeal by the Revenue against a judgment of the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT), Guwahati Bench. The ITAT had annulled an assessment order dated 31.12.2003 passed by the Assessing Officer under section 158BD/143(3)/158BG of the Income Tax Act, 1961. The assessment pertained to the block period from 01.04.1989 to 08.12.1999 for the deceased assessee, Partha Sarathi Dey, and his successors. A search and seizure operation was conducted on 08.12.1999. Notices were issued to the legal representatives of the deceased, including the respondent (his wife). The Assessing Officer initially dropped proceedings under section 158BD and initiated fresh proceedings under section 158BD, issuing a notice to the respondent, which was allegedly received on 24.12.2001. The assessment order was passed on 31.12.2003. The respondent's appeal before the CIT(A) was dismissed, but the ITAT allowed it, holding the assessment barred by time.
What were the issues?
1. Whether the assessment order dated 31.12.2003, passed under section 158BD/143(3)/158BG of the Income Tax Act, 1961, was barred by time as per section 158BE(2) of the Act? Assessee's contentions: The respondent argued that following the search, notices under section 158BC and 142(1) were issued to the legal heirs. The last of these notices was received on 28.12.2000. Therefore, as per section 158BE(2), the assessment ought to have been completed by 31.12.2002, making the assessment order dated 31.12.2003 time-barred. Additionally, the respondent contended that the search and seizure proceedings, initiated based on a warrant issued in the name of a deceased person (Partha Sarathi Dey), were void ab initio. Revenue's contentions: The Revenue argued that fresh proceedings under section 158BD were initiated on 19.12.2001, and the consequent notice was received by the respondent on 24.12.2001. Therefore, the assessment order dated 31.12.2003 was within the time limit prescribed by section 158BE(2). The Revenue relied on the decisions in C&C Construction (P) Ltd. Vs. Commissioner of Income Tax and Sanjay Kumar Modi Vs. Director of Income Tax (Investigation) & Ors.
Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?
Section 132,Section 142(1),Section 143(3),Section 148(2),Section 158BC,Section 158BD,Section 158BE(2),Section 158BG,Section 260A
AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below
ITA 1/2010 BEFORE HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE AMITAVA ROY THE HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE S.R. SEN Judgment & Order Amitava Roy, J In challenge is the judgment and order dated 11.09.2009, passed by the learned I ncome Tax Appellate Tribunal, Guwahati Bench, Guwahati (for short hereafter refe rred to as the Tribunal) in ITA No. 75 (Gau)/2007, allowing the same and annulli ng the order dated 31.12.2003 of the Assessing Officer under section 158BD/143(3 )/158BG of the Income Tax Act, 1961 (for short hereafter referred to as the Act) vis-a-vis the respondent herein. 02. We have heard Mr. S Sarma, learned Counsel for the Revenue and M r. GN Sahewalla, Senior Advocate assisted by Mr. P Deka, Advocate for the respon dent. 03. Following a search and seizure operation under section 132 of th e Income Tax Act, 1961 (for short hereinafter referred to as the Act) conducted in the business and residential premises of the assessee, Partha Sarathi Dey (si nce deceased) and his successors in interest on 08.12.1999 a notice under sectio n 158BC was issued on 07.06.2000 to the legal representatives of the deceased ab ovenamed, which was received by them, according to the Revenue, on 26.06.2000. P artha Sarathi Dey had expired on 18.08.1999. By the aforementioned notice dated 07.06.2000, addressed to his legal representatives, they were required to submit return as mentioned therein. Thereafter, a notice dated 27.11.2000 was issued t o Sri Sunil Chandra Dey, also a legal representative of Lt. Partha Sarathi Dey, requiring him to produce the necessary documents pertaining to the block period from 01.04.1989 to 08.12.1999 in connection with the assessment of income. The r ecords reveal that the respondent herein, the wife of Lt. Partha Sarathi Dey sub mitted her return on 06.12.2000 for the aforementioned block period. By a notice No. GIR-S-740/ACTT/SII/Block Asstt., dated 02.11.2001, issued by the Assistant Commissioner of Income Tax, Investigation Circle, Silchar, the respondent herein was required to furnish the informations as detailed in the list appended there to. It was clearly indicated in the said list that the requisition for the infor mations as mentioned in the notice dated 27.11.2000 under section 142(1) had not been complied with till then. This was duly replied to on behalf of the respond ent. 04. While the matter proceeded thus, the Assistant Commissioner of Income Tax, Investigation Circle, Silchar, by order dated 19.12.2001 taking note of the panchanama i.e. 08.12.1999, issued in the name of Partha Sarathi Dey, wh o was dead on the date of search & seizure, dropped the proceedings and initiate d a fresh proceedings under section 158 BD. Thereby, a notice was ordered to be issued to the respondent, as the legal representative of Lt. Partha Sarathi Dey. According to the revenue, this notice was received by the respondent-Assessee o n 24.12.2001, whereupon, the assessment was validly made on 31.12.2003. 05. Being aggrieved by this assessment, the respondent unsuccessfull y preferred an appeal before the Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals) Shillong, which dismissed the same on 08.11.2006. The learned Tribunal, however, by the ju dgment and order impugned herein, interfered with the assessment order on the gr ound that in terms of section 158BE (2) (a) or (b), the block assessment in the case in hand ought to have been completed within 31.12.2002 and, thus, the asses sment order dated 31.12.2003 was barred by time. 06. Mr. Sarma has urged that, as a fresh proceeding under section 15 8 BD, in the attendant facts and circumstances, had been initiated by the assess
ing officer on 19.12.2001 and the notice consequently issued was received by the respondent on 24.12.2001, the assessment order 31.12.2003 as per section 158BE (2) was within time and, thus the finding to the contrary is per se, illegal and is liable to be set aside. In support of his contentions, the learned counsel f or the Revenue has placed reliance on the decision of the High Court of Delhi in C&C Construction (P) Ltd. Vs. Commissioner of Income Tax, (2012) 204 TAXMAN 363 (Del) and that of the High Court of Calcutta in Sanjay Kumar Modi Vs. Director of Income Tax (Investigation) & Ors., (2005) 199 CTR (Cal) 666. 07. Per Contra, the learned Senior Counsel for the respondent has ur ged that following the search involved, a panchanama on the basis of the proceed ings had been prepared in the name of Sri Sunil Chandra Dey, father of Partha Sa rathi Dey, in whose name the warrant had been issued. Thereafter, notices were i ssued on 07.06.2000, 17.11.2000 and 07.12.2000 under section 158 BC & 142(1) of the Act to the legal heirs of Lt. Partha Sarathi Dey requiring them to furnish n ecessary informations and documents for the assessment of income for the block p eriod from 01.04.1989 to 08.12.1999. According to Mr. Sahewalla, the last date o f receipt of the notices being 28.12.2000, the assessment ought to have been obl igatorily completed by 31.12.2002 and in that view of the matter, the assessment order dated 31.12.2003 had been rightly held to be barred by time by the learne d Tribunal. Without prejudice to this plea, the learned Senior Counsel has furth er insisted that in any view of the matter, the proceedings of the search and se izure conducted on the basis of a warrant issued against a dead man were void ab initio and, thus all consequential steps towards the assessment were non est. 08. The pleaded facts and the arguments advanced have been duly cons idered by us. That, at the first instance, the search for the aforementioned blo ck period had been conducted on the basis of a warrant issued in the name of Sri Partha Sarathi Dey, who was dead on the date thereof, is a matter of record. Re cords reveal that Sri Partha Sarathi Dey was dead on 18.08.1999 and, thus, prior to the date of search i.e. 08.12.1999. The Assistant Commissioner of Income Tax (Investigation) Circle, Silchar, however, by notices dated 07.06.2000, 27.11.20 00 and 07.12.2000 issued under section 158BC, 142 (1) and 148 (2) respectively, addressed to the legal representative of Lt. Partha Sarathi Dey proceeded with t he assessment proceedings. The assessment order dated 31.12.2003 bears out as we ll the above view. The finding of the learned Tribunal that the search had been conducted and completed on 08.09.1999 is not disputed. The assessment order date d 31.12.2003 does not disclose, inter alia, that the assessment proceedings init ially drawn on the basis of the search held on 08.09.1999 had, in fact, been dro pped. To the contrary, the text thereof demonstrates that the same was pursuant to, amongst others, the notice dated 07.06.2000 issued under section 158BC of th e Act. The assertion of the respondent-assessee is that the last of the notices dated 07.06.2000, 17.11.2000 and 07.12.2000 had been received by her on 28.12.20 00. In this view of the matter, in terms of section 158BE (2), the assessment ou ght to have been completed latest by 31.12.2002. We, thus, in the facts and circ umstances of the case find ourselves in respectful agreement to the finding reco rded to this effect by the learned Tribunal. 09. The decisions cited at the Bar are distinguishable on facts. Whe reas, in C&C Construction (P) Ltd. Vs. Commissioner of Income Tax (Supra), the p roposition of law is that an issue neither raised nor decided by the learned Tri bunal cannot be a subject matter of appeal under section 260 A before the High C ourt, in Sanjay Kumar Modi (Supra), the search and seizure was admittedly conduc ted on the premises of a joint family. The contextual facts therein disclosed th at the name of the petitioner was not in the search warrant and, therefore, the search vis-a-vis him was held to be invalid. In spite of this lacuna, the search vis-a-vis the other co-noticees residing in the premises were sustained with th e conclusion that the entire proceedings of the search thus could not be held to be invalid. This decision, according to us, in the singular facts and circumsta nces of the case is of no avail to the Revenue. On a cumulative consideration as
above we find no merit in this appeal, which is, accordingly, dismissed. No cos ts.
More judgments on Section 132
- DCIT Central Circle 32, Delhi vs M/S Triveni Tv Networks Private Limited…ITA 5661/DEL/2026[2019-20]Status: Disposed18 Nov 2026AY 2019-20
- Quickpaisa Fintech Private Limited, Delhi vs Assistant Commissioner of Income Tax…ITA 1067/DEL/2026[2018-19]Status: Disposed18 Nov 2026AY 2018-19
- Quickpaisa Fintech Private Limited, Delhi vs Assistant Commissioner of Income Tax…ITA 1066/DEL/2026[2017-18]Status: Disposed18 Nov 2026AY 2017-18
- Asst. Commissioner of Income Tax, Central… vs Jagdish Kumar Dhingra, DelhiITA 5462/DEL/2024[2017-18]Status: Disposed18 Nov 2026AY 2017-18
- Asst. Commissioner of Income Tax, Central… vs Apichem Laboratories Pvt Ltd, HyderabadITA 2394/HYD/2026[2021-22]Status: Disposed13 Nov 2026AY 2021-22
Recent GST High Court judgments
Search GST case law →- Subrat Kumar Samal vs. The Commissioner, CGST, Cx And Customs, BhubaneswarOrissa · 3 Nov 2026
- Laxmipriya Biswal vs. Assistant Commissioner Of State Tax,BhubaneswarOrissa · 3 Nov 2026
- M/S Shree Jagannath Engineering,Angul vs. Assistant Commissioner, Angul Division ,AngulOrissa · 3 Nov 2026
- M/S. Archana Agro, Nayagarh vs. The Chief Commissioner Of Commercial Taxes And Goods And Services Tax, CuttackOrissa · 3 Nov 2026
- M/S.Shree Jagannath Associates, Angul vs. The Chief Commissioner Of Commercial Taxes And Goods And Services Tax, CuttackOrissa · 3 Nov 2026