JCIT, SPECIAL RANGE, PANAJI vs. M/S ZUARI AGRO CHEMICALS LTD, VASCO
What did the Tribunal hold?
The Tribunal held that the disallowance under Section 14A is to be restricted to investments yielding exempt income. In this case, the assessee had not earned any dividend income from its investments. The Tribunal noted that the assessee had interest-free funds significantly exceeding its investments, leading to the presumption that investments were made from interest-free funds, citing South Indian Bank Limited v. CIT and CIT vs. HDFC Bank Ltd. The Tribunal also found that the amendment by the Finance Act 2022 to Section 14A, inserting an explanation, was not retrospective. Therefore, the CIT(A) was justified in holding that no disallowance under Section 14A was called for, except for the suo motu disallowance of Rs. 5,16,500/- made by the assessee. The grounds of appeal raised by the Revenue were dismissed. For AY 2014-15, the same issue was involved, and the Revenue did not press certain grounds. The Tribunal held that its decision in AY 2012-13 would apply mutatis mutandis. Both appeals were dismissed.
What were the facts?
The Revenue filed appeals against the orders of the CIT(A) for Assessment Years (AY) 2012-13 and 2014-15. This was the second round of litigation, as a previous ITAT order had dismissed the Revenue's appeals on a legal issue without deciding on merits. The Bombay High Court at Goa remanded the matter to the ITAT for adjudication on merits. The assessee, M/s. Zuari Agro Chemicals Ltd., is a fertilizer business. For AY 2012-13, the Assessing Officer (AO) disallowed Rs. 2,14,80,163/- under Section 14A read with Rule 8D, considering expenditure incurred for earning exempt income. The AO also made additions for loss on sale of fertilizer bonds and disallowance of interest expenditure. The CIT(A) partly allowed the assessee's appeal, deleting the addition under Section 14A.
What were the issues?
1. Whether, on the facts of the case, the CIT(A) was justified in deleting the addition made under Section 14A of the Income Tax Act, 1961, read with Rule 8D of the IT Rules, when the AO recorded dissatisfaction regarding the correctness and genuineness of the assessee's claims for expenditure? (Question of law and fact, concerning Section 14A and Rule 8D) 2. Whether, on the facts of the case, the CIT(A) was justified in deleting the additions made under Section 14A read with Rule 8D in light of CBDT Circular No. 5/2014 clarifying legislative intent? (Question of law, concerning Section 14A, Rule 8D, and Circular No. 5/2014) Assessee's contentions: The assessee argued that it had suo motu disallowed Rs. 5,16,500/-. It also contended that no disallowance under Rule 8D(2)(ii) and (iii) can be made for investments that did not yield dividend income during the year. Reliance was placed on various judicial decisions, including Poonawalla Fincorp Ltd. vs. ITO, DCIT vs. John Deere India Pvt. Ltd., and others. Regarding Circular No. 5/2014, the assessee argued it is not binding on appellate authorities, citing Redington (India) Ltd. vs. ACIT and PCIT vs. McDonald’s India Pvt. Ltd. Revenue's contentions: The Revenue argued that the AO was justified in disallowing expenditure under Section 14A as the assessee had shown dissatisfaction regarding the claims. It also relied on CBDT Circular No. 5/2014, suggesting disallowance even if no exempt income was earned. The Revenue's grounds for AY 2014-15 regarding grounds 4 to 6 were not pressed.
Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?
Section 14A,Section 36(1)(iii),Section 143(1),Section 143(3),Section 271(1)(c)
AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below
Income Tax Appellate Tribunal, PANAJI BENCH “DB”, PANAJI
Before: SHRI MANISH BORAD & SHRI VINAY BHAMORE
IN THE INCOME TAX APPELLATE TRIBUNAL PANAJI BENCH “DB”, PANAJI BEFORE SHRI MANISH BORAD, ACCOUNTANT MEMBER AND SHRI VINAY BHAMORE, JUDICIAL MEMBER आयकर अपील सं. / ITA Nos.13 & 15/PAN/2020 िनधा�रण वष� / Assessment Years : 2012-13 & 2014-15 JCIT, Special Range, Vs. M/s. Zuari Agro Chemicals Panaji. Ltd., Jai Kisan Bhavan, Zuari Nagar, Vasco- Goa, Goa 403726. PAN : AAACZ3924H Appellant Respondent Revenue by : Shri Naveen Kumar B. Assessee by : Shri Kalpesh Unadkat Date of hearing : 10.08.2026 Date of pronouncement : 04.11.2026 आदेश / ORDER PER VINAY BHAMORE, JM: These appeals filed by the Revenue are directed against the separate orders dated 06.11.2019 passed by Ld. CIT(A), Panaji-1 [‘Ld. CIT(A)’] for the assessment years 2012-13 and 2014-15 respectively. 2. Since identical facts and common issues are involved in both the above captioned appeals of the Revenue, therefore, we proceed to dispose of the same by this common order. 3. First, we shall take up the appeal of the Revenue in ITA No.13/PAN/2020 for A.Y. 2012-13 for adjudication as the lead case.
2 ITA Nos.13 & 15/PAN/2020 ITA No.13/PAN/2020, A.Y. 2012-13 : 4. The Revenue has raised the following grounds of appeal :- “1. The order of the CIT(A), Panaji-1, is bad in law ignoring the relevant facts and findings of the Assessing Officer. 2. Whether on facts of the case, the CIT(A), Panaji-1 was justified in deleting the addition made u/s 14A of the Act r.w. Rule 8D of the IT Rules when the Assessing Officer had recorded his dissatisfaction regarding correctness and genuineness of claims of such expenditure made by the assessee in the return of income filed. 3. Whether on facts of the case, the CIT(A), Panaji-1 was justified in deleting the additions made u/s 14A of the Act r.w. Rule 8D of the IT Rules in the light of the Board's Circular No.5/2014 issued clarifying the legislative intent of such disallowance under the said provisions of the Act and relevant Rules thereupon. 4. The appellant craves to amend or alter any grounds of appeal or add the same, if deemed necessary.” 5. This is second round of litigation before this Tribunal in as much as the Tribunal vide consolidated order dated 24.08.2023 dismissed the appeals of the Revenue on legal issue but did not dealt on merits. Assessee approached the Hon’ble High Court and the Hon’ble High Court of Bombay at Goa in Misc. Civil Application No.133 of 2026 in Tax Appeal No.23/2024 judgment dated 11.03.2026 has remanded the matter to the ITAT, Panaji Bench with a direction to adjudicate the matters on merits. Relevant observation of the Hon’ble High Court reads as under :- “1. The appeals filed by the Revenue, having been admitted, are listed for hearing. The respective counsel representing the respondents/Assessee submit that they are ready to be relegated to the ITAT and are agreeable to the fact that the appeals can be decided by the Tribunal on its merits. 2. Ms Amira Razaq, appearing for the Revenue, expresses her consent for remanding the matter but would submit that the appeals shall be
3 ITA Nos.13 & 15/PAN/2020 decided on merits by keeping the rights and contentions of the respective parties open. 3. The respective counsel representing the Assessee are, however, agreeable to have the appeals heard on merits as the Tribunal had merely pronounced upon the technical aspect of the matter. 4. In the wake of the aforesaid statement, the respective ITAT appeals are remanded back to the Panaji Bench with a direction to the Tribunal to adjudicate the matters on merits without looking into the technical objections of the issue of Document Identification Number (DIN).” 6. Respectfully following the above direction of Hon’ble High Court, the cases have been heard on merits and we therefore proceed to adjudicate the appeals. 7. Facts of the case, in brief, are that the assessee is a private limited company engaged in the business of Fertilisers. The assessee company furnished its return of income on 28.09.2012 declaring income of Rs.1,45,10,42,814/- which was processed by CPC u/s 143(1) of the IT Act on 11.03.2014. the assessee revised its return of income on 30.03.2014 declaring income of Rs.1,08,54,41,630/-. The case was selected for scrutiny through CASS and notice u/s 143(2) & 142(1) of the IT Act respectively were issued to the assessee. During the course of assessment proceedings, it was observed by the Assessing Officer that the assessee has made investments in equity shares etc and exempt income of Rs.9,16,98,237/- has been shown. The Assessing Officer in the light of section 14A of the IT Act (which suggest that for the purposes of computing the total income under this Chapter, no deduction shall be allowed in respect of expenditure incurred by the assessee in relation to income which does not form part of the total income under this Act) requested the assessee to provide working of disallowance u/s 14A r.w. Rule 8D.
4 ITA Nos.13 & 15/PAN/2020 In response the assessee company furnished that the assessee has not earned any exempt income from its investments in equity shares of subsidiary companies, however, has earned exempt dividend on mutual funds which were purchased for trading during the year and the assessee on its own has already made a lump sum disallowance of Rs.5,16,500/- out of the total expenses as per its own calculation, however, the assessee is furnishing the working of disallowance as per Rule 8D of the IT Rule which is not acceptable to the assessee. The Assessing Officer after considering the reply of the assessee, disallowed a sum of Rs.2,14,80,163/- u/s 14A r.w. Rule 8D as expenditure incurred for earning the exempted income and added the same to the income of the assessee. The Assessing Officer also made addition of Rs.36,39,08,246/- on account of loss on sale of fertilizer bonds and also made addition of Rs.2,91,76,980/- on account of disallowance of interest expenditure u/s 36(1)(iii) of the IT Act. Accordingly, vide order dated 05.03.2015 the Assessing Officer completed the assessment proceedings u/s 143(3) of the IT Act by determining the income of the assessee at Rs.1,50,00,06,959/- as against the income of Rs.1,08,54,41,632/- returned by the assessee. 8. Being aggrieved with the above action of the Assessing Officer, the assessee preferred an appeal before Ld. CIT(A). After considering the reply and submissions of the assessee, Ld. CIT(A) partly allowed the appeal filed by the assessee by observing as under :- “31. I have perused the matter under consideration and the said ground is disposed as under:
5 ITA Nos.13 & 15/PAN/2020 a) It is observed that the interest free funds are considerably more than the amount of interest free loans given to the subsidiary companies. Further, it is noticed that the interest free funds are Rs. 785 crores as against interest bearing funds of Rs. 325 crores. Thus, in the present scenario, based on the decision of the Hon'ble Jurisdictional High Court in the case of CIT v. Reliance Utilities & Power Ltd. (2009) 313 ITR 340, it can be assumed that the loans are given from the interest free funds. It is also noticed that out of the total loan of Rs. 67.50 crores, loan of Rs. 45 crores had been given by the parent company which is now reflecting in the books of the Appellant on account of demerger. It had been held in the case of the parent company i.e. Zuari Global Limited by the Hon'ble ITAT, Panaji that provisions of section 36(1) (iii) of the Act is not applicable. Thus, it is held that the loans were given out of the interest free funds only and there may not be any disallowance under section 36(1)(iii) of the Act. b) Further, it is held by various authorities including the Supreme Court in the cases cited supra that it is the decision of the businessman as to how the business may be conducted and the Revenue Authorities cannot step into the shoes of the department and decide it otherwise. In the present case, it is noticed that the subsidiary companies are also into the business of fertilizers and thus, it may be held that the temporary loans granted to the subsidiary companies were also for the purpose of business. c) The contention of the AO is not correct in the present case that the interest free loans were given out of the interest-bearing funds, as the same was not substantiated by any evidences and was based on suspicion. Based on the above findings, the ground nos. 3.1 and 3.2 are disposed off accordingly in the favour of the Appellant. Thus, there is no need to deal with Ground no. 3.3 as the same becomes in fructuous. 32. Ground no. 4: Short Grant of advance tax credit - INR 2,50,00,000 The said ground is not pressed by the appellant and therefore this ground is not being adjudicated. 33. Ground no. 5: Penalty Proceedings under section 271(1)(c) of the Act This ground is related to initiation of penalty proceedings. The appellant has raised the ground on initiation of penalty proceedings.
6 ITA Nos.13 & 15/PAN/2020 The penalty has been initiated u/s. 271(1)(c) and has not been levied. Any ground on initiation on penal provision is premature. 34. In the result, the appeal is partly allowed.” 9. Now, the Revenue is in appeal before this Tribunal challenging the addition of Rs.2,14,80,163/- made by the Assessing Officer u/s 14A r.w. Rule 8D. 10. We have heard Ld. Counsels from both the sides and perused the material available on record including the paper book furnished by the assessee. In this regard, we find that it is the contention of the assessee that the assessee has received exempted dividend income from treasury operations in Mutual Funds. These Mutual Funds were purchased and sold during the year. Thus, these Mutual Funds were not owned at the year end. No dividend income has been earned on the equity shares of companies. However, the assessee has suo moto made a disallowance of Rs.5,16,500/- (on scientific basis, considering the expenses of treasury department and certain administrative overheads) u/s 14A of the IT Act. It is also the contentions of the assessee that no disallowance u/s 14A r.w. Rule 8D(2)(ii) and (iii) can be made in respect of investments, which has not yielded any dividend income during the year under appeal. This issue has been decided in various judicial decisions. Ld. CIT(A) has referred to various decisions on these legal principles. Reliance is also placed upon some of the following additional decisions, which are rendered post Ld. CIT(A) order :- (i) Poonawalla Fincorp Ltd. vs. ITO (2026) 187 taxmann.com 879 (Pune- Trib.) – order dated
7 ITA Nos.13 & 15/PAN/2020 19.06.2026, the Tribunal has also considered the amendment made in section 14A from A.Y. 2022-23. (ii) DCIT vs. John Deere India Pvt. Ltd. ITA No.1910/PUN/2024 order dated 30.12.2024. (iii) DCIT vs. Nippon Life India Asset Management Ltd., ITA No.3887/Mum/2025 order dated 28.08.2025. (iv) Dai-ichi Karkaria Limited [TS-883-ITAT-2025 (Mum)] dated 11.06.2025 (v) PTC India Ltd. [TS-1548-ITAT-2025 (Del)] dated 24.11.2025. (vi) Delite Enterprises (IT Appeal No.110 of 2009) (Bom)(HC). 11. Regarding second ground about the CBDT Circular No.5/2014, Ld. AR appearing from the side of the assessee submitted that the above Circular is not binding on the appellate authorities & in support of this contention relied on following citations :- (i) Redington (India) Ltd. vs. ACIT (TCA No.520/2016) Madras HC) order dated 23.12.2026. (ii) PCIT vs. McDonald’s India Pvt. Ltd. (ITA No.725/2018) (Delhi HC) order dated 22.10.2018. (iii) Poonawalla Fincorp Ltd. vs. ITO (2026) 187 taxmann.com 879 (Pune- Trib.) – order dated 19.06.2026. 12. In the instant case, we observe that the assessee has not earned any dividend income out of the investments. The fact that assessee has not earned any exempt income get supported with the computation of disallowance made by the Assessing Officer. It is trite law that disallowance u/s.14A is to be restricted for the investments yielding exempt income. Since the assessee has not earned any exempt income for the year in question Ld. CIT(A) has rightly held that no disallowance u/s.14A is called for.
8 ITA Nos.13 & 15/PAN/2020
In the instant case, assessee has interest free funds to the tune of Rs.784.58 crore and the investments are only Rs.197.49 crores. When the interest free funds are far in excess of the investments, then it has to be presumed that investments have been made out of interest free funds. This view is by virtue of judgment of Hon’ble Apex Court in the case of South Indian Bank Limited v. CIT (2021) 438 ITR 1 and the judgment of Hon’ble Jurisdictional High Court in the case of CIT vs. HDFC Bank Ltd. (2014) 366 ITR 505 and in absence of any contrary evidence/binding precedent, we find no force in the contentions raised by the Revenue. Further, the assessee has suo moto disallowed Rs.5,16,500/- u/s.14A of the Act and the disallowance be restricted to the extent of this suo moto disallowance. 14. Hon’ble Delhi High Court in the case of Chem Investment Ltd. Vs. CIT (2015) 61 taxmann.com 18 (Delhi) held that provision of Section 14A will not be applied if no exempt income is received or receivable during the relevant previous year. Revenue contends that vide CBDT Circular 5/2014 dated 11.02.2014 disallowance u/s 14A is to be made even if assesse has not earned any exempt income during the year under consideration. Assessee has placed reliance that CBDT circulars are binding on Tax authorities but not on appellate Forums. We find that the amendment brought by the Finance Act 2022 w.e.f. 01.04.2022 by inserting explanation to section 14A of the Act clarify that notwithstanding anything to the contrary contained in this Act, the provision of Sec. 14A shall apply and shall be deemed to have always applied in a case where exempt
9 ITA Nos.13 & 15/PAN/2020 income has not accrued or arisen or has not been received during the previous year relevant to an assessment year and the expenditure has been incurred during the said previous year in relation to such exempt income. In this regard, we find that Hon’ble Delhi High Court in the case of Pr. Commissioner of Income Tax (Central)-2 v. M/s Era Infrastructure (India) Ltd. decided July 20, 2022 held that amendment made by Finance Act 2022 to section 14A by inserting a non-obstante clause and Explanation will take effect from 1.04.2022 and cannot be presumed to have retrospective effect. 15. Ld. CIT(A) has given a reasoned finding holding that disallowance under 14A r.w.s. Rule 8D(2)(ii) and Rule 8D(2)(iii) of the I.T. Rules, 1962 is uncalled for and therefore, we are thus disincline to interfere with the same. Grounds of appeal raised by the Revenue are dismissed. 16. In the result, the appeal filed by the Revenue in ITA No.13/PAN/2020 for A.Y. 2012-13 is dismissed ITA No.15/PAN/2020, A.Y. 2014-15: 17. Revenue raised seven grounds of appeal out of which Ld. CIT- DR has not advanced any arguments in respect of grounds of appeal no.4 to 6 and the same are therefore dismissed as ‘not pressed’. Ground No.7 is general in nature which needs no adjudication. So far as grounds of appeal no. 1 to 3 raised by the Revenue regarding deletion of addition u/s.14A of the Act read with Rule 8D of the I.T. Rules, we have already adjudicated the issue and has upheld the order of Ld.CIT(A). Therefore, our decision in ITA
10 ITA Nos.13 & 15/PAN/2020 No.13/PAN/2020 for A.Y. 2012-13 shall apply mutatis mutandis to the appeal of the Revenue in ITA No.15/PAN/2020 for A.Y. 2014-15. Accordingly, the appeal of the Revenue in ITA No.15/PAN/2020 for A.Y. 2014-15 is also dismissed. 18. To sum up, both the above captioned appeals filed by the Revenue are dismissed. Order pronounced on this 04th day of November, 2026. Sd/- Sd/- (MANISH BORAD) (VINAY BHAMORE) ACCOUNTANT MEMBER JUDICIAL MEMBER Pune / Dated : 04th November, 2026. Sujeet/DOC Sujeet Kumar Digitally signed by Sujeet Kumar Sharma Sharma Date: 2026.11.06 17:12:24 +05'30' आदेश क� �ितिलिप अ�ेिषत / Copy of the Order forwarded to : अपीलाथ� / The Appellant. 1. ��यथ� / The Respondent. 2. 3. The CIT(A), Panaji-1. 4. The Pr. CIT/CIT concerned. 5. DR, ITAT, Panaji. गाड� फ़ाइल / Guard File. 6. आदेशानुसार / BY ORDER, // True Copy // Assistant Registrar ITAT, Pune.
More judgments on Section 14A
- Indian Herbs Specialities Private Limited… vs ACIT Circle-12 (1), DelhiITA 1785/DEL/2026[2017-18]Status: Disposed18 Nov 2026AY 2017-18
- Dy. Commissioner of Income Tax, Ainthapali… vs The Koraput Central Cooperative Bank Ltd…ITA 475/CTK/2025[2017-18]Status: Disposed12 Nov 2026AY 2017-18
- Dy. Commissioner of Income Tax, Ainthapali… vs The Koraput Central Cooperative Bank Ltd…ITA 475/CTK/2025[2017-18]Status: Disposed12 Nov 2026AY 2017-18
- Agriculture Insurance Company of India… vs ITO Circle 1(1), DelhiITA 7997/DEL/2025[2022-23]Status: Disposed11 Nov 2026AY 2022-23
- Agriculture Insurance Company of India… vs ITO Circle 1(1), DelhiITA 7996/DEL/2025[2020-21]Status: Disposed11 Nov 2026AY 2020-21
Recent GST High Court judgments
Search GST case law →- Subrat Kumar Samal vs. The Commissioner, CGST, Cx And Customs, BhubaneswarOrissa · 3 Nov 2026
- Laxmipriya Biswal vs. Assistant Commissioner Of State Tax,BhubaneswarOrissa · 3 Nov 2026
- M/S Shree Jagannath Engineering,Angul vs. Assistant Commissioner, Angul Division ,AngulOrissa · 3 Nov 2026
- M/S. Archana Agro, Nayagarh vs. The Chief Commissioner Of Commercial Taxes And Goods And Services Tax, CuttackOrissa · 3 Nov 2026
- M/S.Shree Jagannath Associates, Angul vs. The Chief Commissioner Of Commercial Taxes And Goods And Services Tax, CuttackOrissa · 3 Nov 2026