DY. COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX CIRCLE-3(3)(1),MUMBAI, MUMBAI vs. VIDYAVIHAR CONTAINERS LIMITED, MUMBAI

PDF · subscribers
ITA 4672/MUM/2026Status: DisposedITAT Mumbai27 October 2026AY 2011-1218 pages

In favour of the assessee: the Revenue's appeal was dismissed. From the AI summary of this appeal.

AI SummaryDismissed

What did the Tribunal hold?

The Tribunal held that for Ground No. 1 and 2, the CIT(A)'s direction to verify and delete the addition of Rs. 5,70,29,675/- was upheld. The Tribunal noted that the assessee's explanation regarding the realization of consideration and interest only after litigation and offering it to tax in AY 2012-13 was supported by documents examined in remand proceedings. The Tribunal clarified that the issue of accrual versus receipt basis for taxation was to be examined in light of the specific facts and the assessee's accounting policy. For Ground No. 4, concerning interest under section 244A, the Tribunal dismissed the Revenue's ground, clarifying that the ascertainment of the correct taxable amount should be done from existing records after affording the assessee an opportunity to be heard, and not by automatically reducing section 244A interest by section 234D interest. For Ground No. 5, the deletion of Rs. 1,20,21,000/- was upheld. The Tribunal found that the assessee's explanation, supported by the development agreement and a confirmatory letter from GNRC, established that the assessee was a confirming party and the transactions were accounted for by the developer. The Tribunal concluded that the AIR information did not establish that these sale proceeds constituted the assessee's income.

What were the facts?

The Revenue appealed the order of the CIT(A) for AY 2011-12, which arose from an assessment order under section 143(3). The assessee, Vidyavihar Containers Limited, a domestic company, filed a return showing a loss. The dispute involved additions made by the Assessing Officer (AO) concerning interest on additional consideration from a developer (Rs. 5,70,29,675/-), interest under section 244A (Rs. 4,29,427/-), and unexplained sale of immovable property (Rs. 1,20,21,000/-). The assessee had a development agreement with M/s. Gammon Neelkanth Realty Corporation (GNRC) for its land, entitling it to flats and additional consideration with interest. The AO added interest on the additional consideration, arguing it accrued despite litigation, and added unexplained sale proceeds from immovable property based on AIR data. The CIT(A) directed verification and deletion of these additions.

What were the issues?

1. Whether the CIT(A) erred in directing the AO to verify and delete the addition of Rs. 5,70,29,675/- on account of interest accrued on additional consideration, considering the assessee followed the mercantile system of accounting and the income had accrued, as argued by the Revenue. The assessee contended that the additional consideration and interest were realized only after litigation and offered to tax in AY 2012-13, relying on the Tribunal's order. 2. Whether the CIT(A) erred in directing verification with reference to AY 2012-13, allowing taxation on receipt basis, contrary to accrual principles, as argued by the Revenue. The assessee argued that the income was offered to tax in AY 2012-13. 3. Whether the CIT(A) erred in setting aside the addition of Rs. 4,29,427/- on account of interest under section 244A for verification, without appreciating that such interest is statutory and taxable irrespective of adjustment, as argued by the Revenue. The assessee explained the refund adjustment and intimation receipt. 4. Whether the CIT(A) erred in deleting the addition of Rs. 1,20,21,000/- on account of unexplained sale of immovable property, without appreciating the assessee's failure to reconcile AIR information, as argued by the Revenue. The assessee explained that the transactions belonged to GNRC, and its name appeared as a confirming party, supported by documents examined in remand.

Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?

Section 250,Section 143(3),Section 5,Section 145,Section 244A,Section 234D

AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below

Income Tax Appellate Tribunal, MUMBAI BENCHES, MUMBAI

Before: SHRI SAKTIJIT DEY & SHRI MAKARAND VASANT MAHADEOKAR

PER MAKARAND VASANT MAHADEOKAR, ACCOUNTANT MEMBER: This appeal by the Revenue is directed against the order dated 24.02.2026 passed by the learned Commissioner of Income-tax (Appeals), National Faceless Appeal Centre, Delhi [hereinafter referred to as “the learned CIT(A)”], under section 250 of the Income-tax Act, 1961 (“the Act”), for the assessment year 2011-12. The impugned order arises from the assessment order dated 13.03.2014 passed by the Deputy Commissioner of Income-tax-10(2), Mumbai (“Assessing Officer”), under section 143(3) of the Act.

2.

The Revenue has raised the following grounds of appeal:

ITA No. 4672/MUM/2026 VIDYAVIHAR CONTAINERS LIMITED 1. On facts and in the circumstances of the case and in law, the ld. CIT(A) has erred in directing the Assessing Officer to verify and delete the addition of Rs. 5,70,29,675/- made on account of interest accrued on additional consideration from the developer, without appreciating that the assessee was following mercantile system of accounting and the said income had already accrued during the year under consideration. 2. On facts and in the circumstances of the case and in law, the ld. CIT(A) has failed to appreciate that the right to receive the additional consideration along with interest had crystallized during the year and, therefore, the same was taxable on accrual basis as per the provisions of section 5 read with section 145 of the Income Tax Act. 3. On facts and in the circumstances of the case and in law, the ld. CIT(A) has erred in directing verification with reference to A.Y. 2012-13, thereby allowing taxation on receipt basis, which is contrary to the settled principles of accrual of income and results in deferment of tax liability. 4. On facts and in the circumstances of the case and in law, the ld. CIT(A) has erred in setting aside the addition of Rs. 4,29,427/- on account of interest under section 244A for verification, without appreciating that such interest is a statutory income and is taxable irrespective of its adjustment against any other demand. 5. On facts and in the circumstances of the case and in law, the ld. CIT(A) has erred in deleting the addition of Rs. 1,20,21,000/- made on account of unexplained sale of immovable property, without appreciating that the assessee had failed to reconcile the AIR information and offer the income from the sale of immovable property to tax. 6. The appellant craves leave to add, amend, alter or withdraw any of the above grounds of appeal at the time of hearing. 3. Briefly stated, the assessee is a resident domestic company. It filed its return of income for the assessment year under consideration on 29.09.2011 declaring a net loss of Rs.1,08,77,303/-. The return was processed under section 143(1) of the Act. Subsequently, the case was selected for scrutiny.

4.

The assessee had entered into a development agreement dated 24.06.2005 with M/s. Gammon Neelkanth Realty Corporation (“GNRC”) for development of its land at Vidyavihar. Under the arrangement, the assessee was entitled to residential flats having an aggregate carpet area of approximately 2,19,000 sq. ft., together with 200 parking spaces, to be constructed and made available by the developer free of cost. The arrangement also contemplated additional consideration upon permission being granted for utilisation of externally procured transferable development 2

ITA No. 4672/MUM/2026 VIDYAVIHAR CONTAINERS LIMITED rights. Under the second supplemental agreement dated 14.07.2005, such additional consideration was fixed at Rs.25,00,00,000/-. In the event of default in payment on the due date, the assessee was entitled to interest at five per cent per annum above the prevailing prime lending rate of the State Bank of India, with monthly rests.

5.

In terms of clause 5.2 of the development agreement, the developer was also obliged to reimburse the assessee for lease rent, property taxes, levies, cesses and other assessments, including non-agricultural assessment, relating to the land. During the relevant previous year, the assessee accounted for Rs.1,32,68,074/- receivable from the developer towards such dues as income from property development activities and claimed expenditure of Rs.76,93,432/- towards taxes and levies payable for the year.

6.

During the assessment proceedings, the Assessing Officer examined the non-recognition of interest on the additional consideration of Rs.25,00,00,000/-. He noted that the additional consideration had been treated as having accrued in the assessment year 2009-10 and that interest thereon had similarly been brought to tax in earlier years. The notes to the accounts recorded that the developer had failed to pay the additional consideration and that the assessee had instituted winding-up proceedings before the Hon’ble Bombay High Court for recovery of the amount, including interest. The assessee had not recognized the disputed consideration and interest in its accounts, referring to its accounting policy concerning revenue recognition and the uncertainty surrounding recovery.

7.

The Assessing Officer did not accept the assessee’s explanation. According to him, the assessee followed the mercantile system of accounting and its contractual right to receive the additional consideration and interest was enforceable. He considered that non-receipt of the amount and the pendency of litigation did not defer accrual. He further observed that postponing recognition until possession of the constructed flats was handed 3

ITA No. 4672/MUM/2026 VIDYAVIHAR CONTAINERS LIMITED over and the sale of land was completed was inconsistent with the method of accounting followed by the assessee. Accordingly, interest of Rs.5,70,29,675/-, as worked out for the period from 01.04.2010 to 31.03.2011, was added under the head “Profits and gains of business or profession”, treating it as part of the consideration arising from the development arrangement.

8.

The Assessing Officer also examined interest granted under section 244A of the Act in relation to the assessment year 2009-10. The assessee explained that the refund had been adjusted against the outstanding demand for the assessment year 2006-07 and that the relevant intimation had not been received. It further submitted that, upon completion of the subsequent assessment, interest under section 234D of Rs.4,92,765/- had been charged, as against interest under section 244A of Rs.4,29,427/-. The Assessing Officer rejected the explanation and added Rs.4,29,427/- as interest income not accounted for by the assessee.

9.

A further addition arose from reconciliation of the Annual Information Return (“AIR”) data. Six transactions relating to sale of immovable property were reported in the assessee’s name. According to the Assessing Officer, supporting documentary evidence was furnished for only four transactions. Despite a further opportunity recorded in the order-sheet entry dated 03.03.2014, the assessee could not furnish the requisite reconciliation for the remaining two transactions of Rs.60,21,000/- and Rs.60,00,000/-, dated 15.07.2010 and 05.08.2010, respectively. The Assessing Officer, therefore, added their aggregate amount of Rs.1,20,21,000/- to the assessee’s income.

10.

Apart from the aforesaid additions, the Assessing Officer disallowed Rs.12,59,961/- claimed towards irrecoverable interest written off. He observed that the corresponding interest income from inter-corporate deposits had been assessed in earlier years under the head “Income from other sources” and held that the deduction claimed was not available under 4

ITA No. 4672/MUM/2026 VIDYAVIHAR CONTAINERS LIMITED section 57 or section 36(1)(vii) of the Act. The assessment was completed under section 143(3) on 13.03.2014 determining total income at Rs.5,98,62,760/-, after making aggregate additions and disallowances of Rs.7,07,40,063/- to the returned loss.

11.

Aggrieved, the assessee preferred an appeal before the learned CIT(A). In relation to interest on additional consideration, the assessee explained the contractual arrangement and the dispute with the developer. It submitted that the additional consideration and interest were realized only after litigation and were offered to tax in the assessment year 2012-13. The assessee also relied upon the Tribunal’s consolidated order in its own case for the assessment years 2009-10 and 2010-11, whereby the additions concerning the additional consideration and interest had been deleted. As recorded in the appellate order, the assessee furnished particulars of the return, computation of income, explanatory letter and assessment order for the assessment year 2012-13 in support of its contention that the amounts had been offered to and accepted for taxation in that year.

12.

The learned CIT(A), in paragraph 6.2.2 of the impugned order, noted that a similar issue had been decided in favour of the assessee by the Tribunal for the assessment years 2009-10 and 2010-11. He further recorded that the interest brought to tax in the year under consideration was included in the amount offered to tax upon actual receipt in the assessment year 2012-13. He directed the Assessing Officer to verify this position from the assessment order for that year and, subject to such verification, deleted the addition of Rs.5,70,29,675/-.

13.

Concerning interest under section 244A, the assessee contended before the learned CIT(A) that the refund initially granted had subsequently become subject to the consequences of the scrutiny assessment and levy of interest under section 234D. It accordingly disputed the separate addition of the interest income. The learned CIT(A), in paragraph 6.3, observed that the 5

ITA No. 4672/MUM/2026 VIDYAVIHAR CONTAINERS LIMITED adjustment of interest under section 244A against interest levied under section 234D required verification from the record. He directed the Assessing Officer to verify whether the interest received under section 244A had been considered twice in computing income and treated the assessee’s ground as allowed for statistical purposes.

14.

As regards the addition of Rs.1,20,21,000/-, the assessee submitted that the two disputed transactions pertained to flats sold by the developer and had been accounted for by the developer. The assessee explained that, being the owner of the land, it had joined the agreements as a confirming party and its name consequently appeared in the registered documents and the AIR information. It relied upon the development agreement, relevant portions of the sale agreements and a confirmatory letter dated 13.03.2014 issued by GNRC. The assessee further explained that the developer’s confirmation could not be furnished before completion of the assessment.

15.

The matter was referred to the Assessing Officer for examination and a remand report was obtained. In the remand proceedings, the assessee furnished further details and evidence through its letter dated 29.08.2018. The Assessing Officer objected to admission of additional evidence under rule 46A of the Income-tax Rules, 1962, referring to the opportunities afforded during assessment. On examination of the documents, however, he recorded that the assessee was a confirming party and that the transactions had been accounted for by GNRC. He also noted that the developer’s confirmation bore the same date as the assessment order and had been produced subsequently. Relying upon the verification recorded in the remand report, the learned CIT(A), in paragraph 6.4.2, deleted the addition of Rs.1,20,21,000/-.

16.

The learned CIT(A) confirmed the disallowance of Rs.12,59,961/- towards irrecoverable interest written off. He also dismissed as withdrawn the assessee’s additional ground seeking deduction of municipal taxes of 6

ITA No. 4672/MUM/2026 VIDYAVIHAR CONTAINERS LIMITED Rs.55,74,642/-, the assessee having stated that the ground had become infructuous following deletion by the Tribunal of the corresponding addition in the earlier year. The assessee’s appeal was, accordingly, partly allowed.

17.

The Revenue is aggrieved by the relief granted concerning interest on additional consideration, the direction for verification concerning interest under section 244A, and deletion of the addition relating to the two immovable property transactions, and has preferred the present appeal on the grounds reproduced above.

18.

The learned Authorized Representative (AR), with the consent of the Departmental Representative (DR), reiterated the submissions made before the learned CIT(A) and supported the impugned order. Referring to the second supplemental agreement dated 14.07.2005, placed at pages 43 to 49 of the paper book, he submitted that the additional consideration of Rs.25,00,00,000/- was payable upon the occurrence of either of the events specified in clause 2.1 of that agreement. In the event of default in payment on the due date, interest was payable at five per cent per annum above the then prevailing prime lending rate of the State Bank of India, with monthly rests. He submitted that disputes among the partners of GNRC prevented payment. The assessee served a legal notice dated 08.09.2009, placed at pages 69 to 74 of the paper book, and thereafter instituted winding-up proceedings before the Hon’ble Bombay High Court. The petitions were referred to at pages 75 to 124 of the paper book. According to the learned AR, the dispute was ultimately resolved through orders dated 28.04.2011 and 22.06.2011, referred to at pages 134 to 145 of the paper book, and the amount was realized in the financial year 2011-12.

19.

The learned AR submitted that the Assessing Officer had made additions concerning the additional consideration and interest in the assessment year 2009-10 and a further addition towards interest in the assessment year 2010-11. Those additions were deleted by the Tribunal in 7

ITA No. 4672/MUM/2026 VIDYAVIHAR CONTAINERS LIMITED the assessee’s own case (ITA No. 6914 & 6915/Mum/2013). He drew attention particularly to the Tribunal’s finding on interest, reproduced in the material placed before us, which reads: “In short, no real income had accrued to the assessee during the year under appeal under the head ‘interest income’ considering the method of accounting adopted by it. The assessee has offered the entire interest income in AY 2012-13 i.e. the year of actual receipt.” (para 5.2) 20. The learned AR submitted that the same contractual arrangement and dispute underlay the addition of Rs.5,70,29,675/- in the present year. He stated that the assessee had offered the additional consideration and the interest received thereon to tax in the assessment year 2012-13, referring to pages 163 to 172 of the paper book. On that basis, he supported the learned CIT(A)’s direction to verify the assessment record for that year and, subject to verification, delete the addition. These are the assessee’s submissions; the extent to which the amount now in dispute was included in the income assessed for the assessment year 2012-13 remains the subject of the verification directed by the learned CIT(A).

21.

As regards the addition of Rs.1,20,21,000/- arising from the AIR information, the learned AR submitted that the assessee owned the land at Vidyavihar, whereas GNRC developed it and entered into agreements with the purchasers of flats. The assessee joined those agreements as a confirming party, which explained the appearance of its name in the registration information. He referred to the AIR report at pages 173 to 175 and the transaction documents and correspondence at pages 176 to 193 of the paper book. According to him, the two transactions in dispute pertained to the developer and had been accounted for by it. The developer’s confirmatory letter, placed at page 194 of the paper book, was obtained after completion of the assessment and was examined in the remand proceedings.

22.

The learned AR further relied upon the Assessing Officer’s remand report dated 24.09.2018. He pointed out that, upon examining the 8

ITA No. 4672/MUM/2026 VIDYAVIHAR CONTAINERS LIMITED development agreement and the developer’s confirmation, the Assessing Officer recorded that the assessee was a confirming party and that the transactions were accounted for by GNRC. He submitted that the learned CIT(A) had deleted the addition after considering this remand report and that the mere appearance of the assessee’s name in the AIR information did not establish receipt of the sale consideration by it.

23.

With respect to interest of Rs.4,29,427/- under section 244A of the Act, the learned AR submitted that it related to a refund initially granted for the assessment year 2009-10 under section 143(1). According to him, following the scrutiny assessment for that year, interest under section 234D was levied in respect of the refund. He therefore supported the learned CIT(A)’s direction to the Assessing Officer to verify the treatment of the interest under section 244A in the computation and whether the amount had been considered twice.

24.

The learned Departmental Representative, on the other hand, relied upon the assessment order and supported the additions made by the Assessing Officer.

25.

We have considered the rival submissions and examined the assessment order, the impugned appellate order and the material placed before us. Grounds Nos. 1 to 3 concern the addition of Rs.5,70,29,675/- towards interest on additional consideration payable by the developer. Ground No. 4 concerns interest of Rs.4,29,427/- under section 244A of the Act. Ground No. 5 challenges deletion of Rs.1,20,21,000/- relating to two transactions reported in the AIR information. We proceed to adjudicate these issues separately.

26.

In relation to grounds Nos. 1 to 3, the controversy concerns the year of taxability of interest arising from the development arrangement with GNRC. The additional consideration of Rs.25,00,00,000/- and the interest

ITA No. 4672/MUM/2026 VIDYAVIHAR CONTAINERS LIMITED payable upon default emanate from the development agreement and the second supplemental agreement dated 14.07.2005. The Assessing Officer brought the interest to tax principally because the assessee followed the mercantile system of accounting and, according to him, its contractual entitlement had accrued notwithstanding non-payment and the pending litigation.

27.

Section 5 of the Act includes within the total income of a resident income received or accruing or arising during the relevant previous year, subject to the other provisions of the Act. Section 145(1), as applicable to the assessment year under consideration, provides for computation of business income and income from other sources in accordance with the cash or mercantile system regularly employed by the assessee. These provisions require examination of whether income has accrued in the relevant year. The adoption of the mercantile system does not, by itself, answer whether a particular disputed receipt represents income which has really accrued. Equally, mere non-receipt does not postpone taxation where income has already accrued. The contractual provisions and the circumstances affecting accrual must therefore be considered together.

28.

In the present case, the treatment of the same additional consideration and interest has already been examined by the co-ordinate Bench in the assessee’s own case for the assessment years 2009-10 and 2010-11. The order dated 23.06.2017 disposed of the cross appeals bearing ITA Nos. 6914, 6915, 7029 and 7030/Mum/2013. Paragraphs 5.1 and 5.2, as reproduced in the material furnished by the assessee, read as follows: “5.1. From the above, it is clear that payment of Rs. 25 crores was to be made by the developer to the assessee on occurrence of either of the two events. The Hon’ble Bombay High Court passed order on 20.11.2006, therefore the income could have been taxed in the A. Y. 2007 – 08. The assessee received additional consideration and the interest in the A. Y. 2012 -13 and offered the same in that year. The AO while completing the assessment order u/s. 143(3) of the Act substantively taxed the additional compensation for the AY 2012-13. At that time 10

ITA No. 4672/MUM/2026 VIDYAVIHAR CONTAINERS LIMITED he was aware of the fact that same amount was assessed in the earlier year. Even then he did not pass a protective assessment. Coming to the facts of the case, it is found that in the year under appeal there was order of the Revenue Minister. But, order of the Minister was not one of the condition of the agreement. The assessee had challenged the valuation adopted by the Revenue Authorities and as per the provisions of law assessee challenged the valuation. In our opinion, the order of the Revenue Minister cannot be the deciding factor for determining the year of assessment in which disputed amount could be taxed. Therefore, we hold that the FAA was not justified in taxing the additional consideration of Rs. 25 crores in the year under consideration. Reversing his order, we decide the first part of the first ground of appeal in favour of the assessee. 5.2. As far as interest portion is concerned, we find that the assessee was consistently following a particular method of accounting and same had not been rejected by the AO. It has shown interest income in the year of receipt. Here, we would like to mention that the ‘computation of total income’, u/s. 5 of the Act has to be made of real income and not of any hypothetical income. In short, no real income had accrued to the assessee during the year under appeal under the head ‘interest income’ considering the method of accounting adopted by it. The assessee has offered the entire interest income in AY 2012-13 i.e. the year of actual receipt. Considering the peculiar facts and circumstances of the case, we decide second part of the first ground of appeal in favour of the assessee. In short, first ground of appeal is allowed.” 29. While deciding the corresponding issue for the assessment year 2010- 11, the co-ordinate Bench followed its finding in paragraph 5.2. Paragraph 7, as reproduced in the impugned appellate order, reads: “7. First ground of the appeal filed by the assesse, is about addition made by the AO under the head interest accrued to it during the year under appeal. He made an addition of Rs. 4.69 crores, to total income of the assesse, as he was of the opinion that the assesse was entitled to the interest, amounting to Rs. 4.69 crores, from GNRC. Following our order for the earlier AY (paragraph 5.2), we decide the first ground in favour of the assesse.” 30. The earlier decision thus specifically addresses interest arising from this development arrangement. It does not merely decide the taxability of the principal consideration. The co-ordinate Bench considered the accounting treatment, the surrounding circumstances and the subsequent offer of the entire interest income to tax in the assessment year 2012-13. Its conclusion concerning interest was expressly applied to the succeeding assessment year as well.

ITA No. 4672/MUM/2026 VIDYAVIHAR CONTAINERS LIMITED 31. The material now placed before us shows continuation of the same dispute during the previous year relevant to the present appeal. The assessee had issued a legal notice dated 08.09.2009 and instituted winding-up proceedings against the partners of GNRC. The settlement and realization relied upon by the assessee followed the orders dated 28.04.2011 and 22.06.2011, both subsequent to the close of the relevant previous year on 31.03.2011. The Revenue has not identified any intervening event during the relevant previous year which distinguishes the present interest claim from the interest considered by the co-ordinate Bench. Reliance upon the mercantile system, without addressing the earlier determination concerning this very arrangement, does not furnish sufficient reason to depart from that decision.

32.

The applicable principle also finds support in CIT v. Excel Industries Ltd. [2013] 358 ITR 295 (SC). In paragraph 20, the Hon’ble Supreme Court observed: “income accrues when it becomes due but it must also be accompanied by a corresponding liability of the other party” 33. The judgment requires accrual to be examined realistically, including the probability of realization. It also recognizes the significance of a consistent view where the same fundamental circumstances continue across assessment years. Its application here is confined to those principles. We do not understand it as permitting every unpaid contractual claim to escape taxation until receipt. Our conclusion rests upon the earlier adjudication of this particular arrangement and the absence of any material distinction for the year before us.

34.

We also clarify that acceptance of the books of account is not, by itself, conclusive of the correct tax treatment of every item. An adjustment required by the Act may be made notwithstanding the accounting entries. However, the addition in the present case must be considered in the light of the co-

ITA No. 4672/MUM/2026 VIDYAVIHAR CONTAINERS LIMITED ordinate Bench’s specific determination concerning accrual of this interest. The subsequently notified Income Computation and Disclosure Standards do not alter the position for this year, since Notification No.87/2016 dated 29.09.2016 applies to the assessment year 2017-18 and subsequent assessment years.

35.

The learned CIT(A) has followed the earlier Tribunal decision and directed verification of the assessee’s statement that the interest presently in dispute was included in the income offered to tax in the assessment year 2012-13. Taxation in a later year does not, standing alone, establish that an amount was not taxable in an earlier year. Here, however, the direction accompanies a conclusion supported by the earlier decision concerning the same interest stream. The verification ensures that the assessee’s factual statement concerning the inclusion of the disputed amount is correct.

36.

Accordingly, we uphold the relief granted in respect of Rs.5,70,29,675/-, subject to the verification expressly directed by the learned CIT(A). Such verification shall remain confined to identifying the interest component and reconciling it with the return, computation and assessment record for the assessment year 2012-13. It shall not become an occasion for reconsidering the issue of accrual contrary to the findings recorded above. The assessee shall furnish the necessary reconciliation and supporting particulars. Grounds Nos. 1 to 3 are dismissed.

37.

We next consider ground No. 4 concerning interest of Rs.4,29,427/- under section 244A. The assessee’s submission is that interest initially granted with the refund for the assessment year 2009-10 was affected by the subsequent scrutiny assessment and levy of interest under section 234D. The learned CIT(A) directed verification of whether the section 244A interest had been considered twice in computing income. His order also refers to adjustment against interest under section 234D. These observations require the following clarification. 13

ITA No. 4672/MUM/2026 VIDYAVIHAR CONTAINERS LIMITED 38. Interest under section 244A represents a statutory entitlement arising in connection with a refund. Adjustment of the refund against another outstanding demand does not, merely because payment is effected through adjustment, render the interest non-taxable. Nor does the possibility of subsequent variation postpone its taxation until all proceedings attain finality. In Avada Trading Co. (P.) Ltd. v. ACIT [2006] 100 ITD 131 (Mumbai) (SB), the Special Bench held that interest under section 244A is assessable in the year in which it is granted. It also explained the consequence of its subsequent reduction. The relevant extract from paragraph 14 reads: “the interest granted in earlier year gets substituted and it is the reduced amount of interest that would form part of income of that year.” 39. Thus, the original grant and any subsequent statutory reduction must both be taken into account in determining the correct taxable amount.

40.

Section 244A(3) expressly provides for increase or reduction of interest consequent upon the orders specified therein. Section 234D, on the other hand, provides for interest payable by the assessee where the refund granted under section 143(1) exceeds the refund due on regular assessment, or no refund is then due. The levy of interest under section 234D is therefore distinct from a reduction or withdrawal of interest under section 244A(3). The former does not, by itself, establish the latter. Neither provision authorizes an automatic netting of the two amounts for determining taxable interest income.

41.

In these circumstances, the limited verification directed by the learned CIT(A) is warranted. The Assessing Officer shall examine the original intimation granting the interest, the subsequent assessment or rectification orders, any consequential reduction or withdrawal under section 244A(3), and the treatment already accorded to the amount in computing income. Interest which remained granted and was not otherwise included in taxable

ITA No. 4672/MUM/2026 VIDYAVIHAR CONTAINERS LIMITED income shall be brought to tax once in the appropriate year. Conversely, an amount already included shall not be added again, and an actual statutory reduction or withdrawal shall receive the corresponding effect in accordance with law. Mere adjustment of the refund against a demand, or levy of section 234D interest, shall not justify deletion.

42.

We therefore sustain the learned CIT(A)’s direction for verification, read in the limited manner explained above. We do not approve any proposition that interest under section 244A must automatically be reduced by interest charged under section 234D. The direction is for ascertainment of the correct taxable amount from the existing record, after affording the assessee a reasonable opportunity of being heard. With this clarification, ground No. 4 is dismissed.

43.

Ground No. 5 concerns deletion of Rs.1,20,21,000/-, comprising transactions of Rs.60,21,000/- and Rs.60,00,000/- reported in the AIR information. The assessment addition arose because the assessee could not furnish the requisite reconciliation for those two transactions before completion of the assessment. Before the learned CIT(A), the assessee explained that the transactions belonged to GNRC and that its own name appeared in the registered agreements because it continued to own the land and had joined as a confirming party.

44.

The explanation was supported by the development agreement and the developer’s confirmatory letter dated 13.03.2014. These documents were referred to the Assessing Officer, who examined them in the remand proceedings. The material findings in paragraphs 4.3 and 4.4 of the remand report, as reproduced in the supplied submissions, are as follows: “4.3 Also, the assessee has submitted confirmatory letter dated 13.03.2014 from the developer i. e. Gammon Neelkanth Realty Corporation, subsequent to the assessment In this letter, the developer has confirmed that the above mentioned transactions of 2 properties have duly been accounted for by them i.e. The Developer Gammon Neelkanth Realty Corporation. 15

ITA No. 4672/MUM/2026 VIDYAVIHAR CONTAINERS LIMITED 4.4 On perusal from the submission, it is noticed that the assessee has produced Copy of development agreement (dated 24th June 2005 Gammon Neelkanth Realty Corporation and the assessee. On perusal from para 5.1 and 5.2 of the agreement copy, it is noticed that the assessee is only a "confirming party" and all the transactions are taken account in the Developer i.e. Gammon Neelkanth Realty Corporation. However, no such details were submitted by the assessee during the assessment proceedings and the assessee, had shown its inability to produce details in respect of the above mentioned 2 properties amounting to Rs.1,20,21,000/-. On verification of the said letter, it is noticed that the same was issued on 13.03.2014 and the assessment order was passed on 13.03.2014.” 45. The remand report thus records two material matters. First, the assessee’s participation in the agreements was as a confirming party. Secondly, the developer confirmed that the disputed transactions were accounted for by it. The Assessing Officer noted the belated production of the documents, but his factual examination did not disprove the explanation concerning ownership of the sale receipts. The learned CIT(A) consequently decided the issue upon a fuller evidentiary record than that available when the assessment was completed.

46.

AIR information is relevant material for enquiry and reconciliation. Nevertheless, the appearance of a person’s name in registration information does not dispense with examination of the capacity in which that person executed the document or the person to whom the consideration belonged. For an addition in the assessee’s hands, the information must be connected with income received by or accruing to the assessee. Here, the explanation concerning the assessee’s role was supported by the documents examined in remand. The original absence of reconciliation cannot remain conclusive after that examination has supplied the explanation for the reported entries.

47.

We also distinguish the assessee’s entitlement to consideration under its development agreement from the developer’s receipts on sale of flats belonging to its share. The mere fact that the assessee owned the underlying land does not establish that every sale receipt reported against a document bearing its name constituted its income. The specific transactions and the

ITA No. 4672/MUM/2026 VIDYAVIHAR CONTAINERS LIMITED contractual allocation of their consideration must govern the enquiry. On the findings recorded in the remand report, the two disputed transactions were accounted for by GNRC. No contrary material has been identified before us to establish that the aggregate sale consideration of Rs.1,20,21,000/- represented income of the assessee.

48.

The Revenue’s ground reiterates the failure to reconcile the AIR information during assessment, but does not dislodge the subsequent verification upon which the learned CIT(A) acted. This is not a case of deletion merely on an unsupported denial by the assessee. The Assessing Officer had an opportunity to examine the supporting documents and furnished his report. On the merits of the addition challenged before us, we find no infirmity in the learned CIT(A)’s conclusion. Deletion of Rs.1,20,21,000/- is upheld and ground No. 5 is dismissed.

49.

Ground No. 6 is general in nature and calls for no separate adjudication. The limited verifications concerning developer interest and section 244A interest shall be carried out strictly within the scope explained above. The other matters decided by the learned CIT(A), which do not form the subject matter of the Revenue’s grounds, require no adjudication in this appeal.

50.

In the result, the appeal filed by the Revenue is dismissed, in the terms recorded above. Order pronounced in the open court on 27-10-2026.

Sd/- Sd/- SAKTIJIT DEY MAKARAND VASANT MAHADEOKAR VICE PRESIDENT ACCOUNTANT MEMBER Mumbai Dated: 27-10-2026 Tarun Kushwaha Sr. P.S. 17

ITA No. 4672/MUM/2026 VIDYAVIHAR CONTAINERS LIMITED

Copy to: DY. COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX CIRCLE-3(3)(1),MUMBAI, 522, 5TH FLOOR, AAYAKAR BHAWAN 1 , MK ROAD MUMBAI-400020, MUMBAI-400020, MAHARASHTRA VIDYAVIHAR CONTAINERS LIMITED, 2 BAJAJ BHAWAN 226, NARIMAN POINT, MUMBAI, MUMBAI-400021, MAHARASHTRA 3 THE PCIT / CIT, 4 THE D.R., ITAT, MUMBAI BENCH 5 GUARD FILE

More judgments on Section 5

All 1,101 judgments and leading authorities on Section 5 →

Recent GST High Court judgments

Search GST case law →