DY. COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX, CENTRAL CIRCLE-3(3), MUMBAI, MUMBAI vs. KALPATARU PROJECTS INTERNATIONAL LIMITED, GUJARAT
What did the Tribunal hold?
The Tribunal held that for the issue of CER receipts, it would follow the lead case of AY 2021-22. Regarding the disallowance for purchases from Parchalit Infra and Infomedia Pvt. Ltd., the Tribunal noted that the assessee's grounds related to denial of opportunity for cross-examination and independent inquiry, and that the AO/DRP erred in not providing documents. The Tribunal restored the issue to the AO for fresh adjudication after providing the assessee with an opportunity for cross-examination and furnishing relevant documents. On the issue of adjustments based on Section 143(1) intimation, the Tribunal noted that the assessee's grounds were not adjudicated upon by the ITAT in the provided extract. For transfer pricing adjustments, the Tribunal restored the issue of corporate guarantee for AY 2021-22 to the TPO for re-adjudication based on directions regarding internal CUP. For the disallowance under Section 14A, the Tribunal, following its decision for AY 2018-19, restricted the disallowance to the exempt dividend income of Rs.7,96,65,060, after allowing credit for the assessee's suo motu disallowance of Rs.34,50,921, resulting in a further disallowance of Rs.7,62,14,139. The CIT(A)'s order was modified to this extent, and the Revenue's ground was partly allowed.
What were the facts?
The assessee, M/s Kalpataru Projects International Limited, and the Revenue are in cross-appeals before the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT) for Assessment Years (AY) 2018-19 and 2020-21, challenging orders dated November 29, 2025, passed by the CIT(A)-56, Mumbai. The assessee also appeals for AY 2021-22 against a final assessment order dated October 24, 2024, passed by the DCIT, Central Circle-3(3), pursuant to a DRP order. The appeals were heard together, with AY 2021-22 taken as the lead case. The disputes arise from identical facts and circumstances. The assessee's grounds for AY 2021-22 include treating Certified Emission Receipts (CER) as revenue, disallowing purchases from Parchalit Infra and Infomedia Pvt. Ltd., adjustments to intimation under section 143(1), and transfer pricing additions related to marketing support services and interest on advances. The Revenue's grounds include disallowance under section 14A.
What were the issues?
1. Whether the receipt on account of Certified Emission Receipts (CER) is a revenue receipt or a capital receipt, and if taxable, whether it is taxable under Section 115BBG, as argued by the assessee that it is a capital receipt not included in the definition of 'income' under Section 2(24). 2. Whether the addition of Rs.3,21,01,311 on account of alleged bogus purchases from Parchalit Infra and Infomedia Pvt. Ltd. is justified, with the assessee contending that services were provided and payments are allowable expenses, while the Revenue/DRP/AO held otherwise, invoking Section 69C and denying an independent inquiry and cross-examination. 3. Whether the AO and DRP erred in considering income determined in intimation u/s 143(1) instead of returned income for additions under Section 143(3) r.w.s. 144C, as argued by the assessee, who also contended that the CPC is not an 'Assessing Officer' for Section 144C(1). 4. Whether the assessee is eligible for deduction under Section 80M and credit for tax paid under Section 115QA and TCS credit, as claimed by the assessee, which were allegedly not dealt with by the AO/DRP. 5. Whether the transfer pricing adjustment of Rs.83,97,611 on marketing support service fees paid to an AE is justified, with the assessee arguing against the TPO's ad-hoc rate and rejection of its TP study, and the Revenue supporting the TPO's findings. 6. Whether the adjustment of Rs. 26,64,076 on account of notional interest on advances to KP Mauritius is justified, with the assessee arguing the advances are quasi-equity and no interest is chargeable, while the TPO/DRP computed interest at 5.87%. 7. Whether the disallowance under Section 14A read with Rule 8D is justified, with the assessee having suo motu disallowed Rs.34,50,921 and the AO making a further disallowance of Rs.7,21,88,079, which the CIT(A) deleted, holding the assessee's disallowance to be reasonable.
Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?
Section 115BBG,Section 2(24),Section 69C,Section 143(1),Section 143(3),Section 144C,Section 80M,Section 115QA,Section 14A
AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below
Income Tax Appellate Tribunal, MUMBAI BENCH “K” MUMBAI
Before: SHRI OM PRAKASH KANT & SHRI ANIKESH BANERJEE
PER OM PRAKASH KANT, AM
The captioned cross-appeals of the assessee and Revenue for AY 2018-19 and AY 2020-21 respectively are directed against two separate orders, both dated 29th November 2025, passed by the learned Commissioner of Income-tax (Appeals)-56, Mumbai, [in short ‘the Ld.CIT(A)]. The appeal for assessment year 2021-22 by the assessee is directed against final assessment order dated 24th October 2024, passed by the learned Deputy Commissioner of Income-tax, Central Circle-3(3), pursuant to the order passed by the learned Dispute Resolution Panel (DRP) for AY 2021-22.
The grounds raised in these appeals are arising from identical facts and circumstances and having common disputes and therefore these appeals were heard together and disposed off by way of this consolidated order for the sake of the convenience. Both parties agreed to take the AY 2021-22 as lead case for adjudication and follow the same mutasis mutandis.
ITA 6717/MUM/2024 3 ITA 744, 745, 985,986/MUM/2026 M/s Kalpataru Projects International Ltd.
Accordingly, firstly, we take up the appeal of the assessee for AY 2021-22. The grounds raised by the assessee are reproduced as under:
Regular Additions: Carbon Credit - Rs.1,80,25,785 1. The learned AO and learned DRP erred in law and in facts in treating receipt on account of Certified Emission Receipts (CER) as revenue receipt instead of capital receipt and thereby making an addition of Rs. 1,80,25,785 to business income. 2. The learned AO and the learned DRP erred in law and in facts in treating receipt on account of Certified Emission Receipts (CER) as taxable u/s 115BBG of the Act despite the fact that such capital receipt is not subject to tax in absence of its inclusion in definition of 'income' u/s 2(24) of the Act. Disallowance of Rs.3,21,01,311 on account of Bogus Purchases 3 The learned AO and the learned DRP erred in law and in fact in making an addition of Rs.3,21,01,311 in respect of payment made to Parchalit Infra and Infomedia Pvt. Ltd by invoking provision of section 69C of the Act by incorrectly holding that no services has been provided by such party. 4. The learned AO and DRP erred in law and in fact in making the addition by holding that no services have been provided by the said party to the Appellant. 5. The learned AO and the learned DRP erred in law and in fact in making such addition without conducting an independent inquiry, denying the opportunity of Cross examination and without providing the copy of reports, documents, enquiry reports etc. if any received from the GST department thus denying proper opportunity of being heard in the matter. 6. The learned AO and the learned DRP erred in law and in facts in not considering the evidences and explanations submitted by the Appellant which beyond doubt establish that Parchalit Infra and Infomedia Pvt Ltd has actually provided the services to the Appellant and the payments are allowable as business expenses. 7. The learned AO and the learned DRP erred in law and in facts in invoking the provisions of section 69C of the Act when the Appellant has duly justified the source of expenditure being payment through banking channel for the purchase of services from Parchalit Infra and Infomedia Pvt Ltd.
ITA 6717/MUM/2024 4 ITA 744, 745, 985,986/MUM/2026 M/s Kalpataru Projects International Ltd.
Adjustments/Variations made in intimation u/s 143(1) and not dealt in the Assessment Order and DRP order 8. The learned AO and the learned DRP erred in law and in facts in considering income determined in intimation u/s 143(1) of the Act instead of returned income for the purpose of making additions while passing assessment order u/s 143(3) r.w.s. 144C of the Act. 9. The learned DRP and consequently the learned AO erred in fact and in law in completely ignoring the submission of the Appellant for not making adjustment(s) as made in intimation issued u/s 143(1) of the Act by concluding that the Deputy Commissioner of Income-tax, Centralized Processing Centre ('CPC'), who made adjustments in intimation u/s 143(1) of the Act, is not an 'Assessing Officer' for the purpose of section 144C(1) of the Act. 10. The learned AO and the learned DRP erred in facts and in law in not dealing with the Appellant's plea of granting deduction of Rs. 26,94,86,945 u/s 80M of the Act despite the fact that the Appellant has fulfilled all the necessary conditions for claiming such deduction. 11. The learned AO and the learned DRP erred in facts and in law in not dealing with the Appellant's plea of granting credit of tax paid of Rs.33,01,90,730 in respect of buy back of shares u/s. 115QA of the Act (despite the fact that such taxes were duly paid within time permitted under provisions of section 115QA of the Act and the evidences of payment of tax was duly filed with the AO/DRP). 12. The learned AO and the learned DRP erred in facts and in law in not dealing with the Appellant plea of granting credit of TCS credit to the extent of Rs. 41,014 though same is duly reflected in the Form 26AS for the year under consideration in respect of Siemens Limited. Transfer Pricing Additions: Marketing support service fees paid to Kalpataru Power Transmission USA Inc. 13. The learned TPO and consequently, the leamed AO and the learned DRP Bench erred in law in making an adjustment to the marketing support service fees paid to the AE-Kalpataru Power Transmission US wholly owned subsidiary of the Appellant in USA, hereinafter referred to as "KP USA") and thereby making an addition of Rs.83,97,611. 14. Appellant. The learned TPO and consequently the learned AO and the learned DRP erred in fact and in law in making the addition of Rs. 83,97,611 to the value of Marketing support service charges paid by the Appellant to KP USA, by applying an ad-hoc 2% arm's length rate of success fees payable, instead of 3% of the order value paid by the Appellant.
ITA 6717/MUM/2024 5 ITA 744, 745, 985,986/MUM/2026 M/s Kalpataru Projects International Ltd.
The learned TPO and the learned DRP erred in fact and in law in making the addition by rejecting the TP Study submitted by the Appellant. 16. The learned TPO and the DRP erred in fact and in law in rejecting the TP study by holding that the comparable data is incorrect/ unreliable without verifying or reviewing the detailed survey methodology submitted by the Appellant. 17. The learned TPO and the DRP erred in fact and in law in making the addition without brining on record any alternate study and by applying an adhoc rate of 2% as arm's length price. 18. The learned DRP Bench erred in not referring the Appellant's own case in earlier years for the same matter, wherein the Hon'ble ITAT deleted the addition made by the AO on similar grounds. Adjustment on account of interest on advances granted to KP Mauritius 19. The learned TPO and consequently the learned AO and the learned DRP Bench erred in law by making adjustment of Rs. 26,64,076 on account of notional interest on the advances granted to KP Mauritius. 20. The learned TPO/DRP erred in rejecting Appellant's contention that such advance granted to its wholly owned subsidiary is in the nature of Quasi-Equity Capital. 21. The learned TPO/DRP erred in fact and in law in computing the rate of interest to be charged on loan at 5.87% instead of the claim of the Appellant that no interest is required to be charged as the transaction is in the nature of Quasi - Equity capital. 22. The learned TPO erred in loading 100 basis points (or 1%) on the comparable USD denominated interest rate arrived at by the TPO from Loan Connector database, alleging the fluctuation in USD and INR. However, the TPO has not taken cognizance of the fact that the interest rate determined is itself denominated in the USD, and hence does not warrant any further adjustment on account of currency. 23. Without prejudice to Grounds Nos. 19 to 22, the Appellant contends that the maximum interest rate to be charged should be restricted to LIBOR, and no further spread should be added for computation of arm's length interest to be charged from a subsidiary. Adjustment on account of interest on trade advances to KP Ukraine 24. The learned TPO and consequently the learned AO and the learned DRP Bench erred in law by making an adjustment of Rs. 9,05,548 on account of notional interest at the rate of 3.37% on the trade advances given to Kalpataru Power Transmission Ukraine LLC ("KP Ukraine").
ITA 6717/MUM/2024 6 ITA 744, 745, 985,986/MUM/2026 M/s Kalpataru Projects International Ltd.
The learned TPO and consequently the learned AO and the learned DRP Bench erred in treating outstanding trade advance as a separate international transaction and failed to appreciate that the amount receivable from KP Ukraine pertains to trade advance (and not loan) for furtherance of AE's business under nonnal business circumstances. 26. Without prejudice to the grounds nos. 24 to 25, the learned TPO erred in loading 100 basis points (or 1%) on the comparable USD-denominated interest rate arrived at by the TPO from Loan Connector database, alleging the fluctuation in USD and INR. However, the TPO has not taken cognizance of the fact that the interest rate determined is itself denominated in the USD. Adjustment towards the Corporate Guarantee Commission received 27. The learned TPO and subsequently the AO and the learned DRP erred in making an upward adjustment of Rs. 2,25,65,337 to the ALP of Corporate Guarantee Commission charged by the Appellant from its subsidiaries Kalpataru Power Transmission Sweden AB ("KP Sweden") and Kalpataru IBN Omairah Company Ltd ("KP IBN") by applying 1.50% as arm's length rate of commission instead of 0.4% as charged by the Appellant. 28. The learned TPO disregarded the benchmarking exercise conducted by the Appellant in the TP documentation by stating that the Deed of Indemnity pertained to FY 2019-20 and not to FY 2020-21, however the TPO did not take cognizance of the fact that the Guarantee arrangements were itself entered with AEs during FY 2019-20. 29. The learned TPO disregarded various contracts and supporting evidence submitted by the Appellant during the course of TP assessment proceedings and erred in stating that the Appellant failed to provide the documentary evidence. 30. The learned TPO has not dealt with the transaction of guarantee provided to KP IBN and accordingly, no addition is warranted in that respect. The guarantee commission of 0.5% charged from KP IBN ought to be considered at arm's length. 31. Without prejudice to the above ground, the TPO has made addition for guarantee commission in case of KP IBN for an entire year, despite the guarantee being applicable from December 2021. Others 32, The learned AO has erred in law and in facts in determining long term capital gain at Rs. 96,16,53,158 instead of Rs. 69,15,63,531 in the computation sheet annexed to the Assessment order. It is submitted that there is no discussion/ adjustment in Assessment order or in directions issued by the learned DRP in connection with capital gains and thereby no such adjustment can be made in this regard. It be so held now.
ITA 6717/MUM/2024 7 ITA 744, 745, 985,986/MUM/2026 M/s Kalpataru Projects International Ltd.
The learned AO has erred in law and in facts in computing interest u/s 234A of the Act at Rs. 71,00,916. It is submitted that the Appellant had filed its return of income on March 9, 2022 which was within the extended due date of filing the return of income of March 15, 2022. Thereby such interest u/s 234A of the Act shall not be applicable in the Appellant's case. It be so held now. 34. The learned AO has erred in law and in facts by computing interest u/s 234C amounting to Rs. 1,25,47,112 as against Rs. 94,44,813 as computed by the Appellant while filing its return of Income. It is submitted that interest u/s 234C of the Act is computed with reference to the returned income and not based upon the assessed income and thereby the same shall be restricted to Rs. 94,44,813. It be so held now. Your appellant prays for leave to add, alter and/or to amend any of the grounds before the final hearing of the appeal.” 4. Briefly stated facts of the case are that the assessee company is engaged in the business of design, manufacturing & erection and commissioning of power transmission lines in India and outside India. The assessee filed return of income for the year under consideration on 19/03/2022, declaring total income of Rs 7,78,75,97,150/-. The return was processed under section 143(1) of the Income-tax Act, 1961 (in short ‘the Act’) determining the total income at Rs 805,70,84,110/-. Thereafter, the return of income was selected for scrutiny and statutory notices under the Act were issued and served upon the assessee. During assessment proceedings, the Assessing Officer noted that assessee was also engaged in business of generation of electricity by using agriculture waste being mustard husk, cotton sticks and other agriculture crop residue. Further, the ld Assessing Officer noted the international transactions carried out by the assessee with its Associated Enterprises (AEs) and accordingly, referred the matter of the determination of the arm's
ITA 6717/MUM/2024 8 ITA 744, 745, 985,986/MUM/2026 M/s Kalpataru Projects International Ltd.
length price of those international transactions to the learned Transfer Pricing Officer (TPO) after obtaining prior approval from the Principal Commissioner of the Income-tax (PCIT). The learned TPO, proposed transfer pricing adjustment of Rs 2,69,74,672/- having details as under:
Sr. No. Particulars Amount (Rs.) 1 Services availed by the assessee Rs. 83,97,611/- 2 Interest free loans & advances Rs. 26,64,076/- 3 Trade advance Rs. 9,05,548/- 4 Corporate guarantee Rs. 2,25,65,337/- 5 Total Adjustment Rs. 2,69,74,672/- 4.1 Considering the order of the learned TPO proposing adjustment to the international transactions, the Assessing Officer passed a draft assessment order, wherein he proposed (i) transfer pricing adjustment of Rs. 2,69,74,672/- ; (ii) addition of Rs1,80,25,785/- of considering the ‘Certified Emission Receipts (CER)’ as revenue in nature liable to be taxed under the provision of section 115BBG of the Act; and (iii) addition of Rs.3,21,01,311/- under section 69C of the Act towards bogus purchases. Aggrieved, the assessee approached to learned Dispute Resolution Panel (DRP) and filed objections against the proposed additions / adjustment. The learned DRP issued directions to the Assessing Officer vide their order dated 29/09/2024, pursuant to which, the learned Assessing Officer passed the impugned final assessment order after making addition of Rs: 2,69,74,672/- for transfer pricing adjustment; addition of Rs:1,80,25,785/- on account of the CER held as revenue receipt and
ITA 6717/MUM/2024 9 ITA 744, 745, 985,986/MUM/2026 M/s Kalpataru Projects International Ltd.
addition on account of the bogus purchases under section 69C amounting to Rs.3,21,01,311/- and added to the income computed under order section 143(1) of the Act and finally assessed the income at Rs 8,13,41,85,880/-.
Before us the learned counsel for the assessee filed a paper book containing pages from 1 to 841.
Taxability of the Certified Emissions Receipt (CER)
Grounds Nos. 1 to 2 of this appeal raise a common question as to whether the sum of Rs. 1,80,25,785/- received by the assessee on account of Certified Emission Reduction ("CER") credits generated at its biomass-based power plants, is chargeable to tax as a revenue receipt under Section 2(24)(xviii) read with Section 115BBG of the Act, or is, as contended by the assessee, a capital receipt falling outside the charge altogether. 6.1 The facts in brief qua the issue in dispute are that the assessee operates two biomass-based power generation plants, using agricultural waste in place of fossil fuel, situated at ‘Padampur’ and at ‘Tonk’, Rajasthan. The ‘Padampur’ plant commenced power generation in financial year 2002-03 and was registered with the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change ("UNFCCC") with effect from 23.05.2005, under the sponsorship of the Kingdom of the Netherlands, acting through ‘SenterNovem’. The
ITA 6717/MUM/2024 10 ITA 744, 745, 985,986/MUM/2026 M/s Kalpataru Projects International Ltd.
‘Tonk’ plant commenced power generation on 10.11.2006 and was registered with UNFCCC with effect from 07.10.2008, under the sponsorship of the Republic of Germany, acting through ‘AtmosfairGmbH’.
6.2 Both plants operate under the Clean Development Mechanism ("CDM") of the Kyoto Protocol to the UNFCCC, which is the only mechanism of the Protocol available to a developing country such as India. The other two mechanisms (joint implementation and international emissions trading) are confined to parties inter-se. mentioned in Annexure-1 of Kyoto Protocol. Under the CDM, a developing-country project that demonstrably reduces greenhouse gas ("GHG") emissions, by substituting biomass for fossil fuel becomes eligible for earning CERs, each representing a verified reduction of one tonne of carbon dioxide equivalent, which the sponsoring Annexure-1 country may set off against its own binding emission-reduction target under the Protocol.
6.3 During the year under consideration, the assessee credited to its profit and loss account a sum of Rs. Rs. 1,80,25,785/- on account of CER receipts from the ‘Tonk’ plant, and claimed corresponding expenditure incurred in earning the same. While computing total income, the assessee reduced the entire CER credit from its business income, treating the receipt as a capital receipt in the nature of a
ITA 6717/MUM/2024 11 ITA 744, 745, 985,986/MUM/2026 M/s Kalpataru Projects International Ltd.
subsidy or grant, and correspondingly added back the claimed expenditure.
6.4 The ld AO called upon the assessee under Section 142(1) to explain the details of receipt. The assessee filed a detailed response setting out background of the Kyoto Protocol and CDM mechanism and placed reliance on the orders of the Ahmedabad Bench of this Tribunal in its own case for Assessment Years 2010-11 and 2011-12, which had held the identical receipt to be capital in nature following the decisions of the Hon'ble Gujarat High Court in PCIT v. Alembic Ltd., Income-Tax Appeal Nos. 553 & 554 of 2017, and Gujarat Fluorochemicals Ltd. v. DCIT, ITA No. 805/Ahd/2017.
6.5 The ld AO in his order, firstly, described brief background and source of CERs entitlement (or ‘carbon credit’, as popularly known) in paragraph 5.1 as under:
"A carbon credit is a generic term for any tradable certificate or permit representing the right to emit one tonne of carbon dioxide or the mass of another green house gases (GHG in short) (with a carbon dioxide equivalent (CO2e)), equivalent to one tonne of carbon dioxide." The Collins English Dictionary also defines a carbon credit as "a certificate showing that a Government or company has paid to have a certain amount of carbon dioxide removed from the environment". The "Investopedia Inc. investment dictionary" defines a carbon credit as a "permit that allows the holder to emit one tonne of carbon dioxide". Such permits (or CERs) "can be traded in the international market at their current market price". Certain industries, especially in power, cement, steel, textile, fertilizer sectors rely on fossil fuels (coal, electricity derived from coal, natural gas and oil). The burning of fossil fuels is a major source of GHG emissions. The major green house gases emitted by these industries are carbon dioxide, methane, nitrous oxide, hydro-floro carbon (HFCs), etc., all of which increase the atmosphere's ability to trap infra-red energy and, thus, affect the climate. Under the UN umbrella about 170 countries signed "KYOTO PROTOCOL" under which a cap was put on such carbon and GHGs emissions. Total amount of GHGs emission in the atmosphere by all the countries in a year was fixed and
ITA 6717/MUM/2024 12 ITA 744, 745, 985,986/MUM/2026 M/s Kalpataru Projects International Ltd.
equivalent number of CERS was worked out and distributed among the member countries. The member countries, in turn, distributed or assigned these certificates among the designated industries in their country. An industry in power sector would become entitled to these certificates. If they used fossil fuel they would have to restrict the GHG emission to the level as per CER assigned to them. If instead of fossil fuel they used alternate source of fuel such as bio-mass they would be able to save CERs which could be sold in the international market. They were purchased by those industries where due to excessive use of fossil fuel the allotted CERs were exhausted and they still required more CERs to continue to maintain production. The CERs are also tradable at Stock Exchange. In brief, the carbon credits are CERs, which give permission to emit assigned amount of GHGs. The CERs are consumed to the extent the carbon gases (or GHG) are emitted in the atmosphere by consuming fossil fuel. 6.6 Thereafter, the ld AO rejected the assessee's claim and held the receipt to be a revenue receipt, for the following reasons:
Attributes of goods: The CERs possess utility, are (a) capable of being bought and sold, and are capable of being possessed, transferred, and delivered, attributes which, in the AO's view, bring them within the characterisation of "goods”. The Assessing Officer further compared the CERs with transferable replenishment license (TRP) which have been held as goods by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in various cases. The Assessing Officer relied on the judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Tata Consultancy Services v. State of A.P. [2004] 271 ITR 401 (SC) and Vikas Sales Corporation v. CTO (1996) 102 STC 106 (SC), wherein the freely transferable replenishment licenses were held to be goods, and therefore the income generated from their sale was in the nature of revenue receipt. Relevant finding of AO is reproduced as under:
ITA 6717/MUM/2024 13 ITA 744, 745, 985,986/MUM/2026 M/s Kalpataru Projects International Ltd.
“ 6.1 The CER credits have all the attributes of 'goods' such as utility, capability of being bought and sold, transferred, stored/possessed even though they do not have a physical existence since, essentially they are certificates having market value. In other words, they command a ready market, have a market value, with willing buyers and sellers and are freely transferable as other marketable commodities. Their characterization as 'goods' derives support from the decision of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of Tata Consultancy Services vs. State of Andhra Pradesh [2004] 271 ITR 401. Another decision of the Hon'ble Supreme Court that can be gainfully considered in this context is that of Vikas Sales Corporation vs. Commissioner of Commercial Taxes, (1996) 102 STC 106 (SC), where freely transferable replenishment licenses (R.E.P.) license were held as goods. The attributes as laid down by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the above said cases are fully satisfied in the case of CERs too. Hence, CER, are not dissimilar to the trade and profit of other 'conventional or orthodox' goods and, thereby, equally amenable to tax. The contemporaneous trends support the view that carbon credits need not be sequestered for tax purposes. Globally, climate changes, such as European Climate Exchange (ECX) and Nymex Green exchange provide a trading platform for carbon credits. In India, the Multi Commodity Exchange of India Ltd. (MCX) which is a demutualised exchange with permanent recognition from the government of India, offering futures trading in items such as bullion, grains, plastics, metals, spices, etc., launched carbon credit futures trade from January, 2008 onwards. On an appreciation of facts, law and the commercial aspects of carbon credits, it is evident that the gain arising from the sale of CERs is liable to be taxed at par with profits from other commodities and goods. (b) Analogy to import entitlements: The AO drew a close analogy between CERs and import entitlements, both being incentives conferred by a public authority that may either be exploited directly or realised by sale, and relied on a line of decisions, including George Maijo & Co. v. CIT [1986] 157 ITR 475 (Mad.), Swadeshi Cotton Mills Co. Ltd. v. CIT [1989] 47 Taxman 215 (All.), and Gedore Tools Pvt. Ltd. v. CIT [1999] 105 Taxman 3 (Delhi), holding that sale proceeds of import entitlements are revenue receipts. Accordingly, he held that provision of Section 28(iv) were wide enough to bring about taxability of the CERs as revenue income as they resulted in a
ITA 6717/MUM/2024 14 ITA 744, 745, 985,986/MUM/2026 M/s Kalpataru Projects International Ltd.
benefit accruing to the assessee from business. The relevant finding of AO is reproduced as under:
“ 5.1.1 Whether CERs are akin to "import entitlements"?: The CERs are, therefore, incentives given by the Government to avoid use of fossil fuel in the industry. If saving in CERs is made, the industry can make money by selling them. 5.1.2 They have almost similar features as in an "import entitlement". Based on the quantum of exports, the exporters are given import entitlements (IEs in short). The exporter can either import the raw material/goods covered by the IEs or without importing the goods they can sell the IEs. If they import they consume or exhaust the IEs to that extent. If they do not, then to the extent they save they can sell and earn money. CERs are also entitlements for consuming fossil fuel. Savings in these are available for sale. Both are rights or permits given by Government. "If an assessee exploits the IEs by actually importing the goods referred to therein and sells the same, the sale proceeds cannot, in any sense, be said to be a capital receipt. The fact that the assessee chooses to exploit the IEs in a different manner, other than actual import, will not make any change in the character of the receipt. The sale of import entitlement is one of the modes of exploiting the import entitlement and, therefore, will clearly be a revenue receipt [RE., George Maijo& Co. (Vizag.)v. CIT[1986] 157 ITR 475 (Mad.)]. Similar view has been taken in 1. Swadeshi Cotton Mills Co. Ltd.v. CIT[1989] 47 Taxman 215 (All.), 2. Jeewanlal (1929) Ltd.v. CIT[1991] 57 Taxman 123 (Cal.), and 3. Gedore Tools Pvt. Ltd.v. CIT [1999] 105 Taxman 3 (Delhi)
(c) Section 28(iv): The AO held that CERs are received as a benefit arising in the course of business, the right to receive them arising only where the assessee carries on the business of power generation and achieves savings in fossil-fuel consumption, and are accordingly taxable as a business benefit under Section 28(iv). The relevant finding of AO is reproduced as under:
“5.1.3 Whether CERs should be taxable as revenue receipt under section 28(iv)?: Further, section 28(iv) clearly brings the receipt from sale of CERs within the ambit of taxability. It reads as follows:
ITA 6717/MUM/2024 15 ITA 744, 745, 985,986/MUM/2026 M/s Kalpataru Projects International Ltd.
Profits and gains of business or profession. The following income shall be chargeable to income-tax under the head "Profits and gains of business or profession"....... (iv) the value of any benefit or perquisite, whether convertible into money or not, arising from business or the exercise of a profession. There are following two conditions: (i) assessee receives any benefit or perquisite, (ii) they should arise in the course of business. "Benefit" means "advantage; Profit; Gains; Interest; Use; Promotion of welfare or Prosperity; helpful result; A benefaction or deed of Kindness; favour bestowed; privilege. Benefit" is a word of wide import. It could be express or otherwise. The term perquisite" means that it is an additional benefit and not a complete substitution of one's income.
5.1.4 The CERs are received from the Govt. (out of the quota allotted to the Govt, as per KYOTO PROTOCOL) permitting the assessee to use fossil fuel to the extent mentioned in the CERs. The Govt, of a sovereign State has a right to place a reasonable restriction on carrying on profession or business and, therefore, restrictions are placed to use fossil fuel. However, this restriction also has an inbuilt incentive. "If you do not consume fossil fuel, or consume less, you can sell and earn money". One may call it a reverse entitlement. Savings of CERs make the industry richer. This is the benefit given to the industry during the course of carrying on business. It has to be only shown by the industry that during the course of production it has either not consumed fossil fuel or has consumed less than what was assigned to it. Therefore, sale proceeds of such savings of CERs arise, during the course of business, and as a result of carrying on business without consuming fossil fuel. Thus, (i) right to receive CERs arises only if business is carried on by the assessee, (ii) such business is carried on by saving on fossil fuel. (iii) CERs have a market value. (iv) Quantities of CERS assigned by Govt. vary with the size of the industry or production target, (v) Quantities of saved CERs are variable, depending upon saving made in consumption of fossil fuel, (vi) sale proceeds of saved CERs compensate for incurring extra expenditure on using alternative fuel (other than fossil fuel). 5.2 Therefore, sale proceeds of CERs are revenue receipts not only from the intrinsic nature of the entitlement but also because these are closely connected with carrying out business. They are taxable under section 28(iv) as benefit arises during the course of carrying on business.
(d) Rejection of the capital-receipt argument: The AO held that the assessee's reliance on the ‘purpose test’ enunciated in CIT v.
ITA 6717/MUM/2024 16 ITA 744, 745, 985,986/MUM/2026 M/s Kalpataru Projects International Ltd.
Sahney Steel & Press Works Ltd. [1997] 228 ITR 253 (SC) was misplaced, since that decision and the other subsidy cases cited by the assessee concerned grants flowing from government funds for setting up or expanding an undertaking, whereas no such monetary grant underlies the CER mechanism. The relevant finding of AO is reproduced as under:
“5.3 The assessee has argued that income from sale of CERs may be regarded as similar to subsidies received from the Government and, accordingly, the objective for which they are given should be examined. The assessee then went on to state that since CERs are received under the Kyoto Protocol, the ultimate objective was the reduction of green house gases, it is in public interest and for a 'noble purpose' and, hence, exempt from tax. 6.0 This argument is misconceived. In the entire gamut of carbon credit, there is absolutely no monetary consideration or a grant flowing from the Government or from any Government agency, any public agency or a public fund. Moreover, the contention that since the underlying purpose is advancing public interest and has a benevolent objective, the receipt is not chargeable to tax, is without basis in taxation. To this extent, the assessee has completely misread the decision of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the landmark case of CIT vs. Sahney Steel & Press Works Pvt. Ltd.[1997] 228 ITR 253, which has no applicability since it is not remotely connected to the issue at hand. The other cases quoted by the assessee were that of CIT vs. Kanyakumari Distt. Co-op. Spg. Mills Ltd[2003] 264 ITR 684 (Mad) and that of DCIT v. Reliance Industries Ltd([2004] 88 ITD 273 (Mum.) (SB). Both do not advance its case as they are related to Government subsidies. The other case cited, i.e., of Bharat Seats Ltd. Vs Jt. CIT[2002] 120 Taxman 120 (Del) (Mag), is related to grant received from a specified Multilateral Fund which is not the case here. Thus, the argument of the assessee that profit arising from carbon credits is a non- taxable capital receipt does not succeed on the basis of the arguments furnished by it. (e) Accrual: The AO held that the CER income had accrued during the relevant previous year, the assessee itself having recognised it on a mercantile basis with reasonable certainty of realisation, notwithstanding that residual certification
ITA 6717/MUM/2024 17 ITA 744, 745, 985,986/MUM/2026 M/s Kalpataru Projects International Ltd.
formalities with UNFCCC remained to be completed. The relevant finding of AO is reproduced as under:
6.7 CERs have accrued during the relevant period The contention of the assessee is that the CERs have not accrued as per the Income tax Act as the Padampur and Tonk Plants got UNFCC certificates and the registration for the said plants with regard to the CER credits in the years following the relevant previous year. Despite the fact that the treatment in accounts is not decisive it is noted that in totality of the facts and circumstances the aforesaid receipt is liable to tax in the relevant assessment year. The facts and circumstances are discussed hereunder: As per the details provided by the assessee company the Date of the registration for the Padampur Plant is 23.05.2005 and that of Tonk Plant is 07.05.2008 6.8 There has been emission reduction during the relevant previous year and the same has been computed by the assessee with certainty and as per the prescribed procedure. The assessee-company has entered into contracts with the Sponsors during the relevant period as is clear from the dates of registration. 6.9 books of account and credited the same to the profit and loss account. Moreover, the The assessee-company has itself recognized the receipts on account of CERs in assessee is following mercantile system of accounting wherein income and expenditures that have accrued are only credited or debited to the books of accounts. It is pertinent here to refer to the Notes to accounts of the assessee- company wherein it has been clearly noted that: There is reasonable certainty about its ultimate realization. There is a reasonable assurance that the Company complies with the conditions in relating thereto. In view of the above, the receipt of the CERs was reasonably certain as the assessee-company has already completed the formalities for getting the UNFCC certification, as itself stated by it in its submission. Only residual formalities were required to be completed. Thus, the contention of the assessee on this count is rejected. 6.6 Further, the ld AO also observed as under:
6.2 It is true that there is no specific provision for the taxation of carbon credits in the present Act. However, it would too simplistic, as well as patently erroneous, to hold that absence of an explicit provision means that it is not taxable. It is well recognized that it is impossible for the Legislature to exhaustively conceive or enumerate all items of income or revenue receipts in any enactment. The omission by the Finance Act, 2002, of section 10(3) of the Act has immense significance in endorsing the aforesaid reasoning. The erstwhile section, in one stroke, removed all casual and non-recurring receipts of any amount and description from the ambit of 'income not forming part of total income. The deletion conveyed the intention of the lawmakers to exponentially widen the scope of what constituted a taxable receipt. Resultantly, the scope of reflexively claiming any receipt as exempt under
ITA 6717/MUM/2024 18 ITA 744, 745, 985,986/MUM/2026 M/s Kalpataru Projects International Ltd.
the Act is severely restricted and, in dand, in any event, could not be pleaded by default. Carbon credits are not exempt from tax under the ACCOME the Act, either under Chapter-II (Incomes which do not from part of total income'). 6.3 On the other hand, the inclusive definition of 'income as per section 2(24) of the Act, is wide enough to bring the receipts arising from their transfer within its sweep. It is settled that the word 'income' will take in its fold any monetary return 'coming in' unless explicitly exempt. The assessee has full control over this receipt. In the case of CIT v. Smt. Shanti Meattle [1973] 90 ITR 385 (All.), it has been held that the word 'income' as used in the Act, has often been characterized by judicial decisions as formidably wide and vague in its scope. Every receipt generally may be described as 'income' unless it is expressly exempt. The issues has been discussed at length in para 5.2 and earlier paragraphs of this order. 6.4 The insistence of the assessee that the receipt is capital in nature, is unacceptable. There is no dispute that the said receipt has accrued to the assessee- manufacturer in the course of carrying out its business. Therefore, the receipt is not divorced from it but is attributable to the same, though not from the mainstream activity of the assessee-company. In other words, if the assessee were to discontinue its business lock, stock and barrel, the receipt would not have arisen. The receipt cannot be contemplated de horsits business. However, it is crucial to note that the receipt is not in the nature of making good the loss of profit making apparatus or the sterilization of a capital asset of enduring value so as to have the essential ingredients of a 'capital receipt'. It is not in the nature of compensation paid for damage caused to assessee's capital asset. It cannot be characterized as liquidated damages. There is no requirement of law that a receipt should stream in with a discernible regularity. Ltd. v. CIT[1964] 53 ITR 261 held that "It is again not predicated that the income must necessarily have a recurrent quality. "Thus, the assessee's reasoning urged that the same is a capital receipt is not well-founded. 6.5 While it would be excessive to hold that anything which is received by the assessee is liable to be unquestionably treated as income, yet, the onus is also on the assessee to prove that this income is exempt from tax. No plausible basis has been demonstrated by the assessee except to merely state that the same is a capital receipt. Here, it is also worth taking note of the fact that had the Legislature intended to make carbon credits trading arising from Kyoto Protocol as exempt from tax it would have specifically said so as it did in respect of amounts received from the multilateral fund of Montreal Protocol on Substances (ozone depletion) interms of proviso (ii) to section 28(va) of the Act. 6.6 The definition of 'business in section 2(13) of the Act includes any trade, commerce or manufacture or any adventure or concern in the nature of trade, commerce or manufacture. The Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of CIT v. Calcutta National Bank Ltd [1959] 37 ITR 171, held that "the term "business" is a word of very wide, though by no means determinate, scope. It has rightly been observed in judicial decisions of high authority that it is neither practicable nor desirable to
ITA 6717/MUM/2024 19 ITA 744, 745, 985,986/MUM/2026 M/s Kalpataru Projects International Ltd.
make any attempt at de-limiting the ambit of its connotation. Each case has to be determined with reference to the particular kind of activity and occupation of the person concerned. Though ordinarily "business" implies a continuous activity in carrying on a particular trade or avocation, it may also include an activity which may be called quiescent". The Apex Court went on to hold that it might be that a subsidiary line of business activity might not be the main part of its business, but even so, if realizations there from was a sources of business income to the assessee, it had got to be included in the computation of its profits for the purposes of the Act. In this light, there is unimpeachable logic to hold that the same is well within the taxing provisions of the present Act being a revenue receipt. Therefore, there is little doubt that profit arising from the sale of carbon credits is eligible to tax as business profits within the meaning of section 28 of the Act. 6.10 CERs are not Capital assets and are not eligible to tax under the head capital gains. The said issue is not under consideration, thus, no comments on the merits of the issue are being offered here. CERs are eligible for deduction under section 801A of the Act The assessee has taken an alternative contention that receipts on sale of CERs if treated to be business income the same are eligible for deduction under section 801A(4)(iv) of the Income-tax Act, 1961 as the same are derived from its business activity of generating of power. In view of the reply of the assessee and position of law as laid down, the income for the sale of CERs is no doubt derived from the activity of generation of power and running of the power plant. Thus, the contention of the assessee that it is eligible for the claim under section 801A(4)(iv) is acceptable. However, the issue whether assessee would be entitled to deduction under sec. 80-IA on profit derived from sale of CERs required detailed arguments. It should have been decided whether profit from sale of CERs was derived from business of Industrial Undertaking, or it was distantly connected with business activities. It required discussion and a finding thereon. Prima facie, the assessee had a case because use of the term "business of industrial undertaking" in section 80-IA has wide coverage. Entitlement to CERs is a direct result of production process, being incentive for use of alternative fuel in place of fossil fuel and, therefore, has a direct nexus with business of Industrial undertaking engaged in production of power. 6.11 In view of the facts discussed above, it is held that the income earned by the assessee from the sale of CERs is a taxable revenue receipt and taxable as income from "business and profession". It is also held that the CERs have accrued during the relevant period. Further, the assessee is eligible for deduction under section 801A of the Act for the Tonk Plant as the assessee has claimed deduction under section 801A of the Act during the assessment proceedings as per discussion above. The net receipts of Rs. 1,57,55,127/-on sale of CERs are to be added to the business income of the assessee being taxable revenue receipts. Penal proceedings under section 270 A of the I.T. Act, 1961 is being initiated for under-reporting of income.”
ITA 6717/MUM/2024 20 ITA 744, 745, 985,986/MUM/2026 M/s Kalpataru Projects International Ltd.
6.7 Before the ld DRP, the assessee reiterated that the receipt was capital in nature and, in the alternative, contended that even after the insertion of Section 115BBG into the Act with effect from Assessment Year 2018-19, the provision was merely a rate- prescribing machinery provision and in the absence of a corresponding amendment bringing CER receipts within the definition of "income" under Section 2(24), the receipt could not be taxed merely because a special rate had been provided for it.
6.8 The ld DRP rejected this contention. It held that prior to the insertion of Section 115BBG there existed no specific mechanism for taxing carbon-credit income, but that the Hon’ble Legislature, having now expressly brought such income to tax at a concessional rate under Section 115BBG , with no deduction permissible for any expenditure or allowance in relation thereto, the assessee's submission that the receipt remained a non-taxable capital receipt outside Section 2(24) could not be accepted. The AO was directed to finalise the assessment accordingly. Pursuant to the directions of ld DRP, the Assessing officer passed the impugned assessment order. Aggrieved with the same, the assessee is before us.
Before us, the learned counsel for the assessee made manifold arguments. He submitted that issue in dispute is covered by the decision of the Coordinate Bench of the Tribunal, Ahmedabad, in the case of the assessee from AY 2010-11, AY 2011-12, and AY 2015-16,
ITA 6717/MUM/2024 21 ITA 744, 745, 985,986/MUM/2026 M/s Kalpataru Projects International Ltd.
which are further upheld by the Hon’ble Gujarat High Court. The learned counsel also submitted that profit arising from sale of the carbon credit has been held not to be a business income under Section 28 in various decision of the Coordinate bench of the Tribunal. Further, regarding the taxability of the CERs under Section 115BBG of the Act is concerned, the learned counsel submitted that until and unless total income of the assessee does not include income on account of transfer/sale of carbon credit, Section 115BBG would not have any tax implication. The relevant submissions of the assessee are reproduced as under:
“ (i) Covered Issue:
1.1 The Appellant most respectfully submits that the ld. AO while treating the CERs as revenue receipt has not considered the decision of the higher authorities in case of Appellant for preceding years. The Appellant wishes to submit that the taxability of receipt of CERs has been a subject matter of assessment as well as appellate proceedings in earlier assessment years. In the Appellant’s own case for AY 2012-13 to AY 2015-16, the Hon’ble Ahmedabad ITAT has considered the receipt from sale of CER as capital receipts and decided the issue in favor of the Appellant. 1.2 It is further submitted that the findings of Hon’ble Ahmedabad ITAT from AY 2010-11, AY 2011- 12 and AY 2015-16 were also upheld by the Hon’ble Gujarat HC. The relevant extract of the order of Hon’ble Gujarat HC for AY 2015-16 in ITA No. 209 of 2024 vide order dated 10.09.2024 is reproduced below for ready reference: 3.2. It was submitted that question No.(i) pertaining to the deletion of addition on account of the receipt of CER and treating the same as Capital Receipt instead of Revenue Receipt, is answered by this Court in case of The Principal Commissioner of Income Tax versus M/s Gujarat Flurochemicals LTD in Tax Appeal No. 423 of 2023 wherein, the Co- ordinate Bench of this Court has answered the similar question pertaining to treating the income from realisation of Carbon Credit as capital in nature as under: “4.5 Similarly, in case of the last question (F), the coordinate bench has answered the same as below:
ITA 6717/MUM/2024 22 ITA 744, 745, 985,986/MUM/2026 M/s Kalpataru Projects International Ltd.
“26. The fifth question proposed by the revenue whether the income from the Carbon Credits is capital in nature. This issue is squarely covered by the following decisions: (1) M/s. Alembic Ltd. Tax Appeal No.553 & 554 of 2017 (2) CIT Vs. My Home Power Ltd. [2014] 46 Taxmann.com 314 (3) Subhash Kabini Power Corporation Ltd. (KHC) [2016] 69 Taxmann.com 394
We quote the relevant observations made by this Court in the Alembic Limited (supra) as under:
“6. The last surviving question pertains to the treatment that the assessee's income from trading of carbon credits should be given. The Tribunal held that receipts should be in the nature of capital receipts and therefore, would not invite tax. This issue has been examined by two High Courts. The Karnataka High Court in case of CIT v. Subhash Kabini Power Corporation Ltd. reported in (2016) 385 ITR 592 (Karn) and Andhra Pradesh High Court in case of Commissioner of Incometax v. My Home Power Limited reported in (2014) 365 ITR 82 (AP) have held that receipts of carbon credit are in nature of revenue receipts. Following the decision of said two High Courts, this question is also not considered.”
Having considered the question of law and in light of the decision of the coordinate bench of this court which has been relied upon by the tribunal in the order under challenge, no substantial question of law arises for the consideration of this court. In view of the same, the appeal is dismissed.”
The Tribunal has also followed its earlier decisions in the earlier years for AssessmentYear 2014-15 wherein, in turn it has followed the decision for Assessment Year 2012-13 by treating the Carbon Credits as Capital Receipt.
In view of the decision of this Court in case of Gujarat Fluro chemicals LTD (Supra), we are of the opinion that no substantial questions of law arise from the impugned orderof the Tribunal wherein, the Tribunal has followed the decision for its earlier year.
1.3 Since the CERs receipt has already been treated as capital receipt by the Hon’ble Gujarat High Court in Appellant’s own case, the case of the Appellant for the year is fairly settled and therefore treatment of CERs receipt on the same facts should be considered as capital receipt, not chargeable to tax for the year under consideration.
(ii) Taxability u/s. 28:
1.4 The ld. AO contended that profit arising from sale of carbon credits is taxable as business profits
ITA 6717/MUM/2024 23 ITA 744, 745, 985,986/MUM/2026 M/s Kalpataru Projects International Ltd.
within meaning of section 28 of the Act. It is submitted that in earlier years also, the AO has taxed receipts from sale of carbon credits as business income u/s 28. The Hon’ble ITAT for AY 2012-13 and 2013-14 in ITA No. 2471 & 2853 of 2017 by placing reliance on following decisions held that carbon credits is not taxable as business income u/s 28:
(i) CIT vs My Home Power Ltd – Andhra Pradesh HC (ii) Sri Velayudhaswamy Spinning Mills (P) Ltd vs. DCIT – ITAT Chennai (iii) DCIT vs. Shree Rayataseema Green Energy Ltd – ITAT Hyderabad (iv) CIT vs. Subhashkabini Power Corporation Ltd – Karnataka HC
The copy of decision of ITAT Ahmedabad for AY 2012-13 & 2013-14 is placed on page no. 455 to 497 of paper book for AY 2021-22.
1.5 The Hon’ble Hyderabad Tribunal in case of My Home Power Ltd vs DCIT (2012) 27 taxmann.com 27 which has been upheld by the Andhra Pradesh High Court in (2014) 46 taxmann.com 314 has given specific finding that sale of carbon credits is not taxable u/s 28 of the Act. The relevant finding of Hon’ble Hyderabad Tribunal is reproduced below for ease of reference:
We have heard both the parties and perused the material on record. Carbon credit is in the nature of "an entitlement" received to improve world atmosphere and environment reducing carbon, heat and gas emissions. The entitlement earned for carbon credits can, at best, be regarded as a capital receipt and cannot be taxed as a revenue receipt. It is not generated or created due to carrying on business but it is accrued due to "world concern". It has been made available assuming character of transferable right or entitlement only due to world concern. The source of carbon credit is world concern and environment. Due to that the assessee gets a privilege in the nature of transfer of carbon credits. Thus, the amount received for carbon credits has no element of profit or gain and it cannot be subjected to tax in any manner under any head of income. It is not liable for tax for the assessment year under consideration in terms of sections 2(24), 28, 45 and 56 of the Income-tax Act, 1961. Carbon credits are made available to the assessee on account of saving of energy consumption and not because of its business. Further, in our opinion, carbon credits cannot be considered as a bi-product. It is a credit given to the assessee under the Kyoto Protocol and because of international understanding. Thus, the assessees who have surplus carbon credits can sell them to other assessees to have capped emission commitment under the Kyoto Protocol. Transferable carbon credit is not a result or incidence of one's business and it is a credit for reducing emissions. The persons having carbon credits get benefit by selling the same to a person who needs carbon credits to overcome one's negative point carbon credit. The amount received is not received for producing and/or selling any product, bi-product or for rendering any service for carrying on the business. In our opinion, carbon credit is entitlement or accretion of capital and hence income earned on sale of these credits is capital receipt. For this proposition, we
ITA 6717/MUM/2024 24 ITA 744, 745, 985,986/MUM/2026 M/s Kalpataru Projects International Ltd.
place reliance on the judgment of the Supreme Court in the case of CIT v. Maheshwari Devi Jute Mills Ltd. [1965] 57 ITR 36 wherein held that transfer of surplus loom hours to other mill out of those allotted to the assessee under an agreement for control of production was capital receipt and not income. Being so, the consideration received by the assessee is similar to consideration received by transferring of loom hours. The Supreme Court considered this fact and observed that taxability of payment received for sale of loom hours by the assessee is on account of exploitation of capital asset and it is capital receipt and not an income. Similarly, in the present case the assessee transferred the carbon credits like loom hours to some other concerns for certain consideration. Therefore, the receipt of such consideration cannot be considered as business income and it is a capital receipt. Accordingly, we are of the opinion that the consideration received on account of carbon credits cannot be considered as income as taxable in the assessment year under consideration. Carbon credit is not an offshoot of business but an offshoot of environmental concerns. No asset is generated in the course of business but it is generated due to environmental concerns. Credit for reducing carbon emission or greenhouse effect can be transferred to another party in need of reduction of carbon emission. It does not increase profit in any manner and does not need any expenses. It is a nature of entitlement to reduce carbon emission, however, there is no cost of acquisition or cost of production to get this entitlement. Carbon credit is not in the nature of profit or in the nature of income.
1.6 We further rely on following judicial pronouncements wherein it is held that carbon credits are not chargeable to tax as business income:
(i) PCIT vs. Alembic Ltd – TA No. 553 & 554 of 2017 – Gujarat HC (refer page no. 1 to 6 of case law compilation) (ii) CIT(A) vs. Subhash Kabini Power Corporation Ltd – (2016) 69 taxmann.com 394 – Karnataka HC (refer page no. 7 to 16 of case law compilation) (iii) CIT vs. My Home Power Ltd (2014) 46 taxmann.com 314 – Andhra Pradesh HC (refer page no. 17 to 18 of the paper book) (iv) PCIT vs. Gujarat Fluro Chemicals Ltd – TA No. 423 of 2023 – Gujarat HC (refer page no. 19 to 47 of the paper book)
1.7 Considering the above, it is submitted that as held by various High Courts, sale of carbon credits is not taxable as business income u/s 28 of the Act.
(iii) Taxability u/s. 115BBG of the Act:
1.8 The ld. DRP has held that receipts on account of sale of CER are chargeable to tax by considering such CERs receipt as revenue receipt in view of insertion of section 115BBG providing the special rate of tax of charging such income. Section 115BBG of the Act reads as under:
ITA 6717/MUM/2024 25 ITA 744, 745, 985,986/MUM/2026 M/s Kalpataru Projects International Ltd.
Tax on income from transfer of carbon credits. 115BBG. (1) Where the total income of an assessee includes any income by way of transfer of carbon credits, the income-tax payable shall be the aggregate of— (a) the amount of income-tax calculated on the income by way of transfer of carbon credits, at the rate of ten per cent; and (b) the amount of income-tax with which the assessee would have been chargeable had his total income been reduced by the amount of income referred to in clause (a). (2) Notwithstanding anything contained in this Act, no deduction in respect of any expenditure or allowance shall be allowed to the assessee under any provision of this Act in computing his income referred to in clause (a) of sub-section (1). Explanation.—For the purposes of this section, "carbon credit" in respect of one unit shall mean reduction of one tonne of carbon dioxide emissions or emissions of its equivalent gases which is validated by the United Nations Framework on Climate Change and which can be traded in market at its prevailing market price
1.9 On perusal of the above, it may be noted that the very first condition for invoking section 115BBG is total income should include income by way of transfer of carbon credits. Thus, unless and until total income of Appellant does not include income on account of transfer / sale of carbon credits, section 115BBG would not have any tax implication. Section 115BBG is a machinery provision and provides the rate as well as manner of computing income chargeable to tax and is not charging section which provides for treating such income as revenue receipts chargeable to tax. It is therefore submitted that even after insertion of section 115BBG, CERs receipt cannot be considered as revenue receipt in absence of any amendment made u/s. 2(24) or 28 of the Act.
1.10 The Hon’ble Apex Court in case of ParimisettiSeetharamamma vs CIT (1965) 56 ITR (Sh. N.) 3r held that “By section 3 and 4 the Act imposes a general liability to tax upon all income. But the Act does not provide that whatever is received by a person must be regarded as income liable to tax. In all cases in which a receipt is sought to be taxed as income, the burden lies upon the department to prove that it is within taxing provision. Where however a receipt is of nature of income, the burden of proving that it is not taxable because it falls within an exemption provided by the Act lies upon the assessee.” Applying said analogy to the facts of the case, it may be appreciated that not all receipts can be held liable to tax and where it is sought to be taxed, the burden to prove that it is chargeable to tax lies upon the department. The Department in given case has held the sum as taxable u/s 28, however as held by various High Courts, CER receipts are capital receipts and not revenue receipts taxable u/s 2(24) or section 28 of the Act. In absence of any change in facts on the hand, it is on the revenue to prove that decisions of Hon’ble High Courts do not apply to the Appellant and therefore CER receipts are chargeable to tax during the year under consideration.
1.11 The Appellant would also like to rely on the decision of Ahmedabad ITAT in case of ITO vs Ganeshsagar Infrastructure (P.) Ltd [2022] 135 taxmann.com 313, wherein the Hon’ble ITAT
ITA 6717/MUM/2024 26 ITA 744, 745, 985,986/MUM/2026 M/s Kalpataru Projects International Ltd.
held as under:
“21.1 It is trite that a capital receipt can be taxed only when the same has been expressly included and deemed as 'income' under s.2(24) of the Act. As a general rule for Income Tax, all revenue receipts unless specifically exempted are taxable under the provisions of Income-tax Act and all capital receipts unless made specifically taxable by the Act do not constitute income chargeable to tax. The compensation received for release of right to sue being a capital receipt is not deemed to be 'income' and hence not chargeable to tax. Significantly, the Constitution itself uses the term 'tax on income' and the term 'income' must be construed in the same manner as the one defined under Income-tax Act. As a corollary, it is impermissible to cover such capital receipts under s. 115JB in an unregulated manner. At this stage, we notice a pertinent plea taken on behalf of the assessee that the receipt being of capital nature does not enter into the computation provision at all and hence, there is no question of including the same in book profits for the purposes of section 115JB of the Act.
21.2 The view as propounded that the capital receipts unless specifically included as 'income' cannot brought to tax even under alternate provision gains traction from the fact that clause (ii) of Explanation (1) to section 115JB which provided for an adjustment to the book profit of the Company, require a company to exclude those income which do not form part of total income under ss. 10, 11 and 12 subject to some exceptions. Thus, those items of income which are exempt under s. 10 are specifically excluded from book profit. If that is so, by extension of the innate logic, those items of receipts which are not income at all, requires to be excluded at the threshold and rather in preference to items of section 10 of the Act. Since capital receipts are not ordinarily construed as income under rudimentary understanding of accounting and tax laws, they do not find a specific mention in section 10 of the Act and consequently Explanation 1 to section 115JB of the Act is silent on exclusion of capital receipts. 1.12 Considering the above, it is submitted that though Finance Act, 2018 introduced tax on carbon credit income by way of insertion of section 115BBG of the Act, since such receipt is capital in nature and not covered by the definition of income u/s. 2(24) or 28 of the Act, it shall not be subjected to tax.
1.13 Before the ld. DRP, the Appellant has submitted that despite insertion of section 115BBG in the Act, income of CERs does not become revenue receipt. The Appellant submitted that section 115BBG is not a charging section and in absence of amendment made under section 2(24) of the Act by considering receipt from sale of CERs as income under the Act, it shall not be taxable under the Act since the jurisdictional ITAT as well as Gujarat High Court and other Courts had considered the same as capital receipt. The Appellant also cited the decision of Ahmedabad ITAT in case of ITO vs Ganeshsagar Infrastructure (P.) Ltd [2022] 135 taxmann.com 313 before DRP, however DRP
ITA 6717/MUM/2024 27 ITA 744, 745, 985,986/MUM/2026 M/s Kalpataru Projects International Ltd.
without contradicting such decision held that in view of section 115BBG of the Act, income from sale of CERs is taxable under the Act. Please refer to Page No. 605 to 627 of Paper Book.
1.14 Further, it is respectfully submitted that a receipt can be subjected to tax under the Act only when it falls within ambit of "income" as defined under Section 2(24) of the Act or is otherwise specifically brought to tax by a charging provision. It is a settled principle of taxation law that a capital receipt cannot be taxed unless the legislature expressly provides for the same by creating a charging mechanism. In the instant case, while Section 115BBG of the Act prescribes the rate at which income from transfer of carbon credits is to be taxed, no corresponding amendment was made either in the definition of "income" contained in Section 2(24) of the Act or in the provisions of Section 28 dealing with profits and gains of business or profession. Thus, although a tax rate has been prescribed, the legislature has not expressly provided for treating receipts from transfer of carbon credits as income chargeable to tax.
1.15 It is further submitted that section 115BBG of the Act is not an independent charging provision. The charging provisions under the Act are contained principally in Section 4 of the Act, which levy tax on income chargeable under the provisions of the Act. It is important to note that there is no amendment in section 28 which taxes the income under the head income from business or profession. Section 115BBG of the Act merely provides the rate of tax applicable to a particular category of income and, therefore, constitutes machinery or computational provision. It is a well-established principle of law that a machinery provision cannot enlarge the scope of the charging provisions, nor it can create a charge of tax where the charging provisions themselves do not apply. Before invoking Section 115BBG of the Act, it must first be demonstrated that the receipt in question constitutes taxable income under the Act.
1.16 Once it is established that income is capital in nature, it can be brought into tax by including same in definition of income u/s 2(24) of the Act. However, while the provision of section 115BBG was introduced in legislation, no amendment was brought into provision of section 2(24) of the Act. In absence of inclusion of carbon credit receipt as ‘income’, it is not liable to be taxed merely by introducing section 115BBG of the Act. Therefore, in absence of any amendment to section 2(24), section 28, or any other charging provision of the Act specifically to bring the receipts from transfer of carbon credits within the tax net, the consideration received on sale of CERs receipts cannot be regarded as taxable income in the hands of the Appellant when various judicial authorities have held such income as capital receipt. Hence, impugned addition made by treating such capital receipts as taxable under section 115BBG of the Act is contrary to the scheme of the Act and deserves to be deleted.
1.17 As stated above, capital receipt can be taxed only when same has been expressly included and deemed as 'income' under section 2(24) of the Act. As a general rule for Income Tax, all revenue receipts unless specifically exempted are taxable under the provisions of Act and all capital receipts unless
ITA 6717/MUM/2024 28 ITA 744, 745, 985,986/MUM/2026 M/s Kalpataru Projects International Ltd.
made specifically taxable by the Act do not constitute income chargeable to tax. Such view has been duly upheld by Ahmedabad ITAT in case of ITO vs Ganeshsagar Infrastructure (P.) Ltd [2022] 135 taxmann.com 313 stated supra. 1.18 Considering the above facts and arguments, the Appellant submits that the receipt from sale of CERs is a capital receipt, not chargeable to tax under the Act in absence of inclusion of such receipt in the definition of income u/s. 2(24) or u/s. 28 of the Act. We, therefore, requests the Hon’ble Bench to delete addition made by the ld. AO by treating receipt from sale of carbon credits as revenue receipt. 8. Before us, the learned Departmental Representative(DR) submitted that Section 2(24)(xviii) of the Act defines "income" to include any assistance in the form of a subsidy, grant, cash incentive, duty drawback, waiver, concession, or reimbursement — "by whatever name called" — received in cash or in kind from the Central Government, a State Government, or "any authority or body or agency," other than assistance taken into account in determining the actual cost of an asset or a grant to a trust. It was submitted that the CER credit, issued under the auspices of UNFCCC, which is an agency constituted under a United Nations framework, and remitted to the assessee by or on behalf of the sponsoring Annexure-1 countries for using biomass instead of fossil fuel, is assistance of precisely this description, and that the deliberately open-ended words "by whatever name called" and "any authority or body or agency" are wide enough to capture it regardless of the label, whether subsidy, grant, credit, or incentive, attached to it.
8.1 The learned DR further submitted that the assessee first credited the, the sale proceeds, the credited profit on account of the transfer of CER into profit and loss account, but while computing the
ITA 6717/MUM/2024 29 ITA 744, 745, 985,986/MUM/2026 M/s Kalpataru Projects International Ltd.
income under the head ‘business and profession’, the assessee has reduced the said amount claiming to be in the nature of the ‘subsidy’ and ‘grant’ to be a capital receipt.
We have carefully considered the rival submissions, perused the orders of the authorities below and examined the material placed on record & the decisions cited at the Bar. The controversy before us is essentially whether the amount realised by the assessee on transfer of Certified Emission Reductions (“CERs”) is a capital receipt, as contended by the assessee, or a receipt chargeable to tax under the provisions of the Act, as held by the Assessing Officer and the learned DRP.
9.1 At the outset, we find considerable force in the contention of the learned counsel that, prior to the statutory amendments referred to hereinafter, various judicial authorities had examined the nature of carbon credits and held the receipts arising from their transfer to be capital in nature. The assessee has specifically relied upon the decisions in CIT v. My Home Power Ltd.(supra), CIT v. Subhash Kabini Power Corporation Ltd.(supra), PCIT v. Alembic Ltd. (supra) and PCIT v. Gujarat Fluro Chemicals Ltd.(supra), besides the decisions rendered by the Ahmedabad Bench in the assessee's own case for earlier assessment years. It has also been brought on record that the orders of the Tribunal in the assessee's own case for earlier years were affirmed by the Hon'ble Gujarat High Court. The judicial view relied
ITA 6717/MUM/2024 30 ITA 744, 745, 985,986/MUM/2026 M/s Kalpataru Projects International Ltd.
upon by the assessee proceeded, inter-alia, on the reasoning that carbon credits arise on account of reduction of greenhouse gas emissions and environmental concerns and are not generated from the sale of the assessee's product or rendering of services. In My Home Power Ltd.(supra), the Tribunal had, in the factual and statutory setting prevailing in the relevant assessment year, treated the consideration received on transfer of carbon credits as a capital receipt and not as business income. We accept, as a matter of record, that the Ahmedabad Bench of this Tribunal, and the Hon'ble Gujarat High Court affirming it, have held receipts of this very assessee from the very same ‘CDM’ mechanism to be capital in nature for Assessment Years 2010-11, 2011-12, 2012-13, 2013-14 and 2015- 16. The assessee has, therefore, correctly submitted that such decisions cannot be brushed aside merely because the Assessing Officer has taken a different view on the nature of the receipt.
9.2 However, the matter before us cannot be decided solely by applying the legal position obtaining in those earlier assessment years. The statutory landscape has undergone a material change. The inclusive definition of "income" introduced into Section 2(24) by clause (xviii), inserted by the Finance Act, 2015 and the special charging-cum-computational provision of Section 115BBG, inserted by the Finance Act, 2017 with effect from Assessment Year 2018-19, govern the assessment year before us.
ITA 6717/MUM/2024 31 ITA 744, 745, 985,986/MUM/2026 M/s Kalpataru Projects International Ltd.
9.3 The Section 2(24) of the Act was amended by the Finance Act, 2015 by insertion of clause (xviii) with effect from 01.04.2016. The provision expressly includes within the definition of “income” any assistance in the form of subsidy or grant or cash incentive or duty drawback or waiver or concession or reimbursement, by whatever name called, received from the Central Government or a State Government or any authority or body or agency, whether in cash or kind, subject to the exclusions specifically provided therein. Further, we also noted that the Hon’ble Bombay High Court in the case of Serum Institute of India (P.) Ltd. v. Union of India [2024] 463 ITR 582 (Bom)(HC), has dismissed the writ petition challenging constitutional validity of the section 2(24)(xviii) of the Act. In the case, the Serum Institute challenged the provision arguing that it was unlawfully taxed capital receipts (such as state government subsidies and incentives under the Maharashtra Package Scheme of Incentives) by broadly defining them as taxable "income," thereby overriding past Supreme Court rulings like Ponni Sugars (supra) and Sahney Steel (supra). The Hon’ble Bombay High Court ruled that the legislature holds wide, competent latitude in fiscal and economic policies. It held that including subsidies and concessions in the tax net is a valid economic choice to ensure equitable distribution of resources, and does not violate Articles 14, 19(1)(g), or 289 of the Constitution
9.4 But the question before us is no longer merely whether a receipt which has historically been regarded as a capital receipt can be
ITA 6717/MUM/2024 32 ITA 744, 745, 985,986/MUM/2026 M/s Kalpataru Projects International Ltd.
brought to tax under section 28(iv), or whether it bears the characteristics of business profits. The first question is whether the receipt in instant case before us falls within the expanded statutory definition of “income” contained in section 2(24)(xviii). If it does, its character as a receipt for the purposes of the charging provisions has to be examined in the light of the amended statutory scheme.
9.5 We are conscious that the assessee has specifically contended that section 2(24)(xviii) deals with assistance from the Government or an authority, body or agency, whereas CERs arise under the international mechanism established pursuant to the ‘Kyoto Protocol’ and the United Nations framework. Though before the AO assessee characterised the CER as kind of subsidy , but before us the ld Counsel for the assessee urged that CERs are not a subsidy, grant or cash incentive granted by the Government and that the assessee merely earns an entitlement by reducing emissions through the use of alternative fuel.
9.6 We are unable to accept the contention in the manner in which it has been advanced. The statutory provision does not restrict the expression “assistance” to a payment made in cash, nor does it make the nomenclature employed by the scheme determinative. On the contrary, Hon’ble Parliament has expressly used the words “by whatever name called” and has further employed the expression
ITA 6717/MUM/2024 33 ITA 744, 745, 985,986/MUM/2026 M/s Kalpataru Projects International Ltd.
“in cash or kind”. The legislative language is consequently of considerable amplitude.
9.7 The expression “assistance” must therefore be examined with reference to the substance of the mechanism under which the benefit reaches to the assessee and not merely by reference to the nomenclature “CER”, “credit”, “entitlement” or “certificate”. In the present case, the material placed on record shows that the assessee's biomass-based generation of power, and the consequent reduction in the use of fossil fuel and greenhouse-gas emissions, resulted in CERs being available under the international environmental mechanism. Those CERs possessed an ascertainable market value and were capable of being transferred for consideration. The assessee itself realised a monetary value upon their transfer. Thus, what the assessee obtained was an economically valuable benefit in kind, capable of being converted into money. The fact that the benefit was first embodied in the form of a certificate and was thereafter monetised by transfer does not, by itself, take it outside the statutory expression “assistance ... in cash or kind”.
9.8 In this context, the subsequent decision of the Special Bench of this Tribunal in DCIT v. Aarti Drugs Ltd., ITA Nos. 3069 & 3138/Mum/2023 and connected matters, assumes significance. Though, the decision has been pronounced after hearing of the case, we are merely making reference and drawing support from the said
ITA 6717/MUM/2024 34 ITA 744, 745, 985,986/MUM/2026 M/s Kalpataru Projects International Ltd.
decision after arriving at our conclusion and not relying solely on that. The Special Bench considered the scope and effect of section 2(24)(xviii), particularly the expression “assistance ... by whatever name called”. The Special Bench held, in substance, that the legislative expression is deliberately wide and elastic and that the characterisation given to the benefit under the concerned scheme cannot, by itself, take the receipt outside the statutory definition. The Special Bench further rejected an interpretation which would confine the expression “assistance” by reference merely to the nomenclature of the incentive. The ratio of the said decision, in our considered view, is not confined to an incentive bearing the particular name “MEIS”. What is material for the present purpose is the interpretation placed upon the statutory expression “assistance ... by whatever name called” and the recognition that the legislature intended to cover assistance granted in different forms and under different nomenclatures, unless the receipt falls within one of the specific statutory exclusions.
9.9 We may also observe that the expression “by whatever name called” cannot be rendered otiose by describing the receipt as an “entitlement” rather than as“assistance”. If the legislature intended the taxability of assistance to depend upon the label assigned to it under the scheme under which it is received, the words “by whatever name called” would have little or no operative effect. A construction
ITA 6717/MUM/2024 35 ITA 744, 745, 985,986/MUM/2026 M/s Kalpataru Projects International Ltd.
which gives meaning to every part of the statutory provision is to be preferred.
9.10 Equally, the fact that the benefit is received in kind cannot assist the assessee because section 2(24)(xviii) expressly contemplates assistance “in cash or kind”. In our opinion, the CERs, being transferable certificates, having an identifiable market value, fall within the latter expression.
9.11 The assessee has relied upon the decisions rendered in its own case for earlier years and the affirmation thereof by the Hon'ble Gujarat High Court. We have given due consideration to this submission. Those decisions undoubtedly constitute material judicial precedents on the nature of carbon-credit receipts under the statutory provisions considered therein. However, the assessment year presently under consideration is governed by the amended statutory framework containing section 2(24)(xviii), which was not the provision under consideration in the earlier decisions relied upon by the assessee. A precedent rendered in the context of an earlier statutory regime cannot be mechanically applied where the legislature has subsequently altered the statutory definition of income. The principle of consistency is undoubtedly an important consideration in tax adjudication. Nevertheless, consistency cannot prevail over a subsequent statutory amendment which directly bears upon the legal characterisation of the receipt. Therefore, the earlier
ITA 6717/MUM/2024 36 ITA 744, 745, 985,986/MUM/2026 M/s Kalpataru Projects International Ltd.
orders in the assessee's own case, though relevant, do not conclude the issue for the year presently before us.
9.12 The assessee has also relied upon My Home Power Ltd.(supra), Subhash Kabini Power Corporation Ltd.(supra) and Alembic Ltd.(supra) to contend that the receipt is not business income under section 28. We have carefully considered the same. Those decisions primarily dealt with the question whether carbon-credit receipts constituted business profits under the provisions then applicable. The present case stands on a materially different footing in view of the specific statutory inclusion contained in section 2(24)(xviii). Once Hon’ble Parliament has expressly included the specified category of assistance within the definition of “income”, it is not necessary for the Revenue to establish that the receipt independently satisfies the test of business income under section 28. A finding that a receipt is not a business benefit under Section 28(iv) says nothing about whether the very same receipt answers the separate and independently operating inclusive definition of "income" under Section 2(24)(xviii). Consequently, the assessee's argument that CERs cannot be taxed because they are not profits arising from the carrying on of business does not answer the statutory question arising under section 2(24)(xviii).
9.13 The contention of the assessee that CERs arise from an environmental concern and not from its business also does not alter
ITA 6717/MUM/2024 37 ITA 744, 745, 985,986/MUM/2026 M/s Kalpataru Projects International Ltd.
the position. We accept that the underlying object of the carbon- credit mechanism is environmental and that the benefit is intended to encourage reduction of greenhouse-gas emissions and the adoption of cleaner sources of energy. But the beneficial or environmental object of a scheme does not, by itself, determine whether the monetary value of the benefit is income under the Income-tax Act. The character of the receipt has to be determined with reference to the statutory provisions governing the assessment year. Indeed, the very mechanism relied upon by the assessee demonstrates the nexus between the environmental objective and the economic benefit. The assessee used biomass or other cleaner fuel in substitution for fossil fuel, thereby reducing emissions; the resulting reduction enabled CERs to be obtained; and those CERs were capable of being transferred for consideration. Thus, the environmental objective and the economic benefit coexist; the former does not efface the latter for purposes of section 2(24)(xviii).
9.14 The assessee has next contended that section 115BBG is merely a machinery provision prescribing a concessional rate and cannot itself create a charge where the receipt is otherwise not income. The proposition, in the abstract, is unexceptionable. A machinery or rate provision cannot ordinarily be read as enlarging the charge beyond what the charging provisions permit. But that principle does not advance the assessee's case once the receipt is
ITA 6717/MUM/2024 38 ITA 744, 745, 985,986/MUM/2026 M/s Kalpataru Projects International Ltd.
found to fall within the definition of “income” under section 2(24)(xviii).
9.15 Section 115BBG begins with the expression “Where the total income of an assessee includes any income by way of transfer of carbon credits” and prescribes the rate and manner of taxation of such income. Therefore, section 115BBG need not be treated as the provision which creates the income. Its operation follows upon the existence of income by way of transfer of carbon credits. In the present case, the statutory source for treating the receipt as income is section 2(24)(xviii), while section 115BBG prescribes the special rate and computational treatment applicable to income from transfer of carbon credits.
9.16 The assessee's submission that section 115BBG, standing alone, cannot convert a capital receipt into income is therefore accepted only to that limited extent. It does not follow that a receipt which independently falls within section 2(24)(xviii) escapes taxation merely because section 115BBG is not itself a charging provision.
9.17 The reliance placed by the assessee upon Parimisetti Seetharamamma v. CIT (supra) is also of no assistance in the ultimate determination. The principle that the burden lies upon the Revenue to establish that a receipt falls within a taxing provision is well settled. In the present case, however, the Revenue has identified the specific statutory provision, namely section 2(24)(xviii), and has
ITA 6717/MUM/2024 39 ITA 744, 745, 985,986/MUM/2026 M/s Kalpataru Projects International Ltd.
demonstrated the nature of the benefit received by the assessee. The dispute, therefore, is not one concerning an unclassified receipt sought to be taxed merely because money has come into the hands of the assessee. It concerns a receipt which, on the facts found, answers the statutory description of assistance received in kind and thereafter realised through transfer.
9.18 The assessee's reliance upon ITO v. Ganeshsagar Infrastructure (P.) Ltd. (supra) also has to be examined in the same statutory context. The general proposition that a capital receipt is not ordinarily taxable unless brought within the statutory definition of income or otherwise specifically subjected to tax is not in dispute. But the premise upon which the assessee seeks to invoke that principle—namely, that the CER receipt continues to remain outside the statutory definition of income—is not sustainable after considering section 2(24)(xviii). Once the receipt is brought within the inclusive definition of “income”, the argument based merely upon its earlier characterisation as capital cannot prevail.
9.19 We also do not find merit in the contention that the insertion of section 115BBG necessarily demonstrates that carbon-credit receipts continued to remain outside the definition of income until section 115BBG was introduced. Section 115BBG is a specific provision dealing with the rate and computation of income from transfer of carbon credits. It does not follow that, merely because
ITA 6717/MUM/2024 40 ITA 744, 745, 985,986/MUM/2026 M/s Kalpataru Projects International Ltd.
such specific rate provision was subsequently introduced, the underlying receipt could not already fall within the general definition of income. The provisions have to be read harmoniously: section 2(24)(xviii) identifies the receipt as income where its statutory conditions are satisfied, while section 115BBG prescribes the special rate applicable to income from transfer of carbon credits.
9.20 We have also considered the reasoning of the Assessing Officer that CERs possess the attributes of marketable goods, namely utility, transferability and market value, and his reliance upon Tata Consultancy Services v. State of Andhra Pradesh (supra) and Vikas Sales Corporation v. Commissioner of Commercial Taxes (supra). In our view, it is unnecessary, for deciding the present controversy, to rest the taxability of the receipt upon the proposition that CERs constitute “goods” for every legal purpose. Their transferability and market value are relevant only to demonstrate that the benefit obtained by the assessee in kind had an ascertainable economic value. The taxability in the present case follows from the statutory provision contained in section 2(24)(xviii), and not merely from the fact that CERs may possess characteristics of marketable commodities.
9.21 Similarly, the analogy drawn by the Assessing Officer between CERs and import entitlements cannot, by itself, determine the issue. Import entitlements were considered revenue receipts in the
ITA 6717/MUM/2024 41 ITA 744, 745, 985,986/MUM/2026 M/s Kalpataru Projects International Ltd.
decisions relied upon by the Assessing Officer on the basis of the statutory and factual setting governing those incentives. Nevertheless, the analogy does reinforce one limited proposition, namely that the mere description of a benefit as an entitlement does not necessarily determine its tax character. In the present case, however, we decide the matter principally upon the language and effect of section 2(24)(xviii).
9.22 The argument of the Assessing Officer that the receipt is taxable under section 28(iv) also does not require separate acceptance for sustaining the addition. Section 28(iv) deals with the value of any benefit or perquisite arising from business or the exercise of a profession. Once the receipt is independently brought within the definition of income under section 2(24)(xviii), it is unnecessary to rest its taxability upon section 28(iv). We, therefore, do not express any opinion on whether the CER receipt, in the circumstances of the present case, would independently satisfy all the requirements of section 28(iv).
9.23 We may, however, clarify one aspect concerning the expression “assistance”. The fact that the CERs are generated pursuant to an international environmental mechanism and are ultimately monetised by the assessee does not take them outside section 2(24)(xviii). The statutory provision expressly extends to assistance received in kind and employs the words “by whatever name called”.
ITA 6717/MUM/2024 42 ITA 744, 745, 985,986/MUM/2026 M/s Kalpataru Projects International Ltd.
Therefore, assistance need not necessarily assume the conventional form of a direct cash grant or subsidy. A benefit conferred through an authority, body or agency, which has an identifiable economic value and is received in connection with the prescribed scheme, fall within the statutory expression if the other requirements of the provision are satisfied.
9.24 In the facts before us, the CERs constitute such an economically valuable assistance. The mechanism encourages the assessee to adopt a cleaner source of fuel in substitution for fossil fuel, and the resultant emission reduction gives rise to transferable CERs. The economic benefit is thus inseparably connected with the assistance afforded under the environmental mechanism. The expression “assistance…., by whatever name called” is sufficiently wide to encompass such assistance notwithstanding that it is described as a carbon credit or CER rather than as a subsidy or grant. We are unable to accept the assessee's submission, advanced before the lower authorities that no "assistance" within the meaning of this clause flows in a CER transaction because no monetary grant is paid out of any government fund. The clause does not require that the assistance originate from Indian government funds, nor that it take the form of a cash grant in the conventional sense; it expressly extends to assistance received "in cash or in kind" from "any authority or body or agency," language of deliberately wide and open texture, reinforced by the qualifying words "by whatever name
ITA 6717/MUM/2024 43 ITA 744, 745, 985,986/MUM/2026 M/s Kalpataru Projects International Ltd.
called." The CER mechanism places the assessee's biomass plants in a position to receive, from the sponsoring Annexure-1 countries acting through their nominated agencies namely ‘SenterNovem’ for the Netherlands, and ‘AtmosfairGmbH’ for Germany, a quantified benefit for having reduced the emission of greenhouse gases by using biomass in place of fossil fuel, that benefit being certified and administered by UNFCCC and the CDM Executive Board, bodies constituted under an international treaty framework. This shows that the assistance is occasioned by an environmental, rather than a commercial cause. Further, the purpose does not place it outside the clause (xviii), which draws no such distinction, and was in fact inserted precisely to capture government and agency assistance of every description, "by whatever name called," within the tax net, superseding the narrower purpose-test enquiry that had previously governed the capital-or-revenue character of such receipts under the general law explained in Sahney Steel (supra) and Ponni Sugars (supra).
9.25 We therefore hold that, for the assessment year under consideration and in view of the statutory framework applicable thereto, the receipt arising to the assessee from transfer of CERs is covered by section 2(24)(xviii) and constitutes ‘income’. Once such receipt constitutes income and is income arising from transfer of carbon credits, section 115BBG is attracted, subject to the conditions prescribed therein.
ITA 6717/MUM/2024 44 ITA 744, 745, 985,986/MUM/2026 M/s Kalpataru Projects International Ltd.
9.26 We accordingly reject the assessee's principal contention that the receipt is not taxable merely because earlier judicial authorities had regarded carbon-credit receipts as capital receipts. Those decisions were rendered in a different statutory setting and cannot override the subsequent legislative inclusion contained in section 2(24)(xviii).
9.27 The assessee has also contended that the amount was recognised in the books and thereafter reduced while computing taxable income only because, according to the assessee, the receipt was capital in nature. Such accounting treatment, though relevant as a matter of factual record, cannot determine the legal character of the receipt. The taxability has to be determined in accordance with the provisions of Act. The assessee's treatment in the books therefore does not alter the conclusion reached above.
9.28 We have also taken note of the fact that the Assessing Officer has separately recorded findings regarding the accrual of CERs during the relevant previous year, including the registration of the concerned plants, reduction in emissions, completion of the prescribed procedure and the assessee's recognition of the receipt in its books. The assessee has challenged the taxability primarily on the legal character of the receipt and on the ground that the CERs were not taxable income. In view of our finding that the receipt is income under section 2(24)(xviii), and in the absence of any material brought
ITA 6717/MUM/2024 45 ITA 744, 745, 985,986/MUM/2026 M/s Kalpataru Projects International Ltd.
before us demonstrating that the CERs transferred during the relevant year did not accrue or were not capable of realisation during the relevant previous year, the challenge on accrual also does not survive.
9.29 As regards the alternative claim of deduction under section 80- IA, the Assessing Officer himself has recorded that the assessee is engaged in the business of generation of power and that the entitlement to CERs arose from the production process and use of alternative fuel. However, the precise allowability of deduction under section 80-IA has to be examined with reference to the statutory conditions governing the deduction and the computation of eligible profits. Since the receipt now stands taxed not as business income under Section 28 but as income from transfer of carbon credits under Section 2(24)(xviii) read with Section 115BBG, the alternative claim for deduction under Section 80IA(4)(iv), accepted by the AO without prejudice to the primary characterisation, will survive or not , need to be examined. Further, the Section 115BBG(2) expressly excludes any deduction "in respect of any expenditure or allowance" in computing income of this kind, "notwithstanding anything contained in this Act" — language that, in our view, overrides the general deduction available under Section 80IA(4)(iv) in respect of income falling within sub-section (1)(a) of Section 115BBG. Since the present ground is directed against the very taxability of the CER receipts, we do not consider it appropriate to enlarge the controversy beyond the
ITA 6717/MUM/2024 46 ITA 744, 745, 985,986/MUM/2026 M/s Kalpataru Projects International Ltd.
issue arising from the impugned addition. Any consequential computation shall be carried out by the Assessing Officer in accordance with law.
9.30 In the result, considering the statutory amendment contained in section 2(24)(xviii), the special statutory treatment provided by section 115BBG for income from transfer of carbon credits and on the amplitude of the expression “assistance ... by whatever name called”, we hold that the amount received by the assessee from transfer of CERs during the relevant previous year constitutes taxable income. The contention of the assessee that the receipt is a capital receipt outside the scope of the Act is accordingly rejected.
9.31 The grounds relating to taxability of CER receipts are accordingly dismissed and the order of the learned DRP/Assessing Officer on this issue is upheld, subject to the consequential computation in accordance with section 115BBG and the other applicable provisions of the Act.
Grounds No. 3 to 7 – Addition of ₹3,21,01,311 under section 69C of the Act 10. Grounds Nos. 3 to 7 relate to the addition of ₹3,21,01,311 made by the Assessing Officer under section 69C of the Act on account of alleged bogus expenditure incurred towards services obtained from M/s Parchalit Infra and Infomedia Pvt. Ltd. ('Parchalit Infra').).
ITA 6717/MUM/2024 47 ITA 744, 745, 985,986/MUM/2026 M/s Kalpataru Projects International Ltd.
10.1 The facts in brief qua the issue and dispute are that the assessee is engaged in the business of manufacturing, designing, supplying, erecting and commissioning power transmission line towers. During the relevant year, the assessee executed contracts, which were awarded (i) by Power Grid Corporation of India Limited under Work Order No. K-372; and (ii) by Bikaner Khetri Transmission Limited under Work Order No. K-373. The contracts were related to the supply and construction of transmission line towers at different locations in Rajasthan between ‘Bikaner’ and ‘Khetri’. The assessee submitted that the tower components had to be transported to remote locations where the towers were to be erected but the terrain at these locations was rough and difficult. According to the assessee, approach roads were therefore required to transport the tower components and machinery to the sites. The assessee claimed that it engaged 'Parchalit Infra' for providing road-related services at ‘Bhadla’ village, in Rajasthan. It claimed expenditure of ₹3,21,01,311 towards such services. The assessee furnished the ledger account of Infra', purchase order, invoices, bank statements 'Parchalit evidencing payment through banking channels. The assessee also relied upon other documents in support of the expenditure.
10.2 But the Assessing Officer was having in his stock information received from the Directorate General of Goods and Service Tax (GST) Intelligence, Bhubaneswar, concerning 'Parchalit Infra', which revealed that it was in the business of generating and issuing fake
ITA 6717/MUM/2024 48 ITA 744, 745, 985,986/MUM/2026 M/s Kalpataru Projects International Ltd.
invoices without supply of goods and services, leading to wrongful availing of ITC by others. In his report, the ld DG reported that the firm was reported to be non-existent/non-functioning at its registered premise and its only work was to provide bogus bills to beneficiaries. The modus operandi of these bogus billers was to provide bogus bills to beneficiaries on demand. These bogus bills were usually received by the beneficiaries, who would make an RTGS payment on these bogus bills into the bank account of these bogus firms, subsequent to which, cash was withdrawn by these operators from the banks after keeping a small commission, and the balance cash would be returned back to the beneficiaries.
10.3 The ld AO noted that the information indicated that 'Parchalit Infra’ was allegedly involved in issuing invoices without actual supply of goods or services and in facilitating wrongful availment of input tax credit. The Assessing Officer further noted that 'Parchalit Infra' was reported to be non-existent or non-functioning at its registered premises. According to the information received, the entity was allegedly engaged in providing accommodation entries through bogus invoices. For verification, the Assessing Officer issued notice under section 133(6) of the Act to 'Parchalit Infra', but no satisfactory response was received from the said party. The Assessing officer confronted this fact to the assessee, but no attempt was made to produce said party. The Assessing Officer therefore treated the transaction claimed by the assessee as not genuine. The Assessing
ITA 6717/MUM/2024 49 ITA 744, 745, 985,986/MUM/2026 M/s Kalpataru Projects International Ltd.
Officer also considered the documents furnished by the assessee. He was not satisfied that the documents established the actual rendering of services by 'Parchalit Infra'. The Assessing Officer relied upon the judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Sumati Dayal v. CIT (214 ITR 801) and applied the test of human probabilities. He held, in substance, that the mere fact that payment was made through banking channels did not establish the genuineness of the underlying transaction. He accordingly treated the expenditure of ₹3,21,01,311 as unexplained expenditure and made an addition under section 69C of the Act.
10.4 The assessee challenged the proposed addition before the learned DRP. The learned DRP noted that the Assessing Officer had received information from the GST authorities regarding 'Parchalit Infra'. The information indicated that 'Parchalit Infra' was a bogus billing entity and was engaged in issuing invoices without actual supply of goods or services. The learned DRP observed that the assessee had produced the ledger account, purchase orders, invoices, bank statements and photographs of the approach roads. However, according to the learned DRP, those documents did not establish the genuineness of the underlying transaction. The learned DRP held that payment through banking channels by itself could not establish that the services had actually been rendered by said party. It observed that, where the Department had material indicating that the supplier was a bogus entity, the assessee was required to
ITA 6717/MUM/2024 50 ITA 744, 745, 985,986/MUM/2026 M/s Kalpataru Projects International Ltd.
establish the actual rendering of services by that entity. The learned DRP also considered the assessee’s request for cross-examination. It noted that the Assessing Officer had issued notice under section 133(6) to 'Parchalit Infra' and that the notice had remained unserved. According to the learned DRP, this fact supported the information received from the GST authorities that 'Parchalit Infra’ was not functioning from its registered address. The learned DRP therefore rejected the assessee’s contention that the Assessing Officer had failed to make any enquiry. The learned DRP relied upon the following decisions referred by the AO in support of its conclusion that the right of cross-examination depends upon the facts of each case and the nature of the material relied upon and upheld the proposed addition:
(i) State of J&K vs Bakshi Gulam Mohd. (SC) and Nath International Sales vs UOI held that the right to hearing does not include the right to cross-examine. The right to cross examine depends on the individual facts of each case and the statute concerned. (ii) judgement in the case of M/s Manidhari Stainless Wire Private Limited vs UOI, the A.P. High Court has held: .."when the Revenue authorities have not placed reliance on oral evidence, then assessee cannot stretch the right of cross- examination to those persons who never made any examination-in-chief in the first place. (iii) judgement in the case of Amrapali Fincap Ltd (2016), where in it is held that when statements are relied upon by the Department as secondary evidence in collaboration with other evidences e.g. correlation with books, bank accounts, seized material etc. then the denial of the right to cross-examination cannot be taken as a plea not to make the addition.” 10.5 Before us, learned counsel for the assessee made the various arguments and filed written submissions.
ITA 6717/MUM/2024 51 ITA 744, 745, 985,986/MUM/2026 M/s Kalpataru Projects International Ltd.
10.6 On the issue of documents already filed in support of claim, the ld Counsel submitted that the assessee gave the Assessing Officer a copy of purchase order for Rs. 3,21,01,120/-, invoices raised by ‘Prachalit Infra’, bank statements showing payment through normal banking channels, and photographs of the approach road. The Assessing Officer did not examine or rebut any of those documents. He relied only on the GST department's information, without showing any link between that information and the assessee's own transaction with ‘Prachalit Infra’.
10.7 On the law governing bogus-purchase additions, the ld Counsel relied on the following decisions, each holding that an addition cannot rest on third-party information alone, without independent verification and without an opportunity to the assessee to meet that information:
PCIT v. Uni Packs (India) [2019] 108 taxmann.com 454 (Bom.) — where the addition rested only on material from the Sales Tax Department, and the Department had not offered its witnesses for cross-examination, the Bombay High Court upheld deletion of the addition. CIT v. Odeon Builders Pvt. Ltd. [2019] 110 taxmann.com 64 (SC) — the Supreme Court dismissed the Department's review petition where the disallowance rested solely on third- party information that the Assessing Officer had never independently verified, and where he had denied the assessee a copy of the statements relied upon. Geolife Organics v. ACIT [2017] 88 taxmann.com 756 (ITAT Mum.) — the Assessing Officer had brought no material of his own to show that the purchases were bogus; he had merely relied on the Sales Tax Department's information. Indravadan Hanjarimal Jain v. DCIT (2025) 180 taxmann.com 308 (ITAT Mum.) — once the assessee produces documentary evidence of a genuine transaction, the burden shifts to the Department to disprove it; mere suspicion does not suffice, citing Omar Salay Mohamed Sait v. CIT [1959] 37 ITR 151 (SC), Kishinchand Chellaram v. CIT [1980] 125 ITR 713 (SC), and Umacharan Shaw & Bros. v. CIT [1959] 37 ITR 271 (SC).
ITA 6717/MUM/2024 52 ITA 744, 745, 985,986/MUM/2026 M/s Kalpataru Projects International Ltd.
10.8 Ld. Counsel also relied on Siemens Engineering & Manufacturing Co. of India Ltd. v. UOI (1976) 2 SCC 981; PCIT v. Nitin Ramdeoji Lohia [2022] 145 taxmann.com 546 (Bom.); Sarwan Kumar Poddar v. UOI [2022] 142 taxmann.com 34 (Cal.); PCIT v. Shapoorji Pallonji & Co. Ltd. [2022] 141 taxmann.com 509 (SC); ACIT v. Mahesh K. Shah [2017] 88 taxmann.com 615 (ITAT Mum.); and Fancy Wear v. ITO [2017] 87 taxmann.com 183 (ITAT Mum.), each holding that an order passed without giving the assessee a chance to cross- examine an adverse witness breaches natural justice.
10.9 On non-service of notice to ‘Prachalit Infra’, Ld Counsel submitted that ‘Prachalit Infra’ and the assessee are independent parties. The assessee has no control over ‘Prachalit Infra’'s affairs. ‘Prachalit Infra’'s failure to reply to a departmental notice is a fact about ‘Prachalit Infra’, not about the assessee, and cannot by itself discredit the assessee's own genuine transaction.
10.10 Ld. Counsel also pointed to what he called a shift in the Department's own case. The assessment order, at one place, records that notice under Section 133(6) was served on ‘Prachalit Infra’ but ‘Prachalit Infra’ did not reply. The ld. DRP, however, proceeded on the footing that the notice was returned unserved. Ld. Counsel submitted that the addition cannot stand on a basis that even the Revenue's own authorities state inconsistently.
ITA 6717/MUM/2024 53 ITA 744, 745, 985,986/MUM/2026 M/s Kalpataru Projects International Ltd.
10.11 On Sumati Dayal (supra), ld Counsel submitted that the Assessing Officer misapplied this decision. Sumati Dayal (supra) concerned horse-race winnings, where the surrounding facts showed that the entire transaction was a colourable device. The decision permits the tax authorities to weigh human probabilities; it does not permit them to discard genuine documentary evidence merely because a third party has not responded to a notice.
10.12 On the scope of Section 69C, ld Counsel submitted that Section 69C applies only where the source of an expenditure is unexplained. Here, the source is not in dispute: the assessee paid ‘Prachalit Infra’ through its bank account, and this fact is on record. The Assessing Officer's real objection goes to the genuineness of the transaction, not to its source, and Section 69C does not cover that objection. Counsel relied on ITO v. Growel Energy Co. Ltd. [2014] 150 ITD 633 (Mum.), which holds that once an assessee furnishes full details of an expense with supporting documents, the basic condition for invoking Section 69C — an unexplained source — ceases to exist.
10.13 The learned Departmental Representative (DR) supported the orders of the Assessing Officer and the learned DRP. He submitted that the information received from the GST authorities was not a mere general allegation. The investigation had specifically identified ‘Parchalit Infra’ as an entity involved in issuing invoices without actual supply of goods or services. He submitted that the assessee
ITA 6717/MUM/2024 54 ITA 744, 745, 985,986/MUM/2026 M/s Kalpataru Projects International Ltd.
had merely produced a documentary trail of the transaction. Such documents could not establish actual rendering of services when the supplier itself was found to be a non-genuine entity. The learned DR further submitted that the assessee was required to establish the actual rendering of the services by way of producing that party being his witness rather than seeking cross examination from the AO. The photographs relied upon by the assessee of an alleged ‘kutcha’ road are stand alone picture, which did not establish road was constructed on that site or that ‘Parchalit Infra’ had constructed the approach roads. Further, those photographs further required verification either from the ‘Google earth photographs’ or from ‘satellite picture’ from Indian Space Research Organization (ISRO). He submitted that the assessee had not produced any independent certificate from the Power Grid Corporation of India Limited or the concerned project authority confirming that the approach roads were constructed by ‘Parchalit Infra’ as part of the assessee’s contractual obligations. He therefore submitted that the assessee had failed to discharge the burden cast upon it.
10.14 We have heard both sides and examined the record. The assessee has filed a paper trail: a purchase order, invoices, bank statements. This paper trail shows that money left the assessee's account and reached ‘Prachalit Infra’s account. It does not show, on its own, that ‘Prachalit Infra’ actually built the road. Even the photographs also don’t establish that Road was constructed by the
ITA 6717/MUM/2024 55 ITA 744, 745, 985,986/MUM/2026 M/s Kalpataru Projects International Ltd.
‘Prachalit Infra’. The Assessing officer made addition u/s 69C on the inference that when ‘Prachalit Infra’ issued only fake invoices , then the assessee must have got the work done from someone else in cash and source of such cash was not explained , and so said cash expenditure was liable as unexplained expenditure u/s 69C. Before us the ld Counsel also placed reliance on decision of Hon’ble Bombay High court in the case of Principal Commissioner of Income Tax v. Kanak Impex (India) Ltd. ,474 ITR 175 (Bom). But, the Assessing Officer, for his part, has not placed on record the outcome of the GST department's proceedings against ‘Prachalit Infra’. He has made the addition only on the ground that the notice sent under Section 133(6) came back unserved.
10.15 Before us, counsel for the assessee submitted that the DRP recorded this fact wrongly, and that the notice was in fact served on ‘Prachalit Infra’, which then simply chose not to reply. Whichever version is correct, the duty to prove that the expenditure was incurred wholly and for the purpose of the business rests on the assessee. The assessee could have produced ‘Prachalit Infra’ before the Assessing Officer, along with independent proof that the road was actually built by that party. It did not do so. The photographs the assessee filed show excavation machinery at a site; they do not, by themselves, prove that the approach road was built by ‘Prachalit Infra’. A certificate from Power Grid Corporation confirming that this road was needed, and was in fact built, for commercial reasons that
ITA 6717/MUM/2024 56 ITA 744, 745, 985,986/MUM/2026 M/s Kalpataru Projects International Ltd.
too by ‘Prachalit Infra’ would have gone a long way to establish the claim, but no such certificate is on record.
10.16 In these circumstances, the record before us is incomplete on both sides. The Revenue has not placed the GST investigation findings against ‘Prachalit Infra’ on record, and has not resolved the inconsistency pointed out by the assessee over whether notice to ‘Prachalit Infra’ was served or returned unserved. The assessee, equally, has not produced the kind of independent, third-party proof , such as a certificate from Power Grid Corporation, or the physical production of ‘Prachalit Infra’, that would settle the genuineness of the transaction one way or the other.
10.17 We accordingly consider it appropriate to restore this issue to the file of the Assessing Officer for fresh consideration. We direct the Assessing Officer to place on record the outcome of the GST department's proceedings against ‘Prachalit Infra’, to clarify whether notice under Section 133(6) was in fact served on ‘Prachalit Infra’ or returned unserved, and to decide the issue afresh after giving the assessee a fair opportunity to produce independent evidence — including, if available, a certificate from Power Grid Corporation or Bikaner Khetri Transmission Ltd. confirming the construction by ‘Prachalit Infra’ and commercial necessity of the approach road. The assessee shall be free to produce ‘Prachalit Infra’, or any other evidence it considers necessary, before the Assessing Officer. We
ITA 6717/MUM/2024 57 ITA 744, 745, 985,986/MUM/2026 M/s Kalpataru Projects International Ltd.
make no finding, at this stage, on the merits of the addition, as whether the Road was constructed by someone else and payment made to that party was liable for addition u/s 69C of the Act.
10.18 We set aside the addition of Rs. 3,21,01,311/- made under Section 69C of the Act, and restore the issue to the file of the Assessing Officer for fresh decision in terms of paragraph above, after giving the assessee a reasonable opportunity of being heard. Grounds Nos. 3 to 7 of the assessee's appeal are allowed for statistical purposes.
The next ground numbers 8 to 12 of the appeal were not pressed on behalf of the assessee and therefore same are dismissed as infructuous. 12. Before we proceed to adjudicate grounds related to transfer pricing adjustment, it is appropriate to understand profile of assessee and it’s Associated Enterprises (AEs) as under:
(a) the assessee, Kalpataru Power Transmission Limited (KPTL), is a public listed company engaged principally in engineering, procurement and construction (EPC) activities in the power transmission and distribution sector. Its principal functions include design and engineering, procurement, fabrication of transmission towers and other equipment, erection, installation, testing, commissioning and post-
ITA 6717/MUM/2024 58 ITA 744, 745, 985,986/MUM/2026 M/s Kalpataru Projects International Ltd.
commissioning operation and maintenance of transmission projects. The power transmission and distribution segment constitutes the core business of the assessee. The assessee also has operations in other infrastructure sectors, including oil and gas pipelines, railways and civil infrastructure. During the relevant period, it was also engaged in generation of electricity from biomass using agricultural waste. The assessee has a substantial international presence and its transmission business extends to several countries.
(b) The international transactions relevant to the present appeal were undertaken with various Associated Enterprises (AEs) of the assessee. The principal AEs involved in the transactions under consideration were Kalpataru Power Transmission Ukraine LLC (KPT Ukraine), Kalpataru Power (KPT USA), Transmission USA Inc. Kalpataru Power Transmission (Mauritius) Ltd. (KPT Mauritius) and Kalpataru IBN Omairah Company Ltd. (KPT IBN). KPT Ukraine and KPT USA were wholly-owned subsidiaries, KPT Mauritius was a subsidiary engaged in investment activities, and KPT IBN was a Saudi Arabian joint venture in which the assessee held 65% interest.
(c) KPT Ukraine was established principally for execution of transmission projects in Ukraine. It did not have manufacturing
ITA 6717/MUM/2024 59 ITA 744, 745, 985,986/MUM/2026 M/s Kalpataru Projects International Ltd.
facilities of its own. The transmission equipment required for the projects was sourced from the assessee, while KPT Ukraine undertook erection and assembling activities at the project sites through contractors and other supporting agencies. Thus, in the relevant transactions, the assessee principally undertook design, manufacture and supply of transmission equipment, whereas KPT Ukraine performed the local execution and erection functions in Ukraine.
(d) KPT USA was incorporated as the marketing subsidiary of the assessee for developing business in the USA, Canada and Latin American markets. Its principal functions included identification of business opportunities, liaison with prospective customers, collection of project and technical information, assistance in pre-qualification, communication with customers and support in arranging logistics and completion of projects. The assessee retained the decision-making authority in relation to acceptance or rejection of orders and the terms and conditions of contracts. KPT USA was accordingly characterised in the transfer pricing documentation as an agent providing liaison and marketing support services, while the assessee remained the full-fledged manufacturer and project executor.
(e) KPT Mauritius was established as an overseas subsidiary for exploring business opportunities and was in the initial stage
ITA 6717/MUM/2024 60 ITA 744, 745, 985,986/MUM/2026 M/s Kalpataru Projects International Ltd.
of its operations. During the relevant period, the assessee had provided an interest-free short-term advance to KPT Mauritius. The assessee's transfer pricing documentation characterised the advance as funding in the nature of quasi-equity, whereas the transfer pricing authorities treated it as a loan for determining its arm's length price.
(f) KPT IBN was incorporated in Saudi Arabia as a joint venture with IBN Omairah Contracting Company Limited, with the assessee holding 65% interest. The joint venture was formed to undertake turnkey transmission line and substation projects in Saudi Arabia. The assessee supplied galvanized steel towers and other bought-out items to KPT IBN for execution of its projects. KPT IBN also availed certain support in the form of manpower, machinery and vehicles from the assessee in connection with project execution.
12.1 Thus, the functional profile of the parties may broadly be summarised as follows: The assessee is the principal operating entity, undertaking the major functions of design, engineering, manufacturing, procurement and project execution and assuming substantial operational, market, foreign exchange, capacity utilisation, technology, inventory and customer-related risks. KPT Ukraine principally performs local erection and execution functions; KPT USA performs marketing and liaison functions; KPT Mauritius was
ITA 6717/MUM/2024 61 ITA 744, 745, 985,986/MUM/2026 M/s Kalpataru Projects International Ltd.
established for exploring business opportunities and received funding from the assessee in its initial stage; and KPT IBN undertakes transmission projects in Saudi Arabia with the benefit of supplies and certain support functions from the assessee. The detailed FAR analysis is relevant to the determination of the arm's length price of the respective international transactions and, therefore, the nature of each transaction, the findings of the TPO and the learned CIT(A), the rival submissions and our findings thereon are dealt with hereinafter under the respective grounds of appeal.
Grounds No. 13 to 18 – Transfer Pricing Adjustment in respect of Liaison Support Services received from KPT USA
The material facts qua the issue in dispute are that with a view to expanding into the American market, the assessee incorporated “KPT USA” as its wholly-owned subsidiary and in 2013 entered into a Liaison Services Agreement with it. Under the agreement, ‘KPT USA’ was required to identify projects in the American market, collect project data and technical specifications, obtain information regarding pre-qualification requirements and communicate the same to the assessee. The ‘KPT USA’ also acted as a communication interface between the assessee and prospective customers. The assessee retained the discretion to accept or reject the enquiries and to determine the terms and conditions of the contracts; it finally enters into in the United States, Canada, or Latin
ITA 6717/MUM/2024 62 ITA 744, 745, 985,986/MUM/2026 M/s Kalpataru Projects International Ltd.
America. In consideration of these services , which have been described at different points in the record as "liaison support services" and as "marketing support services" , the assessee agreed to pay a success fee of 3% of the net invoice value of each order obtained through efforts of ‘KPT USA’. The assessee benchmarked the transaction by using data obtained from the US Census Bureau/US Economic Census relating to commission earned by agents in the USA. According to the assessee, the comparable commission rates were in the range of 4.3% to 4.6%. The assessee therefore considered the payment of 3% to be at arm’s length.
13.1 The learned Transfer Pricing Officer ("TPO") did not accept the benchmarking adopted by the assessee. He examined the data relied upon by the assessee from the US Census/US Economic Census and questioned its comparability with the services rendered by ‘KPT USA’. The ld TPO was also not satisfied with the evidence regarding the actual rendition of services and the comparability of the data used for benchmarking. Following the approach adopted in the earlier years, the ld TPO determined 2% as the appropriate remuneration for the services and made a transfer-pricing adjustment in respect of the excess payment made by the assessee.
13.2 The ld DRP upheld the adjustment made by the ld TPO. The ld DRP observed that the data relied upon from the US Census related to different industries and could not, without further
ITA 6717/MUM/2024 63 ITA 744, 745, 985,986/MUM/2026 M/s Kalpataru Projects International Ltd.
examination, be treated as comparable uncontrolled transactions. The DRP also noted the alleged deficiency in establishing the actual rendition of services. The DRP relied, inter alia, upon the decision in of Ahemadad Bench of this Tribunal in Cadila Healthcare Ltd in IT (TP) No. 898/Ahd/2014 & 694/Ahd/2015 (Assessment Years 2009-10 & 2010-11) and confirmed the adjustment. The ld TPO and the ld DRP gave the following reasons for rejecting the assessee's benchmarking:
(a) the data used was of the year 2019, and could not be used to benchmark a transaction of Assessment Year 2021-22; (b) the comparables used were not drawn from the assessee's own line of business; (c) the figures underlying the benchmarking were based on estimated, rather than actual, sales and commission; (d) the assessee had not established that KPT USA had, in fact, rendered the services described in the Liaison Agreement; and (e) the TPO had followed the same approach, and arrived at the same 2% mark-up, in the assessee's own case for Assessment Years 2012-13, 2014-15, 2016-17, 2017-18, and 2020- 21. 13.3 Submissions on Behalf of the Assessee : Before us, learned counsel for the assessee submitted that this very issue stands decided in the assessee's own favour by the Co-ordinate Bench of this Tribunal for Assessment Year 2012-13, in ITA No. 2853 of 2017, and for Assessment Year 2014-15, in ITA No. 270 of 2020. It was submitted that in AY 2014-15 the Tribunal had considered the very nature of services rendered by KPT USA and the benchmarking
ITA 6717/MUM/2024 64 ITA 744, 745, 985,986/MUM/2026 M/s Kalpataru Projects International Ltd.
adopted by the assessee. The Tribunal had accepted the relevance of the US Census/US Economic Census data, particularly after noticing that the data was based on actual transactions and was not merely a notional or theoretical estimate and held the 3% success fee paid to KPT USA to be at arm's length, and deleted the addition made by the TPO and the AO on this account.
13.4 The learned counsel submitted that the services rendered by ‘KPT USA’ remained substantially the same and there was no change in the nature of the arrangement warranting a different approach in the year under consideration and the addition of Rs. 83,97,611/- should accordingly be deleted. It was accordingly submitted that the TPO was not justified in rejecting the benchmarking merely by referring to differences in industry or by questioning the data without examining whether the relevant transactions and services were comparable.
13.5 We have considered the rival submissions and carefully perused the material available on record, including the orders of the Co-ordinate Bench for Assessment Years 2012-13 and 2014-15. The dispute relates to the arm's length price of the liaison/support services rendered by KPT USA. Though the services have been described in the earlier years as Marketing Support Services, the nature of the activities referred to before us includes identification of
ITA 6717/MUM/2024 65 ITA 744, 745, 985,986/MUM/2026 M/s Kalpataru Projects International Ltd.
projects, collection of relevant information and specifications, obtaining pre-qualification details and interaction with customers.
13.6 We find that the Tribunal had occasion to consider the same issue in the assessee's own case for AY 2014-15. In that year also, the benchmarking exercise involved the data obtained from the US Census/US Economic Census. The Tribunal, after examining the material, took note of the fact that the data was based on actual transactions. Therefore, the data could not be rejected merely on the ground that it was obtained from the US Census. At the same time, the arm's length price has to be determined with reference to the comparability of the services and the transactions relevant to the year under consideration.
13.7 In the present case, the ld TPO proceeded largely on the basis of the approach adopted in the earlier years and determined the remuneration at 2%. The assessee, on the other hand, has relied upon the same US data and the decision of the Tribunal for AY 2014- 15.
13.8 We accept, in principle, the ratio laid down by the Co- ordinate Bench in the assessee's own case for Assessment Year 2014- 15, where in the Tribunal accepted the US Census Bureau and US Economic Census data as a sound basis for benchmarking the success fee paid to KPT USA, and held a rate of 3% to be at arm's length on that basis. We find no reason to take a different view of the
ITA 6717/MUM/2024 66 ITA 744, 745, 985,986/MUM/2026 M/s Kalpataru Projects International Ltd.
comparability of this data in principle, and we respectfully follow that ratio.
13.9 We are, however, unable to accept that this ratio can be applied to the year under appeal without first verifying the actual transactions executed during this year. The Tribunal's finding for Assessment Year 2014-15 rested on an examination of the data and the transactions actually placed before it for that year. The Comparable Uncontrolled Price (CUP) method, by its very nature, calls for a comparison between the price actually charged in the controlled transaction under examination and the price charged in comparable uncontrolled transactions; it is not a one-time finding that, once recorded for an earlier year, continues to hold good automatically for every subsequent year regardless of the transactions that actually took place in each such year. The volume and pattern of orders obtained through KPT USA, and the fee actually paid in respect of each, may vary from year to year, and it is these particulars, examined afresh for the year in question, that will show whether the 3% rate drawn from the Tribunal's earlier ratio truly reflects an arm's length price for this year.
13.10 We also note that the ld TPO raised certain objections that go beyond the mere rate of commission, in particular, the objection that the assessee has not established that KPT USA actually rendered the services described in the Liaison Agreement during the year. This
ITA 6717/MUM/2024 67 ITA 744, 745, 985,986/MUM/2026 M/s Kalpataru Projects International Ltd.
is a factual objection that was not, so far as the record before us shows, examined by the Co-ordinate Bench in the context of the particular transactions of the year now under appeal. It requires separate verification on the facts of this year, and cannot be answered merely by applying the ratio of an earlier year's order.
13.11 In these circumstances, we consider it appropriate neither to delete the addition outright, as the assessee seeks, nor to confirm it, as the Revenue seeks. We restore the issue to the file of the Assessing Officer/TPO, with a direction to decide it afresh in light of the ratio laid down by this Tribunal for Assessment Year 2014-15 — namely, that US Census Bureau and US Economic Census data of the kind relied upon by the assessee is, in principle, an acceptable basis for benchmarking the success fee paid to KPT USA. The Assessing Officer/TPO shall, in applying that ratio, examine the actual transactions executed during the year under appeal, the orders obtained through KPT USA, the invoice values on which the success fee was computed, and the evidence of services actually rendered by KPT USA in respect of each such order and shall re- determine the arm's length price on that basis, after affording the assessee a reasonable opportunity of being heard.
13.12 Grounds Nos. 13 to 18 of the assessee's appeal are allowed for statistical purposes. The transfer pricing adjustment of Rs. 83,97,611/- is set aside, and the issue is restored to the file of the
ITA 6717/MUM/2024 68 ITA 744, 745, 985,986/MUM/2026 M/s Kalpataru Projects International Ltd.
Assessing Officer/TPO for fresh determination in terms of paragraph above.
Transfer Pricing Adjustment on Interest on Advance to KPT Mauritius
Ground Nos. 19 to 23 relate to the transfer pricing adjustment made on account of interest on the advance given by the assessee to its Associated Enterprise, KPT Mauritius.
14.1 The material facts qua the issue in dispute are that the assessee had advanced an amount of USD 617,538, equivalent to ₹4,53,84,600, to its wholly owned subsidiary, ‘KPT Mauritius’. The assessee did not charge any interest on the said advance. It was explained that ‘KPT Mauritius’ was established to explore business opportunities for the assessee and was in the initial stage of its operations. According to the assessee, the amount was in the nature of funding for the subsidiary and was given in lieu of the proposed investment by way of equity.
14.2 The ld TPO rejected this characterisation and instead, treated the amount as a loan. He noted that the amount was recorded as a loan in the books of both the assessee and ‘KPT Mauritius’ and that there was no agreement providing for an interest-free advance. The ld TPO also considered the foreign exchange risk borne by the assessee and determined an arm's length rate of interest of 5.87%,
ITA 6717/MUM/2024 69 ITA 744, 745, 985,986/MUM/2026 M/s Kalpataru Projects International Ltd.
drawn from a loan-connector database, the ld TPO computed notional interest of Rs. 26,64,076/- and made a corresponding upward adjustment. The ld TPO also relied upon the orders of the Tribunal in the assessee's own case for AYs 2012-13 and 2014-15, wherein the advances to KPT Mauritius had been treated as loans and an interest adjustment had been upheld.
14.3 The ld DRP upheld the action of the TPO. It held that the purpose for which the funds were advanced and the source of the funds were not relevant for determining the arm's length price under the transfer pricing provisions. The ld DRP also agreed with the TPO that the treatment of the amount as a loan in the books of both the entities was relevant for determining its character. The adjustment made by the ld TPO was, accordingly, confirmed.
14.4 The reasons for arriving at finding of ld TPO and ld DRP could be summarised as under:
(a) no agreement exists between the assessee and KPT Mauritius providing for an interest-free advance; (b) the funds are recorded as a loan in the books of both parties, and this treatment in the books is the principal tool for characterising the transaction; (c) the assessee bears foreign-exchange risk, since its sales to its associated enterprises are denominated in US Dollars, and must accordingly be compensated for bearing that risk; the TPO added 1% to the benchmarked rate on this account;
ITA 6717/MUM/2024 70 ITA 744, 745, 985,986/MUM/2026 M/s Kalpataru Projects International Ltd.
(d) Rule 10B of the Income-tax Rules, 1962, governing comparability analysis, does not recognise the purpose or source of funding adopted by an associated enterprise as a relevant factor in determining the arm's length price; and (e) the Ahmedabad Bench of this Tribunal, in the assessee's own case for Assessment Years 2012-13 and 2014-15, has already upheld an identical adjustment on an identical advance to KPT Mauritius. 14.5 The learned counsel submitted that ‘KPT Mauritius’ was established to explore business opportunities for the assessee and was still in the initial stage of operations. It was, therefore, necessary for the assessee, as its promoter, to provide funds. It was also submitted that KPT Mauritius did not have the financial capacity to repay the amount and the funding was, in substance, in the nature of quasi-equity.
14.6 Before us, the learned counsel for the assessee fairly accepted that the issue of the character of the advance stands decided against the assessee by the Co-ordinate Bench of this Tribunal for Assessment Years 2012-13 and 2014-15, which held the advance to be a loan rather than quasi-equity, and upheld a transfer pricing adjustment on that footing.
14.7 Without prejudice to this position, and relying on the same orders of the Co-ordinate Bench, ld Counsel submitted that the rate of interest applied in those years was not a comparable loan rate drawn from a database, but the average USD LIBOR rate, and that
ITA 6717/MUM/2024 71 ITA 744, 745, 985,986/MUM/2026 M/s Kalpataru Projects International Ltd.
the adjustment ought to be correspondingly restricted in the year under appeal by applying the applicable LIBOR rate and not the rate adopted by the TPO. Ld Counsel placed before us the assessee's own working, filed before the TPO, showing the average USD LIBOR rate for Financial Year 2020-21 at 0.37%, and submitted that, applying the Co-ordinate Bench's own method, the addition should be limited to this rate rather than to the 5.87% rate adopted by the TPO.
14.8 In support of restricting the adjustment to the LIBOR rate, ld counsel relied on CIT v. Vaibhav Gems Ltd. [2017] 88 taxmann.com 12 (Raj.) (SLP dismissed by the Hon'ble Supreme Court, (2018) 99 taxmann.com 2); United Spirits Ltd. v. JCIT (2023) 149 taxmann.com 187 (ITAT Bang.); TVS Logistics Services Ltd. v. DCIT (2016) 72 taxmann.com 89 (ITAT Chennai); and ISG Noasoft Technologies Ltd. v. DCIT (2021) 128 taxmann.com 440 (ITAT Bang.) — each holding that, where an advance to a foreign associated enterprise is treated as a loan for transfer pricing purposes, the arm's length interest rate is properly benchmarked against the LIBOR rate applicable to the currency of the advance, rather than against domestic or third-party commercial lending rates.
14.9 Without prejudice, it was submitted that the benchmarking adopted by the TPO did not properly consider the volume and tenure of the advance, its purpose and other relevant comparability factors. Ld. Counsel additionally submitted, that the 1% addition for foreign-
ITA 6717/MUM/2024 72 ITA 744, 745, 985,986/MUM/2026 M/s Kalpataru Projects International Ltd.
exchange risk made by the TPO in the year under appeal, a feature absent from the adjustment sustained for Assessment Years 2012- 13 and 2014-15, is misconceived, since the comparables selected by the TPO are themselves denominated in the same currency as the advance to KPT Mauritius, so that no additional currency risk arises beyond what the LIBOR rate itself already reflects. The learned counsel accordingly prayed that the adjustment be deleted or, alternatively, be restricted to the average LIBOR rate of 0.37%.
14.10 We have considered the rival submissions and carefully perused the material available on record including the order of the Co-ordinate Bench of this Tribunal for Assessment Years 2012-13 and 2014-15. The learned counsel fairly submitted that the issue of charging interest on the advance given to KPT Mauritius has already been considered by the Tribunal in the assessee's own case for AYs 2012-13 and 2014-15 and has been decided against the assessee. We have also gone through the relevant findings of the coordinate Bench. The Tribunal has held that the advance given to ‘KPT Mauritius’ is in the nature of a loan and that an arm's length interest is required to be determined in respect thereof. The same issue arises in the year under consideration. No material has been brought before us to show any material change in the facts or the nature of the transaction so as to warrant a different view. Therefore, respectfully following the decision of the coordinate Bench in the assessee's own case, we hold that the interest-free advance given to ‘KPT Mauritius’
ITA 6717/MUM/2024 73 ITA 744, 745, 985,986/MUM/2026 M/s Kalpataru Projects International Ltd.
is required to be benchmarked for the purpose of determining its arm's length price. The assessee's contention that the advance was in the nature of quasi-equity or was given for promoting the business of KPT Mauritius has already been considered in the earlier proceedings and does not persuade us to take a different view.
14.11 The learned counsel has, however, submitted that, even if the transaction is treated as a loan, the rate of interest should be restricted to the average USD LIBOR rate of 0.37%. The assessee's submission on this point does not seek to reopen the question already decided against it; it seeks only to apply, in this year, the very method that the Co-ordinate Bench itself applied in the two earlier years, namely, benchmarking the interest rate against the average LIBOR rate for the relevant currency, rather than against a rate drawn from a database of third-party commercial loans. We find this submission to be well-founded. An advance denominated in US Dollars, extended by an Indian parent to its wholly-owned foreign subsidiary, is not comparable, without more, to a commercial loan extended by an independent lender to an independent borrower on ordinary banking terms; the LIBOR rate, being the benchmark rate at which banks themselves lend to one another in the relevant currency, is the more apposite comparable for an intra-group advance of this kind, and this is the method that the Co-ordinate Bench itself adopted in the assessee's own case.
ITA 6717/MUM/2024 74 ITA 744, 745, 985,986/MUM/2026 M/s Kalpataru Projects International Ltd.
14.12 As to the TPO's addition of 1% to the benchmarked rate on account of foreign-exchange risk, we find force in the assessee's submission that this addition is not warranted. The comparables on which the ld TPO himself relies are stated to be denominated in the same currency as the advance in question; there is accordingly no additional, uncompensated currency mismatch of the kind that an exchange-risk premium is meant to address.
14.13 However, both the aspects have to be considered in the light of the findings of the coordinate Bench and the rate ultimately applicable to the transaction in the year under consideration. We accordingly, direct the ld AO/TPO that the arm's length rate of interest on the advance to KPT Mauritius be computed with reference to the average USD LIBOR rate for Financial Year 2020-21, in the light of earlier years decision in the case of assessee and to restrict the upward adjustment accordingly.
14.14 In the result, Ground Nos. 19 to 23 are dismissed, subject to the above direction regarding computation of the adjustment in accordance with the applicable rate determined in terms of the Tribunal's earlier orders.
Interest on Trade Advance to KPT Ukraine
ITA 6717/MUM/2024 75 ITA 744, 745, 985,986/MUM/2026 M/s Kalpataru Projects International Ltd.
Ground Nos. 24 to 26 relate to the transfer pricing adjustment made on account of interest on the trade advance given by the assessee to its Associated Enterprise, KPT Ukraine.
15.1 The material facts qua the issue in dispute are that the business structure in Ukraine involved two constituent entities: a Ukraine branch office, which, being a branch, is an extension of the assessee and offers all its profit to tax in India; and ‘KPT Ukraine’, a wholly-owned subsidiary. Owing to local customs and indirect-tax considerations, towers manufactured in India could not be transferred directly to the branch office; instead, KPT Ukraine procured the towers from the assessee and supplied them to the branch office, which then invoiced the end customer for both the towers and the erection and commissioning work. KPT Ukraine functioned as a limited-risk service provider in this chain, retaining little or no profit, with the entrepreneurial profit being booked and taxed in the branch office's hands in India.
15.2 As of March 2019, KPT Ukraine owed the assessee's head office UAH 45 million as trade payable for towers procured, while the branch office owed KPT Ukraine UAH 35 million as trade receivable for towers supplied. To move funds from Ukraine to India, KPT Ukraine collected UAH 45 million from the branch office, including the UAH 35 million receivable and remitted it to the assessee's head office. This left a net balance of approximately UAH 10 million due
ITA 6717/MUM/2024 76 ITA 744, 745, 985,986/MUM/2026 M/s Kalpataru Projects International Ltd.
from KPT Ukraine, which the branch office had advanced to it with the expectation that the balance would be set off against supplies on future projects.
15.3 It is this amount, which has been considered as a trade advance of UAH 1,01,70,000, equivalent to ₹2,68,70,869, to KPT Ukraine. It was explained that the advance was given in the ordinary course of the business and was intended to be adjusted against supplies under upcoming projects. The advance was expected to be settled through supplies under subsequent projects. However, owing to political unrest (including armed conflict in 2019, the constitutional crisis since 2020 and subsequently the Russia- Ukraine war in 2022, the conditions had not been conducive for business opportunities in Ukraine, with the contemplated projects could not be executed and the trade advance remained outstanding. The assessee accordingly considered the arm's length price of interest at nil under the ‘Other Method’ as most appropriate method. 15.4 It was submitted that that considering peculiar facts of the case, even if the amount were advanced to the third party due to unavoidable circumstances, the assessee would not be able recover amount or charge interest on it. Thus, the transaction cannot be compared with loan simplicitor and therefore no adjustment on account of notional interest can be made. Further, for the reasons beyond the control of the assessee (i.e. war situation) advances were
ITA 6717/MUM/2024 77 ITA 744, 745, 985,986/MUM/2026 M/s Kalpataru Projects International Ltd.
held in the books and so ALP of interest on such advances cannot be benchmarked by comparing rate with interest chargeable on loans.
15.5 The ld TPO did not accept the assessee's claim that no interest was chargeable on the outstanding trade advance. According to the ld TPO, the outstanding trade advance constituted a separate international transaction and its arm's length price was required to be determined separately. The ld TPO benchmarked the transaction using the Loan Connector database and determined an arm's length interest rate of 3.12%. He also made an addition of 1% towards foreign exchange risk. On this basis, an adjustment of ₹9,05,548 was proposed. The ld TPO proceeded on the basis that the amount described as a trade advance did not dispense with the requirement of determining its arm's length price. The assessee's explanation regarding the purpose of the advance and the circumstances in which it remained outstanding was not accepted.
15.6 The ld DRP upheld this adjustment. It held that (a) the arm's length price of each international transaction must be determined separately, and the outstanding trade advance is a distinct transaction in its own right; (b) the assessee bears foreign-exchange risk and must be compensated for it; and (c) the comparability analysis mandated by Rule 10B does not recognise the purpose or source of a transaction adopted by an associated enterprise as a relevant factor in determining its arm's length price. On the foreign-
ITA 6717/MUM/2024 78 ITA 744, 745, 985,986/MUM/2026 M/s Kalpataru Projects International Ltd.
exchange point, the ld DRP reasoned that since the funds, once uncollected, remain applied in India, the interest itself accrues in India and in Indian currency, justifying the additional 100 basis points.
15.7 Before us , learned counsel for the assessee submitted, first, that the advance is not a loan but a trade advance, arising out of a genuine commercial arrangement for the supply of towers, and remaining unsettled only because political unrest and war made it impossible to execute the projects against which it was to be set off. Even an unrelated party, placed in the same position, would neither recover such an advance nor be in a position to charge interest on it; the extraordinary circumstances that froze the underlying commercial arrangement cannot be treated as if they had no bearing on what an arm's length party would do. Second, counsel submitted that the TPO's fresh benchmarking exercise, conducted on a loan- connector database, did not account for the qualitative factors proper to comparability — tenor, volume, purpose, and the industry of the loan. The database search itself suffered, on the record, from the following defects: the TPO did not disclose the search steps or the accept-reject matrix; the comparables included arrangements with "general purpose" and "leveraged buyout" descriptions, which bear no resemblance to a trade advance; the comparables were drawn from the general manufacturing sector, whereas the assessee operates in the EPC sector; and the comparables ranged from USD 3
ITA 6717/MUM/2024 79 ITA 744, 745, 985,986/MUM/2026 M/s Kalpataru Projects International Ltd.
million to USD 15,000/- million in volume, against a tested transaction of roughly USD 350,000/-, a range so wide as to show that no genuine qualitative screening was carried out. Ld Counsel submitted that banks themselves, in their responses under Section 133(6), confirm that cost of funds, risk, tenor, market conditions, and the borrower's industry all bear on the interest actually charged, precisely the factors the TPO's exercise ignored. Third, and without prejudice to the foregoing, counsel submitted that the TPO's addition of 1% for foreign-exchange risk is arbitrary and unexplained, particularly since the comparables selected by the TPO are themselves denominated in foreign currency, so that no uncompensated currency mismatch remains to be addressed by a further loading. Fourth, and in the further alternative, counsel submitted that even if some interest adjustment is to be sustained, it should be restricted to the average USD LIBOR rate for Financial Year 2020-21, namely 0.37%, since the assessee is not in the business of lending or financing, relying on CIT v. Vaibhav Gems Ltd. [2017] 88 taxmann.com 12 (Raj.) (SLP dismissed, (2018) 99 taxmann.com 2 (SC)); United Spirits Ltd. v. JCIT (2023) 149 taxmann.com 187 (ITAT Bang.); TVS Logistics Services Ltd. v. DCIT (2016) 72 taxmann.com 89 (ITAT Chennai); and ISG Noasoft Technologies Ltd. v. DCIT (2021) 128 taxmann.com 440 (ITAT Bang.).
15.8 We have considered the rival submissions and carefully perused the material available on record. There is no dispute that the
ITA 6717/MUM/2024 80 ITA 744, 745, 985,986/MUM/2026 M/s Kalpataru Projects International Ltd.
amount given to KPT Ukraine was recorded as a trade advance. The assessee has explained the commercial purpose for which the advance was given and the circumstances in which it remained outstanding. The explanation is that the advance was to be adjusted against supplies under future projects, but the projects could not materialise because of the extraordinary political and business conditions prevailing in Ukraine. We find the character of this advance to be materially different from an advance made purely for financing purposes. It did not originate as a loan; it arose from a running commercial arrangement for the supply of towers between the assessee's own branch office and its subsidiary, and was, on the assessee's uncontroverted explanation, intended to be set off against supplies on future projects rather than repaid with interest. It became outstanding, and remained outstanding, only because political unrest, constitutional crisis, and ultimately war made the anticipated projects impossible to execute, circumstances entirely outside the assessee's control and outside any arrangement between the assessee and KPT Ukraine.
15.9 We are unable to accept the ld DRP's view that such extraordinary circumstances fall outside the scope of comparability analysis under Rule 10B. Rule 10B(2) expressly directs that comparability be judged with reference to, among other things, the conditions prevailing in the markets in which the respective parties operate. A country in the grip of armed conflict and constitutional
ITA 6717/MUM/2024 81 ITA 744, 745, 985,986/MUM/2026 M/s Kalpataru Projects International Ltd.
crisis is not offering ordinary market conditions, and an arm's length comparison that ignores this reality is not a comparison between like and like. The DRP's observation that Rule 10B does not recognise the "purpose and source" of an associated enterprise's transaction addresses a different point altogether, it is well established that an associated enterprise's subjective purpose in structuring a transaction cannot be used to avoid the arm's length standard. But that principle has no bearing on whether the surrounding market and economic conditions, which Rule 10B(2)(d) itself requires to be considered, point to a different arm's length outcome.
15.10 For the same reason, we do not accept that a trade advance of this kind can simply be run through a database of commercial loan agreements, without first asking the only question that the arm's length principle actually poses: what would an unrelated party, placed in the same commercial relationship and facing the same extraordinary disruption, actually have done? If independent trade creditors, confronted with a counterparty whose business has been frozen by war or comparable upheaval, do not in fact charge interest on advances left outstanding in these circumstances, that is the comparable the law requires, not the yield on an ordinary working- capital loan negotiated between willing lenders and borrowers in stable market conditions.
ITA 6717/MUM/2024 82 ITA 744, 745, 985,986/MUM/2026 M/s Kalpataru Projects International Ltd.
15.11 The question before us is, therefore, not merely whether an outstanding amount due from an AE can constitute an international transaction. The real question is what would have been the arm's length consideration, if any, for such a trade advance in comparable uncontrolled circumstances.
15.12 The arm's length principle requires the controlled transaction to be compared with a comparable uncontrolled transaction. Under Rule 10B, the comparison has to take into account the characteristics of the transaction, the contractual terms, the functions and risks of the parties and the conditions prevailing in the relevant market. Where the differences materially affect the price, such differences have either to be reasonably adjusted or the comparable transaction cannot be relied upon. Therefore, a trade advance cannot automatically be benchmarked against an ordinary loan merely because the amount has remained outstanding for a considerable period. A loan is ordinarily advanced for financing purposes, whereas a trade advance may arise from an underlying commercial transaction and may be intended to be adjusted against future supplies.
15.13 In the present case, the assessee has specifically relied upon the exceptional circumstances prevailing in Ukraine. The assessee's case is that the advance would have been adjusted against supplies had the projects proceeded, but the business itself came to a
ITA 6717/MUM/2024 83 ITA 744, 745, 985,986/MUM/2026 M/s Kalpataru Projects International Ltd.
standstill. It has further been submitted that, in these circumstances, even an independent third party similarly placed would not have been in a position to recover the advance or charge interest on it. This contention cannot be accepted or rejected merely on the basis of the assertion of either side. It requires examination from the standpoint of an uncontrolled transaction.
15.14 In our view, the appropriate exercise would be to examine whether there was, during the relevant period, any comparable uncontrolled transaction involving a trade advance under similar commercial circumstances, where the advance remained outstanding and no interest was charged because the underlying transaction could not be completed owing to political unrest, war or any other comparable extraordinary event. If such an uncontrolled transaction is available, it would have direct relevance for determining the arm's length price. If there are material differences, the same have to be appropriately considered in accordance with Rule 10B. The mere availability of loan transactions in a database cannot by itself establish their comparability with the present trade advance.
15.15 At the same time, the assessee's claim that the arm's length interest should necessarily be nil also cannot be accepted merely because the advance was described as a trade advance or because the business could not ultimately be carried out. The assessee has to establish, on the basis of comparable uncontrolled circumstances,
ITA 6717/MUM/2024 84 ITA 744, 745, 985,986/MUM/2026 M/s Kalpataru Projects International Ltd.
that an independent party in a similar situation would likewise have neither charged nor paid interest. The Tribunal has, in appropriate cases, accepted a nil arm's length price where the peculiar nature and circumstances of the transaction were such that an equivalent transaction between independent parties would also not have carried interest.
15.16 In the present case, however, the ld TPO has not examined the transaction from this perspective. He has proceeded with loan comparables from the Loan Connector database. The material placed before us also indicates that the database contained transactions having different purposes, amounts, tenures and industry characteristics. The assessee has specifically pointed out that several comparables related to general-purpose, working-capital or leveraged-buyout loans, whereas the transaction before us arose from a trade arrangement in the EPC business. In these circumstances, we are of the view that the existing benchmarking exercise does not provide a reliable basis for determining the arm's length price of the impugned transaction.
15.17 We, therefore, restore the issue to the file of the AO/TPO for fresh determination. The AO/TPO shall first examine the true nature of the transaction and the circumstances in which the trade advance remained outstanding. Thereafter, the arm's length price shall be determined by applying the most appropriate method and by
ITA 6717/MUM/2024 85 ITA 744, 745, 985,986/MUM/2026 M/s Kalpataru Projects International Ltd.
considering comparable uncontrolled transactions having similar commercial and economic circumstances. In particular, the AO/TPO shall examine whether an independent party, in a comparable trade arrangement and faced with similar political or other extraordinary circumstances resulting in failure of the underlying business transaction, would have charged interest on the outstanding trade advance. If an appropriate uncontrolled comparable is available, the same shall be considered after making reasonably accurate adjustments for material differences, if any. The issue of the additional 1% towards foreign exchange risk shall also be reconsidered in the fresh benchmarking exercise. Such adjustment cannot be made merely on an ad-hoc basis and must have a proper basis in the comparable uncontrolled transaction and the relevant risk assumed by the assessee. Needless to say, the assessee shall be afforded reasonable opportunity of being heard and shall be permitted to furnish relevant comparable data and supporting material. Accordingly, Ground Nos. 24 to 26 are allowed for statistical purposes. Corporate Guarantee Commission – KPT Sweden and KP IBN 16. Ground Nos. 27 to 31 relate to the transfer pricing adjustment made on account of corporate guarantee commission in respect of guarantees furnished by the assessee on behalf of its Associated Enterprises, Kalpataru Power Transmission Sweden AB (KPT Sweden) and Kalpataru IBN Omairah Company Limited (KP IBN).
ITA 6717/MUM/2024 86 ITA 744, 745, 985,986/MUM/2026 M/s Kalpataru Projects International Ltd.
16.1 The facts qua the issue in dispute are that the assessee had given performance guarantee on behalf of its subsidiaries - Kalpataru Power Transmission Sweden AB (KPT Sweden) and Kalpataru IBN Omairah Company Limited (KP IBN). The assessee acquired 85% stake in LMG Sweden, a Swedish EPC group with over 25 years' experience in the transmission and distribution sector, through its wholly-owned subsidiary KPT Sweden. In June 2019, Nordic Guarantee Insurance Company Limited issued a performance guarantee of SEK 17,83,79,958/- in favour of LMG Sweden, for the execution of its contracts with Svenska Kraftnät, the Swedish electricity transmission authority. The assessee, in turn, gave a counter-guarantee to Nordic Guarantee, and charged KPT Sweden a commission of 0.4% for doing so.
16.2 Similarly, the assessee gave a counter-guarantee to Saudi British Bank in respect of a performance guarantee that bank had issued in favour of Saudi Electricity Company, for a contract to be executed by KP IBN. The assessee charged KP IBN a commission of 0.5% for this counter-guarantee. In both cases, the assessee's exposure is secondary, it is liable only if the subsidiary itself defaults in performance and in both cases, the underlying guarantee is a performance guarantee furnished as a standard pre-condition for signing an EPC contract, not a financial guarantee securing repayment of a loan.
ITA 6717/MUM/2024 87 ITA 744, 745, 985,986/MUM/2026 M/s Kalpataru Projects International Ltd.
16.3 The assessee had charged guarantee commission at 0.40% from KPT Sweden and 0.50% from KP IBN. The assessee benchmarked the transactions under the CUP method by comparing the rates charged to its Associated Enterprises with the rates at which banks had charged the assessee for guarantee facilities. According to the assessee, the average rate under these arrangements was around 0.30% and, therefore, the rates of 0.40% and 0.50% charged to the AEs were at arm's length. The assessee also contended that the guarantees were performance counter- guarantees connected with EPC contracts and were not in the nature of ordinary financial guarantees. 16.4 The learned Transfer Pricing Officer ("TPO") rejected this benchmarking. He issued notices under Section 133(6) to several banks, sought their guarantee-commission rates, and on the responses received, arrived at a median arm's length rate of 1.5% per annum. Applying this rate, he computed the arm's length commission for KPT Sweden at Rs. 2,37,94,500/- (against Rs. 60,71,354/- actually charged) and for KP IBN at Rs. 51,58,500/- (against Rs. 3,16,309/- actually charged), resulting in a combined upward adjustment of Rs. 2,25,65,337/-. 16.5 The TPO, inter-alia, took the view that the assessee had not furnished sufficient documentary evidence in support of the rates adopted by it. He also considered the rates obtained from banks to
ITA 6717/MUM/2024 88 ITA 744, 745, 985,986/MUM/2026 M/s Kalpataru Projects International Ltd.
be relevant for benchmarking the guarantee transaction. The TPO did not accept the assessee's contention that the performance guarantee could not be compared with financial guarantee transactions.
16.6 The DRP upheld the adjustment, holding, in substance, that: the assessee had not furnished documentary evidence supporting its own benchmarking or the underlying guarantee agreements at the assessment stage; the deed of indemnity for KPT Sweden related to Financial Year 2019-20 rather than the year under appeal; transfer pricing being "an art rather than an exact science," comparability standards need not be applied strictly; a financial guarantee and a performance guarantee may both be used as comparables, since both fasten a contingent liability on the guarantor; and the median rate of 1.5%, drawn from the banks' responses, represented the arm's length rate.
16.7 The DRP did not accept the assessee's contention that the rates adopted by the TPO were not comparable merely because they included financial as well as performance guarantees.
16.8 The primary reasonings of the Ld. TPO/AO and DRP are as follows: a. The assessee has not provided any documentary supported evidences for the basis of rate determined for benchmarking purpose and not provided documents pertaining to the guarantee given by assessee to its subsidiaries. b. The deed on indemnity for the performance guarantee given on behalf of KPT Sweden was for FY 2019-20 and not for FY 2020-21 i.e. the relevant year. The comparables selected are of FY 2019-20 basis the logic that the decision of pricing the guarantee
ITA 6717/MUM/2024 89 ITA 744, 745, 985,986/MUM/2026 M/s Kalpataru Projects International Ltd.
commission percentage was undertaken on existing arrangements with banks during that period, however under Indian Income tax act only current year comparables must be taken for comparability. c. Transfer pricing is not exact science, it is an art and therefore the standards of comparability should not be applied very strictly. d. While the assessee mentioned that the Ld. TPO has not followed the parameters to be followed in CUP method, but ld DRP held that the assessee’s benchmarking is almost identical, based on quotes received from various banks e. The comparable can be of either financial and performance guarantee for comparison of the assessee’s transaction of performance guarantee since both cases result in fastening of liability on assessee. f. Based on the responses given by various banks towards the aforesaid notice u/s 133(6), the Ld. TPO and subsequently ld DRP arrived at an arm’s length commission rate with median of 1.5%. g. Accordingly, the Ld. TPO and ld DRP made an upward adjustment of Rs. 2,25,65,337/- in the value of corporate guarantee commission charged by the assessee as shown under: Commissi ALP on Rate Commission Commission Name Amount in Comm Adjustment charged Amount at ALP of AE INR ission (INR) by (INR) (INR) Rate Appellant KP 1,58,63,00,000 0.40% 60,71,354 1.50% 2,37,94,500 1,77,23,146 Sweden KP 34,39,00,000 0.50% 3,16,309 1.50% 51,58,500 48,42,191 IBN Total Adjustment 2,25,65,337
16.9 The learned counsel submitted that the assessee had an internal CUP in the form of actual guarantee arrangements entered into by the assessee with various banks. According to him, the rates under those arrangements were negotiated rates and were therefore more reliable than the standard rates obtained by the TPO from
ITA 6717/MUM/2024 90 ITA 744, 745, 985,986/MUM/2026 M/s Kalpataru Projects International Ltd.
banks under section 133(6). It was submitted that the average rate under the assessee's actual bank arrangements was around 0.30% and, therefore, the rates of 0.40% and 0.50% charged to the AEs were reasonable. 16.10 Before us, learned counsel for the assessee advanced the following submissions: 1. On the nature of the transaction: The guarantees in question are performance guarantees, furnished as a standard condition precedent to signing an EPC contract, and not financial guarantees securing repayment of a loan. The TPO's benchmarking conflated the two, relying substantially on financial-guarantee rates quoted by banks. 2. On the DRP's "Other Method" observation: The DRP recorded, at paragraph 13.3.3 of its order, that recourse to an indirect method such as the ‘Other Method’ is impermissible where a direct method such as CUP is available. The ld Counsel submitted that this observation proceeds on a mistaken premise, since the assessee has throughout applied the Comparable Uncontrolled Price method, not the Other Method, and the DRP's remark accordingly does not address the assessee's actual case. 3. On Rule 10B comparability: ld Counsel submitted that the TPO's benchmarking fails each of the specific comparability factors set out in Rule 10B(2): it compares the assessee's performance guarantee with standard, unnegotiated bank rack-rates rather than an actual, executed, comparable transaction; it does not match the specific characteristics of the transaction, since performance and financial guarantees are conflated; it does not have regard to the functions, assets, and risks of the parties, since the assessee's exposure is secondary and arises from an EPC contract, not a primary lending relationship; no contractual terms are available for comparison, since rack-rates are not backed by any agreement; and no account is taken of the conditions prevailing in the EPC industry specifically, as against the general lending market from which the TPO's comparables are drawn. 4. On internal comparability: ld Counsel submitted that generally accepted transfer pricing principles prefer internal comparability i.e. the assessee's own actual, negotiated agreements with its bankers, over external comparability drawn from unrelated rack- rates, and that the ld TPO and ld DRP have given no substantive reason for preferring the latter over the former here.
ITA 6717/MUM/2024 91 ITA 744, 745, 985,986/MUM/2026 M/s Kalpataru Projects International Ltd.
On the specific bank responses relied upon by the TPO: The learned counsel further submitted that the information obtained by the TPO under section 133(6) consisted largely of standard or rack rates. Such rates were subject to negotiation depending upon the type of guarantee, amount, geography, creditworthiness, business relationship and other commercial factors. It was submitted that the TPO had selected the higher rates from the range furnished by the banks without undertaking a proper comparability analysis under Rule 10B. Ld Counsel took us through each bank's response and submitted that the TPO had, in each case, selected the highest rate quoted, without regard to the qualifying conditions attached to it: (a) Union Bank quoted a tiered schedule — 1.2% per annum for guarantees up to USD 5 lakh, 0.6% between USD 5 lakh and USD 2 million, and 0.4% above USD 2 million. The guarantee in question, being of the order of USD 17 million, falls within the lowest tier, yielding a comparable rate of 0.4% — not the 1.2% rate (applicable only to the smallest guarantees) that the TPO in fact adopted. (b) State Bank of India furnished 56 different rates, varying with credit rating, guarantee amount, guarantee type, and tenor, and expressly noted that high-value guarantees may attract a concessional rate on approval. The TPO selected 2.55% — a financial-guarantee rate for guarantees up to USD 2,50,000 — while the assessee's own executed agreement with SBI fixes the rate at 0.30%. (c) ICICI Bank quoted a range of 0.10% to 3.00%, expressly dependent on risk, credit rating, geography, tenor, and value, while the assessee's own executed agreement with ICICI fixes the rate at 0.35%. The TPO selected the top of the range, 3.00%. (d) Standard Chartered Bank quoted a range of 0.25% to 0.75%, again dependent on multiple factors and without a usable objective criterion; the TPO selected the top of this range, 0.75%, as well. (e) HDFC Bank quoted a standard rate of 1.8%, but its sample agreements were for financial borrowings of EUR 10,000 to 100,000 — small-value transactions bearing no resemblance to the USD 17 million guarantee under consideration. (f) Citi Bank quoted two distinct rates — 0.90% for financial guarantees and 0.45% for performance guarantees — yet the TPO adopted the financial-guarantee rate of 0.90%, notwithstanding that the transaction under consideration is a performance guarantee. (g) IDBI Bank's quoted rates related to small-value guarantees of Rs. 2,00,000 to Rs. 6,00,000, again bearing no relation to the transaction in question.
ITA 6717/MUM/2024 92 ITA 744, 745, 985,986/MUM/2026 M/s Kalpataru Projects International Ltd.
On a without-prejudice recomputation confined to banks that furnished an objective, transaction-specific rate (SBI at 0.30%, ICICI at 0.35%, Union Bank at 0.40%, Citi Bank at 0.45%, and Yes Bank at 0.24%), ld counsel submitted that the average works out to 0.35%, and that even on a broader recomputation including the standard rack-rates of the remaining banks, the arm's length range works out to 0.40%–0.45% — in either case comfortably accommodating the assessee's own rates of 0.4% and 0.5%. 7. On judicial precedent distinguishing bank and corporate guarantees: ld Counsel relied on a substantial body of authority — including the jurisdictional Bombay High Court in CIT v. Everest Kento Cylinders Ltd. [2015] 58 taxmann.com 254 (Bom.) and PCIT v. Concentrix Services India (P.) Ltd. [2019] 102 taxmann.com 575 (Bom.), as also Thomas Cook (India) Ltd. v. ACIT [2016] 69 taxmann.com 443 (Mum-Trib.), Glenmark Pharmaceuticals Ltd. [TS-329-ITAT-2013(Mum)-TP], IL&FS Transportation Networks Ltd. v. ACIT [2021] 128 taxmann.com 475 (Mum-Trib.), 63 Moons Technologies Ltd. v. DCIT [2022] 137 taxmann.com 278 (Mum-Trib.), JSW Steel Ltd. v. DCIT [2023] 153 taxmann.com 17 (Mum-Trib.), Crayon Group AS v. ACIT [2023] 153 taxmann.com 345 (Mum-Trib.), Anand NVH Products (P.) Ltd. v. DCIT [2024] 169 taxmann.com 684 (Del- Trib.), and DCIT v. Bank of Tokyo Mitsubishi UFJ Ltd. [2021] 133 taxmann.com 517 (Del-Trib.) — holding uniformly that a corporate guarantee issued by a parent for the benefit of its subsidiary is not comparable to a bank guarantee issued by a commercial bank, since a bank bears the full risk and performs the full range of functions of an independent guarantor, whereas a parent's guarantee is typically a secondary, back- stopping obligation. 8. On the rate itself: ld Counsel further relied on a long line of decisions accepting a corporate guarantee commission in the range of 0.2% to 0.5% as being at arm's length — including CIT v. Reliance Industries Ltd. [2024] 161 taxmann.com 423 (Bom.) (0.38%), Asian Paints Ltd. v. ACIT [2014] 41 taxmann.com 71 (Mum-Trib.) (0.20%), Greatship (India) Ltd. v. ACIT [2022] 142 taxmann.com 143 (Mum-Trib.) (0.40%), Laqshya Media (P.) Ltd. v. DCIT [2017] 80 taxmann.com 309 (Mum-Trib.) (0.20%–0.50% range), DCIT v. Lanco Infratech Ltd. [2017] 81 taxmann.com 381 (Hyd-Trib.) (0.27%), DCIT v. Berger Paints India Ltd. [2022] 142 taxmann.com 279 (Kol-Trib.) (0.35%), and a further series of decisions accepting 0.5% as the arm's length rate, including Cadila Pharmaceuticals Ltd. [2024] 164 taxmann.com 52 (Ahd-Trib.), Rubamin Ltd. [2021] 131 taxmann.com 344 (Ahd-Trib.), Tata Consultancy Services Ltd. [2024] 163 taxmann.com 671 (Mum- Trib.), and PMP Auto Components (P.) Ltd. v. DCIT [2019] 107 taxmann.com 520 (Mum-Trib.), among others. Without prejudice, the learned counsel submitted that several judicial decisions have accepted guarantee commission rates in the range of 0.20% to 0.50%. It was therefore submitted that, even if an adjustment was considered necessary, the rate should not exceed 0.50%. 9. On an identical issue in AY 2020-21: Ld Counsel submitted that the learned CIT(A), for Assessment Year 2020-21, considered this very transaction on identical facts and deleted the addition, holding that the TPO's benchmarking was "arbitrary in nature and not scientific," that an available internal CUP ought to have been examined first,
ITA 6717/MUM/2024 93 ITA 744, 745, 985,986/MUM/2026 M/s Kalpataru Projects International Ltd.
and relying on the same body of authority now pressed before us, including Asian Paints Ltd. (supra). 10. On the KP IBN peri, finally, and independently of the rate dispute, ld counsel submitted that the guarantee in favour of KP IBN was operative only from December 2021, yet the TPO computed the adjustment for the full year, resulting in an inflated figure. 16.11 We have considered the rival submissions and the material on record. The question is whether the guarantee commission of 0.40% charged from KPT Sweden and 0.50% charged from KP IBN is at arm's length, or whether it must be replaced by the median rate of 1.5% adopted by the TPO and confirmed by the DRP.
16.12 The assessee has applied the Comparable Uncontrolled Price method. Rule 10B(1)(a) requires the price in the controlled transaction to be compared with the price in a comparable uncontrolled transaction. Rule 10B(2) requires comparability to be judged on the characteristics of the service, the functions performed, assets employed and risks assumed, the contractual terms, and the conditions prevailing in the relevant market. An uncontrolled transaction of the assessee itself with an independent party (an internal CUP) is the most reliable comparable, because the differences between parties and markets are largely eliminated. Where such a transaction is claimed, it must first be examined, and generic market data cannot be applied in a blanket manner in preference to it. Asian Paints Ltd. v. ACIT [(2014) 41 taxmann.com 71 (Mum.-Trib.)], as reproduced by the learned CIT(A) for Assessment Year 2020-21, took this view.
ITA 6717/MUM/2024 94 ITA 744, 745, 985,986/MUM/2026 M/s Kalpataru Projects International Ltd.
16.13 The guarantees are performance guarantees and counter- guarantees furnished in connection with EPC contracts of the subsidiaries. They are not financial guarantees securing the repayment of a loan. The assessee's case is that it obtains the same class of credit support from independent banks under executed agreements at rates of SBI 0.30%, ICICI 0.35%, Union Bank 0.40%, Citi Bank (performance guarantee) 0.45% and Yes Bank 0.24%. These range from 0.24% to 0.45% and average about 0.35%. It states that it charged its AEs 0.40% and 0.50%, which are within or above that range. If this is established, it constitutes an internal CUP of the kind that ought to be examined first.
16.14 The TPO and the DRP rejected the assessee's benchmarking mainly because the assessee had not furnished documentary evidence of its computation of the arm's length price, including the guarantee documents. In their place, they adopted a median of 1.5% drawn from the bank responses under section 133(6). Those responses are standard or rack rates, and the assessee has pointed out that they are tiered and conditional on guarantee type, amount, tenor, credit rating and geography. For instance, Union Bank's schedule falls to 0.4% for guarantees above USD 2 million, and Citi Bank quotes 0.90% for financial guarantees but 0.45% for performance guarantees. The record does not show that the TPO tested those conditions or compared the assessee's agreements with them. The DRP's observation that transfer pricing is "an art and not
ITA 6717/MUM/2024 95 ITA 744, 745, 985,986/MUM/2026 M/s Kalpataru Projects International Ltd.
an exact science" does not dispense with the comparability analysis required by Rule 10B(2).
16.15 The assessee's internal CUP has not been examined by the TPO, and the assessee itself is said to have furnished the supporting documents inadequately. We are therefore not in a position to determine the arm's length rate on the present record. We also do not think it proper to confirm the 1.5% rate, which has been arrived at without examining the internal CUP now relied upon. In the interest of justice, we restore the issue to the file of the TPO for fresh determination, with the following directions:
(a) The assessee shall file before the TPO the executed agreements with SBI, ICICI, Union Bank, Citi Bank and Yes Bank, the guarantee and counter-guarantee documents for KPT Sweden and KP IBN (including the deed of indemnity), the working of its arm's length price, and any other material on which it relies. (b) The TPO shall examine the comparability of the assessee's bank arrangements with the guarantees in question under Rule 10B(2), having regard to the nature of the guarantee (performance as against financial), amount, tenor, credit standing and the conditions prevailing in the EPC industry. He shall consider the internal CUP in the first instance, and shall not prefer standard bank rack rates over it unless he establishes with reasons that the internal CUP is not comparable. Having done so, he shall determine the rate at which the transaction should be benchmarked. (c) The TPO shall also examine the assessee's contention that the guarantee for KP IBN was in force only from December 2021, and
ITA 6717/MUM/2024 96 ITA 744, 745, 985,986/MUM/2026 M/s Kalpataru Projects International Ltd.
shall restrict any adjustment to the period for which the guarantee was in force. (d) The assessee shall be given a reasonable opportunity of being heard and shall cooperate in the proceedings and furnish the documents without seeking unnecessary adjournments. 16.16 The other contentions of the parties, including the decisions relied upon by the assessee on the rate of guarantee commission, are left open for consideration by the TPO. Grounds Nos. 27 to 31 are allowed for statistical purposes.
Ground number 32 has not been adjudicated by the learned DRP and therefore, we feel it appropriate to restore this matter back to the file of the AO.
Ground Nos. 33 and 34 are consequential in nature and therefore same are not required to be adjudicated at this stage, therefore, we are restoring back to the file of Assessing Officer for computing subject to the verification. Cross appeals for AY 2018-19
Now, we take up the cross appeals of the assessee and Revenue for A.Y. 2018-19. The grounds raised by the assessee are reproduced as under:
GROUNDS:- Certified Emission Receipts taxed as revenue receipts - Rs.1.57.55.127:
ITA 6717/MUM/2024 97 ITA 744, 745, 985,986/MUM/2026 M/s Kalpataru Projects International Ltd.
The learned Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals)-56, Mumbai ["CIT(A)"] erred in fact and in law in confirming the action of the learned Income Tax Officer, National Faceless Assessment Center, Delhi ("the AO") in making addition of Rs. 1,57.55.127 by treating Certified Emission Receipts (CER) as revenue receipt instead of capital receipt. 2. The learned CIT(A) erred in fact and in law in confirming the action of the learned AO in treating CER as revenue receipt without appreciating the findings of the jurisdictional High Court wherein the CER was considered as capital receipt not liable to tax. 3. The learned CIT(A) erred in fact and in law in confirming the action of the learned AO in treating CER taxable u/s 115BBG of the Income Tax Act. 1961 ("the Act") without appreciating the fact that provisions of section 115BBG are machinery provisions and not charging provisions. 4. Without prejudice to the above, the learned CTT(A) erred in fact and in law in confirming the action of the learned AO in taxing CER on gross basis without allowing deduction of expenditure incurred of Rs. 30,04,345 for the purpose of earning income. Transfer Pricing Adjustment Interest on Advances - Rs. 31,22,571: 5. The learned CIT(A) erred in fact and in law in confirming the action of the learned Deputy Commissioner of Income Tax, Transfer Pricing-1, Ahmedabad ("the TPO") and consequently the learned AO in making addition of Rs. 31,22,571 by charging notional interest on advances granted to Kalpataru Power Transmission (Mauritius) Ltd ("KPT-Mauritius). 6. The learned CIT(A) erred in fact and in law in confirming the action of the learned TPO and the learned AO in making addition of notional interest without appreciating the fact that the advances were granted for benefit of the Appellant. 7. The learned CIT(A) erred in fact and in law in confirming the action of the learned TPO and the learned AO in applying six months LIBOR plus spread of 255 hasis points.. thereby computing ALP of interest at the rate of 4.06% instead of USD LIBOR rate of 1.50%. 8. Without prejudice to the above, the learned CIT(A) erred in fact and in law in confirming the action of the learned TPO and the learned AO in adding 100 basis points on account of forex risk and thereby not considering spread of 155 basis points instead of 255 basis points. Interest on TDS-Rs. 2,47,260: 9. The learned CIT(A) erred in fact and in law in confirming the action of the learned AO in disallowing deduction of interest expense of Rs.2,47.260 on late payment of TDS u/s 201(1A) of the Act. Other Grounds:
ITA 6717/MUM/2024 98 ITA 744, 745, 985,986/MUM/2026 M/s Kalpataru Projects International Ltd.
The learned CIT(A) erred in fact and in law in confirming the action of the learned AO in charging interest u/s. 234B of the Act. 11. The learned CIT(A) erred in fact and in law in confirming the action of the learned AO in charging interest u/s. 234C of the Act. 12. The learned CIT(A) erred in fact and in law in confirming the action of the learned AO in initiating penalty proceedings u/s. 270A of the Act. 13. Your appellant craves the right to add to or alter, amend, substitute, delete or modify all or any of the above grounds of appeals.” 20. The Revenue has raised the following grounds of appeal:
Whether on facts and circumstances of the case and in law, the Ld CIT A erred in deleting the adjustment in respect of Payment of Liaison support service without considering the findings of the Ld TPO that no supporting evidence was provided by the assessee that KP USA assists KPTL India in identifying projects for KPTL India to bid on in America and collect project data and technical specification and other pre-qualification requirements. 2. Whether, on the facts and in the circumstances of the case, the Ld. CIT(A) was justified in law in accepting the Any Other Method (Rule 10AB) as the Most Appropriate Method without first recording a finding on the inapplicability of the traditional methods prescribed under Section 92C(1) of the Income Tax Act. 3. Whether , on the facts and in the circumstances of the case, the Ld. CIT(A) erred in allowing the benchmarking of Liaison Support Services against US Census Bureau data for Wholesale Trade, thereby ignoring the fundamental Transfer Pricing principle of functional comparability (FAR analysis) as required under Rule 10B as liaison services are service-oriented (coordination, logistics, back-office), whereas wholesale trade involves significant inventory and market risks that a liaison office typically does not bear. 4. Whether ,in facts and circumstances of the case and in law, the Ld CIT(A) erred in deleting the adjustment in respect of Payment of Liaison support service by relying on the decision of Ld CIT(A) in assessee s case for Ay 2012-13 without appreciating the fact that department had filed further appeal against the said decision. 5. Whether on the facts and in the circumstances of the case and in law, the Ld. CIT(A) erred in deleting the disallowance made under section 14A of the Income Tax Act, 1961 on the ground that no exempt income was earned during the year by overlooking the clarification of legislative intent provided by the CBDT vide circular No. 5 20104 dated 11.02.2014 and to this effect even an amendment was made by Finance Act, 2022 by way of insertion of Explanation to Section 14A. 6. Whether on the facts and in the circumstances of the case and in law, the Ld. CIT(A) erred in allowing the FTC amounting to Rs. 19,91,64,697 ignoring the fact that Rule 128(8) of the Income-tax Rules, 1962 provides that Foreign
ITA 6717/MUM/2024 99 ITA 744, 745, 985,986/MUM/2026 M/s Kalpataru Projects International Ltd.
Tax Credit (FTC) shall be allowed only if Form No. 67 is furnished within the prescribed time and strictly to the extent specified therein. 7. The appellant craves to leave, to add, to amend and OR to alter any of the ground of appeal, if need be. Taxability of CER receipts 21. Grounds Nos. 1 to 4 concern the taxability of CER receipts. During the year, the assessee received Rs.1,57,55,127/- from CERs generated at its Tonk biomass-based power plant and treated the receipt as capital in nature. It also disallowed related expenditure of Rs.30,04,345/-. The Assessing Officer treated the receipt as taxable revenue. The learned CIT(A) upheld that treatment, observing that section 115BBG had been inserted with effect from AY 2018-19 and that the earlier decisions had been rendered under the pre- amendment statutory framework. 21.1 The issue is identical to that decided for AY 2021-22 in this consolidated order. For the reasons stated in that finding, section 2(24)(xviii) includes assistance received in cash or in kind, by whatever name called, and the CERs constitute an economically valuable benefit. Their transfer for consideration does not take the receipt outside that provision; section 115BBG prescribes the applicable tax treatment. The earlier decisions treating CER receipts as capital in nature do not govern the year under consideration, which is covered by the amended statutory framework. No distinguishing feature has been shown.
ITA 6717/MUM/2024 100 ITA 744, 745, 985,986/MUM/2026 M/s Kalpataru Projects International Ltd.
21.2 Respectfully following our finding for AY 2021-22, we hold that the receipt of Rs.1,57,55,127/- is taxable under section 2(24)(xviii) read with section 115BBG. The consequential contention concerning taxation on a gross basis and the alternative claim relating to expenditure of Rs.30,04,345/- shall be considered in accordance with the statutory scheme applicable to income from transfer of carbon credits. Ground Nos. 1 to 4 are dismissed. Ground Nos. 5 to 8 – Interest on advance to KPT Mauritius
Ground Nos. 5 to 8 relate to the transfer pricing adjustment on account of notional interest on the advance given by the assessee to KPT Mauritius. The assessee had advanced funds to its overseas subsidiary without charging interest. The assessee contended that the advance was given to meet the initial operational requirements of KPT Mauritius and was in the nature of quasi-equity. The learned TPO, however, treated the advance as a loan and determined an arm’s length interest, resulting in an adjustment of Rs.31,22,571/-. The learned CIT(A) upheld the adjustment.
22.1 Before us, the learned counsel submitted that the issue is covered by the decision of the Co-ordinate Bench in the assessee’s own case for Assessment Years 2012-13 and 2014-15, as also identical issue is involved in appeal for Assessment Year 2021-22, which is part of this bunch of appeals. It was submitted that, following the decision for AY 2021-22, the advance might be treated
ITA 6717/MUM/2024 101 ITA 744, 745, 985,986/MUM/2026 M/s Kalpataru Projects International Ltd.
as a loan for transfer pricing purposes, but the arm’s length interest should be determined by applying the appropriate USD LIBOR rate and not the rate adopted by the TPO. The learned counsel accordingly prayed that the adjustment be recomputed mutasis mutandis to AY 2021-22.
22.2 We have considered the rival submissions and carefully perused the material available on record. The issue regarding the character of the advance given to ‘KPT Mauritius’ has already been considered by the Co-ordinate Bench in the assessee’s own case for Assessment Years 2012-13 and 2014-15. The Tribunal held that the advance was in the nature of a loan and that an arm’s length interest was required to be determined thereon. The same issue again came up for consideration before us in Assessment Year 2021-22, which we have adjudicated above. On identical facts, we have in AY 2021- 22 followed the earlier decision and held that the advance was required to be benchmarked as a loan. We have further directed that the arm’s length interest be computed with reference to the appropriate average USD LIBOR rate and did not approve the additional 1% towards foreign exchange risk.
22.3 In the year under consideration also, no material has been brought before us to demonstrate any change in the nature of the transaction or in the facts relevant to the issue. The assessee’s contention that the advance was in the nature of quasi-equity has
ITA 6717/MUM/2024 102 ITA 744, 745, 985,986/MUM/2026 M/s Kalpataru Projects International Ltd.
already been considered in the earlier years and does not call for a different view. Following our decision in Assessment Year 2021-22, we hold that the advance to KPT Mauritius is required to be benchmarked for determining its arm’s length price.
22.4 As regards the rate of interest, we direct the Assessing Officer/TPO to follow the methodology adopted by us in Assessment Year 2021-22 and determine the arm’s length interest with reference to the appropriate average USD LIBOR rate applicable to the relevant financial year. The additional 1% towards foreign exchange risk shall not be separately added. The adjustment shall accordingly be recomputed on the actual amount and period of the advance in accordance with law.
22.5 In view of the above, the issue is decided mutatis mutandis in accordance with our decision for Assessment Year 2021-22. Accordingly, Ground Nos. 5 to 8 are dismissed, subject to the aforesaid direction for recomputation of the transfer pricing adjustment.
Ground No. 9 – Deduction of interest paid under section 201(1A)
Ground No. 9 relates to the disallowance of deduction claimed in respect of interest of Rs.2,47,260/- paid under section 201(1A) of the Act delayed remittance of tax deducted at source.
ITA 6717/MUM/2024 103 ITA 744, 745, 985,986/MUM/2026 M/s Kalpataru Projects International Ltd.
23.1 Brief facts qua the issue in dispute are that the assessee paid interest on late payment of TDS of Rs.2,47,260 under the provisions of section 201(1A) of the Act on short / non-deduction of TDS, but same was disallowed u/s. 40(a)(ii) of the Act in its tax return as reported by the Tax Auditor in Clause 34c of the Tax Audit Report in Form 3CD. Though such interest was disallowed by the assessee in its tax return out of abundant caution, however, during the course of assessment proceedings, the assessee made claim for such interest paid u/s. 201(1A) of the Act as a deduction while computing income under the head ‘profit and gains of business or profession’ by relying upon decision of ITAT, Kolkata Bench in case of DCIT v. M/s. Narayani Ispat Pvt. Ltd. [ITA No.2127/Kol/2014].
23.2 The learned CIT(A) rejected the claim, principally on the ground that the amount had not been claimed in the return and further observing that the interest was penal in nature.
23.3 Before us, the learned counsel for the assessee submitted that the interest paid under section 201(1A) is compensatory and not penal in nature. Reliance was placed, inter-alia, on the decisions in Lachmandas Mathuradas v. CIT, [2002] 254 ITR 799 (SC), and CIT v. Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd., [2009] 315 ITR 102 (Kar.) as well as certain decisions of the Tribunal which have allowed such interest as business expenditure. It was also submitted that the decision in Bharat Commerce & Industries Ltd. v. CIT, [1998] 230 ITR 733 (SC),
ITA 6717/MUM/2024 104 ITA 744, 745, 985,986/MUM/2026 M/s Kalpataru Projects International Ltd.
is distinguishable, as that case concerned interest on delayed payment of advance tax.
23.4 We have considered the rival submissions and perused the material available on record. In our view, the fact that interest under section 201(1A) is compensatory in character does not, by itself, determine its allowability under section 37(1) of the Act. The two questions are distinct. The first is the character of the levy; the second is whether the expenditure satisfies the substantive requirement of section 37(1), namely, whether it was laid out or expended wholly and exclusively for the purposes of the business.
23.5 The interest under section 201(1A) arises because of a statutory default in deducting or remitting tax within the prescribed time. The tax so deducted is not the assessee's own tax liability; it is tax withheld by the assessee on behalf of the recipient and required to be remitted to the Government. The interest under section 201(1A) is consequently a liability arising from such failure to comply with the statutory obligation. It cannot, merely because it is compensatory and not penal, be regarded as expenditure incurred wholly and exclusively for the purposes of the assessee's business.
23.6 The Hon’ble Supreme Court in Bharat Commerce & Industries Ltd. v. CIT, (supra), while considering the allowability of interest payable under the Income-tax Act, held that such interest could not be regarded as expenditure incurred wholly or exclusively for the
ITA 6717/MUM/2024 105 ITA 744, 745, 985,986/MUM/2026 M/s Kalpataru Projects International Ltd.
purposes of the assessee's business. The principle laid down therein is relevant to the application of section 37(1), irrespective of whether the particular levy is characterised as compensatory or penal.
23.7 The issue of allowability of interest under section 201(1A) under section 37(1) has been considered by the Hon’ble jurisdictional Bombay High Court in Ferro Alloys Corporation Ltd. v. CIT, (1992) 196 ITR 406 (Bom.). The Hon’ble High Court, while considering the allowability of interest under section 201(1A), answered the issue against the assessee. The said decision is binding upon us. The issue in dispute is also covered by the decision of the Co-ordinate Bench of the Tribunal in Expat Engineering India Limited (ITA No. 1129/Bang/2022 for AY 2016-17).
23.8 The decisions relied upon by the learned counsel regarding the compensatory nature of interest under section 201(1A) do not advance the assessee's case. Those decisions deal with the nature or levy of interest and do not decide the separate question whether such interest constitutes an expenditure allowable under section 37(1). The fact that the levy is compensatory does not dispense with the requirement that the expenditure must have been incurred wholly and exclusively for the purposes of business.
23.9 We therefore find that the claim of the assessee fails on the substantive requirement of section 37(1). We, however, do not approve the observation of the learned CIT(A) that the interest is
ITA 6717/MUM/2024 106 ITA 744, 745, 985,986/MUM/2026 M/s Kalpataru Projects International Ltd.
penal in nature. The issue does not require determination on that basis. Further, the mere fact that the assessee had not claimed the deduction in the original return cannot, by itself, be the decisive ground for rejecting a claim made during assessment proceedings. The claim is liable to be decided on its merits under the provisions of the Act.
23.10 For the reasons stated above, and respectfully following the binding decision of the Hon’ble jurisdictional High Court in Ferro Alloys Corporation Ltd. v. CIT (supra), we hold that the interest of Rs.2,47,260/- paid under section 201(1A) is not allowable as a deduction under section 37(1) of the Act. The disallowance is, accordingly, upheld. Ground No. 9 of the appeal is dismissed.
Ground Nos. 10 and 11 are in respect of charging of interest under Section 234B and 234C, which are consequential in nature, and therefore we are not required to adjudicate upon at this stage.
Ground No. 12 in relation to initiation of penalty under Section 270A is premature at this stage, and therefore we are not required to adjudicate upon the same.
Ground No. 13 being general in nature is dismissed as infructuous. 27. Now we take up the appeal of the Revenue for AY 2018-19.
ITA 6717/MUM/2024 107 ITA 744, 745, 985,986/MUM/2026 M/s Kalpataru Projects International Ltd.
Transfer pricing adjustment in respect of liaison support services
Ground Nos. 1 to 4 relate to the transfer pricing adjustment of Rs.25,04,228/- in respect of liaison support services rendered by the assessee’s Associated Enterprise, KPT USA.
28.1 The facts qua the issue in dispute as stated by the assessee are that KPT USA was incorporated as a wholly-owned subsidiary to assist the assessee in exploring business opportunities in the USA, Canada and Latin America. Pursuant to the Liaison Services Agreement, KPT USA was required, inter alia, to identify projects, collect project and technical information, assist in pre-qualification requirements and act as a liaison between the assessee and prospective customers. The assessee retained the right to accept or reject the proposals and to determine the terms of the contracts. For the services so rendered, the assessee paid success fees at 3% of the relevant order value.
28.2 For benchmarking the transaction, the assessee relied upon data published by the US Census Bureau/US Economic Census relating to commission earned by agents and brokers. According to the assessee, the comparable commission rate was higher than the 3% success fee paid to KPT USA. The TPO, however, rejected the benchmarking adopted by the assessee and, following the approach taken in earlier years and relying upon the decision in Cadila
ITA 6717/MUM/2024 108 ITA 744, 745, 985,986/MUM/2026 M/s Kalpataru Projects International Ltd.
Healthcare Ltd.(supra), adopted 2% as the arm’s length rate and made an adjustment of Rs.25,04,228/-. The learned CIT(A) upheld the assessee’s contention and deleted the adjustment, following the orders passed in the assessee’s own case for Assessment Years 2012- 13 and 2014-15. Pasted markdown Pasted markdown
28.3 Before us, the learned counsel submitted that the issue in year under consideration is identical to the assessee’s own case for Assessment Year 2021-22, wherein the identical issue relating to liaison/marketing support services rendered by KPT USA has been argued. It was accordingly submitted that the finding for AY 2021-22 might be followed in the year under consideration.
28.4 We have considered the rival submissions and perused the material available on record. We find that the issue before us is identical to the issue considered by us while adjudicating Ground Nos. 13 to 18 for Assessment Year 2021-22 in the present consolidated order. The nature of the services rendered by KPT USA, the basis of remuneration by way of success fee and the dispute regarding determination of the arm’s length price are substantially the same.
28.5 We have already examined the issue in detail while adjudicating issue-in-dispute for Assessment Year 2021-22 and recorded our findings therein. No distinguishing feature has been brought to our notice for the year under consideration which would
ITA 6717/MUM/2024 109 ITA 744, 745, 985,986/MUM/2026 M/s Kalpataru Projects International Ltd.
warrant a different view. We, therefore, respectfully follow our own finding recorded for Assessment Year 2021-22. Accordingly, the issue relating to the arm’s length price of the liaison support services rendered by KPT USA is decided mutatis mutandis in accordance with our findings for Assessment Year 2021-22. The transfer pricing adjustment of Rs.25,04,228/- made in respect of the said transaction is therefore dealt with in accordance with the said finding. Ground Nos. 1 to 4 are allowed for statistical purposes in terms of our findings recorded for Assessment Year 2021-22.
Ground No. 5 – Disallowance under section 14A read with Rule 8D
Ground No. 5 of the Revenue’s appeal relates to the disallowance made under section 14A of the Act read with Rule 8D of the Income-tax Rules, 1962 (“the Rules”).
29.1 The facts qua the issue in dispute are that during the year under consideration, the assessee earned exempt dividend income of Rs.3.41 crores. In the return of income, the assessee suo-motu disallowed a sum of Rs.33,26,060/- under section 14A of the Act. During the assessment proceedings, the assessee submitted that its investments were made out of its own funds and were held for business purposes. It also furnished the basis of the aforesaid disallowance.
ITA 6717/MUM/2024 110 ITA 744, 745, 985,986/MUM/2026 M/s Kalpataru Projects International Ltd.
29.2 The Assessing Officer, however, was not satisfied with the basis of the disallowance. He noted that the value of investments had increased from Rs.690.78 crores as on 31.03.2017 to Rs.760.85 crores as on 31.03.2018 and that the assessee had earned substantial exempt dividend income. He further noted that there was activity in the investment portfolio involving sale of existing investments and acquisition of new investments. According to the Assessing Officer, management time and administrative resources were required for making, managing and monitoring such investments. He also referred to the remuneration and other payments made to the directors and key managerial personnel and held that a part of such expenditure was attributable to the investment activity.
29.3 At the same time, the Assessing Officer accepted the assessee’s contention that the investments were made out of funds available with it and, therefore, did not make any disallowance under the interest component of Rule 8D. He proceeded to compute the disallowance under the administrative expenditure component of Rule 8D and determined the same at Rs.7,25,81,860/-, being 1% of the average value of investments. After reducing the suo-motu disallowance of Rs.33,26,060/-, the Assessing Officer made a further disallowance of Rs.6,92,55,880/- under section 14A of the Act.
ITA 6717/MUM/2024 111 ITA 744, 745, 985,986/MUM/2026 M/s Kalpataru Projects International Ltd.
29.4 The learned CIT(A), on further appeal, deleted the aforesaid disallowance. He noted that the assessee had worked out the suo motu disallowance by applying a percentage of the remuneration of the Chief Financial Officer, Company Secretary, Managing Director and other managerial personnel involved in investment functions, together with an amount towards general administrative expenses. He also noted that the basis of the computation had been reported by the Tax Auditor. Considering the assessee’s turnover of about Rs.5,826.51 crores, exempt dividend income of Rs.3.41 crores, and the methodology adopted by the assessee, the learned CIT(A) held that the disallowance of Rs.33,26,060/- was reasonable and that further disallowance under Rule 8D was not warranted. He accordingly deleted the addition.
29.5 We have considered the rival submissions and perused the material available on record. The first question is whether the Assessing Officer was justified in recording dissatisfaction with the assessee’s claim and in invoking Rule 8D.
29.6 In our considered view, the Assessing Officer has examined the basis of the assessee’s suo motu disallowance and has recorded reasons for not accepting the same. He noticed the substantial investment portfolio, the exempt dividend income and the activity in the investment portfolio. He also considered the assessee’s explanation regarding the source of investments. Thus, the
ITA 6717/MUM/2024 112 ITA 744, 745, 985,986/MUM/2026 M/s Kalpataru Projects International Ltd.
requirement of recording dis-satisfaction under section 14A(2) cannot be said to have been absent. The Assessing Officer was, therefore, justified in proceeding to determine the disallowance in accordance with Rule 8D.
29.7 However, the disallowance so determined cannot be sustained without applying the statutory restriction that the expenditure disallowed under section 14A cannot exceed the exempt income earned during the relevant year. In the present case, the assessee earned exempt dividend income of Rs.3,41,24,845/-, therefore, irrespective of the amount computed under Rule 8D, the disallowance under section 14A cannot exceed the exempt income for the year. The Hon’ble Delhi High Court in Joint Investments (P.) Ltd. v. CIT [2015] 233 Taxman 117 (Delhi) has held that the disallowance under section 14A cannot exceed the exempt income earned during the relevant year. The same principle has subsequently been followed by various Courts and Tribunals. In the present case, the Assessing Officer himself has not made any disallowance for interest component under Rule 8D. The dispute, therefore, is confined to the administrative expenditure component. Since the computation under Rule 8D results in a figure substantially higher than the exempt income, the disallowance has to be restricted to the amount of exempt income. At the same time, the suo motu disallowance already made by the assessee has to be given credit.
ITA 6717/MUM/2024 113 ITA 744, 745, 985,986/MUM/2026 M/s Kalpataru Projects International Ltd.
29.8 Accordingly, the disallowance under section 14A is restricted to Rs.3,41,24,845/-, being the exempt dividend income earned during the year, as against the amount of Rs.7,25,81,860/- computed by the Assessing Officer. Since the assessee has already disallowed Rs.33,26,060/-, the further disallowance is restricted to Rs.3,07,98,785/-. The order of the learned CIT(A) is, accordingly, modified to this extent. Ground No. 5 of the Revenue is partly allowed
Ground No. 6 – Foreign Tax Credit
Ground No. 6 of the Revenue’s appeal is directed against the order of the learned CIT(A) allowing the assessee’s additional claim of Foreign Tax Credit (“FTC”) of Rs.19,91,64,697/- in respect of taxes paid in Senegal.
30.1 The material facts qua the issue in dispute are that the assessee had established a branch in Senegal for execution of a transmission line project. In the return of income, the assessee had claimed FTC of Rs.9,91,62,726/- in respect of taxes paid in Senegal under section 91 of the Act read with Rule 128 of the Rules. Subsequently, the Senegalese tax authorities completed an assessment for Calendar Year 2017 and raised an additional tax liability by making certain adjustments, including in respect of construction revenue accounted for in India. The assessee accepted the assessment and paid the additional taxes in Senegal. Consequent to the additional payment of tax, the assessee revised its computation
ITA 6717/MUM/2024 114 ITA 744, 745, 985,986/MUM/2026 M/s Kalpataru Projects International Ltd.
of eligible FTC to Rs.29,83,27,423/- and, during the course of assessment proceedings, vide submission dated 16.08.2021, claimed additional FTC of Rs.19,91,64,697/-. The assessee furnished the computation and supporting documents, including proof of payment of the additional taxes.
30.2 The Assessing Officer did not grant the additional FTC. As noted by the learned CIT(A), the assessment order did not contain any specific reason for not considering or allowing the additional claim made by the assessee during the assessment proceedings. In the appellate proceedings, the learned CIT(A) examined the claim and the supporting documents. He noted that the additional taxes had been paid in Senegal pursuant to the assessment made by the Senegalese tax authorities after the filing of the return of income. He, therefore, observed that the assessee had no occasion to claim such additional taxes in the original return. He further recorded that the claim had been made within the period prescribed under Rule 128(4) of the Rules. On this basis, the learned CIT(A) directed the Assessing Officer to allow the additional FTC of Rs.19,91,64,697/-.
30.3 Before us, the Revenue has challenged the aforesaid direction. The learned Departmental Representative relied upon the assessment order, whereas the learned counsel for the assessee supported the order of the learned CIT(A) and submitted that the additional tax liability arose only pursuant to the subsequent
ITA 6717/MUM/2024 115 ITA 744, 745, 985,986/MUM/2026 M/s Kalpataru Projects International Ltd.
assessment in Senegal and that the claim, together with the supporting documents and proof of payment, was duly furnished during the assessment proceedings.
30.4 We have considered the rival submissions and perused the material available on record. The additional FTC claimed by the assessee did not arise from any omission in the original return. The additional liability itself arose subsequently pursuant to the assessment made by the Senegalese tax authorities. The assessee thereafter paid the additional tax and furnished the revised computation and supporting documents before the Assessing Officer during the course of assessment proceedings. We also note that the learned CIT(A) has recorded a finding that the additional claim was made within the period prescribed under Rule 128(4) of the Rules. The ld DR has not brought any finding to the contrary or pointed out any specific defect in the additional claim, the computation or the evidence furnished by the assessee. Further, the Mumbai Bench of the Tribunal in Sonakshi Sinha v. CIT(A), NFAC, Delhi, ITA No. 1704/Mum/2022, order dated 20.09.2022, reported in [2022] 142 taxmann.com 414 (Mumbai-Trib.), while considering the provisions of Rule 128(9), held that the requirement relating to filing of Form No. 67 was directory and that the FTC could not be denied merely on account of a procedural delay where the form was furnished before completion of the assessment.
ITA 6717/MUM/2024 116 ITA 744, 745, 985,986/MUM/2026 M/s Kalpataru Projects International Ltd.
30.5 In the present case, the facts stand on a stronger footing. The additional foreign tax liability itself arose after filing of the return and was paid pursuant to the assessment in Senegal. The assessee thereafter made the additional claim during the assessment proceedings and furnished the relevant computation and evidence. Thus, the claim could not have been rejected without examining its substantive eligibility under section 91 of the Act read with Rule 128 of the Rules. In view of the above facts and respectfully following the decision of the coordinate Bench in Sonakshi Sinha (supra), we find no infirmity in the order of the learned CIT(A) directing the Assessing Officer to allow the additional FTC of Rs.19,91,64,697/-, subject to verification of the actual payment of tax and fulfilment of the other statutory conditions governing the grant of such credit. The assessee may also file documents in support of the claim that said foreign credit has not been disputed before Senegal Tax Authorities and not refunded to the assessee in full or in part. Accordingly, the order of the learned CIT(A) is upheld and Ground No. 6 of the Revenue is dismissed.
Cross appeals for AY 2020-21 31. Now, we take up the cross appeals of the assessee and Revenue for assessment year 2020-21. The grounds raised by the assessee are reproduced as under: Certified Emission Receipts taxed as revenue receipts -Rs. 1,72,82,405:
ITA 6717/MUM/2024 117 ITA 744, 745, 985,986/MUM/2026 M/s Kalpataru Projects International Ltd.
The learned Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals)-56, Mumbai ["CIT(A)"] erred in fact and in law in confirming the action of the learned Income Tax Officer, National Faceless Assessment Center, Delhi ("the AO") in making addition of Rs. 1,72,82,405 by treating Certified Emission Receipts (CER) as revenue receipt instead of capital receipt. 2. The learned CIT(A) erred in fact and in law in confirming the action of the learned AO in treating CER as revenue receipt without appreciating the findings of the jurisdictional High Court wherein the CER was considered as capital receipt not liable to tax. 3 The learned CIT(A) erred in fact and in law in confirming the action of the learned AO in treating CER taxable u/s 115BBG of the Income Tax Act, 1961 ("the Act") without appreciating the fact that provisions of section 115BBG are machinery provisions and not charging provisions. 4 The learned CIT(A) erred in fact and in law in confirming action of the learned AO in treating CER as revenue receipts without considering facts on record in proper perspective.
Transfer Pricing Adjustments Interest on Advances - Rs. 42,99,496: 5. The learned CIT(A) erred in fact and in law in confirming the action of the learned Deputy Commissioner of Income Tax, Transfer Pricing-1, Ahmedabad ("the TPO") and consequently the learned AO in making addition of Rs. 42,99,496 by charging notional interest on advances granted to Kalpataru Power Transmission (Mauritius) Ltd ("KPT-Mauritjus). 6. The learned CIT(A) erred in fact and in law in confirming the action of the learned TPO and the learned AO in making addition of notional interest without appreciating the fact that the advances were granted for benefit of the Appellant. 7. The learned CIT(A) erred in fact and in law in confirming the action of the learned TPO and the learned AO in determining Arm's Length Price ("ALP") of the transaction by applying fixed interest rate of 7.02% based on US LIBOR rate available on Bloomberg Database. 8. The learned CIT(A) erred in fact and in law in confirming the action of the learned TPΟ and the learned AO in determining ALP of interest using comparables pertaining to money borrowed and not relating to granting of loans and advances.
ITA 6717/MUM/2024 118 ITA 744, 745, 985,986/MUM/2026 M/s Kalpataru Projects International Ltd.
The learned CIT(A) erred in fact and in law in confirming the action of the learned TPO and the learned AO in determining ALP of interest rate at 7.02% without providing complete details of search process and manner of computing ALP at 7.02%. 10. Without prejudice to the above, the learned CIT(A) erred in fact and in law in confirming the action of the learned TPO and the learned AO in not determining ALP using average six-month USD LIBOR rate of 2.006%
Interest on Trade Advances - Rs. 14,04,585: 11. The learned CIT(A) erred in fact and in law in confirming the action of the learned TPO and learned AO in making addition of Rs. 14,04,585 on account of notional interest free trade advances granted to Kalpataru Power Transmission Ukraine LLC ("KPT-Ukraine"). 12. The learned CIT(A) erred in fact and in law in confirming the action of the learned TPΟ and the learned AO in making addition of notional interest on outstanding trade advances given to KPT-Ukraine without appreciating the fact that the advances were not recovered due to unavoidable circumstances. 13. Without prejudice to the above, the learned CTT(A) erred in fact and in law in confirming the action of the learned TPO and the learned AO in determining ALP of notional interest by adopting comparables pertaining to money borrowed and not relating to granting of loans and advances. 14. The learned CIT(A) erred in fact and in law in confirming the action of the learned TPO and the learned AO in making addition of notional interest on trade advances at the rate of 5.06% based on US LIBOR rates available on Bloomberg Database. 15. The learned CIT(A) erred in fact and in law in confirming the action of the learned TPO and the learned AO in determining amount of addition applying annualized interest rate instead of considering period for which advances were granted. 16. Without prejudice to the above, the learned CIT(A) erred in fact and in law in confirming the action of the learned TPO and the learned AO in not determining ALP using average six-month USD LIBOR rate of 2.006% 17. Without prejudice to the above, the learned CIT(A) erred in fact and law in not considering the fact that the learned TPO has used an arbitrary exchange rate to
ITA 6717/MUM/2024 119 ITA 744, 745, 985,986/MUM/2026 M/s Kalpataru Projects International Ltd.
compute the amount of advance in Indian currency i.e. INR 2,77,58,592 instead of the amount disclosed by the assessee in its related party transaction (i.e., INR 2,64,37,241) and hence such arbitrary application of exchange rate ought to be rejected. Other Grounds: 18. The learned CIT(A) erred in fact and in law in confirming the action of the learned AO in initiating penalty proceedings u/s. 270A of the Act. 19. Your appellant craves the right to add to or alter, amend, substitute, delete or modify all or any of the above grounds of appeals.
Grounds Nos. 1 to 4 – Taxability of Certified Emission Reduction (CER) receipts 32. Grounds Nos. 1 to 4 concern the taxability of CER receipts. During the year, the assessee received Rs.1,72,82,405/- from CERs generated at its Tonk biomass-based power plant and treated the receipt as capital in nature. It also disallowed expenditure of Rs.32,94,197/- relating to the CERs. The Assessing Officer treated the receipt as taxable revenue, and the learned CIT(A) upheld that treatment, noting that section 115BBG applied from AY 2018-19.
32.1 The issue is identical to that decided for AY 2021-22 and followed for AY 2018-19 in this consolidated order. For the reasons stated in our finding for AY 2021-22, the receipt falls within section 2(24)(xviii) and income from its transfer is governed by section 115BBG. No distinguishing feature has been brought to our notice. We therefore hold that the receipt of Rs.1,72,82,405/- is taxable under section 2(24)(xviii) read with section 115BBG. The contention that it is a non-taxable capital receipt is rejected.
ITA 6717/MUM/2024 120 ITA 744, 745, 985,986/MUM/2026 M/s Kalpataru Projects International Ltd.
32.2 The lower authorities’ orders on this issue are upheld. The consequential contention concerning taxation on a gross basis and the alternative claim relating to expenditure shall be dealt with in accordance with the statutory provisions applicable to income from transfer of carbon credits. Ground Nos. 1 to 4 are dismissed. Ground Nos. 5 to 10 – Interest on advance to KPT Mauritius 33. Grounds Nos. 5 to 10 concern the transfer-pricing adjustment of Rs.42,99,496/- for notional interest on the advance to KPT Mauritius. The assessee contended that the advance was provided to meet the expenditure requirements of its subsidiary during the initial stage of operations and was in the nature of quasi-equity. The TPO treated it as a loan and determined arm’s-length interest; the learned CIT(A) upheld the adjustment. 33.1 The character of the advance and its benchmarking have already been considered for AY 2021-22 and AY 2018-19. Following the decisions in the assessee’s own case for AYs 2012-13 and 2014- 15, we held that the advance is to be benchmarked as a loan, with arm’s-length interest computed by reference to the appropriate average USD LIBOR rate applicable to the relevant financial year. No separate 1% adjustment for foreign-exchange risk is warranted. No distinguishing feature has been shown for the year under consideration.
ITA 6717/MUM/2024 121 ITA 744, 745, 985,986/MUM/2026 M/s Kalpataru Projects International Ltd.
33.2 We accordingly set aside the adjustment of Rs.42,99,496/- for the limited purpose of recomputation in accordance with the methodology and directions laid down for AY 2021-22, having regard to the actual amount and period of the advance. Grounds Nos. 5 to 10 are allowed for statistical purposes. Ground Nos. 11 to 17 – Interest on trade advance to KPT Ukraine 34. Grounds Nos. 11 to 17 concern the transfer-pricing adjustment of Rs.14,04,585/- for notional interest on the trade advance to KPT Ukraine. The assessee advanced UAH 1,01,70,000 (equivalent to Rs.2,68,70,869/-) for adjustment against supplies under future projects. The projects could not proceed owing to political unrest and adverse business conditions in Ukraine. The TPO treated the outstanding amount as a separate international transaction, applied an interest rate of 3.12% plus 1% for foreign-exchange risk, and made the adjustment; the learned CIT(A) upheld it. 34.1 We have considered the rival submissions and perused the material on record. The nature of the advance, the circumstances in which it remained outstanding, and the benchmarking dispute are materially identical to those considered for AY 2021-22. We held there that an outstanding trade advance cannot, merely by reason of its remaining unpaid, be treated as an ordinary loan without examining the underlying commercial transaction, its terms and the prevailing economic circumstances. The issue was restored to the
ITA 6717/MUM/2024 122 ITA 744, 745, 985,986/MUM/2026 M/s Kalpataru Projects International Ltd.
AO/TPO for fresh determination, including reconsideration of the additional foreign-exchange-risk adjustment.
34.2 Following that finding, we set aside the adjustment of Rs.14,04,585/- and restore the issue to the AO/TPO for fresh determination in accordance with the directions given for AY 2021- 22. The AO/TPO shall examine the nature and terms of the trade advance, the circumstances in which it remained outstanding, appropriate comparable uncontrolled transactions, the relevant period and the basis for any foreign-exchange-risk adjustment. Reasonable opportunity shall be afforded to the assessee. Grounds Nos. 11 to 17 are allowed for statistical purposes
Now, we take up appeal of the Revenue for assessment year 2020-21. The grounds raised by the Revenue are reproduced as under: 1."Whether on factsand circumstances of the case and in law, the Ld CIT(A) erred in deleting the adjustment in respect of Payment of Liaison support service without considering the findings of the Ld TPO that no supporting evidence was provided by the assessee that KP USA assists KPTL India in identifying projects for KPTL India to bid on in America and collect project data and technical specification and other pre-qualification requirements"? 2. "Whether, on the facts and in the circumstances of the case, the Ld. CIT(A) was justified in law in accepting the 'Any Other Method' (Rule 10AB) as the Most Appropriate Method without first recording a finding on the inapplicability of the traditional methods prescribed under Section 92C(1) of the Income Tax Act?" 3. "Whether, on the facts and in the circumstances of the case, the Ld. CIT(A) erred in allowing the benchmarking of Liaison Support Services against US Census Bureau data for 'Wholesale Trade', thereby ignoring the fundamental Transfer Pricing principle of functional comparability (FAR analysis) as required under Rule
ITA 6717/MUM/2024 123 ITA 744, 745, 985,986/MUM/2026 M/s Kalpataru Projects International Ltd.
10B as liaison services are service-oriented (coordination, logistics, back-office), whereas wholesale trade involves significant inventory and market risks that a liaison office typically does not bear.?" 4. "Whether, in facts and circumstances of the case and in law, the Ld CIT(A) erred in deleting the adjustment in respect of Payment of Liaison support service by relying on the decision of Ld CiT(A) in assessee's case for Ay 2012-13 without appreciating the fact that department had filed further appeal against the said decision?" 5. Whether on the facts and circumstances of the case and in law, the Ld. CIT(A) is correct in deleting the TP adjustment of Rs.2,45, 12,831/- on account of Corporate Guarantee given to assessee's A.E's? 6. Whether on the facts and circumstances of the case and in law, the Ld. CIT(A) erred in applying on the judgements in the case of Everest Kanto Cylinders Limited (EKC) of Hon'ble ITAT Mumbai (34 Taxmann.com 19 (Mum Trib) dated 23.11.2012) and other decisions without appreciating that the decision in the case of Everest Kanto Cylinders Ltd. cannot be standard for every assessee as benchmarking for different assessee's is a factual exercise dependent upon number of factors including credit rating, financial strength, country of AE, attendant risks etc. 7. Whether on the facts and circumstances of the case and in law, the Ld. CIT(A)erred in holding that the fee for the guarantee issued by the assessee for the loans availed by the AE from banks should be charged at 0.75%, without realizing the fact that the transfer pricing study is highly facts-based and it differs from case to case and that all the factors in Rule 10B have to be considered for every case and every year independently and that a rate decided ina different case for different set of facts and for different year cannot be adopted as such to the instant assessee, which would be violative of the specific provisions in Rule 10В? "Whetheron the facts and circumstances of the case and in law, the Ld. CIT(A) failed to appreciate that the explicit guarantee provided by the parent company provides a measurable economic benefit (lower borrowing cost/enhancedcreditworthiness) to the AE, which warrants a commission higher than the mere cost of funds to the parent? 9. Whether on the facts and circumstances of the case and in law, the Ld. CIT(A)erred in failing to recognize the facts of the case that the assessee has given corporate guarantee to its AEs, thereby exposing itself to a 'lending business' risk as well as the 'single customer' risk by charging fee for such guarantee below the comparable ALP rate, which the assessee would have done, had it stood guarantee to any third party in uncontrolled conditions as in section 92F(ii)?
ITA 6717/MUM/2024 124 ITA 744, 745, 985,986/MUM/2026 M/s Kalpataru Projects International Ltd.
Whether on the facts and circumstances of the case and in law, the Ld. CIT(A)erred in failing to see that AE had no credit-worthiness and financial capacity to service its own loan and in such a situation assessee standing guarantee for the loan, it had to be remunerated at arm's length as per section 92F(ii)? 11. "Whether on the facts and circumstances of the case and in law, the Ld. CIT(A) was correct in law to allow the appeal based on judicial precedents from unrelated industries (Asian Paints etc.) without verifying if the risk profile of the EPC industry for the year under consideration was identical to the facts of those cases? 12. "On the facts and circumstances of the case, the Ld.CIT(A) erred in deleting the addition of Rs. 7,21,88,079/- made u/s. 14A r.w.r 8D of the Income Tax Act, 1961and restricting the disallowance u/s. 14A to the amount of Rs. 34,50,921/- which is suo-moto disallowed by the assessee"
Grounds Nos. 1 and 2 – Transfer Pricing adjustment in respect of liaison support services rendered by KPT USA
Grounds Nos. 1 and 2 of the Revenue’s appeal relate to the deletion of the transfer pricing adjustment of Rs.1,84,37,563/- made in respect of liaison support services rendered by the assessee’s Associated Enterprise, KPT USA.
36.1 Before us, the learned Departmental Representative supported the order of the TPO, whereas the learned counsel for the assessee submitted that the issue is identical to the assessee’s own case for Assessment Year 2021-22. It was submitted that the identical issue was also in Assessment Year 2018-19 and, therefore, the same finding might be followed in the year
ITA 6717/MUM/2024 125 ITA 744, 745, 985,986/MUM/2026 M/s Kalpataru Projects International Ltd.
36.2 We have considered the rival submissions and perused the material available on record. The nature of the services rendered by KPT USA, the basis of remuneration by way of success fee at 3%, the benchmarking by reference to the US Census Bureau/US Economic Census data, and the dispute regarding adoption of 2% by the TPO are substantially the same as those considered by us while adjudicating Grounds Nos. 13 to 18 of the assessee’s appeal for Assessment Year 2021-22.
36.3 While adjudicating the said grounds, we accepted, in principle, the relevance of the US Census Bureau/US Economic Census data for benchmarking the success fee paid to KPT USA. At the same time, we held that the arm’s length price has to be determined with reference to the actual transactions of the relevant year and that the actual orders obtained through KPT USA, the invoice values on which the success fee was computed and the evidence of services rendered during the relevant year require examination. The issue was accordingly restored to the AO/TPO for fresh determination.
36.4 The aforesaid finding has subsequently been followed by us while adjudicating the identical issue for Assessment Year 2018-19. No distinguishing feature relating to the year under consideration has been brought to our notice which would warrant a different view. We, therefore, follow our finding recorded for Assessment Year 2021- 22, as followed for Assessment Year 2018-19.
ITA 6717/MUM/2024 126 ITA 744, 745, 985,986/MUM/2026 M/s Kalpataru Projects International Ltd.
36.5 Accordingly, the transfer pricing adjustment of Rs.1,84,37,563/- is set aside and the issue is restored to the file of the AO/TPO for fresh determination in accordance with the directions contained in our finding for Assessment Year 2021-22. The AO/TPO shall examine the actual transactions undertaken during the year, the orders obtained through KPT USA, the corresponding invoice values and the evidence of services actually rendered, and determine the arm’s length price in accordance with law, after affording the assessee reasonable opportunity of being heard. Grounds Nos. 1 and 2 of the Revenue are allowed for statistical purposes.
Grounds No. 3 to 6:
The ground numbers 3 to 6 of the appeal of the Revenue relates to adjustment of ‘corporate guarantee’ given to associated enterprises. 37.1 The material facts qua the issue in dispute are that the assessee had furnished a corporate guarantee on behalf of its subsidiary, Kalpataru Power Transmission Sweden AB (KPT Sweden), and charged guarantee commission of 0.40%. The TPO held this to be below the arm’s length rate and applied a rate of 1.80%, making an upward transfer pricing adjustment of Rs. 2,45,12,831/-. For this purpose, the TPO called for guarantee rates from various banks under section 133(6). The banks furnished standard (rack) rates of
ITA 6717/MUM/2024 127 ITA 744, 745, 985,986/MUM/2026 M/s Kalpataru Projects International Ltd.
guarantee commission on a general basis, and the TPO adopted the rate on that basis.
37.2 Before the ld CIT(A), the assessee submitted that it had actual comparable transactions available as an internal CUP, being the guarantee commission charged to the assessee itself by banks. The assessee further submitted that the rack rates furnished by the banks cannot be compared with the commission charged by the assessee, because the rate applicable to each entity is subjective, and rates specific to the EPC industry, in which the AE also operates, were available and were the closest comparable. The assessee submitted that the TPO took the highest rates quoted by the banks, which relate to financial guarantees, whereas the assessee had given a performance guarantee. He did so without a comparability analysis of the type of guarantee, credit standing, business volume, geography and contract terms. Without prejudice, it was submitted that even if the TPO’s rates were taken and appropriately selected, the assessee’s rate would still fall within the arm’s length range. The assessee relied on Asian Paints Ltd. v. ACIT [(2014) 41 taxmann.com 71 (Mum.-Trib.)] and other decisions that accepted guarantee commission of 0.40% or less (0.20% to 0.50%).
37.3 The learned CIT(A) found merit in the assessee’s submissions. He held that the CUP method requires accurate comparison, and that the assessee had comparable data available while the data used by
ITA 6717/MUM/2024 128 ITA 744, 745, 985,986/MUM/2026 M/s Kalpataru Projects International Ltd.
the TPO was generic. The industry in which the guarantee is given is important for comparability, and the close EPC-industry comparable should have been used. He relied on Asian Paints (supra), in which it was held that rates from the market cannot be applied in a blanket manner without a comparability analysis, and that an internal CUP in the form of bank guarantee charges borne by the assessee ought first to be analysed. He also noted the decisions relied upon by the assessee, which accepted rates between 0.20% and 0.50%. He held the TPO’s approach to be arbitrary and unscientific, since comparing general bank rates was not a reliable basis for determining the arm’s length range when an internal CUP was available. He accordingly deleted the adjustment. 37.4 We have heard the rival submissions and perused the record. The Revenue challenges the deletion of the adjustment of Rs. 2,45,12,831/-, made by applying a rate of 1.80% in place of the 0.40% charged by the assessee from KPT Sweden. The issue is the same as the one considered by us for Assessment Year 2021-22, where we held that the assessee's claimed internal CUP must be examined before standard bank rack rates are applied. In that year, the matter has been restored to the TPO because the TPO and the DRP found that the assessee had not furnished the documents supporting its computation. In the present year, the learned CIT(A) examined the assessee's material and found that the TPO's data consisted of generic rack rates not tested for comparability, and that
ITA 6717/MUM/2024 129 ITA 744, 745, 985,986/MUM/2026 M/s Kalpataru Projects International Ltd.
the rates actually charged to the assessee by its bankers for equivalent EPC-related guarantees were available and ought to have been applied as an internal CUP. That finding is in accordance with the principle stated above. The Revenue has not pointed out any defect in the material considered by the CIT(A) or any other ground on which his finding is wrong. We therefore restore the issue in dispute in present appeal to the file of the TPO for deciding as per our direction on the issue of corporate guarantee for AY 2021-22. The ground Nos. 3 to 6 of appeal of Revenue are accordingly allowed for statistical purposes. Ground No. 7 – Disallowance under section 14A read with Rule 8D
Ground No. 7 of the Revenue’s appeal relates to the disallowance under section 14A of the Act read with Rule 8D of the Rules.
38.1 During the year under consideration, the assessee earned exempt dividend income of Rs.7,96,65,060/-. In the return of income, the assessee suo motu disallowed Rs.34,50,921/- under section 14A. The assessee explained that the said disallowance was computed on the basis of the remuneration of the Chief Financial Officer, Company Secretary, Managing Director and other managerial personnel involved in investment-related functions, together with general administrative expenses.
ITA 6717/MUM/2024 130 ITA 744, 745, 985,986/MUM/2026 M/s Kalpataru Projects International Ltd.
38.2 The Assessing Officer did not accept the basis of the suo motu disallowance and invoked Rule 8D. He accordingly made a further disallowance of Rs.7,21,88,079/- under section 14A. The assessee challenged the disallowance before the learned CIT(A), inter-alia, contending that the investments in foreign companies were not covered by section 14A, that investments which had not yielded exempt income during the year should be excluded, and that the Ind AS adjustments were required to be ignored while applying Rule 8D.
38.3 The learned CIT(A), after examining the basis of the assessee’s suo motu disallowance, held that the same was based on a rational methodology and was also reported by the Tax Auditor. Considering the facts of the case, he held that the disallowance of Rs.34,50,921/- was reasonable and that no further disallowance under Rule 8D was warranted. He accordingly deleted the further disallowance made by the Assessing Officer.
38.4 We have considered the rival submissions and perused the material available on record. We find that the identical issue has already been considered by us while adjudicating Ground No. 5 of the Revenue’s appeal for Assessment Year 2018-19 in the present consolidated order.
38.5 In that year, we held that the Assessing Officer was justified in recording dissatisfaction with the assessee’s computation and in invoking Rule 8D. We also held that, notwithstanding the
ITA 6717/MUM/2024 131 ITA 744, 745, 985,986/MUM/2026 M/s Kalpataru Projects International Ltd.
computation under Rule 8D, the disallowance under section 14A could not exceed the exempt income earned during the relevant year. The disallowance was accordingly restricted to the amount of exempt income, after giving credit for the suo-motu disallowance already made by the assessee.
38.6 The facts and controversy in the year under consideration are materially the same. No distinguishing feature has been brought to our notice which would warrant a different view. We, therefore, respectfully follow our finding for Assessment Year 2018-19.
38.7 Accordingly, the disallowance under section 14A is restricted to the exempt dividend income of Rs.7,96,65,060/-. After allowing credit for the suo-motu disallowance of Rs.34,50,921/- already made by the assessee, the further disallowance is restricted to Rs.7,62,14,139/-.
38.8 The order of the learned CIT(A) is modified to this extent. Ground No. 7 of the Revenue is partly allowed.
Before parting, we make it clear that we have considered all the decisions cited by the parties at Bar and referred wherever required but wherever found that decision’s ratio was of merely repetitive nature, has not been mentioned specifically.
ITA 6717/MUM/2024 132 ITA 744, 745, 985,986/MUM/2026 M/s Kalpataru Projects International Ltd.
In the result, the appeals of the assessee and Revenue are partly allowed for statistical purposes.
Order pronounced in the open Court on 28/10/2026.
Sd/- Sd/- (ANIKESH BANERJEE) (OM PRAKASH KANT) JUDICIAL MEMBER ACCOUNTANT MEMBER Mumbai; Dated: 28/10/2026 K.Kr. P.S. Copy of the Order forwarded to : 1. The Appellant 2. The Respondent. 3. CIT 4. DR, ITAT, Mumbai 5. Guard file. Digitally signed by ABHINAV ABHINAV ANANT ANANT GAVANDE BY ORDER, GAVANDE Date: 2026.11.03 13:54:18 //True Copy// +05'30' (Assistant Registrar) ITAT, Mumbai
More judgments on Section 115BBG
- Dy. Commissioner of Income Tax, Central… vs Kalpataru Projects International Limited…ITA 986/MUM/2026[2020-21]Status: Disposed28 Oct 2026AY 2020-21
- Kalpataru Projects International Limited… vs Dy Commissioner of Income Tax Cental Circle…ITA 745/MUM/2026[2020-21]Status: Disposed28 Oct 2026AY 2020-21
- Kalpataru Projects International Limited… vs Dy Commissioner of Income Tax Central…ITA 744/MUM/2026[2018-19]Status: Disposed28 Oct 2026AY 2018-19
- M/S. Kalpataru Projects International… vs DCIT Central Circle 3(3) Mumbai, MumbaiITA 6717/MUM/2024[2021-22]Status: Disposed28 Oct 2026AY 2021-22
- Jindal Saw Ltd., New Delhi vs DCIT, Circle- 13(2), New DelhiITA 463/DEL/2019[2013-14]Status: Disposed13 Jul 2026AY 2013-14
Recent GST High Court judgments
Search GST case law →- M/S Jaleswar Packaging, Bhubaneswar vs. Superintendent, CGST And Central Excise, BhubaneswarOrissa · 11 Nov 2026
- Talasethi Sanmukharao vs. Commissioner, CT And GST, Odisha, CuttackOrissa · 11 Nov 2026
- M/S Ramamani Behera (Trade Name S.V.Enterprises) Bhubaneswar vs. Addl Commissioner Of GST And Central Excise, BhubaneswarOrissa · 11 Nov 2026
- Prasanta Kumar Biswal vs. The Chief Commissioner, CGST, Central Excise And Customs, BhubaneswarOrissa · 11 Nov 2026
- M/S.Dibyanee Agency., Keonjhar. vs. Chief Commissioner Of CT And GST, Odisha, CuttackOrissa · 11 Nov 2026