M/S MARUTI SAH AND BROTHERS vs. THE PRINCIPAL COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX
What did the High Court hold?
The High Court held that the ITAT's decision to remand the matter to the Assessing Officer was a proper exercise of discretion. The Tribunal had taken into account the limited time available to the assessees to present their defense after the High Court's order dated December 26, 2016, and the assessment order being passed on December 30, 2016. By setting aside the assessment order and directing a fresh examination by the AO, with liberty to the assessees to raise all available contentions, the Tribunal's action did not cause prejudice. The High Court found that this order did not give rise to a substantial question of law warranting interference under Section 260-A of the Act. Therefore, the appeals were dismissed.
What were the facts?
The appeals by M/s Maruti Sah & Brothers and Maruti Nandan Sah (assessees) are against an order of the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT) dated December 19, 2018. The ITAT had remanded the matter back to the Assessing Officer (AO) for a fresh consideration. Proceedings under Section 147 were initiated for assessment year 2009-10, with a notice under Section 148 issued on March 31, 2016. The assessees' writ petitions challenging the Section 148 notice were dismissed by the High Court on December 26, 2016. Subsequently, the assessees filed special appeals, which were also dismissed on March 15, 2017, with liberty to raise contentions before the statutory authority. The assessees then approached the ITAT, which noted the limited time available for defense due to the assessment order being passed on December 30, 2016, shortly after the High Court's order.
What were the issues?
1. Whether the ITAT erred in remanding the matter to the Assessing Officer for fresh consideration, instead of deciding the factual dispute regarding the effective service of notice under Section 148(1) of the Income Tax Act, 1961, as the ITAT is the final court of fact? (Question of law) Assessee's contention: The ITAT, being the final court of fact, should have adjudicated the factual dispute concerning the effective service of the Section 148(1) notice and should not have relegated the matter back to the Assessing Officer. Revenue's contention: Not recorded in the judgment.
Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?
AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below
IN THE HIGH COURT OF UTTARAKHAND AT NAINITAL
Income Tax Appeal No. 08 of 2019
M/s Maruti Sah & Brothers
…….Appellants Versus The Principal Commissioner of Income Tax & another
…….Respondents With Income Tax Appeal No. 09 of 2019
Maruti Nandan Sah
…….Appellant Versus The Principal Commissioner of Income Tax & another
…….Respondents Mr. B.M. Pingal, Advocate for the appellants. Mr. H.M. Bhatia, Senior Standing Counsel for the Income Tax/respondents.
COMMON JUDGMENT
Coram: Hon’ble Ramesh Ranganathan, C.J. Hon’ble N.S. Dhanik, J.
Dated: 23rd April, 2019
RAMESH RANGANATHAN, C.J. (Oral)
These appeals are preferred, under Section 260-A of the Income Tax Act, 1961 (hereinafter referred to as the “Act”), against the order passed by the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (for short the “ITAT”) in ITA No.3044/Del/2018 and ITA No.3045/Del/2018 dated 19.12.2018 remanding the matter to the Assessing Officer for considering the matter afresh, after affording an opportunity to the assessees to put forth their defense on all aspects, as directed by the High Court.
Facts, to the limited extent necessary, are that the assessees filed their return of income for the Assessment Year 2009-10. On the ground that some part of the income had escaped assessment, proceedings under Section 147 of the Act were initiated, by issuing a notice under Section 148 thereof on 31.03.2016. The appellants-assessees filed their reply stating that the original return of income may be treated as the return filed in response to the notice under Section 148 of the Act. They sought for the reasons recorded, for the issuance of notice under Section 148 of the Act, to be supplied to them; and the same were furnished to them on 08.06.2016.
Questioning the notice issued under Section 148 of the Act, the assessees preferred Writ Petition (M/S) No.2804 and 2813 of 2016. Both the Writ Petitions were dismissed by order dated 26.12.2016. Aggrieved thereby, the assessees-appellants filed Special Appeal Nos.29 and 30 of 2017 and a Division Bench of this Court, in its order dated 15.03.2017, observed that interference under Article 226 of the Constitution was not justified in the facts of the case; and it was open to the appellants (assessees) to raise all such contentions, as were available to them in law, before the statutory authority.
The appellants-assessees, thereafter, approached the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal which, in the order under appeal, noted that the learned Single Judge had observed that this Court was not inclined to entertain the writ petition for quashing the notice issued under Section 148 of the Act; it would be appropriate for the petitioner (assessees) to approach the Assessing Officer and reply to the notice; and it was always open to the petitioner to take all the pleas, before the Assessing Officer, which they had taken before the Court.
After taking note of the order of the learned Single Judge in Writ Petition (M/S) Nos.2804 and 2813 of 2016 dated 26.12.2016, the Tribunal observed that there was some force in the submission of the assessees that, when the order was passed on 26.12.2016 by the learned Single Judge, they could not have prosecuted their defense effectively before the learned Assessing Officer as only five days were left for the assessment to be completed; the order of the High Court was dated 26.12.2016, and the assessment order was passed on 30.12.2016; and, in such circumstances, they were of the view that, because of the paucity of time, the assessees could not conduct their defense effectively under Section 148 of the Act. The Tribunal deemed it just and proper to set-aside the impugned order, and remand the matter to the Assessing Officer for considering the matter afresh after affording an opportunity to the assessees to put forth their defense in all aspects, in terms of the order of the learned Single Judge which was to approach the Assessing Officer.
As noted hereinabove, the Division Bench disposed of the appeal leaving it open to the assessees to pursue the statutory remedy which the learned Single Judge had earlier held was to approach the Assessing Officer. As the learned Single Judge had passed an order on 26.12.2016, and the last date for assessment was 30.12.2016, the assessees, instead, preferred the Special Appeals before the Division Bench. During the pendency of the Special Appeals, revised assessment orders were passed by the Assessing Officer on 30.12.2016. Since the assessees could not have approached the Assessing Officer, thereafter, they preferred an appeal to the Commission of Income Tax (Appeals) and, on the appeal being rejected, they invoked the jurisdiction of the ITAT contending, among others, that the notice under Section 148(1) of the Act was not an effective service of notice. The Tribunal has exercised its discretion and, while setting-aside the revised assessment order dated 30.12.2016, had remanded the matter to the Assessing Officer, leaving it open to the assessees to raise all such contentions, as were available to them in law, before the Assessing Officer. Aggrieved thereby, the present appeals.
The only submission urged before us by Mr. B.M. Pingal, learned counsel for the appellants, is that, since the Tribunal is final court of fact, it should have determined the factual dispute regarding effective service of notice under Section 148(1) of the Act; and it ought not to have relegated the matter to the Assessing Officer to examine the matter afresh.
As noted hereinabove, the learned Single Judge had, in his order in Writ Petition (M/S) No.2804 and 2813 of 2016 dated 26.12.2016, permitted the assessees to approach the Assessing Officer. In the order under appeal the Tribunal having taken note of the fact that the assessees had a very little time to put forth their defense, set-aside the impugned order; and had directed the assessing officer to examine the matter afresh, leaving it open to the assessees to raise all such contentions as were available to them in law. Exercise of discretion by the Tribunal, to remand the matter to the Assessiong Officer, cannot be said to have caused prejudice to the assessees.
Interference, in proceedings under Section 260-A of the Act, is warranted against the order of the Tribunal, only if the said order gives rise to a substantial question of law. The order under appeal, whereby the assessment order was set-aside and the Assessing Officer was directed to examine the matter afresh, leaving it open to the assessees to put forth their defense on all aspects, does not give rise to any such substantial question of law warranting an appeal, under Section 260-A of the Act, being entertained.
10.
The appeals fail and are, accordingly, dismissed. No costs.
(N.S. Dhanik, J.)
(Ramesh Ranganathan, C. J.) 23.04.2019
23.04.2019
NISHANT
More judgments on Section 260-A
- Principal Commissionier of Income Tax vs M/S. Trident Microsystems India Pvt LtdITA/227/20215 Nov 2026
- The Commissioner of Income Tax vs Huawei TechnologiesITA/451/201329 Oct 2026
- The Pr. Commissioner of Income Tax -Central… vs Huawei Telecommunications ( India) Co. Pvt…ITA/775/202629 Oct 2026
- The Pr. Commissioner of Income Tax -Central… vs Huawei Telecommunications ( India) Co. Pvt…ITA/774/202629 Oct 2026
- The Pr. Commissioner of Income Tax -Central… vs Huawei Telecommunications ( India) Co. Pvt…ITA/771/202629 Oct 2026
Recent GST High Court judgments
Search GST case law →- M/S Steel Met Enterprises,Sundargarh vs. The Central Board Of Indirect Taxes And Customs,New DelhiOrissa · 18 Nov 2026
- Mangala Associates Private Limited vs. The Assistant Commissioner (Anti- Evasion) CGST And Central Excise, RourkelaOrissa · 18 Nov 2026
- M/S.Maasarala Fly Ash Bricks, Jagatpur vs. Commissioner Of CT And GST, CuttackOrissa · 18 Nov 2026
- Rapaka Govinda Rao vs. Assistant Commissioner CT And GST, Koraput, JeyporeOrissa · 18 Nov 2026
- M/S Life Care Emporium vs. Commissioner Of Commercial Taxes And GST,CuttackOrissa · 18 Nov 2026