BRIAN DWIGHT GAFFINO., vs. INCOME TAX OFFICER, MARGAO AND 3 ORS.,

PDF · subscribers
WP/689/2018HC BombayHCBM05002149201830 October 2018Author: HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE N. M. JAMDAR,HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE PRITHVIRAJ K. CHAVAN4 pages
AI SummaryRemanded

What did the High Court hold?

The High Court held that the present case squarely falls within the ambit of the law laid down in KEC International Ltd. The court found that the impugned orders were passed perfunctorily by the Department without proper reasons, solely for recovery purposes. Consequently, the impugned orders were set aside. The proceedings were restored to the Income Tax Officer, who was directed to decide the stay application afresh in light of the parameters outlined in KEC International Ltd. These parameters include briefly setting out the assessee's case, considering unconditional stay or partial deposit based on prima facie reasons, assessing financial viability for deposit, and examining the likelihood of the assessee defeating the demand before taking coercive action. The court also directed that no coercive steps be taken against the Petitioner pending the adjudication of the stay application.

What were the facts?

The Petitioner, Brian Dwight Gaffino, challenged orders passed by the Income Tax Officer and the Principal Commissioner of Income Tax concerning a stay of demand for Assessment Year 2010-11. The Income Tax Officer rejected the Petitioner's stay application on February 21, 2018, deeming the Petitioner in default. Subsequently, the Commissioner of Income Tax rejected the Petitioner's appeal on May 29, 2018. The Petitioner argued that these orders failed to consider the parameters laid down in the case of KEC International Ltd. vs. B.R. Balakrishnan. The Respondent did not file a reply affidavit.

What were the issues?

1. Whether the orders passed by the Income Tax Officer and the Principal Commissioner of Income Tax rejecting the Petitioner's stay application for Assessment Year 2010-11 were in accordance with the parameters laid down in KEC International Ltd. vs. B.R. Balakrishnan (Section 220 of the Income Tax Act, 1961, implicitly relevant for stay of demand). Assessee's Contention: The Petitioner contended that the impugned orders were passed without adhering to the parameters established in KEC International Ltd., which are crucial for deciding stay applications. The Petitioner argued that these parameters were not kept in mind, necessitating the setting aside of the orders. Revenue's Contention: The judgment records no specific arguments from the Respondent. However, the court noted that nothing was shown on behalf of the Respondent as to why the course of action suggested by the Petitioner should not be followed, and a reply affidavit was not filed.

Which sections of the Income-tax Act were involved?

Section 220

AI-generated summary — verify with the full judgment below

1 WP689-18dt 30-10-2018 IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY AT GOA

WRIT PETITION NO.689 OF 2018 Brian Dwight Gaffino … Petitioner Versus Income Tax Officer & Ors. …. Respondents Mr. S.R. Rivankar and Mr. A. Kakodkar, Advocates for the Petitioner. Ms. A. Razaq, Standing Counsel for the Respondent No.3. Coram : N.M. Jamdar & Prithviraj K. Chavan, JJ. Date : 30 October 2018. P.C. :

The Petitioner has challenged the orders passed by the Income Tax Officer and the Principal Commissioner of Income Tax in respect of the stay of demand for the Assessment Year 2010-11. By the order dated 21 February 2018, the Income Tax Officer rejected the application made by the Petitioner for stay of demand and the Petitioner was directed to be deemed to be in default to the extent of tax demand. The petition filed before the Commissioner of Income

2 WP689-18dt 30-10-2018 Tax was rejected by order dated 29 May 2018. 2. The learned counsel for the Petitioner has drawn our attention to the judgment in the case of KEC International Ltd. Vs B. R. Balakrishnan1. In the said judgment the Division Bench has laid down certain parameters for considering the stay application preferred by the Assessee. It is the contention of the Petitioner that while passing the impugned orders these parameters are not kept in mind and therefore, the impugned orders will have to be set aside and therefore the exercise would have to be kept in mind indicated in KEC International Ltd. Nothing is shown on behalf of the Respondent as to why this course of action should not be followed. Reply affidavit is not filed. 3. In the decision of KEC International Ltd., while setting aside the orders passed in respect of the stay of demand, the Division Bench had observed that in large number of matters the Court has found that such orders have been passed perfunctory by the Department only with an idea for recovery before date and without proper reasons. In view of the same, the Division Bench laid down certain parameters for dismissal which parameters reads thus:

[2001]251 ITR 158 ( Bombay )

3 WP689-18dt 30-10-2018 “(a) While considering the stay application, the authority concerned will at least briefly set out the case of the assessee. (b) In cases where the assessed income under the impugned order far exceeds returned income, the authority will consider whether the assessee has made out a case for unconditional stay. If not, whether looking to the questions involved in appeal, a part of the amount should be ordered to be deposited for which purpose, some short prima facie reasons could be given by the authority in its order. (c) In cases where the assessee relies upon financial difficulties, the authority concerned can briefly indicate whether the assessee is financially sound and viable to deposit the amount if the authority wants the assessee to so deposit. (d) The authority concerned will also examine whether the time to prefer an appeal has expired. Generally, coercive measures may not be adopted during the period provided by the statute to go in appeal. However, if the authority concerned comes to the conclusion that the assessee is likely to defeat the demand, it may take recourse to coercive action for which brief reasons may be indicated in the order, and (e) We clarify that if the authority concerned complies with the above parameters while passing orders on the stay application, then the authorities on the administrative side of the Department like respondent No. 2 herein need not once again give reasoned order.”

4 WP689-18dt 30-10-2018 In our opinion the present case squarely falls within the ambit of law laid down in the KEC International Ltd. 4. In these circumstances, the impugned orders will have to be set aside and accordingly set aside. The proceedings stand restored before the Income Tax Officer, who will decide the application in the light of the above parameters which we have culled out. Needless to state that since we have set aside the orders, no coercive steps be taken against the Petitioner pending the adjudication. 5. The writ petition is disposed of in above terms.

Prithviraj K. Chavan, J. N.M. Jamdar, J.

More judgments on Section 220

All 543 judgments and leading authorities on Section 220 →

Recent GST High Court judgments

Search GST case law →