Tin Box Company v. CIT

249 ITR 216Supreme Court of India2001#93 most cited

What is Tin Box Company v. CIT authority for?

When an issue is remitted to the Assessing Officer for fresh adjudication, the AO must conduct a de novo examination and provide the assessee a full opportunity of being heard. The assessee is bound to comply with the notices issued by the AO.

624

judgments rely on this decision, according to BharatTax’s citation analysis of 384,979 Indian tax judgments — from 2015 to 2026.

Also referred to as

Tin Box Company v CIT · 249 ITR 216 · remission to AO · fresh adjudication · de novo assessment · opportunity of being heard · natural justice · section 68 · unexplained share capital · set aside order · compliance with notices · section 143(3)

Issues it is cited on

Judgments citing Tin Box Company v. CIT

DCIT-CC-7(3), Mumbai vs. Shri Majni Karamshi Patel, Mumbai

In the result, the cross objections of the assessee and the appeal filed by the revenue is dismissed

ITA 6128/MUM/2019[2014-15]Status: DisposedITAT Mumbai10 Aug 2022AY 2014-15

Bench: Shri Pavan Kumar Gadale & Shri Gagan Goyal, Accountat Member Dcit, Cc-7(3) Vs. Shri Manji Karamshi Room No. 655, Patel Aayakar Bhavan, Office No. 1, Patel M.K.Road, Bhavan-29, Vijaywadi, Mumbai.-400020. Dr. Nagindas N Shah Lane Chira Bazar, Mumbai – 400002. "थायी लेखा सं./जीआइआर सं./Pan/Gir No. : Aabpp0130D Appellant .. Respondent Co No. 45/Mum/2021 (A.Y: 2014-15) Shri Manji Karamshi Vs. Dcit, Cc-7(3) Patel Room No. 655, Aayakar Office No. 1, Patel Bhavan, Bhuvan-29, Vijaywadi, M.K .Road, Dr. Nagindas N Shah Mumbai-400002. Lane Chira Bazar, Mumbai – 400002. "थायी लेखा सं./जीआइआर सं./Pan/Gir No. : Aabpp0130D Appellant .. Respondent

For Appellant: Shri.Rushab Mehta.ARFor Respondent: Shri .T .Shankar.DR
Section 142(1)Section 143(1)Section 143(2)Section 143(3)Section 148Section 68

…ts in breach of principles of natural justice. It is a serious flaw which renders the order a nullity. Attention is invited to the decision of the Three Hon'ble Judges of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of Tin Box Company v. Commissioner of Income-tax, 249 ITR 216 (SC), wherein the Hon'ble Lordships held as under :- " It is unnecessary to go into great detail in these matters for there is a statement in the order of the Tribunal, the fact- finding authority, that reads thus: "We will straightaway agree with the assessee's submission that the Income-tax Officer had not given to the assessee proper opportu…

New Metal Refinery India Pvt Ltd., Mumbai vs. DCIT 5(1)(2), Mumbai

In the result, the appeals filed by the assessee are allowed for statistical purposes

ITA 2616/MUM/2019[2013-14]Status: DisposedITAT Mumbai22 Jul 2022AY 2013-14

Bench: Shri Aby T. Varkey, Jm & Shri Gagan Goyal, Am आयकर अपील सं/ I.T.A. Nos. 2614 To 2616/Mum/2019 (निर्धारण वर्ा / Assessment Years:2009-10, 2010-11 & 2013-14) New Metal Refinery India बनाम/ Dcit-5(1)(2) Pvt. Ltd. Aayakar Bhavan, New Marine Vs. 132, Appa Building, S.V.P. Line, Mumbai-400020. Road, Null Bazar, Mumbai- 400004. स्थधयी लेखध सं./जीआइआर सं./Pan/Gir No. : Aabcn9710C (अपीलधथी /Appellant) (प्रत्यथी / Respondent) .. Assessee By: Shri Rajesh S. Shah Revenue By: Shri Chetan M. Kacha (Sr. Ar) सुिवधई की तधरीख / Date Of Hearing: 18/07/2022 घोर्णध की तधरीख /Date Of Pronouncement: 22/07/2022 आदेश / O R D E R Per Aby T. Varkey, Jm: These Are Appeals Preferred By The Assessee Against The Order Of The Ld. Commissioner Of Income Tax (Appeals)-10, Mumbai [Hereinafter In Short “Ld. Cit(A)”] Dated 22.01.2019 For A.Y. 2009- 10, 2010-11 & 2013-14. 2. At The Outset, The Ld. Ar Of The Assessee Pointed Out That The Impugned Order Of Ld. Cit(A) Is An Exparte Order, Even Though In The Cause-Title Of The Impugned Order, It Is Shown That Shri Shantilal Vora, Director Have Appeared For The Assessee. In Order To Demonstrate That It Was An Exparte Order, He Drew Our Attention To Para No. 7.2 Of The Impugned Order Wherein The Ld. Cit(A) Has Observed That The Appeal Was Fixed For Hearing Time To Time & That Shri Shantilal Vora, Director Of Assessee Appeared For Hearing Time To Time & Requested For Adjournments Which Were Granted But He Could Neither Make Any

For Appellant: Shri Rajesh S. ShahFor Respondent: Shri Chetan M. Kacha (Sr. AR)
Section 147

…the assessee. In the light of the aforesaid facts, according to him, the assessee did not get proper opportunity during the assessment proceedings itself. Therefore, relying on the decision of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Tin Box Company Vs. CIT (249 ITR 216) (SC), the Ld. AR submitted that since the assessee did not get proper opportunity during assessment proceedings, de novo assessment may be ordered. A.Ys.2009-10, 2010-11 & 2013-14 New Metal Refinery India Pvt. Ltd. And that assesssee undertakes to produce relevant documents before AO provided it is given a chance. 3. Per contra, the Ld. DR, repr…

New Metal Refinery India Pvt Ltd., Mumbai vs. DCIT 5(1)(2), Mumbai

In the result, the appeals filed by the assessee are allowed for statistical purposes

ITA 2615/MUM/2019[2010-11]Status: DisposedITAT Mumbai22 Jul 2022AY 2010-11

Bench: Shri Aby T. Varkey, Jm & Shri Gagan Goyal, Am आयकर अपील सं/ I.T.A. Nos. 2614 To 2616/Mum/2019 (निर्धारण वर्ा / Assessment Years:2009-10, 2010-11 & 2013-14) New Metal Refinery India बनाम/ Dcit-5(1)(2) Pvt. Ltd. Aayakar Bhavan, New Marine Vs. 132, Appa Building, S.V.P. Line, Mumbai-400020. Road, Null Bazar, Mumbai- 400004. स्थधयी लेखध सं./जीआइआर सं./Pan/Gir No. : Aabcn9710C (अपीलधथी /Appellant) (प्रत्यथी / Respondent) .. Assessee By: Shri Rajesh S. Shah Revenue By: Shri Chetan M. Kacha (Sr. Ar) सुिवधई की तधरीख / Date Of Hearing: 18/07/2022 घोर्णध की तधरीख /Date Of Pronouncement: 22/07/2022 आदेश / O R D E R Per Aby T. Varkey, Jm: These Are Appeals Preferred By The Assessee Against The Order Of The Ld. Commissioner Of Income Tax (Appeals)-10, Mumbai [Hereinafter In Short “Ld. Cit(A)”] Dated 22.01.2019 For A.Y. 2009- 10, 2010-11 & 2013-14. 2. At The Outset, The Ld. Ar Of The Assessee Pointed Out That The Impugned Order Of Ld. Cit(A) Is An Exparte Order, Even Though In The Cause-Title Of The Impugned Order, It Is Shown That Shri Shantilal Vora, Director Have Appeared For The Assessee. In Order To Demonstrate That It Was An Exparte Order, He Drew Our Attention To Para No. 7.2 Of The Impugned Order Wherein The Ld. Cit(A) Has Observed That The Appeal Was Fixed For Hearing Time To Time & That Shri Shantilal Vora, Director Of Assessee Appeared For Hearing Time To Time & Requested For Adjournments Which Were Granted But He Could Neither Make Any

For Appellant: Shri Rajesh S. ShahFor Respondent: Shri Chetan M. Kacha (Sr. AR)
Section 147

…the assessee. In the light of the aforesaid facts, according to him, the assessee did not get proper opportunity during the assessment proceedings itself. Therefore, relying on the decision of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Tin Box Company Vs. CIT (249 ITR 216) (SC), the Ld. AR submitted that since the assessee did not get proper opportunity during assessment proceedings, de novo assessment may be ordered. A.Ys.2009-10, 2010-11 & 2013-14 New Metal Refinery India Pvt. Ltd. And that assesssee undertakes to produce relevant documents before AO provided it is given a chance. 3. Per contra, the Ld. DR, repr…

New Metal Refinery India Pvt Ltd., Mumbai vs. DCIT 5(1)(2), Mumbai

In the result, the appeals filed by the assessee are allowed for statistical purposes

ITA 2614/MUM/2019[2009-10]Status: DisposedITAT Mumbai22 Jul 2022AY 2009-10

Bench: Shri Aby T. Varkey, Jm & Shri Gagan Goyal, Am आयकर अपील सं/ I.T.A. Nos. 2614 To 2616/Mum/2019 (निर्धारण वर्ा / Assessment Years:2009-10, 2010-11 & 2013-14) New Metal Refinery India बनाम/ Dcit-5(1)(2) Pvt. Ltd. Aayakar Bhavan, New Marine Vs. 132, Appa Building, S.V.P. Line, Mumbai-400020. Road, Null Bazar, Mumbai- 400004. स्थधयी लेखध सं./जीआइआर सं./Pan/Gir No. : Aabcn9710C (अपीलधथी /Appellant) (प्रत्यथी / Respondent) .. Assessee By: Shri Rajesh S. Shah Revenue By: Shri Chetan M. Kacha (Sr. Ar) सुिवधई की तधरीख / Date Of Hearing: 18/07/2022 घोर्णध की तधरीख /Date Of Pronouncement: 22/07/2022 आदेश / O R D E R Per Aby T. Varkey, Jm: These Are Appeals Preferred By The Assessee Against The Order Of The Ld. Commissioner Of Income Tax (Appeals)-10, Mumbai [Hereinafter In Short “Ld. Cit(A)”] Dated 22.01.2019 For A.Y. 2009- 10, 2010-11 & 2013-14. 2. At The Outset, The Ld. Ar Of The Assessee Pointed Out That The Impugned Order Of Ld. Cit(A) Is An Exparte Order, Even Though In The Cause-Title Of The Impugned Order, It Is Shown That Shri Shantilal Vora, Director Have Appeared For The Assessee. In Order To Demonstrate That It Was An Exparte Order, He Drew Our Attention To Para No. 7.2 Of The Impugned Order Wherein The Ld. Cit(A) Has Observed That The Appeal Was Fixed For Hearing Time To Time & That Shri Shantilal Vora, Director Of Assessee Appeared For Hearing Time To Time & Requested For Adjournments Which Were Granted But He Could Neither Make Any

For Appellant: Shri Rajesh S. ShahFor Respondent: Shri Chetan M. Kacha (Sr. AR)
Section 147

…the assessee. In the light of the aforesaid facts, according to him, the assessee did not get proper opportunity during the assessment proceedings itself. Therefore, relying on the decision of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Tin Box Company Vs. CIT (249 ITR 216) (SC), the Ld. AR submitted that since the assessee did not get proper opportunity during assessment proceedings, de novo assessment may be ordered. A.Ys.2009-10, 2010-11 & 2013-14 New Metal Refinery India Pvt. Ltd. And that assesssee undertakes to produce relevant documents before AO provided it is given a chance. 3. Per contra, the Ld. DR, repr…

Deloitte Touche Tohmatsu India LLP (Sucessor of Delotte Touche Tohmatsu India Pvt. Ltd, Mumbai vs. ACIT -Cir 6(2) (1), Mumbai

In the result, the appeal of the assessee is allowed for statistical purposes

ITA 9/MUM/2022[2012-13]Status: DisposedITAT Mumbai31 May 2022AY 2012-13

Bench: Shri Aby T. Varkey, Jm & Shri S. Rifaur Rahman, Am आयकर अपील सं/ I.T.A. No.09/Mum/2022 (निर्धारण वर्ा / Assessment Years: 2012-13) Deloitte Touche Tohmatsu बिधम/ Acit-Circle 6(2)(1) India Llp (Successor Of Room No.504, 5Th Floor, Vs. Delotte Touche Tohmatsu Aayakar Bhavan, India Pvt. Ltd.) Maharshi Karve Road, One International Centre, Churchgate, Mumbai- Tower-3, 32Nd Floor, 400020. Senapati Bapat Marg, Elphinstone Road (W), Mumbai-400013. स्थधयी लेखध सं./जीआइआर सं./Pan/Gir No. : Aalfd7157J (अपीलार्थी /Appellant) .. (प्रत्यर्थी / Respondent) Assessee By: Shri Ketan Ved Revenue By: Ms. R. M. Madhavi (Dr) सुनवाई की तारीख / Date Of Hearing: 23/05/2022 घोषणा की तारीख /Date Of Pronouncement: 09/05/2022 आदेश / O R D E R Per Aby T. Varkey, Jm: This Is An Appeal Preferred By The Assessee Against The Order Of The Ld. Commissioner Of Income Tax (Appeals) (Nfac), Delhi Dated 15.11.2021 For The Assessment Year 2012-13. 2. At The Outset, The Ld. Ar Of The Assessee Drew Our Attention To The Fact That The First Appellate Authority (Nfac) Has Passed The Order Without Giving Proper Opportunity To The Assessee. According To The Ld. Ar, The Assessee Had Filed All The Documents Sought For By The Cit(A) As Well As Had Filed Application Dated 23.01.2019 For Admission Of Additional Evidences (Refer Page No. 5 To 8 Of The Paper Book) As Well As Copy Of Letter Dated 25.10.2021 Uploaded On Income Tax E- Filing Portal On 09.10.2021 In Response To The Notices Dated 01.10.2021 & 11.10.2021 Respectively (Page No. 1 To 4 Of The Paper Book)

For Appellant: Shri Ketan VedFor Respondent: Ms. R. M. Madhavi (DR)
Section 36(1)(iii)

…as not been correctly taken by the AO while computing the disallowance so according to the Ld. AR, the assessee didn’t get proper opportunity before the AO, therefore relying on the decision of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Tin Box Company Vs. CIT (249 ITR 216) (SC) he pleaded that the issue may be remanded back to AO for fresh assessment on this issue. 3. Per contra the Ld. DR after taking note of the aforesaid fact and also the fact that the assessee had filed additional evidences before the Ld. CIT(A) since there was reasonable cause for not presenting the 3 A.Y. 2012-13 Deloitte Touche same before…

Kaushal Premchand Luhadiya, Mumbai vs. ITO 33(2)(2), Mumbai

In the result, the appeal of the assessee is allowed for statistical purposes

ITA 1308/MUM/2020[2011-12]Status: DisposedITAT Mumbai27 May 2022AY 2011-12

Bench: Shri Aby T. Varkey, Jm & Shri Gagan Goyal, Am आयकर अपील सं/ I.T.A. No.1308/Mum/2020 (निर्धारण वर्ा / Assessment Years: 2011-12) Kaushal Premchand बिधम/ Ito-33(2)(2) Luhadiya Room No.846, 8Th Floor, Vs. 2201, A-Wing, Mit- Kautilya Bhavan, C-41 To Niketan Tower, 90Ft Road, C-43, G-Block, Bandra Near Sanskruti Building, Kurla Complex, Bandra Thakur Complex, Kandivali East, Mumbai-400051. East, Mumbai-400101. स्थधयी लेखध सं./जीआइआर सं./Pan/Gir No. : Aawpl3781H (अपीलार्थी /Appellant) .. (प्रत्यर्थी / Respondent) Assessee By: Shri Hari S. Raheja Revenue By: Shri Vijay Kumar Soni (Sr. Ar) सुनवाई की तारीख / Date Of Hearing: 12/05/2022 घोषणा की तारीख /Date Of Pronouncement: 27/05/2022 आदेश / O R D E R Per Aby T. Varkey, Jm: This Is An Appeal Preferred By The Assessee Against The Order Of The Ld. Commissioner Of Income Tax (Appeals)-45, Mumbai Dated 30.12.2019 For The Assessment Year 2011-12. 2. At The Outset, The Ld. Ar Of The Assessee Drew Our Attention To The Impugned Order Of The Ld. Cit(A) Which Is An Ex-Parte Order. Further, He Also Brought To Our Notice That The Ao Has Also Passed An Ex-Parte Order U/S 144 R.W.S 147 Of The Income Tax Act, 1961 [Hereinafter (‘The Act’)]. According To The Ld. Ar The Ex-Parte Orders Were Passed Because The Assessee Had Entrusted His Case To Shri Manoj Doshi Itp Who Mislead Him By Stating That He Is Appearing Before The Ao/Cit(A). However, Only Once The Assessee Received The Impugned Order, He Understood That The Itp Did Not Appear Before Ld Cit(A)

For Appellant: Shri Hari S. RahejaFor Respondent: Shri Vijay Kumar Soni (Sr. AR)
Section 144

…ing perused it and have going through the contents of the same, we are of the opinion that the assessee did not get proper opportunity before the AO. Therefore, relying upon the decision of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in similar case of Tin Box Company Vs. CIT (249 ITR 216) (SC) wherein the Hon’ble Supreme Court held as under: - “ It is unnecessary to go into great detail in these matters for there is a statement in the order of the Tribunal, the fact-finding authority, that reads thus : "We will straightway agree with the assessee's submission that the ITO had not given to the assessee proper opportunity of being…

Ashoka Creations Limited, Kolkata vs. I.T.O., Ward-4(3), Kolkata

In the result, the appeal of the assessee is treated as allowed for statistical

ITA 28/KOL/2020[2013-14]Status: DisposedITAT Kolkata23 Feb 2022AY 2013-14

Bench: Shri Aby T. Varkey, Hon’Ble & Shri Girish Agrawal, Hon’Ble) Assessment Year: 2013-14 Ashoka Creations Pvt. Limited...................................................................………………….............Appellant 204 Eastern Building 19, R.N. Mukherjee Road Kolkata – 700 001 [Pan : Aacca 4333 K] Vs. Income Tax Officer, Ward-4(3), Kolkata...........................................................………..…......Respondent Appearances By: None, Appeared On Behalf Of The Assessee. Shri Biswanath Das, Addl. Cit, Sr. D/R, Appearing On Behalf Of The Revenue. Date Of Concluding The Hearing : February 2Nd, 2022 Date Of Pronouncing The Order : February 23Rd, 2022 Order

Section 143(2)

…given proper opportunity to explain the facts as held by the ven proper opportunity to explain the facts as held by the Apex Court in the case of Tin Box Co. v. Commissioner of Income Apex Court in the case of Tin Box Co. v. Commissioner of Income-tax [2001] 249 ITR 216 [2001] 249 ITR 216 (SC) that order must be made after the assessee has been given a reasonable opportunity order must be made after the assessee has been given a reasonable opportunity order must be made after the assessee has been given a reasonable opportunity of setting out his case. Accordingly, considering the records before us, facts discus…

Rawatsons Engineers Pvt. Ltd., Kolkata vs. A.C.I.T., Circle-15(1), Kolkata

In the result, the appeal of the assessee is treated as allowed for statistical

ITA 2610/KOL/2019[2009-10]Status: DisposedITAT Kolkata23 Feb 2022AY 2009-10

Bench: Shri Aby T. Varkey, Hon’Ble & Shri Girish Agrawal, Hon’Ble) Assessment Year: 2009-10 Rawatsons Engineering Pvt. Ltd...............................................................………………….............Appellant 7C, Mani Square 164/1, Manicktalla Main Road Kankurgachi Kolkata – 700 064 [Pan : Aabcr 2957 D] Vs. Asstt. Commissioner Of Income Tax, Circle-15(1), Kolkata.....................………..…......Respondent Appearances By: None, Appeared On Behalf Of The Assessee. Shri Biswanath Das, Addl. Cit, Sr. D/R, Appearing On Behalf Of The Revenue. Date Of Concluding The Hearing : February 2Nd, 2022 Date Of Pronouncing The Order : February 23Rd, 2022 Order

Section 144Section 148

…given proper opportunity to explain the facts as held by the assessee ought to have been given proper opportunity to explain the facts as held by the Apex Court in the case of Tin Box Apex Court in the case of Tin Box Co. v. Commissioner of Income-tax [2001] 249 ITR 216 [2001] 249 ITR 216 (SC) that order must be made after the assessee has been given a order must be made after the assessee has been given a reasonable opportunity reasonable opportunity of setting out his case. Accordingly, considering the Accordingly, considering the records before us, facts discussed records before us, facts discussed above and…