CIT v. Pruthvi Brokers & Shareholders

349 ITR 336High Court2012#47 most cited

What is CIT v. Pruthvi Brokers & Shareholders authority for?

Appellate authorities can entertain fresh claims or revised computations of income made by an assessee, even if these were not submitted through a revised return of income.

956

judgments rely on this decision, according to BharatTax’s citation analysis of 384,082 Indian tax judgments — from 2014 to 2026.

Also referred to as

Pruthvi Brokers & Shareholders · 349 ITR 336 · Bombay High Court · appellate authority power · entertain fresh claim · additional ground of appeal · revised computation of income · absence of revised return · section 139 · Goetz India Ltd. · Tribunal power

Issues it is cited on

Judgments citing CIT v. Pruthvi Brokers & Shareholders

Vinyroyal Plasicoates P.Ltd, Mumbai vs. ITO 9(3)(3), Mumbai

In the result, the appeals filed by the assessee are treated as allowed for statistical purpose

ITA 1240/MUM/2013[2008-09]Status: DisposedITAT Mumbai16 Dec 2015AY 2008-09

Bench: Shri N.K. Billaiya & Shri Pawan Singhआयकर अपील सं/ I.Ta Nos.1240 & 1243/Mum/2013 ("नधा"रण वष" / Assessment Years:2008-09 & 2009-10 बनाम/ M/S. Vinyroyal The Ito 9(3)-3, Plasticoates Pvt. Ltd., Aayakar Bhavan, Vs. Plot No. 60Cd, Mumbai-400 020 Shlok Bldg., 1St Floor, Govt. Ind. Est, Charkop, Kandivli (W), Mumbai-400 067 "थायी लेखा सं./जीआइआर सं./Pan/Gir No. : Aaacv 4165E (अपीलाथ" /Appellant) (""यथ" / Respondent) .. अपीलाथ" ओर से/ Appellant By: Shri Mayur A. Shah ""यथ" क" ओर से/Respondent By: Shri Pawan Kumar Beerla सुनवाई क" तार"ख / Date Of Hearing :08.12.2015 घोषणा क" तार"ख /Date Of Pronouncement : 16.12 .2015 आदेश / O R D E R Per N.K. Billaiya, Am: These Appeals By The Assessee Are Preferred Against Two Separate Orders Of The Ld. Cit(A)-20, Mumbai Dated 17.12.2012 & 27.12.2012 Pertaining To Assessment Years 2008-09 & 2009-10. Both These Appeals Have Common Grievance By The Assessee Therefore They Were Heard Together & Disposed Of By This Common Order For The Sake Of Convenience.

For Appellant: Shri Mayur A. ShahFor Respondent: Shri Pawan Kumar
Section 36(1)(iii)

…the AO by way of a revised computation of income but the same was not accepted for want of revised return of income. The Ld. Counsel relied upon the decision of the Hon’ble High Court of Bombay in the case of CIT Vs Pruthivi Brokers and Shareholders Pvt. Ltd. 349 ITR 336. 4. Per contra, the Ld. Departmental Representative strongly relied upon the decision of the Hon’ble High Court of Gujarat in the case of CIT Vs Gujarat State Road Transport Corpn. 366 ITR 170. 5. We have given a thoughtful consideration to the factual matrix. Undisputedly, the assessee has paid the contributions which have been received from the…

Addl CIT RG 1(3), Mumbai vs. Rabo India Finance Ltd, Mumbai

ITA 3845/MUM/2011[2006-07]Status: DisposedITAT Mumbai09 Dec 2015AY 2006-07

Bench: S/Shri B.R.Baskaran, Am & Amarjit Singh, Jm आमकय अऩीर सं./I.T.A. No.2511/Mum/2011 (ननधधायण वषा / Assessment Year:2003-04) Rabo India Finance Limited, बनाम/ Asst.Commissioner Of Income Tax Forbes Building, 2Nd Floor, Range -1(3), Vs. Charanjit Rai Marg, Fort, Aayakar Bhavan, Mumbai-400001 Mumbai-400020 (अऩीरधथी /Appellant) (प्रत्मथी / Respondent) .. आमकय अऩीर सं./Ita No.3169/Mum/2011 (ननधधायण वषा / Assessment Year: 2003-04) बनाम/ Jt.Commissioner Of Income Tax M/S Rabo India Finance Limited, Forbes Building, 2Nd Floor, Range 1(3), Vs. Room No.540/564, 5Th Floor, Charanjit Rai Marg, Fort, Aayakar Bhavan, M K Road, Mumbai-400001 New Marine Lines, Mumbai-400020 (अऩीरधथी /Appellant) (प्रत्मथी / Respondent) ..

Section 10

…the ld. CIT(A) declined to adjudicate upon the said claim on the ground that the same is not arising out of assessment order. The ld. Counsel placed reliance on the decision of Hon’ble Bombay High Court in the case of Pruthvi Brokers & Shares Pvt. Ltd [2012] 349 ITR 336 (Bom) and submitted that the additional claim is maintainable before the appellate authority. Accordingly, he prayed that the ground of the assessee may be accepted and the same may be restored to the file of the AO for examining the same. Since, the claim of the assessee is admissible in view of the decision of the Jurisdictional High Court in P…

Addl CIT RG 1(3), Mumbai vs. Rabo India Finance Ltd, Mumbai

ITA 3844/MUM/2011[2005-06]Status: DisposedITAT Mumbai09 Dec 2015AY 2005-06

Bench: S/Shri B.R.Baskaran, Am & Amarjit Singh, Jm आमकय अऩीर सं./I.T.A. No.2511/Mum/2011 (ननधधायण वषा / Assessment Year:2003-04) Rabo India Finance Limited, बनाम/ Asst.Commissioner Of Income Tax Forbes Building, 2Nd Floor, Range -1(3), Vs. Charanjit Rai Marg, Fort, Aayakar Bhavan, Mumbai-400001 Mumbai-400020 (अऩीरधथी /Appellant) (प्रत्मथी / Respondent) .. आमकय अऩीर सं./Ita No.3169/Mum/2011 (ननधधायण वषा / Assessment Year: 2003-04) बनाम/ Jt.Commissioner Of Income Tax M/S Rabo India Finance Limited, Forbes Building, 2Nd Floor, Range 1(3), Vs. Room No.540/564, 5Th Floor, Charanjit Rai Marg, Fort, Aayakar Bhavan, M K Road, Mumbai-400001 New Marine Lines, Mumbai-400020 (अऩीरधथी /Appellant) (प्रत्मथी / Respondent) ..

Section 10

…the ld. CIT(A) declined to adjudicate upon the said claim on the ground that the same is not arising out of assessment order. The ld. Counsel placed reliance on the decision of Hon’ble Bombay High Court in the case of Pruthvi Brokers & Shares Pvt. Ltd [2012] 349 ITR 336 (Bom) and submitted that the additional claim is maintainable before the appellate authority. Accordingly, he prayed that the ground of the assessee may be accepted and the same may be restored to the file of the AO for examining the same. Since, the claim of the assessee is admissible in view of the decision of the Jurisdictional High Court in P…

ACIT 1(3), Mumbai vs. Rabo India Finance Ltd, Mumbai

ITA 3169/MUM/2011[2003-04]Status: DisposedITAT Mumbai09 Dec 2015AY 2003-04

Bench: S/Shri B.R.Baskaran, Am & Amarjit Singh, Jm आमकय अऩीर सं./I.T.A. No.2511/Mum/2011 (ननधधायण वषा / Assessment Year:2003-04) Rabo India Finance Limited, बनाम/ Asst.Commissioner Of Income Tax Forbes Building, 2Nd Floor, Range -1(3), Vs. Charanjit Rai Marg, Fort, Aayakar Bhavan, Mumbai-400001 Mumbai-400020 (अऩीरधथी /Appellant) (प्रत्मथी / Respondent) .. आमकय अऩीर सं./Ita No.3169/Mum/2011 (ननधधायण वषा / Assessment Year: 2003-04) बनाम/ Jt.Commissioner Of Income Tax M/S Rabo India Finance Limited, Forbes Building, 2Nd Floor, Range 1(3), Vs. Room No.540/564, 5Th Floor, Charanjit Rai Marg, Fort, Aayakar Bhavan, M K Road, Mumbai-400001 New Marine Lines, Mumbai-400020 (अऩीरधथी /Appellant) (प्रत्मथी / Respondent) ..

Section 10

…the ld. CIT(A) declined to adjudicate upon the said claim on the ground that the same is not arising out of assessment order. The ld. Counsel placed reliance on the decision of Hon’ble Bombay High Court in the case of Pruthvi Brokers & Shares Pvt. Ltd [2012] 349 ITR 336 (Bom) and submitted that the additional claim is maintainable before the appellate authority. Accordingly, he prayed that the ground of the assessee may be accepted and the same may be restored to the file of the AO for examining the same. Since, the claim of the assessee is admissible in view of the decision of the Jurisdictional High Court in P…

Rabo India Finance Ltd, Mumbai vs. ACIT RG 1(3), Mumbai

ITA 2513/MUM/2011[2006-07]Status: DisposedITAT Mumbai09 Dec 2015AY 2006-07

Bench: S/Shri B.R.Baskaran, Am & Amarjit Singh, Jm आमकय अऩीर सं./I.T.A. No.2511/Mum/2011 (ननधधायण वषा / Assessment Year:2003-04) Rabo India Finance Limited, बनाम/ Asst.Commissioner Of Income Tax Forbes Building, 2Nd Floor, Range -1(3), Vs. Charanjit Rai Marg, Fort, Aayakar Bhavan, Mumbai-400001 Mumbai-400020 (अऩीरधथी /Appellant) (प्रत्मथी / Respondent) .. आमकय अऩीर सं./Ita No.3169/Mum/2011 (ननधधायण वषा / Assessment Year: 2003-04) बनाम/ Jt.Commissioner Of Income Tax M/S Rabo India Finance Limited, Forbes Building, 2Nd Floor, Range 1(3), Vs. Room No.540/564, 5Th Floor, Charanjit Rai Marg, Fort, Aayakar Bhavan, M K Road, Mumbai-400001 New Marine Lines, Mumbai-400020 (अऩीरधथी /Appellant) (प्रत्मथी / Respondent) ..

Section 10

…the ld. CIT(A) declined to adjudicate upon the said claim on the ground that the same is not arising out of assessment order. The ld. Counsel placed reliance on the decision of Hon’ble Bombay High Court in the case of Pruthvi Brokers & Shares Pvt. Ltd [2012] 349 ITR 336 (Bom) and submitted that the additional claim is maintainable before the appellate authority. Accordingly, he prayed that the ground of the assessee may be accepted and the same may be restored to the file of the AO for examining the same. Since, the claim of the assessee is admissible in view of the decision of the Jurisdictional High Court in P…

Rabo India Finance Ltd, Mumbai vs. ACIT RG 1(3), Mumbai

ITA 2512/MUM/2011[2005-06]Status: DisposedITAT Mumbai09 Dec 2015AY 2005-06

Bench: S/Shri B.R.Baskaran, Am & Amarjit Singh, Jm आमकय अऩीर सं./I.T.A. No.2511/Mum/2011 (ननधधायण वषा / Assessment Year:2003-04) Rabo India Finance Limited, बनाम/ Asst.Commissioner Of Income Tax Forbes Building, 2Nd Floor, Range -1(3), Vs. Charanjit Rai Marg, Fort, Aayakar Bhavan, Mumbai-400001 Mumbai-400020 (अऩीरधथी /Appellant) (प्रत्मथी / Respondent) .. आमकय अऩीर सं./Ita No.3169/Mum/2011 (ननधधायण वषा / Assessment Year: 2003-04) बनाम/ Jt.Commissioner Of Income Tax M/S Rabo India Finance Limited, Forbes Building, 2Nd Floor, Range 1(3), Vs. Room No.540/564, 5Th Floor, Charanjit Rai Marg, Fort, Aayakar Bhavan, M K Road, Mumbai-400001 New Marine Lines, Mumbai-400020 (अऩीरधथी /Appellant) (प्रत्मथी / Respondent) ..

Section 10

…the ld. CIT(A) declined to adjudicate upon the said claim on the ground that the same is not arising out of assessment order. The ld. Counsel placed reliance on the decision of Hon’ble Bombay High Court in the case of Pruthvi Brokers & Shares Pvt. Ltd [2012] 349 ITR 336 (Bom) and submitted that the additional claim is maintainable before the appellate authority. Accordingly, he prayed that the ground of the assessee may be accepted and the same may be restored to the file of the AO for examining the same. Since, the claim of the assessee is admissible in view of the decision of the Jurisdictional High Court in P…

Rabo India Finance Ltd, Mumbai vs. ACIT RG 1(3), Mumbai

ITA 2511/MUM/2011[2003-04]Status: DisposedITAT Mumbai09 Dec 2015AY 2003-04

Bench: S/Shri B.R.Baskaran, Am & Amarjit Singh, Jm आमकय अऩीर सं./I.T.A. No.2511/Mum/2011 (ननधधायण वषा / Assessment Year:2003-04) Rabo India Finance Limited, बनाम/ Asst.Commissioner Of Income Tax Forbes Building, 2Nd Floor, Range -1(3), Vs. Charanjit Rai Marg, Fort, Aayakar Bhavan, Mumbai-400001 Mumbai-400020 (अऩीरधथी /Appellant) (प्रत्मथी / Respondent) .. आमकय अऩीर सं./Ita No.3169/Mum/2011 (ननधधायण वषा / Assessment Year: 2003-04) बनाम/ Jt.Commissioner Of Income Tax M/S Rabo India Finance Limited, Forbes Building, 2Nd Floor, Range 1(3), Vs. Room No.540/564, 5Th Floor, Charanjit Rai Marg, Fort, Aayakar Bhavan, M K Road, Mumbai-400001 New Marine Lines, Mumbai-400020 (अऩीरधथी /Appellant) (प्रत्मथी / Respondent) ..

Section 10

…the ld. CIT(A) declined to adjudicate upon the said claim on the ground that the same is not arising out of assessment order. The ld. Counsel placed reliance on the decision of Hon’ble Bombay High Court in the case of Pruthvi Brokers & Shares Pvt. Ltd [2012] 349 ITR 336 (Bom) and submitted that the additional claim is maintainable before the appellate authority. Accordingly, he prayed that the ground of the assessee may be accepted and the same may be restored to the file of the AO for examining the same. Since, the claim of the assessee is admissible in view of the decision of the Jurisdictional High Court in P…

Fortune Equity Brokers (I) Ltd, Mumbai vs. DCIT RG 4(1), Mumbai

In the result, the appeal filed by the assessee is treated as allowed for statistical purpose

ITA 157/MUM/2013[2009-10]Status: DisposedITAT Mumbai08 Dec 2015AY 2009-10

Bench: Shri N.K. Billaiya & Shri Pawan Singhआयकर अपील सं/ I.T.A. No.157/Mum/2013 ("नधा"रण वष" / Assessment Year:2009-10 बनाम/ M/S. Intime Equities Ltd., The Dcit, Range-4(1), (Formerly Known As M/S. Mumbai Vs. Fortune Equity Brokers (I) Ltd., 2002, Naman Midtown, A Wing, Senapati Bapat Marg, Elephinstone Road (W), Mumbai-400 013 "थायी लेखा सं./जीआइआर सं./Pan/Gir No. : Aaacg 2063L (अपीलाथ" /Appellant) (""यथ" / Respondent) .. अपीलाथ" ओर से/ Appellant By: Shri Anuj Kisnadwala ""यथ" क" ओर से/Respondent By: Shri Pawan Kumar Beerla सुनवाई क" तार"ख / Date Of Hearing :08.12.2015 घोषणा क" तार"ख /Date Of Pronouncement :08.12.2015 आदेश / O R D E R Per N.K. Billaiya, Am: With This Appeal The Assessee Has Challenged The Correctness Of The Order Of The Ld. Cit(A)-8, Mumbai Dated 2.11.2012 Pertaining To Assessment Year 2009-10. 2. The Grievance Of The Assessee Relates To The Disallowance Of Rs. 45,10,958/- U/S. 14A Of The Act.

For Appellant: Shri Anuj KisnadwalaFor Respondent: Shri Pawan Kumar
Section 14A

…true that the decision of the Hon’ble Supreme Court does not fetter the powers of the Appellate authorities. Our view is also fortified by the decision of the Hon’ble Jurisdictional High Court in the case of CIT Vs Pruthvi Brokers And Shareholders Pvt. Ltd., 349 ITR 336. Respectfully 3 ITA. No.157/M/2013 following the ratio laid down by the Hon’ble Jurisdictional High Court (supra), we restore this issue to the file of the AO. The AO is directed to decide the issue afresh in the light of the revised computation of income filed by the assessee. Needless to mention, the AO shall give reasonable opportunity of be…