CIT v. Pruthvi Brokers & Shareholders

349 ITR 336High Court2012#47 most cited

What is CIT v. Pruthvi Brokers & Shareholders authority for?

Appellate authorities can entertain fresh claims or revised computations of income made by an assessee, even if these were not submitted through a revised return of income.

956

judgments rely on this decision, according to BharatTax’s citation analysis of 384,082 Indian tax judgments — from 2014 to 2026.

Also referred to as

Pruthvi Brokers & Shareholders · 349 ITR 336 · Bombay High Court · appellate authority power · entertain fresh claim · additional ground of appeal · revised computation of income · absence of revised return · section 139 · Goetz India Ltd. · Tribunal power

Issues it is cited on

Judgments citing CIT v. Pruthvi Brokers & Shareholders

ITO 15(2)(4), Mumbai vs. Shivraj Sahakari Patsanstha Maryadit, Mumbai

ITA 5268/MUM/2014[2010-11]Status: DisposedITAT Mumbai31 Mar 2017AY 2010-11

Bench: S/Sh.Rajendra & Amarjit Singhिनधा"रण वष" वष" /Assessment Year: 2010-11 आयकर अपील सं./I.T.A./5268/Mum/2014,िनधा"रण िनधा"रण िनधा"रण वष" वष" Income Tax Officer-15(2)(4) M/S. Shivraj Sahakari Patsanstha Maryadit Matru Mandir, Room No.111, Grant S.S. Sanstha Maryadit, Omkar Chs, Bldg. Road(W) Vs. No.32/934, Pant Nagar, Ghatkopar (E) Mumbai-400 007. Mumbai. Pan:Aaajs 2751 A (अपीलाथ" /Appellant) (""यथ" / Respondent) राज"व क" ओर से / Revenue By: Dr. A.K. Nayak-Dr अपीलाथ" क" ओर से /Assessee By: None सुनवाई क" तारीख / Date Of Hearing: 22/03/2017 घोषणा क" तारीख / Date Of Pronouncement: 31.03.2017 लेखा सद"य सद"य राजे"" राजे"" केकेकेके अनुसार अनुसार /Per Rajendra, Am- लेखा लेखा लेखा सद"य सद"य राजे"" राजे"" अनुसार अनुसार Challenging The Order Dated 16/06/2014 Of The Cit (A)-26, Mumbai, The Assessing Officer (Ao) Has Filed The Present Appeal. Assessee, An Aop, Filed Its Return Of Income On 13/09/2010, Declaring Total Income At Rs. Nil, After Claiming Deduction U/S. 80P Of The Act, Amounting Rs. 44.50 Lakhs. The Ao Completed The Assessment U/S. 143 (3) Of The Act, On 28/03/2013, Determining Its Income At Rs. 44, 50, 811/-

For Appellant: NoneFor Respondent: Dr. A.K. Nayak-DR
Section 143Section 2Section 56Section 80P

…admissible in view of the findings of the Hon'ble Apex Court in the case of Goetze India Ltd. [284 ITR 323 (SC) (2006)], it is pertinent to mention that the Hon'ble Bombay High Court in the case of the CIT Vs. Pruthvi Brokers and Shareholders P. Ltd. [(2012) 349 ITR 336 (Bom)] has held that the appellate authorities have the power to consider the claim not made in return of income. The Ho'ble Bombay High Court while deciding so, has considered the judgment of the Hon'ble Apex Court in the case of Goetze India Ltd. (supra). In view of that matter, the Ld.CIT(A) giving relief to the assessee at the appellate stage…

Truetzscheler India P.Ltd, Mumbai vs. Asst CIT 2(3), Mumbai

In the result, appeal of the assessee is allowed

ITA 2638/MUM/2014[2005-06]Status: DisposedITAT Mumbai03 Feb 2017AY 2005-06

Bench: Shri D Karunakara Rao & Shri Cn Prasad: (A.Y : 2005-06) M/S Truetzschler India Pvt. Ltd Vs. Asst. Commissioner Of Income-Tax, (Formerly Known As Trumac Circle 2(3) Engineering Co.P.Ltd.) Aayakar Bhavan, M.K. Marg 43, Dr. V.B.Gandhi Marg Mumbai – 400 020 Fort, Mumbai Mumbai – 400 021 Pan : Aaact2153N (अपीलार्थी / Appellant) (प्रत्यर्थी / Respondent) अपीलार्थी की ओर से / Appellant By : Shri Rushabh Vora प्रत्यर्थी की ओर से Revenue By : Shri Akhilendra Yadav सुनवाई की तारीख / Date Of Hearing : 10/11/2016 घोषणा की तारीख Date Of Pronouncement : 03/02/2017 आदेश / O R D E R Per C.N.Prasad (J.M.) : This Appeal Is Filed By The Assessee Against The Order Of The Ld. Cit (Appeals)-6, Mumbai Dated 21.01.2014 For The Assessment Year 2005-06 Arising Out Of The Order Passed Under Section 143(3) Read With Section 254 Of The Act.

For Appellant: Shri Rushabh VoraFor Respondent: Shri Akhilendra Yadav
Section 143(3)Section 254

…He submits that the Ld. CIT (Appeals) has the power to entertain the claim of the assessee which is not there in the return. He placed reliance on the decision of the jurisdictional High Court in the case of CIT Vs. Pruthvi Brokers and Share Holders Pvt. Ltd (349 ITR 336). Therefore he submits that in view of this decision, the claim of the assessee should have been allowed by the Ld. CIT (Appeals). 6. The Ld. DR supported the orders of the lower authorities. 7. We have heard the rival submission and perused the orders of the lower authorities. From the record and the tribunal order, we find that the assessee c…

Hybrid Financial Services Ltd, Mumbai vs. DCIT 8(2), Mumbai

Appeals of the Assessee are hereby Partly Allowed

ITA 6571/MUM/2014[2011-12]Status: DisposedITAT Mumbai29 Dec 2016AY 2011-12

Bench: Shri G.S.Pannu, Am & Shri Amarjit Singh, Jm आयकरअपीलसं/ I.T.A. No.6303/M/12, I.T.A. No. 326/M/14 & 6571/M/14 (िनधा"रणवष" / Assessment Year: 2009-10,2010-11 & 2011-12) बनाम/ Hybrid Financial Services Asst. Commissioner Of Limited Income Tax 10(3) Vs. 17-A Wing, 2Nd Floor, Room No.473, Raj Industrial Estate Aayakar Bhavan, M.K.Road, Premises Ltd., Mumbai - 400020 Military Road, Marol, Andheri(East), Mumbai - 400059 "थायीलेखासं./जीआइआरसं./Pan/Gir No. : Aaacm2824M (अपीलाथ" /Appellant) (""थ" / Respondent) ..

For Appellant: Shri Nitesh JoshiFor Respondent: Shri C.N.Angokar
Section 115JSection 142(1)Section 143(1)Section 143(2)Section 14ASection 194CSection 244ASection 40

…ute that the assessee did not raise his claim in his return as well as in his revised return. However he raised his claim by way of letter dated 11.11.2011. In view of the law settled by Bombay High Court in CIT Vs. Pruthivi Brokers and Shareholders Pvt. Ltd. 349 ITR 336, wherein it is held that it is open to the assessee to raise the additional ground before the appellate authority. In view of the said circumstances, we are of the view that this matter is required to be reconsidered again by the Assessing Officer by giving an opportunity of being heard to the assessee in accordance with law. Therefore, in this r…

Hybrid Financial Services Ltd, Mumbai vs. DCIT 8(2), Mumbai

Appeals of the Assessee are hereby Partly Allowed

ITA 326/MUM/2014[2010-11]Status: DisposedITAT Mumbai29 Dec 2016AY 2010-11

Bench: Shri G.S.Pannu, Am & Shri Amarjit Singh, Jm आयकरअपीलसं/ I.T.A. No.6303/M/12, I.T.A. No. 326/M/14 & 6571/M/14 (िनधा"रणवष" / Assessment Year: 2009-10,2010-11 & 2011-12) बनाम/ Hybrid Financial Services Asst. Commissioner Of Limited Income Tax 10(3) Vs. 17-A Wing, 2Nd Floor, Room No.473, Raj Industrial Estate Aayakar Bhavan, M.K.Road, Premises Ltd., Mumbai - 400020 Military Road, Marol, Andheri(East), Mumbai - 400059 "थायीलेखासं./जीआइआरसं./Pan/Gir No. : Aaacm2824M (अपीलाथ" /Appellant) (""थ" / Respondent) ..

For Appellant: Shri Nitesh JoshiFor Respondent: Shri C.N.Angokar
Section 115JSection 142(1)Section 143(1)Section 143(2)Section 14ASection 194CSection 244ASection 40

…ute that the assessee did not raise his claim in his return as well as in his revised return. However he raised his claim by way of letter dated 11.11.2011. In view of the law settled by Bombay High Court in CIT Vs. Pruthivi Brokers and Shareholders Pvt. Ltd. 349 ITR 336, wherein it is held that it is open to the assessee to raise the additional ground before the appellate authority. In view of the said circumstances, we are of the view that this matter is required to be reconsidered again by the Assessing Officer by giving an opportunity of being heard to the assessee in accordance with law. Therefore, in this r…

Hybrid Financial Services Ltd., Mumbai vs. A, C, I.T.-10(3), Mumbai

Appeals of the Assessee are hereby Partly Allowed

ITA 6303/MUM/2012[2009-10]Status: DisposedITAT Mumbai29 Dec 2016AY 2009-10

Bench: Shri G.S.Pannu, Am & Shri Amarjit Singh, Jm आयकरअपीलसं/ I.T.A. No.6303/M/12, I.T.A. No. 326/M/14 & 6571/M/14 (िनधा"रणवष" / Assessment Year: 2009-10,2010-11 & 2011-12) बनाम/ Hybrid Financial Services Asst. Commissioner Of Limited Income Tax 10(3) Vs. 17-A Wing, 2Nd Floor, Room No.473, Raj Industrial Estate Aayakar Bhavan, M.K.Road, Premises Ltd., Mumbai - 400020 Military Road, Marol, Andheri(East), Mumbai - 400059 "थायीलेखासं./जीआइआरसं./Pan/Gir No. : Aaacm2824M (अपीलाथ" /Appellant) (""थ" / Respondent) ..

For Appellant: Shri Nitesh JoshiFor Respondent: Shri C.N.Angokar
Section 115JSection 142(1)Section 143(1)Section 143(2)Section 14ASection 194CSection 244ASection 40

…ute that the assessee did not raise his claim in his return as well as in his revised return. However he raised his claim by way of letter dated 11.11.2011. In view of the law settled by Bombay High Court in CIT Vs. Pruthivi Brokers and Shareholders Pvt. Ltd. 349 ITR 336, wherein it is held that it is open to the assessee to raise the additional ground before the appellate authority. In view of the said circumstances, we are of the view that this matter is required to be reconsidered again by the Assessing Officer by giving an opportunity of being heard to the assessee in accordance with law. Therefore, in this r…

Tata Condulting Engineers Ltd, Mumbai vs. Addl CIT 7(3), Mumbai

In the result, both the appeals filed by the assessee are hereby ordered to be Allowed

ITA 3595/MUM/2013[2008-09]Status: DisposedITAT Mumbai25 Nov 2016AY 2008-09

Bench: Shri R.C.Sharma, Am & Shri Amarjit Singh, Jm आयकरअपीलसं/ I.T.A. No.3595/Mum/2013 & 6786/Mum/2012 (िनधा"रणवष" / Assessment Year: 2008-09 & 2009-10) बनाम/ Tata Consulting Engineers The Additional Limited (Formerly Known As Commissioner Of Income Vs. Tce Consulting Engineers Tax Range 7(3) Limited) Matulya Aayakar Bhavan, Centre A, 249, Senapati M. Karve Road, Bapat Marg, Lower Parel, Mumbai - 400020 Mumbai - 400013 "थायीलेखासं./जीआइआरसं./Pan/Gir No. : Aabct0772E (अपीलाथ" /Appellant) (""थ" / Respondent) .. Assessee By: Shri Dinesh Vyas & Srihari Iyer Assessee By: Capt. Pradeep Arya सुनवाईकीतारीख / Date Of Hearing: 21.09.2016 घोषणाकीतारीख /Date Of Pronouncement: 25.11.2016 आदेश / O R D E R Per Amarjit Singh, Jm: The Assessee Has Filed The Above Mentioned Two Appeals Against The Order Dated 15.02.2013 & 09.08.2012 Passed By The Commissioner Of Income Tax (Appeals) 13, Mumbai [Hereinafter Referred To As The “Cit(A)”] Relevant To The Assessment Year 2008-09 & 2009-10 Respectively. Since Common Question Of Law & Facts

For Appellant: Shri Dinesh Vyas & Srihari Iyer
Section 120(4)(b)Section 142(1)Section 143(1)Section 143(2)Section 14A

…आयकरअपीलीयअिधकरण, मुंबई"ायपीठ‘ई’मुंबई IN THE INCOME TAX APPELLATE TRIBUNAL“E” BENCH, MUMBAI "ीआर.सी.शमा",लेखासद", एवं"ीअमरजीतिसंह,"ाियकसद",केसम" BEFORE SHRI R.C.SHARMA, AM AND SHRI AMARJIT SINGH, JM आयकरअपीलसं/ I.T.A. No.3595/Mum/2013 & 6786/Mum/2012 (िनधा"रणवष" / Assessment Year: 2008-09 & 2009-10) बनाम/ Tata Consulting Engineers The Additional Limited (Formerly known as Commissioner of Income Vs. TCE Consulting Engineers Tax Range 7(3) Limited) Matulya Aayakar Bhavan, Centre A, 249, Senapati M. Karve Road, Bapat Marg, Lower Parel, Mumbai - 400020 Mumbai - 400013 "थायीलेखासं./जीआइआरसं./PAN/GIR No. : AABCT0772E (…

Tata Consulting Engineers Ltd, Mumbai vs. ACIT RG OSD (7), Mumbai

In the result, both the appeals filed by the assessee are hereby ordered to be Allowed

ITA 6786/MUM/2012[2009-10]Status: DisposedITAT Mumbai25 Nov 2016AY 2009-10

Bench: Shri R.C.Sharma, Am & Shri Amarjit Singh, Jm आयकरअपीलसं/ I.T.A. No.3595/Mum/2013 & 6786/Mum/2012 (िनधा"रणवष" / Assessment Year: 2008-09 & 2009-10) बनाम/ Tata Consulting Engineers The Additional Limited (Formerly Known As Commissioner Of Income Vs. Tce Consulting Engineers Tax Range 7(3) Limited) Matulya Aayakar Bhavan, Centre A, 249, Senapati M. Karve Road, Bapat Marg, Lower Parel, Mumbai - 400020 Mumbai - 400013 "थायीलेखासं./जीआइआरसं./Pan/Gir No. : Aabct0772E (अपीलाथ" /Appellant) (""थ" / Respondent) .. Assessee By: Shri Dinesh Vyas & Srihari Iyer Assessee By: Capt. Pradeep Arya सुनवाईकीतारीख / Date Of Hearing: 21.09.2016 घोषणाकीतारीख /Date Of Pronouncement: 25.11.2016 आदेश / O R D E R Per Amarjit Singh, Jm: The Assessee Has Filed The Above Mentioned Two Appeals Against The Order Dated 15.02.2013 & 09.08.2012 Passed By The Commissioner Of Income Tax (Appeals) 13, Mumbai [Hereinafter Referred To As The “Cit(A)”] Relevant To The Assessment Year 2008-09 & 2009-10 Respectively. Since Common Question Of Law & Facts

For Appellant: Shri Dinesh Vyas & Srihari Iyer
Section 120(4)(b)Section 142(1)Section 143(1)Section 143(2)Section 14A

…आयकरअपीलीयअिधकरण, मुंबई"ायपीठ‘ई’मुंबई IN THE INCOME TAX APPELLATE TRIBUNAL“E” BENCH, MUMBAI "ीआर.सी.शमा",लेखासद", एवं"ीअमरजीतिसंह,"ाियकसद",केसम" BEFORE SHRI R.C.SHARMA, AM AND SHRI AMARJIT SINGH, JM आयकरअपीलसं/ I.T.A. No.3595/Mum/2013 & 6786/Mum/2012 (िनधा"रणवष" / Assessment Year: 2008-09 & 2009-10) बनाम/ Tata Consulting Engineers The Additional Limited (Formerly known as Commissioner of Income Vs. TCE Consulting Engineers Tax Range 7(3) Limited) Matulya Aayakar Bhavan, Centre A, 249, Senapati M. Karve Road, Bapat Marg, Lower Parel, Mumbai - 400020 Mumbai - 400013 "थायीलेखासं./जीआइआरसं./PAN/GIR No. : AABCT0772E (…